30 ms·
Sub.Rehab – See where Reddit communities have relocated
- tjpnz 3y agoBack button is broken on Firefox for Android.
- fcanela 3y agoI was planning to implement the same thing. Happy to see there is a way to quickly check where to go instead of Reddit or when a community is private.
- edvards 3y agoWonder whether any of the new platforms will gain traction, or whether what happened to Twitter repeats and the users will just return from the alternatives.
- littlestymaar 3y agoI don't think anyone has returned to Twitter from Mastodon, of course most people didn't migrate in the first place, but Mastodon is much more active than it was a year ago.
- stinkytaco 3y agoThey have, especially big names that count on high follower numbers and analytics. I run across lots of accounts that have 2 or 3 posts, then stopped.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>especially big names that count on high follower numbers and analytics. Like the parent comment said, those names never left to begin with > I run across lots of accounts that have 2 or 3 posts, then stopped. yeah, you can do that with any random social media account. The average Redditor barely comments.
- RoyGBivCap 3y agoLike three people went to mastadon.
- c-fe 3y agoIts beyond me why one would move away from Reddit due to changes in the API pricing making it hard (but not impossible) for 3rd party apps ... to discord, which is completely closed off and allows no 3rd party apps? Even worse, content on discord wont be visible on search engines.
- koolba 3y agoEven the HTML sites I tried manage to suck even more than Reddit. I didn’t think it was possible, but they’re even worse than “new” Reddit.
- littlestymaar 3y ago[flagged]
- dewey 3y agoAt least Reddit is a walled garden compared to a walled silo that is Discord and can't be searched or discovered.
- littlestymaar 3y agoExcept Reddit's management has made it pretty clear that Reddit is in fact a walled-time-bomb, everything you love about Reddit can be blown with a 2 months notice (if any, I'm not aware of any notice before they removed i.reddit.com earlier this year).
- dewey 3y agoThey make money through ads, closing off traffic coming in through search engines doesn't really sound realistic.
- rglullis 3y agoExcept that there are plenty of other gardens out there that do not have any of the fundamental issues that exist on Reddit/Discord.
- dghughes 3y agoKinda have to laugh at the idea of r/Anarchism having to move and do they have a moderator? lol
- notrealyme123 3y agoYes they have mods and iirc they picked them by popular vote.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoI'm surprised. There are some pretty large and visible subs on this list. Does anybody know if there's anything like a Lemmy + kbin client that could connect to these multiple fora and build a feed that looks somewhat like what you'd see on Reddit? These individual instances remind me a lot of old forums, which is great, but what I like (liked?) about Reddit was having the ability to subscribe to multiple, high quality subreddits and have them all in a single feed.
- Wingy 3y agoYeah you can subscribe to any lemmy or kbin community from any lemmy or kbin instance!
- nicce 3y agoSomehow people should be made more aware of this. You need just one account and it does not matter where you create it as long as you can trust that the server stays up.
- jml78 3y agoThat isn’t 100%. Instances can be blocked from federating. For instance if you are on lemmy.world you are no longer getting beehive posts because beehive disabled federation with lemmy.world I think kbin has the best interface and I am hoping they get “multireddits” implemented soon so you can combine communities from multiple servers into a single view
- Zuiii 3y agoI've been wondering. What does defederation do exactly? Does it only block posting from the defederated instance or does it block both posting and browsing too? Blocking interactions would be understandable but also blocking read-only subscriptions seem like a mistake.
- FireInsight 3y ago
- bhouston 3y agokbin.social is pretty good, love the interface. It appears though that I can not upload images to it yet -- it says it is disabled for some reason? A little confused about. I was trying to contribute to https://kbin.social/m/astrophotography https://kbin.social/m/astrophotography
- chrischen 3y agoInstead of api business model reddit should have blocked google indexing like Facebook does and force everyone to use reddit search and then show ads in search results rather than forcing people to go to google and append “reddit” to the end of search results which i had been doing for something like 99% of my commercial searches. Google has been eating reddit’s lunch… not random third party apps like Apollo.
