10 ms·
Shopify elevated the non-manager career path and ditched meetings
- negamax 3y agoExpect many more such posts and changes after many companies including Shopify shot themselves in the foot by conducting engineering layoffs. None of the engineers were affected. Many were quickly absorbed by other companies who always had dearth of talent I don't trust Shopify to do this properly and forever. This will be like Covid WFH. Once the tide recede companies will be back to what they are
- leviathant 3y agoTobi announced an AI chat assistant for Shopify merchants today. The breathless video did little to mask that this was released in the wake of laying off thousands of talented people who have gone to work elsewhere in the ecommerce space. While I do think it's fair to say they overhired prior to that, it also seems like they're falling into a pattern of over-correction. I'm sure they'll weather it long-term, but they're going to skid around a lot in the mean time.
- negamax 3y agoBad layoffs are extremely costly. More costly than bad hires. Shopify and others signalled to everyone that they are replaceable at the onset of a recession. The people who stayed have seen the blood. How likely is it that the people who were not laid off will stay if economy enters a boom cycle? Not very likely. This article is a tongue in cheek admittance that they messed up. IC tracks being prioritised because people who contribute to product development in a growing tech company are much more valuable than managers. In the coming years many managers will be forcefully moved to IC tracks and will be laid off if they aren't keeping their builder chops up to date. We have seen this happening at Meta.
- Djle 3y agoThis is a re-invention of the wheel. Many companies in the past had non-managerial career paths for technical people, and for some reason this fact, along with many other things, becomes "an innovation" by the current generation.
- esafak 3y agoThe question is whether one path is more attractive than the other.
- Djle 3y agoDefinitely, but the point is that technical people shouldn't feel like they need to take the managerial route to "get ahead". In the same vein, managers should become managers because they are good at managing people and not because they are the smartest people in the room.
- esafak 3y agoThat is what I mean by attractive; whether one path gets you ahead significantly better than the other. Otherwise people will flock to the attractive path, leading to a worse overall outcome for the organization. It's a bit like making sure the characters in a game are balanced so the game "works".
- Djle 3y agoI guess it depends on what you mean by "getting you ahead". It takes a mature and confident organization to implement this type of strategy for sure and allowing people, who are not managers, to make some of the strategic decisions.
- OJFord 3y agoNot GP but isn't it obvious? Compensation, future prospects. If managers are paid more you're putting a price on how much someone has to dislike managing people or prefer spending their time ICing for someone else. I don't think many people will pay much (in opportunity cost) for that. And probably more significant than the initial bump for many is when they're looking for the next job elsewhere, and can say 'led a team of x many' vs. not.
- obblekk 3y agoSilicon valley has benefited from a doubling of workers every x years for decades as the importance of software in the economy kept increasing. In that environment, it's important to push smart people toward management to be able to keep scaling the company. But clearly everyone in the economy cannot develop software. So if we start slowing down the employee growth within SV, it's completely rational to stop pushing smart people into management, and perhaps even pulling them out of management. Non-manager career paths are a way to indicate to smart people they should be spending their time here. Finance is an industry to look at as an example of one where plenty of money can be made by ICs. There must be others as well.
- jjtheblunt 3y ago> it's important to push smart people toward management to be able to keep scaling the company nonsense. Apple is a perfect counterexample of your assertion. (disclaimer: worked there for years with an excellent role and what you said was then countercultural, in our engineering world at least).
- rogerkirkness 3y agoApple is a counter example in that it is not an academy company, it is more like the company where you have your last job once you idealize your craft skills.
- addaon 3y agoAs someone who had my first job at Apple (years ago), I can't think of a single reading of this that makes sense and lines up with my experience.
- ZephyrBlu 3y agoI think in the general case this makes sense. Most people at Apple did not start their career at Apple. They probably got a significant amount of experience before joining Apple.
- leftcenterright 3y agoI worked at a small company with about 50 employees where self-organizing teams was the norm in tech departments. It was comprised of mostly senior developers and researchers though so they mostly were able to avoid rabbit-holes themselves and prioritize as needed. I don't think such teams have shown to work in bigger companies though. Does anyone else also have insight or experience with self-organizing teams?
