20 ms·
Canada plans brain drain of H-1B visa holders, with no-job, no-worries permits
- CyberDildonics 3y agoHere is what the article is actually about in case you can't decipher it from the title: Canada has launched a bid to attract techies working in the USA on the notorious H-1B visa, by offering them the chance to move north. The offer, announced on Wednesday as part of the nation's first ever tech talent strategy, means H-1B visa holders can move to Canada without having a job waiting for them.
- new_user_final 3y agoIf you have American H-1B visa, you can move to Canada to work without having a work permit in Canada.
- arroz 3y agoThat’s not it. You can apply for a open work permit.
- mabbo 3y agoThese are exactly the kind of immigrants any country should be desperate to have. The majority of costs a person will typically have on a country are their initial K-12 education, and their health care costs later in life. Immigrants like these will never cost the government that first major cost. At the same time, they are far more likely to have higher than median salaries when employed. That means higher taxes paid. So from a purely economic point of view, an H-1B immigrant is a perfect profit center for government taxes. Meanwhile a Canadian who gets their K-12 education here, gets a highly government subsidized post-secondary degree, then moves to the USA to work and pay taxes there is a huge loss, economically.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mr90210 3y agoI am in a similar situation in a EU country, where I just live and pay taxes to, my income comes from a company located in another country. The inefficiencies of the country where I live and the quasi-xenophobic sentiment towards foreigners (mostly Americans foreigners) made me decide to plan to leave. I agree with your points, and I think that Canada will have to work smartly to retain those people otherwise they’ll end up leaving.
- 1over137 3y agoCanada's population is already 23% immigrant, highest of any G7 country. There may be less of that 'quasi-xenophobic sentiment towards foreigners' than where you are.
- mr90210 3y agoWell I am not necessarily saying that they need more immigrants, that’s up to them.
- zirgs 3y agoJust because someone is an immigrant himself doesn't mean that he doesn't hate other immigrants.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYes, that's my personal experience. Immigrants are more xenophobic than those born in Canada.
- 1over137 3y agoOf course. But it might mean that the 77% of the population that is born in Canada is more accustomed/acclimatized to immigrants. They are not a weird/rare thing, and so they are accepted/liked by a bulk of the population.
- skissane 3y agoI’ve heard before immigrants take quite negative stances on “illegal”/“undocumented”/“irregular” immigration, saying “I had to jump through all these hoops to come here, I have no sympathy for people who break the rules instead”. Is that xenophobia? Years ago, I went on a business trip to the US, and while there an Indian-American colleague said some very Islamophobic things to me. I guess he probably brought some of that with him from India, although certainly there would have been things in the US to reinforce it. Also, he was a 9/11 survivor and this was only a few years later, so that was likely a factor too. There is some obvious overlap between Islamophobia and xenophobia - although not all Muslims have an immigrant background (converts), and there are billions of non-Muslim foreigners
- JustLurking2022 3y agoHave worked with quite a few H1-Bs with absolutely no special skills. Large off-shoring firms soak up quite a few of them for people coming out of degree mills. The only advantage to businesses is that these people are modern indentured servants, due to their immigration status being dependent on their employer. I'm all for getting rid of that but I also think there should likely be a smaller number with a salary based bidding system (e.g. if you aren't paying in the 80th percentile or above for a person in the industry of that age, you're not getting H1-Bs, and yes age not years of experience since the latter is easily fudged). Otherwise, it simply continues to be a way for companies to suppress wages.
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoThen theoretically, these changes for H1-Bs should both protect them from the indentured servitude, and by removing that leverage, remove the motivation for H1-B abuse. If companies can't bring someone over that they can overwork and underpay at threat of deportation, they'll rethink the MBA-brained "optimizations" and be forced to create a more resilient workforce rather than a loose collection of people to rugpull every time the rate of profit increase dips by .0004%.
- shiftpgdn 3y agoThese days H1B is strictly a wage suppression tool and filled with low skill workers from India based degree mills and body shops. Actual skilled workers are coming in on L-1 or O-1 visas.
- the_svd_doctor 3y agoIf you’re already in the US and eventually want a GC (typical Us graduate), both of those are not very good option and H1-B is better bc of its dual intent.
- grimgoldgo 3y agoThat is patently false. Plenty of skilled engineers come from around the world on H1B visas.
- varispeed 3y agoIt's not as simple. My country (UK) has skilled workers visa that has wage requirement set often at half the market rate for given job. For instance, company can pay a software developer as little as £35k. Given that it is much more expensive to gain skill when you are a native, the government somewhat pulled the rug from underneath the locals who spend a lot of money to go to uni etc and were hoping to have a decent return on their investment in education. This also creates disincentive for locals to learn these in-demand skills. If you combine this with the fact that companies can rent out these cheap workers at £500 or more a day, while avoiding paying taxes it is a poor deal that only benefits big corporations.
- iamflimflam1 3y agoI'm sorry, but have you really honestly been impacted by this? Have you applied for a job and been told that they don't want you because there's a cheaper immigrant available? Have you had a job and been replaced by an immigrant?
- mikece 3y agoYes: his wage is artificially depressed by "market conditions" due to the willingness of foreign workers to make less. This is especially harmful to entry level developers who haven't had time to build up a niche/profitable specialty.
- madeofpalk 3y agoI do not see this "market conditions" in the UK.
- varispeed 3y agoYes. I see fewer offers coming up and at lower rates. I also saw a few jobs of colleagues not renewed and replaced by immigrant teams supplied by a big consultancy. If this trend continues, I'll be looking at retiring early or moving overseas.
- red_admiral 3y ago
- mrangle 3y ago[flagged]
- shyn3 3y agoIt's actually part of our national immigration strategy. If you have 2 kids you can get to Canada faster especially school age. If you have over $500k you used to be able to get into Quebec and drive into Ontario. Since 2010 the goal was 100m in 2050 Right now we need farmers.
- randomdata 3y ago> Right now we need farmers. What for? As a Canadian farmer I struggle to grow my operation because there are 100s of other farmers lined up in front of me, champing at the bit to do the same, with not enough resources to go around. I could more than double the size of my operation without breaking a sweat. I spend most of my days working in tech because there isn't enough farm work to do. In fact, nearly half of all farmers in Canada have an off-farm job, with 68% of them working full-time off the farm. Those who have bitten off more than they can chew likely think we need more farmhands, but they could also downsize and let other farmers pick up the slack.
- carlosjobim 3y agoWhat's the difference between a farmer and a farmhand? Like, why do you work in tech instead of being a farm hand on your surplus time? I assume since you are experienced, they'd offer you a good salary? Or is the matter not that they need farmhands, but more that they need cheap labour to exploit?
- randomdata 3y agoA farmer owns a farm business. A farmhand works for a farmer. While it is not completely unheard of for farmers to also be farmhands, there is difficulty in that the farms will generally share the same busy seasons. Meaning that your employer will want you on the job most especially during the times you will want a vacation to work on your own farm. For me, it is also questionable how much I want to help out the competition. While farmers are generally good spirited and try to work together for a greater good, there is still only so much resources to go around, and I want to see my business thrive. I'd jump in and help in a pinch, but to make it a career... But it is also true that tech will pay me more than other farmers will. That certainly seals the deal.
- x3874 3y ago> These are exactly the kind of immigrants any country should be desperate to have. People of often having a cultural, religious and moral background completely different to more-or-less original value Canadians? How will that work? Oh i guess by appeasing everybody to create that multicultural society with less & less identity of its own, just the same bland globalized aftertaste. The major Canadian cities beside Montreal and Quebec are already taken.
- OldManRyan 3y ago"Original value Canadians" sounds like a dog whistle to me but ignoring that, I grew up in a melting pot city and all of the different cultures intertwining ends up creating a unique culture in itself. LA is different from NYC. Seattle is different from Toronto. All of these cities have many different types of immigrants co-mingling but none of them are the same.