- Yujf 3y agoNo, if reddit does that they lose a giant amount of traffic. And reddit search sucks they should improve it first if they want that. But also for many things you do not necessarily search for reddit but just search a question and reddit turns up in search results. If that goes away, reddit will have less visits and become way less usefull for many things
- CommitSyn 3y agoThey could combine it with the newspaper model and show 3 open posts to unregistered members before asking them to register. That way Google still allows full indexing.
- chrischen 3y agoHonestly the traffic reddit gets from google is probably << traffic from organic reddit users. Even for myself as a non-Reddit user I intentionally search Reddit through Google. What you say holds true for smaller sites, but there's a reason Facebook blocks Google indexing (for the most part), and it's because Facebook wants people to be using Facebook, not Google. Even if Reddit loses some search traffic they shouldn't be giving up that control. It's not like people don't know what reddit is, or that the app isn't sticky (it's obviously very sticky).
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>the traffic reddit gets from google is probably << traffic from organic reddit users. I question "<<" at this point. Maybe "<", but the gap isn't as large as you expect. It's not going to be as impactful as r/all being removed, but removing google searchability would probaly do more harm to traffic than it does benefit to the site. >here's a reason Facebook blocks Google indexing (for the most part), and it's because Facebook wants people to be using Facebook, not Google. I think it's more because Facebook is an inherently more private site. It has public groups but Facebook wasn't made (by default) to have every post you make be searchable from Google. You search on Facebook for people, and you care about who they are. You search for content on reddit and don't care who redditors are.
- Mizoguchi 3y agoSo we have Reddit, a for profit company controlled by a media corporation, asking other smaller for profit companies making millions out of Reddit's API to pay for access, then somehow moderators go on strike? This makes no sense to me. Like what will prevent these subreddits to be back online with new moderators? Do the majority of Reddit's user base even care about what's going on?
- denvrede 3y agoAt this point, if you want to be part of the discussion, please do your own research on the topic and try to understand the situation. It's explained multiple times in every news that comes up regarding Reddit (also in this one).
- coding123 3y agowhat I saw was an app writer that said his monthly cost per user would be $3, and gave no explanation for why instead of shutting down he wouldn't just charge each user $3 per month (plus a fee)
- OnlyLys 3y agoThe developer of Apollo explains it in detail here: https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/13/23759180/reddit-protest-private-apollo-christian-selig-subreddit https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/13/23759180/reddit-protest-p...
- gremlinsinc 3y agothe mods and power users must fed up with Reddit probably contribute 80 percent of the content, even if they are a minority. Without content what exactly is Reddit? nobody will fill this void because of the nature of a lot of these subs. I mean you really gotta be obsessive a little to continuously moderate weird niche subs like birds aren't real. A lot of subs will probably switch to bare minimum policing, which is to say only site wide rules which basically turns every sub into a free for all like /r/worldpolitics. You think it's easy to replace 4 to 10 moderators across 8000 subreddits? I sure you, it most definitely is not.
- Kiro 3y agoThis should include the most obvious migration target: other subreddits.
- midasz 3y agoI'm just a big fan of ActivityPub. It seems like the next logical step. Perhaps there'll be bigger ActivityPub providers in the future but in theory, just like SMTP, I can talk from my thingy to your thingy. It's up to us to abstract the protocol away and make it easier for users.
- nerdponx 3y agoWhat I find interesting is that we are in the middle of A tremendous social experiment where two of the biggest closed platforms on the web recently took major steps to push away and alienate their users, leaving federated platforms as an enticing alternative. It's been very interesting to see who did and did not migrate, and what the growing pains have been as, for the first time that I know of, actual normies tried out some weird open source hacker shit en masse.
- rajamaka 3y agoAnd then immediately returned to Twitter for the most part
- kitsunesoba 3y agoHeavily dependent on the circles one’s part of in my experience. Everybody I followed when I moved to mastodon several months ago (mostly devs, apple users, and a few designers) are still there, actively post, and have no plans to return.
- Pathogen-David 3y agoI've had a similar experience, except in my case a bunch of the bigger posters found they no longer automatically got a ton of attention on Mastodon and without that dopamine feedback loop they just gave up microblogging entirely. Most artists I follow also just dropped Twitter entirely and are on Instagram exclusively now (much to my dismay, the Instagram UI is nails on chalkboard to me.)
