16 ms·
Reflections on Ten Years Past the Snowden Revelations
- DirectorKrennic 3y ago[flagged]
- layer8 3y agoUsername checks out.
- throwbadubadu 3y agoGreat find, love it! But the downvotes are maybe unfair for the Clapperish, wasn't that a parody?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> wasn't that a parody? I can't see how. Post was a wall of copypasta from James Clapper's book.
- kelnos 3y ago> the secrets Snowden was releasing were revealing to our adversaries and international terrorist groups how to avoid or thwart our surveillance. And yet, I don't see these international terrorist groups having been particularly successful since the Snowden leaks. Of course Clapper is going to try to paint the leaks in a bad light; the leaks painted him in a bad light!
- WaxProlix 3y ago> The materials Manning had leaked were embarrassing; the secrets Snowden was releasing were revealing to our adversaries and international terrorist groups how to avoid or thwart our surveillance. Dang, sounds like they should have cast a finer net or something eh? > he had appointed himself as judge over what he had seen, and then, without conducting an investigation or calling out wrongdoers, was going to bring about justice in ways that multiple executive branch agencies, Congress, and federal courts - which were all aware of and conducted oversight of the very programs that concerned him - apparently were unable or unwilling to do. And yet the American people, who ostensibly hold the reins here, weren't uniformly enthused about what they heard. This is an insider with immaculate insider mentality griping about a whistleblower whose complaints in the previous paragraph apparently went miles overhead. What an eye-roller.
- 93po 3y ago> the secrets Snowden was releasing were revealing to our adversaries and international terrorist groups how to avoid or thwart our surveillance. Good, maybe this will incentivize intelligence agencies to not abuse their power knowing people will whistle-blow and reveal secrets. When you remove all other methods of accountability, this is what happens. Intelligence agencies did this to themselves.
- cronix 3y agoMaybe, but more likely, if history has anything to show, is that they just become more draconian in their methods as well as increased ability to identify and go after leakers.
- ok_dad 3y agoExactly. They talk about how he ruined their ability to spy on bad guys, but never mention how they were missing that ability to spy on citizens and friendly foreign governments. Maybe if they had stuck to spying on bad guys, Snowden would still be using his intellect today to help them.
- 93po 3y agoAgreed. They're not sorry for their actions, they're sorry they got caught. If they're sorry at all.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoParent is referring to the same James Clapper who lied (to Congress under oath, to the public) for a living. ref: https://reason.com/2018/01/17/time-is-running-out-for-prosecuting-form/ https://reason.com/2018/01/17/time-is-running-out-for-prosec...
- CrazyStat 3y agoI suppose this is supposed to make Snowden look bad. It doesn't. The author is James Clapper, who Snowden's revelations proved lied in Congressional testimony about whether the NSA was collecting information on millions of Americans. So when he says that "multiple executive branch agencies, Congress, and federal courts [...] were all aware of and conducted oversight of the very programs that concerned [Snowden]," he's talking about the Congress that he lied to about these programs. How are we supposed to trust that Congress can conduct effective oversight when the intelligence community lies to them? (We shouldn't.) Snowden embarrassed the intelligence community and they won't forgive him for it. Americans (and others) should take that into account when they read or listen to the intelligence community's criticisms of Snowden.
- 93po 3y ago> when they read or listen to the intelligence community's criticisms of Snowden. Or anyone who has reason to toe the same line, which is all of corporate news and most any politician. One can also include Assange as a target of this biased criticism.
- EA-3167 3y ago[flagged]
- dijit 3y agoI literally just posted a dismissal of your claims in a sibling comment. You owe it to yourself to think critically about what you think you want out of intelligence services, being secretive is one thing, not permitting any oversight is not ok and being in direct violation of the law is also not ok. It's not a hypothetical situation, people were using these tools to stalk women for crying out loud, you can't defend that. Those tools shouldn't have even existed in the first place, it was a flagrant violation of authority. The reason in the UK police are charged with harsher sentences than ordinary criminals is because they have authority and an enormous capacity to do harm. So do these agencies.
- EA-3167 3y ago
- throw7 3y agoJames "not wittingly" Clapper.
- newZWhoDis 3y agoThe fact that James Clapper is not currently behind bars is appalling. He lied to Congress and lied to the American people.
