11 ms·
Controlled burns can prevent wildfires; regulations make them nearly impossible
- porkbeer 4y agoMany plants also need fires to repopulate. Its a huge issue.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoPine barrens, and specifically the short leaf pine. https://www.fs.usda.gov/features/shortleaf-pine-future-requires-fire https://www.fs.usda.gov/features/shortleaf-pine-future-requi... And if you're into delicious mushrooms, Morels.
- masklinn 4y agoUnless it’s eucalypts, then they’ll eventually get it don’t you worry.
- grumpy-de-sre 4y agoAustralia's revenge for all the invasive species.
- goda90 4y agoOr they need fire to kill off trees that shade them out.
- undersuit 4y agoAhh but replacing old growth forest with burnt out scrub land is not what we necessarily want. Old trees dying and falling naturally creates openings in the canopy to permit new growth without resetting the forest to a grassland like a forest fire would do. A prescribed burn should burn out annual plant growth and leaf litter not perennial plant trunks.
- goda90 4y agoI'm talking about established prairie ecosystems. The plants there depend on saplings to be killed by fires before they become full grown trees, while they can recover from the fires quicker.
- undersuit 4y agoPrairies are formed by the rain shadow of the Rocky Mountains in the United States. They don't need help to beat back water hungry trees.
- dmfdmf 4y agoWay back in the 90's in college I took some elective class (I forget the topic) and the prof had a lecture on how controlled burns prevent wildfires. He also said that govt policy was already limiting controlled burns even then and he predicted that in 20 years, unless the policies changed, that we'd be having giant wildfires and here we are.
- notmypenguin 4y agoGoats emit less co2 than “controlled burns”, and mixed species mature forests don’t have the undergrowth problem commercial cutting cycles entail
- ch4s3 4y agoForests in the US especially on the west coast evolved alongside fire, and burning is how many species propagate in these ecosystems.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoLet me know when you have a goat that will eat thousands of pounds of fallen trees. No offense, but it's fairly clear you have never stepped in the forests that this is a problem. It's not yearly grass. It's 50 years of buildup. You make a 12ft high and 30ft wide pile of this stuff then please tell me about goats. From experience, had a bone fire that lasted three days before it was out.... Goats... Along the same lines, you have an excellent wolf feeding solution, now to find the problem it solves!
- water-your-self 4y agoWith respect to the west coast of the united states this is an absurd proposal.
- dboreham 4y agoFirst eagles, now goats as a device to get out of an awkward plot dead-end.
- EricE 4y ago[flagged]
- masklinn 4y ago[flagged]
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWell I wouldn't go that far to call it disgusting, since the vast majority of human actions probably result in unintended, mostly negative, consequences.
- anonporridge 4y agoAlso see resistance to nuclear fission. Environmentalists have inadvertently shot civilization in the foot and served the interests of the fossil fuel industry by blocking expansion of carbon free nuclear. In exchange, we've spent the last several decades dumping drastically more carbon in the atmosphere than was necessary.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoI'm a little annoyed we're 40 years behind on fusion, because a vocal group spent 40 years crying about fission. Chernobyl was a disaster, that was made possible by the Soviet gov, it was far more a knock on communism than it was nuclear energy. And yet... Here we are with Harvard grads arguing for the former and against the latter.
- squidsoup 4y agoThe Fukushima disaster has the same rating as Chernobyl on the Internation Nuclear Event Scale, and occurred in a highly regulated developed capitalist nation.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoYea, can you imagine if someone said those were the same thing? Good point though, that is what we’re up against.
- stcroixx 4y agoThe only federal regulation I saw referenced in the article were clean air regulations. Otherwise, it appears states and their residents are imposing additional barriers. And public opinion is a local issue of course as well. I don't know if it's really possible to change public ignorance, particularly if the strong opinions are political, so this might be a case where it makes sense for the federal government to step in. We can't just let CO decide to burn themselves to the ground without that decision putting other states at risk. Controlled burns happen regularly in NC on state and federal land.
