19 ms·
The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)
- krayz8 3y agohttps://www.interaction-design.org/literature/topics/forced-registration https://www.interaction-design.org/literature/topics/forced-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bombcar 3y agoThe Pinterest::Google interaction is the most annoying of these; it seems impossible to find an image result from Google on the page Pinterest shows you.
- ranting-moth 3y agoI'm a bit surprised that Google let Pinterest vandalize their image search.
- wpietri 3y agoWhich is especially funny given that Pinterest's business is basically one giant copyright violation. "We'll boost everybody's photos, but god forbid anybody take any of our stolen content from us!"
- marcod 3y agoGlad I checked before adding another thread about how much I hate pinterest. Seriously, no honor among thieves! :p
- isametry 3y agoI've been running uBlacklist [0] for over a year now on all my devices for two sole purposes: blocking (1) Pinterest, and (2) Quora from my Google results. [0] https://iorate.github.io/ublacklist/docs https://iorate.github.io/ublacklist/docs I can report a general positive impact on 98% of my searches. In the remaining 2% of cases (where I'm typically looking for some hyper-specific image I stumbled upon months or years ago), I can temporarily disable the filter with a single click. Adding domains to the list is also as simple as clicking "Block this site" next to a result. In theory, if you diligently block lots of crappy websites, you could gather a collection of domains that de-crapifies your searches extensively. But for me, results from Pinterest and Quora were the biggest gripes by far, and this has worked beautifully just for that. You can even subscribe to blacklists created by others, although I haven't explored that option so far. And your lists and/or settings can sync across devices with Google Drive. Available for Chrome, Firefox and Safari. * I'm not affiliated to the project in any way, just promoting what's, in my eyes, quite a useful browser extension.
- GuB-42 3y agoIt seems that the situation has improved a bit lately, I still get the Pinterest links, but not only I tend to get the actual image a bit more often, but Pinterest results get lower ranks. Essentially "we couldn't find anything good, so here is a Pinterest link so that the result page is not empty". Or maybe it is just me and Google profiling algorithms finally realized that I don't like Pinterest results.
- TobyTheDog123 3y agoThe reason for this (unjustified IMO) is bot/scraping prevention. On most VPNs you cannot browse profiles unless you're logged in. TikTok has a much more elegant solution to this problem (while still being a nightmare for bots/scrapers), with ByteDacne moving bot checks to the client with a mixture of proof of work and fingerprinting.
- syphermil 3y agoCan you elaborate on the twitter bot that finger prints?
- kome 3y agoif it was bot/scraping prevention you would allow more than 3 profiles or reloads... that's just to block humans. probably bots have a way to bypass this.
- throwaway1777 3y agoThis is the truth, and part of why almost all content based apps do it now.
- radarsat1 3y agoIt's actually not that bad a name for this if you think about the concept of 'fuck you' money, ie. that some people have so much money that 'fuck you' they'll do whatever they want. Similarly Instagram can only get away with this behavior because of their level of following as a social media platform. So many people use it that people want to use it to follow others, and will consequently put up with this bullshit, and consequently to they can get away with whatever they want because 'fuck you', people will keep coming anyway. Unfortunate, but not sure what lessons can be taken from it for other players in the market, since (fortunately) few other platforms are in a position to get away with this kind of thing.
- luma 3y agoReddit is now going through this process. Amazon's ecommerce platform made the "fuck you" shift a while back.
- syphermil 3y agoTwitter has a different ‘fuck you pattern’ when you are trying to sign up a new account and they believe you are a spammer. They will force you through never ending captchas that are not meant to verify you, but annoy you until you give up.
- throwawaymobule 3y agoI've only gotten a different sort of fuckery, where signup works fine until I follow a single account (or after a few seconds, sometimes) and then I'm banned until I give a phone number. contacting support used to work after a few days, but not recently.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, absent some very serious events, your 'fuck you' money will be there independently of what everybody else thinks. But the 'fuck you' monopolistic behavior will work only up to the point where you annoy enough people. It is an extremely non-linear thing, and nobody never has any idea of how much further you can go, or even how long you can keep it the same.
- mozman 3y ago> Did Instagram catch me trying to bypass their login modal? Most likely. IG has pretty effective fraud detection heuristics and you probably appeared as a bot due to UEBA deviation.