- 93po 3y agoThe list of people who should be behind bars and aren't is extremely long and probably includes most any household name politician.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoPesky leaks. Protecting democracy when they work in your favour, defending terrorism when they don’t.
- tootie 3y agoSerious question, why are the Snowden leaks so revered and not the reporting of James Risen several years earlier? Risen exposed operation Stellar Wind which was the grossest abuse of spying apparatus approved by the Bush admin over the express objections of their own DOJ. Risen also appeared in court for every summons about his activities and was dutifully defended by the NYT until he was ultimately exonerated.
- colordrops 3y agoBecause you had journalists and documentarians like Greenwald and Poitras doing an amazing job of getting the story out there.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Serious question, why are the Snowden leaks so revered and not the reporting of James Risen several years earlier? Because, historically, the US Press is compulsively deferential to the NatSec state. It's the same reason the press twistered themselves to report the Mark Klein revelations as a warrantless wiretapping issue - instead of the NSA live cloning internet backbone traffic in a room custom built by AT&T for the purpose. ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Klein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Klein That the US press was loudly silent over US Gov's revenge campaign against - not only James Rosen but also James Risen and other journalists who outed NatSec wrongdoing - is for me one of US Journalism's most defining (non)actions. ref: US Gov's persecution of James Risen https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2015/03/james-risen-anonymous-source-government-battle https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2015/03/james-risen-anonymou... ref: US Gov's persecution of James Rosen https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2013/05/james-rosen-named-a-co-conspirator-why-is-barack-obamas-justice-department-going-after-a-national-security-reporter.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2013/05/james-rosen-name...
- hgsgm 3y agoThe US major media reported on this. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- rektide 3y agoBellovin's Governments and Cryptography: The Crypto Wars is the most grand & sweeping review of governments & encryption across time that I've seen! https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-farrell-tenyearsafter-00.html#name-steven-m-bellovin-governmen https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-farrell-tenyearsafter-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- photochemsyn 3y agoIndeed. I guess that whole DUAL_EC_DRBG random-number-generator story - the NSA backdoor deal with RSA is essentially true? No confessions yet it seems, however.
- iJohnDoe 3y agoI think people would be surprised and sickened to know just how cooperative the big tech companies are with the intelligence agencies. Microsoft is especially cooperative, even as going so far to make sure their systems are compatible with surveillance systems. Yes, Telcos have had to this as well, but I don’t think many people know that Microsoft has proactively done this.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Microsoft is especially cooperative, even as going so far to make sure their systems are compatible with surveillance systems. I don't doubt you but a reference would help folks know what to make of this.
- danielovichdk 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Enterprise_Defense_Infrastructure https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Enterprise_Defense_Inf... This for example
- mickeypi 3y agoFTA: “Companies interested in the contract included Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Oracle” and “The deal was considered "gift-wrapped for Amazon" until Oracle (co-chaired by Safra Catz) contested the contract”. So pretty much every single large cloud provider went after this, though Google did eventually bow out early. Other than winning the second round of the bidding (and not actually going live), is there something Microsoft did specifically that warrants being singled out?
- iJohnDoe 3y agohttps://amp.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/11/microsoft-nsa-collaboration-user-data https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/11/microsoft-nsa-... Kind of an older article, but illustrates the situation pretty nicely. Microsoft has also done development work in recent years to enrich the data with more identifiable information and to make the data easier to process for surveillance.
- amoshi 3y ago>Intelligence professionals talk about how disorienting it is living on the inside. You read so much classified information about the world’s geopolitical events that you start seeing the world differently. You become convinced that only the insiders know what’s really going on, because the news media is so often wrong. Your family is ignorant. Your friends are ignorant. The world is ignorant. The only thing keeping you from ignorance is that constant stream of classified knowledge. It’s hard not to feel superior, not to say things like “If you only knew what we know” all the time. I can understand how General Keith Alexander, the director of the NSA, comes across as so supercilious; I only saw a minute fraction of that secret world, and I started feeling it. This really well describes the feelings I was getting around the time of the revelations, as I scrolled through the secret documents, it's like a different world out there. Hackers can hack. But these agencies can do so much more. Intelligence agencies have the law behind them, can force you/the hardware suppliers (so called "interdiction")/software providers (PRISM etc) to play ball and force you to sign an NDA (non disclosure agreement) at the end of the day. Don't want to agree? You end up like Qwest (CEO got jailed) or Yahoo ($250k daily fine until they comply). The power gained is immense though, just read about XKeyScore. Again, it's just a different world out there. Would love to know what their capabilities look like nowadays.
