13 ms·
Now Reddit are coming for the individual personal subreddits
- ck2 3y agoOf all the worlds problems, this is not a difficult problem. Make a free alternative that handles massive load/scale and run it how you want.
- dredmorbius 3y agoFor those interested in HN's approach to moderating the Reddit-topic "tsunami" (and yes, it really is and has been), dang and I discuss this in part in another thread here: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36435312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36435312> As usual, dang is reasoned, articulate, and fair. I have a better understanding of HN's policies and actions, even if I disagree in part on how this is being conducted. I'm told (via email) that it was largely the flameware detector which adjusted this particular post's page ranking.
- cykros 3y agoSad to see Reddit news is still relevant, as it indicates the site still has users. With alternatives growing and the motivation for so many to leave, I'm not sure I have much sympathy for those who just won't leave at this point. They're basically just volunteering to prop up an organization that by all rights should die.
- vinyl7 3y agoI've seen the same story play out time and time again. Alternatives never gain any meaningful traction to overtake what they are trying to replace. In the off chance they do gain traction, they will eventually become the very thing that they sought to replace because they need to monetize to pay for the infrastructure. Tech is basically a giant pump and dump industry. Create an app, pump it up with free access, then try to cash out to investors or monetize...which inevitably kills the product. The internet worked best pre-2010 where people ran small niche communities on their own because they enjoyed the hobby, not because they wanted to make money.
- appleflaxen 3y agoConsider r/redditseppuku
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoSo… are you not allowed to have private subreddits any more? Is this their official stance?
- cortesoft 3y agoIt wasn't private before, it was made private in protest. I think they are just automatically messaging mods of subreddits that were public before the protests and are now private. My overall take on this is people have a weird relationship with reddit.
- stonogo 3y agoIs there a social media platform people don't have a weird relationship with?
- CharlesW 3y ago> My overall take on this is people have a weird relationship with reddit. Alternative explanation: Users may not just roll over when the platforms they've invested countless hours into start abusing them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 3y agoNot sure how much choice the users have in whether reddit rolls them.
- rchaud 3y agothis isn't really costing users anything, unless "time spent on Reddit" is considered a good.
- alwaysbeconsing 3y agoThe choice they have is in whether they're around at all to be rolled.
- nashashmi 3y agoThis is lame. The poster made a good point. If it’s not your platform, then you don’t own it. so if I started a new sub Reddit that was part of a particular company initiative and connected people with it, I would not own that sub Reddit because it is not my platform. this is a problem.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> this is a problem. How so? Reddit pays for the infrastructure and software, why would anyone expect they own their own subreddit? Are people really expecting Reddit to operate at a loss? If you want to own it, pay for it.
- bee_rider 3y agoThe kind of unpleasant moderation jobs they expect people to do requires those people to feel some kind of ownership over the space they are creating. If they want the job done a particular way, they need to pay for it.
- bdcravens 3y agoTo be fair, isn't that a two-way street? The argument of course is that mods are paying by creating content that Reddit can profit from, but the flip side is that those mods are similarly extracting value. (Many subreddits have an income incentive for the mods and/or users, such as the crypto ones or the NSFW ones that point to sites like Only Fans, etc)
- bee_rider 3y agoI don’t know why people moderate reddits. I don’t think “paying by volunteering” is the right model. It seems more like a really weird F2P game or hobby. If people are using the site to advertise stuff, they have an incentive to try and make the experience nice. But is that really the main source of mods? I imagine if I was moderating as a sort of work related thing I’d be more focused on just fulfilling the requirements of my employer (rather than maintaining the general community spirit of the site, if that makes sense).
- MisterBastahrd 3y ago[flagged]
- Applejinx 3y agoIn fact they did not, because I have two subs for which I was the only mod and user. The one that had been long closed and private got no attention, only the other dead sub where I'd closed it quite recently in solidarity. There's no functional difference between the two, and no benefit to anyone to force the one to be reopened and not the other.
- dredmorbius 3y agoI can confirm. /r/MKaTS is a longstanding private sub of mine. No modmail (yet). There's also /r/MKaTH, affiliated with the former but public. I'd taken that private and added a solidarity note. So far, no modmail, though it has far fewer members than /r/dredmorbius. (OP, FYI.)
