8 ms·
Why has Britain become so poor?
- Borborygymus 3y agoOur problems are as much cultural as political. There's a deep cynicism in the British psyche which consumes creative industry.
- fithisux 3y ago"Why has Britain become so poor?" This is not true. Britain is not poor, but the proletariat is. Capitalism has no notion of nation.
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y agohttps://archive.li/rhKdj https://archive.li/rhKdj
- rvieira 3y agoMy takes: The UK has a ridiculously assymetric economy. You either move to London or fight for scraps anywhere else. This ties with the housing problem. Education is a debatable investiment, because highly qualified work presumes moving to London. There is no serious infrastructure investment. There are virtually no specialised companies in big projects, so everything is cut up in small pieces and commissioned to out-of-depth small contractors that see big projects as a "once in a lifetime" opportunity. The process is not streamlined, it can't cope with efficient big infrastructure work. Even small infrastructure work is not being done, like saving classrooms from literally crumbling (https://www.theguardian.com/education/2022/may/14/england-crumbling-schools-risk-warn-no-10-education-department-treasury https://www.theguardian.com/education/2022/may/14/england-cr...). Countryside and suburban people live in a dream-like state induced by the incredibly propagandist media (especially tabloids) where people happily believe that we "once owned the US and Canada" and repeat "5th-6th largest economy" while having tea with the vicar is enough to keep Britain's "achievements". Childcare is preposterously expensive, education likewise. Housing famously so. I could go on for a bit.
- willhslade 3y agoHmm. Sounds like Canada and Toronto.
- ksec 3y agohttps://archive.is/eGoIp https://archive.is/eGoIp
- not_your_vase 3y agoOfftopic, but that picture about that science guy with facemask under his nose really rustles my jimmies.
- jjgreen 3y agoThat sends me down a rabbit hole ... https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/90246/ https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/90246/
- api 3y agoWell let’s see. Right now they’re working on a new anti-encryption bill to chase tech industry away from Britain. That’s right after they withdrew from a huge trading bloc.
- gabereiser 3y agoMake Britain Great Again is going so well… Nationalist views are a nostalgia for “the good ol days” prior to globalization of the economy. Problem is, you can’t go back. If you do, you do what psychologists call “regression”. You’re witnessing this first hand with Britain.
- Finnucane 3y agoApparently the “good olde dayes” of Elizabeth I.
- gabereiser 3y agoI believe you missed a “ye” in there somewhere.
- api 3y agoI see signs that China, juggernaut of globalism, is starting to flounder due to its own Emperor Xi Xinpeng style of make China CCP again nationalism.
- realjhol 3y agoNo, you are confusing things together, because you believe in Whig Historiography. In reality, most of the west is declining due to bad ideas and the rejection of good ideas that our people once held. To return to ideas and traditions would not be to go back in time - noone can do that, rather to reinvent, to rejuvenate, and revive the good ideas of the past in the context of the present.
- gabereiser 3y agoNo, what you just said is confusing. You can’t take good ideas from the past and apply them to the present. Times have changed. The situation is different now. We need new ideas, new philosophies, new approaches, to the new problems we face today. To return to whatever golden years you are referring to is a return to the dark ages, no matter how noble your intent. What we need is for people to stop wishing for golden years and make these years golden. You aren’t going to do that with 1950s thinking. We need 2050 thinking.
- spamizbad 3y agoThis is one of the few articles that seems to do a good job of summarizing why the UK is in its position. It never solved its creeping energy costs, it didn't build enough housing, then it gambled (and lost) on austerity and Brexit, which makes digging itself out of the hole more difficult. But what really hurts is this: the UK knows exactly what ails it but all solutions are politically untenable.
- hnhg 3y agoThe British media, The Times included, have had a big part to play in all of this. For them to behave with their usual convenient amnesia of their past reporting is a bit too much for me, at least, to accept. It just isn't fit for purpose any more. (I tried subscribing to The Times not long ago on a special offer and cancelled my subscription long before it was over. It is immensely pro-Tory and obediently unquestioning of the government. Just today I saw on their front page an article implicitly shilling for the government against encryption).
- sys_64738 3y agoA more apt description is the Murdoch Media as he has control of all the mouthpieces that Tory voters look at.
