18 ms·
Private equity is buying everything from vet offices to tech conglomerates
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- awaythrow483 3y agoIf you want to understand what went wrong with America, start with private equity
- hospitalJail 3y agoLobbying/Bribery seems more egregious than investing. At least investing has some economic forces that cause people to conserve resources and allocate them better than prior. Lobbying/Bribery is just pure corruption. The medical industry is so extravagant because they are among the top lobbyists of all time. Only the entirety of real estate or all US businesses(chamber of commerce) can even compete with merely the American Medical Association or AHA. Heck, combining all of medical and the lobbying is worse than every other industry including all US businesses https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-spenders?cycle=a https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-spenders?cy...
- jtode 3y agoPrivate Equity is the most destructive and bad-faith-operating version of investing, in much the same way that Kim Jong Un is the most destructive and bad-faith-operating version of a politician. The capital that one would define as the "investment" is in fact just a viral delivery mechanism, so the parasite can infest the host, devour its innards, and leave its husk to dry up.
- ambicapter 3y ago> At least investing has some economic forces that cause people to conserve resources and allocate them better than prior. Not when the money is basically free, e.g. the last decade of money policy. PE has always been around, so why is it hated now? Probably the forces that would normally keep it in check, namely, a cost to capital and a competitive business environment (as opposed to monopolies and natural monopolies all over the place) haven't been present in the last decade.
- khuey 3y agoPE has been hated since at least the 1980s, when capital was very far from free.
- Veliladon 3y agoYep. When Carl Icahn was doing it they just called it "asset stripping" and "corporate raiding" instead of using the term private equity. Fucker made squillions off the backs of misery for hundreds of thousands of people.
- ARandomerDude 3y agoDon’t forget teachers unions and the Dept of Ed. They bleed taxpayers dry because they are “helping the children” and everybody knows a nice teacher who isn’t part of the problem but will be held out as a defense of govt and union corruption.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y ago> At least investing has some economic forces that cause people to conserve resources and allocate them better than prior. That's a really whitewashed way of saying "layoffs, benefit reductions, and no more pay raises or bonuses". Far too often, "economic inefficiency" translates to "workers are too highly paid", you see this all time now with companies complaining about a labor shortage while there are tons of people ready to work for respectable wages.
- awaythrow483 3y agoWhere does the money for all of that lobbying come from? Bribery has and will occur in every society. Lobbying is so bad in the US because certain groups have basically unlimited money
- garbagecoder 3y agoI mostly agree with this. I would say a lot of what is wrong with America is that corporation laws allow this kind of thing. There are other ways. Nobody thinks Germany is an economic backwater and they require, I believe in large companies, for employees to have a role in the management of the company [1]. There are also co-ops like the Mondragon Coop in Spain[2]. Some states have co-op laws but are mostly used by farmers and a few other niche things. Interesting, most professional firms must be managed by their professionals, so law firms are partially "worker owned" too. But I think the German model is probably the best. Equity interests and employee interests can both be short-term, but usually the best way to balance them is with long-term thinking. I'm not sure that would save the world, but I think it would improve the lives of working people. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation
- earnesti 3y agoWhat I know about PE firms in Europe, they mostly operate the same way as in the US. There are plenty of PE firms and in general to me it feels like they are more popular here than US actually, as with LP's they are perceived as lower risk. What I don't understand from the article, is how the PE firm is able to shift the debt from the buyer to the firm. That shouldn't be possible in any jurisdiction I know a little bit of, and I highly doubt that it is easy to do in US.
- coastermug 3y agoLeveraged buyouts. I’ve seen them explained like a mortgage, except that doesn’t work in my head either.
- lazerpants 3y agoI am not a PE expert but I will try to explain using the mortgage analogy. This is drastically simplified. The shoehorned part of the analogy is that a bank won't exactly lend as described below. You take out a mortgage for a property you intend to cashflow by posting it on AirBnB. You open an LLC to do so. You put down a fraction of the price of the home, let's say 5-10% and then you do some upgrades, but you borrow against the price of the home for the upgrades, not against your own credit. Now, you start AirBnBing this very nice house out for absolute top dollar. It's nice and people love it, you have great reviews. Every time you get a payment from AirBnB, you take most of the money and move it to your personal bank account as a "management fee" or a "bonus" and you put the smallest amount possible into the mortgage and the second mortgage (the one you used to upgrade the house). Now, as the house gets more use, or you cut costs, say on having the pool cleaned, or on yard maintenance, the house goes down in quality pretty significantly, but your original AirBnB ratings are there and people are willing to pay significant sums so you continue to rake in cash, and you try to avoid maintenance as much as possible. Eventually, the place is a run down heap, and people are leaving terrible reviews, so you stop having bookings/cashflow. Okay, now you just send the keys to the bank and say "it's your problem". They get a rundown house that has barely repaid its mortgage, and you get to keep the cash. The trick is to have moved a lot more cash into your account than you lose in the mortgage down payment. Edit: I should add that PE firms aren't always trying to extract value at the cost of the business (sometimes they absolutely are). However, they are always incentivized to make cash flow and take maximum business risk for potentially even larger payout.
- thrawa8387336 3y agoNah, many countries have it. If people have a damn it would be a different story but in the US, cheaper is always better. See architecture, food, housing, hotels...
- SNosTrAnDbLe 3y agoI have firsthand experience of how PE ruins startups. We were a small startup and unfortunately our founder decided to go with a PE firm rather than a VC firm for a round of funding. The latter were upfront about job cuts but the PE firm did not say anything until them took over. The founder got a good paycheck but we were left holding the bag. There was a bloodbath and they ruined the culture, the product and the morale. I never realized the meaning of a "cutthroat" culture until that time. It was personally the most stressful period of my employment. From then on, the moment that I see PE mentioned anywhere, I know its time to run.