- bhouston 3y agohttps://lemmy.ml https://lemmy.ml OR https://lemmy.world https://lemmy.world and https://kbin.social https://kbin.social and are quite nice. Been posting there myself and it is great. Lemmy is having some stability issues across its instances because of this growth curve: https://lemm.ee/pictrs/image/693866c7-8f65-4046-8781-58aee709cdf1.webp https://lemm.ee/pictrs/image/693866c7-8f65-4046-8781-58aee70...
- mderazon 3y agoMoving entire communities there is going to be challenging
- bhouston 3y agoThe trick is to both (1) promote equivalent communitie to existing Reddits - let them know there are alternaives to being a serf -- and (2) start posting on there. Be the change you want to see! The federated future for social is coming, albeit slowly in fits and starts. What is nice is that many of the communities on these two are shared because it is the fediverse. EDIT: Downvoted why?
- mderazon 3y agoWhat about migrating historic data from Reddit ? Is that possible?
- bhouston 3y agoFrom a technical standpoint: Archive.org is archiving Reddit data. So someone just needs to write an importer for that data. I would have suggested reading from Reddit's APIs directly but they are shutting those down. From a legal standpoint: I am unsure.
- toyg 3y agoDo they archive nsfw too? Edit: I checked, and Archive.org seems to be snapshotting once per quarter or less. Not a realistic strategy for any sub with even modest traffic.
- dorianmariefr 3y agoCouldn't we have a Reddit alternative? (I also want a LinkedIn alternative)
- bhouston 3y agohttps://lemmy.world https://lemmy.world and https://kbin.social https://kbin.social are federated alternatives to reddit. Many of the same communities exist there and there is robust debate. I like the kbin UI better, but Lemmy seems to work better.
- FalconSensei 3y agoTrying to sign up for lemmy.world for a week without success. But happy on https://lemmy.one https://lemmy.one. It doesn't have downvotes, which for me is a big plus!
- spacemadness 3y agoIs the problem with LinkedIn entirely the site design patterns? I think a lot of it is the insufferable nature of modern corporate career ladder climbing and self-promotion as a means of self-preservation and advancement in that space.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- no_wizard 3y agoLinkedIn initially was very much a place where the ethos was something like this: LinkedIn is a place for professionals to interact with other like minded professionals about the trials, tribulations and successes of work Unfortunately, it morphed into what is basically a job hunting platform with social media behaviors as your gateway to getting a job, rather than just applying for a job. This change is what leads to all the self promotion, the "always positive always on" hype posts, the corporate media campaigns etc. Not to mention every friend request got loaded with "is this random person trying to get me to recommend them for a job?" type thing. The organic lets talk about work authentically with others in the profession type stuff is minimized and in some cases I think its gone completely. To be honest, if it wasn't for the fact that it really is the only place to reach recruiters and hiring managers directly, I wouldn't be on LinkedIn anymore at all. It has otherwise lost all career value to me
- napierzaza 3y ago[dead]
- seydor 3y ago[flagged]
- bhouston 3y ago> And they should reign in the moderators, their abuses have angered way too many users. Moderators are always going to be hated by some segment unfortunately.
- babypuncher 3y agoThere will always be people who just want to show up in a space and act like an asshole, then cry "censorship" when they are asked to leave. I kind of want moderators on Reddit to stop moderating just to show how quickly it would kill the platform. Popular subreddits would be overrun with bots and hate speech within a week. Then the real user exodus would begin, meanwhile Reddit has to try and convince their remaining advertisers that bots and racists are worth advertising to.
- Applejinx 3y agoWe already have Twitter doing that, though. Do we have to have ALL established social media hellholes going full toxic simultaneously? I'd rather we didn't. And yes, that was the first thing I thought of. I saw a user similarly griping about mods, saying "all the mods are rigging all the polls" and then added, "sure, pretend the users are behind you, the mods, the ones who ban them for very little reason or mute them/ignore them for asking valid questions in mod mail." A picture emerges… bit of a self-report! I'm curious what was 'very little reason' and then how many 'valid questions' were 'asked'. Some people seem to know who their natural enemies are, and they're really clear on wanting those impediments to be removed.
