18 ms·
The grid isn’t ready for 300M EVs by 2030
- lipoid_ecole 4y ago1. We must switch to EVs because of climate change. 2. The grid cannot support everyone having EVs. 3. Everyone must live in 15 minute cities.
- traveler01 4y agoBuild more nuclear plants and a better grid…
- cs702 4y agoTrue, the grid isn't ready for 300M EVs by 2030... but it will have to be. Alas, consumers have a long history of ignoring exhortations to change their habits. They always do what they want, not what some authority tells them they ought to do. If they want giant-ass long-range electric trucks and SUVs, they will buy giant-ass long-range electric trucks/SUVs. The only viable solution is a massive wave of investment to improve energy generation, storage, delivery, and efficiency worldwide. I believe we can do it :-)
- fowtowmowcow 4y agoMicrogrids are the future.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoWhat’s that?
- p1mrx 4y agoA microgrid generally means having wind/solar/batteries near your neighborhood, with a natural gas or diesel generator that kicks in when the batteries die.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoThat’s neat
- Avshalom 4y agoConsumers are going to be told that they want giant-ass electric trucks and SUVs.
- happycube 4y agosigh yeah - GM's replacing the Bolt with the 2-ft larger Equinox for instance. I'd rather have a revised Spark EV with rear wheel drive and 200mi range myself.
- spacemadness 4y agoI guess I’m much more cynical about who changes consumers habits. Auto companies have spent enormous sums ensuring political behavior is such that cities aren’t as walkable as they could be and that people need cars in their life.
- cs702 4y agoAuto companies didn't change consumer habits. They changed physical infrastructure to make vehicles a necessity. And they did so surreptitiously through back-room political influence, without ever telling consumers what they ought to do. That's... different.
- badpun 4y agoDid they do it in every developed country? The US doesn't have massively higher number of cars than other countries, esp. considering its relatively rural character.
- latency-guy2 4y agoEh, I don't feel like walking today, or tomorrow.
- porkbeer 4y agoGot anything to back up that claim, besides the old and dubious claim of gm buying trolleys?
- kiba 4y agoYou don't need 300M EV if you make cars less mandatory for living.
- George83728 4y agoA lot of people pushing for all-EV laws would be even happier if ubiquitous car culture were brought to an end and commoner rural / suburban people were all forced to move into cities and rely on mass transit. So I'm not convinced such shortcomings in the all-EV plan are unintentional. The 2030 timetable seems deliberately too short to be realistic.
- kcb 4y agoMeh, range of today's EVs is more than enough to support suburban and rural people. Remote rural areas with 100 mile drives to the store exist but are hardly the commoners.
- xbmcuser 4y agoRural people with the space to put in solar panels and large batteries will actually be able to get cheaper electricity than urban. With the way prices are falling for batteries and solar by 2030 it will be cheaper for most to even replace farm machinery running diesel engines with electric motors let alone cars.
- George83728 4y agoRange has nothing to do with it, I didn't say anything about EV range. It's a matter of economics, ICE bans by 2030 will require people to purchase new cars years before they otherwise would have (the economics of running a gas station business will be trashed, gas will become much more expensive.) It will require increased taxes to pay for new infrastructure, or otherwise increase the cost of electricity. All around it increases the cost of a rural lifestyle significantly, pricing commoners out. Which is probably half of the intention in the first place because rural living is frequently castigated by the anti-car crowd (who never seem to propose car bans for the rich, only policy changes that would price commoners out of owning cars.) Response to sibling comment's "just buy a field of solar panels bro": Yeah that's great for the people with money to spare. These policies won't bother rich people, but will price out the poor from whom the rich will eagerly buy up property, creating massive country estates while commoners wallow in cities. Just like Roman times. Just the way the rich want it.