- symlinkk 3y agoThey don’t co mingle though. They segregate themselves into “Mexican neighborhoods”, “Indian neighborhoods”, etc. They marry and socialize amongst themselves.
- howinteresting 3y agoAnd what is your contribution to addressing that? It is easy to call entire groups of people "they", but they are people to and maybe the rest of society needs to welcome them with an open heart before they'll integrate.
- hot_gril 3y agoI think you're overestimating how sensitive immigrants are to this stuff. Comarriage is way more about preserving their family culture than it is about finding someone accepting. Religion and spoken-at-home language will matter. Sizeable chunks of some immigrant populations simply won't melt, which IMO is fine in a place like Canada or the US. They'll still work with everyone else, and I feel like profession and class are both way bigger dividers than ethnicity anyway. A white SWE probably knows more Indian SWEs than white janitors.
- safety1st 3y agoAs a patriotic American, I applaud Canada's plan. The H1-B is a badly run program in many ways, it is a vehicle for large tech and staffing firms to commit graft, entrench their market dominance and enrich themselves, by exploiting H1-B workers and pitting them against Americans. Like so many things it masquerades as beneficial for America but in reality the benefits accrue mainly to the small parasite class which makes the rules and revolves between Washington and private industry. If what's needed to shake this program up and shine a light on the corruption is some competition from our neighbors to the north, sounds great to me. Maybe Canada should extend this program to Americans who don't have health insurance, too. The resulting surge of expatriates just might force the parasite class to rethink America's archaic and corrupt health care system as well.
- muzaffarpur 3y agowhat do "these" americans bring for canada?
- red-iron-pine 3y ago"Raises the IQ of both countries"
- hot_gril 3y ago"diabeetus"
- stickyricky 3y agoWe should shift our perspective on our native-born citizens. Because they're such a massive economic drain we should _stop_ investing in them completely. I know it sounds radical but hear me out. We can realize higher economic utility for our society if A) we stop all investments in non-skilled, non-working-age citizens and B) export those people who are a burden on our society (children, the elderly, the sick, people who enjoy EDM, you get it). In this way Canada can achieve higher economic utility for itself. I'm imagining a system where everyone in the society is brought in on a temporary basis. They are imported after their post-secondary education and exported maybe 10 years before their retirement. In this way we avoid all the costs associated with having "people" in our country and instead we reap the economic reward of their labor! I guess I shouldn't say "our" country. I would be exported fairly quickly... But! To those glorious (and brave) few on the executive committee entrusted to leading Canada Inc. through these difficult times, the society they get to inhabit will undoubtedly be the economic envy of the world!
- coding123 3y agoFavorite comment all year.
- weard_beard 3y agoA modest proposal. The back-ronym for it should be S.W.I.F.T.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> I'm imagining a system where everyone in the society is brought in on a temporary basis This is how the Gulf economies work. (Also the Vatican, but for different reasons and at a different age.)
- unsupp0rted 3y agoIt's the Gig-economy model of citizenship and social welfare and it'll take Canada by storm
- geodel 3y agoFully agree on it. Kids are another great source of profit center that have not been fully utilized. Also we need to explore if un-exportable olds can be mined for parts. That would another win-win.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y ago[flagged]
- throw123123123 3y agoIf only you applied the same logic to americans
- ufish235 3y agoMediocre citizen checking in - I would never live in the US.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoI would never live in the US, but I'm free to be angry at what the last 20 years of provincial and federal governments have done to this country -- especially the under-regulated real estate market which is out of control relative to the rest of the G7 and driven cost of living through the roof. Not so much for me as I'm mostly mortgage free at this point, but for my kids someday, I despair. That, and underfunding the health care system and underbuilding infrastructure It's a corrupt and mediocre country. But it wasn't always like this. And no, I don't blame Trudeau. Both major parties and the entire corporate & political class are implicated.
- aprdm 3y agoIt's just catching up with other big cities. Owning a house in London/UK, SF/US, SYDNEY/AUS etc. has been out of reach forever. Canada has a lot of challenges, as have other countries. Mediocre, rofl.
- grimgoldgo 3y ago[flagged]
- pcthrowaway 3y agoYou must not have talked to many people who live in Canada then. Lots of people here in tears over how this country has fucked them over.
- moneywoes 3y agoHmm curious but wouldn’t they also suppress wage growth for local Canadians as well?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoNo, unless there is a worker shortage which would push up wages in the shorter term but reduce the number of jobs in the longer term as companies flee to countries that have available workers, or implement automation. Basically there isn't a fixed number of jobs. As you add people you need more jobs to provide goods and services for those extra people.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoNothing new there. Wage growth in Canada isn't just stagnant it's terminal.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoYou haven't seen terminal wage growth yet. The salaries I looked at in Italy are the same of 10 years ago, within a 100€ (sometimes down!) Disclaimer: I did move to Canada from Italy, one of the reasons was the insanely low salaries for IT
- aprdm 3y agoCanada is the 2nd or 3rd country that pays more for SWE in the world, what are you talking about ?
- geodel 3y ago> So from a purely economic point of view, an H-1B immigrant is a perfect profit center for government taxes. It is just all things being equal and they are specially not equal in this case. If they were so great countries producing them would have used them for no-downside profit but it is not happening. US being hub of thousands of high tech companies also not finding much use of them lately. I guess good on Canada for finding such a profit booster in times of economic downturn.
- BuyMyBitcoins 3y ago>”The majority of costs a person will typically have on a country are their initial K-12 education, and their health care costs later in life. Immigrants like these will never cost the government that first major cost.” Something about this is horribly depressing. It’s bad enough that the private sector is doing everything humanly possible to maximize profit. It makes me wonder what the point of citizenship is if government officials and elected representatives see the cultivation of those born in the country as more expensive and burdensome than just bringing people in. And, it sounds like the government is more interested in higher salaries for new arrivals than longtime constituents. And it’s not like this is sustainable either. All these much more profitable immigrants are going to become settled and have their own children, who will then become just as expensive to educate.
- vkou 3y ago> It makes me wonder what the point of citizenship There's a pretty important point to citizenship. If you have it, you can't be kicked out.
- carlosjobim 3y agoPurely economic points of view were also used to justify slavery. Many times with exactly the same arguments that are used for labour migration today. I've heard your arguments time and time again, and sadly most people think like this. Even though any economic advantage of labour immigration is mostly reaped by big businesses. A society has failed completely if it depends on abusing foreign labour to function. Let's not pretend that they are hiring the foreigners because it would be too expensive for them to hire locals of the quality they need. You can either side with the employers and think that this is great, or you could side with the people and think this is wrong. I was born in a place were the school children are in the absolute top of the world in their knowledge as measured and awarded by Pisa. And I know from hiring local people, that the youth there are smart, hard working and honest. At the same time it is a place where the media together with politicians and businesses continuously blast out how there is a "shortage of competent labour" and that they need more immigrants. The truth is of course that they don't want to pay. I think it's just audacious to claim there is a shortage of competence, when there is nothing wrong with the stock material. There is a shortage of willingness to pay a decent salary for labour. And there is a fairly high amount of hatred from older generations towards younger generations. A hatred that I have never understood, but it is there out in the open. Nobody has the right to cheap labour. If your business cannot turn a profit without paying lower than market rate salaries - you are simply a failure. You don't go demanding more immigrants so you can cut wages. You don't go demanding child labour so you can cut wages. You have to improve your business or admit that you are a failure and close shop. No sympathy for businesses and sectors that cannot survive without abusing labour. They are not needed. The talk about expensive education for native children is completely false, and just weird. Children are not expensive to educate anywhere in the world. Education turns expensive because corrupt practices of the governments that administrate education. The same government that then turns around and says the country needs more foreign labour because their own children are too expensive and incompetent. Let's compare it with a farm. The owner of the farm notices that he can get more milk to sell by not letting the calves have any milk, letting them die instead. So soon he has no more cows and he goes on buying more cows from another farm. "Great! These cows start milking right away, no need to feed them for a year like I would have to with those annoying calfs" And so on the farmer keeps milking his cows dry and just buying more from his neighbours. All the while people are complementing him for what an economic mastermind he is and how horrible those calfs where that were just drinking all his milk. That is the idea that has taken hold today.
