6 ms·
In Phoenix, this is life at 113 degrees for more than 20 days
- 28304283409234 3y ago“ … drink water, not just soda; ” Right. Yes. Well, I for one have complete faith in our ability to solve this climate crisis. /s
- densh 3y agoI always wonder when increasingly hostile climate is going to start redistribution of population. So far it seems like people are extremely resilient and would rather stay then move.
- skrebbel 3y agoThere’s a huge influx of refugees into Europe and the US mostly from hotter places.
- guepe 3y agoSources? I haven't seen that (yet)
- Xenoamorphous 3y agoBut is that because of the heat or simply because in general the norther hemisphere is richer than the southern one?
- dbingham 3y agoClimate impacts are exacerbating the existing migratory trends.
- IgorPartola 3y agoPeople are resilient here means that we have cheap enough energy and air conditioning as well as access to fresh water. Raise the cost of energy 100x and extracting fresh water and especially air conditioning becomes less economically viable than moving. Then again, the whole desert is wide open for building large banks of solar farms.
- kgermino 3y agoOf course, if you raise the cost of energy that much heating will have more of an impact then A/C. I still think the northern US cities will be more resilient (and I do live in one) but heating isn’t cheap
- rayiner 3y agoNorthern US cities are much worse positioned than other cities. Those cities are full of old, poorly insulated houses with inadequate electrical infrastructure. No ducts for A/C, 100 amp electrical boxes, nowhere to put heat pump outdoor units, etc. It’ll be much easier for more recently built cities across the south and mountain west to go fully electric.
- IgorPartola 3y agoYou are right. But also northern cities have water. You can rebuild a house to be more energy efficient. You can’t create a river (to a first degree of approximation).
- MildRant 3y agoYou may be attributing lack of financial means to resiliency. It cost money to move and if you are already struggling to get by you may not have the money.
- rayiner 3y agoOnly a small percentage of the population lacks the financial resources to move. It’s because people don’t care about the heat and will just turn up the AC. Arizona has the 4th highest rate of domestic net migration (people moving in from other states minus people leaving for other states).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- candiddevmike 3y agoOr when they do decide to move there are folks lining up to buy their house. Why would anyone move to AZ or even FL given the expected climate impact?
- School-Cotton 3y agoMost people, even those who believe in global warming, don't viscerally feel that it will cause large parts of the earth to become inhabitable in their lifetimes.
- asadotzler 3y agoAnd that's a point in favor of this article. Are you more or less likely to move to a city after hearing that it does a month straight over 110 degrees? I know how I answer that question (having left Texas 20 years ago after a month of 100 degree temps.)
- pengaru 3y agoDry deserts just aren't that hostile until there's no more water to be found. When the water runs out is when shit will get real. Until then, articles like this are just describing normal desert life while trying to be alarmist about it. Judging from a bunch of the comments here, it seems to work. The real insanity is doing agriculture in these regions, stealing dwindling groundwater supplies in bulk from the inhabitants who'll need it in the future just to survive.
- andrewl 3y agoThe United States military has, for some decades, been planning for how to deal with the effects of climate change, which include the expected migration of huge numbers of people. Here’s one article: https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/3171958/dod-office-looks-to-effects-of-climate-change-on-department/ https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/31... Two excerpts: As regions become too hot for sustaining livelihoods or human habitation, climate change may spur migration. Tensions over water and other resources could lead to instability and conflict. Climate change is already making the Arctic more accessible with nations vying over resources and access. Due to warming temperatures in many regions, diseases and viruses are expected to migrate to new areas of the globe. And: The world’s largest naval base, Naval Station Norfolk, Virginia, is endangered by rising sea levels, Water in the bay has risen about a foot-and-a-half since the 1920s, and a normal high tide now comes close to lapping over containment walls. The Navy, the city and businesses that depend on the harbor must work to adapt to rising sea levels.
- frob 3y agoAnd in their last appropriations bill, the GOP nutjobs running the house literally stripped out funding even for that. Fortunately, the Senate will probably put it back, but the GOP are just out-to-lunch on this.
