9 ms·
Why doctors hate their computers (2018)
- thunderbong 3y agohttps://archive.ph/PlnQl https://archive.ph/PlnQl
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoFor years, I had a PCP who was a D.O. (osteopath), and he was really good, in terms of conservative treatment decisions, rapport, medical knowledge, good office staff, etc. However, his office moved around a lot, probably 3 times in 15 years. His practice, previously independent, was acquired by a medical group. Shortly after that acquisition, he carried a new notebook computer around, and he sincerely apologized to me, saying that he would be forced to look mostly at the computer and not at me. Do you see how important this person-to-person rapport was to both of us? He always called me "my friend" and he was an expert chess player. I will miss him, especially this week, as I visit a PCP of the opposite sex, who is not a physician, who recently disavowed ever meeting me before, and argues about every detail of my treatment. Ted Kaczinski wasn't wrong.
- dang 3y agoRelated: Why Doctors Hate Their Computers (2018) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24336039 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24336039 - Aug 2020 (317 comments) Why doctors hate their computers - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381969 - Nov 2018 (107 comments)
- animuchan 3y agoAs a software developer, I can relate so much! The amount of trash garbage that IT installs on my (company's) laptop, the unnatural things I need to do to access my cloud environments, the credentials expiring at an insane pace, — all of these contribute to quite a negative experience.
- rejectfinite 3y agoThe article is about Epic, a terrible medical journal software. What you say differs between IT environments and clients. We usually just deploy EDR/MDR like S1 or Defender (Defender that comes with Windows) and deploy settings, so you cannot have a crazy long uptime and force Windows updates, yes you need those. According to some standard body like NIST, you are now supposed to have a longer password or passphrase that never expires.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwaway7439 3y ago[dead]
- rejectfinite 3y agoI never understood what is so special about hospital pacient software. Why cant they do this with the Microsoft 365 suite with Sharepoint for files, Teams for chat, files etc and Word to write notes in? Or Google Workspace for that matter. Aren't they just writing notes and ordering meds? Why is it this mess that is Epic and Oracle Cerner? *Sure being in the downvotes
- Ekaros 3y agoThere is lot of more complex workflows than someone going to doctor for consult. Just think of getting some labwork done. First it needs to be ordered. Then patient must go to nurse to get blood drawn either immediately or after not eating long enough. Nurse needs to know how many samples are needed and if there is something special. Then those needs to be tracked and delivered to lab. Lab needs to know what tests to run. And then results need to be available for years. And you probably want some sort of alerts for values outside expected ranges and in cases where they are really off. This might consist of one or multiple systems, but all those should interoperate automatically. And that isn't even imaging or treatments.
- TotempaaltJ 3y agoPartially it's about data privacy regulation (HIPAA) being especially strict for patient data. It's also a little more complicated than writing notes and ordering meds.
- bmoxb 3y agoIt seems from my naive perspective that Google and/or Microsoft could modify their existing workspace products quite easily to make then suitable for use in hospitals, no?
- Freak_NL 3y agoNo. This is a very complicated domain due to the stringent legal requirements (which vary by country of course). Also, going in to healthcare software would trigger anti-trust lawsuits in a number of regions.
- moron4hire 3y agoWhen I first moved to my current state some years ago, I shopped around for a primary care physician. One of my criteria was that the office not use Epic. I had seen it in action before and heard the complaints. Unfortunately, it didn't last long. 6 months later, my GP was excited that their office was transitioning to Epic. Told her to be careful what she wished for. Another year later and her tone had changed completely. Epic is the Blackboard of the medical industry.
- sxg 3y agoI’m a doctor and have used Epic and other EMRs extensively. The most accurate thing I can say is that Epic is the least horrible EMR available. It’s probably a 3/10 overall while everything else is much worse.
- ThaDood 3y agoI mean, are there any good EHR systems? Lol I would love to see more wide spread adoption of FOSS EHR systems, once with actual feedback and development input from doctors. I don't think it will happen. Meaningful use and interoperability have basically made it so Epic and Cerner and the other big players have an advantage due to resources for development. I had a glimmer of hope, Ohio (where I'm from) was considering allowing a companies to bid on a contract to to host a low-cost/subsidized OpenEMR instance and letting healthcare systems use it. Sadly nothing ever came to fruition.