- esafak 3y agoWhat constituted organization; what did the team look like and do before and after?
- jdbernard 3y agoAs much as we like to decry middle management in tech, this is the purpose, in my opinion, of good middle management. They should be the API between a self-organizing team and the broader organization. They're a glue layer that helps preserve team autonomy in a context where cooperation and coordination have become more important.
- organsnyder 3y agoA former company I worked for was what I call "intentionally disorganized": other than high-level direction, management was completely hands-off, and everyone was expected to self-organize and manage their own work, typically among loosely-organized teams with no formal accountability. Some people seemed to thrive there, but for me it was a devastatingly bad fit. My ADHD (clinically diagnosed) certainly played a major part in this. With everything being up to the individual, it was too easy for me to get caught up in all the myriad things a proper org structure provides, but that I had to do myself: prioritization, assistance with career growth, feedback loops, and the like. Everything was a struggle, and I was ineffective to the point that I was fired.
- paxys 3y agoInteresting discussion. Every tech company I know of has a career path for engineers who don't want to get into management (with roles like staff, senior staff, principal, distinguished engineer, technical fellow etc.) and so you can keep progressing basically indefinitely as an IC. I have never seen this done on the product side, however. After a point every product manager has to start to focus on people management to get ahead, which undoubtedly has a negative effect on the product itself. I wonder if more companies will start following this approach for non-technical roles as well.
- travem 3y agoI agree this is a big issue. I liked the article written by Ken Norton about this issue (in Product Management) at https://www.bringthedonuts.com/essays/dual-product-management-career-path/ https://www.bringthedonuts.com/essays/dual-product-managemen... I have seen a "Principal" Product Manager role at some companies I have worked at, but the Distinguished Product Manager level role is not one that I have seen in practice unfortunately.
- jasonsync 3y agoPeter principle? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle
- Gareth321 3y agoI work for a global top 100 and while I can’t vouch for every department, ours offers product progression. Senior, Lead, etc. It’s relatively new.
- spandrew 3y agoThis is my experience as well. In most companies I've worked at (non-FAANG) the product team just isn't really large enough to support a more variable career chart. You have 8-10 PMs. You promote 1 to manager and another to principal. So does the one manager have 9 reports? You end up with a strange org chart where some director's at facilitating work, and others are doing more strategic stuff. Ultimately some manager is going to be over burdened with days full of 1:1's and that's it. Interested in hearing other's experience with this!
- kpw94 3y ago> We built an operating system called GSD (get shit done). This internal tool emphasizes frequent written updates, which are much easier to digest than constant meetings Curious what this mean/what this actually looks like
- OJFord 3y agoSounds to me like a Slack bot (or whatever they use) that prompts you to provide an update to a couple of questions, like a text-based 'stand-up', at a scheduled time or manually triggered. But I may just be overfitting to my own experience with something like that (not at Shopify) and don't know why that couldn't just be Jira (or whatever) comments. To have a more product-oriented than ticket-micro-managing view perhaps?
- jacques_chester 3y agoIt's nothing too fancy. A Rails app with some text boxes and nice styling.
- bbojan 3y ago"We don’t over-index on OKRs. Many important things can’t be measured and not everything that can be measured is important." Can't agree enough.
- nine_zeros 3y agoIt seems like you don't want to argue endlessly over if a project is 65% complete or 70% complete? Here's a "needs improvement" rating for you. /s Notice how the rating is negative for corporate BS and not for actual service/product.
- extr 3y agoThe problem with dedicated IC career paths are that they aren't respected outside of core tech companies. At some point if you want to switch industries you could be looking at a massive pay cut. I noticed this in FAANG. Okay, you get to IC8, you're a master of the universe. Realistically you can only take that credibility with you to other FAANG. If you're a manager/director, you can take that with you anywhere and the comp bands will be more comparable. There are of course exceptions if you are a true rock star and have worked on/led household-name projects as an IC. But again, if you jump ship, you might end up in a manager-esque role anyway. Once you reach a certain level of seniority/experience you are just way more valuable in the force-multiplying role of "leader" than anything you can do with your hands on the keyboard.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 3y agoThat's definitely the case at my company. To get to the same pay grade that even mediocre managers get promoted to by default, an IC basically has to walk on water.
