19 ms·
Large-scale study reveals autoimmune disorders now affect around one in ten
- nestorD 4y agoHere is a link to the actual paper (it appears that they forgot to link to it in the article): https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(23)00457-9/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- jemmyw 4y agoSo are they increasing or are we just figuring them out more and living longer and keeping more kids alive? I've got a spinal arthritis condition that didn't start until I was mid 30s and it's not a new condition but the thinking around it has changed substantially. Edit: the consultant I saw said I probably wouldn't get diagnosed 20 years ago when she started. I had trouble convincing my doctor it could be this condition. I'd never have known about it unless I'd mentioned it to my mum who told me my sister (who I don't have contact with) has this quite severely and it took her 10 years to get a diagnosis and access to helpful drugs.
- epgui 4y agoTheir incidence/prevalence has mostly been increasing (this is known), but yes we are also diagnosing them better.
- explorer83 4y agoThis study was published from a journal that got caught publishing a questionable study on a major health issue a few years ago that they later had to retract. This was despite their reputation of being one of the best and peer-reviewed. So I don't blame you for questioning it. But I'm a parent with children with issues. And everything we study from other very mainstream sources says their issues are on the rise. These are issues that you can't ignore or not recognize.
- johnnymorgan 4y agoLove how you framed this, also a parent with a kid with issues. All issues are rising, the whole 'we are just smarter now' is hubris, we really are not.
- Grimblewald 4y agoabsolutely, technology changes but people don't. It is precisely because of technology that we aren't changing, that is its entire point.
- throwaway290 4y agoWait, are you saying humans would be evolving if not for technology? Interesting take...
- nverno 4y agoAlways evolving, but technology has surely influenced natural selection - a lot of illnesses/conditions that might have killed people prior to them reproducing are no longer factors in that regard
- gnz11 4y agoWe're altering the environment rapidly. Environment has a large influence on gene expression. Not a biologist but that is more likely the reason.
- Grimblewald 4y agopretty much - we don't adapt our form to our environment, rather when a problem arises we develop a technology that removes the discomfort we feel, which would otherwise act as an adaptation driving pressure. We develop our tech such that any segment can be readily learned as an isolated component, and as such our memory isn't under pressure to improve. We outsource memory to digital storage, and so there is even an allowance for memory to shrink. Overall, all our tech looks at helping us not have to change, grow, or adapt. We want to live a life of comfort but comfort means no pressure and no pressure means no adaptation reinforcement of advantageous mutations, since what is most advantageous is being average in every way.
- Panzer04 4y agoI recall somewhere that due to us getting better at protecting people from pathogens, immune systems get “less practice” at identifying friend from foe, increasing the likelihood of contracting an autoimmune disorder down the line. I have no idea how accurate that is, but it’s what over heard.
- fnord77 4y agothis is the "hygiene hypothesis" and there is a correlation but nobody has shown causation. it was popular 10 years ago but other models have become more prominent
- miriam_catira 4y agoPersonal anecdote: I have Graves disease, and it didn't flare up until a couple years after I finished immune therapy for a variety of severe allergies. The allergies are much better! But my immune system got bored, or something. Correlation vs causation though... causation makes a lot of sense when living it, but it's not proof. I'm also quite certain my great-grandmother had this same thing, but no would have been able to diagnose her as anything but excessively thin back then. (It severely increases your metabolism and can cause osteoporosis.)
- odyssey7 4y agoIt could be true for some of them, but it's also possible that "autoimmune" is not a very good description of what's happening for some others. Disorders lacking an obvious cause seem to get lumped into the autoimmune category whenever the symptoms are related to inflammation. Before modern medicine, these disorders might have been masked by or passed as a milder form of tuberculosis or something else. It's still possible that there are pathogens involved that haven't been identified.