- duckmysick 3y agoFor others who are curious: UEBA = User and Entity Behavior Analytics
- galoisscobi 3y agoI don’t think this is a dark pattern per se. You don’t expect to walk into any restaurant and get free food. With meta products, you pay for content by being tracked. If you refuse to sign in, they refuse to show you content. It’s simple.
- fuzzy2 3y ago> If you refuse to sign in, they refuse to show you content. Ah, but this is not what is happening. They do show content! It's just that basically any interaction whatsoever with this content immediately triggers the login prompt.
- 0x_rs 3y ago>you pay for content by being tracked Meta likes tracking you even outside their own walled jail-platforms, too. https://www.theregister.com/2018/04/17/facebook_admits_to_tracking_non_users/ https://www.theregister.com/2018/04/17/facebook_admits_to_tr...
- swagasaurus-rex 3y agoI’d say its more like an art gallery where other people provide the content, but fuck you if you aren’t gonna give your privacy up
- galoisscobi 3y agoThat has been Meta’s play for a long time. It’s why I don’t use meta products and encourage others to do the same.
- sledgehammers 3y agoExcept in a restaurant, the chef gets paid. In this platform, value is extracted from the chef, the waiter, the eater, the eaten, and their interaction, while tearing down societies. Not a fair comparison.
- EGreg 3y agoWelcome to shareholder capitalism, extracting rents from all sides of the market perpetually to enrich shareholders. This is why utility tokens were such a big game changer for me. Remember Zuck was an open source bro who turned down M$ for $1M and ended up open sourcing Synapse. He built Wirehog, as a decentralized file sharing network. I was attending TechCrunch Disrupt 2010 in NYC and personally heard Sean Parker speak proudly about how they “put a bullet in that thing” — because it threatened corporate profits and rent extraction. Sean Parker learned not to mess with corporate profits, when his company Napster got sued into oblivion by the other “lock up the IP monopoly” industries — music and movies. MPAA and RIAA. So he started Plaxo and learned to be VC. Then he brought Peter Thiel, the guy who seriously advocates “competition is for losers, build a monopoly”. He gave Mark a lot of good advice and the VC industry turned him from an open source bro into a corporate golden boy who buys up the competition, the founders of which leave in disgust after their golden handcuffs are off (WhatApp, Oculus, and yes Instagram). This isn’t an isolated story. Elon owns Twitter. Bezos owns Amazon. The nicer guys like Ohanian and Jack got out, after selling, though. And they all want decentralization now. Moxie left WhatsApp and started an end-to-end encrypted messenger (Signal).
- vbo 3y agoMy fuck-you-right-back response is I don't sign up and give up using the app. I had an instagram account and deleted it years ago. I don't want a new one. Sadly instagram is sign up only, so good luck to them and good bye.
- faangsticle 3y ago[flagged]
- albert_e 3y agoLike the archive.ph bypass for soft paywalls on news articles ... Isn't there a website that simple records a GIF of the said tiktok/ IG reel and lets you share that instead?
- sheepishly 3y agoDon't know about Tiktok, but this site seems to work for IG to some degree: https://www.picuki.com/ https://www.picuki.com/ Don't know exactly how much it captures, but you can toss the page it gives you into archive.ph at least.
- mnsc 3y agoYup I have a friend that sends link to shorts(?) videos on ig and I usually open them in a private tab and accept only necessary cookies. The annoying part is that I only get to watch it once, if I miss something and want to watch it again I need to create an account... Nope! And it's usually just rehashed tiktok videos so I go there and search for it instead.
- sira04 3y agoI make burner accounts on these platforms for this use case. No profile image, random character usernames. works fine.
- BaseballPhysics 3y ago> So you either have to ignore your friends, bore them with your morals or just give in anyway. Is it really so hard to just say "Gah, sorry, I don't have an IG account"?
- totallywrong 3y agoIt's most annoying when businesses make IG their actual website, or restaurants have their menus there, etc. I've never been on IG and can't access the content, so they don't get my business.
- tough 3y agoYou can still go to the restaurant to eat presumably they'll have some paper menus in there, or QR's or whatever
- luma 3y agoOr I can go to any of a hundred different places that don't lock their info behind Zuck's paywall.
- faangsticle 3y agoSure, you could also just go to a supermarket. If you don't know what to expect, why risk it?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mr_mitm 3y agoIt's not that big of a risk to be honest. People did it all the time before the internet. Some people are not pathologically risk adverse and might even enjoy being surprised.
