21 ms·
Automatic emergency braking should become mandatory, feds say
- version_five 3y agoRegulatory capture marches forward. In an environment where small, cheap, runabout electric vehicles could become very popular, I expect lots of "for your safety" reasons why cars have to be complicated and expensive.
- cudgy 3y agoWell they have to do something with all the new funding from the latest “infrastructure” bill. “helped secure a historic 50 percent increase in funding and staffing resources for the agency under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law” https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsa-leadership/ann-carlson https://www.nhtsa.gov/nhtsa-leadership/ann-carlson
- asoneth 3y agoMulti-ton vehicles capable of moving at highway speeds are dangerous and kill roughly a hundred people a day in the US[1]. So whether these changes are driven by regulatory capture or not it makes perfect sense to tightly regulate automobiles. Personally I think consumers should be free to decide things like seatbelt and airbag use but if they drive on public roadways they should not be allowed to make cost/benefit tradeoffs that decrease the safety of those around them. > small, cheap, runabout electric vehicles could become very popular Agreed that's a promising area. It's possible that the increasing regulatory burden on cars may drive an increase in low-speed vehicles such as neighborhood electric vehicles (NEV) for use cases that do not require more than 25mph/40kph.[2] Since they are exempt from the vast majority of new automobile regulations that makes them comparatively much simpler and more affordable. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7126a1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7126a1.htm [2] I am not claiming this works for every suburban commute, just that there exists a nontrivial number of car trips in cities and towns that would be feasible in a NEV.
- pdonis 3y ago> it makes perfect sense to tightly regulate automobiles Not the way we do it, it doesn't. What it does make sense to do is put the liability for harm where it belongs: on those who actually cause harm. But the vast majority of our automobile regulations--I include traffic laws in this category--do not do that. The regulation proposed here is an example.
- taeric 3y agoNonsense. Better than worrying about liability of the harm that happens, is reducing the amount of harm that happens. To argue otherwise is silly.
- pdonis 3y agoRegulations that restrict people who have not caused actual harm do not, in general, reduce the amount of harm that happens. But they do work great as revenue sources for local governments (speeding laws are the most common example but not the only one), not to mention as excuses for manufacturers to charge higher prices and squeeze out more profit from consumers. They also reduce general respect for laws and regulations among the public: people start to view driving, for example, as a game to avoid being caught doing things that are technically illegal but which the vast majority of people do anyway (such as exceeding posted speed limits). Fostering that kind of mentality among the public arguably increases the amount of harm that happens. Furthermore, government institutions, particularly in the post-COVID era, simply lack credibility when they make claims about some government mandate reducing harm. In this case, as I pointed out elsewhere in this thread, NHTSA's claims about harm reduction assume that these systems will always operate perfectly and will never cause any harm, only prevent it. Such an assumption is not credible. In short, I do not share your faith in the ability of government regulators to actually reduce harm, on net. More generally, I do not share your faith in the ability of governments to actually act in the interest of all the people, instead of benefiting the governments themselves and particular special interests.
- taeric 3y ago
- taeric 3y agoI mean, I can certainly agree that there is a thing as regulatory capture. I am not clear that this is it, though. Making cars safer has legit improved life expectancy. Anti-lock brakes, seat belts, rear view cameras, blind spot indicators, etc. are all very welcome advances that make modern vehicles much more safe than they would otherwise be.
- pdonis 3y agoAll of the safety devices you mention were bought by many consumers before they were required by regulations. Why? Because they are obvious benefits with no real downside. In fact, the only reason regulators were able to require things like anti-lock brakes and seat belts on all cars was that the vast majority of cars already had them, because the vast majority of drivers already recognized their benefits. They didn't need regulators to tell them. The systems under discussion here are different, because they have the capability to do something that none of the other safety systems you mention can: take control of your car from you. Anti-lock brakes only work when you press the brake pedal. Seat belts and rear view cameras are passive. Automatic systems that can press the brakes without warning and without you expecting it are very different; what if the system makes a mistake? Multiple other posters in this thread have described such mistakes. These systems are more like rudimentary self-driving cars and should be judged accordingly. They are not just passive safety features with no downside.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe car industry fought seatbelts and airbags. https://www.nytimes.com/1975/04/06/archives/industry-resists-carsafety-costs-companies-feel-consumers-will.html https://www.nytimes.com/1975/04/06/archives/industry-resists... Your claims about widespread voluntary adoption appear false. https://www.history.com/news/seat-belt-laws-resistance https://www.history.com/news/seat-belt-laws-resistance > At the time, only 14 percent of Americans regularly wore seat belts, even though the federal government required lap and shoulder belts in all new cars starting in 1968.
