15 ms·
After days of destruction, Macron blames a familiar bogeyman: video games
- xracy 3y agoWeird, I'm pretty sure Macron worked for the last CS:GO major to be held in Paris. Also pretty sure he made some announcement for it... I know his gov't had some involvement in the "last CS:GO Major" being in Paris... https://www.talkesport.com/news/csgo/2023-major-emmanuel-macron/ https://www.talkesport.com/news/csgo/2023-major-emmanuel-mac... Just saying, while we're blaming... violent video games? Or just video games?
- swayson 3y agoPolitician always point elsewhere, and change the focus. Why folks fall for the shallow reasoning I will never understand. Calibrate on behaviour, not words.
- bell-cot 3y agoThe headline is corrected in the 4th paragraph: > President Emmanuel Macron has mostly blamed social media for the devastation, but he has also claimed that video games have inspired copycat violence and vandalism. Kudos to NPR for using ~60% of their article to call "BS" on Macron. Though they probably should have opened the history book, too - France experienced a number of similar situations ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_civil_unrest_in_France#20th_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_civil_unr... ) before social media existed, or modern-ish video games were seriously available. My reaction: Macron is delusional, and needs to be shown the door.
- di4na 3y ago[flagged]
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoThe saddest thing is, Macron's playbook doesn't seem any different from what I'd expect from most current politicians. It feels like the real problems the world needs to solve are beyond any existing political will. So it's the downward spiral of denial and self-delusion.
- yardie 3y agoOne thing I notice about European politicians: they all come from the same background, come from the same families, same socioeconomic status, attend the same schools (Eton, Science Poe, etc), take the same jobs. At the end they all provide the same talking points and try to use the same programs. You can't expect change from the same people who have no idea they are the problem. And this is why diversity is critical in this era. Those same politicians have been ossified in their thoughts. They trundle out the same centrist playbook that may have worked in 80s 90s 00s. And then are surprised when an extremist trundles them in the elections.
- bell-cot 3y ago@dang - Did user di4na's comment (below) get flagged/killed for using "the s word"? In context, I see no suggestion of physical harm or self-harm, nor other objectionable content.
- istjohn 3y agoIt probably got flagged for being a racist dog whistle.
- LawTalkingGuy 3y agoThat's surely what happened, even though it obviously isn't correct. Islam is a religion, not a race. It's just as reasonable for the French to complain about Islam as for a progressive Californian to complain about Christianity. Sadly, HN doesn't seem to take away the right to flag posts when people abuse it.
- istjohn 3y agoA progressive Californian and a Christian Californian are as likely as not to have the same racial background. A French Islamophobe and a French Muslim, not so much. California never colonized a Christian country like France colonized Algeria. Sometimes the superficial truth is just that, and reality is more nuanced.
- LawTalkingGuy 3y agoYou're trying too hard to force a racial context onto France and deny one in the USA. In California a Christian is less likely to be white, and a progressive more likely to be white than not. And many of those Christians come from countries that the USA has been involved in and not always left in good shape so most of the same dynamics even exist. Regardless, criticizing religion is fair game and a Euro has a right to criticize Islam the same as to criticize Christianity, even if there's a racial disparity between the membership of the two.
- bell-cot 3y ago
- taoufix 3y agoIn the last week, Macron/France : - call[s] to 'cut off' social media during riots sparks backlash in France (france24.com) - passes bill to allow police remotely activate phone camera, microphone, spy on people [2] - blames Video games [3] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36615378 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36615378 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36616037 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36616037 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36630151 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36630151
- rayiner 3y agoMacron has to do something to divert blame from France’s importation of a underclass from its former colonies. I don’t see how Europe isn’t totally screwed. Their tight-knit social democracies are not compatible with immigration. But without immigration they don’t have enough workers.
- volfied 3y agoThey don’t have enough workers they can exploit
- layer8 3y agoThe demographic trend (age curve) is a real problem, difficult to solve without immigration.