- mhb 3y agorisk averse
- bee_rider 3y agoIt was how restaurants worked for a long time. Of course, if you prefer the predictability of seeing the menu before you get there, that’s your preference, fair enough. But I wonder if you might miss out on some places run by cooks who put all their talent into cooking, and none into technology. Could be some good stuff…
- Glyptodon 3y agoIG is evil. So many small businesses seem to mostly have Instagram. And you can't effectively browse without signing up, the sign up will decide you're not real and lock your account, etc. They definitely attempt to detect frequent visits and circumvention of their walls to do harder blocks after. When they decided my account should be locked every visit to a business page started 404ing or something similar.
- omoikane 3y ago2021: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27666455 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27666455
- syphermil 3y agoIt’s not just you. Twitter has done this to me, when they assumed I was a spammer. Made me verify extremely difficult captchas that were intended not to verify me but to annoy me so I would give up.
- omoikane 3y agoTwitter doesn't do this anymore, probably because they don't want any popup to interrupt users scrolling through more ads, logged in or not. Instagram and Twitter's login prompt might have been motivated by a desire to increase number of logged in users, and Twitter might have given up on that in recent months considering the increased ad load.
- syphermil 3y agoIt’s not just you or an A/B test. This has happened to me before with twitter.
- paddw 3y agoI think what makes this a "fuck you" pattern is the fact that you are given a "teaser" of the content before being forced to log in. Like, if IG forced you to login to see anything, you might dislike that, but it wouldn't feel manipulative.
- throwaway1777 3y agoI feel like almost every app does this. Pinterest, quora, reddit, Twitter. They’ve all had “features” like this.
- quattrofan 3y ago[dead]
- web3-is-a-scam 3y agoInstagram doesn’t even work for me, any link someone sends me just goes to a white blanks screen. I refuse to make an account so I just tell people to stop sending me those links because it’s just a waste of time.
- fwlr 3y agoThe IP-level block you experienced after trying to get around the login modal is an anti-scraping measure. I doubt it is based on anything like “detecting that you’ve opened web inspector”, it’s much more likely that Instagram is running some heuristic that tries to bucket you into either “potential signup” or “scraper trying to download as many images as possible”, and once your behavior pattern fits into the second bucket they apply a (very) temporary IP block. It comes off as extreme and insulting to a regular user, but it is also one of the few methods that scrapers can’t trivially dodge (it’s fairly easy to maintain a roster of IPs, but that is merely easy, while e.g. changing your user agent to pretend to be a different browser is trivial).
- roughly 3y agoInsta definitely uses IP blocks to force login walls, but I don’t think it’s anti-scraping, because the limit seems to be like 3 images before you get redirected to log in - it’s way too low and too much of a pain in the ass to normal users to be intentionally anti-scraping and unintentionally anti-logged-out-users.
- fwlr 3y agoThe fact that it pushes anonymous viewers to log in or sign up is definitely a positive (for their conversion rate metric, if nothing else), and that might be the main reason the number of images is so low. But the specific mechanism of IP blocking that is used to achieve restriction - that is anti-scraping, pure and simple.
- mhuffman 3y ago... except, that "pro" scrapers use parallelized calls from rolling ip addresses. It is one of the only ways to scrape things like Youtube... so I hear!
- fwlr 3y agoNobody is going to be able to stop motivated, well-resourced, professional scrapers. IP blocks are effective for stopping most trivial scraping.
- bee_rider 3y agoI don’t really mind blocking ads and that sort of stuff. The social contract for websites is that they’ll send me what they want and I’ll render it however I want. But if they don’t want to send me content because I don’t have an account, that’s fair game IMO. I mean, it is fine to complain, but I get where the company is coming from. They don’t make any money off those of us who block all their stuff. So, why do they want to do business with us?
- SoftTalker 3y agoBecause 90% of their userbase doesn't think about this stuff and doesn't block anything. Why waste effort trying to rope the last few people into your schemes, when they will just find some other way around it or get pissed, write blog posts that get posted to HN, and abandon your platform otherwise.
- bee_rider 3y agoI suspect they don’t want to serve anyone without an account, and just added the preview feature to get new users. So, I suspect the zero-effort response would go in the other direction; just block everyone without an account completely.
