10 ms·
Global fertility has collapsed, with profound economic consequences
- tjr225 3y ago[dead]
- megablast 3y agoGood. Most of our modern problems are due to too many people. House prices, inflation, traffic, pollution, climate change, food scarcity, water, etc...
- steve_taylor 3y agoOverpopulation is the real inconvenient truth that no one wants to address.
- Clubber 3y agoIt's not. We can sustain many more, probably 10B+. The problem is everyone wants to live in the same few places. This is mainly driven by economics (workplaces). The WFH revolution will solve a lot of this if it can be sustained. Imagine if you can dig a well, get solar or any type of non-grid energy, and internet. There are no limits to where you can live, and most of the acreage in the US is cheap. You don't need to have millions of people in the same few square miles, at least in the US. We can go back to smaller communities of people more spread out, instead of 5-10 megacities and 50 or so big cities in the US.
- steve_taylor 3y agoEveryone living in megacities is better than urban sprawl, which clears forests and woodlands. More agriculture is required for more people, which means more land clearing. Renewable energy infrastructure needs energy and resources to build and needs to be replaced at EOL. Whether acreage is cheap or not only refers to money, not the environmental cost. And I haven't even said anything about the environmental costs of manufacturing and shipping goods. People won't go back to a "simpler" way of life because it's a backward step in lifestyle. People don't want to sacrifice their lifestyle to do their very small part to help stave off a catastrophe.
- Clubber 3y ago>which clears forests and woodlands. Strictly speaking in the US, it's already cleared. The center of the country, the Great Plains, has almost no trees. Much of the US is pastureland, and you don't have to clearcut a place to live there. >More agriculture is required for more people, which means more land clearing. Which means more efficient agriculture, which we have an abundance of. >Renewable energy infrastructure needs energy and resources to build and needs to be replaced at EOL. I'm talking create your own grid living, not create a renewable grid. >And I haven't even said anything about the environmental costs of manufacturing and shipping goods. Manufacturing cost is already there, but you're right about shipping. We do have extensive railroads and a massive river system already. >People won't go back to a "simpler" way of life because it's a backward step in lifestyle. Some people won't and they can live in cities. Currently, nearly everyone has to live in a city for economic reasons (workplace). Once that stops being a thing, the people that want to move away from a city, and the crime, and the traffic, can do that. >People don't want to sacrifice their lifestyle to do their very small part to help stave off a catastrophe. With all the talk about climate change, I've seen very few people do any type of personal sacrifice to change it.
- eimrine 3y ago> Which means more efficient agriculture, which we have an abundance of. Which means more harm for the land. I am a farmer and salting of the land is a problem for me. > With all the talk about climate change, I've seen very few people do any type of personal sacrifice to change it. If some person earns 100k annually and another 100M - it means they have to do different sacrifices for holding the climate change. My opinion is that progressive taxation might solve the issue (but I afraid that rich people has both some anticipation of progressive taxation idea and some abilities to obstruct the idea).
- Clubber 3y ago>Which means more harm for the land. I am a farmer and salting of the land is a problem for me. No it doesn't we're already efficient. We've known how to sustainably farm for generations. Efficiency comes from mechanization and computerization and both of those are already done. We're so efficient the government pays farmers to not grow crops. What do you farm? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crop_rotation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crop_rotation >it means they have to do different sacrifices for holding the climate change. That sounds like an excuse to not do anything. This is pretty common. >My opinion is that progressive taxation might solve the issue It won't as long as the government is corrupt. Plus, you have to figure out how to get polluters like China to stop.
- MichaelRo 3y agoExactly. One billion people is far more sustainable than 10.
- mertd 3y agoProblem is people with heavy carbon footprint are not the people in high population regions. Therefore depopulation might not help the environment all that much.
- balaji1 3y agosuch a simple point -- how come no one will accept this? And the rich nations with heavy footprints "wants" the rest of the world to "achieve" the same lifestyle. There are a few big problems - waste management, particularly plastic and other toxic forever chemicals; overuse of toxic chemicals in agri that ends up in the food chain; depletion of soil and water; not enough will to tackle problems sustainably. So a few people can consume more and more -- exacerbated by marketing ads and infinite profit motives.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> House prices, inflation, traffic…food scarcity NIMBYism, combination of bad monetary policy and a supply shock, and bad urban planning. Tokyo has cheaper homes and less traffic than cities with a fraction of the population in America.