- anonymousiam 3y agoTo take what you've said a little further, intelligence agencies have the "law" behind them, but once you become aware of everything they (all of them, worldwide) are doing, you get a completely different perspective on the "law" itself. Being involved in these activities can also diminish your ethical base, which I guess explains some of the crazy law-ignoring/law-breaking activities within all governments.
- markus_zhang 3y agoLaw is a weapon of the ruling class. That's why I laugh at whoever suggests about unions. Downvote me as you wish, but it won't fix the problem for ya.
- 3y ago
- drumhead 3y agoRealistically intelligence agencies have access to whatever information they want. If they can crack encryption they're not going to tell us and they will probably act like they can't. You're compromised and you have no secrets and can't hide anything from them. The best thing we can do is stay safe from criminals.
- scrum-treats 3y ago> The best thing we can do is stay safe from criminals. And if the criminals are government entities or government-sponsored entities?
- nabogh 3y agoSome cyphers maybe. But it's highly unlikely that all or even most in use are compromised. There are many cryptography researchers who aren't part of the NSA. Other nations for example. And banks obviously trust some cryptography.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoEven if they were compromised I imagine the nsa would probably hesitate to use it in a detectable way and "save it for a real threat"
- DontchaKnowit 3y agoI recall reading that government agencues forced the NIST to relax certain crypography standards so that they could still be reasonably broken with super computers.
- MathMonkeyMan 3y agoI want to downvote you but can't think of a better reason than I don't like what you say. Surely we can encode better behavior into our institutions.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> If they can crack encryption they're not going to tell us and they will probably act like they can't. The thing that was pretty apparent from Snowden's leaks is primarily that they don't need to. This fear that "NSA can crack cryptography" is the wrong fear. First, as others have noted, there are legions of other researchers evaluating and attempting to break widely used crypto-systems. There is no reason to believe the NSA has some unique brilliant minds that aren't available elsewhere. More importantly, though, why bother with a "frontal assault" on breaking crypto schemes when endpoint security is a million times more hackable. That is, usually at some point someone wants to view the encrypted data that is being sent, and at that point it needs to be decrypted, so why not just try to hack at that point (which is exactly what they do). As an example, just look at all the stolen cryptocurrency heists. All of these heists resulted from stolen keys or from implementation bugs, not from cracking the crypto schemes that protect cryptocurrency in the first place.
- motohagiography 3y agoWhen the Snowden docs came out, the main thing that surprised me wasn't the tech, it was the scale. I thought I had seen the tip of the iceberg doing security work for over 15y prior, but I had barely seen ripples in the surface. Most of what I saw would have been in the category of "BULLRUN," which I incorporate into client threat models today, but also some of the ISP interception equipment I saw at peering points / IX's during the 90s that had just been called "some old police telco stuff, ignore it." I think an unintended consequence was that it also emboldened a lot of authoritarian personalities to just say, "yeah, we do this, you are with us or against us, here's the line, toe it." A decade later, participation in elite circles like media, academia, and politics is based on how convincingly one can be seen to parrot obvious untruths, not because anyone believes them at all, but because it signals status to be able to lie to the faces of people who know you are doing it, and still say nothing. Snowden's leaks were an unambiguous act of conscience. They made sustaining dissonance about how the sausage of empire gets made a lot harder for regular people - even if we also learned that most people really just like sausage. I tolerate the spook-adjacent types in my field who parrot absurd official lines and slogans about russian interference because being seen to align with it is just how they are trying to survive, and I can't judge what people do to keep their families fed. But the ones who know what's true, yet take a kind of pleasure in repeating official lies because it makes them feel powerful - I think the real impact Snowden had is showing people like that for what they are, and how low the bar is for getting involved in public service and just doing better. There are amazing people in public service, and they are mostly sidelined by a minority of these eels who demoralize their agencies by normalizing small acts of deviance, corruption, and partisan favours. You can change that. The best way for a technologist to leverage their skills to effect change in government is to go get a Privacy Professional certification https://iapp.org/certify/cipp/ https://iapp.org/certify/cipp/, and do work for your state, municipality, or a federal agency. Privacy laws everywhere got absolutely gutted over the pandemic, but the work privacy pros did in the decade prior prevented some of the worst abuses by people leveraging that crisis, and it's going to take a lot of smart technical people working in government to ensure there are technical limits on what a few sleazy appointees like the very ones who exploited 9/11 to build the panopticon Snowden exposed, can do.