- pdonis 3y ago
- nradov 3y agoThat's not what is happening here at all. There is a separate set of regulations for those small, cheap, runabout electric vehicles. They are classified as "neighborhood electric vehicles". The NHTSA has not proposed to require automatic emergency braking for them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighborhood_Electric_Vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neighborhood_Electric_Vehicle
- killdozer 3y agolmao not every law is "regulatory capture", sometimes laws make dangerous activities that most of us are forced into (like driving) a bit safer as better technology becomes available.
- sidewndr46 3y agoI have never understood how this would work in the real world. If my car automatically brakes, I would just get cutoff by other drivers constantly until my car comes to a complete stop in the roadway.
- dalyons 3y agoAnd yet I have it in my very real world (and unexciting) Subaru for years and it never does what you say. I’m guessing it has some idea of differential speeds , not just distance-to-object
- maxfurman 3y agoI too have a Subaru, my emergency brake has only engaged when trying to parallel park a bit too aggressively. I must be a very good driver! But perhaps it has saved my bumper a few dents
- sidewndr46 3y agoso if someone merges over into your lane where you are it doesn't activate? I must not understand the point of this feature then.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoIt’s for when your mother in law hurtles your family towards a truck in front of you with no indication of trying to slow down (personal experience). The car does its best to stop acceleration while maximizing braking force safely.
- caconym_ 3y agoOn my Honda if a car merges in front of me and is accelerating, it maintains its speed presumably on the assumption that the separation will continue to increase. If a car merges in front and is slower than me, i.e. separation is decreasing, it will brake in an attempt to maintain the set following distance. In practice it does leave a bit more following distance than most human drivers, but your worry of constantly getting cut off until you come to a stop in the road is not a real thing. This is partly because the car modifies the set following distance based on speed, so that the same setting is much closer at e.g. 5 mph than at 60.
- jacquesm 3y agoThis almost got me into a serious accident, twice. Definitely would not recommend and I switched cars because of it. The last thing I need is buggy software with the capability of instantly changing the trajectory of my vehicle (slippery surfaces, cornering). A brand car as well (MB) so really, really disappointed, what should have been a safety feature actually was the opposite. Dealer said everything was fine so that was the end of that car, if 'fine' means that you have a couple of close calls in the first few thousand km on account of a feature that can't even be properly disabled without sabotaging the electronics then that's just too bad. Now I drive a 27 year old car that has none of these 'features'. It does what I tell it to and when I tell it to, it doesn't phone home, and has no touch screen, but old fashioned buttons. If the government wants to immediately improve car safety they should outlaw touchscreens instead.
- jo6gwb 3y agoTouchscreens first, quickly followed by excessively bright, flickering, and aftermarket headlights.
- ddalcino 3y agoWould you care to elaborate on what went wrong? The other comments here make ‘automatic emergency braking’ sound like a really good idea, and it’s hard for me to imagine that this particular feature would be so problematic. If you’re talking about other automatic steering features, that’s very different, and your comment makes more sense to me.
- burgerzzz 3y agoI’ve had the automatic breaking in my Jeep take effect needlessly, which can be quite jarring
- lsaferite 3y agoMy Kia has AEB, Lane Keeping, and Adaptive Cruise Control. They have false positive type events from time to time, but generally you just know when it's going to happen. The first couple of times it was a shock, but I've never had it trigger in such a way that I felt like it would cause an accident. That being said, you can't just leave it un attended. You're still the PiC of the vehicle.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoThe only time my vehicle ever used its emergency braking was when my wife’s mom was driving, and my entire family was in the car. I was so grateful for it. The scariest part was that she accelerated toward a truck that was travelling very slowly in front of us, the car braked so hard we were all pressed into our seatbelts and the car was audibly vibrating as it lurched from the anti lock brakes. We were literally inches from hitting this truck, and her mom was completely unperturbed. Like nothing had happened. I was shaken. If I’d done that myself I’d think I needed to take a brake from driving and seriously contemplate how that was able to happen. She just kept driving and talking about whatever she was talking about. Disturbing stuff. So, that’s why I’m generally in favour of emergency braking. It completely saved my ass.
- jacquesm 3y agoSounds like you don't want your wife's mom driving with you and the rest of the family in the car. Sounds like she quite possibly should not be driving at all. That must have been pretty scary.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoIt was one of the scariest vehicle incidents I’ve been in (thankfully). She really shouldn’t be driving; she seems almost senile to me, but her kids and husband are determined to pretend nothing is going on. She lives full time in Mexico so there’s not a lot I can do other than be grateful for that buffer.