- mdorazio 3y agoYes and no. In the US, the vast majority of Americans want to own a single family home, not a condo or apartment [1]. That brings with it the necessity of personal vehicle ownership, which then compounds urban planning and traffic issues. And of course, you can't make more land near cities where people want to live, so you end up in a scarcity situation as the population grows (US population grows by over 1 million per year, whereas Japan's is shrinking - those million+ people have to live somewhere). We can say that American preferences are causing a lot of these issues, but then you have to make the argument that people shouldn't be able to get what they want. [1] https://www.builderonline.com/money/economics/80-percent-of-americans-prefer-single-family-homeownership_o https://www.builderonline.com/money/economics/80-percent-of-...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> then you have to make the argument that people shouldn't be able to get what they want This is basically acknowledging scarcity exists. There will always be fewer places with large plots near people than people want, irrespective of the number of people.
- aylmao 3y ago> In the US, the vast majority of Americans want to own a single family home, not a condo or apartment IMO there's 2 points to consider regarding this though: One can't underestimate the fact it's illegal to build densely in a lot of the USA [1], so it isn't only preferences driving the market. Even if most people prefer single-family homes, and 50% want them to be "away from it all", there's reason to believe that the population that does want to live densely isn't being met with enough supply, and thus prices are still being artificially increased. In terms of the high preference for low density, there's the unfortunate reality that the density is better in a dense context, but that's not something many people in the USA can experience. In New York, for example, ubiquitous density has meant one can live a convenient life without owning a car. An apartment in LA has all the disadvantages of an apartment, without the advantages of a dense city. That's the perception many people who do experience apartment living might have of it. So overall, low density in the USA isn't purely preference-driven, and there's an argument to believe if more density _were_ built, preferences would change. It's worth keeping in mind. [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/18/upshot/cities-across-america-question-single-family-zoning.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/18/upshot/cities...
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoThe weirdest part is that I’m pretty sure women generally want a replacement rate (or more!) number of children when surveyed, but feel like they’re unable to support that number. Why can’t we address those? Edited to ask: some replies seemed skeptical so I went to find what I based this idea off of. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/13/upshot/american-fertility-is-falling-short-of-what-women-want.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/13/upshot/american-fertility... https://ifstudies.org/blog/how-many-kids-do-women-want https://ifstudies.org/blog/how-many-kids-do-women-want
- yablak 3y agolol citation needed.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoSo I googled this and I don’t seem to be wrong. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/13/upshot/american-fertility-is-falling-short-of-what-women-want.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/13/upshot/american-fertility...
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBeing pregnant, birthing kids, breastfeeding them, and raising them to age ~3 sucks for a woman. It could just be that evolution did not bestow humans with a sufficiently easy and risk free process to reproduce, hence the price women demand is too high (in an environment where women can actually price their sacrifice in birthing and raising children due to achieving in financial independence).
- throwaway29291 3y agoPerhaps, instead, we can see this as a good thing and plan a graceful way back to a more sustainable population over the course of a century. Just yesterday yet another in a long line of reports talked about how humanity has not just bent but likely broken many of the Earth's ecological boundaries that humans and non-humans alike depend upon. We've known this for decades -- mountains upon mountains of studies in ecology, climate science, and many more fields. We've largely chosen to ignore it all and keep forging ahead with resource consumption and waste production. Part of the challenge to conventional logic of what I wrote above is that the economy, in standard neoclassical economic thought, is separate from the ecosystem. The two interact, but are entirely distinct. Sometimes human society is another distinct third bubble. Instead, ecologists have long known that the ecosystem of today (and likely for the decades of concern here) contains human society which contains the human economy. So, we're better off planning a graceful descent -- one that will have less competition for resources and less harm to the global ecosystem.
- whaleofatw2022 3y agoUnfortunately, the likely reality is that the ones who can afford to continue reproducing will also continue to consume an unfair amount of resources.
- judge2020 3y agoConsumption of resources in general is the problem, and that only happens at a scale where population growth remains stable or increases. It's not the difference between even 90% of newborns eventually doing something like modding their car to roll coal instead of using bike transportation.
- Telemakhos 3y agoI think the answer is the opposite. Consumption of resources is proportional to standard of living: it takes resources to make the most modern lifestyle available. The demographic collapse, however, is evident in highly industrialized societies like Korea, while backwards regions with a low standard of living still have high birthrates. Subsaharan Africa, for example, consumes less than Korea per capita but has a higher birthrate. It seems more likely that higher rates of resource consumption are correlated with lower birthrates.