- imtringued 3y agoNordhaus published a study how the economy is barely affected by rising temperatures because all high value activity happens indoors. This ignores that in Africa there is a significant subsistence population that lives off their own food production which is exclusively conducted outdoors and very little of the produce is sold commercially which in turn means their monetary income is close to zero aka they are a low value industry. The fact that these people move away does in no way contradict the predicted impact on the economy, in fact, you would think that it expects them to move somewhere else with lots of indoor economic activity.
- projectileboy 3y agoOne of the many consequences of global warming is going to be a reckoning of trying to support large cities in areas that fundamentally cannot sustain them. Las Vegas, Phoenix, even Southern California do not really have any business existing in their present forms.
- tnel77 3y agoIf you get rid of private swimming pools, golf courses, and water hungry farming in those regions, I think they’d be fine to continue as is. Aka: be smarter with water
- api 3y agoI disagree. These cities have vast amounts of solar power to the point that they could, with storage, not only self sustain on mostly just rooftop solar but could perhaps even be net energy exporters. They’re also not in areas likely to be inundated by flooding, and they are not in places where their expansion destroys forests. They are low density today too meaning they have tremendous room to build up. Lack of freeze thaw cycles means roads and buildings last longer, reducing energy use in constant repair and CO2 from constant reapplication of concrete and asphalt. Water is their big problem but with cheap renewable energy that problem is solvable either with pipelines or desalination. Lastly air conditioning takes less power than winter heating in extremely cold climates and like I said above is more easily fueled by renewable energy. Solar generation peaks exactly with A/C demand. Cities up North tend to burn tons of fossil fuels for heat and that is harder to decarbonize. Heat pumps help but it’s still more intensive than A/C. If the water problem is solvable these cities could become far more sustainable than say New York or Chicago due to all their cheap solar.
- scrollaway 3y ago> If the water problem is solvable Pretty big "if", gotta say.
- wheelerof4te 3y ago"Water is their big problem but with cheap renewable energy that problem is solvable either with pipelines or desalination." So, they kill their big advantage by using it to kill the biggest disadvantage? Where is the gain in this? And it's not OR situation, but AND. They would need both desalination plants and lots of pipelines to just alleviate, not SOLVE the water problem.
- pengaru 3y ago"And it’s so dry that you barely sweat… a condition that conceals dehydration." Without sweating I'd sure like to know what's happening to all that hydration... It seems there's been a lot of stupid hyperbolic drama in the news lately about high desert temps and how unlivable they are. But the reality is it's the non-arid regions that are unlivable in extreme heat waves. Deserts are so dry it's trivial to stay cool enough to survive. All it takes is shade and water, perspiration and evaporation takes care of the rest. You can't do the same with so much humidity the sweat can't carry the heat away from your body. That's what kills people. (I own land in the Mojave by JTNP, on which I'm presently spending yet another AC-less summer. I wouldn't dare do this in muggy IL, but here it's really no big deal - I just get less work done outside having to stay in the shade.)
- throwaway72762 3y agoYes, this is exactly right. The wet bulb temperature in parts of Texas and Florida in the heat wave a week or two ago got close to the limit of human survivability. Five years from now Texas, Florida, the Persian Gulf, and South Asia are all going to be seeing that limit exceeded at least briefly every summer.
- bscphil 3y agoI was in New Mexico a while back, and being outside walking around in 35 C heat was completely comfortable because of how dry it was. Relative humidity less than 20%. It's so dry that the heat index (by the National Weather Service's formula) is actually less than the true temperature. By comparison, life at 60% humidity in the Northeast at 30 C is considerably more miserable without air conditioning. Without a fan blowing in my face constantly to improve evaporation, my head starts to feel like mush after about an hour. Conversions: 35 C = 95 F, 30 C = 86 F
- throwaway72762 3y agoDefinitely. The only place in the deserts in the US that will be an exception to this is Yuma AZ because it is close to the warm ocean waters to the south of it so it's more humid. But it doesn't have a huge population unlike Houston or Miami.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThis is the kind of stuff that baffles me. We have people who believe that we can take rockets to other planets, which have surfaces so hostile that it makes this example of Phoenix look like a garden paradise. Meanwhile, we scratch our heads at those people who are attempting to live in a place that is literally only 30° hotter than average for the continent - yet completely hostile to life. Yet somehow this group believes that the future of humanity is on a less hospitable planet. Help me reconcile this Why aren’t we doing all that fancy Geoengineering and biodoming that is planned for Mars in Phoenix right now?