- seneca 3y agoIt's a supply/demand issue. There are piles of ambitious engineers who want to be staff+, and not that many instances where it's needed. Contrary to popular narratives, management outside the c-suite is a mostly a thankless grind with no glory. Getting competent people to do it requires some major incentives, and every team, at every level, requires management.
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoThis has been the exact opposite of my experience. There is an endless availability of engineers who can push JSON to an API, but people who can lead a team, handle cross team comms, architect, and code the hard problems are fairly rare. This is why they command salaries comparable to specialist doctors. Meanwhile, MBAs are an endless resource, given that that and Law School are the default for people who haven't figured out what they want to do in undergrad.
- lifeisstillgood 3y agomy conjecture is that coders are the new managers - because the new workers are CPUs and GPUs. Prior to 2000s ish you needed people to do most tasks manually. Software has eaten enough of the world that most (middle class middle world) jobs are automated or can be. And so you have a league of coders organising the work of the compmay on CPUs and then a layer of legacy managers who can't or don't code trying to work out how to pull levers they cannot see anymore.
- danjc 3y agoI'm guessing you're under 30
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoHilariously above 30. way above. Why the guess? What makes young people think management is mostly wasted space but not older people?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agothe phrase "are automated or can be" is doing a lot of heavy lifting, and the pure-opinion portion "or can be" is doing about 99% of that heavy lifting put tersely, they aren't, and can't be in the relevantly immediate future, so the optimistic take might have been misconstrued as youth (since such optimism on average tends to decrease with age, in my experience) it's a good premise for a sci-fi novel at the moment
- engcoach 3y agoThat doesn’t connect with my (FAANG) experience. The best managers are highly technical regardless of current code output.
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoBut the best managers aren't what we are talking about. Or rather, what is the point of management - to organise resources to achieve organisational objectives. Resources are now CPUs. A farm that bought a thousand tractors and combine harvesters but still tried to have the same manual labourer management practises, hiring, compensation would struggle. We are seeing old labour practises trying to meet a world where one coder can launch and co-ordinate thousands or hundreds thousands of CPUs globally. There is a management impedance mismatch
- eclectic29 3y agoI'm sorry to be cynical here but all this is good only in theory or in a blog article. Real life is much different. Let me articulate. 1. There are many more sr mgr/director+ positions than sr. staff+ 2. Corporate politics is brutal and a seasoned mgr is adept at it. Unfortunately, the sooner you get better at it the better for your career. This is one of the reasons why a seasoned director will always be able to command a much bigger scope than sr. staff+. 3. The bar for rising in the IC ladder is astronomically higher than that for mgmt ladder. 4. And let's not forget interviews. Management interviews are much easier than ICs. (think leetcode). 5. Last but not the least, even in big tech companies (FAANGM or whatever acronym) you should really measure how many of sr. staff+ folks became sr. staff+ after a stint in mgmt. They used mgmt to catapult their career after seeing stagnation/difficulty of moving up as an IC. You would be surprised how many of these very senior ICs have had mgmt careers for several years before. It's easy to extol the virtues of being an IC once you've reached there but no one sees how they got there :-). Now, don't get me wrong. There are some companies/orgs/teams where higher ICs are valued much more and do better than mgrs but it's really the minority. It's in your best interest to switch to mgmt after 8-10 yrs of IC career (8-10 yrs is sufficient enough to gain a solid footing in tech) and learn the ropes fast. I waited for 18 yrs and can see the difference.
- nine_zeros 3y agoThere is a lot of reality in this post. Sadly, ICs have far too much scrutiny, starting from aggressive interviews, to onboarding, to performance reviews etc. A manager path is just a chiller life. No leetcode interviews, performance review is focused on hiring/firing/delivery rather than actual product building, maintenance etc. Managers create arbitrary processes for their team just to show to their bosses that they are doing something important. Managers also scapegoat ICs when their policies fail. It's a wild paradox. Companies want ICs, to develop and maintain but the corporate ladder is designed to favor/give power to managers. Wild!
- eclectic29 3y agoThe important thing is to learn to play the same game your company plays (whether it's IC or mgmt) and start learning the mgmt ropes soon.