- chris_wot 3y agolemmy.world seems… slow
- hellweaver666 3y agothey are open source projects without major financial backing. Mastodon had a similar challenge last year when people started leaving Twitter en masse.
- paulmd 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36383120 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36383120 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33855250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33855250 it seems most instances hit scaling limits at 1k-30k signups per instance. 1k is more like consumer hardware, a consumer CPU and 32GB of memory type stuff, while using epyc and 128GB or 256GB of memory with enterprise SSDs behind it gets you to 30k. Federation actually makes this worse because right now there is an all-to-all broadcast model. There is no concept of a "relay" node that is allowed to carry your posts to another, even if you are in an all-connected clique of N nodes you need to connect to N-1 nodes to exchange data, which means load increases with federation. Obviously there are several pretty clear optimizations that shake out of just my description here, and I assume many smart people are working on it. On the other hand... this is also where you bump into "everybody kinda wants different things". Do you want other pods to be able to "forge" messages from you? Do you want to sign every message you post (or have your pod sign it for you) to prevent forgery? Do you want to have any ability to ever yank a post back out of the void, or are you comfortable with the "once it's out there, it's out there"? A lot of people have tacitly different answers to these questions and have never really had to think about it because Reddit provided a one-size-fits-all answer for them, just like the problem of moderation between federated pods. Like, what if you have a great contributor on your pod but he's completely a shithead on politics on some other pod, and people start looking to defederate your pod unless you take care of them? Reddit simply solved this by establishing some global baselines and if you don't like it tough, don't post on reddit.
- hacker_9 3y agoI have to say, watching this car crash in real time has ironically made me browse reddit more, just to watch the drama unfold. It's the same with twitter, these community sites have become so big, that the actions they take themselves are newsworthy. The way this is unfolding, I can imagine this being a case study in a future revision of 'how to win friends and influence people', on completely what not to do. If that book is worth it's salt, then reddit's management complete unwillingness to work with its community, and constant lies, leading to virtual riots on its sites, should result in it's total collapse.
- irthomasthomas 3y agohttps://kbin.social/m/RedditMigration https://kbin.social/m/RedditMigration
- nailer 3y agoLemmy seems to be OK. I clicked on https://lemmy.ml/c/apple https://lemmy.ml/c/apple and was entertained and informed rather than the content being about the protest, or about how great some new platform is. Someone that can hack Swift and likes money: please make a Lemmy app. Currently there's nothing in the iOS App Store. I will pay 5 dollars. Probably other people will too.
- rglullis 3y agoBefore offering money for a shiny client, please find an instance that is outside of the top 5 and support them? :)
- nailer 3y agoI don't have any reason to not like instances outside of the top 5.
- rglullis 3y agoIf they continue getting people like you who can't think one step ahead, then they collapse under their own weight. Are you then going to look after another instance or are you going to be complaining about how "it doesn't work"? Even the lemmy.ml admins (who are also the Lemmy developers) are asking people to find other instances.
- nailer 3y agoPerhaps they should have thought themselves realised that it is not reasonable to expect end users to think one step ahead. Have you ever made software that was used by people? > be complaining about how "it doesn't work"? You just stated that it won’t work. I’m not sure why you would blame users for that, they’re not building it. From the sounds of it, maybe I was wrong and Lemmy isn’t OK.
- rglullis 3y agoIt's not like they stated a goal of creating something exactly like Reddit. They are building an application that is meant to be decentralized and with no single entity concentrating power - or in the case of social media, "eyeballs". Do you think they should just say "oh, we set out to build something to help people get rid of Big Tech and Surveillance Capitalism, but people are really impatient so we are just going to scrap that and do that instead?" The fact that it doesn't work if everyone tries to gather around a handful of servers is a feature and not a bug. If others can not be patient, supportive or understanding enough, then what else can we say besides "good luck and I hope that Big Tech does not destroy you like they are destroying everyone else"?
- damontal 3y agoThis list is not accurate. The gaming subreddit is still on Reddit. It hasn’t relocated.
