17 ms·
To make more stingers, U.S. needs to revive production technology from scratch
- t43562 3y agoIIRC the Polish Piorun (Thunderbolt) is better so why not make them instead?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mikeryan 3y agoIt’s easier, politically, for the Biden administration to justify the Ukraine support budget when purchasing US made munitions.
- x3874 3y agoThank you for pointing out this fact
- cornholio 3y agoWhile the far more cost effective step would be to dismantle these outdated production lines and ship them into Ukraine, where they can be operated by cheap, skilled labor, with much diminished environmental and safety overhead, as part of a war economy. Every modern war is a production war, you either outproduce your opponent, or you get overwhelmed. If Ukraine can't achieve self reliance and remains fully dependent on western trickle down, it cannot succeed long term.
- jeremyjh 3y agoIf the US can kill Russians only by giving money and weapons to Ukraine they will definitely keep doing it. Ukraine has the will to fight and that’s way more important than native production lines.
- varjag 3y agoPiorun isn't really better. It's a modernization/rebranding of old Soviet Igla system.
- ahartmetz 3y agoAccording to some unverified articles online, Piorun is more effective than Stinger. It wouldn't be a surprise - the latest Stinger technology is obviously at least 20 years old and Piorun was introduced in 2019. Being derived from Russian missiles (debatable for Piorun) is also not a mark of bad quality - at some point, Western militaries were surprised to learn that Russian air-to-air missiles were much better than their own (leading to greatly improved Western missiles).
- varjag 3y agoPiorun is Igla with usability enhancements. The hard part (propulsion and warhead) is mostly unchanged and this is why Piorun is slower than Stinger despite the warhead being at half the weight. Most of East European mods of Soviet weapons are "easy" upgrades, where they change electronics and optics packages.
- t43562 3y agoEffectiveness is the important measure though, right? Not individual statistics but whether people can succeed with it. That's what those unverified reports claim - that it was tested against Stinger and more likely to achieve success. That might be because it is easier to use or for other reasons.
- t43562 3y ago"Piorun’s new generation seeker is equipped with two photodiode sensors that work within two electromagnetic radiations: near-infrared and mid-infrared. The signal is instantly digitalized, quickly making corrections and analyzing the heat source, distinguishing between targets and diversions." Doesn't seem like the upgrade was that easy.
- dismalpedigree 3y agoThis is just another example of the depth of issues caused by allowing production and mechanical know how to apathy. We literally have to build up the generational knowledge again from nearly nothing.
- mildchalupa 3y agoThis sort of thing is true nearly everywhere. In my own career I try to seek out those with the tribal design knowledge and deep understanding and learn as muh as possible.
- ttfkam 3y ago"Atrophy", not apathy, though the atrophy may be due to apathy.
- mcculley 3y agoMaybe vocabulary is a victim of atrophy.
- brilee 3y agoThe U.S. quite appropriately cut its defense spending after the USSR collapsed: https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/military-spending-defense-budget https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/mili... which in turn caused a cascade of mergers in defense contractors and the retirement of much this production and mechanical know-how. I think you are incorrectly conflating this transition period with the offshoring knowledge decay.
- giantg2 3y agoMany of the skillsets and technical knowledge overlap. The downsizing and offshoring are both important factors.
- therealdkz 3y agonot in real dollars
- coldtea 3y agoSo much for the post-industrial revolution...
- dylan604 3y agoNo, the revolution happened. The US just decided it wasn't interested, so it moved overseas.
- frankfrankfrank 3y ago[dead]
- coldtea 3y agoI said the post-industrial, as in the BS 90s-00s ideology of some elites about how it's all about controlling the bits and bytes and information flows now, and factories and production "don't matter" (so might as well be outsourced).
- YLYvYkHeB2NRNT 3y agoStingers are really productive /sarcasm. Let's put this to work for something good. Stingers only cause harm.
- bioemerl 3y agoWe need them to give to Ukraine, no? I would suggest they are preventing harm in that case. Edit: The mods here apparently think responding to the Russian influence campaigns on their site is worthy of a shadow ban.
- yasp 3y agoWhy do we need to give them to Ukraine?