- nine_zeros 3y ago> At Shopify, our primary job is to build products, not career ladders. If only my company understood this, we would spend so less time on optics. Managers would be rated on their ability to build products rather than on generating "short-term impact" documents for optics. Engineers these days are asked to spend far too much time documenting their work for optics than on the actual work itself. This comes from a place of career-ladder managers who don't really know anything about the business except people management. These management practices are an incredible overhead on the business.
- esafak 3y agoNetflix did this right: they had no ladder for as long as possible and outsourced raises to the market ("bring an offer and we'll match it").
- Infinitesimus 3y agoI'd love to hear the perspective of current or former employees of Netflix. At some point, they decided that an IC career ladder was important and instituted it. Management always had a ladder so that's not new. What changed?
- esafak 3y agoNetflix outgrew its one-size-fits-all solution. Here are the details: https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/netflix-levels/ https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/netflix-levels/
- pmulard 3y agoI’m curious how many opportunities the IC path has to lead and conduct “managerial” duties. I’m sure it varies by company, but I’d like to believe it’s like how most research teams operate - leaders lead and organize meetings when necessary, but they are primarily responsible for the research at the end of the day. I’ve only been a low level IC, so I don’t know what it looks like. Anyone care to share their experience?
- ptmcc 3y agoMy experience as a staff-level IC is that I end up doing a lot of project management, scoping, resource allocation, interacting & negotiating with business stakeholders, and defining & delegating work items. I meet often with my actual EM and work with him on strategic team direction. I still code but quite a bit less than as a senior IC, instead doing more oversight, review, and direction-setting across all the team's projects and work. But I don't have to do the real people management stuff like perf reviews, dealing with personal issues, hiring/firing, reporting to the execs/board, etc. I have some previous "real" management experience from a prior job but I noped out of it for staff+ IC, for now.
- webel0 3y agoI’d like to see some stats on slack usage, Google docs activity, and jira ticket activity (or their equivalents) before and after this shift. Basically: does this just mean that everything is migrating to written form? If so, is that good?
- nerdo 3y agoCouldn't you use the calendar as a salary lookup tool here?
- webel0 3y agoWhat is the policy for ad hoc huddles? If I’m spending more than 20% of my attention on a message thread, then I’m not being a productive programmer. At that point I just want to pick up the phone and talk to people (but not hang around and chat forever).
- OJFord 3y agoThat's just a personality thing isn't it? I'd generally rather thrash it out over text, have the written record to refer to and point others at. I'm not doing anything else either way, so a call doesn't help that.
- webel0 3y agoIt is. And my question is that - given that it is a personality thing - how is Shopify dealing with it?
- neilv 3y ago> Shopify laid off 20% of its global workforce today — its second sizeable employee culling after a reduction of 10% announced last July. -- https://techcrunch.com/2023/05/04/how-shopify-bungled-its-latest-layoffs-and-made-employees-feel-like-npcs/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/05/04/how-shopify-bungled-its-la... I'd like to make an HN grassroots proposal... that people impose a moratorium period on indulging a company's PR attempts to sell their enlightened management culture, right after something like that. Layoffs looks like either a huge fudge-up that screws employees, or screwing employees as a greedy or dumb business move. In neither scenario is it in the interests of the hiring pool to pretend it didn't happen.
- hackernewds 3y agoNot to mention, companies announcing major acquisitions (Uber acquiring Postmates), or share buybacks (Apple) right afterwards. If a company really did mismanage their workforce the CEO would be fired for it, not rewarded.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoLayoffs are not seen as mismanaging your workforce by investors. They're generally seen as a gamble that didn't pay off. Especially with tech companies, taking gambles is a good thing, investors want to see that management is taking risks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sam0x17 3y agoThough sometimes the gamble _is_ the layoff (see Twitter atm)
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoTwitter's layoffs are because Elon Musk has no idea how to manage a company, not because of actual business or market pressures
- lgharapetian 3y agoDoes anyone know how they extended the Google Calendar interface to show the cost of the meeting?
- inerte 3y agoProbably Chrome extension, as the browser is managed by the company, they can basically extend it with anything they want.
