5 ms·
An ultra-sensitive on-off switch helps axolotls regrow limbs
- qup 3y agoThis is the most important work.
- Teever 3y agoIt really is. Imagine if we can get to a world where the difference between not having health insurance and having insurance means either you wait for your body to naturally regrow a limb or your insurance covers a more quickly lab grown one. Imagine a world where organ transplant wait lists aren't a thing. Imagine a world where Ukrainian landmine victims are walking on new limbs. We can have this, but instead our best minds are fucking around with optimizing web ads, or they're figuring out how to tweak assembly lines that shit out McDonald's Happy meal toys.
- puchatek 3y agoI think i'd prefer a world where there are no landmines in Ukraine. I would even sacrifice the ability to regrow a limb of it helped us get there.
- Teever 3y agoBut you know that isn't an option? Limb regeneration is useful for more than just landmines. Does the kind of comment you made really contribute to the conversation?
- nradov 3y agoHow specifically would you propose to reduce the rate of traumatic amputations in Ukraine? There are a wide variety of kinetic weapons being used beyond just landmines.
- re_ed 3y ago[flagged]
- taminka 3y ago> Imagine if we can get to a world where the difference between not having health insurance and having insurance means either you wait for your body to naturally regrow a limb or your insurance covers a more quickly lab grown one. america moment
- Teever 3y agoYes I'm trying to frame it in terms the audience of HN can understand. I'm not sure what's wrong with that.
- csdvrx 3y ago>> america moment > Yes I'm trying to frame it in terms the audience of HN can understand. > I'm not sure what's wrong with that. What's wrong is that it's orthogonal to the problem, so it risks creating a pointless discussion about health insurance instead of focusing on the technology. The key problem is the ability to regrow limbs is not yet within our technological reach. Having (or not) health insurance won't get you another pair of legs if you walk on a mine. Maybe you'll get very fancy prosthetics, but it will not be flesh and bone. In a world where this is known technology, even if the costs may initially put it out of reach of people without insurance, should it just be a gene edit AND we have the ability to gene edit like we now have the ability to 3d print, the cat will be out of the bag, and it will be like people buying 3d printers to 3d print guns in countries where gun ownership is forbidden, or people ordering drugs on the dark web: it may be illegal, but people with addictions (or here, without legs) may not really care about the legality. Or they will just do a road trip to Mexico, like how it is for dental work. Health insurance is rarely the #1 issue: I think even Europeans do similar trips when they want something immediately instead of accepting long waitlines or some procedures not being officially available in their country. The only difference is they don't go to Mexico but to Turkey, the Balkans or Eastern Europe. What we need is more technology, and fewer legal limitations, like how it was pointed out last week about how the FDA risk aversion costs human lives in a way that's impossible (or extremely hard) to measure. We're very lucky the Trump administration (and a few others around the world) decided to bypass the regular vaccine safety process during operation warp speed: regardless of what you think about Covid vaccines, we now have mRNA vaccine technology, which is already being tested for many other things.
- mxkopy 3y ago> We can have this Can we? I think a necessary step towards this direction is a complete genetic model of the human body, which we haven’t even the ability to compute until very recently (if at all). I feel like we need to solve the bioinformatics thing before we’re able to gcc new body parts. Which I think is incredibly solvable, though ofc it’ll take decades.
- amelius 3y agoYes, but remember that humans need like 16+ years to grow limbs into their final shape and size. PS: those adtech folks are destroying the planet by boosting consumption
- Teever 3y agoMost humans as they currently are may need 16 years to grow an adult size limb, but it doesn't need to be that way. An interesting question would be how long does it take a baby to gain the mass of a limb? Another interesting question would be how fast can an adult gain weight? Another interesting question would be if it takes a person 18 years to reach 6' and 160lbs and then they stop growing, how long would it take them to grow another foot or two if they didn't stop growing?
- soulofmischief 3y agoSomething tells me that death is built-in feature of many nested systems in order to prevent stagnation / local minima or maxima. In the case of social humans, death prevents bad people from remaining alive forever, cementing in power structures and not providing the needed substrate for continual growth of a society. I don't mean to ascribe intention to nature, but rather state that social systems which get far enough for its members to discuss it freely on the internet likely converge on this feature. One could argue that eternal life unlocks the next phase of a civilization, but I am unconvinced that humanity is even properly equipped for the level of technology we have today, much less tomorrow.
- skeaker 3y agoI would rather a hundred bad people live than let one more good person die if we can help it. > I am unconvinced that humanity is even properly equipped for the level of technology we have today, much less tomorrow. If you had 1,000 years to figure everything out, you would be more than properly equipped. Instead we all have to operate with this arbitrary 80ish years to just barely figure anything out and then most of us die before we can do anything with the knowledge. It is a horrible and unfair system. Imagine if Einstein were still around today and was able to keep building on top of the knowledge he had before. Surely in that time he would have gotten things done that the vast majority of people could not begin to imagine.