- croes 3y agoWouldn't birth rate be a better word instead of fertility? There is a difference between not wanting and not being able.
- iandanforth 3y agoMan there's a lot of nuance here. Fertility as you are thinking of it is also greatly reduced, but confusingly "fertility rate" and "birth rate" are highly correlated measures which basically measure the thing the article is actually talking about. So, kinda, but not really?
- lotsofpulp 3y agohttps://www.differencebetween.com/difference-between-birth-rate-and-vs-fertility-rate/ https://www.differencebetween.com/difference-between-birth-r... > Fertility rate determines the birth rate but, not the other way around. I think fertility rate is the better metric here, so using fertility seems appropriate as well.
- wyager 3y agoBoth are collapsing.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Wouldn’t birth rate be a better word instead of fertility? Birth rate and fertility rate are related but different measures. Birth rate: # of live births per population per unit time (General) Fertility Rate: # of live births in a time period per woman of childbearing age (15-44 is one definition, not sure if it is the most common.) (Total) Fertility Rate: splitting up a definition of childbearing age (often, slightly wider than that used for GFR on the high end; I’ve seen 15-49 used where 15-44 is used for GFR), into equal size age bands (e.g., 5 year bands), calculate the GFR for women in each band on an annual basis, multiply by the width of the bands, and sum; this represents an approximate measure of the expected lifetime births per woman. Yes, this technical usage conflicts with some common uses of “fertility”, but technical jargon is that way.
- thedailymail 3y agohttps://archive.md/vekpF https://archive.md/vekpF
- aemreunal 3y agoAs the article points out, having a choice, and not being pressured by society into having kids one doesn't want, certainly is a good thing. On the other hand, as the article notes: > [...] cannot afford to have more children, or because of other policy failures, such as housing shortages [...] the financial aspect is a huge blocker for those who want to have children. We live in a world where the majority of young people can't afford to live in a city center without 2+ roommates, let alone afford a lifestyle where they have any amount of disposable income, of which a lot is needed to have children. This policy and societal failure of squeezing every bit of wealth out of the new generation and not giving them anything will eventually drain cities of young people and those cities will be left behind as times change with the newer generations. The cities will miss out on culture, societal change, modernity, eventually of sheer people. See San Francisco, New York, Seoul, etc. It doesn't seem like countries are treating this as the problem it is and I fear for the future of all these currently-popular cities.
- lynx23 3y agoAt least in my case, I moved to a city for more infrastructure, public transport and my job. I had absolutely no plans to raise kids there. In fact, most people I know move out of the city center to the suburbs once they have kids. I dont follow your analysis why less childbirth would automatically lead to deserted cities.
- klipt 3y agoA shrinking population does eventually have to lead to smaller (or fewer) cities.
- lynx23 3y agoWhy? What if those left alone in rural areas end up moving to cities for the exact reasons they already do? At least that is what happens right now. Rural areas do nothing to make the young stay. If you don't own a car, you are lost. Most jobs are mechanical in nature, software almost nowhere to be found. And the cities are growing, slowly, but they are. What maes you think this effect would be changed just because overall, population goes down?
- pcurve 3y agoScary part is population collapse is a slow moving train wreck that is hard to avoid. The population projection for decades from now are set in stone. Yet we are powerless to anything about it.
- aylmao 3y agoIMO calling it "population collapse" and a "train wreck" is the wrong way to describe it. This isn't so much a collapse, it's a leveling-off. A train isn't supposed to wreck, but populations are supposed to reach a maxima. The fact historical short-sightedness meant we didn't plan for it properly is an issue. The problem here should be framed around our economic system though, not fertility rates.
- chii 3y ago> populations are supposed to reach a maxima. This is an assumption. In nature, a population reaches a maxima but it's a survivorship bias metric. Populations that _didn't_ level off struggled to find the now scarce food, and died off too fast to re-populate, or some other reason died off. Humans are the only species so far to be able to exploit more resources as population grew, and have the technology to prevent such a collapse (by constantly expanding the resource acquisition game). In the future, i would expect space exploration to be space resource collection. Therefore, we will not reach maxima because there's no such thing. No natural force should be able to kill off humans or their expansion.
- tsunagatta 3y ago> No natural force should be able to kill off humans or their expansion. I will believe this once a way is found to reverse entropy.