- jacquesm 3y agoI once was in the car with an American friend who was looking sideways while talking to me and would then swerve around cars in front at the last moment. Very annoying and quite scary. I asked him to stop the car and got out. There is no way I'll trust my life to someone who isn't 100% on the ball when it comes to driving. Good for you you did not end up in an accident there, and it must really suck that you are essentially powerless to do something about it given the family relationship. But, at least one very positive story about automatic emergency braking. I think such features are quite possibly a net positive from a statistical perspective but for me personally they are a no-go.
- dmfdmf 3y agoI have a modern car (2019) and the auto braking, collision and lane drift alert is a nuisance. False positives are common and there is no way to disable most of it. Some of it can be turned off but as soon as the car is restarted it resets to the default. I've even had the car emergency brake and come to a complete stop in the middle of the road due to a phantom collision. As soon as I pay it off I am going to sell it and roll back to an earlier model without all this mandated, modern tech and keep the older car rolling till I die. We will become like Cuba keeping 50's cars running into the 70's or even the 80's and this time it won't be due to the commies but the fascists.
- mint2 3y agoName the car brand and model. Not all implementations are so bad, so it’s important to raise awareness of the bad ones.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 3y agoSeconded, better yet a public registry of locations and situations where these systems go off so that manufacturers can include these in their tests.
- lsaferite 3y agoWeird that you cannot disable the collision warning and lane keeping. What Make/model is it?
- jacquesm 3y agoUsually you can disable it but on a per-ride basis and it takes a lot of menu scrolling and tapping to do it again. It defaults to 'on' when you start the car, and there is no physical switch to disable it permanently.
- 3y ago
- mkmk 3y agoThis feature once saved me from what would have otherwise been a very nasty crash, many years ago. I was driving too fast in a borrowed car over a small hill and hadn't realized that traffic had stopped just out of my sight until too late. I heard a beep and saw flashing on my dash and I started braking but a moment later the emergency braking system kicked in, braking much harder than I would have been able to. The car stopped, hard, a foot or two short of the pickup truck in front of me. As the brakes kicked in, my seatbelt tensioned and pulled me into my seat, which was surprising because, although I had a vague idea of emergency braking, I didn't know the seatbelts would do that. And although I may be mis-remembering since this was so long ago, it feels like the passenger seat next to me started moving (I'm not sure why) – I should look that up. Made me infinitely grateful for the engineering that went into this system. I was quite young and insufficiently cautious, and it was an eye-opening experience.
- jacquesm 3y agoSeatbelt tensioners are life savers. They're a little explosive charge under the chair near the seatbelt attachment point that yanks hard on the belt to squeeze you against the chair while the car comes to a stop. They're super powerful and you don't want to mess with them unless you know exactly what you're doing (see also: airbags).
- mkmk 3y agoInteresting! My recollection was that it was a non-explosive tensioner, but maybe I'm wrong. Thinking about explosive tensioners reminds me of an EOD tool I recently learned about – the rocket wrench. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11qa5LFB6zI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11qa5LFB6zI [1:36]
- jacquesm 3y agoThere are spring loaded ones too but they're not as powerful or as fast. https://laughingsquid.com/a-slow-motion-video-of-a-pyrotechnic-seat-belt-pretensioner-activating-at-28000-frames-per-second/ https://laughingsquid.com/a-slow-motion-video-of-a-pyrotechn...
- 1MachineElf 3y agoNext it will be, "watch 30 seconds of this ad to unlock your brakes."
- jacquesm 3y agoThat gives a whole new meaning to 'anti-lock braking'.
- taeric 3y agoI confess that I find a dark humor in how many self professed "great drivers" find these features a nuisance. All the while so many people are completely unaware that they have these, as they have never activated. Hard for me to square those pegs in a favorable way. Which, yes, being a great driver means you may be pushing close to limits while still be completely under control a lot. I just don't have a strong prior for that view.
- labcomputer 3y agoI am reminded of the quote, often attributed to astronaut Frank Borman: “Superior pilots use their superior judgement to avoid situations that require use of their superior skills”
- _moof 3y agoThere's a similar one among sailors: "The mark of a great shiphandler is never getting into situations that require great shiphandling." Anyone operating a machine in a way that doesn't leave much margin is, in fact, not skilled at operating that machine.