- soulofmischief 3y ago> I would rather a hundred bad people live than let one more good person die if we can help it. This sounds nice and idealistic on paper, but like a hellscape in reality. A ratio of 1% good people does not a society make.
- satvikpendem 3y ago> I would rather a hundred bad people live than let one more good person die if we can help it. Why would you want that? Sounds like a terrible society to live in. Imagine if Einstein still existed, sure, but also imagine if a hundred serial killers or Hitlers still existed.
- seydor 3y ago... if you re an axolotl
- dekhn 3y agoAxolotl, by Julio Cortazar: https://ambystoma.uky.edu/teachers_materials/axolitbook/AxolotlByJulioCortazar.html https://ambystoma.uky.edu/teachers_materials/axolitbook/Axol... (read the whole thing carefully)
- ycombinete 3y agoThis built up to such a beautiful end. Thank you
- generalizations 3y ago(Paywalled) article: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06365-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06365-1
- Conasg 3y agoWill we be able to genetically transfer this behaviour to, say, a mouse for testing, to see whether the mouse would gain the ability to regrow its limbs or tail?
- reflektoin 3y agoIIRC Michael Levin has started limb regrowing experiments with mice. He might've mentioned it in some podcast he was on.
- grishka 3y agoWhenever morphogenesis comes up, especially with the usual "work from DNA and proteins up" approach, I feel obliged to mention Michael Levin. He also researches morphogenesis, except his approach is on a higher abstraction level. He manipulates the electrical network that cells use to communicate with each other to organize their work towards multicellular goals. Do watch his lectures, it's some really fascinating stuff. You don't need to touch genes at all to regrow limbs and organs. Neither do you need to operate on that low level to cure cancer. This whole "let's effect organism-level changes by observing and manipulating DNA and proteins" feels to me like "let's add a feature to a react web app by observing and modifying the behavior of individual transistors in the CPU". Doable given enough time, but you'd drown in complexity in the process. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ed3ioGO7g10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ed3ioGO7g10
- echelon 3y agoThe code is there. It's a timing and signalling problem.
- hereallofit 3y agoPiling on; I emailed Michael Levin during lockdown and he replied with answers to some high level questions and a bit of documentation. Not sure what his pace is like these days but he seems open to sincere attempts at discourse. Let's fund this instead of shitcoins, layers of indirection around POSIX.
- _yb2s 3y agoI think that analogy is very apt- the fact that we have such a hard time understanding and predicting the outcomes of bioengineering/synthetic biology suggests that we are still missing huge parts of the picture of how life works. It seems very likely to me that our views are too reductionist, and the much of the key information isn't even encoded at the level of DNA as previously assumed. The cells multicellular organisms are constructed from are all shockingly similar... "cells" are basically a solved problem for this type of life, and somewhat frozen in their functionality because major changes would disrupt the larger systems that they make up.
- westurner 3y agoFrom TA https://scopeblog.stanford.edu/2023/07/26/how-an-ultra-sensitive-on-off-switch-helps-axolotls-regrow-limbs/ https://scopeblog.stanford.edu/2023/07/26/how-an-ultra-sensi... : > Axolotls, they discovered, have an ultra-sensitive version of mTOR, a molecule that acts as an on-off switch for protein production. And, like survivalists who fill their basements with non-perishable food for hard times, axolotl cells stockpile messenger RNA molecules, which contain genetic instructions for producing proteins. The combination of an easily activated mTOR molecule and a repository of ready-to-use mRNAs means that after an injury, axolotl cells can quickly produce the proteins needed for tissue regeneration. From "Reactivating Dormant Cells in the Retina Brings New Hope for Vision Regeneration" (2023) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35871887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35871887 : > "Direct neuronal reprogramming by temporal identity factors" (2023) https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2122168120#abstract https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2122168120#abstract : > Abstract: Temporal identity factors are sufficient to reprogram developmental competence of neural progenitors and shift cell fate output, but whether they can also reprogram the identity of terminally differentiated cells is unknown. To address this question, we designed a conditional gene expression system that allows rapid screening of potential reprogramming factors in mouse retinal glial cells combined with genetic lineage tracing. Using this assay, we found that coexpression of the early temporal identity transcription factors Ikzf1 and Ikzf4 is sufficient to directly convert Müller glial (MG) cells into cells that translocate to the outer nuclear layer (ONL), where photoreceptor cells normally reside. We name these “induced ONL (iONL)” cells. Using genetic lineage tracing, histological, immunohistochemical, and single-cell transcriptome and multiome analyses, we show that expression of Ikzf1/4 in MG in vivo, without retinal injury, mostly generates iONL cells that share molecular characteristics with bipolar cells, although a fraction of them stain for Rxrg, a cone photoreceptor marker. Furthermore, we show that coexpression of Ikzf1 and Ikzf4 can reprogram mouse embryonic fibroblasts to induced neurons in culture by rapidly remodeling chromatin and activating a neuronal gene expression program. This work uncovers general neuronal reprogramming properties for temporal identity factors in terminally differentiated cells. >> Is it possible to produce or convert Müller glial cells with Nanotransfection (stroma reprogramming), too? Muller