- theironhammer 3y agoWhat makes u think they'll stay?. First chance they get they'll move back to the USA because the salaries are that much better.
- xbonez 3y ago5 years to Canadian citizenship is a strong reason to stay. Indians on H1B in the US are looking at about 7-10 years for a Greencard, and then an additional 5 years after that for citizenship. As a datapoint: I immigrated to the US in 2008. After 5 years on an F1 visa and 10 years on an H1B, I'm still at least 10 more years away from being freed from the immigration and visa hassle.
- TMWNN 3y agoSo when are you planning to move to Canada? No? Could it be because you and I both know that FAANG companies' Canadian offices are basically places to stash those who cannot and will not ever get US visas, plus the occasional native Canadian who does not want to move to the US for family reasons?
- amrocha 3y agoYou're both underestimating how many people would hate to live in the US, and overestimating how high salaries in the US are compared to Canada
- TMWNN 3y agoFirst, your answer has nothing to do with my question to xbonez about why, despite his being stuck in the US H-1B morass, he did not mention planning to take up this offer. Second, your supposition of my under/overestimation has nothing to do with the factual composition of FAANG and other US tech companies' Canadian offices. As I said, they are a) mostly people who cannot and will not ever get US visas (i.e., those who didn't make the first hurdle that xbonez was lucky enough to cross), and b) a few native Canadians who for one reason or another don't want to move to the US.
- bilekas 3y agoIt’s also not a big risk at all as the US has basically already vetted them by way of the H-1B visa application. Really it's a win win and as you say, minimal cost.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoAll statements are true. The thing that is glossed over and usually just dismissed is the impact on locals and impacts those immigrants have on wages and unemployment rate.
- octacat 3y agoIf we trying to maximize profit for the government - that's correct. On another hand, extra people would make extra pressure on the housing market (especially well paid developers, especially on the overheated market in Canada). So, that means inflation and it is bad for the regular citizens. If before they needed to work forever to afford their own housing, now they would have to work even more.
- jxi 3y agoThe problem is that for a productive H-1B holder in the US, they have no incentive to move to Canada if they're already doing well. Canada's wages will be less than half of what they would get in the US and healthcare in the US is better if you have good insurance. What's more likely to happen is the people who take Canada's offer will be the ones that were let go for performance reasons or have other productivity or efficiency issues.
- dukeyukey 3y agoOr those from the wrong country with extreme green card waiting times, those who roll the wrong lottery number, or were working at companies that went under.
- ppeetteerr 3y agoWhile I would agree with you in an otherwise normal year, in the year of layoffs, this policy may be the kind of fast-thinking that actually makes sense.
- 5440 3y agoMan this applies to me. I got an bioengineering degree and had to go to the US to find work. I started at $30K in the US and now I'm up to over $350K/yr. Would love to come back to Canada but the horrible expereince of applying for over 100 jobs and no interviews was disheartening.
- extasia 3y ago350? What do you do?
- hot_gril 3y agoCanada does have an issue with brain drain. It's kinda funny how the US has awful K-12 education but world-class university and post-grad opportunities, so immigrants come here once they're almost ready to be productive. H-1B and other immigration paths make sense if the goal is to collect the most tax money. But the country has to (at least somewhat) work by the will of its people. Even many immigrants who have gained citizenship are opposed to easing the immigration policy.
- slt2021 3y ago>US has awful K-12 education US has awful public K-12 in most of School Districts. Private schools are very good, but cost just as much as college. What I understand is that anything good in America costs $$$$. And all the free stuff is the same quality as a free couch on a sidewalk
- rawgabbit 3y agoFree couch may have bedbugs which will literally suck the blood out of you.
- slt2021 3y agoyeah and your kids can be shot to death at any public school in the US
- hot_gril 3y agoI did go to a private high school that had better security, but that required driving further, which probably more than negated the safety benefits.
- midoridensha 3y agoYes, I think that was the point of that comment.
- hot_gril 3y agoYeah, I'm thinking of private schools too, but not many people go to them. Otherwise I would say the education is decent. End of the day, average American graduating grade 12 probably didn't get much. Everyone I know from other countries loves the US except for the K-12 public education. There are (or were?) second or third world countries where private is the majority and only really poor people go to public.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoIn my opinion this will only worsen Canada's tech scene, compensation bands for tech workers, and the type of work done here, while undermining our university system and local talent development. It will just push us more in a mediocre "near shoring" direction and undermine actual local innovation and discriminate against homegrown talent. Here's why: Remember that Canadian graduates from engineering/CS university programs here can go directly south to the US without much hassle under a TN NAFTA VISA. They have a lot of advantages over H1B holders. So what this really ends up being is an exchange between local talent -- who will go south to where the salaries are much better under TN -- for immigrant talent that currently struggles in the US. Remember that the local talent was developed under subsidy by Canadian universities. Our tuition rates are a fraction of the US private universities -- while being very high quality. And while they're not free, they are highly funded by the gov't. So... indirectly, we are subsidizing US tech employers with Canadian taxpayer dollars. I've heard numbers as high as 75%, 80% for the number of e.g. University of Waterloo (highly respected CS/SWE school) graduates who go south after graduating. Meanwhile H-1B type candidates who come up to Canada will likely be doing it only as a stop-gap before returning to the US; because compensation here is on the whole not competitive with the US, the US was the destination they likely had in mind in the first place, and the selection of employers and interesting companies here is far worse. And this will only worsen the compensation gap between here and the US by flooding the market with talent; which will thereby encourage more of our own homegrown talent -- who wants to get fair compensation -- to go south ... along with a bunch of these H-1B holders. Vicious circle. The structure of things are such that Canada has already simply become on the whole a "landing pad" for talent before they relocate to the US. This only further entrenches that. While I'd say this was not the case for Google Canada (where I worked before) it is the case for most other large US-based employers. And the local companies are on the whole choosing to underpay and take advantage of fresh-off-the-boat talent from overseas at lower cost. Most shops here aren't doing much of interest, and the VC community here is fairly insular and conservative. The kinds of businesses that will generally succeed here will be places that can take advantage of large work forces of 'meh' imported talent, while the high quality talent finds ways to get to Silicon Valley. It's also not a great deal for the immigrants who come here; they will find that cost of living here is terrible while compensation rates are lower. There's already a growing recognition/bitterness among many that the Canadian gov't is selling an image of prosperity and potential to skilled immigrants that it can't deliver on when they arrive. And it used to be that at least one could hope one's children would prosper, but the state of the real estate market here is such that most will never able to own a home or get out of debt. That said, remote work may change this somewhat for some. At least it has for me, giving me a wider pool of (American) employers to choose from. All in all, I don't think this is much of a good move for Canada. Canadian employers need to learn how to compete with the US for quality talent by offering quality interesting work with better compensation that matches the insanely high cost of living in cities like Toronto or Vancouver -- cities with Bay Area real estate prices & rent but with compensation ranges far lower.
- kafkaesque 3y agoCanada is doing this wrong. What will happen in practice is someone who lives in the US with an H-1B will move to Canada to get that "easy" job, all the while applying for jobs in the US. As soon as they find one in the US, they will leave again. This solution is a band-aid and Canada will be used as a doormat, as it often is.
- phendrenad2 3y agoTo play devil's advocate: why should I care what immigrants my government is desperate to have? My government would probably love to deport me, a native-born citizen with disabilities. I'm not as valuable as a H1-B AI developer. So by this logic, what right do I have to stay here?