- hnhg 3y agoDon't forget the Daily Mail, the Daily Express and the Daily Star. Then, take a look at how the composition of the BBC's board changed starting under Cameron's administration. Until recently, their Chairman was Richard Sharp, who donated more than 400k to the tories, and was forced to resign for helping Boris secure a 800k loan. The Director General is Tim Davie, who ran for a seat as a Tory councillor once. Check out the others on the board, many have had positions with some relationship to the tories. Also, what about Ofcom, the regulatory body? Their chairman is Michael Grade, a Conservative life peer. And now we have GB News emerging (aka KGB news), backed by gulf money but also some major tory donors. This isn't healthy, the UK cannot afford an implicit one-party system. Democracy cannot function like this.
- chrisaycock 3y agoA similar article from The Atlantic: > How the U.K. Became One of the Poorest Countries in Western Europe https://www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-economy-disaster-degrowth-brexit/671847/ https://www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2022/10/uk-e... The subtitle says it all: > Britain chose finance over industry, austerity over investment, and a closed economy over openness to the world.
- rayiner 3y agoWait, that doesn’t track. Until 2020, Britain had one of the most open and trade dependent economies. And austerity dates only back to 2010 or so. It’s doubtful that Britain’s current situation can be explained by policies that are barely a decade old. In terms of per-capita GDP, the UK was behind France from 1985 to 1998. It jumped to parity with the US from 1998 to 2008. But that jump seems to be a product of the very financialization that the Atlantic article complains of. That evaporated after the 2007 recession. And since then, the UK hasn’t done any worse than France or Italy: https://www.google.com/search?q=uk+per+capita+gdp&client=safari&hl=en-us&ei=TYfGZLCuDrij5NoP9K-N8AY&oq=uk+per+capita+gdp&gs_lp=EhNtb2JpbGUtZ3dzLXdpei1zZXJwIhF1ayBwZXIgY2FwaXRhIGdkcDIKEAAYgAQYRhj7ATIFEAAYgAQyBRAAGIAEMgUQABiABDIGEAAYFhgeMgYQABgWGB4yBhAAGBYYHjIGEAAYFhgeSMItUKMEWMkqcAF4AZABAJgBnAGgAbIOqgEEMjUuMrgBA8gBAPgBAcICChAAGEcY1gQYsAPCAgoQABiKBRiwAxhDwgIHEAAYigUYQ8ICBRAuGIAEwgILEC4YgAQYxwEYrwHCAggQABiABBixA8ICChAAGIoFGLEDGEPCAg8QABiKBRixAxhDGEYY-wHCAggQABiKBRiRAsICCxAAGIAEGLEDGIMBwgIMEAAYigUYQxhGGPsBwgINEAAYigUYkQIYRhj7AeIDBBgAIEGIBgGQBhE&sclient=mobile-gws-wiz-serp https://www.google.com/search?q=uk+per+capita+gdp&client=saf...
- RosanaAnaDana 3y agoUKs austerity dates back to Thatcher.
- trumpeta 3y agoThey were making austerity jokes in Yes Minister!
- 3y ago
- linuxftw 3y agoLack of natural resources, meaningful industry moved overseas, and a surplus of labor. As the rest of the world develops, they don't need British loans and engineer knowledge. Over the next 20 years, they'll revert to being a tiny agricultural state.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y ago> and a surplus of labor. With 4.0% unemployment rate I would disagree with surplus of labor
- nvm0n1 3y agoThose rates don't include all the "economically inactive" people who are on long term benefits. Around 5 million at last count.
- shapefrog 3y agoWhy has Britain become so poor? > Even eastern Europe is catching up with our sluggish GDP. Our politicians have been slow to act, but economists say there’s still reason for hope. Our finest journalists can't even get through the subheading without failing. Our politicians have been acting - thats the problem.
- fidotron 3y agoAs a Brit that left a long time ago, the problem is the British long since stopped valuing people that actually do anything, and want the entire economy to be gambling/speculation on if others will succeed at what they are doing. They have now been learning, surprisingly slowly, that eventually others that used to fund this speculation start to wonder about the value of a middle man to do it when they can do it themselves. On top of this the absolute waste of talent in the UK is prodigious. The education system has been a wreck for decades, to the point it simply has to be a deliberate ploy to reduce social mobility.
- softwaredoug 3y agoEspecially hard to do global finance when suddenly you cut yourself off from the regional international governing body.
- MaggieL 3y ago"Regional international governing body" I remember when regions were smaller than nations...
- tommiegannert 3y agoI'd say EU is more in the region of "continental body."
- softwaredoug 3y agoJFC lots of it is nimbyism > The Lower Thames Crossing, a tunnel project to connect Kent with Essex under the Thames estuary, has held five consultations since 2017 and still does not have permission to build. To date, more than a quarter of a billion pounds have been spent on the planning application — more, Dumitriu tells me, than it cost to build the Laerdal tunnel in Norway, the longest road tunnel in the world.