- D13Fd 4y agoThis was my first thought as well. The title should be "Regulations make them nearly impossible [in Colorado]"
- putnambr 4y agoIt's not Colorado's land to burn, though. Most of the issue is fuels load on federally-managed land.
- jwie 4y agoThis quirk of the west should really be addressed. The feds “own” far too much of the western US.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Sakos 4y agoThe federal government is infinitely better than some local government selling it off to pad their budget for a year or two. Tragedy of the commons.
- putnambr 4y agoUhh, no. Fed just needs to relax regulations around air quality, especially when the thing they're saying no to will improve air quality in the long run. I recreate on our federal lands and can't imagine the same access in state or private hands. State ownership inevitably leads to valuing extraction activities over recreation activities, if not just selling it to the highest bidder (Wilkes Brothers) directly.
- njarboe 4y agoOne of the big problems is that controlled burns can and do become uncontrolled burns. The largest ever wildfire in New Mexico was started as a planned burn (more honest label) just last year. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2022/05/27/new-mexico-wildfire-service-controlled-burn/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2022/05/2...
- BobbyJo 4y agoI'd rather experience frequent uncontrolled burns in areas that do regular controlled burns than even a single uncontrolled burn in an area that doesn't.
- putnambr 4y agoWithout prescribed burns it's only a matter of time until we experience another 'Big Blow Up' - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Fire_of_1910 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Fire_of_1910
- bo1024 4y agoOf course, this is discussed in the article.
- WhatsTheBigIdea 4y agoAll of the Rangers and CalFire people I know never call them "controlled burns". Rather they call then "prescribed burns"... for exactly this reason.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoMake no mistake about just how much money is involved here. I got to work on a helicopter used for fire. It was a 1980s French something or another. It took an RPG in Afganistan and was refurbed to live in the pacific northwest. The crew makes an insane amount of money. They are tickled with how many fires there are a year and how they "have" to be put out. I'm talking areas so far away from houses that it takes an hour to get there by helo, dump a few buckets, then an hour back. MAYBE in a 9 hour shift you get 12 buckets dumped. This vehicle has only one turbine engine and goes through about 300 gallons an hour. There were two blackhawks in the same area that burn twice that, two engines. Think of the money to make it not only profitable, but exceptionally so, to run vehicles that burn 300 gallons an hour for 8-12 hours a day, per helo, per engine, with crew, and the millions it costs to upkeep, cert, logistics, insurance, etc. This is business now. And that's just one annecdote about helos. When you see people and machinery it takes to run firecrews, it's a wonder there aren't even more firecrew arsonists than there already are.
- anonporridge 4y agoThis illustrates a more generic problem with our legal system. When the option for positive action to mitigate a problem exists, we often don't do it because the action creates legal liability for any and all negative externalities of the action, even if the negative externalities as a whole are drastically less than what would happen doing nothing. We resist permitting prescribed burns because when they cause unintended damage and harm, there's a person to institution to blame, so no one wants to take on that liability. So instead, we let brush grow out of control and eventually a mega fire hits that creates orders of magnitude more destruction and health hazard than the sum of all prescribed burns ever would have. Another example is medical treatment. If you develop cancer and die because you get no treatment, there's no person to blame and no one to sue. It's just an "act of god" so people accept the outcome and move on. But if you get treatment and the doctors make a mistake and their actions cause some unintended harm, then there's someone to blame and sue, even if your statistical outcome was drastically improved by their intervention. The same problem is going to exist trying to mitigate climate change. Positive actions to reverse the problem will create negative externalities that hurt some people, but doing nothing will be drastically worse. I don't know how we solve this problem. To me, the root of the problem seems to be a weakness of the constitution of our society and/or leaders. Collectively, we need to figure out how to balance diffuse statistical risk against acute, dramatic risk, or else we all risk being the frog slowly boiled alive.