- andix 3y agoWas it at least a good deal for the founder? I feel your pain about what happened. I've seen comparable things a few times first hand. My learning was: just leave once the change starts, only stay if you're getting something out of it. It's not my company, I'm only in charge of my life, I'll find something better soon. I think I would not recommend to run once PE is mentioned, it can also change for the better, but it can be a red flag to look more closely.
- fnimick 3y ago> Was it at least a good deal for the founder? This doesn't make it any better for the, you know, entire rest of the company. It's important to remember that this startup industry relies on selling dreams to idealistic young grads who will usually end up under the bus while the higher-ups walk away with the profit, if there is any. And a lot of us here are complicit, because we rely on cheap labor and false promises to get the next company off the ground. Once you see your first exit where the CEO walks away with $10+ million and every single other employee's stock (even the first few engineers) was made worthless in backroom dealings, you get jaded about the way this entire business operates.
- twiddling 3y agoIt's strictly business. You keep your CV up to date and move on.
- S_A_P 3y agoI don't know the answer here, so Im asking hoping that someone may. Couldn't private equity be seen as the "ants" of the economic landscape? Scraping the skeleton companies of the world for the last bits of meat on the bone and then move on to the next?
- bell-cot 3y agoPE is more like a flock of buzzards, cleaning up the bodies at train wrecks. A very clever, malicious flock of buzzards - who've learned how to hack the switches & signals, to ensure an ample & growing supply of train wrecks.
- GartzenDeHaes 3y agoMore like zombies overrunning the last defenses of civilization and consuming the few remaining survivors.
- ekanes 3y agoYes. That's perfect. Except that the animal they're eating wasn't necessarily dying, it might have just been growing slowly.
- oneplane 3y agoI'd say more like some slimy poison frog, toxic, nasty and only care about themselves while smearing themselves all over the place. Looks great from a distance tho. Or, they are a self-aware trolley that eats run-over people after choosing to switch tracks to where a bunch of people are tied down. I think more similar descriptions can be found, but as for what they really are: definitely not the economy immune system cleaning up the remains of dead companies. They are just predatory wealth hoarders. But it's all legal and I'm sure the people making lots of money don't emphatise with the rest of the humans, otherwise they might not be doing it.
- zactato 3y agoFrogs are notorious for their selfishness.
- addflip 3y agoIt's a shame what's happened to my local HVAC contractor. It used to be a great local operation where a real person picked up when you called. But lately, after a private equity group took over, it's all automated calls and foreign call centers. The personal touch is gone and, sadly, their service quality has taken a noticeable hit. It's just not the same anymore.
- bombcar 3y agoI knew some local guys that basically made a living doing that - start an HVAC company, get it working good, sell it to a equity group, they destroy it pretty quickly, everyone quits, then one of the other original guys starts a new HVAC company, gets it working good, sells it ...
- bhewes 3y agoOil and Gas field services does the same thing and only difference is they buy the company back and then flip it again.
- SN76477 3y agoA few years back I had to run door dash orders to pay the bills. I noticed then that distribution of labor removes a lot of the spirit and purpose behind the work. No one at the call center is enjoying the satisfaction of a job well done, it is complete detached. I'm sure the laborers are pushed hard to high quotas and have zero time to follow up with customers. I think we need to back to owning the entire system if we are going to have better services, better profits and satisfied employees.
- hotpotamus 3y agoEasy there comrade, you need to watch that talk about alienation of labor and ownership of the means of production. But it is interesting how a brief trip through the gig economy will start someone talking like Marx even if they (presumably) haven't read him.
- bena 3y ago> When KKR buys Toys“R”Us or when Carlyle buys the nursing home chain ManorCare, the debt is held by the company that they bought That right there is what should be made illegal. Somehow. There's probably all sorts of technicalities wherein KKR didn't buy it directly, but as the majority of the board of TRU, authorized the self-purchase or something like that. But you shouldn't be able to force a company to essentially buy itself, pay you a lot of fees to do so, then fuck off while it drowns in the debt you forced on it. If you have authority over something, you are also responsible for it. Both the good and the bad.
- bell-cot 3y agoOld, old school solution: Nobody is stupid enough to buy the mountain of debt (junk bonds, whatever) - debt which will only be paid off if everything goes exactly perfect for many years to come. Perhaps the SEC and DoJ should be considering fraud charges against the ratings agencies, investment banks, brokers, etc. who (in effect) represented that debt as worth ~100 cents on the dollar?
- Veliladon 3y agoPE doesn't go through rating agencies. Their deals are by and large unrated and the debt for the most part is not traded on the secondary market because of that. That's why they can pull off so much shady shit.
- 8note 3y agoIt should incur some tax in that you took out debt with one entity, then another entity paid off your debt and it on its own. The PE has been paid the amount of the loan by the company they just bought as some kind of return
- bequanna 3y agoWell, they aren’t really forcing the company to do anything. The original owners agree to the sale which is financed by debt that is secured by the business. The other non-owner stakeholders (employees, customers) may not enjoy this new deal but that is the reality with any new owner of a business. Of course, it is crappy when this results in negative experiences for them but at the end of the day, employees are free to work elsewhere and customers are free to buy elsewhere. That last sentence is mostly meant as a warning to the new owners: screw up the business too badly and you won’t have clients or employees.
- ranting-moth 3y agoI don't know if it was PE change, but I remember the last time I went to Toys R Us. The whole shop was full of expensive garbage toys. I didn't buy anything and left feeling like someone had just tried to scam me.
- coastermug 3y agoI’ve pushed back on previous discussions on here about PE because of lack of detail about wrong doings, however this article is excellent. “dividend recapitalization” seems absolutely insane for anyone running a business.