- Arnavion 3y ago>I tried to simply remove the modal in the browser Inspector. It sort of worked, but I wasn’t able to scroll any further on the page. Usually when sites show a modal they also set CSS on the html / body element to disable overflow scrolling, so you'd have to find and remove that too.
- smolder 3y agoAnd many are smart enough to not load the full page content hidden behind css these days, too.
- macNchz 3y agoReddit’s mobile web experience really embraces this–even as a logged in user there is a frequent “Use our app!” popup that has been made progressively more obnoxious. Once upon a time there was a preference option to disable the popup, though it would periodically become unchecked on its own. Then the option to disable it disappeared. Then the popup started appearing not just on page load, but after a period of time while you’re partway down the page reading, instantly jumping your scroll position to the top and making you lose your place. The ultimate effect has been that I swore to never, ever install their stupid app, and I spend way less time there on my phone, which is probably a good thing anyway.
- gavinray 3y agoRecently on mobile it's stopped giving me the option to even view the page anonymously, at least for adult content. It gives me: "This is mature content and may not be appropriate for certain viewers. To continue, use the app to confirm you're over 18 and browse anonymously."
- khazhoux 3y agoold.reddit.com
- aqfamnzc 3y agoIts days are numbered, I think...
- wholinator2 3y agoIf they are then so are my days on reddit. The whole API debacle is already pretty rough for them. I can't imagine removing old.reddit could possibly be a good decision for them now. I have an account but only i choose when to use that account. If reddit removes choice, I'll remove reddit. It's really striking though that all of this hate for these terrible dark patterns invariably ends in a statement like, 'leaving would honestly improve my life'. These companies have become so ingrained and good at attention economy that most people feel like it makes their lives worse, and yet also cannot stop. I have a feeling this whole social media ship could go the way of the opium wars is we don't change course soon
- ranting-moth 3y agoSearch engines have always penalized sites that serve different content to users vs. the search engine. This fuck you pattern feels like a variation of that trick so in my opinion it should be heavily penalized.
- janandonly 3y agoI feel the same burning hate like a thousand suns for FB/Meta, Google/YT and other platforms that monetize their users. But, let's be frank here: They monetize you and me, us, the users because 1 they can and, 2, they have to. Yes, they have to. Imagine they provided access to their platforms for free. How would the shareholders (your retirement funds included) respond when less profit was made? You see, we view them as public utilities, as a shared park or public garden or nice riverside picnic area, but they are not anything like that at all. They are companies that have a responsibility to the paying user, that is to the advertisers who want to track you as a viewer, to know if/how much their ads work. The closest thing to a "public utility" on the internet to this day is email, good old SMTP/IMAP email. It's open, everybody who's not yet on Hotmail's or Gmail's spam-list can use it, and you can even develop an app for it yourself if you so wish. The closest thing to a social open protocol is: the fedi-verse on Mastodon or the relay-based Nostr system. You don't want to be the product of a mega corp? Try these open platforms instead...
- anonymousiam 3y agoThey can monetize by presenting ads, and they can identify you with cookies when you don't log in (or later when you do). They don't need to restrict their content to monetize. It's more likely that they are restricting their content to prevent scraping and/or indexing.
- henriquez 3y agoIt's definitely to prevent scraping. Used to be you could scrape and hydrate any profile or hashtag. It was sort of a cat and mouse thing a couple years ago and now the Instagram website is locked down tight.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoYep, and Reddit in particular is the culmination of over a billion dollars' worth of VC funding. The changes we're seeing are unsurprising when you take that into account—even though Reddit has never been profitable, those investors are still expecting their return, which forces Reddit to either start bringing in serious revenue or have a promising IPO (or both). None of this has ever been for users; we're merely a driver of growth/profit to them. Investor-backed platforms offer the illusion of "free public utility," but they were never meant to serve us in the first place. Their goal has always been to cash out.
- AH4oFVbPT4f8 3y agoI’m really hating the signin with google on nearly every website. I don’t want you to know who I am, I might never even return to the site. Stop asking me to login so you can data mine me.
- drivebycomment 3y agoTurn it off at https://myaccount.google.com/connections/settings https://myaccount.google.com/connections/settings
- AH4oFVbPT4f8 3y agoWow how did you find this? Thank you so much!