- jackphilson 4y agoAnd this just generalizes to the recurring problem of individualism vs collectivism. Government regulation is the answer, but it's not being applied efficiently here
- vuln 4y ago> Government regulation is the answer, but it's not being applied efficiently here Do you have any examples of Government Regulations that are applied efficiently and do not cause harm to any individuals?
- 4y ago
- motohagiography 4y agoThis 'controlled burn' issue is a general principle in risk management as well, where you respond to minor issues so as to not let them pile up into a tinderbox inferno. Risk aversion isn't prudent, ethical, or professional either. It's a source of false conflict whose purpose is to centralize the objector so that they can direct and manage a proposed change. This is from someone who has been working in security for longer than most. It's something I find repulsive about some of the people who have joined the field, where once it was hackers who used elevated competence to judiciously take risks, and now it's authoritarian personalities who use affected fear and appeals to uncertainty under the guise of safety to position themselves as gatekeepers. The same is true for government policy on controlled burns. Nobody ever gets fired over mega wildfires, even though their gatekeeping is the direct cause of them.
- anoncow 4y agoI think the equivalent analogy here is to prevent a big issue from occurring, management creates small issues that it can control. Or do I have it wrong? If you handle small issues, it’s similar to handling small fires and not letting the small fires eat away at a certain portion of the forest.
- thanatos519 4y agoRight. The small issues are minor outages causing customer inconvenience and/or lost revenue. The big issues are major pwnage and loss of everything because you were afraid of causing small issues while fixing things.
- anoncow 4y agoThat makes a lot of sense. By allowing the teams to fix things quickly and break things, management creates an environment where people can continuously learn how to handle fires and this makes them ready to handle bigger fires and also prevent bigger fires.
- 4y ago
- ldom22 4y agoI thought only you can prevent wildfires
- bluGill 4y agoSure, but I have known for several decades that I shouldn't. That slogan was already being questioned when Regan was president.
- exabrial 4y agoThey also destroy invasive species: plants, animals, bugs. Native species evolved long ago to deal with fire. Research has also shown its net carbon negative.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoIntuitively I’d guess the carbon is net negative because so many forests require fire in order to differentiate strong, durable trees from weaker ones, which then opens the canopy, returns nutrients to the soil, and creates conditions more like we see in old growth forests which are able to store absolutely massive amounts of carbon compared to young (even very dense) forests. Not only that but they store water better, too. They’re less likely to burn as they stay wetter later in the dry season and hold onto rain and atmospheric moisture far better. Cutting down old forests was a much worse idea than anyone would have guessed.
- exabrial 4y ago> Cutting down old forests was a much worse idea than anyone would have guessed. It's species dependent.. Cutting down trees that take 250 years to mature probably isn't sustainable for example. However, logging can be a carbon negative practice if done with correct practices and the correct species. You're literally taking the mass of the air and turning it into a useful building material. I'll try to find a source
- jonnycomputer 4y agoWhy wouldn't non-native species also be adapted for fire?
- exabrial 4y agoThey’re not from there and there’s no evolutionary pressure to maintain traits that they don’t experience in their home habit.
- jonnycomputer 4y ago
- fooker 4y ago> Regulations make them nearly impossible That is equivalent to saying sulphuric acid kills cancer. While true, it does other things too like kill normal cells. Likewise, broadly scoped regulation can hamper freedom and prevent people from doing otherwise harmless activities. Worse, it paves the way for selective enforcement. Think about federally mandated drugs regulation and how that is abused by biased authorities.
- tikkun 4y agoI like controlled burns as an analogy, too. The US economy needed more controlled burns and small "fires" - eg restricting spending back a long time ago when that could've been done without major consequences, unlike now. Similarly, as a parent, allowing your child to experience small failures so that they are less at risk of big failures. Small failures that don't cause ruin = increased strength. Reminds me of the antifragility concepts.