- NemoNobody 3y agoI don't think we will get there while we are burdened en masse by the 9-5... but, if entropy itself were ever to be the "last problem left" - I've no doubt that we would solve that problem also. We are far closer to literally living Star Trek lives (without space travel) than we are away from it. Before millennials die we will hear terms like "post scarcity" - assuming we live long enough and society doesn't fall apart.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoThis is the angle here. Don't stop the AI bandwagon! > With that in mind, recent advances in ai could not have come at a better time. An über-productive AI-infused economy might find it easy to support a greater number of retired people. Eventually ai may be able to generate ideas by itself, reducing the need for human intelligence.
- svnt 3y agoAs everyone who has non-programming friends knows it is basically just the shortage of ideas that holds back the growth of the global economy.
- gtaylor 3y agoSeems possible or even plausible, but can't help but feel like this takes us one step closer to: > Welcome to Costco. I love you.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoTiktok is essentially "Ow, my balls"
- aylmao 3y agoAn economic system that depends on an ever-growing population is by definition not a sustainable economic system. Wether shortages happen this century or N centuries from now, at some point, like any population, a cap will be reached If this is dire to the economy, we are better off thinking at once about changing the economic system, not the fertility rate.
- jll29 3y agoExactly. Just a few years ago people were panicky because earth cannot support the "billions and growing" human inhabitants. Don't forget every human conceived less on earth also means fewer cars, plane trips etc. We need to change from a growth-oriented capitalist consumption economy to an elastic (robust against dynamically growing and shrinking) sustainable economy. Part of this is to chain the attitudes about consumption, but part of it is also re-organizing production and supply chains after globalization in ways that ensure goods are produced as locally as possible and as globally as necessary to reduce transportation pathways.
- pyuser583 3y agoWouldn’t that increate insane redundancy? Imagine all the iron mines. Not like we could just have a hand full of mines. We’d have to have tons of them all over. Same with … everything.
- Clubber 3y agoThere is no economic system that is sustainable where there are more elderly people not working / unable to work than there are young people who do work. That's the problem. Many countries are experiencing this problem. The US evaded it currently due to immigration. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x64f7NxQKKk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x64f7NxQKKk
- aylmao 3y ago> There is no economic system that is sustainable where there are more elderly people not working / unable to work than there are young people who do work. I don't think this is true. At the micro-economic level, it's not outlandish to see households where a working generation sustains not only their kids, but also their parents. At a macro-economic level, we'd certainly have to adjust our expectations of profits and growth, but that's because we are used to an always-growing economy.
- tus666 3y agoThe worlds population is/was racing towards 10B. It's just too much. 2-3B is realistic. AI can take over where new workers would have filled in. A small elite living in an AI paradise just as SciFi predicted is the right time to be alive.
- throwme_123 3y ago[flagged]
- djmips 3y agoOriginal sources? Studies? Papers?
- throwme_123 3y ago[flagged]
- djmips 3y agoThat's really immature.
- COGlory 3y agoI've been wondering a lot about fertility lately. Almost every married woman that I know of my age group is seemingly unable to have children, despite, in most cases, wanting to. This is often accompanied by PCOS, thyroid problems, or other strange but undiagnosed illnesses. The one exception to this seems to be those of Italian American vintage. Having grown up in Rhode Island I know quite a lot of Italian Americans, and while they all have those strange illnesses, they do seem to be able to have kids almost universally. Something really strange is going on, and it's awful to watch. In some instances the women have actually considered self harm because of their desire and inability to have children, even after tens of thousands spent on IUI and IVF. This can't be accidental, but I have no idea what could be causing it and how anyone would go about proving the connection. I hear all sorts of wild theories such as birth-control in the water, or plastics imitating estrogens, or pesticides interrupting hormone pathways, but they're all correlative when I've investigated. Never really seen it any truly compelling evidence. In fact, I've never even seen real evidence to prove that this is a phenomenon that's actively occurring, but man, it feels like nearly every fertile-age woman I know is having problems, and the few that aren't probably just aren't talking about it. From a personal and selfish standpoint, I now have two kids and it sucks not having any friends that have kids. I hope it gets figured out.
- xeromal 3y agoEvery comment I read about this is how low housing, low income, no time, etc is the cause of a global fertility drop, but I don't buy. Humans have been having boatloads of kids in horrible horrible times and they haven't been stopped until now.
- hotpotamus 3y agoAny theories as to the cause then?