- tarr11 4y ago> The Stanford study points out that since charging electric vehicles takes time using conventional chargers, owners tend to leave their cars charging in the evenings and overnight, putting added pressure on the grid. Demand peaks between 5-9 pm as people return home from work and use electric appliances like televisions and kettles. > If vehicle owners were to charge them during the day, this could cut costs and help the grid as the number of electric vehicles increase to meet sustainable goals, the authors say. My EV (Tesla) already has a charging option for when rates are cheapest. I would assume that most EVs will have that feature if they don’t already? Not sure I understand why this is considered a big problem.
- bombcar 4y agoI think they’re saying people don’t charge at work - a disconnected Tesla can’t charge.
- klyrs 4y agoWhich is odd, I know people who only charge at work. Who knows, maybe that could be a perk to encourage RTO if management was so concerned.
- the__alchemist 4y agoHow does that work?
- klyrs 4y agoThere are chargers in parking lots at/near office buildings. People use them during the day. In residential areas without offstreet parking, there are few to no convenient chargers.
- the__alchemist 4y agoInteresting. My suspicion is that the amount of workplaces where this is an option is small compared to workplaces as a whole, but I've no idea! My (incorrect?) assumption is that the primary convenient option is for homeowners in suburbs to charge in their driveway or garage when home.
- AdrianB1 4y agoThe grid will never be ready for that, but smart charging may be the solution. What do I mean by that: there is already a number of solar panel installations that are feeding the grid at daytime, sometime even more than what the grid can consume. There is no way currently to link the PV systems and the cars so that when the PV generates a lot of electricity all the cars in the area will start charging, maybe discharge at night to cover home consumption, practically using the cars as very large and intelligent batteries with the side effect of using all the excess PV energy to change cars for driving. Otherwise we will be in the situation of cars charging at night will fail the grid and PVs overproducing at day will fail the grid, while most cars are used less than a couple of hours per day on average (ignoring commercial vehicles and taxi/Uber, cars carry people from home to work and back, eventually with a round trip to shop for groceries).
- klyrs 4y agoWill there even be 300M drivers by 2030?
- prepend 4y ago> if adaptations aren’t made before net-zero goals for EVs are met. Of course. Why would we not make adaptations? The job of the grid is to adapt to consumer needs. They aren’t perfect, but it makes sense that they’ll adapt. I wouldn’t count on consumers changing unless the grid does something simple like set prices to incentivize charging patterns. I have a few electric companies near me. One just has flat rates. The other has nighttime rates that are much lower. I expect all power companies will end up like this. Or just grant low prices for “smart chargers” that auto charge based on when there’s excess capacity. These types of articles seem funny to me as a form of “I haven’t eaten in the past 8 hours, if this trend continues I will starve to death in two days.”
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIndeed. I have talked to multiple utility representatives from Florida all the way up to Illinois, and they are all aware of the upgrades that are going to be necessary to support full electrification. Not just vehicles, but everything (cooking, hvac, etc). ComEd in Illinois even mentions it on billboard advertising they have in their market (“Electrification is coming. We’ll be ready.”). https://www.icc.illinois.gov/docket/P2022-0432/documents/325766/files/567114.pdf https://www.icc.illinois.gov/docket/P2022-0432/documents/325... https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-biz-comed-seeks-multiyear-rate-increase-electrification-20230117-2uhp7swyrng73oxy32cj4asini-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-biz-comed-seeks-m...
- AdrianB1 4y agoIf you consider what is the cost of "adapting" I bet your discourse would change. EVs have massive consumption, way bigger than lights, computers and AC/heating combined. In my part of the world (Eastern Europe) the usual power consumed by a home is 0.5 to 2kW, with short time spikes to 3-4kW. An EV can easily go 12KW, that requires a very expensive upgrade in capacity and load balancing of the grid to accept locally (in a city block) hundreds of cars randomly connecting with huge surges. You need some kind of interface and protocol to coordinate car charging per micro-grid.