- aprilnya 3y agoOnly the links with a checkmark are official and from the mods of the subreddit.
- hellweaver666 3y agothe subreddit still exists (even if Mods removed it, Admins would recreate) but the communities are at least partially moving to the Fediverse.
- twobitshifter 3y agoyeah, this feels like a list of people trying to move a sub but people aren’t moving just because they tried. I checked the ‘new home’ of AITA, and the last submission was 9 days ago.
- WA 3y agoCheck Reddark, which was posted here about a week ago. Most subs are public again: https://reddark.untone.uk/ https://reddark.untone.uk/ I don’t think any significant subs went anywhere at all.
- pimterry 3y agoThat shows 39% as still fully dark, but large numbers of the 'public' subs that have opened up are doing malicious compliance, e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/ https://www.reddit.com/r/aww/ https://www.reddit.com/r/aww/ and https://www.reddit.com/r/Art/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Art/ are some of the biggest subreddits on the site, and all now exclusively for John Oliver pictures only, while quite a few others like https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/ https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/ have gone full NSFW (meaning although they're public Reddit can't show ads).
- NekkoDroid 3y ago> (meaning although they're public Reddit can't show ads) Slight correction: they can't show targeted ads
- Havoc 3y agoSurprised to see bigger subs moving to BOTH kbin and lemmy. Could someone articulate the rationale behind that?
- HWR_14 3y agoEstablish a presence on both services. In a year deprecate the one that didn't win via network effects.
- Havoc 3y agoI see. Risky play splitting it during the shaky reddit migration though.
- HWR_14 3y agoWell, if you assume splitting it means splitting your community, it's risky. If you assume splitting it means maintaining both while waiting to see which wins the majority of the exodus, it's less risky but more expensive.
- jasonjayr 3y agoWith lemmy though, the fediverse is the network. One can subscribe/interact with the other. The real hedge is which 'home' instance is going to be more stable.
- jensgk 3y agoWouldn't it be better if there was a Wikipedia page, that would track where big communities (currently) resides? Eg. former "/r/thiscommunity" now resides on "XXX" and "YYY" former "slashdot.org" now resides on "news.ycombinator.com" and "lobste.rs" or something like that.
- haunter 3y agoI don't get this list /r/3DS is active and not moving. The Discord is there for years. The lemmy instance is not affiliated with the sub (and it has 0 activity compared to the sub) The kbin AITA has only 2 posts from a week ago. While the main sub is still alive and active with thousands of comments on each posts etc. Feels like this a site for showing alternatives to the subs not "where Reddit communities have relocated" which is very misleading
- David_SQOX 3y agoI agree. I'm not aware of a single sub that has wholesale moved to a lemmy instance. There's def a big increase in fediverse usage, but to say entire communities have migrated already is beyond hyperbole, it's just marketing speak.
- dvngnt_ 3y agostartrek, piracy are two that have migrated
- goatlover 3y agoThere are new posts and comments in both subreddits. How can you migrate a sub when other people on reddit can still use it?
- evilkorn 3y agoNo subreddit can fully move. Reddit is too popular for everyone to leave. A mod can start a new place but if they threaten the the sub itself like going private or not allowing posts the company can just open it with new mods.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>How can you migrate a sub when other people on reddit can still use it? there were still people on Digg for over a decade after the "digg migration". I think you're taking the term a bit too literally. besides, migrations in software work the same way. You don't cold turkey drop the old tools. You make bridges, start weaning people on new tools, and phase out the old. That's the concept behind deprecation models.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoI wish I could have the site scrape my user page for the list of subreddits I am/was subscribed to. (This would be easy with the API, of course, but...)
- goda90 3y agoI think I had this idea about YouTube originally, but it could theoretically be applied to Reddit as well. A way to smooth the transition to a new platform could be to have a system that copies the posts automatically from the old one, and gives the account owner on the old system the option to claim the copied content for their new user on the new site. Legal issues would probably make it a non-starter though.