- tialaramex 3y agoIt's really interesting watching videos of emergency responders in my country (the UK) either showing how their advanced driving looks in practice, or in later stages of training when they're explaining their thoughts to an instructor as they work. Their progress through traffic is markedly faster without greatly compromising safety. They aren't making violent manoeuvres, they accelerate pretty aggressively but other than speed limits they aren't breaking many rules that apply to everybody else. They are paying a lot more attention to the environment and applying excellent judgement from what they learned. For example rather than weaving through traffic like a Hollywood movie, they take clear bold lines and hold them, which gives them better vision of what's ahead and more options when things go wrong. It's doesn't look as flashy, but it's very effective.
- 3y ago
- maximinus_thrax 3y agoLooking at the comments here I need to double check if I'm on some gearhead forum where automatic transmission is considered appropriate exclusively for teenagers and geriatric patients. Anyway, I'll add my anecdote when my Toyota surprised me with a panic brake in a blind corner which probably saved my life by not ending up under a stopped bus. But the kicker is that my insurer gave me quite a steep discount when I originally bought the car, specifically due to the emergency brake feature. They may have more data comparing collisions for cars with/without this feature than anons on internet forums, who knows?
- jacquesm 3y agoInsurance companies are run by people that are good at statistics, and there is a fair chance that statistically this works out well but that does not mean anything for any particular individual. Chances are that EAB will cause some accidents and prevents a whole lot more, and that's enough for the insurers.
- peter422 3y agoEvery possible change to a car’s safety system will cause some deaths and save others… look at airbags. The aggregate stats are the most important things to look at, especially for something like AEB which has the ability to save pedestrians, which as of late are getting mowed down more and more frequently.
- jacquesm 3y agoAgreed that overall it can be an improvement. But I've clocked up a good 40K km since I got rid of the car that was equipped with defunct EAB and I'm fairly sure (but of course can not prove it) that I would have been in an accident by now on account of it triggering falsely. Conversely, I've never had a problem with airbags deploying without cause and my seatbelt is on just to move the car 10 meters because it is deeply ingrained and I refuse to drive - or be in - a car without it. But faulty EAB caused more trouble for me than any other safety feature to date and I really wonder what caused Mercedes Benz to release this feature in such a horrific functional state. It is beyond belief how broken it is and I would love to see their internal stats for how often their EAB caused - not prevented - single vehicle accidents.
- opwieurposiu 3y agoThe quality of these systems varies wildly IME. If your car has a good one, they are quite useful. If your car has a glitchy one they are dangerous. How do we keep the glitchy ones off the road? Extended return policy? Make the unit swappable/replaceable?
- jacquesm 3y agoSet some standards and 100% transparency on cases where they fail, mandatory disclosure of every case where they phantom brake and what the cause and end result was. Unlike seatbelts or airbags where there is very little downside these can cause perfectly safe situations to turn into nasty accidents.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoThey should be equipped with cameras at both the front and rear and ship off a recording of what was occurring on both cameras in the seconds leading up to and following every time the emergency brake systems engaged. Only then can they determine what percentage of a specific emergency brake system's engagements actually make things more dangerous or are responsible for accidents. Then they should hold the auto makers accountable, and require them to fix or replace fault vehicles
- perlgeek 3y ago> How do we keep the glitchy ones off the road? Extended return policy? Make the unit swappable/replaceable? Treat a failure as a cause for vendor warranty. Either the vendor has to fix it, replace it or refund the car.
- porkbeer 3y agoNever. As someone who works on these systems, the cure is often worse than the disease. Fix the root issue and enforce distracted driving laws, ban in car touchscreens.
- Eumenes 3y agoI wanna know the quality of software developer engineering these features. Are they hiring bootcamp grads?
- drewmol 3y agoAn eye tracking feature would be nice if incorporated into the AEB where it could be set to only activate if I’m not looking at the road in front of me. This plus have a disabling trigger on the steering wheel and auto disabled if you punch the gas from a stop. Uhhg… just imagine someone pointing a gun at you from the front of your car to carjack you, you duck while stepping on the gas - only for your tires to squeal and not go anywhere!
- Vecr 3y agoFrom random evasive/tactical driving videos I've seen, you also need to be able to ram attackers, as well as the front wheel of a blocking car with your frame rail. This system would prevent you from using your car as a weapon in lawful self defense.
- drewmol 3y agoThat’s what a disabling trigger on the steering wheel would be for, one of the reasons at least. There may be situations where I want to ensure it is off, such as in an environment where it has often detected false positives in the past.
- nickpinkston 3y agoI'm becoming an old man at 36... I just want a feedspinning NA engine with a 6 speed on a 3000 lb RWD chassis where everything isn't driver aids. I know... I know... this isn't practical or safe, but goddamn it, it's the most fun for me!