- fwungy 4y agoTry cutting down trees on your forested property in California. Environmental regulations can make that really tricky. California should have regular wildfires. It's part of the ecosystem. Government regulations that prevent fires have created the tinder box we have now.
- sosodev 4y agoLiving in Southern California is frustrating in that way. It's obvious that the plants here are adapted for regular fires. The native people of this area knew the importance of controlled burns and had incorporated them into their tradition. They likely were doing controlled burns for thousands of years before their lives were disrupted.
- foxyv 4y agoI think the most frustrating aspect of California is the capricious interpretation of laws. There isn't a clear way to ensure compliance. Louis Rossmann did a pretty good job demonstrating a similar issue with New York and the LeadsOnline reporting requirements. Often the people responsible for enforcing the laws, don't even know what the laws are and will often err on the side of fining people. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yi8_9WGk3Ok&pp=ygUjbG91aXMgcm9zc21hbm4gTGVhZHNPbmxpbmUgZGF0YWJhc2U%3D https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yi8_9WGk3Ok&pp=ygUjbG91aXMgc...
- uoaei 4y agoTrees are not the problem, it's scrub and grasses. You're right, regulations are way out of step with current understanding.
- anoncow 4y agoRelevant post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35081218 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35081218
- everythingfine 4y agoI'd like to point out that this problem can technically be solved by a well-meaning arsonist who's willing to break the law. Simply send a public message to fire departments naming the date and location that a forest fire will start, let the fire departments prepare like they would for a controlled burn, and then set off the blaze. There's some difficulty involved with establishing sufficient credibility for this to work, but it's a weird case where illegal action can accomplish things that operating within the legal system cannot.
- markusde 4y agoAn extremely brief google search tells me that controlled burns require firebreaks, knowledge of the wind patterns (something called a downwind backfire?) and presumably continued monitoring/support from firefighters to actually be a controlled burn over the area that needs it. I think what you're describing is a total fantasy.
- bluGill 4y agoThe only controlled burn is one that happens regularly. You cannot start with a controlled burn after years of suppression as there is too much fuel. You have to "rip the band-aid off". That is evacuate the whole state, and then start the whole state on fire at once. If you want your house to survive, then you use the warning to clear all the trees/bush around your house so it isn't close to the fire (this is easy to say, impossible to pull off).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Maciek416 4y agoThis is not really true, and if you'd like to learn more than you ever wanted to know about this topic then you should start following Zeke Lunder from The Lookout and review some of his wildfire analysis videos on YouTube. He often talks about the idea of "good fire". Not all fire is "good fire". A lot of megafires, the kind that might be sparked by an arson technique ignorant of modern wildfire management practices, do not necessarily lead to "good fire". They may at certain stages (especially when wind dies down) exhibit some traits of "good fire", but for the most part, these are forests that are the way they are due to too much suppression for too long, and now require "good fire" if our goal is to still have a healthy forest after the fire. An arson that starts a megafire is going to potentially transition to a very different type of forest, or an un-forested wasteland, as seen in various places in the Sierra foothills and SoCal.
- kyleblarson 4y agoI live in a remote area in Washington State and we have many controlled burns every spring and fall. https://methowvalleynews.com/2023/03/29/methow-valley-ranger-district-plans-prescribed-burns-this-spring https://methowvalleynews.com/2023/03/29/methow-valley-ranger...
- agentultra 4y agoAlong the North Eastern coastal regions of North America the predominant biome before European settlers began colonizing the region in earnest was the oak savanna: an ecological system dependent on fires. After those settlers arrived they took steps to prevent those fires from affecting their towns and inadvertently by clearing land for farming. The result are forests that are choked with under brush, mass migrations of animals, the spread of parasitic insects, etc. Completely changed the character of the region.