- surge 3y agoTotally not a scheme to keep wages suppressed and avoid having to pay market rates to people who are already in the country, and have the skills needed.
- hugocbp 3y agoThat is going to be interesting, but not in the positive sense of the world. A lot of tech workers affected by the rounds of layoffs last year are still struggling to find other jobs, specially the most junior ones. I've been personally trying to help some friends and ex-coworkers and it is brutal out there. Right now there doesn't seem to be a lack of tech workers, at least not in Vancouver. Canada housing situation is also not that great and with no signs of improving. At first glance, it looks like those measures will only serve to devalue the tech salaries even more (already at a considerable discount over US ones) and make the housing situation even worse. I don't expect most people using the new visas will want to live in the countryside, specially considering if they come without a job lined up. The majority will likely want to come to Vancouver, Toronto, Montreal.
- version_five 3y ago> At first glance, it looks like those measures will only serve to devalue the tech salaries even more (already at a considerable discount over US ones) and make the housing situation even worse That's exactly the point, but they call it "addressing a skills shortage" and there is a huge entrenched interest in keeping the property bubble going higher and higher. Mortgage rates should be slaughtering house prices, more scarcity is the only way to keep them high.
- morkalork 3y agoSeems like people are waiting to sell because of the high rates instead of settling for less.
- tenpies 3y ago> there is a huge entrenched interest in keeping the property bubble going higher and higher. Just to paint the picture, in Canada: * Prime Minister Trudeau is a trust fund kind with rental income * Finance Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Freeland, has four mortgages * Housing Minister Hussen literally purchased another rental property recently * 1/3 of all Liberal MPs have rental income in their disclosures What Trudeau is doing to Canada is what my friends and I call the Slum Lord's Delight scenario: * Flood the country with people who will need housing, while offering them no warning of just how unaffordable things are. * Do absolutely nothing to increase housing supply. Add as many new taxes, fees, and regulation as you can to ensure new supply declines. * Do everything you can to allow younger Canadians and new immigrants to borrow more and pay more for housing. Your solution to affordability is helping them borrow more, not reducing prices. * If anyone complains about immigration, call them racist. * If anyone complains about housing, blame the provinces and municipalities (whichever level isn't Liberal). * If anyone thinks of protesting, go Trucker Protests / Tiananmen Square on them I would not be surprised if Trudeau achieves a China-esque market before he's eventually removed or self-exiles, meaning a market where people never actually own the land, but rather have long term rentals (under a different name) of the property from a State owned company or monopoly.
- afavour 3y agoI’m honestly surprised it took Canada so long to do this. Always felt like an easy win to pluck some talented developers that are stuck in purgatory waiting for a green card and bring them north. Would have been invaluable a few years ago, right now the jobs market might not be so supportive of it. But we’ll see.
- version_five 3y agoCanada is seeing record emigration of it's own citizens (amongst other reasons, it's less affordable, less opportunity and lower salaries than the US). Anyone with the option (meaning the top people) will ignore this and stay in the states. This kind of thing works to get people, but not the best or even necessarily "good" people (from a qualification perspective)
- dkqmduems 3y agoI think a good number return once they have kids...
- mr90210 3y agoThe most qualified people are attracted by exciting challenges and excellent income.
- JustLurking2022 3y agoOn an aggregate level, probably true, but I've run across plenty of highly talented people in smaller markets and at less exciting companies purely because it's where they wanted to be.
- mr90210 3y agoAgreed. My comment was too absolutist.
- bovermyer 3y agoI dunno, I'm willing to take a pretty substantial pay cut to move to Canada from the USA. I like to think I'm fairly competent.
- LegitShady 3y agoI think you do not know how badly the housing gand healthcare crisis in Canada is right now. But you do you!
- 3y ago
- seydor 3y agoIt's nice to see the competition for immigrants but wish we would see more of it in europe
- lametr01 3y ago[flagged]
- spacephysics 3y agoGood way, and perhaps one of the only ways, to counter the coming population collapse and intense strain on social welfare and healthcare costs in next ~10 years
- lametr01 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lametr01 3y ago[flagged]
- gmerc 3y agoReplacement you say. Care to elaborate how this is replacing Canadian population? Are we shipping neonazis down south in return ?
- lametr01 3y ago[flagged]
- jkic47 3y agoNot the OP, but I suspect they meant that the immigrants will likely be young, and start families in Canada, adding to the population. Over time, this will likely change the demographics of the country "replacing" the "original" population
- ngcazz 3y agoMate, what are you talking about? it's a conspiracy theory and a racist dog whistle
- bovermyer 3y agoI have been trying to immigrate to Canada as a (US citizen) tech worker for the past six months. The H-1B visa thing is cool, but it's the other changes that are exciting for me. I'm particularly interested in the new LMIA exemption.
- kkukshtel 3y agoCan you say more about this? Which changes? Also interested.
- bovermyer 3y agoThese changes: > the development of an Innovation Stream under to the International Mobility Program to attract highly talented individuals, options for which include > > employer-specific work permits for up to five years for workers destined to work for a company identified by the Government of Canada as contributing to our industrial innovation goals > open work permits for up to five years for highly skilled workers in select in-demand occupations and: > the creation of a STEM-specific draw under category-based selection to issue additional invitations to apply under the Express Entry program
- moneywoes 3y agoJust do express entry, I did the same ( regrettably) I should add. Feel free to shoot any questions
- shagie 3y ago
- idontwantthis 3y agoI can’t imagine the stress of being H1-B. I know for a fact I just couldn’t handle it, so I admire anyone who is willing and able to take it on to better their life and their family’s. If I weren’t American I wouldn’t have the guts to try. It’s insane how they are treated; both for their own and for America’s wellbeing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BizarreByte 3y agoSo I can expect a mass influx of new workers and probably a lowering of my income/benefits over the next few years I guess?
- have_faith 3y agoDepends on if there’s a lot of demand currently not being fulfilled. You’d expect wages to go down if new workers flooded a market already operating in a sense of “equilibrium” for lack of a better word. I don’t know what the case is in Canada though.
- ricardobayes 3y agoMaybe, but you can expect a lot of new businesses being opened too. You would never dream of starting your company on a H-1B but with a blanket work permit you absolutely will.
- devnullbrain 3y agoYou can expect an influx of companies taking advantage of a base of talent. That's why startups pay SV rent.
- BizarreByte 3y ago> You can expect an influx of companies taking advantage of a base of talent. We have been promised this time and time again in Canada, but it seemingly never comes to fruition. Call me cynical, but I don't foresee it working out like that.
- fidotron 3y agoA cynic might be tempted to believe the purpose of the population is to work in almost but not quite well paid jobs in specific geographic locations where the only option is to rent at hilariously high prices, coincidentally from the law makers, while providing tax revenues to support the actual productive enterprise that is the government. But cynicism gets you nowhere.
- elzbardico 3y agoBeing an immigrant is stressful. period.
- mrtksn 3y agoI wonder what is the sentiment of complete abolishment on the Visa regime. Just plain background check for security maybe, and let everyone who wants in. Maybe keep the social programs for the citizens but let whoever wants to work, work. IMHO it's ridiculous to have the bureaucracy as the first step in employment, people shouldn't be asking bureaucrats for permission to work. Edit: Can you please also write why you don't like the idea? Are you worried about competition? About culture? About something else? Edit2: Wow, I wasn't aware of how much people love restrictions on working and traveling. Please tell me, I want to know your thinking behind this, maybe you are right about it?
- sokoloff 3y agoSovereign countries can set their visa (and citizenship and work eligibility) requirements. I’m not aware of any that have chosen fully open borders, mostly because that’s not in the interest of the citizens and residents of the country. Edit in response to P’s edit: if the country I’m in has a good balance of labor, jobs, and related resources, and is therefore a great place to live, what’s the incentive to open our borders to everyone and risk upsetting that balance with no way to turn off the tap?