- abawany 3y agoSounds like Caterham might have what you need: https://caterhamcars.com/us/models/the-range https://caterhamcars.com/us/models/the-range .
- nickpinkston 3y agoI'd love to drive one, but they always seems like death traps to me haha. Makes an Elise look like an SUV!
- abawany 3y agoI agree - the low-slung structure is excessively unfit in the era of SUVs and crossovers. I have dreamt of owning one for decades now but the price often gives me pause - I wave away the personal safety considerations by telling myself that it is probably safer than a motorbike :) .
- globular-toast 3y agoThat's great. Keep your fun off the public highway, though. It's too dangerous. There are plenty of racetracks and a race car doesn't need to be road legal or practical so what you describe should be much more affordable.
- nickpinkston 3y agoI like to have fun while driving everyday, but yea you gotta be safe / courteous.
- hedora 3y agoThere is a lot of concern about incorrect actuations in this thread. One way to address this is to dictate that the car AEB status prior to each accident was made known to everyone involved, and to hold the manufacturer directly liable whenever AEB contributed to a collision. After making that change, they could circulate the draft bill, and let the car manufacturer lobbyists kill it.
- AlexandrB 3y agoLove the path this comment took.
- autoexec 3y agoI was probably lobbyists driving the push to make them mandatory in the first place
- sebzim4500 3y agoI don't think that car manufacturers should be held responsible just because AEB contributed to a collision. It isn't that rare for safety features to do harm in specific circumstances, for example seatbelts can prevent people leaving the car in a hurry and airbags can sometimes kill people when they activate. The question is whether the feature is a net positive, not whether it is a positive in literally every potential collision.
- throw9away6 3y agoCan confirm phantom braking is a problem. I was driving an ionic 5 and it activated emergency brakes despite not having any forward sensors (due to an earlier accident) and braking supposedly being disabled due to lack of sensors.
- getmeinrn 3y agoI've always wondered why brakes don't have a variable brightness based on how hard the driver is braking. If you've ever been behind someone who has braked hard, part of the danger is not realizing just how fast they're stopping.
- nateb2022 3y agoPerhaps the reverse lights could activate when extremely hard braking is applied.
- trgn 3y agoNew cars they flicker rapidly I thought
- imp0cat 3y agoYes, they do. Some even activate hazard lights when coming to a rapid stop.
- globular-toast 3y agoYeah, but really you were just driving close to the person in front. Remember, the person in front could emergency brake at any time. Even if you manage to detect that and emergency brake too, is the person behind you going to be able to? Just don't drive close. Train yourself on what the proper distance is and stick to it.
- ouid 3y agoAs soon at the becomes prevalent, people are going to start fucking with it. For instance, I'm personally going to bring a big piece of posterboard with a car printed on it, and hold it out in intersections that I'm about to cross on foot. A feature that lets an adversary take control of your car in this way is known as a bug.
- imp0cat 3y agoA high-visibility vest worn while walking on the side of a road is sometimes all that it takes to activate it. :)
- jedberg 3y agoI see a lot of comments in there in the lines of "it almost caused an accident!". Yeah, my AEB has misfired too, often when coming around a curve and it thinks I'm about to have a head on collision with the oncoming traffic even though we are both turning. Or when making u-turns with a car in front of me. But it's never caused me to get hit. And more importantly, if the other cars around me also had AEB, then they too would get triggered. Yeah, it's sometimes annoying when it misfires, but man, that one time it fired in a real situation definitely saved my life as I stopped inches from the car in front of me. I'd take the minor annoyance of misfires over a crash any day. Especially if everyone has it.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoMy AEB is overridden by an increase in throttle; even a small one. If (rarely) it misfires, it’s only pretensioning the brakes initially. That’s just getting the pedal firm and pads against the rotors, no braking force. A small bit of throttle, not even enough to speed up, is enough to tell it to cool it. No actual braking occurs. Anyone who’s losing control of their vehicle over that is already driving too close to the vehicle’s limits.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoBut how long do we have to wait for everyone around us to get AEB? 20 years? 30 years? In meantime, every time it misfires, we’re risking an accident. Yes, it’s an accident caused by the poor following distance of the car behind us, but the blame isn’t much of a consolation when there’s no guarantee you can walk away from the crash without an injury.
- Drunk_Engineer 3y agoRisk Compensation theory predicts this technology will increase risky behavior by drivers. It has been well established that people adjust their behavior in response to perceived risk -- and if the car is going to handle the emergency braking it will cause more dangerous speeds and tailgating. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_compensation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_compensation
- teej 3y agoTheory is great. What has data shown?
