9 ms·
I’m all for the “fake data” idea, but also: Apps should be required to gracefully handle the cases where users deny permission to access real data. I know last
by ryandrake 3y ago
I’m all for the “fake data” idea, but also: Apps should be required to gracefully handle the cases where users deny permission to access real data. I know last time I developed for iOS, it was Apple’s policy that apps cannot punish users or exit() the app in retaliation for them denying a permission. Apps must gracefully handle it and continue running.
Also, and this was even longer ago, apps could not require users to have “an account” in order to run. I remember (this was over a decade ago) my company making a product change that forced users to have an account in order to function and we got (rightfully) rejected by the AppStore for this. It seems they must have softened this stance because I am seeing more and more apps that require an account to function.
- aftbit 3y agoEvery smart home app seems to want an account on Android. Maybe they have a different path on Apple, related to HomeKit or similar, but I'm a bit skeptical.
- skinner927 3y agoTasmota + CloudFree + Home Assistant and never make an account again and have full control over the devices in your home. No accounts and your lights still work when your internet is down.
- qwerpy 3y agoI love my home assistant installation and didn’t even know about Tasmota/Cloudfree. Thanks for sharing, this is the next logical step to fully detaching from subscriptions/accounts.
- progman32 3y agoEsphome is also good to learn about here.
- plagiarist 3y agoI also like the part where it is harder for a device to call home if it doesn't have wi-fi at all.
- Aulig 3y agoThe guideline to be able to access apps without an account still exists, but the enforcing might have become lighter - or it's just the random fluctuations in review qualities we all know by now :)
- ksala_ 3y agoBoth of them still exists, but of course in some situations it doesn't make sense, so there is a lot of leeway depending on the reviewers. My experience is positive here, I can't remember the last time an app did not allow me to not have an account or manually provide data when it made sense. https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#data-collection-and-storage https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#dat... (iv) Access [...] Where possible, provide alternative solutions for users who don’t grant consent. For example, if a user declines to share Location, offer the ability to manually enter an address. (v) Account Sign-In: If your app doesn’t include significant account-based features, let people use it without a login [...]
- ryandrake 3y agoThanks for doing the work by digging up and linking to the actual guidelines! That's pretty close to how the wording was all those years ago. Like all things AppStore, the enforcement is what ends up being uneven and subject to Apple's discretion and judgment. Which is a good thing IMO. Without publisher discretion, you just get scummy developers who rules-lawyer their way onto the app store.
- mormegil 3y ago> apps could not require users to have “an account” in order to run There is some big qualification missing or I don't understand what does that even mean. How could a banking app run without an account? An online game? The Twitter app nowadays? Dropbox/Nextcloud/...? Etc. Yeah, I agree that for a lot of apps, requiring a account is just a marketing gimmick, but I don't think such a general rule could work.
- EA-3167 3y agoPerhaps the standard should be, "If you are required to have an account to use this service, on or off the app, then you can require it on the app." For context that would mean that to browse a site like Hacker News, you couldn't require an account, but to post you could. It covers things like Banks or Steam, etc. Would that be workable?
- freedomben 3y agoThat seems like a great policy to me. I bought a guitar tuner app in the past and that's exactly and all it did: act as a tuner. But it then got acquired by a company that sells guitar lessons and other things, and they completely f-ed up the app and it requires an account and a subscription now if you want to tune your guitar. Fortunately there are other options in the Play Store, but I paid like $15 or $20 for it at some point. This tempts me at a side comment about why I hate automatic updates, but I'll refrain. Luckily it was Android so I was able to backup the APK before they ruined the app, and I sideload it now. Along with old Pocket Casts, Audible, and a couple of others.
- grishka 3y ago> Apps should be required to gracefully handle the cases where users deny permission to access real data Or else? You're suggesting an organizational solution to a technical problem. This can't possibly work. Fake data is the only practical solution to this, such that the app would see the permission as granted when it is not actually granted.
- rmorey 3y agoelse not be allowed in the App Store, a stick apple is more than happy to wield
- grishka 3y agoIt should be illegal for a device manufacturer to retain any kind of control over devices after sale. Some governments are finally realizing this. So no, this is not a viable solution in the long run. Besides, Android is a thing. I personally have never used an iPhone as my real phone precisely because of this — I can't install modded apps, I can't install pirated apps, etc etc. It's not okay to have to jailbreak the thing to make it usable.