- theaussiestew 3y ago
- user6723 3y agoWhen I tell someone to use Signal app and they say "I'm not that important" all I can do is smile and nod: "no.. you are not that important".
- bee_rider 3y agoI prefer to point out: if only “interesting” people encrypt their messages, then encrypting your messages becomes a signal that you are interesting. As a boring person who thinks the state shouldn’t be allowed to focus the Eye of Sauron on anybody, I have a responsibility to encrypt my boring brunch plans. I think “I’m not that important” is basically either the result of someone not thinking very hard, or it is a dishonest anti-encryption position. Embedded in it is the message that only certain types of people ought to be worried about the scrutiny of the state, and that the person holding the position is happy to take advantage of the fact that they aren’t that sort of person. Force them to face that position head-on, I think.
- Zetice 3y agoWhat about as a boring person who does think the state should be allowed to focus the Eye of Sauron on people? And that person doesn't have to be anti-encryption, just anti-bad opsec.
- bee_rider 3y ago> What about as a boring person who does think the state should be allowed to focus the Eye of Sauron on people? Sure. Not everyone has to agree with me. I think it is unpopular to be happy about intelligence agencies spying on us. So hopefully I can win over some of the in-between people by causing them to fully face their position. But if someone just fundamentally disagrees with me, I think this tactic won’t work. Coming up with arguments for people who fundamentally disagree with you is pretty difficult. > And that person doesn't have to be anti-encryption, just anti-bad opsec. I’m not sure I follow here. But in general, for example I don’t think it is reasonable to expect non-technical people who aren’t, like, spies to have perfect opsec all the time. So, like journalists and activists, they will inevitable slip up sometimes, anything we can do to mitigate that is good.
- 36097082 3y agoTIL that the Arab polymath al-Kindi invented frequency analysis & wrote the first cryptanalysis book ‘Manuscript on Deciphering Cryptographic Messages’, in the 9th century.
- StrangeATractor 3y agoIf you're interested in this sort of thing you'd probably like David Kahn's The Codebreakers. It's pretty much the authoritative source of what's publicly known about the history of cryptography. I believe he had some trouble getting it published at first, actually, because he made what was considered sensitive material more accessible.
- yeetsec 3y ago[flagged]
- theaussiestew 3y agoI have a vaguely related question about Signal. People say it’s secure and encrypted but it was widely publicised that Sam Bankman Fried’s Signal messages were inspected by authorities. How did this happen?
- ben_w 3y agoWhile I can't prove this, my expectation in this case is: The authorities asked for them and, possibly after consulting a lawyer, he handed them over.
- from 3y agoThere were cooperators in the same chatroom, a participant in the chats gave up their phone at an airport, or he volunteered it (probably not this). Same way it was obtained in all these cases: https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22signal%22+AND+%22encrypted%22&type=r&order_by=score+desc&case_name=united+states&description=complaint&page=1 https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22signal%22+AND+%22encrypt...
- c420 3y agoInterception occurs prior to encryption
- scrum-treats 3y agoHow? Is it exploitation of hardware vulnerabilities (e.g., processor vulnerabilities), software vulnerabilities (e.g., apple's webkit vulnerabilities, google chrome + search JS vulnerabilities), or Wifi/Bluetooth vulnerabilities? The only way I can think to intercept prior to encryption would be Key logger, so this would require an already compromised device. Alternatively the government could force a vulnerability state (e.g., the Perseus text message of doom). Is this also your understanding?
- dmbche 3y agoSignal protects your messages while it's on the web, on the way to your recipient. During this time, it is encrypted - but while on your or the recipients device, its plain text (as you can read it). There are many ways to get to those messages, like getting access to your unlocked phone/unlocking your phone, if your signal is not password locked (and if they can't break that password), or doing this with your recipient. OpSec is a process, not single tools!
- flumpcakes 3y ago[flagged]
- funbil 3y agoFunny how all the comments critical of Snowden and his actions are being flagged. No dissent allowed?