- Drunk_Engineer 3y agoAmong other things, data showed mandatory helmet laws may have had a perverse impact on motorcycle fatalities: http://john-adams.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2006/motorcycle%20helmets.pdf http://john-adams.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2006/motorcycle%2...
- doodlesdev 3y agoHaven't read it completely or paid attention to the data yet, but the conclusion got me hooked: > Conclusion > The foregoing review of the statistical case for helmet legislation suggests that the faith of the BMJ in the reliability of the statistical evidence on the effect of helmet legislation is misplaced. But debates about sophisticated statistics should not be allowed to drown out the voice of common sense. The risk compensation hypothesis is essentially common sense. There is a wealth of evidence from everyday experience that suggests that people's behaviour is influenced by their perception of risk. People tend to be more cautious when up high ladders than when up low ladders. They tend to take more care when standing on the edge of a high precipice than when standing on a low kerb. They tend to slow down when they encounter bends in the road or patches of fog and to speed up when the road becomes straight or the visibility good-and so on. The possible illustrations of the phenomenon are countless. > There is an impressive amount of propaganda designed to encourage people to believe that they are very much less vulnerable when using seat belts and motorcycle helmets, and common sense suggests that driving behaviour will be influenced by safety devices that diminish the user's sense of vulnerability. What unaided common sense cannot predict is whether the behavioural changes induced by a safety device will partly, completely, or more than completely nullify the intended effect of the device. > The statistics which the NHTSA considers the most compelling evidence in support of helmet legislation are displayed in figure 1. The state which Watson et al (1980) consider has had the greatest increase in deaths as result of helmet law repeal is Utah. > When the distorting effects of the analytical methods employed by the NHTSA and Watson et al are removed, their data (with the caveats discussed above) suggest that the effect, if any, of helmet legislation on motorcycling fatalities is perverse. I'll have to read the paper with more attention later to see if I agree with this, but it's a fascinating hypothesis regardless. Also, this is tangential, but I'm always impressed how different conclusions can be based on the same sets of data. Statistics is a truly fascinating field of mathematics because it's still an objective topic (regarding numbers, in isolation) but becomes very human and subjective when it comes to the different conclusions, transformations, and visualizations for the same data sets.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- greenthrow 3y agoBought a VW and a BMW with these features in the last 6 months. Both can disable them but we find them to be worth leaving on even though the occasional false positive can be jarring.
- giantg2 3y agoFunny, when will the feds mandate a serious driver test...
- lgleason 3y agoGiven how many people drive cars every year in the US, 360 lives saved is a rounding error. Would like to see the data on the accidents it actually prevents. I have cars with and without this. Honestly I haven't noticed a difference one way or the other with anecdotal experiences.
- sam36 3y agoPerhaps I'm getting jaded (or wiser) in my old age, but anytime I see "mandate", I just picture congress people shoveling truck loads of money into a company's stock. So if this is mandated, what stock should I buy? (I'm serious).
- Vapormac 3y agoMandated safety features wouldn't increase stock price of any of the auto manufacturers. You might be able to expose yourself to the increase in price if you can isolate the manufacturer(s) of the technology involved itself. You're still highly unlikely to capture any alpha if the various car companies diversify which chips/camera's they are using.
- lettergram 3y agoThis might be controversial, but I don’t want any automated systems. I want a mechanical car and I don’t trust government or tech. Particularly in the privacy space primarily. I say this as someone who spends hrs a day on a computer building AI systems…
- tremere 3y agoIf they do this, then - Make alignment of front facing cameras free (for newer automobiles not retrofits), not a $500 service option. The front facing camera is bound to fall all out of alignment, which makes the system begin to see ghosts. This then causes drivers to simply disable the automatic emergency braking, after 1 or 2 scares. Therefore the system is broken. - Fine car companies that cause accidents due to emergency braking randomly braking due to ghosts or other spectra, if due to flawed mechanics. There should not be corner cutting in a safety feature. Such fines already exist for airbag regulations. If we were to mandate automatic emergency braking today with the state of the current technology, it would be a disaster.
- fwungy 3y agoThe point is to gradually remove private automobiles from the transit system by incrementally nudging out their availability, either through expense or added bureaucratic hassle. The WEF has discussed the need for this repeatedly: don't forget, you'll own nothing and be happy AND safe!