- danlugo92 3y agoFlynn effect
- chii 3y agoFreedom from being forced to reproduce in recent/modern times for women, and the fact that a lot of women now have a lot of choices (such as going career focused). Not to mention the fact that a lot of younger people would prefer to have financial security "setup" first, before embarking on the journey of child raising (but unfortunately, this takes a lot of time, and fraught with uncertainty).
- idontwantthis 3y agoIt's entirely because people now have a choice of whether or not to have kids and most people are choosing not to for completely valid reasons.
- erikerikson 3y agoBirth control
- randallsquared 3y agoAs children, humans are receiving a torrent of new information all the time. For hundreds of thousands of years, the torrent slows as the human becomes an adolescent, puberty kicks off, and then they have children as the product of the latest new sensation. All that is upended, now. Not only are people continuing to have an available torrent of information into their twenties, but now it is possible to just never stop, so the transition to the next stage of life doesn't happen for more and more, and we just stay (functionally) children into the thirties, forties, or later, after which it's too late for more than half of us. Not sure how seriously I take this. :)
- jimbob45 3y agoCollapsed? We're 0.2 above replacement rate coming off of a major worldwide pandemic. I'm forecasting that number to remain stable or even rise and I don't see much disagreement from mainstream news. You wanna talk about collapse? Let's talk about South Korea.
- NemoNobody 3y agoWhere have you been?
- ars 3y agoWe better get energy technology sorted out this generation! Because from what I see it's going to become impossible soon - there won't be enough available productive people. It's already hard to hire people to produce all the services people want. (You can pay more for one particular thing, but then other things don't have enough people - it's a zero sum game.) With a declining birth rate it's going to become impossible.
- danlugo92 3y ago[flagged]
- dbgev 3y agoConsider Victorian era Britain, when the average person is much poorer, the air is heavily polluted with coal use, and the medical care is almost non-existant by modern standards. Fertility rate is about 5-6. Then it dropped to around 3 over 100 years and has been on a steady downward trajectory ever since. This pattern is broadly replicated everywhere that industrializes. Whatever the cause, it's not due to wealth per capita or personal health. It's probably cultural. Contraceptives / family planning definitely plays a big part too.
- echelon 3y ago100% I think this popular narrative of "kids are too expensive" is mostly a media fiction. It's more about individual comfort. Money can be a factor in comfort, but it's hardly the only one. Poorer immigrants tend to have many children. Even today, poorer people in general have more kids than wealthy folks. Just look at the data - it contradicts the headlines. As Peter Zeihan likes to say, kids were free labor for the farm and made life easier. In today's world, they're expensive furniture for your condo or apartment and they break things. People are focused on their own lives and careers and aren't ready to take a back seat and turn attention to children. They're main characters. I think a lot of folks feel that having children turns you into an NPC. Poor people aren't climbing the corporate ladder. They don't need to worry about keeping their calendars clear for meetings. They're not filling their Instagram with travel photos. Middle income folks have access to social media and easy dopamine hits. They want to stretch being single or unmarried or not having kids out longer and enjoy it more. It's society, not wealth and cost of living, that is causing the dip in children.
- Clubber 3y ago>It's society, not wealth and cost of living, that is causing the dip in children. Yes, people want to party and be free and not have to be tied down and spend money on raising kids. Having kids is a pretty fulfilling experience though. It's not something I understood until I had some. The people that don't have kids will really struggle when they get old and infirm with no one to take care of them.
- dirtyoldmick 3y agoGood. There is too much traffic and food is too expensive.
- rigevunit 3y agoThe reason only partially is due to economic factors(gets rehashed alot) but one major thing everybody overlooks is the simple fact that males and females, in this era, are having difficulties pairing up! Platforms like Tinder are only making it harder for the majority* of people to build lasting bonds. I personally make good money and have a decent home but have never been able to find a mate in my entire 28 years of life.
- thou32io4u3243 3y agoGood. People are today essentially stand-ins for robots to work for elites who collude with each other and anyway deeply despise the 'plebs'. Little wonder, in this mad pursuit, there has been a big collapse in diversity of people, traditions, languages, cultures, are all a miniscule fraction of what they were when the world population was < 1B. You can extend this to the way we treat animals and the world and things automatically make sense. Obviously uniformity has been good for control and productivity. And for what ? Even the act of bringing up your child in a manner not dictated by the state and state-allied academics is seen as a act of iconoclasm in this day across the world. Little wonder it's very close to being criminalized. Reminds me of the 'Clone army' from star wars.