- Footkerchief 3y agoYes: https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/greed-and-debt-the-true-story-of-mitt-romney-and-bain-capital-183291/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/greed-an... > Romney and Bain avoided the hostile approach, preferring to secure the cooperation of their takeover targets by buying off a company’s management with lucrative bonuses. Once management is on board, the rest is just math. So if the target company is worth $500 million, Bain might put down $20 million of its own cash, then borrow $350 million from an investment bank to take over a controlling stake. > But here’s the catch. When Bain borrows all of that money from the bank, it’s the target company that ends up on the hook for all of the debt. > This business model wasn’t really “helping,” of course – and it wasn’t new. Fans of mob movies will recognize what’s known as the “bust-out,” in which a gangster takes over a restaurant or sporting goods store and then monetizes his investment by running up giant debts on the company’s credit line. (Think Paulie buying all those cases of Cutty Sark in Goodfellas.) When the note comes due, the mobster simply torches the restaurant and collects the insurance money. Reduced to their most basic level, the leveraged buyouts engineered by Romney followed exactly the same business model. “It’s the bust-out,” one Wall Street trader says with a laugh. “That’s all it is.”
- coastermug 3y agoWhat I want to know, is how do the banks keep lending to PE outfits? They are surely the losers in this situation?
- phendrenad2 3y agoIt's not like the government will allow banks to fail. Now consider the inverted incentives that might cause.
- motohagiography 3y agoI've turned down interviews with several companies after finding out they were PE managed. If you need the job take it, but otherwise find something with hope. After looking them up on crunchbase or the public filings, a decline on sight policy on PE owned companies has saved me a lot of time and, I think, career suffering.
- maximinus_thrax 3y agoVery curious how you conduct the research. I'm legitimately interested as at some point I almost accepted an offer from a company and one of my friends stopped me telling me that they're PE managed. Is there an easy systematic way of finding out without having to read public filings? How do you decide? Based on the ownership shares? Board members?
- motohagiography 3y agoWhat's hard about reading filings that are literally public? The only barrier is english literacy, a solved problem. Crunchbase tells you any public funding rounds, and then if a PE group acquires more than something like 10% they have to make an SEC filing. (if I'm wrong about that threshold, the internet will correct me.) I should disclose that early in my career I would do job interviews recreationally on my lunch hours just to get good at them, so it's not reasonable to just use what I say as a reference, and I've done serious reading and practice on negotiation theory and a bunch of other business topics, so essentially, I look at companies like an investor when I decide to work for them. Part of that is getting a sense of what their cap table probably looks like, because that drives the incentives in the product and organization. If you need a job, take what's available, but if you are serious, look at how startups necessarily survive as a function of their runway and board structure. Brad Feld's "Venture Deals" is a good reference, as is YC's startup school library (all free online) and then maybe Jeffery Pfeffer, then DeMesquita and Smith. Then understand how your own skills get them through the incentive structures described in those books. PE creates a set of incentives in an organization that are orthogonal to startup growth, they're just different types of companies. Once you know the board structure and the cap table, the survival of every company flows from the incentives that creates, imo.
- scarface_74 3y agoI am not anti-capitalists by any means and I think much of the VC industry is a Ponzi scheme. But at least some good comes out of it occasionally. But private equity is pure evil. I worked for a number of VC backed companies and the only one that failed completely was just not able to pivot to a changing mobile landscape as much as we tried. We had a years long head start on mobile devices/field services with Windows CE and Microsoft imploding in mobile and the rise of iPhones and cheap Android devices was too much of a sea change. On the other hand, the slice and dice and look good for the public market that I saw first hand from a PE firm when I was the tech lead was too much. They wouldn’t hire any permanent people for a massive migration/integration effort as they were consolidating the market and forced me to use contractors.
- letsdothisagain 3y agoPE is just a rebrand of Corporate Raiders. The fact that this worked is a testament to just how much of our media is directly controlled by Wall St.
- monnok 3y agoI sold my house to PE. I work for a conglomerate that was captured by a vulture capitalist and immediately flipped to PE. I’ve been thinking a lot about PE. I think PE is this decade’s banks bailout. Bank balance sheets were severely unhealthy in the face of fixed rate loans and skyrocketing inflation. Easy credit was eagerly extended to anyone crooked enough take on variable rates and capture real assets. The LLCs that the smart firms financed for their small captures (like houses) are going bankrupt while the revenue they booked is already packaged into REITs and held by corporations as part of their supposed inflation hedges (or timebombs). Meanwhile, the reckless PEs owning multiple corporations are either going to flip them to international bag holders, or drown under the operating costs of servicing 100% debt-financed equity themselves. When catastrophe comes, and bagholders go under, rotten assets will revert to the banks… and taxpayers will bailout the banks to protect hundreds of PE-owned corporations and thousands of “innocent” corporations saddled with toxic REIT-backed instruments and each other’s default swaps. All of which means, if you were priced out of a home in the last three years, it might have been your future tax paying self who outbid you… on behalf of the banks who will indirectly own that home.
- Avshalom 3y agoJust bankrupted instant pots and pyrex too https://edition.cnn.com/2023/06/13/business/instant-brands-bankruptcy/ https://edition.cnn.com/2023/06/13/business/instant-brands-b...
- pierat 3y ago> Instant Brands was purchased by private equity firm Cornell Capital in 2017. And although https://cornellcapllc.com/investments/ https://cornellcapllc.com/investments/ provides the shell companies they own, who knows what's under each of those shells, and under those shells.
- hoppyhoppy2 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36310733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36310733
- rhino369 3y agoI can’t speak to Toys R Us specifically, but if the underlying business was solid, it would reemerge under chapter 11.
