9 ms·
Brazil's Jair Bolsonaro is barred from office until 2030
- motohagiography 3y ago[flagged]
- peepeepoopoo13 3y ago[flagged]
- josephcsible 3y ago[flagged]
- vkou 3y agoHow is it not? Election laws exist, if you break them, it's your problem. Not enforcing election laws is what's incompatible with democracy, because it results in a loser being declared the winner. When you're caught tampering with an election, there's no reason to give you a chance to try again. When you're caught organizing a coup, there's no reason to give you a chance to try again, either.
- djaychela 3y agoBecause that handful of people is there to ensure that the laws of the country are followed, and that those who break them are punished. That's an integral part of democracy.
- simplelogic1 3y ago[flagged]
- peepeepoopoo13 3y ago[flagged]
- andreresende 3y ago[dead]
- cogman10 3y agoIn a country with 200 million people, do you think Bolsonaro is the only one that can carry the will of the people? Bolsonaro was attacking democracy. Claiming the election was stolen and ginned his supporters up to try and cease power by force. That sort of person is incompatible with democracy.
- ftxbro 3y agoOK but what if the will of the people is to move forward from democracy?
- andybak 3y agoThe word "forward" needs a bit of explaining here.
- ftxbro 3y agoThe expression "move forward" is just an idiom. It's like "circling back" except about the future and with a more forward-thinking can-do and proactive attitude.
- shitpostbot 3y ago[dead]
- felipelemos 3y agoIn a democracy, the only way forward from a democracy, legally speaking, is through laws. Specifically a new constitution. And the constitution (at least in Brazil) is very clear on what happens of you try to depose the democracy by force.
- cogman10 3y agoThen they can do what every other nation that has lost democracy does, elect a dictator with enough party members to undo democracy and kill off the opposition. Heck, they can get Bolsonaro back in power with exactly this playbook. It'll generally help if the party runs on a moralist/religious platform. "We've sinned and need to bring the nation back to god." That way, as the party breaks laws they can claim to do it in the name of god so that's ok. This even often gives them some wicked heathens to hate. Having a common enemy really brings people together. However, if they can't find that it's easy enough to blame outsiders for all the problems. Perhaps a conspiracy or two about how "those foreigners are taking all our jobs, resources, and are generally making everything here worse. If it wasn't for them, our country would be amazing. Let's make their lives a living hell because they've harmed everyone with their presence" You know, standard fascist stuff.
- pessimizer 3y agoWe wouldn't democracy to become a popularity contest, where the country is run by whoever most people prefer. The safety and security of the Homeland is too important for that.
- andybak 3y agoYou might want to read up on the complex design that went into Athenian democracy - to some extent to ensure that it wasn't just a popularity complex.
- ribosometronome 3y agoThen how is any restriction on who can be leader compatible with democracy?
- xp84 3y agoExcellent point! If 100% of Americans (and the EC as well of course) voted to make King Charles President, he still wouldn't be, since he's ineligible by law. That also would defy the will of the people but I think most of us are okay with that.
- carlosjobim 3y agoHe would most certainly be, since reality moves by itself and not by any rules written by men.
- felipelemos 3y agoThe will of the people is expressed in vote and then indirectly applied by the elected officials. If 100% of Americans decided to make King Charles president, then they will amend the laws allowing him to do so.
- skissane 3y agoIf literally 100% of Americans are voting to make Charles III their President, that 100% must include Congress unanimously voting to approve the constitutional amendment to make him eligible to run for President, and all the state legislatures voting to ratify it. If any of them vote against that amendment, then your premise that 100% of Americans vote for him would be false.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoMaybe the thing that wasn't compatible with democracy was giving politicians a free pass to commit crimes by making it taboo to talk about holding them accountable.
- Arnt 3y agoBasically: The demos isn't prohibited from deciding something that conflicts with its own later will. There's a vaguely similar case in Germany at the moment, where a political party and its voters was in favour of a a rule to keep fringe parties out of parliament, and now that same party is in danger of falling below the threshold it helped set, even if it wins every seat for which it fields a candidate. The voters for that party wanted the threshold then, wanted it to apply to future elections including the upcoming election, and if their party is below the threshold in the upcoming election, their past will conflict with their present vote. Nothing compels the demos to have conflict-free preferences.
- andreresende 3y agogreat day
- isitademocracy 3y agoIt depends. If you are right-wing, this was actually a very much great day: Bolsonaro is the worst candidate the right has ever produced in Brazil, and his removal from the next elections make it almost guaranteed that the left will not take it again. If you are left-wing, this was actually a terrible day. If you disagree, you are not paying attention.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYou're right about Bolsonaro, we have much better candidates now. I still don't consider this a good day though. This blatant and shameless persecution and censorship makes a mockery of the very concept of justice. They had to bury the constitution to do this. Why should anyone take this circus seriously after all this?