- hedgehog 4y agoI spent some time talking about this with a family member that works in forestry. My takeaway was that the core issues are 1) it's labor intensive and expensive to manage the burns, beyond what we have budget for now, 2) there's a liability+harm issue to work through (e.g. when a burn will necessarily put a lot of smoke into an inhabited area how do you manage that), and 3) the combination of climate change and many years of fire suppression mean that doing the burns safely is harder than it was say 50 years ago. It's really a political issue, that is to get broad support to spend more and have worse quality of life for a while in order to get the situation under control and in much better shape a decade down the line. Tough sell.
- atomize 4y agoAll controlled burns have to happen with government regulation for obvious reasons. Fire ecology and the legislation that regulates it in practice (read: research and it's influence on controlled burn methods) revolves mainly around constant disputes between agriculture and conservation efforts. This even winds all the way down to the age-old dispute about grazing cattle on public lands out west. Grazing on public lands leads to a reduction of fuel for natural wildfires in heavily grazed areas, leading to an imbalance in the natural fire cycle, causing the need to do controlled burns in the interest of human habitat and the economy rather than ecology. This ultimately causes a disruption is various parts of the ecosystem. In the high desert of Nevada, California, and other fire prone states that also are the home of agriculture that depends on grazing livestock, this issue is hot, no pun intended, and there is a constant dialogue going on between regulators and scientists researching land management methods in habitat where wildfire is not only necessary, but essential.
- thecosas 4y agoOriginal article on ProPublica: https://www.propublica.org/article/colorado-wildfires-controlled-burns-marshall-fire https://www.propublica.org/article/colorado-wildfires-contro...
- wcarron 4y agoHere in Flagstaff and NAZ we've been getting hit hard by huge wildfires. The amount of fuel in these forests is mindblowing, and terrain is often a big challenge, too. Luckily, we had a heavy monsoon season last year and a brutal winter. So much water that roads/levees have broken and lakes that are normally dry beds were overflowing. This has abated the normally horrible winds of April/May. This wet and abnormally calm weather has allowed for some action and I'm beyond pleased to have seen numerous prescribed burns in the forests around town this year. I really hope they can keep it up and treat a few thousand more acres before conditions turn. The forest service seems like it does a good job here with fuel and flood management. There are still pockets of land that are wayyyy overladen/undertreated but much of the area, especially near town has been treated with thinning and slash and burn piles. Unfortunately, the logging industry here is deteriorating and one of the longest-running operators closed shop. A few factors contributed to this, including the failure to open an OSB plant in Winslow, and the closure of a local mill just before the turn of the millenium. A damn shame, as logging ops really bolster the ability of the FS to manage fires.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoInterestingly enough, a large water event before doesn't mean a mild fire season. In more northern areas, a lot of snow and water means a lot of grass, and that grass will dry out by August. It's not kindling, but it's the paper.
- wcarron 4y agoYeah, we're all pretty concerned about that. We'll see if we get another heavy monsoon season to dampen the potential for big fires midsummer. Fingers crossed. Unfortunately, we've got a bunch of events coming up that are going to draw big numbers of off-roaders and 'overlanders' who are, imo, some of the worst and least responsible recreators. Some of us are bracing for fires being started by them.
- dylan604 4y agoJust this week, there was a post here about an invasive plant in the Sonoma desert that has taken off this season because of the extra rain, and this is one of their concerns outside of it being invasive. It's just going to be fuel for any fires that might start.
- paulorlando 4y agoThe US Forest Service was started in 1905 in part to reduce forest fires. The result of that policy was forests with a much higher tree density than naturally occurred otherwise. Other changes include that around 1900 settlers of the western US introduced livestock that ate grass, which in turn removed potential fuel for smaller fires, and enabled smaller trees to grow. After a hundred years of fire prevention, you end up with very different forest density. As the fire manager of Santa Fe National Forest noted: “On this forest, it’s averaging about 900 trees per acre. Historically it was probably about 40.” The result is a much bigger fire risk than previously. https://unintendedconsequenc.es/morals-of-the-moment/ https://unintendedconsequenc.es/morals-of-the-moment/
- foxyv 4y agoI wonder how much of the wildfires are caused by lack of wildlife. The city I grew up in used livestock to manage brush every year. There were herds of goats and sheep that would go through in the spring and summer to make sure that brush growth was trimmed to the roots. I wonder if we stopped killing wildlife wholesale if we would see reductions in this overgrowth. Although I wonder if any native species would be able to handle the insane numbers of Russian Thistle/Tumbleweeds.
