8 ms·
I don't think this sort of emotional, loose-facted "hot take" style response is real constructive. I'm unhappy about this decision by Red Hat, and am also very
by freedomben 3y ago
I don't think this sort of emotional, loose-facted "hot take" style response is real constructive. I'm unhappy about this decision by Red Hat, and am also very concerned about the trajectory RH is on. For the first time in well over a decade I'm re-evaluating which ecosystem to base all my work (and the company(ies) for who I make decisions). I don't believe that Red Hat's leadership cares a whole lot about open source anymore. If they do, they've demonstrated that they are willing to harm open source in order to (short-term at least) increase sales. (congrats salespeople, you finally won and killed CentOS. And congrats to all the people who used to tell the salesperson "I can run CentOS for free, why should I buy RHEL?")
But that said, as far as I know, one guy used the term "freeloaders" and the context wasn't clear at all who he was talking about, and certainly not clear whether that is one person's opinion or the company's opinion. I find it incredibly unlikely that he was talking about people who used CentOS and actually contributed to the community. But either way, attributing that to Red Hat as a whole is completely unfair and unproductive. Every big organization is going to have at least one person with an opinion they don't agree with, and painting the entire org with the brush of one person is fallacious.
What's the goal here? Is it to polarize into good and evil sides? Get people to dig in and defend their ground for fear of the "other side" seizing their words or decisions and holding it over them?
I like a lot of OP's content, but I am a little worried that he's a little too immersed in the Youtube success formula of tapping into emotions (particularly rage and anger) and it's driving him to a very emotional take on this issue.
- lakomen 3y agoIt is exactly the right response.
- dmix 3y ago> But that said, as far as I know, one guy used the term "freeloaders" and the context wasn't clear at all who he was talking about, and certainly not clear whether that is one person's opinion. Yeah, Red Hat wasn't the one that called them "freeloaders", this was language The Register used in an article: >> Having given the move time to successfully eliminate most of the clones, Red Hat then killed off its own official free version of its paid-for flagship product. Instead, it switched to offering a free test version, an announcement which it made accompanied with lots of positive-sounding language about community involvement, and so on. In fact, what it was really doing was cutting off those that might be seen, from its perspective, as a bunch of freeloaders. The move was accompanied with free production deployment of RHEL for developers – but only up to 16 machines. https://www.theregister.com/2023/06/23/red_hat_centos_move/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/06/23/red_hat_centos_move/
- geerlingguy 3y agoThere have been two instances I have seen where the word 'freeloader' was used by someone internally at Red Hat. And there are a number of examples in public comments (one recently in the Fedora mailing list[1]) where you can easily substitute the phrase 'freeloader' for a longer description of the downstream communities. The same sentiment comes across either way. [1] https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@lists.fedoraproject.org/thread/PPM7P7IZYJZRVHS6LCFHVVIJ6FGWUPD4/ https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@lists.fe...
- lproven 3y agoHi there. I am the author of the Register article that you quote: > this was language The Register used in an article So, in response to that, I'd like to point out a few things. 1. This is, I feel, now widely and well-established language in this discussion. For example, note its use in the comments to this article about the discontinuation of CentOS Linux three years ago: https://blog.centos.org/2020/12/future-is-centos-stream/ https://blog.centos.org/2020/12/future-is-centos-stream/ 2. Others are using it in the context of this story; for example, here: https://fosspost.org/red-hat-is-shooting-itself-in-the-foot-again/ https://fosspost.org/red-hat-is-shooting-itself-in-the-foot-... 3. The direct personal reason that I used the phrase "a bunch of freeloaders" is that this is a Douglas Adams quotation, or rather, paraphrase. I am not an especially big name, but those who do know my name may recognise it: I was once the president of ZZ 9 Plural Z alpha, the official Douglas Adams appreciation society. I was interviewed quite widely in media around the world at the time that the Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy film came out. I used the phrase in order to refer to the Douglas Adams line about "a taxi service for a bunch of degenerate freeloaders." For reasons which I trust are obvious I removed the adjective.