- mrtksn 3y agoI don't say that they can't do that. What I say is, they shouldn't be doing it and any person anywhere in the world should be free to travel, live and work anywhere in the world. I'm curious about your argument against that.
- sokoloff 3y agoPeople in literally every nation appear to disagree with your position, at least as expressed in their border policies. If your position were the majority opinion, some nation somewhere would be trying it. For me personally, I think that the US would be a substantially less appealing place for those I care about if our population doubled to 700M. With open borders, we couldn’t prevent that. Do I support more immigration of high-skilled, highly educated people and their families? Absolutely. Do I support open borders? Absolutely not.
- manojlds 3y ago> Canada has launched a bid to attract techies working in the USA on the notorious H-1B visa, by offering them the chance to move north. If I move from Seattle to Toronto, I am going south.
- lordloki 3y agoYet still entering a colder climate.
- netfortius 3y agoI love the tongue-in-cheek "Land of the Free" :-)
- ac130kz 3y agoIt's only laughable. A few years ago I was thinking about migrating to Canada, and now I see houses priced around 1M CAD and salaries that are only 2x the amount I have now.
- shyn3 3y ago[flagged]
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoIt's because the situation outside (in poorer countries) is even shittier, and stocking shelves is not paid enough to be able to live normally (without 6+ people in one bedroom), because cheap foreigners living 6+ in one bedroom do it, instead of the company having to pay local workers high enough wages. Even if foreigners leave, someone new, from an even shittier situation will come and replace them. If shop owners were forced to pay native canadians the "livable" amount of money, the situation might be different... but I agree, that the housing situation is fucked in most of the developed world and governments actively try to keep it in a fucked state.
- grimgoldgo 3y ago[flagged]
- shyn3 3y agoBecause immigrants come here for a good culture but the people who built it are gone which makes Toronto a regular boring city. We leave where we came from because we hear ideas of how great it is and different from where we are leaving.
- alkonaut 3y agoFor context, what is the "normal" immigration policy for Canada? E.g. if you are a poor person from a random country with no H-1B? How many non-refugee economic migrants normally move to Canada in a year?
- discretion22 3y agoRight now is probably the best time to apply. The current government has a policy to maximize immigration, currently at over 400K/year. You do need to apply and meet basic criteria. Essentially be in good health (also all dependents accompanying you), have no substantial criminal history and have a reasonable level of education and have functional English or French. If you have French proficiency then it is substantially easier as you can qualify for special more relaxed immigration programs in Quebec (Quebec has different programs aimed at promoting French speakers). More advanced qualifications do help prioritize your application. The downside is getting established can be difficult - many immigrants do end up in low paid sales jobs at appliance stores, driving Uber, working in fast food places etc. Living costs are extremely high (rent, food etc.). Tech jobs tend to pay less than 50% of US equivalents (speaking from experience) though it is possible to work remotely for US companies and get paid substantially better than any Canadian employer would pay. Quite a few Canadians do that, but do have to constantly deal with the problems of cross border payroll as US companies cannot comprehend that Canada is a different tax system and keep screwing things up by filing stuff with the US IRS instead of the Canadian CRA and you then have to sort it out yourself and fill out mountains of paperwork to stop the IRS tax enforcement for taxes that are not due since you don't live in the US. Also speaking from experience.
- theironhammer 3y agoBring cash, lots of it. Your going to need it for rent. Oh and a really warm coat. Winter's last 6 months and it gets very very cold.
- sremani 3y agoCanada eating America's lunch is something that I have heard multiple times in past 20 years. There was a time where YC took pitches in Vancouver or something perhaps a decade or so ago. I do not know if they are still continuing this. At the end of the day, the immigration is only part of it. The economics of being Software developer compared to US or India are not that great (in general). That is where Canada in my humble opinion should focus.
- sashank_1509 3y agoTrue I think Bangalore beats Canada on software developer salaries. Bangalore in fact beats most of the world except Silicon Valley and NYC.
- paxys 3y agoCanadian cities have become as or more expensive than their US counterparts but have a way worse employment and salary situation. I don't see how this current environment is favorable for immigration. If anything it will make the problem worse. Where is the new housing going to come from? Who is going to create the new jobs? And if you don't have any jobs for skilled immigrants to fill, what exactly are they going to do in your country? And no, don't start with the usual "they will create a new Silicon Valley!". That's not how it works.
- mikece 3y agoCollect welfare (or is it called "social insurance" north of the border?). In actuality I expect there to be a rise in "mid-shoring" of technical work to Canada rather than overseas (same time zones, less appearance of selling out since it's sending work to Canada, not a "real" foreign country).
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoThe hardest thing for me to grasp about Canada is the massive amounts of government land, which is forests, which can become lumber AND to build cheap housing. A McMansion for everybody. Aren't many US homes built with Canadian lumber?
- luxurytent 3y agoYou need to pay for all the supporting infrastructure (roads, power, fire services, etc. etc). Not that simple :)
- Tiktaalik 3y ago1. No there's no room. Many of the existing urban centres are pretty much "built out" and no more McMansions for everyone. Maybe we could build an apartment for everyone, and a townhouse for many. This is the core reason why prices have spiked up so much. 2. There's actually not a lot of lumber. Mills are closing and lumber towns are dying. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/canadian-centre-for-policy-alternatives-bc-logs-1.6419399 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/canadian-cen... https://thetyee.ca/Analysis/2023/01/18/Running-Empty-BC-Forestry-Crash/ https://thetyee.ca/Analysis/2023/01/18/Running-Empty-BC-Fore... 3. People and the courts have come to realize that the "massive amounts of government land" are not actually the government's to give away. In many cases these lands are unceded by indigenous First Nations who are wrestling back control of their title and natural resources. All of this means that future use of the land is more complex than it may seem.
- tho3i23o4i23423 3y ago[flagged]
- noisy_boy 3y agoWhat I want to know is which countries allow parents to immigrate with the main applicant. Lots of countries don't allow it for the fear that they have to bear the health care costs; even when the main applicant is willing to give an undertaking to bear the costs. This excludes a section who have parents dependent on them. Singapore is one notable exception I know that grants a long term pass to the parents that folks can renew every 1-3 years, depending on the expiry - the sponsor needs to bear the healthcare costs but at least it provides an option to keep one's parents with them.
- alach11 3y agoIt's always funny to me to see the hypocrisy of HN on immigration policy. Low-income workers to clean our buildings, pick our crops, and receive more in taxes than they pay? Bring 'em in! High-income workers to drive America's tech industry success and pay way more in taxes than they receive? They're taking our jobs! While I'd argue we need both, the latter is clearly better for the nation, considering our skyrocketing debt.
- SonOfKyuss 3y agoIt’s easier to have sympathy for immigrants who are starving and dying trying to make it here and then demonized and used as a political punching bag if they do make it.