- thescriptkiddie 4y agoReading the actual article, it seems like the problem isn't regulation, it is complaints from locals.
- jrs235 4y agoWe have, what seems like, quartely prescribed burns in the Florida panhandle.
- photochemsyn 4y agoSounds like this is the issue: > "Also included in the prescription are optimal weather conditions, including a minimum temperature for burns in grass and brush of 30 degrees and a maximum of 80 degrees; relative humidity between 5% and 40%; and wind speed between 2 mph and 15 mph. Such conditions are becoming rarer." If you broaden the acceptable range of conditions, you risk more prescribed burns going out of control, and you generate more air quality issues - and Colorado, like the California Central Valley, has some pretty bad air quality already: https://www.cpr.org/2022/04/12/front-range-air-quality-ozone-violations-epa/ https://www.cpr.org/2022/04/12/front-range-air-quality-ozone... Note that prescribed fires aren't the only way of removing excess vegetation, there's mechanized mowing and goat herds for example.
- petsfed 4y ago>Note that prescribed fires aren't the only way of removing excess vegetation, there's mechanized mowing and goat herds for example. Which works fine for the areas east of the Flatirons (that is, the plains), but that's only half the county. A real problem for wildfire management is that they often happen in areas that we consider undevelopable, which is to say, difficult to get into and out of. I recall going climbing in Boulder Canyon some decades ago, looking up at some burn scars and thinking "it would be several hundred feet of technical climbing to even reach where that fire occurred". Fighting it would be simply out of the question, and prevention without controlled burns would be just as difficult.
- freitzkriesler2 4y agoControlled burns and prescriptive cullings of deer do wonders. Honestly, the fools that prevent these end up suffering when fires and deer accidents jump up.
- variant 4y agoFar bigger contributor to wildfires than "climate change."
- qxxx 4y agoI was reading "Controlled burps help prevent wildfires"... time to go to bed.
- oatmeal1 4y agoIf only there were some good samaritans who would toss lit cigarettes out of their cars in the spring...
- pvaldes 4y ago...then we would have a case of environmental terrorism. Terrorists like Gary Maynard, Alexandra Souverneva, Viola Liu... 800 wildfires in California in 2022 were arsons.
- oatmeal1 4y agoTerrorism is used to influence politics. This would be simply to achieve a practical result of a healthier forest, so it would not be terrorism.
- pvaldes 4y agoFirst, why are you sure that this didn't influenced elections results? 100 people killed or still missing. Many killed only in one wildfire by the mud floods that came later. Helicopter pilots and firefighters killed. More than 13500 homes and human structures destroyed only in 2020 and 2021. Not all fires were deliberated, but too much wildfires were deliberated to be statistically random. We'll never know how much of them were attacks. A few people managed to spread chaos in entire villages, forced the authorities to evacuate tens of thousands of people, nuked the local budgets, and introduced a lot of tension in the economy and society. And it cost them practically nothing. And I'm not talking about the people killed and injured, or the natural resources lost (like millions of liters of freshwater stored in the area that were lost and have some, non negligible, economical value). "Maynard's fires were placed in the perfect position to increase the risk of firefighters being trapped between fires" [1] If this is not terrorism, nothing is. Don't fool yourself. The only difference between a "non cleaned" and a "cleaned" forest (whatever it means), is that the terrorist will carry its own can of gas. [1] https://www.npr.org/2021/08/11/1026700103/former-college-professor-arson-charges-california-dixie-fire https://www.npr.org/2021/08/11/1026700103/former-college-pro...