- Amezarak 4y agoLife expectancy after age 5 has not budged much over the centuries, though you’ll find most graphs begin at a trough circa 1900. Prior to that it was about the same as it is now in many countries. So “we’re living longer” is not the answer, it probably has much more to do with the massive amounts of new chemicals and pollutants we’ve exposed ourselves to. No barriers to transport along with unrestrained trade and frequent migration also mean were exposed to way more pathogens than we evolved to encounter, so some of them could also be blowback from legitimate immune responses.
- jemmyw 4y agohttps://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortality-life-expectancy-improved-at-all-ages https://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortalit... has life expectancies for age ranges from 1841 and shows a huge difference for a 5 year old. If conditions get worse with age then the average going from 55 to 82 (from age 5) could hide a lot of data about these disorders.
- Amezarak 4y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19440443/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19440443/ > Analysis of the mid-Victorian period in the U.K. reveals that life expectancy at age 5 was as good or better than exists today, and the incidence of degenerative disease was 10% of ours. You see this basically throughout history except in very bad times like famine or major plagues, or were there is persistent dietary issues as we introduced in the late 19thc, or early on in the switch to farming. Rural areas also tend to do better than urban.
- hattar 4y agoSpondylitis? I’m curious mostly because I received a similar story and diagnosis, but over the last 5-10 years have had multiple doctors second guess what may be affecting me.
- jemmyw 4y agoYes. Once my mum told me to get a test for the HLA-B27 gene, which was positive, my doctor referred me, while still being doubtful. Consultant didn't second guess at all, she looked over my x-ray and family history and said it was pretty clear. It might seem like bad news but it's such a massive relief knowing and having a path forward treatment wise as I get older.
- dfinninger 4y agoI’ve had as AS diagnosis for over a decade now and it was definitely a relief. Just having a name for why I wasn’t “normal”. Why everyone around was able to just do so much more than I could. That this was a real thing, I’m not somehow faking it, and there’s someone who can help. I wish you luck and hope you find some physical relief as well!
- tehjoker 4y agoThey are increasing due to COVID. A recent study found a 40% increase in risk after infection. https://www.livescience.com/covid-19-linked-to-40-increase-in-autoimmune-disease-risk-in-huge-study https://www.livescience.com/covid-19-linked-to-40-increase-i...
- 6nf 4y agoDo we see the same thing in unvaccinated populations? Like the Amish or PNG or African countries that has super low uptake?
- tehjoker 4y agoNot sure, but the difference between a measured amount of bound spike protein and an uncontrolled amount of fully functional spike + other evil proteins like those derived from orf8 and orf6 means I fully expect the virus to be the main problem here.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- 6nf 4y agoI don’t know if you know this but the vaccine is not a measured amount of bound spike protein at all. It’s mRNA that gets transcribed over and over - each mRNA molecule creates many spikes. Exactly how many depends on many factors in your body. When I’m at a PC again I will link you to some studies showing cases where it exceeds the amount you’d expect in a natural infection and there’s documented cases where it continues weeks after injection unlike the virus which doesn’t last that long in healthy young people.
- tehjoker 4y agoThat's fair, but it's a fixed amount of RNA and RNA degrades. The virus can continually create new RNA. COVID has been shown to persist in a fraction of patients, so it will continue for months or years. I don't see how these situations are comparable. Again, the vaccine spike is edited to be bound in the pre-fusion conformation whereas the natural spike is flexible and can bind to ACE2 and expose additional internal inflammatory sites. https://cen.acs.org/pharmaceuticals/vaccines/tiny-tweak-behind-COVID-19/98/i38 https://cen.acs.org/pharmaceuticals/vaccines/tiny-tweak-behi... "Young, healthy people" makes enormous assumptions about a tiny slice of the population. After one or more COVID infections, they may acquire the dreaded "co-morbidities" that a huge fraction if not a majority or supermajority of the population have. Despite how we like to think we have personal control over our circumstances, in this situation, we do not. It is a collective effort and we are failing to control transmission. Vaccines are part of this, as are masking with N95 respirators, testing, air cleaning, paid sick leave, scientific isolation and quarantine periods, etc. I am hopeful that with targeted or universal air cleaning combined with partial population immunity (maintained via periodic vaccine updates) and paid leave, we can push the reproduction number below one. This is a very serious crisis that is worsening in some ways, but we are acting like the physical environment has no bearing on our lives if we think positively.