- afterburner 3y agoTwitter is used as a one-to-many platform though, and I as a user (one of the 'many') can derive value from subscribing to what are essentially blog posts or announcements. I can ignore the chatter if I want to. Reddit is all about the forum chat. Having trolls fill that up is more problematic to me as a user looking for value in the chatter.
- LanceH 3y agoI don't have a lot of fondness for companies which offer a free product until it becomes entrenched, then take it away. I think of how MS and Adobe both turned a blind eye toward piracy until everything else had been killed off, then they went hard on piracy. That said, perhaps moderators and users should be willing to admit that Reddit produces some of the value here. Every voice I've heard is, "we do all the work", "we produce all the value". It's also comical to hear moderators say that when the users of their subreddit could make the same claim trumping the moderator. Right now the mods seem to be flexing their muscle, showing that Reddit has allowed them too much power, rather than showing the actual need for an api. In all of these discussions, I haven't seen a single video detailing side by side how necessary the third party apps are. Just claims that everyone needs them and uses them. Reddit, of course, seems hell bent on making their UI worse and worse. I don't know what their play is or how they plan on getting paid for it. I have to say, though, for a free product their ads are among the least intrusive I can think of. Every subreddit is just a click away from moving, though. I see some doing it. But a lot of those subreddits enjoy the influx of users that reddit brings them (until they don't, of course).
- richardjam73 3y agoThat is not what Microsoft did at all.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe point of this post is that the contributors to this subreddit are one person. And has been for going on ten years. The moderator team is one person. And has been or going on ten years. Much of the readership is ... one person, who refers back to older posts to link elsewhere. (Though I'll admit that according to Reddit's stats, surprisingly more than that.) That the subreddit had already been largely on hiatus for the past three years, because of preexisting frustrations with Reddit's leadership and direction. The subject of much of the front page of the subreddit. Archive snapshot from this past February (there's been no change to content since then): <https://web.archive.org/web/20220224161047/https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220224161047/https://old.reddi...> That the moderator and contributor had long voiced concerns over precisely the issue of Reddit seizing control of subreddits, and a lack of any ongoing right over a subreddit, no matter how personal and how long it had been: Quoting from "No, this subreddit is not fully dead yet, but ...": <quote> Years before "profile pages" became a thing, several people started what were effectively personal subreddits. /r/TalesByToxlab[1] is a classic instance, and also an exemplar of the conflicts arising. This is not my sub, and I'm not nominating it, to be ABSOLUTELY clear. TBT was a personal space where one person shared their personal stories, some from real life, some fictional. And I say "was", because /u/toxlab[2] died three years ago. A fact which large sites need to deal with. (A ways back I'd computed that a site at the scale of Google+, with a nominal 3 billion profiles, saw on the order of 10k newly dead accounts every day. Reddit operates at about 1/10 that scale. Do the math.) Should TBT be recycled back into the pool? It was never a "community site". What any modmail or logs, which might reveal personal messages and communications? I get these myself from time to time via several subs. Reddit's stance has long been that subreddits are community, not personal, resources. For large and leading subs, this may well be appropriate. For small efforts, it almost certainly is not. That concern is a chief one I've had with Reddit since beginning a few experiments of my own. I wrote on various aspects of Reddit which raise flags[3] five years ago. And this weighs heavily (though other factors contribute) in my decision to move my principle posting activity elsewhere[4], specifically to a blog whose features, content, and presentation are far more under my control. I don't want my subs to become zombies or be allocated to others. When they're done, they should die, and be buried, their electrons recycled. And I suspect I'm not the only one. </quote> <https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/dt527o/no_this_subreddit_is_not_fully_dead_yet_but/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/dt527o/no_this...> Links: 1. <https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddit.com/r/TalesByToxlab https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddi...> 2. <https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddit.com/u/toxlab https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddi...> 3. <https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/20yhxc/reddit_and_community_what_works_what_raises_flags/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddi...> 4. <https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/9ebkjh/current_plans_on_migrating_this_blog_elsewhere/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddi...> This is no longer about arguably large and "community" subreddits which might arguably have some thin line of reasoning to legitimise Reddit's corporate claim to them, but small group and individual efforts, with private data and communications potentially being handed over to third parties. Issues I'd raised years ago, now proving to have been quite prescient concerns. One-person subreddits. And in this case, that one person happens to be me.