- BurningFrog 4y agoIt's time to regulate all these regulations!
- pvaldes 4y agoWe should put in the air as many CO2 as possible, yep. What could go wrong?. This valuable fertile soil that need 200 years to build and all the CO2 accumulated must be released... because religious thinking. Or we could try something different and jail the arsonists. Respect the soil and let the forest accumulate water and include thousands of new species.
- MrVandemar 4y agoWhile it seems wildly counter-intuitive, burning, done properly is usually a net carbon increase. Many, many ecosystems require fire for their life-cycles. Without reasonably regular fires, some species can go extinct. The soil fertility, for example, in Australia is so poor, and there's not enough moisture for fungi etc to break down the leaf-litter, that unless there is a fire valuable nutrients remain unavailable and it impedes growth.
- henearkr 4y agoCompletely agree.
- londons_explore 4y agoDo we have understanding of fire frequency naturally? ie. how many years, on average, between fires on a given bit of land? If we do, then it seems to make sense to try to maintain the same frequency - that, I assume, would be best for the plants and animals which have adapted to that.
- mrangle 4y agoControlled burns are a single example of the uncountable things that humans have always had to do to maintain what is good for everyone and animals, but which come to be targeted by loud people who see a path to personal gain by making them a political issue. Presenting solutions as problems is explained as being more civilized, but it is less. Animal population management is another example.
- joe_the_user 4y agoThe fundamental problem that controlled burns face today is that there has been a huge and irresponsible increase in development on "Urban-wildland border". Here in the California Sierras, you have a uniform peppering of (often luxury) houses outside of the various small urban areas. Those forests naturally burn on a regular basis but with this situation, any controlled burn is going to threaten some number of houses. Of course, the regular fires threaten and destroy these areas too. We've seen the destruction of Paradise, Berry Creek, Greenville, and Grizzly Flats in the last few years (just reading from Wikipedia). Edit: Always need to mention that global-warming/climate-change makes this worse even if it was caused by local irresponsible behavior. Of course what climate hits first are areas where the local ecology already had problems (In before "It's not [Local bad behavior], it's climate change" or the opposite).
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis is not the fundamental problem. The fundamental problem is that fires were suppressed for nearly 200 years and now turn into raging infernos. Fires were suppressed first for economic reasons, and then later for misguided Environmental reasons Forest fires of a historically typical magnitude would pose much less Danger to communities adjacent to wildlands. This is further complicated by the fact that any of these communities and dwellings were not designed for fire resistance because public policy at the time was no fires ever.
- joe_the_user 4y agoIt depends how you want to put. Fire suppression is indeed the fundamental cause and the shape of development is the barrier to fixing it.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't think I agree that the distribution of development poses a significant challenge. If that were the case, you would see at least some controlled Burns in undeveloped areas, but that is not the case. You might see more logging or a small low risk Burns near inhabitated areas. The fact that we still see essentially no control burns is strong evidence that the barrier is Still what it has been for the last 100 years. Bad government policy informed by Environmental emotion instead of environmental science. At the end of the day, the rationale is stupid but simple. People don't like the Aesthetics of a burn Forest for the smell of smoke in the air. Actual risk to life and property from controlled Burns can be effectively minimized. In some areas of the state they never existed in the first place and still don't exist The solution isn't rocket science. You just start with small safe Burns adjacent to communities. Nobody wants to look at a burn scar for several years, so instead they roll the dice on their Community burning down
- prvc 4y agoDid not the current wildfires in Alberta, Canada start with an attempted "controlled burn" gone awry?
- DannyBee 4y agoSo? Just because a process sometimes fails does not mean the solution is to change the process, and if you do, it doesn't mean the result will end up better overall. Expected value and all that.
- prvc 4y agoAlso, it's not clear why burning should be used instead of, say, selective logging, or some other manual method of moving the material somewhere other than into the atmosphere.