- zackees 4y ago[dead]
- sandworm101 4y agoI have osgood schlatter syndrome, basically a bone growth on the knee. Had it for decades but not diagnosed until 30s during physical for new job. Zero impacts. No pain. No limitations. No issues whatsoever. But I do have a named syndrome that, in years past, would never have been noticed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Miner49er 4y agoI know one study found celiac is increasing, not just being diagnosed more (although it is also being diagnosed more). I'm not sure of other autoimmune diseases. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090701082911.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090701082911.h...
- ksaun 4y agoAnother example of an autoimmune disease that has been becoming more common (not just more frequently diagnosed) is type 1 diabetes (T1D). (From March, 2020): https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7146037/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7146037/ (Increased diagnostic capability seems unlikely to be a factor in T1D's prevalence -- when it is triggered, untreated T1D leads to obvious and serious symptoms (eventually death through ketoacidosis) over the course of months. It's not something you can just ignore and power through; treatment is required to survive.)
- zug_zug 4y agoI looked into this a while back, and I believe there are a number of different autoimmune conditions that are definitely going up with no cause known (corroborated by multiple studies). One is linked I also am a bit troubled by how quick people are to dismiss such studies. I think people are operating off of a prior of "big shifts in health don't just happen," which in my opinion is a demonstrably false prior. I think the default prior should be "We're in completely new health waters, testing in production, anything is possible and problems are known and not explained." In particular nobody can explain why eyesight is getting drastically worse. Obesity in the developed world is a big unknown (I think even lab rats weigh more). I believe there's consistent evidence of allergies increasing. And the balance of evidence is that sperm counts are going down, but for whatever reason I think people assume that's a conspiracy theory or just are afraid to believe it. [1] https://www.academia.edu/download/40579191/ijcd-3-4-8.pdf https://www.academia.edu/download/40579191/ijcd-3-4-8.pdf
- tremon 4y agoWhat level of evidence do you require for those explanations? Because all three observations you mention have credible theories, some even have partial proofs. nobody can explain why eyesight is getting drastically worse The prevailing theory has to do with lack of exercise of the eyeball, i.e. children spend too much time indoors locked at a single viewing depth; children who spend more time in the outdoors tend to have better eyesight. In China they're running broad studies which seem to indicate that children's eyesight stops deteriorating when exposed to more bright daylight: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT05156190 https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT05156190 Obesity in the developed world is a big unknown Sugary/unbalanced foods and sedentary lifestyles? The proofs we have go as far to document the entire systemic changes that ultimately lead to insulin resistance: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6471380/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6471380/ sperm counts are going down There's suspected links to endocrine-disruptive pesticides, but FAFAIK no proven mechanisms.
- krackers 4y agoAlso wearing glasses when they're not needed. Your eyes will adapt to the accommodative stress presented. If you look at a screen all day, you'll end up with a power of roughly -2 assuming you don't wear any glasses looking at your screen, since your eyes have adapted to treat that 2 feet as optical infinity so it can remain in focus without any accommodation needed. If you then go ahead and wear prescribed glasses for close-work where they are not needed, you again restart the process. Interestingly it has been found that only periphery matters for this process, that's how those fancy glasses like Hoya Miyosmart work, by intentionally defocusing the periphery.
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoThe hygiene hypothesis is pretty well proven now as far as I know. Its the idea that early childhood exposure to various germs is important to tune the immune system correctly. It atleast partially explains the rise of autoimmunity. From the wiki: The rise of autoimmune diseases and acute lymphoblastic leukemia in young people in the developed world was linked to the hygiene hypothesis.