- bioemerl 3y agoBecause Ukraine is a democratic state/western ally being invaded by it's much bigger and meaner neighbor and will cease to exist if we do not help them defend themselves. We don't have to give them to Ukraine, but doing so generally furthers our interests.
- qbasic_forever 3y agoIs Ukraine actually a democracy right now? Last I read all of Zelensky's opposition parties were arrested and made illegal. https://www.npr.org/2022/07/08/1110577439/zelenskyy-has-consolidated-ukraines-tv-outlets-and-dissolved-rival-political-par https://www.npr.org/2022/07/08/1110577439/zelenskyy-has-cons...
- ceejayoz 3y agoThis a misreading. Specific pro-Russian parties were. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_parties_in_Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_parties_in_Ukraine > On 20 March 2022, President Volodymyr Zelensky announced a ban on 11 political parties for ties with Russia: Opposition Platform — For Life, Party of Shariy, Nashi, Opposition Bloc, Left Opposition, Union of Leftists, Derzhava, Progressive Socialist Party of Ukraine, Socialist Party of Ukraine, Socialists Party and Volodymyr Saldo Bloc. Quite a few other parties remain in Parliament: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_parties_in_Ukraine#Political_parties_in_Parliament https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_parties_in_Ukraine#P... Given history - one such party helped Russia take Crimea in 2014, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Unity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Unity - that seems reasonably prudent in the pursuit of still being able to be a proper democracy in the future.
- dylan604 3y ago"In order to revive Stinger production, the company has recruited retired engineers who will train current employees in the manufacturing process." I wonder what the compensation packages look like for these roles. What does coming out of retirement for an assumed well paying job for up to a couple of years??? do to someone's retirement financial plans? What if you're on a fixed income from the gov't, and now you have a salary again? Is paying them under the table viable?
- throwaway9274 3y agoUsually they are either former government employees or contractors who incorporate their own 1-2 person “engineering consulting firm” that can then sell services back to the government at high rate. The financial benefits are usually quite extensive for the engineers involved, because there is nowhere else to obtain supply of the needed skills.
- thechao 3y agoI knew a guy who came back — in his late 70s — to do "flange design" for old oil pipelines whose lifespan was being extended beyond the original expected span. He said — inflation adjusted — he made more money each month consulting than he did his last year working salaried at the same company. Bc he consults, he only does 3–4 months of work a year.
- throwaway9274 3y agoSimilarly my great uncle works on satellite systems. His income over 5 years when brought out of retirement to service legacy systems was greater than his income over his entire prior USG career.
- ElevenLathe 3y agoThere's no reason you can't collect social security and also make a paycheck. Many many people (unfortunately have to) do it.
- giantg2 3y ago
- H8crilA 3y agoJust import the PPZR Piorun instead. It is much more modern and more effective than the Stinger, for example with much better flare evasion. Stinger is from the 70s.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe Stinger's one part of a larger ecosystem, though. For example, they throw them on Humvees for a cheap, portable air defense system: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AN/TWQ-1_Avenger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AN/TWQ-1_Avenger Pioruns probably aren't interchangable in these.
- H8crilA 3y agoNo, but Pioruns are also attached to cars and lightly armored vehicles. It's not that difficult to do :) The real answer is that the Stinger needs a long overdue modernisation.
- giantg2 3y agoThe real issue is politics and lobbying. It's extremely rare that the US would adopt foreign designs vs designing and building in-house. After all, we want to be the ones selling to the rest of the world.
- bluGill 3y agoWe also want the expertise to design and build in house in case politics change and we are no longer friends with whoever is making it
- vGPU 3y agoThe problem with scaling up manufacturing is that the US needs to manufacture here, now. What good is importing a polish missile when Wagner is so close to the factory that they can almost make it out if they squint? It’s not like Poland has a history of getting invaded or anything, right? Why could we possibly want to continue outsourcing our production to try to fix the problem that outsourcing production caused?
- morkalork 3y agoI've read somewhere that this situation is why some production lines are never shut down even though more isn't needed (I think Abrams?).