- EamonnMR 3y agoI made and later closed a tiny sub before this whole kerfuffle. I haven't received any flack from Reddit yet.
- dredmorbius 3y agoI mod several subreddits, a mix of public and private. Some have received the notice, some haven't, yet, as of last check.
- Applejinx 3y agoConfirmed: I'm Chris from Airwindows (small open source audio software dev) and am the sole mod for r/airwindows, which is a dead sub. People interact with me elsewhere, for a while I had a ITTT posting new plugin releases to the sub, then I stopped. I took the sub private largely because as the only user I wanted to endorse the striking Redditors taking much larger subreddits offline. There's no real impact to this. I got this in mod-mail: "Hi everyone, We are aware that you have chosen to close your community at this time. Mods have a right to take a break from moderating, or decide that you don’t want to be a mod anymore. But active communities are relied upon by thousands or even millions of users, and we have a duty to keep these spaces active. Subreddits belong to the community of users who come to them for support and conversation. Moderators are stewards of these spaces and in a position of trust. Redditors rely on these spaces for information, support, entertainment, and connection. Our goal here is to ensure that existing mod teams establish a path forward to make sure your subreddit is available for the community that has made its home here. If you are willing to reopen and maintain the community, please take steps to begin that process. Many communities have chosen to go restricted for a period of time before becoming fully open, to avoid a flood of traffic. If this community remains private, we will reach out soon with information on what next steps will take place." I responded with the following, and have heard nothing further: "Understood. Note that airwindows is my intellectual property and I control the website and the youtube channel which is my primary mode of engaging with Airwindows users. As such, and since there are no legitimate users trying to re-open the subreddit, it's an interesting test case. I await whatever further information you care to share with me :)" There was also another subreddit where I was the sole user, called r/homesoil (a Minecraft mod me and my brother made). I believe that had been taken private long before, and I haven't received mod mail over it. Looks like it's strictly punitive, directed toward anyone aligning with the striking redditors no matter how small they are. I was asked by another redditor, "Do you have a TM on the name? Could you sue Reddit to take it down b/c they should not have a forum named with your trademark?" I responded, "Oh no, I created the subreddit. Not only that, people are allowed to create fansites so the mere concept of a subreddit that's solely my business name without me associated with it, is not itself a problem. For instance, there's at least one Facebook group using the name that's not me, and nobody is confused. The test case (which may never happen, fair warning as this is kinda telegraphing their exposure if it did) would be the use of such a subreddit to try and convince people I represented stuff I don't represent. In other words, the activity I DON'T want to see is: kicking me off my own subreddit, installing some other person as a mod, who then uses that subreddit to imply I support Reddit's position and leadership. And in the absence of really impressive pro bono representation, my counter would not be trying to sue Reddit over that, but exposing the situation in a Youtube video, most likely as an aside in a video that's otherwise intended for a product release that would see a lot of attention. For instance, I'm doing reverb effects where the tone quality is tailored to work similarly to Bricasti hardware reverbs, which cost over $4000. There will be people paying close attention to my efforts there, so a mention of the Reddit situation would get outsider attention that wouldn't go to a video solely about Reddit." That's what I'm interested in watching for. Not so much if control of the subreddit with my company name is wrested from me (might be a Wikipedia-like situation, where that isn't necessarily an issue) but if they're looking to do that for the purpose of misrepresenting my positions and establishing an endorsement where one doesn't exist. Right now, my sub going private is a statement of how I feel about the situation. If that changes, it changes, but if it represents me it'll be private, and sitting on that subreddit name.