- zpeti 4y agoI wonder how our global lifestyle affects this too. You might have had a really dirty childhood in the UK and adapted to all the dirt and toxins there, but then you take a job in Nevada or something and you don’t have childhood immunity to anything there. I’d love a study done on autoimmune disease prominence in expats vs local populations.
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoHeres one: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31351784/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31351784/
- giantg2 4y agoI think this is a true increase, but don't have anything to back this up. One major reason it might be increasing is our increasingly sterile world. Less exposure to nature, animals, etc , especially as children, might be preventing proper immune function. I also wonder about chemical exposures - food additives, vaccine adjuvants, manufacturing chemicals, etc. Although I think many of those suppress immune function rather than increase it. It is interesting that we don't know how some of these work, but use them anyways. For example, we don't know the mechanisms for vaccine adjuvant work. There's a theory about molecular size, and we know they increase immune response. There's a lot we don't know about the immune system in general.
- oigursh 4y agoIf only my immune system would attack all the microplastics in my blood.
- ars 4y agoThat would be horrible for your health. Massive inflammation and hormonal issues. Best is if your body ignores the plastic, that would mean the plastic doesn't do anything to you.
- throwaway290 4y agoBut it's not clear whether ignoring is possible or happens now...
- 0x073 4y agoThen you would be permanent sick.
- amelius 4y agoSome people consider frequent blood donations as a way to reduce the amount of foreign particles in their blood.
- throwaway290 4y agoI read on HN once it helps with some PFOS or PFAS in blood...
- extasia 4y agoThat study was specifically on Australian firemen IIRC. Firemen are exposed to more of those particular chemicals because of their widespread use in flame retardant sprays.
- HealthNeed 4y agoAlso donating plasma was a better option than whole blood.
- bjornsing 4y agoWould be interesting to know the exact findings regarding effect of socioeconomic factors. Anybody with access to the paper that could cut-n-paste?
- AstralStorm 4y agoThe study ends in 2019. It will be interesting to compare rates since COVID.
- tehjoker 4y agoPosted this elsewhere, but this study shows a 40% risk increase (population increase from 11% to 15%) in Germany. https://www.livescience.com/covid-19-linked-to-40-increase-in-autoimmune-disease-risk-in-huge-study https://www.livescience.com/covid-19-linked-to-40-increase-i...
- hackernoteng 4y ago[flagged]
- 0x486566e7279 4y agoWouldn’t that mean that infections are also a major source, as more people are infected by virus than are vaccinated by against them? Most vaccines excluding the new MRNA vaccines are just versions of the original virus, dead or weakened.
- jtc331 4y agoNo, because the argument for vaccines causing autoimmune disorders is largely not about live viral vaccines (or at least not them on their own) but rather vaccines that contain adjuvants (and not all do). The idea is that the adjuvants result in the immune system targeting many proteins (not just the proteins ones in the vaccine).
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoMy (pharmacy student) daughter has a plausible theory about that. Most (all?) vaccines have something in them to make the immune system recognize that there's something there to fight. (It might me called an "adjuvant" or something like that - I'm not the pharmacy student, so I'm probably getting the word wrong.) It's included in the vaccine that you get from the manufacturer. That was fine, when you only had a very few vaccines to get. But now kids are supposed to get something like 18 different vaccines. Well, doctors know that the mom isn't going to bring their kid in 18 different times to get vaccinated. So they give the kid five different vaccines at a visit. So the kid gets five doses of the adjuvant (or whatever it's called) at once. For some kids, that's enough to make their immune system hyperactive. And behold, they develop autoimmune diseases. As I said, this is a plausible theory. It's not proven. But it makes some sense, and it explains what changed.
- mentalpiracy 4y ago[flagged]
- moneywoes 4y agoAs someone with 3 I believe one factor may be increased testing
- Diederich 4y agoI'm sorry to hear that you're dealing with that. If you're comfortable doing so, I wonder if you could share more details about how increased testing is involved? Thank you.