- matthewdgreen 4y ago
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- thelastgallon 4y agoSeems to be sloppy research. Doesn't seem to understand the difference between world/US and US grid doesn't have to supply the worlds' EVs. >> There were 16.5 million electric vehicles on the world’s roads in 2020 That's the world, not the US. The US has less than a million EVs, maybe 2 at most.[1][2] >> this is expected to rise to 300 million by 2030. But with these rising numbers, the US grid could struggle without investment and changes in charging habits, a Stanford study finds. Projections are 26 million[3] by 2030 in US, 300 million is worldwide, but what has US grid got to do with it? But, even if it were true, it won't be as big as a challenge as its made out to be. a) There is plenty of free renewable power. Renewables oversupply, which is currently being curtailed. Renewables are growing, this will mean plenty of oversupply coming online. If only there was a way to create demand. b) Wholesale prices went negative about 200 million times across the seven US grids in 2021 c) EVs can absorb all of this free energy or get paid to absorb d) Right now, energy bill is split between gas, electricity and nat gas. Households switching to EVs will have solar, bringing their bills to zero as well as no new demand on the grid. e) Quite possibly, there is no net new demand. A comment on HN: It takes about as much electricity (or energy) to refine a tank of gas as to charge an EV. [5] [1]https://environmentamerica.org/articles/youre-not-imagining-it-there-are-more-evs-on-the-road-today-and-even-more-are-on-their-way/ https://environmentamerica.org/articles/youre-not-imagining-... [2]https://electrek.co/2021/11/09/the-number-of-us-electric-vehicles-grows-from-16k-to-2-million-in-10-years/ https://electrek.co/2021/11/09/the-number-of-us-electric-veh... [3]https://www.eei.org/News/news/All/eei-projects-26-million-electric-vehicles-will-be-on-us-roads-in-2030 https://www.eei.org/News/news/All/eei-projects-26-million-el... [4] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-30/trapped-renewable-energy-sends-us-power-prices-below-zero#xj4y7vzkg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-30/trapped-r... [5] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35653034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35653034
- jgalt212 4y agoIf people are given the the ability to charge their cars during the daytime, this will be a non-issue. That, however, is a big if. https://twitter.com/MegaWattXinfo/status/1650913384206942414 https://twitter.com/MegaWattXinfo/status/1650913384206942414
- syllablehq 4y agoSure, we can try to change people's behavior, which of course will only work with smart incentives. And/or we need a lot more grid-scale energy storage. Changing people's behavior is really hard. And before it's even possible to implement "surge pricing" in a way that's exposed to individuals, we need a ton of infrastructure changes. Those are good goals, but it might be simpler to incentivize behavior at a larger scale than consumers and cover the gap with storage. For example, add storage to car charging stations instead of telling consumers when to charge. The charge station would then charge up at low demand so it won't pull from the grid during peak demand. Maybe we need all of the above, we'll see.
- mooktakim 4y agoHow did we get petrol cars without already having petrol stations everywhere??
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoIt was common to carry containers of gas when traveling cross-country (USA) in the 1930s (source: my grandparents). I don’t know the size but would guess several 5-gallon containers would do it.
- kortilla 4y agoSpare gas cans can get you hundreds of miles. When I was growing up this was super common for long road trips just because gas stations usually closed at night and there weren’t credit card readers for 24 hour pumps.
- mooktakim 4y agoI'm talking about 100 years ago when cars were invented. We didn't stop and wait for the infrastructure to be ready. We built it, got it out there. Everything else will come when and as we need it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- manquer 4y agoEarly car adopters probably were range conscious as hydrogen car owners today like me are . Built it and it will come doesn’t always work for the early adopters, early investment in a technology can be risky it might take longer than expected or some other tech might replace the current front runner. Gasoline powered cars weren’t the only tech in early 1900s either, steam powered cars were being as late as 1930s. The diesel and petrol engines were competing too, very different kinds of engines and fuels
- bcrosby95 4y agoYou could literally stop at a hardware store or pharmacy to buy a can of gasoline. It didn't need dedicated fueling infrastructure.