- wpietri 3y agoYou have made my life so much better. Thank you.
- boring_twenties 3y agoExcept now you have to be logged in to a google account in order for that setting to work...
- drivebycomment 3y agoThe automatic "sign in with Google" prompt only shows up if you're already signed-in. So if you're not signed-in, it doesn't (and can't) display - because there's no logged-in session, there's no existing user. In case you're misunderstanding what we're discussing here - the feature in question is https://developers.google.com/identity/gsi/web/guides/offerings https://developers.google.com/identity/gsi/web/guides/offeri... . If you use extensions like Privacy Badger or other ads/tracking blocking extensions, it blocks that by default so you may not have seen this on the web, though if you use certain apps on mobile, you may still have seen it.
- boring_twenties 3y ago
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoHow I spell "fuck you" when it comes to instagram: grep '0\.0\.0\.0.*instagram' /etc/hosts | wc -l 387
- squirtlebonflow 3y ago[dead]
- asylteltine 3y ago[dead]
- squirtlebonflow 3y ago[dead]
- motohagiography 3y agoI only ever look at IG posts that show up in chats as parts of conversations and IG appears to have banned my phone from viewing their content at all. Fine with me, as there is zero chance I will ever create a login on their site anyway, but I tell the people in the chats that IG links don't work for non-users, and so they share less of the content. I call this the, "Fuck me? Fuck you!" pattern. Nothing quite says "hemorrhaging MAU," like dark patterns to get people to login, and "urgent account information" emails to get those same logins. Someone should take a hard look at those numbers, as I'd suspect they're a bit soft.
- the_arun 3y agoThis is the same pattern Twitter uses today. If you are on a tweet anonymously it shows login page after x seconds. Basically, they are interested to know “who” is doing “what”.
- Given_47 3y ago[dead]
- lbrito 3y agoThere is a very simple solution here. Say fuck you back. Don't use Instagram and other loginwalled software.
- einpoklum 3y agoTake that as a hint, and stop going on Instagram. And Facebook if you can manage it.
- latexr 3y ago> Instagram would force me to login 5 seconds after navigating to Ollie’s Instagram page. That’s five more seconds than I ever got. I don’t have an Instagram account and can never look at any content. If someone sends me a link, it might render inside Messages but forget about trying to open it on the website.
- throwawaymobule 3y agoisn't requiring signup/login like this a gdpr violation? I assume they're relying on the account being 'compliant' or thinking nobody would see it that way.
- penguin_booze 3y agoIt's for this reason that I've burner accounts with burner emails. Recently, I got this treatment from Glassdoor, too. I've had a real account with GD, and had made some honest contributions in the past. I haven't made any contributions in a while, because I haven't had any. Now, what do I see when I go to look up something? An indismissable pop up that says "looks like you haven't contributed anything in a while. Make a contribution to continue browsing". I didn't really wanted to, but now I'm going to get a burner account for GD, too.
- nottorp 3y agoWon't work; I made an account like 2 days ago and i got the "contribute something" popup before i could browse anything.
- Luctct 3y agoI have a bigger beef with other Fuck You patterns. 1. The increasingly high number of sites that will show a blank page when I disable Javascript. 2. The increasingly high number of sites that will show a blank page when I disable cookies even if I have no intention to login and often the site doesn't even involve any kind of membership. 3. Sites that refuse me their content because my browser "is no longer supported" but wil gladly open up to me as soon as I tell my browser to lie about its brand or version. 4. Oh, almost forgot! Cloudflare.
- malfist 3y agoI especially love the websites that tell me I need to be using the latest version of Firefox when.... I'm using the latest version of Firefox. I'm just on Ubuntu
- I_am_uncreative 3y agoWhat's wrong with Cloudflare?
- fsflover 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11404770 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11404770
- user3939382 3y agoAmong other possible criticisms, they hold too much power. So much of the web is behind their walls, if let's say you couldn't access them or decided you didn't want to communicate with CF, huge portions of the web would become off limits.
- XCSme 3y agoWhat's the alternative? As a basic website owner, should we just ditch CDNs and anti-DDOS protection?
- user3939382 3y ago
- gunshai 3y agoI also despise this pattern, it's the same on yelp. I have friends who swear by yelp (I'm not sure why) but every time I get sent links by them their desktop website seems to be purposely absolute trash and nagging me every 10 seconds to download their app and sign in. I just refuse to deal with that kind of crap. I'm probably not the user they want on their platform and that's fine by me.