- tsimionescu 4y agoNot OP, but generally if you increase testing, you find more instances of disease, especially for diseases with lower/hard to gauge impact (ones that people may not have gone to the doctor for in the past).
- spondylosaurus 4y agoAlso not OP, but I recently got diagnosed with (another) autoimmune disorder solely because a single doctor twisted my arm into getting some unpleasant tests done. Turns out I have Crohn's disease and not just an unusually capricious stomach. (Also, thankfully, turns out Crohn's symptoms get significantly better with treatment.) But if I hadn't been willing to power through the time and money and discomfort of getting tested, I probably would've remained undiagnosed for years. I'm thankful we caught it now and not before things got bad enough to land me in the hospital.
- Mikejames 4y agoThe foods we eat today have higher amounts of Omega 6. Theres a ratio between omega 6 and omega 3, 3:1, 2:1 for healthy omega 6 to omega 3 balance. when Omega 6 is high it seems to correlate to autoimmune disease and allergic diseases along processed seed oils are in most foods we eat
- diordiderot 4y agoPaper?
- lamp_book 4y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2646454/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2646454/ This is dealing with a specific condition (MGD) but after the intro sections it describes how dietary omega fatty acids play into inflammation.
- jasonhansel 4y agoThat study says that the risk factor is red meat consumption, not seed oils: > The typical American and Northern European diet is high in omega-6 FAs, with the average person having an omega-6 to omega-3 FA intake ratio between 15:1 and 18:1. These populations tend to overconsume red meat and underconsume unprocessed oils and cold-water fish.
- lamp_book 4y agoYou can google what foods have high omega 6:3 ratio - plant seed oils are just one culprit of many. Livestock is largely fed corn derived feed so that’s why our meat is high in omega 6 content.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoSo, stick to canola oil over olive oil if you want lower omega 6 ratios. Stick to unsaturated fats over sat fats. People who fixate on omega 6 and seed oils usually dismiss the downsides of saturated fat, as a rule. They will go on about the dangers of seed oil based on something that isn’t scientific consensus, yet the overwhelming balance of evidence against saturated fat doesn’t meet their epistemic standard. Always awkward to watch.
- Gatsky 4y agoVery interesting. The increase in Coeliac disease will mostly be due to the advent of a useful blood test to detect it. The lack of association between other autoimmune diseases and multiple sclerosis fits with the recent identification of Epstein-Barr virus as a probable causative agent. The reduction in pernicious anaemia could be explained by reductions in the prevalence of Helicobacter pylori (due to effective treatment and improvements in food handling).
- jjtheblunt 4y agoisn't pernicious anemia also caused by B vitamin deficiency?
- Miner49er 4y agoKind of, we have evidence that there are a lot more people with celiac now. It's not just that people are being diagnosed more. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090701082911.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090701082911.h...
- ksaun 4y agoThere's another confounding factor regarding celiac diagnosis, though its impact may be negligible: the lack of unique treatment options. I know someone who learned through an elimination diet that they are sensitive to gluten. Maybe they actually have celiac disease, but they currently have no reason to investigate further -- the only practical "treatment" is avoiding gluten, which they are already now doing. Furthermore, apparently the blood test for celiac disease requires the patient be exposed to gluten for some time before the blood is drawn. So they'd have to start eating gluten again (and thus suffering) to learn whether what they have is celiac disease.
- Miner49er 4y agoYes, that is a big problem. IIRC, it's estimated only 20% of people with celiac are actually diagnosed.
- akokanka 4y agoWiFi and other frequencies with which we are bounced daily are to blame
- Fragoel2 4y agoOn the basis of which proof?
- sowbug 4y agoAnd solar-generated electricity still carries the dangerous UV radiation. That's why skincare companies are the biggest sponsors of the solar energy revolution.