- GloomyBoots 3y agoIt’s impossible to solve with immigration. Even with an immigrant population that was completely willing and able to assimilate (unlike those in question), that process takes generations and requires a lack of ethnic ghettos and a high proportion of native and nativized people relative to immigrants. No honest person would say that we could solve Japan’s falling birthrate by rapidly and continually pumping it full of Europeans and expect it to remain recognizably Japanese. But anyway population fluctuates. These things tend to work themselves out normally when your main goal is the good of the nation and not just inflating the GDP as quickly and recklessly as possible.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoSo all the violence is being committed by 14 - 16 year olds? Or is it those who were 14-16 in the late 80's / early 90's when this particular pearl-clutch was popularised? Also "a mimicking of violence, which for the youngest leads to a kind of disconnect from reality." Seems there's a bit of that going around.
- ben_w 3y ago"If Pac-Man had affected us as kids, we'd all be running around in dark rooms, munching pills and listening to repetitive electronic music." - Marcus Brigstocke
- Izkata 3y agoBetween the phrasing and when people usually pull out that quote, it seems like it's supposed to be on the side of "video games don't affect us". But uh... isn't that a pretty accurate description of raves?
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoIf GTA would be affecting kids, then I should be out beating up hookers with a baseball bat to steal their cash, and shredding cop cars with a minigun.
- vuln 3y ago
- throwawayttu 3y ago[flagged]
- iuiuiuasdd 3y ago[flagged]
- throwawayttu 3y agoI was talking about martial laws
- pjc50 3y agoThe French DGSE were deployed, and they're pretty martial.
- x86x87 3y agoLol. You don't really understand the French if you think this would work. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_vests_protests https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_vests_protests Declaring martial law would escalate things into a full blown revolution.
- eunos 3y agodebank all protestors
- sgt101 3y agoI think it's the opposite - god alone knows what sort of social upheaval Europe would have seen in the financial crisis from 2009 - 2015 if playstation and x-box hadn't been around to distract all the young men with no job!
- doctorpangloss 3y agoIt's interesting that anyone who has actually played video games understands, unequivocally, that they are a substitute, not a promoter, of bad behavior. But really, our politicians barely use computers, so what can we do.
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoSame. I think the reason we don't have more riots in Europe is the huge amount of affordable distractions (alcohol, porn, tinder, social media, streaming shows, video games, weed, etc.) to distract us from the real problems (unaffordable housing while increasing immigration and stagnating wages, wealth transfer from poor to rich, underfunded healthcare with ever increasing waiting times, unsustainable pension system, high interest rates on loans with low rates on savings, etc.) Without all of that we'd see a lot more young men have more free time to protest against their future being take away from them.
- chaostheory 3y agoIm surprised that there isn’t more government funding for VR technology, outside of the military, for this very reason
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoThe military is funding psy-ops to make you think there'll be hot young e-girls waiting for you if you enlist, instead of big dudes.
- tsss 3y agoFor the same reason that drugs are illegal: If there is an affordable happy pill they can't sell you their fake shit anymore. People that give up on the rat race are outside of their power.
- SkipperCat 3y agoMacron used the words "video games" and that makes him sound like a fool because the correlation between video games and actual violence is nil. But, I do think he and other people are trying to make a point that there is a lot of content on the web which is horrifying, and sadly young people learn by example. Watching constant reels of people acting awful to each other desensitizes us against engaging in bad behavior. IMHO, all the garbage videos I see of people doing "pranks" (which are often low grade violence against strangers) just make impressionable teens and young adults feel is is OK do engage in that sort of behavior - especially when it becomes gamified by getting Internet/social media points. And this is where TikTok comes into play. Scott Galloway makes the argument that China is using TikTok to push a lot of this negative content into America with the effort to cause instability. They are also only pushing highly positive content inside China to bolster "healthy" social interaction. I'm not sure I can say this is 100% truthful, but anecdotally it seems correct.
- drcongo 3y agoWhy are you watching these videos?