- mullingitover 3y agoAs much as Brave New World is discounted as being about a dystopian society, being able to automate fertility would be a game changer for humanity. We can’t depend on hoping people voluntarily make irresponsible financial decisions by having children in order to save the economy.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoIt would also be an absolute horror from an ethical standpoint
- mullingitover 3y agoCouldn’t be worse than the ethical horror show we’re have today. There are people in positions of power who have created laws with the aim of forcing millions of people to bear pregnancies to term, against their will. This is just taking the coercion out of the equation.
- aylmao 3y agoWhere is this the case? I've only heard of incentive-driven programs to drive fertility (economic help, fertility-positive ad campaigns, etc). I haven't heard of countries forcing millions to bear pregnancies to term against their will.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoIt would absolutely be worse, I can't believe I'm reading a take like this. Automating the creation of humanity could very easily be one of the biggest steps towards creating a slave class born explicitly to fulfill labor demands. Yeah, societal pressure from various angles may nudge people in that direction today, but building technology to serve this purpose explicitly is absolutely worse.
- mullingitover 3y ago> building technology to serve this purpose explicitly is absolutely worse The end result of the current trends in population trees will be the collapse of many nations, and pretty much a four horsemen situation that'll follow. Supplementing the unhealthy fertility rates might help stave this off, if we're lucky, and there's no reason to believe it would create any worse of a wage slavery system than already exists. I can't imagine that it would be more dystopian than the future we're already making a beeline toward.
- rideg 3y agoI think there is an interesting aspect of the depopulation that I haven't seen discussed yet: the scientific progress. If we have less and less people, there will be less brain power to innovate while as far as I can tell the innovation is getting more and more difficult as we moving forward. Just imagine inventing the wheel was probably easier than inventing the combustion engine. I have a feeling that the huge technological advancements of the 20th century happened because of the exponentially increasing population. Also having more advanced technology helped back the population growth too. So I think if the shrinking population will cause technological stagnation on top of the constant hardship due to the proportionally increasing number of elderly who need support.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoI think AI is just as, if not more of a threat, than population decline in this regard. With the ability to generate endless amounts of content on demand, an already overburdened and under-resourced education system is nowhere near sophisticated enough to deal with tools like ChatGPT. And scientific progress cannot happen unless we cultivate and nurture our education system. We're already seeing younger people not understanding basic computing concepts like file systems because they grew up on locked-down mobile OSes that abstract this from users. AI is going to remove the affordances needed to learn on a scale we've never seen before. https://www.theverge.com/22684730/students-file-folder-directory-structure-education-gen-z https://www.theverge.com/22684730/students-file-folder-direc...
- peteradio 3y agoBuilding a useful wheel isn't chipping it from stone. There is a lot of materials science and engineering evolved to make one, I wouldn't short change the effort in it. Anyway who cares if tech stagnates? I'd be more worried about a backslide where we lose hard won knowledge.
- seydor 3y agoevery shortage is followed by glut which is followed by shortage. It's the opposite of the boomer era > The obvious one is that it is getting harder to support the world’s pensioners that was never taken for granted, the expansion of welfare was a happy accident of the largest generation the world will ever see. Also, the idea that real estate prices will keep going higher should not be taken for granted. Ideas like these are taken for granted because "boomer" generations were so dominant numerically -- and that s the reason why they loved democracy so much. We might see a regression in democracy as the world is becoming more and more expensive for everyone but the boomers. Anti-fertility is driven by the anomalous cost structures that we have created: children require physical space , they are physical objects after all. But real estate is extremely unaffordable compared to most of history (when people just built their own homes), and nobody talks about it as a global crisis (people are worried that housing prices might fall and actively discourage buildiung for environmental reasons). Instead, luxuries such as travel , tourism and touchscreens are cheap and people flock to them. Ironically low fertility will be used as a weapon for wages to go up, way up
- bane 3y agoThere are quite a few comments here about "you need money to raise kids". There are similar statements made about housing size, cost, etc. and those end up on "but you don't need 8,000 sq ft to live!" These are, frankly IMHO, bizarre arguments that seem conditioned on socio-commercial training along the lines of "you need a diamond to propose!". Absolutely none of these are true: - People had sex and stable relationships before diamond mines existed. - You, strictly speaking, don't need any amount of square footage to live. You might be cold, wet, and miserable, but you'll be alive. - Children existed for millions of years before money and will alarmingly, and generally, grow and learn regardless of what you do. You may not be happy with the outcome, but it'll happen. A friend of mine is recently pregnant and focused on giving birth, but the medical expenses and doctor visits are becoming a burden. I mentioned to her that my grandmother gave birth to 12 children without a doctor on a farmhouse table at zero cost and no doctor visits. What she's paying for is not having a baby, but reducing child and mother mortality. I have loads of family in South Korea, a country in near terminal population decline, and the reason I've always heard is "it's expensive to raise a child". But the real reason is, it's expensive to train a child to get into a top-3 university. Raising a child to adulthood is possible even in abject poverty. We (us), as a civilization(s), are fundamentally dishonest about what our problems are, and it makes it difficult to reason about our solutions. "Children are expensive" turns into "have less kids" rather than "the road to top-3 universities are expensive" -> "let's be okay with kids getting into lesser schools or not any school at all" or "let's figure out how to make higher education more accessible". We don't understand what we're even paying for, and why, and we need to relearn it and rethink it.