- legitster 3y agoDespite the directions the interviewer tried steering this conversation into, this is a really interesting interview. But when it comes to the private equity roll-ups, I think everyone is missing the forest for the trees. If you are a doctor looking to retire and sell your business there is no one else right now who would buy it. The same goes for every category of "mom and pop" business in the US. Even if you could find someone experienced enough and interested in running it - that person could not afford the business. So there is kind of a double problem happening right now. One is simply demographic - experienced business owners are retiring at a much faster rate than they are being replaced. Secondly, there is the capitalization problem. A doctor knows what his practice is worth and wants every cent he can get out of it - but the next generation of doctor is not going to be able to compete with debt financing what a PE cash-buyer can get. In addition, there is a problem specific to medical practices - you can't just hand them over to your kid! (unless they also happened to pursue the exact same medical training you did). And in addition to this medical schools (as I have been told) are really underprepared new doctors for running a business. Keep in mind owner-operators already get a huge income and tax incentive over PE firms. It's kind of a perfect storm that makes medical clinics such a special target vs plumbers or landscapers or whatever. If you want clinics to stay independent and keep retiring doctors happy, we are going to have to carve out special programs or tax breaks for young doctors to buy up these businesses with debt. And keep in mind, these would be essentially subsidies for millionaires.
- mistrial9 3y agosorry, thirty years ago I could have subscribed to "and keep retiring doctors happy" but now, no way Jose
- meepmorp 3y agowhy the change, out of curiosity?
- dwallin 3y ago"there is no one else right now who would buy it." You are missing a qualifier: "at the current market price." If you prevent or disincentivize PE from buying these types of businesses, the price would drop to the level of its new adjusted demand.
- fzeroracer 3y agoVulture capitalists are bad, but at least sometimes they can fund something decent. PE is full of scammers and criminals that honestly should be behind bars because their entire existence involves destruction. It should be blatantly illegal to buy a company and saddle it with the debt you used to buy it.
- toast0 3y agoPrivate equity leveraged buyouts are an option for companies to change their fate. Typically, they're on a long path towards an slow death. With the buyout, current shareholders get a return, and the company is on a 3-7 year path towards a crisis bankruptcy. It's good for the current shareholders, and it's good for the private equity company. It's not good for the business, but if the old owners and the new owners like the deal, who's really got standing to object? How do you force a business to continue to operate in spite of the business being unsustainable and ownership wanting out? Employees don't like it, but the business is already on a path to death, so whatcha gonna do there? It's probably better for employees if Toys R Us closes stores every year for many years, instead of all of them at once, but those jobs are on borrowed time either way. I'd imagine vendors don't like it, because they're going to lose in bankruptcy, but after PE takes over your client, that's a good time to reevaluate their credit and put them on a shorter leash.
- basch 3y agoPlants get pruned and brought back to life. I think there is an argument to be made that PE could be caretakers and stewards that unlock the good trapped by rot, but that might take time, so instead they extract the value immediately but destroy the life in the process. If corporations are people, my friends, they deserve some human rights of their own.
- linuxftw 3y agoThe problem lies in where the money comes from the execute taking the company private. A big bank will issue the debt, then peddle the debt as AAA rated into all of America's 401k's via their friends at the brokerages. You think the banks are just sitting on those debts hoping to make it to maturity? And it's never the PE firm that owes the debt, they're able to get paid back by the thing they buy, and that shell owes the debt. The losses are socialized among the public.
- Invictus0 3y agoYou think the banks are so stupid that they just let PE firms saddle them with a bunch of debt and walk away? Bank PE loans are almost always senior loans, meaning the loan has to be completely repaid before you can start distributing dividends.
- Dowwie 3y agoWell, to be fair, doctors sold themselves out. In New Jersey and New York City, I have to explicitly state that I only want to meet with an MD and not an assistant physician or nurse practitioner. As to how this is even legal is probably explained by insurance company lobbying efforts for cost control.
- alistairSH 3y agoThat hasn't been quite my experience. I've used PAs/NPs when it was appropriate (annual physical, etc) - I don't need an MD to take a blood sample, run a blood pressure check, and read of a standard checklist of questions. And I've seen MDs when that was appropriate (specialist procedures, things that aren't "a cold", etc). There's room for both.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- legitster 3y agoWell, there is a nationwide (potentially global) doctor shortage. It's not like doctors are sitting in a room twiddling their thumbs because insurance companies in the US are cheap. Residency programs are kept artificially low through successful efforts of the AMA to intentionally limit the number of doctors in the US.
- screye 3y agoDoctors are a cartel. Every organization that artificially controls the number of doctors is run by doctors. Ofc, no individual doctor is malicious, but their continued support of what's effectively a 5-10 year hazing is at the core of the issue.
- moomoo11 3y agoPE is only good for PE and privileged shareholders. I think they have a place, maybe in hell? My dad used to work somewhere that got taken over by PE. He was immigrant so can’t really change jobs easily esp in that environment. Fuck those asswipes for making his work life a nightmare that eventually permeated into family life because he was always stressed out.
- jarym 3y agoNot just in the US either - in the UK my local gym (part of a national chain) that I've been with for over a decade got bought by a PE firm. In 18 months the fees went up over 60%. They used to give out regular guest passes - now only 1-2 passes once a year and they're valid for less time than they used to be. They've also doubled the charges for bringing a guest. All these price increases and while the staff are still nice, the gym is now overcrowded and many times there isn't any equipment available. Also, there is dust on almost all the equipment - like a thick layer, clearly the only thing being regularly cleaned is the floor. Naturally, I am looking to go elsewhere but my impression of PE as a consumer based on my personal experience is quite negative.
- gibspaulding 3y agoThe PE firm has managed to charge more, clean less, AND bring in enough customers that the gym is overcrowded? I'd be looking elsewhere too, but from a business perspective that sounds like a roaring success.
- johneth 3y ago> I'd be looking elsewhere too, but from a business perspective that sounds like a roaring success. Short term, yeah. Long term, it's a big opportunity for someone else to come in and provide the original superior service and eat their lunch.
- tucaz 3y agoThis is weird. - Prices went up - Way more people are going to the point where it’s overcrowded - But still dust accumulates on the equipment?
- penguin_booze 3y agoFreakonomics had a couple of related episodes: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/should-you-trust-private-equity-to-take-care-of-your-dog/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/should-you-trust-private-eq....