- bithaze 3y ago> It's not okay to have to jailbreak the thing to make it usable. I guess we'll have to tell millions of users that their iPhones are all unusable, then. Imagine the shock!
- grishka 3y agoIt might not be as much of a problem in the US, but it is a real pain in the ass people have to contend with, for example, in Russia. I've seen it myself. Apple is enforcing US sanctions against some Russian companies, which means they can't have an iOS app. At all. I heard stories about how a sanctioned bank would load some kind of shadily signed copy of its app onto people's iPhones in branches. For Android, that same bank just hosts a self-updating apk on their website — with no intermediates to tamper with their app distribution. Besides, being able to install modified apps is an important leverage against companies that don't act in their users' best interest. This way you can still use their services, but do so on your own terms.
- rollcat 3y ago> it was Apple’s policy that apps cannot punish users or exit() the app in retaliation for them denying a permission. Meanwhile, WhatsApp still "punishes" users for denying contacts access by hiding everyone's names (only the phone numbers are shown), including for contacts that have their own names set in their own profiles. Facebook^W Meta is scum.
- eganist 3y agoWorse, you can't even initiate conversations; if you've denied contacts access, the other user has to message you first. At least for me on Android, which is wild.
- gruez 3y agoThe iOS shows a phone number input if you try to initiate a chat and have contacts permissions disabled. I'm not sure whether that's because it's to comply with app store regulations, or the product owners on both sides prioritizing different things. On both platforms you can still initiate chats without contacts access by using the wa.me domain, eg. wa.me/12125551234 for +1 (212) 555 1234.
- davchana 3y agoSometimes I need to contact somebody on Whatsapp one time or such, and I don't want to save their contact. But Whatsapp on Android shows only my own contacts to initiate chat. Like you said, wa.me is a way. I made this quick page for exactly this: http://spa.bydav.in/num2wa.html http://spa.bydav.in/num2wa.html
- j1elo 3y agoAlternatively on Android, the app "Click to chat" is a tiny utility that directly opens up a WhatsApp chat with any given number: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.trianguloy.openInWhatsapp https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.trianguloy...
- 3y ago
- duxup 3y ago> Apps must gracefully handle it and continue running. Would this include… not doing anything? A notice that to use the app that you must grant access? I hate apps that do that … BUT: I am thinking of a logistics application that I wrote that requires location access. It effectively serves no purpose without location access. It’s a small app that we offer to our clients. Not an app for the general public. But it is a situation where I don’t want the app to continue doing anything without location access.
- freedomben 3y agoI would imagine they just mean "you can't crash or abruptly exit." Telling the user "please grant location access to use the app" and providing a button to try again is probably fine.
- ryandrake 3y agoI think it depends on the function that the permission access provides. If permission use is core to the app (like your app is a map with a dot for the user's location that has no other functionality like business searching), then, you're probably allowed to just sit there with an empty map doing nothing until the user consents. If location access is peripheral to the core function of the app, it's a different story. Like your Yelp and one of many functions of your app is to "search nearby" then you can't just have a screen that does nothing until the user consents. EDIT: Yes, for OP's use case, you'd just appeal to Apple and prove that the app has no other purpose besides the use case that requires location. I've done this in the past successfully.
- freedomben 3y agoYes, the comment I was replying to specified that they are like the map app with no other functionality: > I am thinking of a logistics application that I wrote that requires location access. It effectively serves no purpose without location access.
- dodgson 3y agoIt depends on the app. For example, I can’t view my balance in my banking app if I don’t sign in to an account, but I can find nearby ATMs or pull up the number for customer service. The logistics app could offer some features like phone numbers, support hours, or even account management features without location access, so users can still get access to those things even if they can’t enable location (or are in Airplane Mode, for instance). And then the core part of the app could have a message explaining why location access is essential. Perhaps with a link to a privacy policy or other document to explain how it will be used and handled safely. I love apps that do that and even have a button I can tap to go straight to the proper settings screen to grant access (or in some cases I can tap and the app will request again, so I can say yes this time).
- Swanlyk2 3y agoCouldn't find another place to put this comment but how do I get the privilege of posting an Ask HN discussion starter thread for startup advice?