- worrycue 3y agoSpeaking of YouTube, I wonder if Google will get into the game. The recent blackout has shown that Google search is kind of reliant on Reddit - a lot of top links go to Reddit. I mean Google Search will adapt if Reddit vanishes but why deal with Reddit as a middle man at all? Google can start its own "Reddit". They already have scalable forum software in the form of the YouTube comment system. Heck, they can even copy YouTube's operating philosophy: - poster of content moderates their own content's comment section; reduce concentration of power in the hands of a few mods - comments have a score, users don't; avoids the Black Mirror episode "Nosedive" scenario ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nosedive_(Black_Mirror) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nosedive_(Black_Mirror) ) - frontpage is controlled by algorithm; no "subreddits" - downvotes are hidden to everyone include the user being downvoted They will make money by displaying ads as usual - serving text has got to be way way cheaper than video.
- moneywoes 3y agoDidn’t google plus have communities
- timetraveller26 3y agoOnly to kill it a year later probably
- nerdbert 3y ago- and then they will discontinue it after four years even though hundreds of millions of people are using it happily
- plastic3169 3y ago
- seydor 3y agoI suppose there is also a list of people who moved to Canada. It is unfortunate that reddit search sucks so much that users can't find alternative subreddits
- self_awareness 3y agoI find it hilarious that people think it's a great idea to migrate from Reddit to Discord.
- nonethewiser 3y agoTwo things: First, about the site. The "back" functionality is kinda messed up here. I typed something in then hitting the back button removes the last character. Go to site, type "gaming", hit back, get same page with "gamin", hit back, get same page with "gami." etc. Second, about subs going permanently private. It's a major blow for small, local subs. My city's sub went permanently private. It's a pretty small sub. It's not really sticking it to reddit like a large sub is (which has a big bank of widely useful knowledge). And its too small to probably migrate (its not on this list for example). It pretty much only hurts the people in that community and doesn't hurt reddit.
- lom888 3y agoA few subs like r/themotte and r/drama moved offsite and self-hosted before this current kerfuffle, does anyone know of others of the same ilk?
- smcleod 3y agoThis site seems a bit dodgy, it’s telling people that Reddit’s 3D printing community has “relocated” to some random Lemmy site that seems dead other than one person just filling it with posts simply titled “balls”.
- Stephen304 3y agoMost of those things seem to be true. The 3dprinting mod did endorse those 2 alternatives, and they seem to be the mod of one of them, they also seem to be doing a terrible job moderating the instance they created, and the users of r/3dprinting seem to be spamming it because they disagree with how the mod handled things, and I'm guessing the mod didn't get buy-in from the users of the sub before trying to migrate. I don't think that necessarily makes sub.rehab dodgy, they are accurately communicating alternatives both mod-endorsed and not.
- tomstockmail 3y agoThat instance was from one of the mods, they posted about it here on HN a couple days ago too. They got roasted hard on r/3dprinting, but it's "official" as it can be. Personally moving to an instance that doesn't involve the mods (of any subreddit) is a benefit. https://old.reddit.com/r/3Dprinting/comments/14a7sh5/join_us_at_rhombikcom https://old.reddit.com/r/3Dprinting/comments/14a7sh5/join_us... The 3dprinting communities on other Lemmy instances are plenty active though.
- yewenjie 3y agoLemmy is actually surprisingly fast? I mean, it feels way faster than both Twitter and Reddit, despite being federated.
- e_i_pi_2 3y agoSo many on this list are using "Lemmy", but it seems like they explicitly don't want to recreate a reddit experience there https://lemmy.ml/post/70280 https://lemmy.ml/post/70280 > Lemmy.ml has always been a niche site, and it will most likely stay this way. We don’t have any intentions to turn it into a mainstream instance, or set a goal of getting as many users as possible > having more users would force us to spend more time moderating, and less time for development. Lemmy works quite differently from big tech sites like Reddit in this regard: while they get more money with each extra user through advertising, for us it is the opposite. So we would much rather have a smaller, non-toxic, and friendly userbase, than a large one They do seem to think someone should do it, but I think are wisely not doing it themselves > In particular, I would like to see someone (or a group of people) create a mainstream, or liberal instance. That should help to avoid further drama, and avoid attempts to turn lemmy.ml into something that it is not. But I don't see how this actually solves the core issues - you'd still need someone to run the main instance, they'd need revenue for it. This might take power away from Reddit right now, but does nothing to stop a new company from doing the same thing
- para_parolu 3y agoLink is 500 now. I wonder if it’s because hn?