- sneak 3y agoDelete your IG account and block all facebook/meta domains in DNS and at your router to solve this problem permanently.
- fma 3y agoAFAIK Instagram was always like this? Whenever I get stopped I just hit the back button and thank for them saving me time. TikTok does it right - it annoys you with a pop up to login/open in app...you can dismiss it and watch the video. I believe if you want to do more than that it'll annoy you again - but I usually go back to what I was doing before (responding to someone who sent me that...)
- 29athrowaway 3y agoIf it was possible to bypass then someone would write a bookmarklet, browser extension, etc. that bypassed it.
- mikewarot 3y agoThe evolved response from internet "power users" such as us, is a superpower We're really good at holding a grudge AND telling others why we have that grudge Thus, we route around it, with some grumbling along the way.
- TheBigSalad 3y agoI could give two shits if Google wouldn't keep returning results for websites you can't see without an account.
- barefootjoey 3y agokinda like when the app authors make it impossible to disable app-delivered promotional notifications. So. Much. Spam
- alexfromapex 3y agoI thought this was going to be the "fuck you" software design pattern, where employees attempt to cement their job security by making the codebase extremely hard to learn or comprehend.
- moritzwarhier 3y agoInstagram was like that for me ever since I know it, couldn't bother creating an account though. If it's important, there are scraping sites to visit Instagram profiles by name without an account. Regarding the block/redirect: technically they could have used the MutationObserver API to track your usage of the DevTools to remove the modal. Have had the same experience a while ago if I'm not misremembering. But I'd also assume they're just counting requests without login per IP, much simpler.
- TacticalCoder 3y agoOh that one... I practice it since forever: I don't have FB / WhatsApp and I don't have Instagram. They're simply not part of my life.
- siliconc0w 3y agoReally what needs to happen is like a non profit SAAS movement to create minimal modern versions of these services that runs at minimal cost. Then they can basically be feature compete and like run off an endowment. More like roads or highways that just need maintenance. I guess more like signal. The alternative will always be enshitification.
- mr_sudaca 3y agoi found a page to browser public IG pages a while ago, https://imgsed.com/ https://imgsed.com/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- more_corn 3y agoThis is an important insight. What is the correct response when someone says “fuck you”? The answer is obvious. “No, you” The correct thing to do is to acknowledge the relationship they have expressed by their distain for you. That relationship is adversarial, other. It’s “you’re nothing to me” if you’re nothing to them they probably oughta be nothing to you. For me “fuck you” patterns are a signal you should have no relationship with that company. As are: nag forever patterns and hard nudges (a hard nudge is a shove, I don’t like being shoved — google maps uses a hard nudge to force login so they can bypass US data privacy rules. Thanks, but no thanks) Delete your account, add to your pihole block list and use wireguard to teleport your mobile home so you benefit from that while out and about. You’ll be surprised at how liberating it feels to be able to forever sever ties with products that express “fuck you” patterns.
- parentheses 3y agoI don't agree with this at all. I do concede that some of these patterns use manipulation and visual trickery to send you down a particular (typically more profitable) path. That said, we all enjoy these services for free. The companies that provide them are for profit. I feel the intense hatred people have for these companies is extremely biased. As a person who avoids Meta products for the most part, I still benefit from them greatly. I pay $0 and get a lot of conveniences. I do agree that it's not a nice feeling that they own the things I may post, but it's the deal that gets us what's app, facebook and instagram with near unlimited access to really nice social networking tools. I similarly pay for YouTube premium because I don't want adds. I enjoy hours of video content ad free - often watching it more than I'd watch netflix or whatever other streaming service. I agree that they're monetizing user content, but they're also providing access to compelling and often high quality content for free.
- spuz 3y agoThe "fuck you" isn't that they require you to login in order to view a page. It's that they tease you with the promise that you don't need an account, and when you try to take them up on that promise they slam the door in your face and say "nice try but you gotta create an account first".
- indus 3y agoWhy not call it the ‘Coward pattern’ Why? I’m a coward to not allow not logged in user. I’m a coward to not let Ollie have a day. I’m a coward to not allow good UX judgement prevail.