- lapcat 3y agoSome highlights (lowlights?) of the interview: > the model is that often businesses that service working-class people are attractive because poorer customers don’t have alternatives, so you can raise prices, you can cut quality care > Private equity firms have donated something like $900 million since 1990 to federal candidates. They have a bench of employees that include former cabinet members, secretaries of state, treasury, defense, chairman of the FCC, SEC. > it’s almost impossible for a private equity firm to be held legally responsible under common law veil-piercing arguments > They executed a sale-leaseback, which means they sold the underlying assets of the nursing home chain and had the chain lease it back for a quick hit of money, but now they’ve got a long-term obligation. They executed what’s called a dividend recapitalization, so ManorCare had to borrow money to pay Carlyle and the other investors a profit.
- thedangler 3y agoDon't forget the amazing track record of BCG leading companies into bankruptcy. Yes BCG consulted for Toy's R Us. Maybe there is more too it... There is a conspiracy theory BCG is tied to SHF to lead companies into bankruptcy with help of negative news narratives and help from MM to internalize buy orders and place sell orders on lit markets driving stock prices down. No concrete evidence yet but who knows when all they get is a fine and it's business as usual. BCG also consulted for: Blockbuster OfficeMax Pizza Hut KLM Air France K-Mart Neiman Marcus Pier 1 Imports Sears Toys R Us Circuit City JC Penny Radio Shack Texaco Chrysler MF Global Conseco Inc. CIT Group GM WorldCom Washington Mutual Lehman Brothers GameStop - Fired avoided bankruptcy PulteGroup - Fired and avoided bankruptcy.
- 4rd 3y agoIsn't there significant sample bias here though? I imagine companies in dire circumstances would be more likely to bring on consultants to help "right the ship"
- sailfast 3y agoAlso this isn't exactly their complete client list. That's like saying "Con Edison provided power to these companies and they went bankrupt!"
- vkou 3y agoWhich of these brands do you think were healthy, prior to hiring consultants? Which of them had healthy future prospects, and did not deserve to have 'their stock prices driven down'? I'm not saying that the consultants provided any value add, but if a priest gets hired to say last rights over a terminal patient, it's hard to accuse the priest of killing the patient.
- briandoll 3y agoA friend of mine is a Vet at a place recently sold to a PE firm. If your wait times are crazy long, if you can't get through on a phone, if you realize your vet's office has parted ways with the great vet you used to see -- that's the PE firm counting beans and destroying the service for customers in an effort to squeeze every dollar out of the system. As a specific obviously bad example -- Vet services in California are kinda seasonal. More visits in summer than winter, due to more time outdoors, etc. A PE firm looked at visits on a weekly basis and saw a downward trend in the winter and decided to re-set staffing based on that. Now that summer has arrived they are severely short staffed, have parted ways with great vets, and now wait times are horrific. Thanks PE!
- snapetom 3y agoMy wife is a vet for a corporate owned hospital and our circle of friends are naturally very vet centric. They run the gamut from PE vets, corp vets, and private owners. We know GPS, specialists, dogs and cats only, large animal, exotics. What you are describing is not PE specific. Staffing issues, primarily technicians, have hit everyone across the board. It’s a combination of wages, training, quality of life. Moreover, COVID caused a dramatic demand in vet services but protocols decreased the amount of patients seen. Only now is there starting to be some relief on that. Maybe PE reacted in a way that was not the wisest in your friend’s opinion, but everyone scrambled and few succeeded.
- pc86 3y agoI dated a vet tech several years before COVID and it sounded like a horrendous job. $20/hr was considered good pay, you're constantly bending over, pickup up things (sometimes things that definitively do not to get picked up), and you're literally dealing with some of the shittiest parts of animal care.
- TylerE 3y agoBetter than doing the same work with heavier patients in nursing homes for $12/hr.
- hn8305823 3y ago> That’s a great point, and I’m always adamant about pushing back slightly on the story of Toys“R”Us. Toys“R”Us was profitable the last year before it declared bankruptcy. The challenge was that it had so much debt that it was servicing that rather than being able to expand its operations, and it had advantages that Amazon didn’t have in terms of physical stores. Push back more strongly. My partner at the time had been working at a Toys'R'Us store for many years. She said right up to the last day store traffic was as strong as ever - think last minute shopping for your kid's friend's birthday party, buying toys for your own kid's birthday etc. They had significant traffic and sales throughout the year, not just holiday season. Buying a bicycle for our kid? You're going to want to do that in person. You're a mediocre parent that wants to placate your "annoying" kid? take them to Toys'R'Us and let them shop for something. People really underestimate how well TRU was thriving as a brick-and-mortar store. Also, contrary to what the article says about not figuring out online shopping and logistics, she said associates spent a majority of their time pulling online orders for same-day in-store pickup, and that business was steadily increasing. Too much debt killed Toys'R'Us, not Amazon. I don't know if it was all acquisition debt, or if they loaded up afterwords to strip-mine value but either way it was the debt period.
- crazygringo 3y ago> She said right up to the last day store traffic was as strong as ever... People really underestimate how well TRU was thriving as a brick-and-mortar store. To be fair, that doesn't mean thriving at all. It's easy to have tons of customers but be making zero profit because all your revenue is eaten up by costs. It's common for stores to be busy up to the moment they go bankrupt -- because the problem is they're stuck where they can't raise prices (shoppers will evaporate) and they can't lower costs. > contrary to what the article says about not figuring out online shopping and logistics, she said associates spent a majority of their time pulling online orders for same-day in-store pickup That sounds like not figuring it out to me. Store employees pulling orders for in-store pickup is generally a losing proposition and has never been sustainable. Big warehouses handle online orders efficiently. Retail stores don't at all, generally speaking.
- jrochkind1 3y agoI feel like private equitys game plan is generally to make a good profit while making employers and customers both miserable. So... this is great for our society.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoThis has been capitalism at large since the days of "there's no such thing as society." and I mean that literally. When the edict became shareholder value over all else, the nosedive began and now we get to feel it in earnest.