- gs17 3y agoLemmy is the software, Lemmy.ml is only one instance running it.
- nerdbert 3y agoWhen I go to deep links on lemmy.ml I get an nginx error, and when I go to the default page (/) I get a broken-looking mess.
- marcosdumay 3y agoGo to https://lemmy.world https://lemmy.world The .ml instance doesn't want new users. World is becoming a "main instance", but nobody thinks this will last. Anyway, if you want to move, go there.
- singularity2001 3y agoLemmy doesn't even have a dedicated app. What a missed opportunity
- wellthisisgreat 3y agoThere is an app afaik, Mlem, being actively developed, it’s in Testflight stage now. The TF tester list is full.
- sigio 3y agoSo, feature request: make sub.rehab/r/something... redirect to the new location of the reddit ;)
- FireInsight 3y agoProblem is that there are multiple.
- awinter-py 3y agowhy is there a rehab tld
- mdaniel 3y agoMy understanding is that anyone who thinks they can sell domains for more than the $185k(?) it costs to create one is a winning strategy. I don't know if there are any ICANN renewal costs, such that a gTLD could actually go bankrupt
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoSo nothing of value was ever lost. Every mod who decided to attempt to move a sub has now been shown exactly how much their "power" is actually worth, and has been instructed to either comply or lose their moderation rights. The result is that they're complying, because this never had anything to do with a third party API. They just wanted to be seen participating in something.
- neardeaf 3y agoYeah this pisses me off because the ADHD Lemmy community lives on lemmy.world , but I’m signed up to beehaw, which recently announced they’re “de-federating” from lemmy.world and sh.itjust.works for reasons… and now I have to keep multiple accounts with hopefully my same online handle just to see all my communities I’m subscribed to in a single feed like Reddit does? Ugh… fucking headache. Or run my own lemmy instance? I don’t want to do that… I want a “front page to the internet.”
- FireInsight 3y ago> This is not and is not meant to be a Reddit replacement. The original community here has decided to carve out a space for itself because we grew increasingly upset with modern social media. from https://docs.beehaw.org/docs/core-principles/what-is-beehaw/ https://docs.beehaw.org/docs/core-principles/what-is-beehaw/
- johnnyanmac 3y ago> now I have to keep multiple accounts with hopefully my same online handle just to see all my communities I’m subscribed to in a single feed like Reddit does? better than losing literally everything because beehaw shut down. I already manage multiple accounts for multiple types of communities (including HN), at least the interfaces between these sites are somewhat similar and under a common protocol. >I want a “front page to the internet.” I'd rather not have all my eggs in one basket at this point. But this did oddly remind me of RSS feeds, which were meant to do all this. Minus the modern UI, of course. Do these federated communities support RSS?
- neardeaf 3y agoThat’s a really good point actually. I’d definitely take the time to setup RSS feeds for each thing if it gave me the sort of experience I’m after. I’ll miss the comments sections though since that’s where a ton of golden information from Reddit came from.
- nickzelei 3y agoAt least for Lemmy, every page you go to you’ll find a link to an RSS feed. Even down to your own profile’s comments! It gives you the ability to fine tune and subscribe to whatever filter you desire.
- vaughan 3y agoGood idea. As an extension, I would love a directory of all communities online. Something Yahoo-esque. I often have trouble finding the right place to ask a question or discuss a topic.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoThere should be a client that aggregates the entire thing and makes it look like a cohesive experience.
- wffurr 3y agoNow we just need a search engine replacement for Google with site:reddit.com ...
- thih9 3y agoI like that there is an option to filter by official communities. Feature request: sorting by number of subscribers.
- btw0 3y agoA more compact directory: https://redditmigration.com https://redditmigration.com
- smithjames401 3y ago[dead]
- mofosyne 3y agoIs there a way to have a simpler protocol for community discovery perhaps? E.g. RSS feed of other RSS feeds so people can search for other communities... so the more you Favorited a new feed the more you discover other feeds?