- SkipperCat 3y agoFair question. I don't actively seek it out but I come across a bit of it on Reddit. Sad to say, its engaging on a primal level, much like how people slow down to view a car crash when they're driving by. I used to browse the subreddit r/trashy which at first I found funny, but then after seeing the content for a while, I realized its just making fun of people or showing me examples of Confederate racists. I do like r/tiktokcringe because there is a lot of good hearted humorous content, but there too, you see examples of people being jerks.
- drcongo 3y agoThanks for answering. I asked as someone who hates Reddit, YouTube, Instagram and TikTok so genuinely never sees any of this stuff.
- 3y ago
- jacknews 3y agoYou might expect politicians from previous generations to be clueless and paranopid about this, but Macron must surely have played video games himself as a youth. I'm sure thorough research would show that violent video games are like porn, and actually reduce the incidence of real-world aggression.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoI don't think this is a Hanlon's razor, not on Macron's part at least. Some other commenter said that Macron said people were chasing a rush found in video games, and not that the people wanted to reenact or imitate them. If that is true, then incompetence is on reporters, and not Macron himself.
- m5r 3y agoA study about this from researchers based in Netherlands was recently linked to on HN. They found a correlation between a drop in juvenile crimes following a GTA release.
- hersko 3y agoEveryone knows the French never rioted before the advent of video games, so this makes perfect sense. /s
- shadowgovt 3y agoNobody ever talks about the influence of the popular Grand Theft Head on the French revolutionaries.
- m3kw9 3y agoA big wtf statement
- itiswhatitis3 3y ago[dead]
- HydianSnake1 3y ago[flagged]
- epups 3y agoRobert F. Kennedy has also been making statements against videogames. Quite disconcerting that we still have to listen to this after the mountain of data proving the opposite. And also that these are coming from supposedly progressive politicians.
- LovinFossilFuel 3y ago[dead]
- gsatic 3y agoFrance's leisure class is totally disconnected from its ppl. I don't know how that's going to change.
- constantcrying 3y agoNot so much that they wouldn't know that this is a lie.
- shadowgovt 3y agoI know how it changed in the past...
- green-eclipse 3y agoObviously Macron is right, because violence and destruction have never occurred in human history until video games were created.
- newshorts 3y agoThis is correct. It’s either video games or the electric car.
- lost_tourist 3y agoEspecially when there was a restless underclass that doesn't tend to share your religion, education level, and culture that gets beat down by your media used as political gasoline.
- lefstathiou 3y agoOur society (and every parent I know) has established that kids are highly impressionable. That’s why so many laws are written to moderate advertising (eg not show a camel smoking a cigarette), moderate content (tv and movie ratings) etc. I can’t go a day without people telling me how manipulative social media is on the news for both kids and adult minds. We casually acknowledge entire elections have been manipulated by the content shown to people on television. So what is it about video games that have absolutely zero negative impact on impressionable and unstable minds? Speaking purely for myself, as a life longer gamer (I’m 37), I personally don’t believe video games have inclined me in any way towards violence. I do believe that the idea of handling assault weapons was normalized by video games (it was a non event for me to shoot them at a range when I eventually sought them out), and that trashing cities and committing vandalism became fun. Doesn’t seem like a stretch to me that boys being boys are going to be more inclined to do it, especially without some overarching moral construct to counter balance or (like church).
- jakelazaroff 3y agoWhy video games and not movies or TV? Why not books or music? And why is church a positive moral construct? Maybe I want my kid playing Stardew Valley to counteract all the violent fire and brimstone they're getting from the Old Testament. Hell, why not their own history textbooks? France at least one prominent example of a violent revolution that's looked on positively in retrospect! (Of course, when you're the leader of the ruling class, no challenge to the current status quo could possibly be positive in your eyes). The thing with pinning the blame on any one thing like this is that it betrays one's own biases. Macron grew up without video games like we have today, so they're his go-to culprit — it obviously can't be the violent things I grew up with, I turned out fine, didn't I?
- layer8 3y ago> Macron grew up without video games like we have today, so they're his go-to culprit Video games were already made a culprit in the 80s and 90s, when Macron was a kid and a teenager (he’s 45). I’m pretty sure he’s aware of that.