- dredmorbius 3y agoArchive / paywall: <https://archive.is/4Q1qO https://archive.is/4Q1qO>
- refulgentis 3y agoThe odd thing about BRICS becoming cool in certain tech circles* is you really couldn't pick a worse time to claim any of BRCS were doing well * the new "Great Reset"
- bpodgursky 3y agoSomeone talking about the BRICS as if it's a real, meaningful bloc tells me they are a clown. China is going to be a meaningful player no matter how far in the dumps they get, and India is doing fine. The rest? lol.
- jpgvm 3y agoIf China and India ever make friends geopolitics will change pretty drastically.
- kranke155 3y agoVirtually impossible in the current dynamics of the region, and I don’t think this has ever happened in history.
- bpodgursky 3y agoMaybe? In concrete terms I'm not sure what that means. Both countries are going to work to their individual interests like they do today.
- kjs3 3y agoPeople have been saying the same thing about China and Russia since they got in a pissing contest in the '50s. Or if some fraction of Africa ever decides to work collectively. There are lots of 'what if...' scenarios that will radically change geopolitics and do wake me up when one of them comes to pass...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ftxbro 3y agowaiting for Elon Musk to buy Brazil and reinstate Bolsonaro
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- isitademocracy 3y ago[dead]
- convalescindrey 3y agoWhat were the Supreme Courts reasons for deeming this unconstitutional?
- rodolphoarruda 3y agoThe claim that the current system, including the current eVault, is good enough.
- convalescindrey 3y agoThat can hardly be an argument to rule something new as "unconstitutional". I'm going to need to assume that this is an oversimplifying summary then?
- rodolphoarruda 3y agoI agree with you, but the members of supreme court don't seem to care. They use even shallower arguments to justify a ~1996 eVault model as "reliable" and "safe", and the public opinion has to buy it. Bolsonaro decided to step up against all that, and the rest is history now.
- convalescindrey 3y agoUnfortunately he did a lot of BS along the way which made it easy to dismiss everything he said.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pyuser583 3y agoWhy did the Supreme Court rules against it? And which Supreme Court (doesn’t Brazil have three)?
- seydor 3y agoCurious about the context here. I know there are a lot of Brazilians in here but there seems to be more here. I also wonder how far states will distort democracies using the judicial system, until humans decide they ve had enough and replace politicians with AIs
- napsterbr 3y agoOne side will claim the trial was unfair or overreaching or political. The other will claim that the judicial system did work as expected and followed the rules it set forth well before the 2022 elections began. I have my own take, but then again it is heavily influenced by my own bias. It's hard to share an unbiased opinion here. The idea that Lula is using his political power to take Bolsonaro out of the game is laughable, IMO.
- thrwBR 3y agoGood summary but I think you missed one piece. Lula was convicted and ultimately was allowed to run and govern.
- rodolphoarruda 3y agoGood point. And that is where Lula and Maduro are very similar being both byproducts of a sophisticated political elite operating behind the scenes in Latin America. (some people use "deep state", but I think it is too much of a US based terminology. In Brazil we say "sistema", the system, and we are more used to it.) This elite in Venezuela is responsible for keeping Maduro where he is today. And its Brazilian counterpart is responsible for releasing Lula from prison and making him a president within a 2 year time span. Maduro and Lula cannot do any of that by themselves.
- skissane 3y ago> The idea that Lula is using his political power to take Bolsonaro out of the game is laughable, IMO. I doubt Lula is calling up Superior Court justices and telling them what to do-but he doesn’t need to. It is like the 2000 US case of Bush v Gore-all the Republican-appointed Supreme Court justices voted for Bush, all the Democratic-appointed justices voted for Gore. The first outnumbered the second, so Bush won the Presidential election. Neither candidate or party ordered the justices to vote a particular way-they didn’t need to. The US court system has been corrupted by politicisation. The same appears to be true of Brazil-and Argentina too. Indeed, I wonder if there is any judicial system in the Americas which is free from that disease. (Canada, maybe?)
- mzitelli 3y agoTo clarify, he was convicted after organizing an official event with ambassadors from various countries to claiming the Brazilian electoral system was fraudulent. This discourse was usual throughout his term. He repeatedly claimed to have evidence, but never presented any. We now know that there was a plot for a coup [1], which failed to materialize due to a lack of support from a section of the military. Even though the superior courts have a political nature, Bolsonaro went against the law in an attempt to overtake the political system. The same way a murder trial is a crime, a coup trial also is. Today is a big day for Brazilian democracy! [1] - https://www.correiobraziliense.com.br/politica/2023/01/5065920-minuta-que-previa-golpe-entenda-o-documento-encontrado-na-casa-de-torres.html https://www.correiobraziliense.com.br/politica/2023/01/50659...