- TheAngush 3y agoI had an experience like this today when I tried to use GlassDoor for the first time. As a student making my first ever job applications, I wanted to see what salaries and work environments were like at particular employers. GlassDoor did the same scroll-locking tactic (so an element zapper like Ublock Origin's wouldn't resolve the issue), instructing me to register or sign in to view any information. So I registered an account. Only, it still covered the screen and locked the scroll position, now telling me that I needed to leave a review for my current employer if I wanted to use the website for information gathering. I find this particularly egregious, particularly for a company ostensibly founded around the notion of transparency and freedom of information (in regards to workplace compensation and culture). Evidently one is only entitled to make informed decisions after first experiencing the potential consequences of making uninformed decisions. Joyous. Suffice to say I will not be using GlassDoor in the future.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- actinium226 3y agoTry levels.fyi
- godelski 3y agoI was about to say that levels blocks too but as long as you hit the "I've shared my salary" twice they let you through. Which I find acceptable since they depend so much on that a little friction is okay.
- stickfigure 3y ago> I needed to leave a review for my current employer Perhaps you'd like to join as a disgruntled GlassDoor employee?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mkl95 3y ago> I wanted to browse some pictures of Ollie anonymously on Instagram today, but to my dismay, Instagram would force me to login 5 seconds after navigating to Ollie’s Instagram page. Unless I’m part of an A/B test, you can give this a try and should get the same behaviour on desktop. I don't know if it was ever A/B tested, but AFAIK this feature has been enabled for all users (all IPs?) for years.
- cevn 3y agoI had something similar today with Microsoft. Just to use their OS, MS tried to force me to log into an account. After signing out and back in, I was able to bypass the prompt.
- dave333 3y agoIs there a search engine that shows only results that are free open access - no registration or paywalled sites?
- jonplackett 3y agoTwitter has basically the same policy
- Waterluvian 3y agoReddit does this all the time to me. It simply stops responding to my requests unless I turn wifi off on my phone. Though to be fair, this might just be more Reddit incompetence.
- emmydee 3y agoThe irony => https://www.ycombinator.com/jobs https://www.ycombinator.com/jobs Scroll down, click "See more Jobs"... 'fuck you' pattern reveals itself :)
- ktosobcy 3y agoThis is beyond annoying. But this is directly a result of the dumbest and the most popular metric - number of users on the platform (which is directly fuelel but dumb VC environment)... it doesn't matter if you are profitable or not, but if you have lots of users then it means you are amazing (and it will give you more VC funding)...
- mucle6 3y agoThis pattern would be better if it "just worked". Many times if you make an account it drops you off somewhere else. I made the account to look at a specific piece of content. Show me that content!!!
- JeremyNT 3y agoI hate this so much. I don't want a Facebook account but there are several accounts on Instagram that post things I'd like to view. There's some kind of shady black market for Instagram scrapers that bypass the hard wall the OP describes and publish the content with their own ads injected. I can't vouch for anything about these sites other than the fact that they do work. I highly recommend using noscript or ublock at the very least before checking them out. https://imgsed.com/ https://imgsed.com/ https://dumpoir.com/ https://dumpoir.com/ https://wizstat.com/ https://wizstat.com/ There are likely others, these are just the ones I'm personally aware of.
- shmerl 3y agoInstagram requiring to register is such trash.
- p0w3n3d 3y agoThe same from my side. Login-walled portals are second to pay-walled. And when you login, you pay, but with you and your data. So we can put them in one bucket
- luuurker 3y agoFacebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn redirect me to the login page without ever showing me the content. I guess they don't like my ISP. Since I'm not going to create an account, now I just avoid their links when searching for something. Last year (I think) Twitter started showing a login/registration popup as soon we started scrolling. Not as bad, but the popup wasn't dismissible (now it is), so for a while I also stopped clicking on Twitter links. Reddit also hides some subs on mobile and requires us to install the app... that same sub is available on old.reddit.com (or the now discontinued i.reddit.com). I started using extensions that redirect these services to better front ends. Twitter → Nitter, Reddit → Old Reddit or Teddit/Libreddit, etc. I do the same on my phone (Android and Firefox, I don't think you can do the same on iOS).
- flybrand 3y agoFB regularly ‘fails’ when I attempt to log out - I don’t use the app. Recently it’s been extreme using Safari. It’s so bad it can’t be accidental. Why would the ever optimize logging out?