- ed_balls 3y agoyes, but there is only a single line for Honeywell AGT1500, which is a bit ridiculous. There should be a second factory on another continent in case of a natural disaster.
- dredmorbius 3y ago"Honeywell AGT" being the "Abrams gas turbine", a/k/a the powerplant for the M1 Abrams tank.
- chriscappuccio 3y agojust stick a diesel engine in there
- bombcar 3y agoIt’s often relatively inexpensive to mothball a production line (relative doing heavy lifting) and sometimes you can even keep parts of it operational making things for other uses.
- nradov 3y agoThe production line is one thing, the supply chain is quite another. When the Department of Defense shut down F-22 production they mothballed the Lockheed Martin final production line (although there were some gaps and missing tooling). But then when they looked into restarting production several years later they found it was just impossible because the supply chain had disintegrated.
- stickfigure 3y agoWhy revive stinger production instead of adopting something more modern, like starstreak or any of the other NATO manpads? Surely technology has come a long way since the 80s. License the technology and build it at home.
- aardvarkr 3y agoBecause it’s the American version of those and they have updated the design and tech throughout the years to keep up with the latest improvements. Just because it was first build in the 80’s doesn’t mean the design has been kept static.
- meepmorp 3y agoYes, but the Starstreak has one big missile that releases 3 smaller missiles at mach 4. I get your point, but on the other hand, what about weird British missiles?
- tyho 3y agoStarstreak is also impervious to flares.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoStarstreak is impervious to flares because it requires a human to paint the target. Stingers are fire-and-forget, and modern versions use dual-mode IR and UV imagers that are impervious to flares.
- greedo 3y agoOther than a new proximity fuse, they really haven't updated the design much for a decade. Most of the upgrades have been to extend the service life of the missile, since most munitions have a Best Use By date...
- jsiepkes 3y agoIf you switch to a different platform you will also have to change the way you do training, logistics, (field) maintenance, etc. That's going to be a hell of a project. So if you have something that works...
- m0llusk 3y agoIt would be an additional cost, but it might make sense to require that military contractors include full documentation of production methods with their products. There could be odd measures like keeping the records sealed for a time to protect secrets, but it seems like anything the nation needs to defend its interests should not be left in the hands of the producers who are expected to abandon it.
- davidktr 3y agoGood luck defining what "full documentation" means.
- nradov 3y agoThat concept works well enough for something simple and mechanical like an assault rifle, but it totally falls apart for aerospace products. Just because you have documentation doesn't mean you are actually capable of building the final product. In the real world, manufacturing engineers often make adjustments on the fly to get stuff working. And the designs often assume a particular set of tools, so without knowing how to recreate those tools you don't have anything useful.
- synergy20 3y agoNowadays the supply chain, i.e. the logistics are very different, you may find you have to source many parts, if not majority of them, from China or at least overseas, and that will get harder based on what is going on these days.
- taylorfinley 3y agoCall me cynical, but the ceo of a major defense contractor saying it’s going to take years of testing and R&D to refresh a circuit board design from the late 80s is just a cancerous grifter piggy squealing at the trough. You could crowd source a replacement PCB in a week if they published the design spec. Sure, testing is required, but call this what it is. And don’t try to tell me we can’t share missle guidance tech from the 70s, even the model rocketry community has open source thrust vectoring.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoYou can't crowd source mil-spec ICs. Many have no commercial equivalent and even when they do they often use unusual packages that can't be sourced anywhere else.
- pnpnp 3y agoI completely agree with this. Mil-spec and certified ICs are a completely different beast. As we can see, they have to survive decades in storage, need an absurdly high pass rate, need to survive incredible abuse in battlefield situations AND survive who-knows-how-many G’s of acceleration (/ vibration) catching up to a target.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThat sounds a lot like car grade electronics, TBH. I suspect that there is some combination of military contractors forgetting how to move fast, and the military being so wrapped up in process instead of results at play here.
- squarefoot 3y agoAcceleration isn't the biggest problem on such light devices, vibrations are. Those boards are exposed to high frequency vibrations that could detach or crack components because the pcb resonates inflecing rapidly back and forth.