- nerdponx 4y agoThis is as disingenuous as OP is speculative. There are plenty of studies in non-bullshit journals demonstrating that millimeter-wavelength electromagnetic fields can affect voltage-gated calcium channels in the body. It seems highly unlikely that increased long-term exposure above natural baseline would cause autoimmune disease, but it also seems unlikely that it would have no other effect on the body.
- 6nf 4y agoGot any studies on this I can read?
- quantumwoke 4y agoMostly this is because we have more reliable tests for autoimmune disease, and more are being discovered. I wouldn’t be quick to jump to a boogeyman like crystals, COVID, fluorine, magical wind chimes as the cause.
- callesgg 4y agoThe stronger your immune system is the higher are your chances to survival. Until your immune system is so strong it attacks it’s own host. Evolutionary pressures will make sure that organisms are very close to the edge between to weak and to strong. One naive way of interpreting this is that 50% of the population will have a immune response that is to strong (above the edge) and 50% to weak (under the edge). But it is naive to say that, as this is a topic that has much more complexities than the one dimensional model that I have described here. At what percentage the threshold of the statistics for what we call autoimmune disease would be located would be interesting to know.
- marsven_422 4y ago[dead]
- nickdothutton 4y ago_Anecdotally_ I’ve noticed a huge uptick in colleagues and friends with some kind of autoimmune problem in the last 3 years, especially those with severe symptoms. Looking forward to any good study into this problem which was already growing even before the current “covid age”.
- nerdponx 4y agoWhat are examples of severe symptoms? I would be interested in seeing some kind of long-term study of the appearance of reported symptoms that are associated with autoimmune disease, and not just the diagnosis of autoimmune disease. If rates of reported symptoms in the population are increasing, Then it's suggestive that the prevalence of disease is increasing, whereas if diagnoses are increasing but reported symptoms or not, it's indicative of better testing and a stable prevalence of disease.
- nickdothutton 4y agoSevere symptoms would be painful and persistent Rheumatoid arthritis, MS, Myositis, and some condition requiring regular infusions of immunosuppressant drugs in hospital (I did not wish to pry as to the exact nature of that one). It’s my understanding that all of these were quite easily diagnosed in their respective patients as they were so severe.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- semilattice 4y agoI believe we are increasing in the number of autoimmue disorders. Alergies is a clear sign that these are not 'hidden', 'waiting to be discovered' symptoms. My personal view is that this a combination of the following top factors (in that order): 1) long-distance travel causing quick spreading of various infections illnesses stressing our immune system 2) Food (too much sugar and carbs) 3) Water and air pollution 4) vaccines 'boosters' chasing immunity to rapidly changing pathogens
- lez 4y agoOne factor that you haven't mentioned is government-sponsored, man-made weaponized strains of pathogens, just like Mycoplasma Fermentans Incognitus: http://www.betterhealthguy.com/images/stories/PDF/PHA/2009_07.pdf http://www.betterhealthguy.com/images/stories/PDF/PHA/2009_0... (1. article)
- atleastoptimal 4y agoI have a feeling that microplsatics, PFAS, chemical contamination, digestive problems due to modern diets and like the like are all significant precursors to autoimmune disorders.
- m3kw9 4y agoDiabetes would account for a lot of that increase due to highly process foods with refined sugars/carbs
- terminalcommand 4y agoType 1 diabetes is an autoimmune disease, you catch regardless of your diet. Even newborn babies can be diagnosed with it. Type 2 diabetes results from old age, sugar heavy diet etc. Please learn the difference :(.
- opmelogy 4y agoAnyone know about this idea about low fiber diets making it easier for bacteria to get through the intestinal lining? And that this bacteria is likely a cause for autoimmune issues? I read about this about 10 years ago in the NYTimes and haven't seen it in print since. But the last 3 doctors I've seen (in different cities), I've asked them about this and the responses have ranged from "research is showing this is likely the case" and then another one responded with a flat out "yes, that's correct." Yet I don't see anyone actually talking about this.
- mbrochh 4y agoStop. Eating. Carbs. And. All. Processed. Foods. It's. That. Easy.