- matheusmoreira 3y agoSo what if he did? How the hell is that a crime? "Abuse of political power"? What a joke. Completely made up nonsense. Out of all the questionable dumb shit he said during the pandemic, this is what he goes down for? It's obvious they just wanted to destroy the guy and everything he represents. Remember what the TSE judge-king said? The voting machines are "unquestionable". It's trivial to raise reasonable doubt against such standards of perfection if you bother to look. The military audit for one said the voting machine software's makefile would download unaudited libraries off the network and link them to the final binary. It's fruitless to try to convince laymen who barely understand what source code even is of the importance of that fact but I'm sure anyone here on HN will appreciate the potential for a supply chain attack on the voting machines. You know, the very same type of attack people submit blog posts here on HN about every few months, same attack vector that compromises developers of big tech corporations. Faced with such criticism, they should have released the signed binaries that ran on election day so we could reverse engineer them. Instead, they grepped the report for the words "there was fraud", didn't find it and censored everything as "fake news". Literal censorship. You call this a democracy? You apparently forgot all about the relentless, nearly unilateral censorship campaign against Bolsonaro in the months leading up to the elections. Lula defends abortion but it's fake news to claim he did. Lula is friends with communist dictators but it's fake news to say he is. Lula is a socialist himself but it's fake news to say he is. Lula was condemned by multiple judges for corruption but it's fake news to say he was. Only yesterday he went to his communist forum and openly said he's proud to be called communist. I just saw news that there will be "military exercises" with the countries of Lula's dictator friends, hell he welcomed the Venezuelan dictator on our soil. You call this a democracy? These supreme court judges are openly biased and they think nothing of blatantly unconstitutional political censorship. Who are you supposed to turn to when your supreme court judges start openly shitting on the constitution? I'm supposed to believe my country even has laws after witnessing that? Whatever bullshit the judge-kings write on their paper is law. I'm not convincend this coup nonsense is anything but smoke and mirrors. Actually I wish these people had the balls to attempt it. Given the entire justice system turned into this circus, only the military could possibly bring order to this mess. As far as I'm concerned, the judiciary planned and executed their own coup, they practically named Lula president. Even you admit it yourself: "Even though the superior courts have a political nature". Big day for brazilian democracy? We aren't one. It's a judiciary dictatorship. They're working to censor Bolsonaro friendly radio stations right now. Ever seen a democracy do that?
- pyuser583 3y agoSo Lula was disqualified by being in prison. Then the courts decided to release him and remove his conviction- on very specious grounds. Now they’re removing his main opposition. Wouldn’t it be easier to just cancel the election and choose the President themselves?
- napsterbr 3y agoOne could say this is actually bad news for Lula, in the sense that Lula and Bolsonaro need each other. For the next presidential election, any not-too-exteme right wing candidate has great odds of beating Lula, if he were to run for reelection.
- pyuser583 3y agoNot too extreme for whom? The Supreme Court? I mean Lula can beat anyone if the Supreme Court keeps this up.
- napsterbr 3y agoFor the voters. If Bolsonaro had not made fun of covid victims and needlessly spilled hate on every other word that came from his mouth, he'd be the current president of Brazil. A moderate right wing candidate will likely win for 2026, just like an hypothetical moderate Bolsonaro would have won last year.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago"Never fish in the Rubicon", Auron McIntyre [0], sums it up pretty well. Bolsonaro did not have the guts or the military support to go after his enemy, which of course has not such qualms. The US has its own analogy: FBI interference with the Hunter Biden investigation, as documented by the IRS whistleblower Gary Shapley, while heavily prosecuting Trump. You don't need to be a MAGA flag waving GOPer to see there is some imbalance there. To recap the non-exhaustive list of what went down with the DOJ: - Tipped off Hunter Biden's legal team about a search warrant on his storage unit - Prevented investigators from executing a search warrant on his house - Ordered a "cease and desist" on investigating Hunter during the 2020 election - Prevented investigators from asking questions about the "big guy" - Verified his laptop was real in 2019 and then went to Big Tech and told them to censor it during the election - And didn't even have the key witness in the case testify before the grand jury. This is simply how it works, not just in Brazil. The deep state isn't neutral, how could it be? [0] https://twitter.com/AuronMacintyre/status/1674867664743718928 https://twitter.com/AuronMacintyre/status/167486766474371892...
- hackerlight 3y agoIf someone wants to make an accusation of voter fraud, that accusation needs to go in front of the courts. Either it's true, and the state has committed a crime, and some people need to go to jail. Or it's false, and the person made the accusation cynically, recklessly damaging democracy, which should be a serious crime akin to defamation, and the accuser needs to go to jail. There's a third possibility, which is that the person made the allegation in good faith even though the allegation is false. But it should be up to the courts to figure it out. Because trial by media where someone can make false allegations freely -- far more damaging and evil than defamation towards a single individual, yet somehow not a crime even if the claims are lies -- is clearly not working.