- toss1 3y agoHoly forking shirtballs - NOOO!! At least until it is MUCH better. Like 6 orders of magnitude better. Just watching the "Pre-Collission Warning" red flash and beep on both a Ford Truck and Mazda crossover, there are far tooo many times that it reliably and consistently would brake and CAUSE an accident. The most common one is where there is a car or obstacle just on the outside of a turn, such as (in the US, left side driver) a left bend in the road with a "Y" intersection going off the right side = outside of the turn, or a vehicle pulling off into a right-side driveway. As I turn left around the bend without much slowing and the other vehicle drives off to the right => "ALARM!!!". It obviously 'thinks' I'm about to rear-end that vehicle, when I know that no such thing will happen (unless I straighten the wheel or turn right for some bad reason). If braking happened here, I'd get rear-ended. Similarly, I've seen the alert go off on either dirt roads with some random dark spot in the middle, or a regular road with a temporary steel plate over a work trench, or even just a pebble or small branch in the road. It is clear that all of these miscellaneous items can produce the appearance of an obstacle about to be hit, but that does NOT mean that braking is appropriate. It looks like instead of moving forward to an all-electric vehicle, I may be going back to restore some early 1990's vehicles and run them until the petrol market is no longer sufficiently viable to support common corner petrol stations. Just a few hours ago, I saw an pristine but old Porsche 911 with antique plates. Obviously still way fun to actually DRIVE. Seems like a good way to go!
- xormapmap 3y agoMost of the comments in favour of this technology seem to be "It saved me from rear-ending someone because I wasn't concentrating". On the other hand comments against this technology are essentially "It had a false positive and almost killed me". As I'm capable of maintaining good following distance, riding to the conditions, braking correctly, and being aware of the traffic around me; I'll choose not to use this technology, thanks.
- ke88y 3y ago> I'll choose not to use this technology, thanks. Roads are public. I have been rear-ended by another driver in a completely unavoidable situation (for me -- the other driver should've been paying attention; I saw the collision coming and honked but had nowhere to go). I've also been in an accident as a passenger in a Uber. My Uber driver rear ended someone. I screamed at him twice but by the time he reacted it was too late. I have never activated the emergency braking on my vehicle.
- trgn 3y agoSorry to hear about the accidents. One part makes me wondr (tangential to your stories). Has honking really ever prevented any accidents? I don't even know why a car needs a horn, 99% it's abused out of frustration, and I cannot Eben imagine what that magic 1% situation is that requires car to have a horn. Honest question.
- giobox 3y agoReading this thread, I can't help but wonder if some folks are confusing phantom braking on radar-adaptive cruise (a really widespread issue and common trait of radar based cruise) with AEB (Automatic Emergency Braking) activation. In my experience the former is common and can feel scary at highway speed, but this is not the same thing as AEB, which is a separate system. My ford for example has AEB and no cruise control at all, and has never once misfired.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoI don't ride horses because I don't want my bicycle to have the ability to make bad (or any) decisions mid-ride. Fuck everything about this proposal for identical reasons. I nearly got myself and several other folks killed on the highway in a rental Forrester when lane assist decided it couldn't tell the difference between painted lane markers and pavement seams in the middle of Denver highway construction. If folks don't want to actually operate the vehicle they travel in that's fine, move to an urban area and use mass transit. For myself, I'll just keep driving continuously older vehicles until I finally get around to doing a full EV conversion on a vintage car, thereby permanently sidestepping all manners of similar bullshit.
- runsWphotons 3y agoI have had more problems with such driving tech than it has ever helped. I wonder how the data to justify this is collected.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- meling 3y agoI have a sense that my Model Y has gotten better — less phantom breaking. Curious what other people’s experience with Tesla have been lately…
- sammyjoe72 3y agoI’m conflicted on this one, it has both saved me, and also almost caused a real crash… it’s save me twice when reversing, once a guy pulled in behind me after I had checked mirrors and started reversing, and the auto brake engaged and saved a collision… but it has also jammed the brakes on when driving down the street because it detected an obstacle that was fixed, and I was driving around it comfortably
- globalise83 3y agoTraffic safety would be greatly improved by a system whereby cars could automatically communicate their speed, rate of acceleration / deceleration etc. to each other. Has anyone considered using brake and parking lights as a way of doing this? I could imagine that by rapidly flipping on / off some of the LEDs, it would be possible to communicate simple information to following vehicles with capability to read the signal, while to other vehicles without such capability they would flicker so fast as to just look like normal brake lights.
- mordae 3y agoHmm, perhaps you could also mandate better braking systems in trains while you're at it. :-)
- yaomtc 3y agoPeriodic re-testing to keep your license should become mandatory. 50% of federal transportation funding going to transit and related projects should become mandatory. Getting as many cars off the road as possible in the coming years should become mandatory. Reduced speed limits in cities across the country should become mandatory. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7126a1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7126a1.htm If pedestrian detection "doesn't work very well" as the linked article* says, we need to take the simple, practical approaches that we know will have an impact, and stop sacrificing lives to the altar of convenience and the "American Dream". * https://arstechnica.com/cars/2019/10/aaa-finds-your-new-car-probably-wont-stop-you-from-hitting-pedestrians/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2019/10/aaa-finds-your-new-car-...