- 3y ago
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoI remember when Los Alamos wanted to decommission some research reactor, they were interviewing 80-year-old retired staff to figure out what they were going to find down there. Because what they planned and what they built hardly resembled each other.
- saganus 3y agoWould love to hear that story!
- r721 3y agoHere's a similar story this comment reminded me of: >Institutional memory and reverse smuggling https://web.archive.org/web/20111228105122/http://wrttn.in/04af1a https://web.archive.org/web/20111228105122/http://wrttn.in/0... HN discussion from 2011: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3390719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3390719
- 0xDEF 3y agoAnother problem is that many US weapons programs are actually rural/flyover job creation programs in disguise. This makes it challenging to rapidly scale up production.
- nostrademons 3y agoIs that actually the case for Raytheon specifically, which has deep ties to Massachusetts? It was founded by Vannevar Bush, who was VP and Dean of Engineering at MIT at the time. (And I know they still do a lot of the tech in Massachusetts - my friend's wife works on missile guidance for them.)
- Waterluvian 3y agoIt’s always really easy to armchair criticize using versions of, “why weren’t you prepared for every contingency at all times?” And I see versions of that in the comments. Supply chain is really really really hard. Keeping it warm for decades is really really really expensive. Especially if you’re not churning out 50 million of something every year. Though I imagine there are valid criticisms if we had all the details. “They didn’t think to preserve X specimens.” “Y software was lost on a tape drive somewhere.” “Z blueprints got improperly stored inside the Ark of the Covenant.”
- andrewflnr 3y ago"An actual war breaking out" is an extremely foreseeable contingency when building weapons of war. That said, I blame the government more for not keeping the supply chain alive, and in particular not ensuring they can change manufacturers.
- Waterluvian 3y agoYeah but that’s just the same kind of unqualified broad answer. Then there’s someone blaming the government for spending so much money during peacetime. Then someone will say that military spending is such that they ought to be able to. And someone will say the Stinger is 50 years old and they should be building something entirely new instead. And nobody can actually quantify any of their feelings on the matter.
- andrewflnr 3y agoI think when the dust settles from all the supply chains restarting, we'll be able to quantify the benefits pretty well. For anyone actually interested in truth, anyway.
- Waterluvian 3y agoAs long as we also quantify every other instance where not maintaining production over two generations was the advantageous choice.
- bookofjoe 3y agoElon Musk would be ideal here
- psychphysic 3y agoThere are plenty of good enough in production manpads. This is just squeezing the American tax payer for all they have. Yet again.
- eimrine 3y agoSorry for off-topic, but what US needs to do to revive Saturn-V? Suppose there is an urgent need for that.
- causality0 3y agoStinger portable missile launchers (MANPADS) Call me a pedant but it feels dirty to give an acronym in parentheses without actually saying the thing the acronym describes. It should be "Stinger man-portable air-defense system (MANPAD)"
- jmyeet 3y agoI'm no fan of the US military-industrial complex. We spend almost $1 trillion a year on the military and can't account for where it goes [1]. It's absolutely true that we have a military profiteering problem. But I'm not sure that's what's going on here. Think of the Saturn V. When Congress greenlit the SLS, the obvious question came up: why not just build the Saturn V again? And the answer is... we can't. Obviously there are specs and manufacturing processes and documentation for taht but I'm not sure we even have it all. Some of it was rushed too and bespoke. These were really hand-built every time. Also, materials science has changed in the past 50+ years so it may be an issue producing materials that are to spec. These are remarkably complex systems. And you have to fit in with current logistics processes. Users, installers and maintenance crews need to be trained. If what you build now behaves differently, it's a potential problem. Think of the MCAS issues with the 737MAX. That was a system added to counter more reliable and more powerful engines that were placed more forward on the airframe. You see how these things can cascade. [1]: https://blog.ucsusa.org/jknox/defense-spending-reaches-record-high-as-pentagon-fails-its-audit-for-fifth-time/ https://blog.ucsusa.org/jknox/defense-spending-reaches-recor...
- dralley 3y agoThe US shouldn't produce more Stingers. They're outdated, and our NATO allies have better options available, like the Polish Piorun. If we need domestic production then get a tech transfer.