- sandoze 3y agoWe’ve come along way from running our own web rings and PHPBBs. The internet was our audience but then we put it in the hands of companies looking to profit off our niche communities and now we’re having a leopards ate our face moment. My unpopular opinion is Reddit is making the right move and likely their only move. Moderators got what they signed up for and once a community was created and they owed it to their communities to hand over the keys when they ‘quit’ in protest. In the end, anyone unhappy with how Reddit handled the API situation should have walked instead of sticking around to watch Rome burn.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>My unpopular opinion is Reddit is making the right move and likely their only move the inevitable move, maybe. The only move (for profits), yes. But they are executing this absolutely horribly. Reddit has never been an overly formal site, and I guess that is built into the culture of the admins as well. >they owed it to their communities to hand over the keys when they ‘quit’ in protest Historically speaking, they never did. We have seen mods run a sub to the ground several times and the result was users jumping ship to a new community. So while inevitable, it is inherently hypocritical for Reddit to suddenly care now as if they ever cared about users.
- notfed 3y agoCommunication is everything. Their "move" isn't even the main point of contention, it's the horrifically mismanaged communication from CEO to the public. No reassurance, no de-escalation, no reasonable transparency of the decision making process. Just dictator moves, lack of communication in general except for a few emotion-driven jabs.
- notfed 3y agoHere's a template the Reddit CEO can use to immediately put a stop to this chaos: "Hi Reddit, this is the CEO. I admit it, I didn't handle this well. Some of our recent decisions have not been met well by our users. There are great points being made, and I've decided to take this into consideration. Let's start over."
- 3y ago
- pierat 3y agoSo... why have the feature of "Public, Restricted, Private" if you punish people for using a feature you all put in place? If they don't want private subs, then convert them to public and turn that feature off. What all this seems like is a bad psy-op campaign to force people to do the settings the admins want, and make it "feel" its the moderators doing it. Similar how Twitter forces you to remove bad content rather than just auto-do it
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sangnoir 3y agoThis is leftpad all over again: the intersection of publicly accessible namespaces, control over those namespaces, and what people in charge of the namespace are allowed to do by the platform when their protest actions are seen as harmful by the platform. There's a 3-way social contract between the platform (Reddit/npm), the nominal person in charge (mods/module authors) and the users. If the person in charge does something that is sufficiently disruptive to users', or platforms interests, the platform will step in. We can argue about where the line is, but beyond that point, platform intervention is inevitable. Edit: Thought experiment: would it have been acceptable had the author of leftpad put up a poll for downloaders to vote before taking the module down in protest?
- some_random 3y agoThere's a huge difference between taking down an entertainment source and taking down software build pipelines across the world.
- murphyslab 3y ago> If they don't want private subs, then convert them to public and turn that feature off. I can understand the sentiment, however users of Reddit employ private subreddits for a variety of reasons. Top of the list is in order to facilitate safe discussions, secure from prying eyes. For Reddit Inc it is a benefit, since it encourages moderator groups and communities to remain within the platform. e.g. > r/ArmyofScience > A private community for the comment moderators of /r/science to organize and discussion moderation of the subreddit. If such private communities were forced open, it would require moderator groups, or those other private communities, to join the exodus to other platforms. There are also some more personal collections on the site, without a doubt. Switching those to public would constitute a huge violation the trust which users have placed in Reddit and only further erode the company's image within communities that make their home on the site as well as with the public at large. Lastly, there are over 3 million subreddits in existence [0], so even changing this manually would be a sizeable task. [0] https://www.businessdit.com/how-many-subreddits-are-there/ https://www.businessdit.com/how-many-subreddits-are-there/
- olalonde 3y agoI'm guessing this is an automated message that was sent to all the subs that went from public to private in recent days. And there's no easy way for it to tell whether a given subreddit is "personal".
- dannyisaphantom 3y agoSeems like it; I have a personal subreddit the same as my username that I flip between private and restricted to post music videos I grab with an iOS shortcut (can't post video on private subs) and the same landed in that accounts inbox (2) days ago. My other private subreddit for Wikipedia/github links has never flipped/flopped and it didn't get the same message.