- seydor 3y ago> are fundamentally dishonest about what our problems are It's more like, we make up excuses because we don't know our real motives or don't want to outright say we dont want kids because it's societally unacceptable. I believe statistics show there is a rise in childlessness , but people having kids have on average the same kids as a few decades ago.
- agensaequivocum 3y agoThe number of extremely rude comments my wife has received for having more than the acceptable 2 is disgusting.
- rayiner 3y agoOne overlooked aspect of all this is the evangelism around birth rate reduction that happened in the 20th century. My family actually came to the US because my dad got caught up with these folks, who worked hard to reduce the number of brown people being born around the world. In many ways the effect was positive—in my home country the birth rate dropped from 5.7 the year I was born to a sustainable 2.0 today. In my part of the world this was seen as a necessary step towards economic development and modernity. What I realized over the years, though, was there was an ideological underpinning to it. Frankly it’s deeply disquieting—we had a party the other day with some of my dad’s family work friends, and someone asked whether we’d have a fourth child. One lady got very uncomfortable at the idea and muttered something about family planning (even though we’re rich and could easily afford another kid). It’s as if they are drawn to small families in and of themselves, not means as a means to practical ends. This ideology has now been exported all over the world, even to societies that are historically natalist and family oriented. The birth rate in Japan and Korea of course has plummeted. But birth rates among Asian Americans is also abysmally low, despite their affluence.
- abrookewood 3y agoI know it's the Economist, but it would be great if it could at least contemplate some of the benefits of a shrinking population: - less people, therefore less competition for houses, therefore lower house prices - less urban sprawl, more nature reserves - less cars, less traffic - less farming, therefore less competition with native animals for land It might even lead to a (long-awaited) increase in real wages if there is more competition for workers ... oh wait, AI will take care of that.
- kamikaz1k 3y agoBut that hasn't borne out anywhere. Pretty much everywhere there's a population decline, there's also all sorts of other systemic issues.
- deafpolygon 3y agoThis may be in part by evolutionary pressure. I don't have the link anymore, but I was reading that many species have an evolutionary limit to population size - and you would think it wouldn't apply to humans, but it may. The thought goes that as humans' biological needs for survival are better met, the reproductive needs trend downward.
- kamikaz1k 3y agoIt's actually pretty simple. People are too busy to think about stuff they aren't directly interested in. Pressure to have kids is reducing year by year (relatively, and it compounds quickly). Since everybody is being trained to pursue personal excellence/satiety they're pushing back everything that isn't directly in their interests. This includes devaluation of relationships (romantic, parental, and platonic). In exchange for the elevation of the individual. And so, when the question of kids comes up, it's done with the same myopic lens as most other decisions. Which isn't to say, that its easy to just have children. But, people aren't exactly kicking their feet up. They're busy; very very busy. This is actually probably no different than before, but there was momentum from traditions and peer pressure. But because the rails have diverged for so long, the curve is compounding.
- theshrike79 3y agoA conversation about fertility isn't complete without a link to The Idiocracy (2006) opening scene: https://youtu.be/sP2tUW0HDHA https://youtu.be/sP2tUW0HDHA (length 4:39) It's surprisingly accurate, even if it's very exaggerated, because that's the premise of the movie. tl;dw "Smart/Rich" people put off having kids to the Perfect Time in their life and never end up having kids or maybe just the one. "Stupid/Poor" people just keep having kids all the time.
- danbolt 3y agoDoes that mean that the smartest and richest people of the past all died out, and we’re the descendants of yesteryear’s dumb-dumbs?