- thrwBR 3y agoI dislike Bolsonaro but I find it ironic that the current president (Lula), a convicted criminal, was not barred from office but Bolsonaro, who was never convicted, has been barred. The political nature of superior court in Brazil is disgusting and will destroy the democracy.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYeah. Witnessing this circus makes me sick to my core. They destroyed democracy a long time ago when they started censoring "fake news", these are just the final nails in its coffin.
- Daishiman 3y agoI take it you never even read about Lula's supposed conviction then.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYeah sure. The biggest corruption scandal in the history of the country, it's all a sham, right? All that testimony and evidence, must have been nothing but lies because of some jurisdiction technicality. Had a new trial held in Brasília and the first thing they did was throw out all the evidence. I watched god knows how many politicians get arrested. I saw one get caught with dirty money in their literal underwear. Now I get to watch the supreme court presided by these same judge-kings erase everything they did one by one, and censor anyone who reminds people of facts because they're "spreading fake news". I get to watch Lula give them government positions where they make about 30x what the average brazilian makes on salary alone. That's the "father of the poor" right there.
- Daishiman 3y agoYeah, it was mostly a sham.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoTotally. The actual judges who tried him? Shams. It's these politician-appointed supreme court judge-kings who are impartial, fair and all knowing. I totally believe you.
- nmrtkl 3y ago[flagged]
- 2-718-281-828 3y agoisn't lula the good guy?
- thrwBR 3y ago[flagged]
- irusensei 3y agoWhy don’t they just release the source code and schematics for the voting machines and related systems? Why do they insist on only allowing a select number of professionals, picked by finger whom have to sign an NDA to audit the system? Please note that I’m not claiming fraud here but the sheer arrogance of the Brazilian government in positioning themselves as a source of truth. “It’s safe because I say so”. Am I being unreasonable? Here is a decade spanning thread of the Brazilian government trying to convince Mozilla to accept their super CA audited by… themselves: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=438825 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=438825 So just open source it and add a feature citizens can verify the firmware. It will shut up the rightoids or any future sore losers of course but it will also bring the attention to every field related researcher on the planet to find the ugly vulnerabilities and shitty software quality and they don’t want that. And why the hell something that decides the future of a country the side of Brazil is closed source and kept in secrecy? No other reason than conceiving a terrible job I would say but while I’m assuming incompetence I can’t also blame whoever claims foul.
- cassianoleal 3y agoLet me begin by saying that I wholeheartedly agree the they should open-source it, not only the source code, but perhaps the hardware designs as well. > “It’s safe because I say so”. That's not quite the case. There are members from different parts of society, including regular civilians, who audit the system. Moreover, the political parties (the most interested parties in this whole thing, arguably after the general public) all have representatives who can audit the system. O procurador regional eleitoral deve indicar, então, um representante do Ministério Público para acompanhar os trabalhos da comissão. Os partidos políticos, as coligações, a Ordem dos Advogados do Brasil (OAB), o Congresso Nacional, o Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), a Controladoria-Geral da União (CGU), o Departamento de Polícia Federal, a Sociedade Brasileira de Computação (SBC), o Conselho Federal de Engenharia e Agronomia (Confea) e os departamentos de Tecnologia da Informação de universidades também podem indicar representantes para acompanhar os trabalhos do grupo. Loosely translated: The regional electoral attorney must indicate a representative of the Ministério Público [0] to follow the works of the committee. The political parties, the alliances, the Order of Attorneys of Brazil (OAB), the National Congress, the Supreme Federal Court (STF), the Controladoria Geral da União (CGU), the Federal Police Department, the Brazilian Society of Computing (SBC), the Federal Council of Engineering and Agronomy (Confea) and the IT departments of universities may also indicate representatives to follow the works of the group. [0] Similar to the USA's State Department, if I'm not mistaken [1] Not sure what would be an equivalent. They're a Government organ responsible for taking care of public patrimony, provide transparency, fight corruption and other things Link: https://www.tse.jus.br/comunicacao/noticias/2020/Dezembro/veja-como-funciona-a-auditoria-de-funcionamento-das-urnas-eletronicas https://www.tse.jus.br/comunicacao/noticias/2020/Dezembro/ve... So you see, there's a lot of space for people from outside of the Government, the Electoral Court and the political system in general to take part in the audit proceedings. I personally know someone who has followed the audit process. He's also fighting for opening up the source code but has vouched for it. In fact, one of his arguments for opening up is precisely the fact that the audits have all come out well (with observations for improvements).