- ASalazarMX 3y agoI think people in Phoenix would fare better if they were willing to make the changes expected for outer space colonization. How many of them would be willing to recycle urine, compost their own excrement, live in caves, become small farmers/yeast growers, only go outside in full spacesuits, repair their own equipment, get used to weird smells, etc.? Civilization, as we know it, can't survive on Mars, Moon, or a space station. Think of them more as pioneers, and like pioneers, they will pay with life and blood every little mistake. Some people would kill for that adventure.
- asadotzler 3y agoWe have year-round research stations in Antarctica. What is possible for a few is not necessarily desirable for the many.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoI guess that would incur even more cost (ecologically) in the long term, making more places that miserable.
- lm28469 3y agoFuturology and progressology are the new religions that's why. They think science can and will resolve everything, we'll bend the law of physics, extract ressources indefinitely, live forever, &c.
- 3y ago
- empressplay 3y agoLived through similar runs of heat to this in Adelaide, Australia... not awesome, but the buses still ran on time (and were air conditioned!)
- asimpleusecase 3y agoMy flight through Phoenix was delayed 4 hours so I rebooked through another city. On that flight the fellow next to me said - “good choice, Phoenix is no good for flying today.” I asked why and he said “ My wife is there, plane took off and had to dump fuel and land. Too heavy to get to altitude with the hot air. They had to reduce the load and take off again. All flights having to reduce load.” I did not try to confirm this report.
- mabbo 3y agoCommon thing is Phoenix. It's just harder for planes to take off when the ground is at such high temperatures.
- lordnacho 3y agoI hadn't considered it before reading your comment, but it seems plausible when I google "air density vs temperature". It seems a few degrees is enough to change the density by several percent, and IIRC density is proportional to the lift you get.
- jaclaz 3y agoYes, but usually the plane won't take off at all without getting lighter, the issue is in taking off, not in getting altitude once air borne. Typically in case of particularly high temperatures or other adverse conditions, the plane is loaded with the minimum fuel needed to reach a near airport with better conditions, so that there is an added landing and take off, and since there are added costs for this, companies try to avoid it by disembarking luggage and even passengers. The most recent case that made the news has been about disembarking some 20 people and their luggage by EasyJet: https://www.insider.com/easyjet-passengers-lanzarote-liverpool-get-off-plane-because-too-heavy-2023-7 https://www.insider.com/easyjet-passengers-lanzarote-liverpo...
- mabbo 3y agoBefore I ever visited Phoenix, I'd hear people say something that I did not understand: "yeah but it's a dry heat". So what if it's dry, it's still an oven, right? But I went there for work a few times. In the summer. And the fact that it was so dry made it bearable. When the air is moist, sweating doesn't work well. Nothing is evaporating off of you, so you don't get cooled at all. But in pretty-much-nothing humidity, your sweat vanishes immediately and you are cooled. Just make sure you're drinking enough water (more than you think you need). You also get neat tricks like swamp coolers that blow a mist of water above you. You don't get wet- the water evaporates, cooling the air, which falls on you. Now do I want to live in 45C for weeks on end? Hell no. But I'd take that over 35C and 99% humidity.
- wirthjason 3y agoGrowing up in Chicago as a kid I was always envious of people living in places where it never got “freeze your ass off” cold. They seemed magical. Not needing a heavy coat, being able to go outside in the the winter. I was young and didn’t really know any better. The Chicago summer is nice this time of year but winter can be brutal. I couldn’t fathom the downsides of the summer. I’ve come to realize that it’s quite different, all the things I enjoyed as a kid, playing outside, riding bikes, backyard sports, etc. are all but impossible in that kind of heat. I’m not sure which area is better prepared for climate change but reading these articles makes me appreciate where I grew up and remind me, when I’m freezing my ass off, that sometimes the winters aren’t so bad. As my parents used to say, “you can always wear an extra sweater but there’s only so many you can take off.”
- gradschool 3y agoIs it time for some enterprising startup to invent a Dune-style stillsuit? https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Stillsuit https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Stillsuit
- sys_64738 3y agoDon't live in Phoenix. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize that it's a desert, there's no water, and global warming, all lead to an endgame you don't want to be near. I figured that out 25 years ago.