- theshrike79 3y agoIn the world of the movie, yes. People are watering plants with Mt Dew (or something) because it tastes good to them and don't know why their crops keep dying. In the story a regular average joe from our time ends up in the future and is hailed as a genius just because he has basic level knowledge of stuff =) Fun fact: the set designer wanted to have everyone wear some stupid shoes that nobody would ever actually wear in public and they picked a small up-coming company making pressed plastic shoes. The company was Crocs.
- smitty1e 3y agoRead no these sorts of headlines and despair. There is no literal "global fertility". There are no aggregate testicles/ovaries that produce people. There are only reproductive organs integrated with a body near you. Marry. Prioritize family. Enjoy the blessing of your offspring, if possible. Participate in a community of faith, a like-minded extended family, that can enjoy life with you and help you raise those blessings, whether or not they are your own, or you take the noble road of adoption. Best wishes to all.
- NemoNobody 3y agoLow motility is real and the data is seemingly showing a drastic increase very recently in make infertility - the harder of the two both to mess up and fix, hence the global concern. Your advice is rather backhanded. Prioritizing family and going at it like rabbits won't do anything if your shooting blanks. If this was a global problem one can only surmise there will also be fewer kids to adopt...
- isolli 3y agoI can't access the article, but how much of the collapse is due to the pandemic and its consequences? I remember visiting a maternity in Berlin, where they had a chart showing births by year in that hospital since its inception. I was surprised to see that there had been a stronger decline in births after the fall of the wall in 1989 than during or after the second world war. I would not be surprised to see a similar decline in the past few years.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoI realize this is from 'the economist' so that means they would of course be thinking about the economy, but it reminded me of those parody news headlines like "Mega-Asteroid to utterly destroy all of Earth, what this means for your 401-k"
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt is related because your 401k is for buying labor, and if the price of labor goes up due to shifts in supply and demand, then your 401k is not going to get you as far as you thought.
- Balgair 3y agoNew parent here in the US. My views on this have been swinging wildly over the past months/years, and it's been 'fun' to experience. Are kids too expensive to have? Hells yes. We're at ~$400/wk for daycare per kid. And compared to others in my social circle, that's pretty cheap! Now add in all the toys, daycare, near weekly MD visits, etc. Kids are really expensive. But here's the thing. You love them so damn much that you, somehow, make it work. I know people that can't afford the cost of daycare. So they reach out to family, church members, neighbors, etc and make it work. Same is true with most of the costs for kids. They reach out, it sucks for a while, and then they make it work, somehow. Look, I know what the child poverty rates are in the US, they are appalling. I know what the hunger rates are, similarly, horrible. Mortality rates for birth in the US? Awful. Pick a statistic, the US sucks at it. Sure, okay? But, somehow, we want more kids. We just love them. I haven't slept a full nights sleep in years. I'll get 3-4 good hours in and I'm good to go now. Something that would have wrecked me for the next day, I barely bat an eye at. All the poop, snot, fluids, are not a 'thing' anymore. The incessant cries from teething barely phase (you get a sense of a 'real' cry pretty quick). Parenthood is a heck of a ride, especially with the covid-bounce-back in diseases. I don't know how to explain this to anyone here that is on the fence. I'm more than happy to try to field questions though.
- snowwrestler 3y agoAlso in the news: AI is going to take everyone’s jobs, with profound economic consequences. All we need to do is merge these two storylines and watch the consequences cancel out as AI productivity compensates for population decline. Voila: narrative renormalization.
- feoren 3y agoYes, the two problems really can solve each other. Or should I say: they could solve each other. But they won't, will they? Because the positives all happen to a small group of people (those who already own everything) and the negatives all happen to a different, much larger group of people (those now-worthless poorsies). Our problem is what it has always been: asshole human psychopaths that hoard orders of magnitude more wealth than they could ever spend at the expense of everyone else.
- annVoronova 3y ago[flagged]
- Mrfixit2 3y ago[flagged]
- annVoronova 3y agoYes, it's a chore. The more children an average woman has the less time she has for hobbies, work, friends, or even a moment of peace. It's like being a 24/7 house cleaner for the next decade or two, no sane person wants to be that. As for the rare rich "girl", if she is born into money, It's not likely she will give birth to more than 2-3 kids. I doubt you will understand my position, since it's extremely rare for men and boys to "take care of a precious life".
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- sillywalk 3y agoEven if you can afford a child, some people might not want to bring a child into a dystopian nightmare.
- lilboiluvr69 3y ago"The world is not close to full" ...yeah?