- devilbunny 3y agoIt's big, it's complicated, and nobody wants to write all the necessary but mind-numbingly boring interfaces to a thousand older devices and systems to make the glue unless they're being paid well to do it. For all that CPRS - the old VA EMR, paid for by the federal government and thus openly available - got a lot of flak from all angles, not least of which was IT (the whole thing is written in MUMPS and the CLI underneath the GUI could be charitably described as "arcane"), it was a fairly easy EMR to "get", and once you learned how to filter things, you could at least see everything going on. With Epic, Cerner, and the others, you don't. You have a silo'ed role. Early on in our Epic migration, I discovered that I had been misclassified by the system. I was a doctor, yes, but I had a range of options open to me that were appropriate for an ICU doctor, not an anesthesiologist - I simply couldn't do a lot of things that were my bread and butter. Finding information outside your normal specialty is difficult and requires a very precise set of clicks (which are not in any way intuitive) to get to the information you want. I stunned one of the cardiac surgeons by showing him how to get access to the OR status board (which he had, just not as simply as we do) and how to customize it to show him everything going on in every cardiovascular surgery room and in the cardiac catheterization lab. Now, when a cardiologist calls him to say "I'd like to consult you about the patient I just did a cath on, think he needs bypass surgery instead of stents", he can skip getting a medical record number and just open the chart directly from the list. I can't read nursing notes. I've tried, and I know the information is there somewhere, but unless I've been given access to a flowsheet that shows it (and that is another obscure thing), I can't see it. Labor and delivery nurses don't have access to anesthesia records, so they can't see what medications their patient got during a C-section, and end up having to call one of us to tell them precisely what was given and when. Most surgeons don't know how to look at the anesthesia records (it's not easy) for their own cases, let alone their partners' (when covering call), so again - they have to call us to ask. I had to open up one for the head of the peer review committee to show her what had happened in the operating room after a patient death. There are always going to be privacy concerns, but these systems all have aliasing ability, and in any case retail-level, one-by-one accessing of sensitive people's info is going to raise a lot more flags than data breaches involving millions. Not letting me see what went on before, during, and after for a patient I have to care for is far worse.
- sjducb 3y agoThis is a controversial and not fully formed opinion, but I think a big part of the problem is the regulations are no longer fit for purpose. Outside of healthcare if you see something broken then you can just fix it, maybe rope in your manager. Inside healthcare regulations you have to start a massive change control process which involves several busy people to approve it. Those people are busy and focused on getting a few priority items approved. Starting a change control process without a customer request doesn’t make you any friends. The reasons this process exists is so that patients are never harmed by changes. But patients are also harmed by software that’s difficult to use. They’re harmed if you don’t make a change. The regulations were designed for blood pressure monitors and insulin pumps. A patient data portal is orders of magnitude more complex. Outside of healthcare teams iterate towards a good solution. Inside healthcare teams cannot iterate, because of the regulations. This stops healthcare teams from making good software and ultimately harms patient safety.
- carbocation 3y agoMaking your point even more stark, for whatever reason the UI that you're forced to use can be substantially changed by your vendor every ~6 months and there's nothing you can do about it.
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoThat is not what happens in health software, the UIs tend to stagnate for years with bugs, so users don’t have to learn new workflows.
- haldujai 3y agoNot sure why this comment is dead. You’re partially correct that a fair bit of health software is stagnant and fixing bugs takes time (although not years) but when discussing EMRs, especially the biggest player (Epic), they fairly regularly change the UI and I’ve had to learn a new workflow at least once a year for the last decade.
- 3y ago
- amelius 3y agoAnyone who's worked in a hospital knows this. Medical staff looks down on the IT people, with a vengeance.
- AzzieElbab 3y agoYeah, but the IT people are the ones raining the vengeance down on medical staff with our crappy software
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stodor89 3y agoGot three doctors in the family and two among our neighbors. All of them hate software with a burning passion. And I can't blame them, to be honest.
- jordanmorgan10 3y agoMy first job out of college was working in software for long term care/skilled nursing facilities. The software we were making was burdened in so many ways, it was painful. I have no problem believing people don't like this kind of thing.
- civilized 3y agoThis article is actually worth reading. It does not quite go to the "five whys" level, but it has a lot of leads for problem solvers. If you want to cut to the chase, pull up the archive link posted in the sister comment, then search for * Revenge of the Ancillaries * Sadoughi * Jessica Jacobs
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ahnooie 3y agoIt does seem to me some doctors are too busy typing things on their screen instead of listening to patients; like at work when I’m trying to have a conversation and someone is busy typing half of what we say in onenote (at this point, may as well email). I found a doctors office not using a computer system, at least not in front of the patients. I found they’re better listeners and don’t miss as many details. I’m guessing this is because they’re not trying to multitask during conversation. And I prefer the more human interaction.
- dillydogg 3y agoThere's just no time to work this way, in the US at least.
- sarchertech 3y agoThey’re trying to keep up with notes because notes are how they get paid and how they defend themselves against lawsuits. My wife doesn’t do notes in front of patients, but as a consequence she spends several hours at home after her shift finishing up notes from memory. She does it because she works in the ER and it allows her to handle more patients (she hates it when patients have to wait 3+ hours so she does everything she can to get them seen quickly). It is definitely much more work for her to do it that way though.
- goda90 3y agoHas your wife considered dictation software? Things like Dragon can be integrated into some EHRs. She could record what she's saying as she works with the patient and even talks directly to them, then clean it up after the fact.