- OnlyMortal 3y agoSo amazingly primitive they even think a digital watch is a pretty neat idea.
- lproven 3y agoFord? Yes? There's an infinite number of monkey outside, who want to share a single digital watch.
- 255 3y agoThis article is almost identical to the YouTube video just released, which I think partially explains the tone / style. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kF5pyVUQBH8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kF5pyVUQBH8
- barbariangrunge 3y agoI'm personally impressed that Fedora is fully open source while being released by a for-profit company. I would have expected, when learning about this ecosystem, for Red Hat releases to be proprietary for 5 years, and then have those versions switch to a FOSS license, just as a way to ensure they can monetize their work. But Red Hat, at least in the past, sounds like they did something amazing, being able to go foss at the same time as making money. I understand the red hat distro itself has stricter terms Not sure how they will fare under IBM, but the history of this company is pretty cool. I'd love to read more, if somebody knows of a really good article or writeup
- onedognight 3y ago> I'm personally impressed that Fedora is fully open source while being released by a for-profit company You shouldn’t be. Fedora is a community project. RedHat, while a huge contributor, does not maintain all the packages therein. In the end, RHEL is a fork of Fedora so it’s reasonable for the contributors to Fedora to annoyed by this change in the ability to make OS rebuilds of RHEL.
- wink 3y agoI'm not saying you're wrong, but that paints an overly simplified picture that ignores history. AFAIK RHEL came out of Red Hat Linux and Fedora came later, then at some point they made Fedora the upstream. But it has never been a "fork"[0] and there was no clean cut, it just transitioned around. [0]: OK, debatable - depends on the way you use the word fork. They're still Linux distros with common roots and packages were first introduced here or there. My main point is just that it's not like "Here's Fedora, and then later someone forked RHEL off" but more like RHL -> RHEL -> Fedora -> RHEL
- onedognight 3y agoYou are quite right to point out that I glossed over the RHL -> RHEL -> Fedora -> RHEL history. Thanks for clarifying. Yes, I was referring only to today’s community contribution workflow and what I considered the fair but now previous tacit agreement between RedHat and the community of spec patch contributors and packagers. We contribute to the packaging repo and RedHat makes that repo, even the “forked” RHEL branches, available in real-time, minus embargoed security fixes.
- microtonal 3y agoRegardless whether Red Hat said it or not, why not call it what it is? Not every CentOS user was a freeloader and the same is true for its spiritual successors. However, a large majority of CentOS users were not contributing back in any way to CentOS or the larger FLOSS community. Secondly, a substantial chunk of those users used CentOS because they wanted all the benefits of Red Hat EL without paying for it. That pretty much sounds like freeloading to me. Copyleft open source licenses allow freeloading [1], but they also allow Red Hat to gate source code. As long as they fulfill the license obligations towards their customers, it's fine. Red Hat puts enormous amounts of money in the FLOSS ecosystem, I think it's completely fair for them to nudge customers with deep-enough pockets to pay for subscriptions. For other users, there are plenty of other options. [1] For non-copyleft licenses, Red Hat are of course not obliged to provide source code.
- LexiMax 3y ago> As long as they fulfill the license obligations towards their customers, it's fine. This cannot be stressed enough. If we are unhappy with this outcome, maybe we should be taking another look at the licenses we choose when we release our work to the world.
- vbezhenar 3y agoLicense situation is still unclear to me. GPL explicitly does not allow to forbid further redistribution. RedHat does that. I'm not a lawyer, but from a layman PoV this seems sketchy.
- nolist_policy 3y agoI'm not going to analyze if this is illegal or not (I don't think it is). It has been discussed elsewhere already. But even if it where illegal, the only people in a position to sue would be the contributors of the upstream projects that get packaged into RHEL. And I don't see anyone having the appetite for that. I contribute a lot to QEMU and there I'm practically working side-by-side with redhat devs. They contribute so much (maintainership, code review, testing infrastructure and much more), suing them wouldn't occur to me in the slightest.