glial cells and mTOR: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C43&as_vis=1&q=Muller+glial+cells+and+mTOR https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C43&as_vi... : - "Genetic and epigenetic regulators of retinal Müller glial cell reprogramming" (2023) https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2667376223000173 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S266737622... : > A number of factors have been identified as the important regulators in Müller glial cell reprogramming. The early response of Müller glial cells upon acute retinal injury, such as the regulation in the exit from quiescent state, the initiation of reactive gliosis, and the re-entry of cell cycle of Müller glial cells, displays significant difference between mouse and zebrafish, which may be mediated by the diverse regulation of Notch and TGFβ (transforming growth factor-β) isoforms and different chromatin accessibility. From "Fiber-infused ink enables 3D-printed heart muscle to beat" (2023) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36894749 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36894749 https://seas.harvard.edu/news/2023/07/fiber-infused-ink-enables-3d-printed-heart-muscle-beat https://seas.harvard.edu/news/2023/07/fiber-infused-ink-enab... : > In a paper published in Nature Materials, researchers from the Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS) report the development of a new hydrogel ink infused with gelatin fibers that enables 3D printing of a functional heart ventricle that mimics beating like a human heart. They discovered the fiber-infused gel (FIG) ink allows heart muscle cells printed in the shape of a ventricle to align and beat in coordination like a human heart chamber. > “People have been trying to replicate organ structures and functions to test drug safety and efficacy as a way of predicting what might happen in the clinical setting,” says Suji Choi, research associate at SEAS and first author on the paper. But until now, 3D printing techniques alone have not been able to achieve physiologically-relevant alignment of cardiomyocytes, the cells responsible for transmitting electrical signals in a coordinated fashion to contract heart muscle. Hydrogel and gelatin. Regenerative medicine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regenerative_medicine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regenerative_medicine Regeneration in humans > Induced regeneration: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regeneration_in_humans#Induced_regeneration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regeneration_in_humans#Induced...
- myshpa 3y agoThis is a prime example of why biodiversity is so important, and in my opinion, why protecting it should be a top priority for all hackers. Genetic information is code - code that has been written over millions of years. Nature is full of such wonderful programs and hacks. We don't yet know how to write even the simplest one, or even know about most of them. Yet, we're turning a blind eye to the current destruction of biodiversity and not thinking twice about it. I don't understand why the Hacker News community isn't more interested in biodiversity loss, or why articles about climate change and biodiversity loss are not welcome here. We're in the sixth mass extinction event, defined as a 75% loss of species, primarily caused so far by animal agriculture or, more precisely, by our food preferences. This situation is soon to be worsened by climate change. But when someone mentions veganism around here, all those hackers flag his post to oblivion. What makes all those javascript frameworks so important, and the code created by nature unimportant?
- kdmccormick 3y agoWell said. I had not made the parallel between genetic diversity and preservation of code, but now that you've put it like that it makes so much sense. I mean, I'd always cared about conservation, but this gives me yet another way to understand and explain its importance.
- Shosty123 3y agoNever thought about it like that. Thanks for sharing that perspective.
- positus 3y agoGenuinely curious, since almost all (all?) of your submissions to HN seem to involve the climate in some way: what do you do for a living? What causes you to gravitate towards these types of articles and discussions?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- panabee 3y agocould someone with expertise in regenerative medicine kindly shed light on this quote, please? quote: "It was a 180-degree flip when we realized that when an axolotl loses a limb, it actually increases protein synthesis despite the energy cost," Barna said. questions: what is the conventional wisdom on how limb regeneration occurs w/o increasing protein synthesis? inferring from other passages, it seems like conventional research focuses on mRNAs, not actual protein synthesis. why?
- dekhn 3y agoI don't think there was any conventional wisdom and on how limb regeneration occurs without increasing protein synthesis. Personally, I think the person who said that (Barna) is wrong/misinformed (even for a harvard professor!). They specifically meant protein synthesis is lower during stress response (of which limb regeneration is just one highly specialized variant), but we already know that's not true- in fact, whole extra stress-related proteins start being expressed which carry out special repair pathways. But maybe... if you count the overall protein synthesis amount, it seems like the cell would also shut down some non-essential functionality temporarily. As for focusing on mRNA- biologists study where the light is, not where it isn't, and mRNA is incredibly easy to study compared to protein synthesis. It's much easier to just convert that mRNA back to DNA and sequence it and get loads of identity and abundance information.
- thorcodingson 3y agoThis is extremis(from Marvel) level!
- dmvdoug 3y agoHere’s a fabulous short story, “Axolotl,” by Julio Cortázar: https://ambystoma.uky.edu/teachers_materials/axolitbook/AxolotlByJulioCortazar.html https://ambystoma.uky.edu/teachers_materials/axolitbook/Axol...