- sarchertech 3y agoShe uses dragon for notes, but she said it’s too much of a mess if you just let it record everything while talking to the patient. Even if it did work, the notes for future doctors and insurance companies have very little overlap with what you’d say to a patient.
- swayvil 3y agoDoctors need the best tools. But their software is insane. Doctors have a stressful job. But my friend the ER surgeon works 24 hour shifts. Sleep is the best healer. But it's impossible to sleep in the hospital. There's a terrible malfunction here.
- bentt 3y agoI could see an AI based system ultimately winning this battle. Instead of everything needing to be human-input and human-crafted, the AI would be the "trusted mediator" of the system. It would be a front end to something like Epic, but the way it would work with the data would only be seen by it, not people. The programmers and IT people would tune the AI but you could almost think of it as an "expert" in the Epic-like system. It could be great! And then you run through the possiblity space and see how AI will destroy us, because once it works great, we'd start to rely on it and there would be no going back. We wouldn't even be capable of working with the lower layers.
- syndicatedjelly 3y ago[dead]
- supertrope 3y agoAs much as people are sensitive to human physician errors, they will be even less tolerant of AI hallucinations.
- jt2190 3y ago> But three years later I’ve come to feel that a system that promised to increase my mastery over my work has, instead, increased my work’s mastery over me. I’m not the only one. A 2016 study found that physicians spent about two hours doing computer work for every hour spent face to face with a patient—whatever the brand of medical software. In the examination room, physicians devoted half of their patient time facing the screen to do electronic tasks. And these tasks were spilling over after hours. The University of Wisconsin found that the average workday for its family physicians had grown to eleven and a half hours. The result has been epidemic levels of burnout among clinicians. Forty per cent screen positive for depression, and seven per cent report suicidal thinking—almost double the rate of the general working population.
- RecycledEle 3y agoThis has been on HN many times: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=why%20doctors%20hate&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... It is still relevant because the obvious answer that jumps out at me is to either (1) have a person clean up the records, or (2) have a GPT AI try to clean them up.
- donatj 3y agoWhenever I go to the doctor these days they sit facing the computer just reading what the nurse wrote and typing like a stenographer. As a patient, it’s very frustrating and disconcerting. It really does very little to inspire confidence. Sure, what I am saying is being heard and logged but the subtlety and tone is missed in the log and thus often missed by the preoccupied doctor themselves. It really feels like talking to someone half paying attention while they do their homework. I am old enough to remember when it wasn’t like this; I would LOVE to just be able to go in and talk to a doctor like they and I are both human beings, with shared life experiences and understanding. Hell, have an audio recording going for butt covering purposes if they need it. Going to the pediatrician with my new daughter has been a strange breath of fresh air. They look us in the eyes and talk to my wife and I like humans. Far less time spent playing stenographer. It’s such an interesting flip.
- Atotalnoob 3y agoI know someone who is a medical scribe for a practice. They follow the doctor around and write out everything. It's fairly common, maybe explore a different doctor
- jlpom 3y agoI know a company who does that using speech recognition (Nabla), but no physicians I have met had a scribe, only observing / learning residents (« internes » here). Outside of consultations my dad records itself and sends it to its secretary. On a side note I wish there was a way to communicate with (good) physicians asynchronously (via text for exemple) for non trivial issues, or something that allows them the time to research and think about an issue, which you don’t have the time during a consultation, without waiting months before the next appointment. Some try to get up to knowledge and read in front of me but, it doesn’t takes them more than 1 mn so they often have a shallow understanding. I’ve also met terrible ones who where annoyed that I knew more about the subject than they did and discouraged me from doing my own research (even from cochrane and serious meta-analysis), but I guess it is more a problem of the hubris of some french doctors than a process one (accordingly most of my issues stems from the fact that it is difficult to reliability avoid ignorants, that doesn’t care, or arrogant physicians that I could book, more than any other issues including software).
- smrtinsert 3y agoI have to say I have little sympathy. Common diagnoses should be able to be captured effectively in a common manner. If physician groups don't have the patience to train their staff on proper data entry or diligence to properly record within a reasonable time after a visit then they shouldn't accept new patients.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cc101 3y agoI'll add just this. Every time I have encountered health care software, I have been appalled at the poorly planned user interface. I do mean appalled. I would never tolerate this in software I normally use. With all the money (power) behind the health care industry, I don't know why they tolerate it nor why they don't demand change.
- onewheeltom 3y agoHaving access to ones records is a big positive
- n8henrie 3y agoI'm a physician and a tech nerd. My dream job is teaching physicians how to use their computers (with emphasis on EHR). The level of tech incompetence among physicians is astounding. Reciprocally, the level of understanding of "things that would actually be helpful" of most IT crews I interact with is abysmal. So much room for disappointment on both sides, I sure I hope I can help bridge this someday.