- Vecr 3y agoNo way, you and what dictator is getting this passed? No one would get this passed, even the most corrupt possible senate and lobbyists.
- globular-toast 3y agoSo we're completely giving up on people being in control and responsible for these things? Fine. But this is a stupid reaction to that. Cars are far too heavy, far too powerful, far too comfortable and far too distracting. They are too much of a good thing. We desperately need to stop these things. But we're addicted. We're destroying the environment, hurting ourselves and others with these things. But we can't stop. Just like a heroin addict.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eimrine 3y agoCan these systems be FOSS? For example, if my car would have such a so-called safety feature, I have a strong feeling that I must know all possible incomes and outcomes, for understanding what has fired the emergency braking if it fires somehow.
- sschueller 3y agoWhat would really save more lives would be a much stricter license system that is federaly mandated. What little you have to do to get your license compared to European nations like Switzerland or Germany is absurd. Not only can you drive at 16 already there is basically no test to drive what is basically a tank down the road. In the north you have the additional hazard of driving in snow and so many have no clue how to deal with it. A "Schleuderkurs" should be manditory in the north so people know what it feels like to lossee control and how to deal with it. P.S. In Switzerland if you fail your driving test a second time you can't just do it again. You need to get a psychiatric evaluation that you are fit to drive. Yet we still have shit drivers here as well.
- lesuorac 3y ago+1 Imagine if we were debating right now on if Airplanes should have automatic braking systems due to all the runway incursions ...
- yonatan8070 3y agoA while back I saw this article about a Tesla that stopped on a highway and caused a massive pile-up https://theintercept.com/2023/01/10/tesla-crash-footage-autopilot/ https://theintercept.com/2023/01/10/tesla-crash-footage-auto...
- jiveturkey 3y agosadly yes they are right. the implementations are sadly lacking so as a competent and always aware driver, i’ve found that 100% of the time these systems (on all levels of car, honda to mercedes) these systems do more harm than good. however your typical usa driver is quite poor, so yes these systems need to be required
- thomasjudge 3y agoSo in some ways it's hard to argue against new "safety" features; but on the other hand there is a cost to sprawling feature creep in cars (or software): increased complexity surface; increased failure modes; increased repair costs. How many sensors/computers are on new cars; 10 years out how many of them will start to fail/go flaky. Right now I apparently have an O2 sensor and a crankshaft position sensor failure on my vehicle; they do not seem to be impacting normal operation, but replacement of them would cost $600
- aedocw 3y agoThat o2 sensor is an important part of the engine/emissions management system. Without that info, the car computer is not able to efficiently map the fuel/air mixture and over time is likely to lead to more problems. Depending on the car, the CPS sensor could be really critical (like if you've got variable valve timing in an interference engine I think?). Understandable you want to ignore that check engine light but recognize that $600 cost to repair could balloon into a lot more (even a destroyed engine).
- rcktmrtn 3y agoYeah, well put. There are a lot of difficult to quantify cost for new features: * monetary for the consumer (new features give manufactures an excuse to keep the price high) * environmental (because increased failure surface area causes consumers to need more repairs/upgrades) * safety (side airbags hurt visibility... Bigger cars are more dangerous ... generally safety features may make more people drive more dangerously [1]) * increased oligopoly (complex safety requirements stifle competition) The problem isn't that there's no benefit, it's just that all of those "unintended" costs are actually boons to the manufacturers, so as long as they're calling the shots new features will just keep on rolling. Meanwhile, we just get more and more dependent on something that fewer and fewer really understand. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- than3 3y agoYet another classic example of perverse incentives. Create a problem, offer a solution that creates other more serious problems. Force it through bureaucratic circles without representation. Create a less free world. When you drive, you are responsible for you and your passengers safety. How can you possibly be responsible for the car suddenly stopping when you have no control over it as a mandated safety feature. The only choice you have if this is mandated is you can't drive. So you can't travel long distances, or transport things long distance, interferes with interstate commerce and travel you are confined to your local area of walking distance. This is beyond stupid, and lacks any basis of granted authority since it opens the door for violating constitutional rights, in the name of a dubious claimed safety issue. Congress can't create a law and have this not be unconstitutional how can a committee think this will be any different.