- dredmorbius 3y agoAmong other points, I'd raised the issue of distinguishing personal subreddits years ago in a post to which a Reddit admin responded directly and pledged that they'd honour my request in that regard: <https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/dt527o/no_this_subreddit_is_not_fully_dead_yet_but/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230612102634/https://old.reddi...> (OP, FYI)
- agilob 3y agoI havent received that message and have a personal sub
- jmyeet 3y agoIs anyone surprised at this point? Look. This is always going to happen with user-generated content ("UGC") sites where the users who create the content don't own the platform. The owners will always reach a point of trying to extract as much value as possible from those users. Personal subreddits? Well they don't provide value (to the owners). We're long past the point of subsidizing users to grow Reddit. Now it's just value extraction. And it happens to every UGC site and people are still somehow surprised. It's the most Lucy and the football thing I've ever seen. This is why Wikipedia being owned by a foundation rather than a private venture-backed company is so important. Same for ICANN not being a for-profit company (remember how private equity tried to steal the .org registry [1]?). [1]: https://gizmodo.com/private-equity-firm-trying-to-take-over-org-registry-p-1841835506 https://gizmodo.com/private-equity-firm-trying-to-take-over-...
- tyingq 3y agoOCR of the notice screenshot: "We are aware that you have chosen to close your community at this time. Mods have a right to take a break from moderating, or decide that you don't want to be a mod anymore. But active communities are relied upon by thousands or even millions of users, and we have a duty to keep these spaces active. Subreddits belong to the community of users who come to them for support and conversation. Moderators are stewards of these spaces and in a position of trust. Redditors rely on these spaces for information, support, entertainment, and connection. Our goal here is to ensure that existing mod teams establish a path forward to make sure your subreddit is available for the community that has made its home here. If you are willing to reopen and maintain the community, please take steps to begin that process. Many communities have chosen to go restricted for a period of time before becoming fully open, to avoid a flood of traffic. If this community remains private, we will reach out soon with information on what next steps will take place."
- sandoze 3y agoI hate to say it. From a PR move this is a well crafted email. I can support and relate to the argument. If the moderators are so crucial to the subreddit that they’re in charge of, their loss (and possible movement to another platform) will reflect that as community members also move on. That’s the real protest. Instead closing subs felt a lot like burning down your own house.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoSure, the PR of people who never browsed reddit If you read a bit deeper with the context of how reddit has operated: >Subreddits belong to the community of users who come to them for support and conversation. No, subreddits always belonged to mods, and users complaining about power modding has fallen on deaf ears.They never cared about moderator antics outside of a few specific instances across 15 years. >Moderators are stewards of these spaces and in a position of trust. This makes it sound like moderators are voted in, or hired. No, it's literally a factor of who has been a moderator the longest. Without admin intervention or the user deleting their account, the head mod of r/pics would be some 16YO inactive account. If they came back they can boot off everyone. Sure Admins would fix it, but why does a mod have that power if they are merely "stewards"? their tools don't reflect their words. >Redditors rely on these spaces for information, support, entertainment, and connection. Yes, and taking away 3rd party apps definitely definitely helps that reliance. Making the mobile website an unusable ad to the app helps that reliance. I'm sure one day old reddit will be gone and RES will be non-functional and they will send a similar message. >Our goal here is to ensure that existing mod teams establish a path forward to make sure your subreddit is available for the community that has made its home here. And that comes to today's topic: is some small subreddit really worth threatening? I've heard other subs as small as 20 subs getting this message. There is no real "community", and I'm guessing such a move will simply make a small sub unmoderated, and then banned as part of the global rules. Why does Reddit care about such small guppies?
- SirMaster 3y agoI have been using Reddit for like 13 years and I didn't know personal subreddits were even a thing...
- itissid 3y agoNoob Question: Given AI is reducing the cost of creating technology. Isn't making reddit access API based the antithesis of the direction where the future of online communities is? The future I presume is: As computation gets less expensive, content creation and storage is democratized and managing that platform eventually becomes easier with AI tech this walled garden approach is bound to fall. Its just a matter of time yeah?