- wruza 3y agoI believe it’s just a thread with “Ask/Show/Tell HN:” in its title.
- pmontra 3y agoHow that works with banking apps? What can they do without an account? Maybe a web view to the home page of the bank.
- danielhlockard 3y agoAs someone who works in banking - We don't show anything other than login and enrollment (and maybe a link for account opening, if the FI has it). Apple has yet to complain.
- lldb 3y agoWorst offender is google photos on iOS - you can’t even open the app without giving it all photos access. Selected photos doesn’t count. Even just to view photos already saved in the cloud.
- tobr 3y agoDiscussed recently on ATP[1] - this is a huge security hole. If you give access to all photos, apparently the app can search through the EXIF data to extract locations and timestamps, and build up a very accurate timeline of your whereabouts. 1: https://atp.fm/542 https://atp.fm/542
- spacebanana7 3y agoI wish Apple stripped sensitive metadata from photos by default when interacting with third party apps/sites. The few services that actually need this data could request an additional permission. As an app developer I don’t want users to send me location metadata with their photos, but there’s no easy way to communicate this to non-technical users.
- MBCook 3y agoIs it though? If you want Google Photos to back up your photo library… it needs full access to everything to do that. Very very few apps should need full photo access. But photo backups/cloud libraries are the one I can think of that do. I was actually surprised no one on ATP brought that up.
- ilyt 3y ago> I’m all for the “fake data” idea, but also: Apps should be required to gracefully handle the cases where users deny permission to access real data. That lies in gesture of app developer and that will not happen for the apps you'd want to use that feature (or the fake data feature) with.
- TechBro8615 3y ago> It seems they must have softened this stance because I am seeing more and more apps that require an account to function. On Apple they compromised by requiring that apps with a login support "Sign In with Apple." Since you can signup with an anonymous iCloud email, this is almost as effective as not needing to create an account.
- amelius 3y ago> it was Apple’s policy that apps cannot punish users or exit() the app in retaliation for them denying a permission. Sounds a lot like EU's GDPR: you must show a cookie popup but if the user denies it then you must still serve the content. (When companies grow large enough, they become suspiciously similar to governmental regulators.)
- knallfrosch 3y agoApple allows Bloomberg even though it requires an account.
- alickz 3y ago> it was Apple’s policy that apps cannot punish users or exit() the app in retaliation for them denying a permission It's been the same since runtime permissions on Android, which was like Marshmallow i believe https://developer.android.com/training/permissions/requesting https://developer.android.com/training/permissions/requestin...
- curt15 3y agoPolicy is one thing, but enforcement is what really matters. Do Google Play reviewers actually reject apps that hold core functionality hostage?
- omniglottal 3y agoThe point of civil disobedience is often to ensure the non-graceful handling being protested results in a very non-graceful effect. Companies soften their stance real quick when the hard positions they hold cost them a lot more. Apps punish users - there must absolutely be a feedback effect of users punishing apps.
- wlesieutre 3y agoI don't mind fake personal data, like contacts or photos, but once you get into locations I'm iffy. If it's being used locally for showing your location on a map, or searching for nearby businesses, sure, give it fake data. But if you're talking about an app that does internet speed tests and maps the speeds for different cellular providers, or lets users report local weather conditions to improve forecasts, then I have no problem with those apps being able to say "Either give us an accurate location, or give us no location, we don't want your fake location." The platforms would have to be an adjudicator of which apps get an exemption for users contributing back data that will affect other people rather than just influencing their own browsing experience. I think Apple has come up with some good middle grounds on this, you don't have to grant an app "precise location," and you can grant photo access via a system provided image picker that only shows the app photos that you've selected.
- userbinator 3y agoTrue freedom is freedom to do things that others might not like.
- wlesieutre 3y agoLike the freedom to operate a service that only accepts real location data?
- sickill 3y agoAs long as I have freedom and means to feed it fake data as real data :)
- dbgev 3y agoIf apps are threatened with fake data, they will quickly find it's better to let users opt out gracefully, no regulation required.
- m463 3y agoI wish I could use apple products without an account. But an apple id is required for running apps, because you can only get and install apps through the app store. I would like the equivalent of a "de-google'd android phone" on ios.