- woobar 3y agoQuick googling says that Piorun is heavier, slower, smaller payload, and smaller operational range. But even if it is better, can Poland ramp up production to meet the demand?
- dralley 3y agoSays what reference? Every one I can find states the opposite. Not to mention Piorun has a much better seeker.
- woobar 3y agoStinger - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIM-92_Stinger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIM-92_Stinger Mass Missile – 22 lb (10.1 kg) System – 35 lb (15.7 kg) Effective firing range 0.16–8.05 km (.1–5 mi) Warhead weight 6.6 lb (3 kg) Maximum speed 745 m/s Piorun - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piorun_(missile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piorun_(missile) Mass 16.5 kg (36 lb) total 10.5 kg (23 lb) missile Operational range 400 m (1,300 ft)–6.5 km (4.0 mi) Warhead weight 1.82 kg (4.0 lb) Maximum speed 660 m/s
- jandrewrogers 3y agoThere is no credible basis to believe the Piorun has a better seeker. Piorun's seeker uses a design similar to obsolete variants of the Stinger. Modern Stingers share a guidance package with the AIM-9X Sidewinder and, unlike the Piorun, have dual mode imagers that work in both IR and UV which makes them impervious to flares.
- openasocket 3y agoI’m mostly surprised that they stopped the production line without any planned replacement. It sounds like the US still doesn’t have plans to develop a new MANPAD or even a new stinger variant. Was there really a point where the US military thought MADPADs weren’t going to be important in conflict, or was it just so low on the priorities list that it wasn’t taken up?
- CydeWeys 3y agoI mean, yes. They aren't that important to us. We have much better systems, both on land and airborne. The problem is Ukraine hasn't been given most of them (and admittedly our best tools for maintaining air supremacy, the F-22 and F-35, are super expensive and require lots of maintenance). We've also given Ukraine just a tiny fraction of the Patriot and NASAMS systems that we ourselves would use.
- tomohawk 3y agoA lot of the weapons we have given to Ukraine are old, and we'd have to pay to dispose of them before too long. Giving them to a good cause is a fitting use for them, and actually saves money. See for example the Zuni rockets and many other items. It's totally crazy that the pentagon put out a contract for more of these almost obsolete weapons. I'd love to blame RTX, but if someone at the pentagon is willing to put the money out, it's hard to blame them for taking it.
- skhr0680 3y agoI get it: the US strategy of dominating in the air means their normal ground troops should never be facing an enemy air offensive at all, which makes Stinger-type missiles largely useless to them.
- _8j50 3y agoI think that depends in the enemy amd battlefield. Combating China from Taiwan for example, I doubt US Navy can take out all Chinese fighters.
- dragontamer 3y agoChina can't even reliably see the F22, and probably can't lock their missiles onto an F35. How are they supposed to fight against invisible air-superiority fighters (F22) and nearly-invisible multi-role Fighters? (F35) ? ---------- The worry with China is their missile forces, not their air force. The Chinese missiles have a chance at wrecking the USA's Aircraft Carriers.
- _8j50 3y agoAir-to-air combat yeah but I was talking about Chinese bombers/fighters targeting land targets in Taiwan and heading back home safely to mainland China before Taiwan/US jets intercept them in time. They have a lot of capable jets and US has good short range missile defense tech.
- ortusdux 3y agoReminds me of Fogbank, a material used in early US nuclear weapons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fogbank https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fogbank "The material is classified. Its composition is classified. Its use in the weapon is classified, and the process itself is classified." When it came time to refurbish the warheads, everyone in the know had long since retired and documentation was minimal, so it took over a decade and $100m+ to produce a usable batch.
- Sniffnoy 3y agoThere's an interesting little wrinkle here I read somewhere (sorry, I forget where) -- it's likely that it would not have been so expensive to merely produce something that would have worked in place of FOGBANK, or even that would have worked better than FOGBANK. The problem is that because testing of nuclear weapons is now banned (for good reason!), if they produced something different but better, there would have been no way to test it and confirm it. So they had to produce the same thing, yielding this result. Of course, that's just something I read somewhere and don't even remember where, so it's possible that's not accurate...