- sashank_1509 3y agoAs someone who’s on H1b this whole effort by Canada seems pointless and I don’t understand the rationale behind framing this law. H1b comes through a lottery. This year less than 10% got through the lottery (mostly because Indian consultancy scams that US govt is trying to crack down on but mostly won’t). Even in good years, a good 50% don’t get through the lottery. If you complete your masters in US, you get 3 shots at the lottery after which you have to leave the country (Called the STEM OPT extension). If you pass through the lottery you are mostly set for life in US. If you’re not from India or China, you just need to find a company to apply for your green card and then get in in 3 yrs (All of big tech will apply for your green card). If you are from India and China you will have a long waiting line, Indians in particular might have a 100 yr waiting line because of the massive amount of recent immigration. Even then your H1b lasts a total of 9 yrs, after which you can apply for green card and then get an EAD while waiting for your green card, which basically ensures you can stay in the country and work as long as your green card is processing. This situation is a bit stressful, because if your green card processing has issues and you get a reject, you have to instantly leave the country on EAD (your life is uprooted) but by this you are either 100% committed to living here or you’re gonna leave (a lot I’d estimate 50% leave back to India) Which brings me to my puzzlement regarding this law. The main bottleneck is the H1b lottery, I would guess easily a good 30-40% of Indians leave unable to get past the lottery and that number is increasing. Canada is also giving choice to those who went past the lottery. But if I went through the lottery, why would I ever consider going to Canada? No offense, but US salaries are easily double, and even higher the higher you climb, there’s no comparison really. And if Canada is trying to maintain quality of immigrants, the H1b is literally a lottery, a member of Google or an Indian outsourcing sweatshop like TCS have the exact same chance of getting through (and TCS applies way more for H1b) so this isn’t even a great quality filter. By my prediction, this won’t do anything to attract immigrants from US, because those who made it through H1b are not going to leave except to maybe return back to their home country. US is simply too good pay wise, and then on top of that most of the country is very welcoming to immigrants.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mavelikara 3y ago
- mmmBacon 3y agoI think the impact of these things is overstated. Salaries in Canada are pretty low compared to the US and cost of living is pretty similar. When you factor in the climate, it’s hard to see how Canada comes out ahead. I’d think Canada would need a streamlined visa process just to be in the race. Also from what I’ve seen, people often use Canada as a springboard to get to the US. I always maintain that most of the time whatever is good for Canada is also good for the US. I have a team in Canada so will be good for hiring.
- bonadrag 3y agoI don't know how this does not exacerbate the housing problem in Canada. It's terrible here. I own a rowhouse in a decent neighborhood of a middle-sized city in Canada. Prices have doubled since 2017. People moving to the same unit as mine have Teslas, Mercedes, BMWs. These people are making upwards 200k in combined income. The situation is dire here. My household income sits comfortably in the top 5% earning bracket and there is no way we can afford a bigger home even with a substantial equity in our current house. We've been looking into places 40, 50 minutes outside of the SUBURB we live (not downtown) and the prices are slightly lower but not enough to justify the move. Tell me how this will happen the situation of Canadian families here? The strategy of pumping immigrants into the system is not sustainable. At some point, you need to have a sustainable strategy with a TFR > 2.1. We need babies, not immigrants.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoI agree with you, but not sure on the conclusion. The housing problem needs to be addressed if we have more immigrant or not. The renting prices doubled in Vancouver, I have no idea how people are living there right now, given the median income
- rdevsrex 3y agoWell then you know which party to vote for if that's one of the most important issues for you. Or at least, which one not to vote for.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNote that housing is a provincial jurisdiction, so your provincial and municipal votes are the ones that matter, not your federal votes.
- Tiktaalik 3y agoSort of, except that the Federal government controls all sorts of things that influence housing development, such as taxation and significantly contributes to infrastructure spending. When we look at the last time an enormous amount of apartments were being built in this country, through the 60s and early 70s, the Federal government was deeply involved both in directly subsidizing coops and non-profit housing and also through tax expenditure which aided market housing. There were a great deal of federal tax incentives to build market housing, many of which no longer exist. Basically Chretien got the Feds entirely out of housing during the austerity budgets of 1993, housing construction plunged for decades and decades and now we seem to somehow have an enormous shortage. The Feds also are in control of Indigenous reserves, so a failure to build housing there is their fault.
- elzbardico 3y agoMaybe Canada should consider instead attracting first immigrants skilled in the trades to build more houses and medical doctors to improve health care. Pretty hard to attract tech talent with salaries that are way lower than American ones when your housing costs are fastly approaching NYC and Bay Area levels. Maybe someone desperate after the layoffs would bite the bait, out of sheer desperation, but this is neither sustainable nor human.
- randomdata 3y agoCanada brings in a whole slew of medical professionals. But provincial regulation often does not allow them to practice. Hence the doctor driving a taxi trope. Housing, also being a provincial matter, is another area where the provinces and Canada run disconnected. For those not from Canada: The Canadian government and provincial governments operate independently, in parallel, taking different areas of concern. They are considered equals, so there is no means for one to supersede the other. While the areas of concern are clearly defined, reality often sees matters cross into both, so you get such strangeness when one hand wants to do one thing and the other hand wants to do something else.
- aprdm 3y agoI’m pretty positive those are being fast tracked as well
- elzbardico 3y agoI hope so. Canada is a wonderful country.
- jdougan 3y agoIt probably won't work, the problem is a lot deeper than a something a few more talented migrants can fix. A few years ago Alex Danco wrote up what he saw as the issues [1] and it reads pretty much like the list I would have made in the 90s, except for the bit about Montreal. There were also other issues, like accounting practices, [2] which don't sound like thy have changed much either. [1] https://danco.substack.com/p/why-the-canadian-tech-scene-doesnt https://danco.substack.com/p/why-the-canadian-tech-scene-doe... [2] https://troymedia.com/business/tech-sector-canada-problems/ https://troymedia.com/business/tech-sector-canada-problems/
- deskamess 3y ago"I respect myself too much to stay in Canada" was an article that got a lot of traction. https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2023/06/11/i-respect-myself-too-much-to-stay-in-canada-why-so-many-new-immigrants-are-leaving.html https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2023/06/11/i-respect-mys... Just remember, Canada is geographically situated near the US but their attitudes to innovation, risk taking, rewarding talent, and merit based promotion are not the same. Even if they say that it is - the reality is very different.
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoCanada educates a lot of technical and medical workers into the US every year. There is no "brain-drain" except for the person that posted the article FUD. Keep in mind: 1. Canada work Visas usually have a 4 month window for you to get a position. 2. The wages are usually much lower than the identical US position (after currency conversion) 3. The incremental income taxes are relatively high 4. After a few months stay, you will be taxed on residency, and not nationality. If you have US citizenship, than you will still have to report in your home state as well (usually it is whichever is greater that is applied). 5. After several months stay, you can apply for a Medical Services Plan. Note, if you develop some issue while awaiting the provincial coverage it is common they will back date coverage. However, it is still highly recommended you keep your private medical/dental insurance during this transitional period. 6.Housing is expensive, and difficult to find these days. It may take some time to find a place if you have a large family. 7. Do a search to learn about TFSA, RRSP, and CPP. It will help you retain your earnings. 8. Due to the recent stressed medical system over several years, it is now rather difficult to find a doctor in some cities. This should be dealt with as soon as possible if you require care, as it currently takes months to find a GP. Do feel free to ask questions, as the parts of Canada currently not on fire are quite enjoyable. =)
- FalconSensei 3y ago> If you have US citizenship then it doesn't apply to this case, since H-1B visa holders are on this vis because they are not citizens
- red-iron-pine 3y ago> 2. The wages are usually much lower than the identical US position (after currency conversion) on the whole I found roughly 40% difference, but usually decent benefits. strong increases in tax brackets mean it's not really useful to offer you more money, since the gub'mnt will take more of it. meanwhile stock purchase plans or retirement options are generous. not great if you don't plan on staying in Canada long term. > 3. The incremental income taxes are relatively high this, like in the US, will depend on state / province; Quebec is the highest, but also offers great bennies, like free or low-cost child care / daycare. > 4. After a few months stay, you will be taxed on residency, and not nationality. If you have US citizenship, than you will still have to report in your home state as well (usually it is whichever is greater that is applied). you do not have to have a home state as a US citizen. if you need a home state, look into PO boxes in states without an income tax, like TX, FL, or WA. > 5. After several months stay, you can apply for a Medical Services Plan. Note, if you develop some issue while awaiting the provincial coverage it is common they will back date coverage. However, it is still highly recommended you keep your private medical/dental insurance during this transitional period. this is true. usually you have to be in province for 3 months before you can use the provincial healthcare. make sure you have private insurance coverage until then. > 6.Housing is expensive, and difficult to find these days. It may take some time to find a place if you have a large family. not true, generally was easy to find. if you live in the GTA or Vancouver you may have to go pretty far out, however. if you're looking for something large, cheap, and close -- you're gonna be holding your breath for a while. > 7. Do a search to learn about TFSA, RRSP, and CPP. It will help you retain your earnings. The only real takeaway is that the US IRS hates the TFSA, but RRSP are generally okay. The Canadian government will not be cool with you adding money to US retirement accounts. Figure out what an FBAR is, and if / when / why you need to file them. Also look into PFICs and penalties for holding Index funds, ETFs, or holding companies. It's not illegal, just a huge PITA with expensive overhead. Taxes will usually be a non-issue since you will subtract your Canadian taxes (usually higher) from your US taxes, which will result in little to no taxes; capital gains can get messy though. But you still have to file, and you probably want a cross-border specialist if you're north of 100k USD. > 8. Due to the recent stressed medical system over several years, it is now rather difficult to find a doctor in some cities. This should be dealt with as soon as possible if you require care, as it currently takes months to find a GP. Did not ever have any problems in Calgary, Vancouver, or Edmonton; can't speak to the eastern parts of the country. Care will also be different if you're in a big city, 2nd tier city, or small town, and often not in the ways that you think.