- testemailfordg2 3y ago"Our politicians are rarely serious about anything except managing public opinion; they have let every trivial concern take priority over the biggest one of all, economic growth."
- forgingahead 3y agoCould be said about any country that has allowed their yellow newspapers to take over the discourse (and I include most US broadsheets in this category).
- tlogan 3y ago> our politicians are rarely > serious about anything except > managing public opinion I'd like to underscore that this issue persists also here in the United States. I know it is true in California and San Francisco (I presume other regions across the country are similarly afflicted).
- softwaredoug 3y agoA federal system mitigates this somewhat in the US where one region screwing up can suddenly see their neighbors thriving and hopefully lead them to wonder what they’re doing wrong.
- orev 3y agoThat’s the gist of the whole “American experiment” thing, however history has shown that people are far more likely to double down, continue with what they’re doing, and just blame “the other” (immigrants, minorities, liberals, etc.) as the reason it’s not working.
- Supermancho 3y agoSometimes it works, even if it takes decades. Notably marijuana legalization has been spreading state by state.
- paulmd 3y agoSocial issues are a gimmie since most of them don’t have a legitimate harm to the people who are most vocally against progress in the first place. They’re drummed-up issues to turn out votes, like the endless parade of wars on LGBTQ folks (first anti homosexual laws, then DADT, gay marriage, adoption, now trans issues, etc). And those have always been the kinds of sops that rulers love to throw out to the public since they don’t affect anything. The real issues are mostly financial, economic, or environmental justice issues that can’t be addressed by individual states. Even in the cases where it can be, like California air quality regs, it’s being eroded and rolled back anyway. But stuff like containing medical costs or single-payer medical/educational systems are not issues that can really be done by a state. The most you get is things like sales/property/income tax being shuffled around a bit, or californias bizarre prop 13.
- dmje 3y ago[flagged]
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoTrickle down economics have been with us since Thatcher.
- sys_64738 3y agoWhen I think of the phrase "trickle down economics" I always think of the mighty Colorado river in the Rockies and by the time it gets to Mexico you're left with a cup of water.
- krona 3y agoThe rot had set in decades before any of these trifling issues.
- mrlonglong 3y agoI'm filled with anger that it was so easy to gull the people into going along with so much self harming but here we are. Until the people start making smarter decisions this country will race further and further into the morass it finds itself in. I despise the establishment. I despise the generally spineless main stream media who are strangely unable to ask the right questions and dig deeper for the truth. I despise right wing voters. I despise people who conflates socialism with communism. Pretty much sums up the country.
- tetris11 3y agoYou've described my tremulous feelings on the whole situation very well. I blame mostly the Murdoch media. The government was always full of Tory pyschophants, but the media kept the masses informed enough to keep the damage in check. People used to resign in disgrace if they failed their post. After the phone hacking scandal in 2007, the Leveson Inquiry[1], and the resulting lack of action that passed after it, Murdoch media has only been emboldened to act and report disgracefully. As much as I hate the Tory's, I blame the Blair-Murdoch relationship for kicking it off. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveson_Inquiry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveson_Inquiry
- mrlonglong 3y agoA real shame they didn't put into law the findings of the Leveson inquiry. Shadowy figures in the establishment clearly didn't like the implications of the inquiry and sat on it. Eventually they will have to - look at what's happened already. There needs to be far more transparent accountability for wayward ministers and prime ministers - otherwise what's the point?
- rswskg 3y ago[flagged]
- baal80spam 3y ago> I despise people who conflates socialism with communism. You despise me then, I can live with that. Having grew up in both, I despise them both equally.
- softwaredoug 3y agoWhen I read these sorts of articles were clearly there a govt for the NIMBYs, by the NIMBYS, so that everyone gets off my lawn, I start to wonder if we need a maximum voting age. If you're not going to be around in 20 years, don’t understand the issues that will impact working people today and into the next generation, maybe you shouldn’t be voting.
- xeromal 3y agoIf you can't vote, you shouldn't be obligated to participate in society through taxes, laws, and other requirements. I doubt you could sell anyone on that though.
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd then you should not receive anything from society either... No more pensions or public health care. Or other type of social care.
- peoplefromibiza 3y ago> No more pensions or public health care. Or other type of social care. It's the exact opposite. When you are retired you paid all of your life for those things trough taxes. It's the youngsters that are getting them for free, having contributed a lot less if not zero.