- reactspa 4y ago[dead]
- mbgerring 4y agoAre people aware that there’s an entire industry with 100s of billions in capital already working on these problems? Every time I read one of these articles and the comments on them, it reads like a reason why we can’t or shouldn’t decarbonize, rather than a call to do the engineering work to fix the problem. Which plenty of people are doing already! This is Hacker News, right?
- dheera 4y agoYeah exactly, it's not like the world was ready with gas stations for 300M gas cars when that happened, either.
- shipscode 4y agoI doubt that the world was actively preventing consumer vehicles from driving on existing infrastructure. It seems like the same people who are forcing the change over to electric vehicles are also actively working to reduce the presence of vehicles on the roads.. I don’t believe they are operating in good faith.
- mbgerring 4y agoRight? Imagine, having the full benefit of hindsight, and still responding to such a massive opportunity by grumping that there’s no way it could ever work!
- throwaway50606 4y ago
- dicriseg 4y agoSo get it ready. It’s the richest country in the world with profits so large it’s spiking inflation. There are billionaires out the ass. Maybe we can find the money there.
- ajpgrealish 4y agoThe post title misses the important "without investment and changes in charging habits". Most EVs can already be controlled to set charging preferences to match lower cost, off-peak charging overnight. However, this isn't the full solution as it can create secondary demand peaks. For example, if everyone in one region has an off-peak rate starting at midnight, you will get a step-change in demand at that time. Midnight onwards may also not be the lowest carbon time to charge as this will change every day as renewables are not predictable. In California right now, charging during the day would have lower emissions Source: https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/US-CAL-CISO https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/US-CAL-CISO Many people are already thinking about this problem, including https://ev.energy https://ev.energy. We go one step further and actively control EVs and EV Chargers to match their charging to when the grid is most clean. This may be overnight, but it could also be during the daytime when solar generation is highest. It is better for the grid not to use simple peak/off-peak pricing, but instead create tariffs that reward flexibility and move the exact charging times to best suit the grid.
- ttiurani 4y agoA more critical issue with just electrifying cars without also reducing the number of them, is that it's completely inadequate to meet CO2 targets. A new study in Nature Communications modelled this for London and found that: "[T]he current system cannot reach stringent carbon budgets without adopting highly aggressive and disruptive policies. Electrification, including moving the phase out date forward, results in cumulative emissions 7 times greater than the Tyndall carbon budget for the “well below 2 °C and pursuing 1.5 °C” global temperature target. Rather, a combination of aggressive policies is necessary so that future emissions reach levels comparable to the carbon budget. Of these policies, the most important is reducing car travel activity. Policies that decrease car distance driven and car ownership by over 80% as compared to current levels are highly effective in edging close to the designated carbon budget." https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-37728-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-37728-x
- mataug 4y agoCan we also talk about the fact that the fastest growing EV market isn't for cars, its for e-bikes[1], and e-bikes are crazy efficient, and 20x-30x cheaper, compared to electric cars. Example, an e-bike with 400wh ~5 charges of a laptop battery, can get 30 miles of range, compared to ~250wh/mi of a car[2]. Cities are slowly waking up to the fact that more people are biking, and more biking infrastructure leads to even more people biking. I'm not trying to say that the problem highlighted here isn't valid, I'm merely trying to highlight that the scale of the problem might be lower than we expect. [1]: https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/16/21016306/electric-bike-ebike-sales-us-numbers-deloitte-cars https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/16/21016306/electric-bike-e... [2]: https://www.seattlebikeblog.com/2023/04/12/why-an-e-bike-incentive-program-is-one-of-the-best-transportation-investments-washington-can-make/ https://www.seattlebikeblog.com/2023/04/12/why-an-e-bike-inc...
- jseliger 4y agoI just got one of these: https://magnumbikes.com/collections/commuting-errands/products/magnum-metro-750 https://magnumbikes.com/collections/commuting-errands/produc..., granted for under $2k due to a sale at a bike shop, and it's great.
- bullfightonmars 4y agoThis is the way. Building out dedicated bike infrastructure in cities will come at a fraction of the cost of any other investments and provide for a transit mode that suffers from none of these problems.