- phillipcarter 3y agoAs with all of these cute little corporate things that always fail, Microsoft Already Did It. Many meeting rooms at Microsoft were, at one point, installed with devices that showed the cost of a meeting based on the titles of the people attending. It was abandoned for several reasons, one of which being that more junior folks ended up even more intimidated by senior-level folks than before. They won't go on a PR blitz about it like they are now, but Shopify will stop this practice sooner or later, too. Nothing unique or interesting to see here.
- tssva 3y agoThey replaced some meetings with async written communication and decision making. What is that? It sounds a lot like sending emails. I'm not sure that having to follow and respond to email chains or async communication chains on whatever medium was chosen is inherently more cost effective or less intrusive to creators than meetings. The only measurement mentioned was a reduction in the number of meeting, so I'm not sure they really do either.
- RhodesianHunter 3y ago> I'm not sure that having to follow and respond to email chains or async communication chains on whatever medium was chosen is inherently more cost effective or less intrusive to creators than meetings. Async is 100% more efficient and cost effective. You can skim/ignore the content that is irrelevant to you. You can set aside the time that is most efficient for you to work through it. No one has to slice their day according to what is least inconvenient for the group at large.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tssva 3y ago> Async is 100% more efficient and cost effective. You can skim/ignore the content that is irrelevant to you. You can set aside the time that is most efficient for you to work through it. No one has to slice their day according to what is least inconvenient for the group at large. I find it hard to believe that optimizing for the individual vs the group is obviously 100% more efficient and cost effective when what really matters is the overall results of the group.
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoThe overall results of the group are just the sum of results of the individuals. The more efficient the individuals are, the better the results of the group. And that's not even getting in to things like individuals' happiness and the results of turnover.
- tacker2000 3y agoGreat stuff! Now maybe one of these engineers that “love” to build “great” products could take a look at the “great” Shopify PHP SDK [1], where no issue or feedback is ever answered and the developers who use it (and who are actually promoting Shopify by using their API) are left in the dirt to fend for themselves. [1]https://github.com/Shopify/shopify-api-php https://github.com/Shopify/shopify-api-php
- no_wizard 3y agoShopify doesn't have the best developer relations across the board, not just their API packages. Advice I've gotten from others who have maintained Shopify integrations long term recommend that you use their GraphQL or REST APIs directly and build your own client.
- wintogreen74 3y ago"At Shopify, our approach to product reviews is different. " Ah yes, apparently the only thing every single company I've ever worked for has in common is that each and every one is a special snowflake. From his perspective: they have dual career ladders, PMs iterate over the same product for longer periods of time, driven by close customer feedback. What company doesn't say they do this?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hypnotechno9a 3y ago"elevated the non-manager career path" This is misleading. They opened up the doors to move up as Product Manager without needing to manage others. In other words MBA's and not the highly technical people (engineers - which is much harder to do). This isn't hard to do and shouldn't be treated as some significant accomplishment.
- beachy 3y ago> We built an operating system called GSD (get shit done). This internal tool emphasizes frequent written updates... Operating system .... Those words don't mean what you think they mean.
- spandrew 3y agoI know people at this company. The Slack channel purge coupled with a move to Facebook Workplace to "shake up productivity" was disastrous for most productivity during the month of January. They did it right after the holidays too — when many employees are just reacquainting themselves with channels and comms again. Despite some wisdom in the idea of promoting crafters over meetings this isn't some genius mantra of productivity. It was just poor systems neglected by the company being cleaned up in the dumbest way possible. A poor management sandwich.
- softwaredoug 3y agoI can say that both of these things have long been true (Shopify occasionally killing meetings and handing an IC leadership path). Not sure why all the sudden we keep seeing these headlines.
- wmidwestranger 3y agoI feel overdue to apply. Love Ruby, RSpec, and the utility of Rails. When they released the library that let namespaces explicitly control their public and private interface, I had my good OO sensors tingle. I've gone from worse to better in the companies I've worked with but I really feel the blast doors closing on the promise of ten years ago. There was a time when there was a real effort at engineering for the sake of the engineer and user. The window seems to close day by day. So, maybe Shopify and 37Signals can be the last stand in a way Fog Creek, and many others could not.