- arroz 3y agoLaid off canadian work permit holders don’t have access to open work permit in canada Meanwhile, laid off US work permit holders do if they move to canada Wtf? This is so fucking stupid Not only this, but Canada is already having issues with their own laid off people and their own housing bubble
- jxi 3y agoCreating new avenues for immigration is one way to try to plug the housing bubble problem (fresh new capital flowing in). Problem is I don't think it will work, and they'll instead attract even more extra mouths to feed and bring further social problems.
- emmanuel_1234 3y agoI benefited from a similar program a year ago, and although I have no regret, I feel that some honesty might help other. First and foremost, the Canadian tech scene is nothing like the US, Europe, or Asia where I'm coming from. Tech jobs are rare. The flagship tech employer is Shopify and they just recently downsized. Second, salaries are garbage, especially for migrants. There is a term for this situation called "Canadian Experience": employers claim that because one does not have experience working in Canada, they deserve a crappy salary while they acquire it. This is of course bullshit. It got so bad that it's actually been addressed by the government and made illegal, at least in Ontario[0]. Finally, the cost of life is absurd, with respect to income. In Vancouver or Toronto, rents are completely out of control, and buying is out of the question unless you have some serious funds, especially with the recent hike in mortgage rate. Price of food surged dramatically in the past months as well, and although I have a decent job (in terms of distance from the median salary), I don't go out nearly as much as I would want because it's too damn expensive. Now, Canada is a great place for normal humans to live in, especially with a family, and again I have no regret. But right now, it's not a good place to make it in tech. [0] https://www.ohrc.on.ca/en/policy-removing-%E2%80%9Ccanadian-experience%E2%80%9D-barrier https://www.ohrc.on.ca/en/policy-removing-%E2%80%9Ccanadian-...
- aprdm 3y agoMy experience is completely different from yours, lots f American companies paying 300k+ for seniors in Vancouver Sap, workday, Cisco, Amazon, Microsoft , meta , etc
- 908B64B197 3y ago> Second, salaries are garbage, especially for migrants. There is a term for this situation called "Canadian Experience": employers claim that because one does not have experience working in Canada, they deserve a crappy salary while they acquire it. This is of course bullshit. When issuing visas, the Canadian government uses a point system (age, degree...) that never actually checks for employability. That's how you get people claiming they were "Senior Engineers" in their home country that can't pass a fizzbuzz test. With a signal to noise ratio this low, a lot of employers simply won't bother unless someone can demonstrate that someone else is willing to employ them at Canadian wages for the position they claim they can perform.
- theironhammer 3y agoGotta keep the wages down.
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoWhy is Canada rushing all these visa initiatives? They've experiencing sizable issues with fraudulent student visas (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-64988228 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-64988228) which could be resolved with something as simple as having universities submitting paperwork to the immigration agency. Can they really handle reviewing 10,000 more cases on an expedited basis?
- soligern 3y ago[dead]
- txcan 3y agoOh those were not universities. Those were what we call in Canada "immigration mills or diploma mills" sun standard educational institution with a very high tuition fees and low bar of entry. It's money for citizenship scheme run by Canada. Cheap below minimum wage workers leading to wage suppression is the result.
- ArtemZ 3y agoI'm struggling to land any software engineering job for the last 6 months, even though I'm a permanent U.S resident and have 10 YOF and actively applying for jobs every day. I can only imagine how hard it must be now for H1B holders...
- dang 3y agoRelated ongoing thread: Canada's new tech talent strategy - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36506854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36506854 - June 2023 (59 comments)
- abledon 3y agoGoodluck finding Housing
- pjdemers 3y agoHow many tech jobs does Canada have? If everybody who wants to move to (or stay in) the US but can't because of visa issues moves to Canada, are there enough jobs for all of them?
- pcthrowaway 3y agoThere aren't even enough jobs for the people who are already here. See https://reddit.com/r/cscareerquestionscad https://reddit.com/r/cscareerquestionscad There also aren't enough houses for the people who are already here. Vancouver has a Vacancy rate under 0.9%, and we likely have more homeless people than available rentals.
- stjohnswarts 3y agoThis is a drop of water in the ocean. However I hope those people have great lives in Canada, it's an awesome country.
- FpUser 3y agoThey did not say if those wonderful visas can be in time converted to permanent residence. Hopefully they would let them apply for permanent residence from inside the country while being on work permit.
- arroz 3y agoThat’s not how Canadian PR works It’s a point system, you need to get the points The work permit has no relationship to the PR Canadian work experience gives you points though
- jmyeet 3y agoCanada has a ton of structural problems that will prevent this from doing anything most likely, namely housing and wages. The housing crisis in Canada is extreme and well beyond the very real housing crisis in the US. Previously people focused on Vancouver, which is insane, but now the GTA (Greater Toronto Area) is essentially unaffordable basically everywhere. Possibly the only exception is Quebec. There is no political will to fix this problem because houses have become retirement accounts and anything that reduces home values is political suicide. The second problem is that Canadian wages are incredibly low, even in tech. In the US at least software engineer compensation largely shields you from the housing and cost of living crisis. That is not the case in Canada. Canada is very similar to Australia, which also has a housing crisis. Both countries have an economy geared to resource extraction and the respective currencies move with commodity prices. I don’t expect this scheme to have much impact.
- isykt 3y agoNot much of a threat since it’s only 10,000 slots. There’s 420,000 H1B visa holders in the US.
- piloto_ciego 3y agoThis is a hot take and might rule some people up, but… Canadian Immigration policy is often racist, ableist, and just generally bad. The US’s policies are effectively worse in my opinion but the Canucks are often a bit short sighted with this sort of thing. The people support immigration… but they elect leaders who enact laws that make it really hard.
- Kranar 3y agoWhat is racist about it?
- piloto_ciego 3y agoThis one maybe just falls into the “just bad?” Arguably recruiting foreign workers from a group that’s in an extremely precarious position probably isn’t great.
- MPlus88 3y ago[dead]
- Tiktaalik 3y agohousing incredibly scarce rents and prices spiking "hmm maybe we should make it easier for enormously highly paid American tech workers to move to Canada." I like the idea in general, but the specific timing of this, as high interest rates are making house construction slow down and fixing the housing crisis even harder, is going to make a lot of inadequately housed Canadians very annoyed!
- kelipso 3y agoWell I guess Canada made euthanasia legal for a reason.
- octacat 3y agoGood for housing investors though (sarcasm). But yea, it is very easy for the government to "improve" economic situation by increasing the house prices. First of all, we build less = less money spent on the new infrastructure, profit. And if the prices go up, everyone who has a house gets more wealthy (except they cannot sell that, because they would become homeless). Also, makes banking very stable, if everyone knows mortgages are "very nice investment".
- safddsfds 3y agoGreat. At least it's going to a US ally.