- 3y ago
- Havoc 3y agoBut what about chess? We should ban that too. Maybe checkers and monopoly too just to be sure /s
- TMWNN 3y agoContrary to the headline, Macron didn't blame video games. Macron said that social media encouraged rioters to riot, and that while doing so they felt the rush that they had felt while playing video games.
- Garvi 3y agoI wonder how our society would look like if instead of importing a cheap workforce, we'd raise the minimum wage to a point where the shitty jobs would be paid enough for them to feel respectable. You know, like in a healthy capitalistic society of supply and demand. Instead we're manipulating the workforce supply for the sole benefit of the employers. And now we're talking about video games. Sigh.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI think Japan might be the best example of this. I don't know about minimum wage laws, but their immigration system is famously draconian and obviously they're an island.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoMinimum wage is around $6.75/hour
- hotpotamus 3y agoThat number is nominally pretty close the US which is interesting, but I don’t really know what it means in terms of purchasing power parity. I wonder how able a minimum wage worker is to afford their health insurance and rent. And it’s probably relevant what percentage of workers make that wage. I’m really not all that knowledgeable about Japan other than a little bit from talking to people who’ve been and catching the odd online talk/documentary, but it does seem like an I interesting place. In the US for instance, it seems like minimum wage is a dead letter law since it was never indexed to inflation and had been left to wither away.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoinflation and untethered minimum wage is a class warfare tool. it was purposely untethered from inflation from the start.
- Garvi 3y agoInteresting. It seems Japan is subsidizing jobs that are paid too little and no one wants to take at those wages, while employers cannot afford higher rates. That does indeed seem like a great idea, considering they seem to have a rather fair progressive income tax system (5% - 45%).
- andrewclunn 3y agoThis is signaling. Macron can't blame "the migrants" because that's not socially acceptable (without giving credit to his political rivals), but most of them are disgruntled younger (compared to native Frenchmen) men. This is how he can point the finger at their demographic without having to actually do so. Perhaps ironically, this IS a racist dog whistle.
- readyplayernull 3y agoThey must be playing Ubisoft games, their loader is such a rage starter, just read some comments on Steam.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoSo they've learned nothing. So be it. Sometimes lessons take a few goes before they settle in.
- shadowgovt 3y agoOof. When young people are clearly lashing out because they are seeing a disconnect between their needs as citizens and the tools the establishment has to satisfy those needs, coming across as woefully out of touch is the last thing the leadership should be doing. Good luck France.
- hdjjhhvvhga 3y agoThe big question: what can he say? Can you be honest when thousands are in rage? 1. The kid was killed for no good reason, period. This is easy to say and most people will agree. He committed a crime, but the cop overreacted. 2. Cops in France target people of African origin in a different way. Whatever the French government says, that's the truth. 3. Why do they do that? Because crime is more prevalent among these people. This is already a touchy subject and some people will flatly deny that flexing stats in all possible ways. 4. Why is crime among that groups so high? Here we start to deal with the real problem and some solutions to it. But the truth is, nobody has a good solution. If someone came up with that, it would have been implemented a long time ago. But nothing works. And it doesn't even seem like it's going to be better at all. So what can he say? He comes up with some crap about video games that everybody knows is bullshit, but this neither hurts his electorate nor the people on the streets.
- activiation 3y agoSomeone need to ask him which games in particular
- tiborsaas 3y agoIf any game is capable of inciting violence then it's this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6Wc11ErqmA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6Wc11ErqmA
- pengaru 3y agoVideo games? They've always taken to the streets in France, it's one of their more endearing qualities! Macron is such a twat
- steve76 3y ago[dead]
- infamouscow 3y agoThe French never guillotined the elite until video games? Give me a break. Now I understand how revolutions happened in the past.
- lost_tourist 3y agovideo games are a symptom and not the cause. If you're angry and want to break something, you're likely to get a game that does that and not one that calms you down.