- Kaytaro 3y agoThis is like the tech communities version of the Ellen drama. Ellen is far from the worst person in Hollywood and Red Hat is far from the worst ISV, but because they’ve built their image on being the “good guy” anything they do contrary to that elicits a strong emotional reaction.
- solarkraft 3y ago> I don't think this sort of emotional, loose-facted "hot take" style response is real constructive I do. A basic pedagogic principle is that conditioning works better the closer the consequence is to the action. They should be afraid of backlash at every turn. People must be ready to actually walk away, otherwise you get into a Reddit-type situation in which everything ends up just like before.
- freedomben 3y ago> A basic pedagogic principle is that conditioning works better the closer the consequence is to the action. > They should be afraid of backlash at every turn. > People must be ready to actually walk away, otherwise you get into a Reddit-type situation in which everything ends up just like before I actually agree with all of that, but I don't think the hot take gets us there. You can have backlash and people walking away, while staying fact-based and even tempered. In fact I think that's far more effective because then (Red Hat in this case) will see the logical connection. If it's just emotional stuff then it's easy to dismiss the quitters as irrational fringe people that aren't reasonable anyway (and I don't think that's far off from the reality).
- redundantly 3y ago> But that said, as far as I know, one guy used the term "freeloaders" and the context wasn't clear at all who he was talking about One guy? The sentiment of CentOS users being freeloaders is shared by a lot of people, inside and outside of IBM. I remember when the original announcement came out that CentOS was being killed in favour of CentOS Stream. Lots of IBM (Red Hat) employees were defending the change by painting CentOS users as getting a paid product for free. Lots of people here on Hacker News and Reddit and other places were defending it as well. Don't try to rewrite history.
- tcmart14 3y agoThe sad part is the short nearsightedness. I know tons of RHEL engineers who only got into RHEL because they could essentially learn large parts of RHEL for free on CentOS and then go on to work professionally on RHEL. I also understand that a lot of courses to become official RHEL engineers/sysadmins use CentOS for the classes.
- hhhfgshanda828 3y agoThis is not true. Red Hat Enterprise Linux is currently available at no charge to students and non-commercial users for the use cases you mentioned. And it has always been available in that manner. It even comes with additional (paid if used commercially) red hat products on top of the OS itself. I have a tough time believing they didn't know that considering red hat basically advertises training on the free version of RHEL. They want you to pay to take the RHCSA, which costs much more than anybody would realistically spend on a personal OS for learning. https://developers.redhat.com/articles/faqs-no-cost-red-hat-enterprise-linux#general https://developers.redhat.com/articles/faqs-no-cost-red-hat-...
- freedomben 3y agoThe "free" RHEL licenses still require dicking around with subscription manager, and creating/maintaining a Red Hat account. It may not be much overhead if you already have paid RHEL instances, but for somebody who doesn't it's a stumbling block. I think it's great that Red Hat offers free dev subs and I applaud that, but I think they underestimate the friction that creates.
- dylan604 3y agoGeerling is very good at getting his content to the top of lists. I had the same sentiments you have at the second post on this issue with Redhat. Occasionally, he'll post something that piques my interest, but most of the time his YT style "marketing" is just too over the top. I know he's doing it specifically to get those metrics, and I hope it works for him and the audience it gathers is what he's looking for. Since he doesn't change, I assume it is. I'm sure he sleeps at night just fine
- gbraad 3y agoYT style is well expressed. this social media style is click bait and rife of misunderstanding/misinformation.
- gbraad 3y agothis is how he is. this kind people ain't mine. the style of publications is YT based, clickbaity and aimed at social media: grabbing the attention and polarizing. this is why I was done with Geerling months ago. it does not help with the conversation/community.