- Kareem71 3y agoAs a Canadian who moved to the US for tech, I strongly advocate for any young Canadian with capable means who is reading this to leave Canada. An already broken system is being stacked against you Housing prices are more expensive in Canada. Health care systems are crumbling within Canada. Wages are lower in Canada. General cost of living is more expensive in Canada I was frankly shocked after a lifetime of watching CBC just how much my quality of life improved by moving to the USA.
- Cyclical 3y agoI had the exact opposite experience moving from Canada to San Francisco. While wages are much higher, the cost of living is not even comparable - anecdotally much, much higher in SF than either Toronto or Vancouver (both of which I have lived in). Healthcare has been a horrible experience here too, with Kaiser putting my through endless levels of bureaucracy in an effort to avoid paying for my medication.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoBut when did you leave Toronto? Because the situation is getting exponentially out of control. The housing market in southern Ontario & lower mainland BC is a pyramid scheme. When my wife & I first bought our house in Toronto in 2005 in a "bad" neighbourhood (Oakwood-Vaughan) it was a bit of a squeeze on our dual tech-worker salary, but we were able to do it. Fast forward almost 20 years, we would not be able to afford what that house goes for unless we financed to like, a 35 year mortgage, and my compensation has gone way up from back then. Meanwhile COVID f'd up the health care system extremely badly and there's no real commitment from the province to getting the funding situation under control.
- hgs3 3y agoH-1B's undercut supply and demand: if a company can't find workers (low supply) and they need them (high demand) then they're supposed to raise wages to compete for them. Artifactually increasing the supply of workers suppresses wages. It's crony capitalism.
- renewiltord 3y agoThe important thing to remember, for immigrants, is the power of unions. If tech workers unionize, the opinions they espouse will be like these from this thread, which I will quote below. Once they unionize they will have power. Once they have power, they will act on what they say they want here. Read the AFL's (largest union in the US) arguments against immigration[0] and you will see many of those below mirrored there. This what software unions will want. This is what they will push for. If you join them and give them power, you will find yourself suddenly on the outside in the cold. There is a thing Americans say which I like: "When someone tells you who they are, listen". They will talk about how you reduce their wages https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36511005 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36511005 > Artifactually (sic) increasing the supply of workers suppresses wages. They will consider you bad for "regular citizens". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36510490 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36510490 > So, that means inflation and it is bad for the regular citizens. Your existence will devalue their education https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36505802 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36505802 > Given that it is much more expensive to gain skill when you are a native, the government somewhat pulled the rug from underneath the locals who spend a lot of money to go to uni etc and were hoping to have a decent return on their investment in education. "Getting rid" of you will be considered a good idea https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36506071 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36506071 > I think US will benefit in the long run getting rid of these h1bs. You won't be considered to have "original values" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36505919 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36505919 > People of often having a cultural, religious and moral background completely different to more-or-less original value Canadians? How will that work? 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_policies_of_American_labor_unions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_policies_of_Americ...
- SEJeff 3y agoFWIW, Canada did something fairly similar with laws / incentives regarding filming whereas California became outright hostile towards the movie industry. That is why so many shows and movies are now filmed (believe it or not) in Canada and not in the US. https://reviewed.usatoday.com/canada/streaming/features/best-tv-shows-filmed-canada-netflix-amazon-prime-and-crave https://reviewed.usatoday.com/canada/streaming/features/best... https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?locations=Canada https://www.imdb.com/search/title/?locations=Canada The US is losing out on a lot of tax revenue because of poor policies disincentivizing an entire industry.
- version_five 3y agoOr the Canadian government is wasting a lot of money subsidizing an industry. It's not clear to me which is correct but I know many of our industries are effectively pretend and bought with government money
- SEJeff 3y agoHollywood has been spending literally over a billion USD equiv a year in "Hollywood North" aka Canada since around 2006. It creates thousands of local jobs and has a lot of follow on effects. This was more or less the culmination of super-NIMBY California folks making an entire industry pick up and move due to hostilities.
- version_five 3y agoSo, is it a net benefit or not?
- SEJeff 3y agoA large benefit for Canada, yes. It decimated the local industry in or around Los Angeles when I lived there. I was a software engineer and didn’t much care but had several friends who were affected.
- wasimanitoba 3y ago
- spandrew 3y agoI have two of these individuals on my team — who had to leave due to the harsh rules around the H-1B visa. During the Trump administration the backlog for processing these was molasses and I picked up two very talented individuals who have since gone on to become very high-functioning team mates. Good idea.
- ta889988 3y ago[flagged]
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoTerrible talent swap, bad deal for Canadians. Graduates from Canadian universities, who had their tuition subsidized by the Canadian taxpayer, can easily go straight south to the US under TN-1 NAFTA VISA and immediately obtain compensation sometimes 2-3x local rates. Meanwhile we'll bring in skilled immigrants who couldn't make it in the US immigration system. And drive down the wages even lower. Making it even less likely for local grown talent to stay. Race to the bottom, and it will do nothing for the quality of work done here.
- ameminator 3y agoThis is actually a terrible deal in disguise. According to recent reports (which I don't have on hand at the moment), over 70% of immigrants to Canada are under employed or under utilized. While the federal government controls how many immigrants, the provinces control certification and expert recognition. This means that foreign-trained doctors (as an example) can easily get a federal visa to enter the country, but the province will refuse to recognize their medical training, forcing these skilled immigrants to work low-skill jobs instead. It is not rare to find foreign-trained engineers working as taxi-drivers or for PhD-holders to be slinging coffee. Unfortunately, I don't think programs like these will have any beneficial impact until Canadian society can fix its abysmally low productivity (and productivity growth) as well as the severe under-utilization of skilled immigrant labor. All this will accomplish is exacerbate the housing crisis in metropolitan areas and further expose Canada's extremely poor economic performance - expected to be the absolute lowest in the OECD in upcoming years.
- 908B64B197 3y ago> This means that foreign-trained doctors (as an example) can easily get a federal visa to enter the country, but the province will refuse to recognize their medical training, forcing these skilled immigrants to work low-skill jobs instead. It is not rare to find foreign-trained engineers working as taxi-drivers or for PhD-holders to be slinging coffee. That's not the whole picture... Friend of mine is a doctor here in the Bay Area, originally trained in Ontario. There are agreements with some countries to transfer licenses (how he was able to practice here in America). Quebec, for instance, has agreements with France and Switzerland. When someone comes in with medical credentials from a jurisdiction where there's no special agreements, they simply have the candidate take the same exams as the medical students (which, should they be as qualified as they claim, shouldn't be hard). He told me the pass rate was abysmal for foreign trained candidates. Apparently, it's the same for engineers (and is one of the reasons a lot of them end up trying to break into software since it's unregulated).
- ameminator 3y agoI don't disagree, but now imagine Quebec having deals with (for example) France and Switzerland and Ontario only having agreements with Italy and Spain (but only for medical licenses), while Alberta may evaluate accreditation on a case-by-case basis. This is somewhat incredible to behold, as if 10 different countries had their own licensing treaties and then we bolted on a federal immigration system on top of that.
- pyuser583 3y agoSo US companies will hire remote Canadian workers at lower wages.
- pyuser583 3y agoCanada is simultaneously denouncing its own [existence](https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/land-acknowledgment https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/land-ackno...) and facilitating more colonization. It must be weird to arrive in Canada, and then be told your presence is illegitimate.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- appleaday1 3y agoJust commenting again, check out the situation or some top posts in Reddit that had recent discussions about this: [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/canadahousing/comments/13jl3gf/came_to_canada_3_years_ago_and_now_leaving_due_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/canadahousing/comments/13jl3gf/came... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/canadahousing/comments/147p0tx/ontario_get_readyyoure_going_to_lose_your/ https://www.reddit.com/r/canadahousing/comments/147p0tx/onta... If you are a potential H1B moving to Canada think again if you really want to spend a major amount of your income on renting.