- win32k 3y agoGroupthink amongst techies. It's amazing how everyone takes Snowden at his word. Literal traitor and they can't see that he has an agenda.
- scrum-treats 3y agoThe pendulum swings in both directions...
- nyokodo 3y ago[flagged]
- FormerBandmate 3y agoHe was flying to Ecuador and his passport was revoked when he was in Russia. If you speak out against the war in Ukraine in Russia you get shot, and he has a wife and kids now. He's done his part imo
- jki275 3y agoThis is false. His passport had been revoked before he got on the plane. He got on the plane to "Ecuador" on a temporary travel document from Ecuador, knowing he was never getting off anywhere but Moscow. https://apnews.com/article/587786e6e63b4dc2b70c471606d7f584 https://apnews.com/article/587786e6e63b4dc2b70c471606d7f584
- philippejara 3y agofrom your own article: "If a senior official in another country or with an airline orders it, a country could overlook the withdrawn passport, the official said."
- nyokodo 3y ago> He was flying to Ecuador and his passport was revoked when he was in Russia Says who. > If you speak out against Ukraine in Russia you get shot, and he has a wife and kids now. That doesn’t mean he has to pledge allegiance during that period. Regardless it’s not what an American patriot does. That narrative is untenable now.
- throwaway892238 3y agoYears ago, when I interviewed at places that did USG-related work, the stuff I heard about that I didn't have to sign an NDA to hear, scared me enough that I knew Snowden-scale stuff was entirely within the capabilities of the US Govt. I didn't realize they would use it against us just blatantly in direct violation of every law put in place to prevent it, though. I think the lesson I learned from the Snowden leaks is, if the government can do it, the government will do it - if not now, one day soon. That's... kind of a value-changing, life-changing realization. That no law will stop a government from doing what it wants. We can't stop it. But what we can do is install enough peep-holes (transparency) that when it happens, we're more likely to find out about it, so we can do something about it.
- EGreg 3y agoSame with corporations, too: https://community.qbix.com/t/balancing-privacy-and-accountability/215 https://community.qbix.com/t/balancing-privacy-and-accountab... https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=169 https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=169
- passer_byer 3y agoSadly, this seems to be the case. Which means we the people, have lost control of our government.
- freerangebat 3y agoI wonder if historically governments were ever controlled by the people. It seems democracies that can somewhat control the government are extreme outliers in human history.
- dudul 3y agoDemocracy via elected representatives is a lie. "Extreme outliers" may even be too much. Is there even a handful of examples?
- still_grokking 3y ago
- pbj1968 3y agoThe revelations… meh. We all knew it was happening. What I found particularly interesting was he had a distinct look, and either he was a trend setter or following a popular trend amongst young men as I saw it everywhere at the time amongst professionals. I would have thrown away my glasses and gotten a haircut immediately if I had been in that lane. And he was totes a Russian spy.
- DontchaKnowit 3y agoSnowden released an uncinscionably large amount of state secrets far beyind what would have been required to raise flags about surveillance on American citizens. Then he sought asylum in the USAs greatest political enemies? He is a traitor.
- mbg721 3y agoWe got a campaign of "Let's tear down the unelected and unaccountable government agencies," and millions of Americans voted for it. It largely didn't work.
- scrum-treats 3y agoLooks like what we got was more unaccountable government agencies, and a pissing match between FBI and CIA (FBI lost, btw).
- zoogeny 3y agoIn the last ten years technology has increased substantially. In the last five years AI has advanced significantly. That is worth really letting sink in. I try my best to avoid every kind of online discussion on these topics that I reasonably can avoid. Some might even see it as paranoia. But I assume that every single thing I post online (or say on the phone, send in text, or write in emails) is traceable back to me directly, that it is being captured and stored by multiple agencies and countries and that it is all fed into AIs that are at least as capable as GPT-4. Imagine a Gov-GPT where you can ask it: "Tell me everything I need to know about John Smith" and the AI can related his job history, credit score, recent emails at home and work, his phone calls, his purchases, his political opinions, his spiritual beliefs, his likely weaknesses ... all smartly formatted in a succinct essay that we know and love from ChatGPT. My question is, if we aren't there already, how long until we are?
- soraminazuki 3y agoThat's the chilling effect in action and the reason why mass surveillance policies are so undemocratic.