- wmaiouiru 3y agoI am curious if there is a database of all the companies that are being run by a PE firm to bring transparency around the track record of PE firms.
- missedthecue 3y agoIn an analysis of "European companies around their buyout event in the period 2000 - 2008," private equity was found to "select companies which are less financially distressed than comparable companies prior to the transaction and that the distress risks increase after the buyout" [1]. Critically, however, "the distress risk in private equity-backed companies does not exceed the distress risk in comparable companies three years after the buyout," and, "despite this risk increase, private equity-backed companies do not suffer from higher bankruptcy rates than the control group." More broadly, an analysis of "17,171 worldwide leveraged buyout transactions that include every transaction with a financial sponsor in the CapitalIQ database announced between 1/1/1970 and 6/30/2007" found bankruptcy rates around 6% [2]. This isn't exceptionally high. [1] https://madoc.bib.uni-mannheim.de/31366/1/dp11076.pdf https://madoc.bib.uni-mannheim.de/31366/1/dp11076.pdf [2] https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus
- dopylitty 3y agoThis is a good question! I briefly thought of the same thing after the dentist’s office I’d been using for more than a decade began having utterly terrible service. By accident (an employee sent me an email from their corporate email) I found out they had been taken over by a PE owned dental outsourcing company. That explained why overnight their office staff became a rotating assortment of people who had no idea how to run insurance or handle any problems and the visits lost all quality. I would love to have a resource where I could see what entity actually owns a business or company. Not many people realize that even brands like Volvo and Arc'teryx that used to mean something are now owned by companies that if anything are known for the exact opposite qualities.
- version_five 3y agoCurious hot take: There's really dumb money, i.e. public markets Then there's dumb money, i.e. VC Then there's smart-ish money, where I'd place PE, that basically wants to strip mine any value away from companies And it must be some kind of food chain - people get rich from dumb public investors, dupe some companies investing in venture funds, pillage some veterinary clinics or dentists or whatever. But then what? Is there really smart money somewhere making good, sustainable investments in stuff, to secure generational wealth? Some pension funds maybe? And some family offices?
- madballster 3y agoBallou's criticism of PE fund managers being skilled in finance but not in operations or engineering is missing the point. A good PE fund manager understands the ins and outs of capital allocation and its long-term effects on corporate performance. A typical engineer or product company founder does not, and those who do are the exception. PE companies are never operators of businesses. They find (ideally) competent management teams and advise them in capital allocation. Ballou alleges PE buys to pillage and throw away the corpse. In truth, PE buys to sell, that's the only way to make good returns. In a perfect world, they'd buy an under-managed, undervalued company, where necessary throw out management, bring in competent management, perform bolt-on M&A where it makes sense, improve KPIs, then sell a rejuvenated and much more competitive company 5-10 years later at a much higher multiple. Examples? Ingersoll-Rand, Brenntag, SS&C. Unfortunately, Ballou does not talk about the positive outcomes because they don't make headlines.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoI have a pet theory: there are managerially-minded university graduates who value prestige more than power or pay. In the post-War era, they became beige-suited company men. In my generation, they went corporate finance. Today, they work for private equity. Banking was great. Everyone–from liberal arts to engineering majors–could putz around for years in a pre-defined and prestigious path with moderately above-market pay and the potential to become rich. (Most don't.) It was also a field that could absorb a lot of grunt work, because most of what these folks did was format PowerPoints and populate Excel templates. After the GFC, bulge-bracket finance became less prestigious right when technology lowered the industry's hunger for grunts. Silicon Valley took up some slack, but at least until the pandemic hiring boom, there was a modicum of technical gating factors. The entire time, corporate and industrial America needed administration. But working at a chemical plant in Baton Rouge isn't sexy. You know what is sexy? Working for KKR. So KKR's partners buy the plant, hire the college grad, give them a few weeks' training and "deploy" them to Baton Rouge. That will be their "project" for years. There are perks: they get to fly in from a city, for instance. But overall, the partners can acquire this labor cheaper than their portolio companies. (Ask anyone who isn't a partner at a private equity firm what they do, and it's on a spectrum between administrative assistance and middle management in a random business.) It's what consulting did in another era, re-branded for what young people willing to take less pay and power predict their peers and parents find prestigious (and what they consider safe).
- yasman 3y agoThere’s a book called “Excellent Sheep” that explores this idea as well. It’s been a while since I read it but roughly the premise was that all these “prestigious” organisations (they focused more on McKinsey et al) are another, maybe final, stage on a long ladder of structured excellence. AP/Extracurricular -> Ivy League College -> Consulting (or PE/IB) -> MBA -> ? The path is well defined and optimises for essentially racehorses. The path is defined at each step, you bring the sweat and hours. Hope to make it through the filter to the next level. The book ends with the question of what to do after the last rung of the ladder? How do deal with the existential crisis? To be on the ladder is to adopt an external value system. How to find yourself now? Liberate yourself from the golden handcuffs? Interesting read
- koromak 3y agoI fucking hate the financial system
- lordnacho 3y agoI literally tasted a PE takeover once. Those of you in Britain might remember a burger chain called Ed's Easy Diner. They had a shop in Soho, served really good "American" burgers and shakes. So good I used to yearn for them after I left the country. I came back after a few years, and found they had expanded. I excitedly took my family to eat at one of the new branches. I took one bite of what appeared to be my old favorite, spat it out, and immediately reached for my phone. The burger was now made of gristle instead of meat, other ingredients were worse, and the shake was not too nice either. Indeed, it had been bought out not long after my previous visit.
- busterarm 3y agoIt's interesting reading all of the stories of PE firms destroy businesses. I've had those experiences, but I've also had the opposite experience. I used to work for a regional internet service provider/cable/phone company that was owned by PE. They poured a ton of resources into the business, improved our processes and standardized things so that we could expand to more regions. Then they sold us for a nice chunk of money (for themselves, but employees got better pay and benefits under the new company). The new parent used our practices as the model to use across the whole business. It was a good deal.