- MrVandemar 4y agoMany ecosystems require fire. Fire is natural and plants and animals are adapted to it. So much so, that if you don't burn (or equally you burn too often) you can wind up making some species extinct. "Selective logging" I'm afraid is not remotely an effective way to control fire. The fuel loads are often not the trees, but the leaf litter, shrubs, bushes and so on.
- pkrein 4y agoWildfires.org is doing really awesome work on unblocking and accelerating environmental review and planning for all kinds of wildfire prevention treatments.
- ListenLinda 4y agoA few years back CA had serious wild fire issues. PG&E was just the scapegoat. There are multiple factors but the main issue is that it's nearly impossible to get the environmental documentation (Environmental Impact Statements or EISs) prepared and approved for prescribed burns on federal land due to legal challenges from environmental groups that really have no idea what they are doing. The system is broken.
- uoaei 4y agoDo you have any sources for this? I am familiar with people who manage private properties on federal lands and nothing you said here passes the smell test to me. In particular, environmental groups have been loudly calling for better wildland management practices for at least the past decade, typically from the direction of considering and adopting indigenous land management practices such as prescribed burns. It sounds like you're trying to scapegoat environmentalists when the recent tragedies were obviously the fault of PG&E mis-managing their assets and refusing to allocate more budget or personnel to manage what are obviously tinderbox scenarios.
- ListenLinda 3y agohttps://www.perc.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/PERC-PolicyBrief-NEPA-Web.pdf https://www.perc.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/PERC-PolicyB... The litigation is primarily from environmental groups.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoOne approach that I found interesting, and that is gaining momentum in British Columbia is the championing of a first nations indigenous "fire keeper" "cultural burning" movement: https://prescribedfire.ca/cultural-burning/ https://prescribedfire.ca/cultural-burning/ http://nationnews.ca/community/fire-keepers-bring-back-cultural-burning-traditions/ http://nationnews.ca/community/fire-keepers-bring-back-cultu... It especially makes sense in the context of BC where pretty much the whole province is actually unceded first nations territory; the indigenous groups there never signed it away to the Crown like they did here in Upper Canada.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoFirefighter here. I support controlled burns because they're the only sensible way to manage large amounts of excess fuel in the western U.S. The problem is that there have been several occasions where frankly stupid mistakes were made by burn personnel and planners (e.g. not completely extinguishing previous fires [1] and going forward with a burn when the wind was clearly too high [2]) resulting in huge amounts of property damage and in some cases loss of life. This is why we now have to deal with a ton of regulations. Some wildfires will always happen when controlled burns get out of control and it's nobody's fault, but we need to decrease the number of them that are the direct result of somebody doing something very stupid. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calf_Canyon/Hermits_Peak_Fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calf_Canyon/Hermits_Peak_Fire [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerro_Grande_Fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerro_Grande_Fire
- henearkr 4y agoBecause of some careless or stupid humans, throwing cig butts and whatnot, the forests are endangered, and the burden of avoiding fires should be by the forest itself? I don't like it. What about surveil forests with drones. I'm sure that will help people hold their sh*t together and be responsible of their actions. I'm sure wildfires will drop drastically.
- 3littlefish 4y agoAbsolutely terrifying. We have major fires in rural Spain in the Summer months, especially as it's getting drier earlier every year. We've had a huge issue with the grass verges not getting cut in time, before everything dries out. Then people throw cigarettes ends out of their cars on the motorway and the whole area goes up in flames. It's a mixture of risk factors, environmental, council/planning, and some personal responsibility.
- Consultant32452 4y agoControlled burns are dangerous and people die doing it at unfortunate rates. This is just one of many reasons why controlled burns are difficult, even if they are a net life saver.
- lenkite 4y agoKind funny that Trump was excoriated for mentioning this very fact - that the Californian wildfires were happening due to good forest management practices being prevented by bad environmental laws.