- sacnoradhq 3y agoThe problem is it's not just storing all of the jigs in a mothball warehouse, it's that a BOM for a 5-deep subassembly subcontractor vertical supply chain may have no substitute for custom parts with a 12-month+ lead time and require the living process knowledge of particular technicians, engineers, machinists, operators, and more to deliver the goods. Companies go out of business, employees retire, and then you're like a VW mechanic looking for NLA parts or 3D printing your own. Then you're calling around, bribing companies to make your custom shit that they may not make anymore. This shit takes a lot of time and logistics.
- Animats 3y agoIt's strange that the electronics is the problem. A redesign using modern electronics should not be too hard. IR sensors have improved enormously since the 1980s and are now consumer items. You can even get high dynamic range versions for flare resistance. Might not even need sensor cooling now. You'd expect the rocket and explosive parts to be a more of problem. Many companies make electronics, but few make rockets. DoD has a new consortium to make a new Javelin, but it's just Lockheed and Raytheon. They're not going outside the DoD contractor community.
- greedo 3y agoIt's not a problem, if your goal is to design a new MANPADS. If your goal is to build new Stingers, that are compatible with a bunch of other systems, and perform to specifications XYZ, then it's more challenging.
- Animats 3y agoThe interfaces are probably well defined. The seeker head should plug into the rest of the missile via some well defined connector and some well defined mount point. The new unit has to be compatible, but not identical.
- m3kw9 3y agoWhen every part/assembly/testing needs to be mil grade and haven’t made one in 20 years, you have this issue
- frozen11b 3y agoHonestly stingers don't really matter to the US inventory we don't even have an MOS to a job for operating of a man Portable anti-aircraft weapon.and it should be known that the javelin can actually engage the same targets as the stinger. How do I know this, javelin qualified in 2001. Yes it's easier to use a stinger to walk on a fast mover or a helicopter. It is possible with a javelin and if you lock it will hit it.
- greedo 3y agoI thought the Army had 14P for that?
- Giorgi 3y agoIt would be interesting, I bet they can modernize manufacturing too, arms industry is super interesting in that matter.
- rvba 3y agoWhy did Raytheon change name to RTX? On a side note, this explains why US army acquired (bought?) the Piorun MANPAD schematics.
- credit_guy 3y agoLet's talk about the Tomahawk cruise missile. Introduced 40 years ago, and most likely still unparalleled until today. Wikipedia states that the unit cost is $2MM in 2022 dollars [1]. Not clear where the number comes from, but if you check the DoD budget ([2], page 86), you'll see that the 2024 procurement for the US Marine Corps will be of 34 missiles for $105 MM, which comes to a bit more than $3MM apiece. The more concerning thing is the number though: the entire US military will procure only 34 missile for the 2024 year. For a sense of scale, during the 2003 invasion of Iraq, 802 Tomahawk missiles were fired. If we ever get into a hot war with China or Russia, we'll need to fire thousands per month. How can the military industrial complex scale from 34 per year to thousands per month? I hope that the reason these missiles are so expensive is that they keep the assembly lines running, so that if the need arises the production can quickly ramp up. But it's a very difficult optimization problem: on one hand you don't want to waste money on missiles you will not need, on the other hand you want to be able to get them in huge quantities when you'll need them. How do you maintain the production capability as a nation at peace? I can appreciate that the answer is not easy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomahawk_(missile) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomahawk_(missile) [2] https://comptroller.defense.gov/Portals/45/Documents/defbudget/FY2024/FY2024_Weapons.pdf https://comptroller.defense.gov/Portals/45/Documents/defbudg...
- dharmab 3y agoUh, the Marine Corps is not the entire military. The Navy buys a significantly higher number and they're ramping up production by about 6x over the next few years. Other countries buy them too - UK and soon Canada, Australia, Japan and the Netherlands.
- credit_guy 3y agoFor the 2024 year, the Navy is not buying any new Tomahawks. They are refurbishing the ones they have. The only branch that buys Tomahawks is the Marines, and they only buy 34.
- ftxbro 3y ago> "American engineers have encountered difficulties in manufacturing the homing heads for these MANPADS" this sounds like an important part