- dchftcs 3y agoFor a PE buyout to be truly successful, the current owners need to be vastly less informed and/or have access to fewer resources than the fund does. It's a function of both sides of the transaction. When a PE doesn't think they could get a truly good deal, they are incentivized to flip quickly, potentially at the cost of the long term health of the business. What this seems to imply is that many "middling" deals are the ones that are going to go sour - ones that worked fine before but where the PE could not figure out how to get it to grow faster. In those cases, the rational choice for a profit-maximizing PE is to use whatever tactics at their disposable to exploit it to the last cent and move on to the next project, as opposed to leaving the business alone. More money has been going into PE, and businesses consolidate more. Good targets are harder to find, and more incompetent PE managers are coming to the market. What I feel this predicts is that the average experience with PE should decline over time.
- d136o 3y agoOne of the Montessori schools in SF (across the street from blue bird hq) was bought by some Miami PE fund… that and some other data points informed our decision to pass on it.
- KerrAvon 3y agoInstant Pot just got knifed by PE. https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/12/23758602/instant-pot-bankruptcy-new-products-2023-decline https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/12/23758602/instant-pot-bank... > The other reason it’s absolutely got to keep growing is that there are expectations placed upon it by Cornell Capital, the private equity firm that acquired the Instant from its founder in 2019 and merged it with Corelle Brands, which makes all the Pyrex and CorningWare products you probably heat up leftovers in. … > Sometimes you don’t have to grow at all costs. You can just be very good at one thing
- missedthecue 3y agoBy knifed you mean the corporation that owns it is going through chapter 11. Debt will be converted to equity, and the shareholders will be wiped out. Instant Pots aren't going anywhere.
- refurb 3y agoInstapot was going into a crapper PE or no PE.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoThat's a pretty low-effort take. I'm a very serious cook and I absolutely loathe kitchen gadget culture but the Instant Pot has to be the most innovative kitchen tool created in my lifetime. It's a mobile oven, pressure cooker, saute pan, and mess-free food transport system all in one and it's affordable. The amount of food it can produce relative to the active cook time needed is unparalleled. It's the gateway drug to cooking for people who grew up not knowing how to cook.
- refurb 3y agoIt’s going into the crapper because there are so many instapots you can sell. The company sold them and then revenues went into the toilet.
- mperham 3y agoThere’s an effective tactic for dealing with Wall St control: unionize.
- mjcohen 3y agoPrivate equity buying goods that should be public (e.g., hospitals, schools) is a disaster that is crippling society. It should be banned.
- mark_l_watson 3y agoI think that smart money understands that the US dollar is going to lose a lot of purchasing power or value so they want to buy up “real things.”
- sailfast 3y agoIf you haven't read Barbarians At The Gate.... you should. Not much has changed.
- cvccvroomvroom 3y agoAll of the corporate profits from the post-pandemic bonanza, the ones that were the single biggest contributor to the ongoing inflation, are now free to crash other markets because that cash has to be invested somewhere.
- erostrate 3y agoI have a game, whenever I see a familiar brand or local franchise selling consumer products or services whose quality seems to have declined recently, first I try to guess if they've been PE funded, then I check by going to their website and looking for the "investors relations" page, or googling "<company> investors". It's crazy how often it's the case.
- bmitc 3y ago[flagged]
- cik 3y agoRana Foroohar effectively wrote about this in her amazing book, "Makers and Takers". She discusses the ongoing transformation of the economy from one of innovation to one of financial services - using companies like Ford and Apple as examples. Frankly, it's brilliant and highly recommended, regardless of agreeing with her nor not. If anyone has read her second book, I'd love to know your thoughts - I'm debating it, and given what think pieces are books can be... it's a serious investment for me.
- bigbacaloa 3y agoPE = pirate equity
- sytelus 3y agoI have seen this happen over and over. This is the issue that should be front and center for elections but public doesn't know what is going on. Recently PE firm bought out the building which had oldest and only rock climbing gym. PE firm refused to renew their lease and forced to shut it down. The entire community of rock climbers basically died overnight. Lots of children growing up and learning this sport would not have opportunity that their parents did. The disease of PE firm is very real. I am all for free markets but this is NOT free market. These are the cockroaches that get capital from funds that manages yours and mine 401K. They use that capital to kill local businesses, install new passive income generator like warehouse in order to cut all the costs and then sell it back to suckers for short term profits. The price of their profits are paid by huge negative impact on who continues in the area where they caused devastations.
- voiper1 3y agoWhile you've clearly explained how this is bad, how is this not a free market? >an economic system based on supply and demand with little or no government control
- sytelus 3y agoIt is not the free market because they are privileged through their connections to acquire massive amount of cash in form of credit. The trillions of dollars available in funds from banks and retirement funds are managed by just handful of entities. You and me don't fly in our private jets to play golf with CEOs in Palm Beach. You and me don't have privileged access to these entities to get $10M loan in blink of an eye to buy up a local Rock Climbing gym and shut them down overnight. They CAN and they DO. They use their massive credit leverage through privileged connections to destruct any businesses they want, extract short term profits and move on. In many ways, few entities have monopolies over such credit leverage and that's absolutely not free market.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoSo, "because nepotism"? That's always been a problem and capitalism can't solve it.
- hknmtt 3y agoI am getting into M&A, which is what PE do, and I don't even need to read the article to know it's bs. In essence, the PE firm's goal is to consolidate multiple companies, make them work as efficiently as possible, by sharing resources and utilize the best processes, and then either operate them for increased profit or sell them off for good multiples of earnings, because they have added value to it, so someone else can run it from there on with less headache and no more need to put these efficiencies in place. There is nothing bad with any of this. In essence, it's about bringing efficiency into the market and getting paid for doing so.
- bmalicoat 3y ago>> "There is nothing bad with any of this." My experience has been that once a small business is snatched up by a firm, customer service goes out the window and the focus on efficiency leads to a marked decline in overall quality. I'm sure it's all gravy for the people making money though.