- mkbkn 3y agoJust an example, if you're into the Google ecosystem (which kids are, right from the school days) - it knows almost everything about you, more than your ex-friends and spouse - and combined with Bard or AI, very well... you can now imagine.
- neuronic 3y agoWill Gov-GPT then invent answers and generate a profile that is a potpourri of several random folks details? If you need clear facts without the possibility for r/confidentlyincorrect material then I don't believe GPTs are the tools of choice.
- Aerbil313 3y agoLangchain and such tools can do it.
- epolanski 3y ago
- wrp 3y agoI didn't follow the Snowden story because I don't have the background to evaluate the claims, but there is something I recall that hasn't been discussed yet. Snowden was apparently fairly active as a protester against government surveillance before he got his gig as an NSA contractor. It seems he originally pursued the job with the intention of finding information to leak. If this is true, then a large part of the story should be how it shows the incompetence of the government in doing security checks.
- boomboomsubban 3y ago>Snowden was apparently fairly active as a protester against government surveillance before he got his gig as an NSA contractor. This is a bastardized version of events. Snowden had a number of jobs that required high level clearance from 2006-2013. He supposedly took the final Booz Allen Hamilton job because it had a great deal of access to data, but he had long since passed the security checks necessary to get the job. You can argue that there should be more checks done upon switching jobs, or that people with clearance should face more periodic checks to their current status, but there was no real reason for Snowden to fail the security checks.
- wrp 3y agoSo, was Snowden a visibly active protester against government surveillance before getting the job? If so, did the government fail to notice or did they notice and not care? How extreme should such activity be before it become a "real reason for Snowden to fail the security checks"?
- boomboomsubban 3y agoFirst, you're missing the point. Snowden passed his security checks in 2006, when no one considers him anti-surveillance. That's why he had no real reason to fail any checks. Second, some coworkers afterward the leaks said they thought Snowden had started to act disgruntled towards the industry, but he was never a "visibly active protester against government surveillance." He was an active cog in government surveillance from ~2006 til 2013. You're kind of right that he seemingly only took the Booz Allen Hamilton job to get access to data, but every other detail you're way off on.
- rkagerer 3y agoI'm saddened that ordinary people still don't care enough about their digital privacy.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- win32k 3y agoBasically, few people are able to escape the "Snowden good, US Gov bad" groupthink and really see what happened with Snowden. The guy was a massive traitor that made the US much, much less safe for probably a very long time. Remember US Gov actually DOES care about your rights. The CCP and Putin do NOT. He made the latter much stronger. The revelations didn't even show anything malicious. He basically won the court of opinion with all his interviews and books because his opponent literally can't argue back (would reveal classified info). He sucks, and hopefully more people will come around to it, though I fear the groupthink is too strong.
- scrum-treats 3y agoBy your comments on this thread I am assuming reading comprehension and complex critical thinking are not your strong suits. And that's okay. Do realize that there are people who excel in these areas in which you are so clearly lacking.
- sxhunga 3y agoThe government can do whatever it wants in a non-democratic system. People in this case must use any means to organize themselves to overthrow the government cannot openly violate the rights of citizens because the mechanism of overthrowing the government through protest or votes work
- ganesh7 3y agoWhile we commemorate the violation of privacy of US citizens and others, we should also commemorate the victims of US foreign interventions. There were 251 such interventions in the name of "freedom in democracy" in the last 30 years: https://mronline.org/2022/09/16/u-s-launched-251-military-interventions-since-1991-and-469-since-1798/ https://mronline.org/2022/09/16/u-s-launched-251-military-in... https://sites.evergreen.edu/zoltan/wp-content/uploads/sites/358/2019/11/InterventionsList2019.pdf https://sites.evergreen.edu/zoltan/wp-content/uploads/sites/...
- coding123 3y agoThe stretches that various organizations go through to get people's attention is bizarre. Seriously an RFC? What's next an RFC on jailing Trump?
- c00lio 3y agoThe Snowden revelations had profound consequences on the standardisation process, because mass surveilance was thereby proven as a real and present attack that has to be considered. Undue influence on standardisation processes by the NSA was also a relevant point. Later protocols and standards started to take both into account. All those are in scope for RFCs, there are quite a few about standardisation procedures, circumstances, etc.