- cuban-frisbee 3y agoYou are obligated to participate before you can vote, you can be obligated after too.
- ghqst 3y agoI like the general idea, but I don't know if this could ever be implemented, much less in a clean way
- wizofaus 3y ago
- nyar 3y ago[flagged]
- zabzonk 3y ago> Our politicians have been slow to act on the contrary, they have acted far too fast and too mindlesly - for instance brexit.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoI can’t think of anything that the Brits actually make. All they have going for them are a bunch of iconic brands that have mostly been taken over by Chinese/Indian/American corporations.
- farhanhubble 3y agoThis! Many of the prosperous economies now have few industries/brands that the world depends on. It's been outsourced, replaced by cheaper or better brands in upcoming economies. All that's left is banking and other such nonsense.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoIt’s telling that the biggest European business (by market cap) is a luxury goods company (LVMH). Europe mostly survives by selling its identity, legacy and history to the world. MG, Jaguar, Land Rover - all owned and operated by Chinese/Indian businesses make a big deal of the “British heritage”, when that heritage is just a branding ruse.
- Symbiote 3y agoTaking a single datapoint is unreasonable. The second largest company is pharmaceuticals, the third microprocessor manufacture. If anything, it shows the European economy is more balanced than the American one.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoThe fourth and fifth biggest are a makeup brand (L'Oreal) and a luxury brand (Hermes), respectively. Four of the top 10 are luxury/makeup brands - LVMH, L'Oreal, Hermes, Dior.
- Borborygymus 3y agoThere are some specialized industries left - aerospace & pharmaceuticals are fairly prominent, but the days of the UK being a manufacturing power are long gone.
- chris_wot 3y agoUh, you could replace this with one word: Brexit.
- wcoenen 3y agoThe poverty rate (i.e. proportion people who lack sufficient income for basic needs) of the UK is 18.6%. Still lower than Spain and Italy where it is over 20%. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/poverty-rate-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/poverty-r... (Edit: the numbers are from 2017 and 2018, so it is possible that things have changed. For example, it's possible that the UK was hit harder by rising energy costs. I don't know.)
- physicsguy 3y agoIt had vestiges of an empire until the mid-1960s, lost its status as an imperial power, it had industrialised much earlier than other European countries like France so didn’t have an equivalent of “Les Trente Glorieuses”, deindustrialised earlier than other countries and has basically cast about looking for a new purpose ever since.
- massproduction 3y agoThe UK didn't have a "Trente Glorieuses” because it didnt ever succeed in implementing the mass production system, while France, Italy and Germany did. The main blocker was the class system.
- physicsguy 3y agoIt happened a hundred years earlier, just in different industries. Fabric, lace, clothing, etc... you just need to walk around most post-industrial cities and look at all the things that were pioneered in Britain for mass production.
- zgiber 3y agoBritain isn’t really poor as a country if we look at all the money/wealth in it. The distribution of the wealth is very one sided though. Recent decades of law making favouring the top few percent. Giving more to the wealthiest few doesn’t seem to trickle down apparently.. eroding middle class and diminishing purchasing power is what bothers me most. Privatised energy, water, public transport aren’t serving the public’s interest anymore but the shareholder’s. Housing prices getting out of reach of the average workers is rubbing salt on the wound. These are mostly symptoms.
- physicsguy 3y agoMuch of that wealth is mobile though, it’s not that straightforward to start taxing it unless you introduce capital controls.
- paulmd 3y agoIf that wealth wants to be used to do business in the US, there’s ways to tax it. If it sits in a cayman bank account somewhere fine but that’s not doing the owner any good, and its value will be eroded over time. Even if it’s used to do business elsewhere, we have ways of getting at that (see: FINRA) if the place you’re trying to use it wants to do business with any of our banks. Maybe it’s different for the UK but they’ve always framed themselves as an economic mover, fundamentally not believing that there is something in the UK that business wants to access is a refutation of this idea of there being any domestic economic value in the UK as an institution.
- Archelaos 3y agoSimilar HN topic 4 month ago here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35379610 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35379610 > Poland is a remarkable success story. But it is not alone in catching up with Britain. South Korea and Slovenia are both set to overtake us in terms of GDP per capita too, as early as next year. This hold only true when looking at PPP per capita. Looking at GDP in US$ per capita, tells a very different story: UK $45,850.43 South Korea $32,254.63 Slovenia $29,457.40 Poland $18,321.28 Source: https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/GDP_per_capita_current_dollars/ https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/GDP_per_capita_cur... vs. https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/GDP_per_capita_PPP/ https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/GDP_per_capita_PPP...