- kitanata 3y agoI noticed a particularly dark pattern when I used Keeps, by Thirty Madison. They tell you, that you can cancel or pause at anytime but that is a lie. They over-prescribe their medication, and if you try to pause delivery, they automatically resume it after 3 months. You cannot pause, for longer than 3 months. If you want to cancel, you have to call them where they harass you into staying. This is not how you should do customer retention. This is fraud. You are making intentionally difficult pathways for your customers to leave you so that you can report falsely propped up retention number to your investors, Thirty Madison. If you IPOd today, I would short the shit out of you. This is why I reported Thirty Madison to the FTC in a consumer trade complaint and it is why I notified their investors of potential fraud over LinkedIn. Thirty Madison is committing fraud against their investors, in my opinion and you should absolutely stay away from them as a consumer.
- MrDresden 3y agoRemoved Facebook, Instagram and Whatsapp from my life some years ago, and then promptly blocked them all from my local LAN (also dns sinkhole them on my Android device). Couldn't be happier with my decision.
- thih9 3y agoThis was the status quo for most users for years, tech users just used to work around the front end security via dev tools / content blockers. So now they implemented it on the back end too. After all, why should they allow you to view the content on their servers?
- uwagar 3y agocloudflare is the biggest employer of the fuck you pattern. making people captcha shit.
- mateuszbuda 3y agoThat’s why people use mobile proxies which rotate IPs to scrape Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, etc: https://scrapingfish.com/blog/scraping-instagram https://scrapingfish.com/blog/scraping-instagram
- badtension 3y agoThis drives me crazy in substack. Gradual fadeout with the popup sliding down as I scroll... This is a small thing but utterly frustrating. You're evil substack, I'm not going to give way to your shady tactics and login. I'd rather not read anything as a protest.
- atomicbeanie 3y agoI don’t wish to be too much of a fly in the ointment. I understand the darkness of dark patterns. But if we wish to not be secretly tracked (which is dark), then isn’t the alternative to openly ask if I want to exchange knowledge of my identity in exchange for the content I seek, so they can target the ads that pay for the content aggregation service I am using? The preceding question mark is not rhetorical. Maybe I am missing something? In the end though, Cat picture or not, the people that provide the service need to get paid.
- cyanydeez 3y agoSure, but with reddit,their pattern is to push you to their app. If they were just trying to wrangle a user into a simple adnetwork proposition, _why can't they do that with a webapp_. It's because they want far more privacy invasive features.
- atomicbeanie 3y agoYes, I agree, logging in is different than forcing people to use installed software.
- bubblethink 3y agoMost of the internet has "No Trespassing" signs. At least that's how I view it. If a site throws up a banner/popup, we respect their wishes and leave.
- jacooper 3y agoLinkedIn is even worse, its practically impossible to browse without a login, they even call it an authwall in the link!
- dsgnr 3y agoIts been called “deceptive pattern” in my design teams for a number of years so as not to be racist.
- bad_username 3y agoI think it is absurd (and almost racist in itself) to connotate "dark" with race in this context.
- kacesensitive 3y agoCan we stop calling these "dark patterns" Same reason why blacklist and whitelist, black hat and white hat. Dark != Bad.
- Eisenstein 3y agoDark meaning absence of light, and light being something you can see, makes plenty of sense (transparent patterns, visible patterns vs dark patterns, obscure patterns).
- spacebacon 3y agoTry to delete your facebook account, then interrupt the process somehow. In my case the menus and deep links changed totally, and it took me 20 minutes to eventually navigate to the new delete account area. I was given a notice that some users may have different menu options as well as a message along the lines of “we are updating menus”. However, this has been a steady experience with facebook over the years. There is always a fuck you pattern waiting for you to behave differently than the herd.
- mochaki 3y ago[dead]
- dredmorbius 3y agoUnless I’m part of an A/B test... The term of art for "A/B testing" in the mental health industry is gaslighting.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 3y agoDiscussed at the time: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27666455 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27666455> (604 comments).
- pcblues 3y agoI walk a lot, drink wine, and listen to podcasts and audio books. You probably don't need much social media to keep yourself sane. But you have to test it for yourself, and for some months. Good luck with your experimentation. We evolved to be physically social or loners. We have not evolved to anything new in the last few thousand years, including reading and written languages :) Stick to the older stuff, like honesty.