- chankstein38 3y agoI think this title is a bit sensationalized. They're going after subreddits who have gone dark for the protest. That's different than "coming for individual personal subreddits" at least from my read of it. In my mind that would mean there is something they're doing specifically because they're individual personal subreddits. Like "You can't have a subreddit with one poster" kind of deal and banning them because they're not active enough or something. In this case I understand it can be read as "Reddit aren't just going after big closed subs anymore" but the title, to me, doesn't make that obvious enough. I clicked it thinking "Oh no now people can't even have their own subs?!" when in reality it's just that one of the blackout holdouts is getting called on still holding out with the ~~new~~ not-new rule that they have stated they're going to start applying.
- davidgerard 3y agoNo, this is literally an individual personal subreddit.
- chankstein38 3y agoI think we're talking about a distinction in a different spot. My distinction was that rather than "They're shutting down personal subreddits" this post was more "Reddit is even coming for mods who blackout their personal subreddits" I do understand that they are talking about their own personal subreddits. I appreciate the clarification though!
- johnnyanmac 3y ago> That's different than "coming for individual personal subreddits" at least from my read of no, there's a concept in reddit called a "personal subreddit". You know how you can click a user and it will show you the most recent comments? e.g. /u/chankstein38 would be your comment history. Well, in 2017/8 or something, You can choose to convert this into your own subreddit. Complete with followers, votes, and user comments on "your sub". Never understood the idea given reddit's semi-anonymous nature, but I guess OnlyFans models benefited a lot from it. This sub is literally the user's sub.
- throwarayes 3y agoHow is this feature different from just posting to /u/myusername? Maybe this is just a cleanup of duplicate features?
- dredmorbius 3y agoThe /u/myusername feature didn't exist ten years ago when I created /r/dredmorbius. Having a specific subreddit affords the ability to: - Curate the content presented. It's not everything I've ever posted to Reddit, it's a specific set of interests. Visiting via the "old" view shows those topics, visible at the Internet Archive presently: <https://web.archive.org/web/*/https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius https://web.archive.org/web/*/https://old.reddit.com/r/dredm...> - Style the subreddit, as noted. - Provides other subreddit-specific features including the Wiki (which I'd made heavy use of), moderation tools, and the like. TL;DR: It's different in many ways.
- OldManRyan 3y agoLinus from Linus Tech Tips was recently talking about how people have telling him he should kill the forum which is just a cost sink and just fully embrace the subreddit for years and he has adamantly refused for exactly this reason. Your entire community survives at the whim of increasingly toddler-ish CEOs.
- npteljes 3y agoI mean, businesses depend on each other all the time. So depending and not depending both make sense. Different risks though.
- tivert 3y agoMaybe the solution isn't a blackout, but a spam-out. Instead trying to go private indefinitely, the subreddits should just implement automatic moderation policies designed to suppress valuable content and pass through low-value content (that doesn't violate content policies). For instance: automatically kill any post that gets too many upvotes, allow certain tired and overdone memes but block any new memes. That would kill the value of the community to Reddit Inc. but be much harder for the admins to automatically detect and counter.
- dredmorbius 3y agoOne of the ... more interesting ... suggestions I'd seen on the Fediverse responding to my thread there was to start creating ... and immediately setting private ... large numbers of subreddits. A DoS / DDoS attack on finding human mods for those subs, after a fashion.
- cwkoss 3y agoIts pretty funny that Huffman did all this to try to juice IPO price by ~10% and probably will end up dropping IPO price by 40% vs if he had done nothing. I wonder what shareholders think of his 'leadership'.
- 93po 3y agoI wouldn't assume this would drop IPO price. If it winds up making reddit more profitable, that is.
- cwkoss 3y agoI would estimate 10+% of reddit has deleted their accounts, but most importantly, that 10% skews significantly toward 'power user'. Quality of content is already dropping apparently. Not all investors will recognize that nuance, but 'reddit in chaos' was national news.
- TechBro8615 3y ago> I would estimate 10+% of reddit has deleted their accounts You'd be wrong.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI'd be surprised if it was 1%, even if we filter to daily active users. Granted, 1% would still be a lot on this scale. So I'm not saying that as an insult.
- cwkoss 3y agoOK, 10% of actually-active accounts. Reddit certainly has a huge number of zombie accounts - I think I have 3.
- afterburner 3y ago"I must do something. This is something. I will do it."