- RadixDLT 3y agothose sources are outdated and fake, this is a better one: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.PP.CD?end=2022&locations=PL-GB&start=1991 https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.PP.CD?end=2...
- Archelaos 3y agoYou confused the data sets. This one is the equivalent one from Worldbank, which has the exact same figures as quoted: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=GB-PL-KR-SI https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?location...
- kolbe 3y ago(1) Observe UK's decline (2) Take whatever you don't like about the UK, ignore the rest, and write an article with no scientific causal inferences whatsoever about how the things you don't like caused (1). (3) Let everyone argue about how "no no no, it was the things I don't like that caused it--not the things you don't like." I have a friendly reminder that life and society are very complicated. Even with ample data and decades of scientific inquiry, for example, we only have dubious theories as to why crime declined in the 90's so much, and the most plausible ones were not evident until a decade after the fact. Anyone simplifying the UK's economic decline with convenient political talking points is a charlatan.
- sega_sai 3y agoMy opinion (which partially matches what the article says). * The country chose austerity at the time of negligible interest rates. They should have used that to make infrastructure reforms. * The austerity not only prevented infrastructure improvements, but also actively made the country less prepared for things like covid and Ukraine war shock. * Brexit. The idiocy of this act of self-harm is becoming clear to a large fraction of the population now. * Overspending during covid. Because we had BJ as PM during that, Covid was managed pretty badly, with significant debt accumulation that we now have repay at high rates (because a lot of this debt was created in form of inflation indexed gilts) * Series of bad governments over last 5 years. While Cameron was pretty bad, what we had since was really terrible. May, BJ, Truss, Sunak... * Bad housing policy. Not enough housing and allowing extensive usage of housing as an investment vehicle (i.e. promoting Buy to Let).
- nvm0n1 3y agoBrexit had literally no impact on this, and will likely help significantly. Remember that the eurozone has been an economic disaster for most of Western Europe outside of Germany, and now Germany is sputtering out too. The UK was "allowed" to not adopt the euro for legacy reasons but the EU would likely have demanded entry and many other harmful policies had the British accepted the argument that they couldn't leave even if they wanted to (which was the core of the remain argument).
- jemmyw 3y ago> the EU would likely have demanded entry and many other harmful policies That's not how it works. The UK and EU were bound to one another by various treaties. There was no mechanism for the EU to make such a demand, whereas an exit from the EU is a defined path. If the UK wanted to rejoin then the EU would be able to make such a demand.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI wonder if James Bond will have to start working for a different country.
- panick21_ 3y agoBritain has certainly fucked up infrastructure. Britain has many large cities and many of them do not have the infrastructure in terms of trains and metros. They contracted the bus network as well. In general doing a pretty bad job in terms of public transport. Britain literally has the perfect geography for high speed rail, and yet France and Germany out-build them to a hilarious degree. Thankfully they are now doing some high speed rail. This combines with the non buildings of housing, not building housing along transport corridors, making the housing situation increasingly worse and worse. How much did this lead to issue? Hard to say. I don't pretend to understand the UK economy in full.
- ProxCoques 3y ago> though many of [Liz Truss's] proposed solutions were flawed Good old British understatement there. Her proposals were so utterly unhinged that they would either prove the entire field of economics since WWII fundamentally wrong, or meet with abject fail. It was - predictably - the latter.
- no1groyp 3y ago[dead]
- simonblack 3y agoBritain has always been a poor country as a whole. Maybe for a while things looked great, but that was only because of great wealth disparity where a few people were really, really rich and many people were really, really poor. Nobody cared about the rural peasants, or the urban families that lived in one small room without water, sanitation, education, healthcare, or enough food. But, hey, look at the aristocrats, the commercial kingpins, and the Royals. Also, for a hundred or so years, Britain extracted a lot of wealth from its Empire. When that went away in the 1940s, there was a lot less money floating around, even for the upper classes. Britain hasn't become poor, it always was.
- rawgabbit 3y agoThis graph shows that Britain changed from an energy exporter to importing about 35% of its energy after the depletion of the North Sea oil reserves. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.IMP.CONS.ZS?locations=GB-US-FR-DE-IT-JP-CN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.IMP.CONS.ZS?location... To import energy, Britain need to produce things to sell. I can't think of anything the rest of the world wants to buy besides nostalgia e.g. "Downton Abbey" and "Princess Kate".