- hknmtt 3y agoIf decline in service goes up, the people at the top most definitely feel it. It is actually multiplied by the fact that it is consolidated. So it is exponential. The problem with ->big<- PEs is that they usually do not care too much. They usually have 5y exit plan, no matter what. If they are managing other people's money, like pension funds and whatnot, they usually do not care because they already got their fees. So yes, it can become a problem over time. Large PE firms simply gobble up every good deal they can so it is quantity over quality. But then, this can happen with small shop anyway. With PE it might be more exaggerated due to the scope but that's just the market. It bares what it financially can and it does not matter how big or small a business is if the management is lacking. But even big PE firms can be good managers. So again, it is circumstantial and not something that can be generalized. There are always bad apples. But those apples, once they make their bad name, they will go out of business sooner or later because other people will know of them and to avoid them.
- sytelus 3y agoI would high recommend the book The New Tycoons: Inside the Trillion Dollar Private Equity Industry That Owns Everything. The book was released 3 years ago and people are now waking up the devastations caused by the private equity firms everywhere. The fuel of private equity firms is yours and mine 401K. That's trillion of dollars of money floating around. PE firms gets tons of cash as debt which gets sold to 401K fund managers. So, in essence, PE firms get money from you and me to destruct the local businesses we depend on. The entire story of making businesses capital efficient is bullcrap. PE firms lives to make short term profits and move on. They are not into business for its philosophy, values and long term customer loyalty. They want to cut the cost, make it look profitable and sold it to sucker to cash out.
- drumhead 3y agoAt overinflated values I'm sure. I guess this is what happens when interest rates are low and all the good companies have been bought up.
- silencethendang 3y agoI've been reading this book. I’m not actually done with it, but I’ve gotten through a pretty substantial portion of it. The author clearly has a bias, having worked as the DOJ as a prosecutor, but also has the facts to back up what he’s saying. It’s not like this bias makes him not credible. However, there were times when reading I would say to myself, “yeah but a company would probably justify things this way…” I’ve seen firsthand a lot of rationalization of things that seem bad, so maybe this is just how I am now. My takeaways thus far: 1. The author seems to put the blame squarely on the shoulders of private equity firms. While they’re obviously not blameless, a lot of the blame should also go toward the C-suite executives and the boards that run the companies that are eventually bought by these firms. I’m guessing that for the most part, these schemes, like taking out massive debt to pay the PE firm, also hugely benefits the executives that are probably agreeing to sign over the firm for a payday. If I’m understanding ‘dividend recapitalization’ correctly, it’s unsurprising that an executive at a target company would turn down a “loan” that they themselves literally never have to pay back. I mean, corporate executives are probably the kind of people that have been waiting their whole lives for someone to make them this exact offer. 2. I’m getting to the part on how some of these cases have been prosecuted, but it doesn’t seem like the fines for doing anything illicit ever outweigh the benefit of doing so in purely dollar terms… as the author says, the lawsuits and fines faced by these firms are “just a cost of doing business.” If the government is getting paid the fine out of the profits made by illicit activity, then this pretty much fits the definition of extortion by the government as David Graeber has pointed out (somewhere, I don’t remember where). PE is definitely not the only industry that this occurs in but I guess I wasn’t aware of how entrenched they are, especially with the GOP. 3. The easiest way of thinking about these PE firms is almost as if they weren’t run by humans but as if someone wrote a program to extract profits over a 5-year horizon by any means possible. You almost have to admire some of the legal loopholes that they’re able to exploit (and question why they exist). Usually there is at least some potentially fake virtual signaling that comes with “public” capitalism, but in the PE world, it seems like none of that exists (with the pretty hilarious exception of Tom Gores, who released this statement while benefitting from charges from prison phone calls). Most “steady revenue streams” and things that make sense on paper AND abide by the social contract are probably already owned, and anything left screws someone over, somewhere in a pretty unethical way. 4. Following from the last two points, my guess is that the thing that PE firms fear most is press and journalism, not because it affects them directly (they probably don’t care about that) but because it puts pressure on companies and funds and whoever else is involved with them to divest if they don’t want to be considered evil. Like I said before, profits that look good on paper and in Excel are almost undoubtedly screwing someone over somewhere, and people (read: executives) want these profits, but they don’t want to know how they’re obtained. PE firms do this dirty work. A big, underrated selling point of PE seems to be blame avoidance – if you’re the CEO at a major retailer, you hate your job, and you want to retire in Beverly Hills now with absolutely no mortgage payments, then PE is your answer. If someone starts attacking you on Twitter when the benefits get cut, you’ve got a great alibi – “I had no idea Blackstone was gonna do this!”
- tduan 3y agoGenuine question, why do most articles discussing PE seem to portray them in a malicious light? Fundamentally, PE investors have skin in the game - they do invest on behalf of their LP, but typically GPs contribute a portion of their own income into the fund as well, not to mention their compensation is tied to performance. The consequence of that gives them every incentive to help a company succeed, and not ruin it. Sure there are failures as with every investments, but one can simply evaluate the overall returns within the asset class across a period of time to see that there is value being created (or at least allocated)
- archon810 3y agoBecause Private Equity is associated with squeezing every penny from the purchased business and making user experience a secondary concern. For some examples, read some of the stories in other comments here and on the web.
- tduan 3y agoHere's another perspective - I've seen PE firms do as you described, cut costs and fire employees, just as much as I've seen them inject more capital into a business and help them with further M&A. Having better user experience can lead to increased revenue (better product, improved branding - leading to increased market share for example) - which should equally be an incentive to PE firms as well. None of the anecdotes you mention counteract the nature of the industry as whole: https://caia.org/blog/2022/07/20/long-term-private-equity-performance-2000-2021 https://caia.org/blog/2022/07/20/long-term-private-equity-pe... I've already caveated that bad investments may occur. My question is why the negatives are being focused versus the positives?