- bertil 4y agoIndeed: “The grid isn’t ready for 300M Electric Monster Trucks by 2030” but the grid will have no problem to power 300M electric bikes.
- peteradio 4y agoLol, you like riding bike in the rain? What about in the snow? What about when its excessively hot out? The US doesn't want and will not use 300m bikes. Or do we expect the US to come to a stop when its anything but pleasant outside?
- jdeibele 4y agoI've had a Chevy Bolt EUV for 3 weeks. We are moving to a new house that has a 240V outlet in the garage. This house does not, so I'm using the stock Chevy portable charging cable with the 110V adapter, not the 240V one. Setting a known location (like home) means that you can charge at 12A because you can tell the car there's nothing else on the circuit. Otherwise, it will charge at 8A to avoid overloading the circuit. The Bolt charges about 3.5 miles per hour on 110V, which is 35 miles of range or more overnight, which is fine for this situation. Somebody in the neighborhood has a PHEV Subaru. They park on the wrong side of the street (can be ticketed for this in Portland) so they can run their charging cable out a window and plug it into the car. It is almost certainly another 110V. The local utility offers $25 off if you let them control your smart thermostat during the winter and summer (not spring or fall) seasons. You have to participate in at least half of the events to qualify. The typical recommendation for EV batteries is to charge them to 80% unless you need more. There are times where energy prices have gone negative because utilities have too much electricity from solar or wind power. It doesn't seem impossible to do some combination of "let us fill you to 100% if we have too much energy" or "please go plug in your EV" along with time-of-day rates. 240V can draw up to 32A for the Bolts, other cars up to 50A (on a dedicated 60A circuit) and is easily multiples of 110V, which might not be worth really worrying about it. There are solar panels on this house and there'll be ones on the next one, too.
- bbarn 4y agoThe company I work for manages those demand response programs. Many of them now also support smart L2 chargers that can also be controlled similar to the thermostat you mention. We also still, at the end of the day have a greed problem. My local utility, for example (smaller, very monopolized one in the socal mountains) has halted being able to get credits from feeding solar back into the grid. They've all but made getting home solar irrelevant unless you have an expensive battery system like a Tesla powerwall or similar. I live in an area at altitude where it's sunny for much more than average and we are prime candidates to have solar on every home - but a greedy local utility has halted nearly all progress that the last decade has seen.
- nasmorn 4y agoDuring WW2 the US built e.g over 300 destroyers in 6 years. Now they struggle to complete 2 per year. It might not be impossible but something has fundamentally changed.
- manquer 4y agoWar time procurement subverts entire industries and reserves everything anybody produces first for the military. Sure the country produced 300 destroyers, tens of thousands of aircraft and tanks, and that production is what ultimately won the war , but you have to keep in mind the country produced little else any other normal economic activity was severely curtailed and even basic life needs were rationed. It not only ramping up but also ramping down are problematic, for example even though military doesn’t really want congress keeps budgeting for M1 tanks so it can keep those jobs. Suddenly producing 20 destroyers in one year and nothing for next 15 is going to impact labor market massively and also you are going to loose all the skills acquired In peacetime you want a low constant throughput for your military.
- throw0101b 4y ago> During WW2 the US built e.g over 300 destroyers in 6 years. Yes, with 40% of GDP going to war production: * https://www.stlouisfed.org/en/on-the-economy/2020/february/war-highest-defense-spending-measured https://www.stlouisfed.org/en/on-the-economy/2020/february/w... And every other form of manufacturing shutdown or rationed for the war effort. Even how jeans were stitched together was regulated (to save on resources): * https://www.ropedye.com/2013/05/levis1944-501/ https://www.ropedye.com/2013/05/levis1944-501/ * https://www.levistrauss.com/2020/09/30/world-war-ii-levis/ https://www.levistrauss.com/2020/09/30/world-war-ii-levis/ > It might not be impossible but something has fundamentally changed. Societal priorities and focus against an existential threat.
- tiku 4y agoAs it happens tomorrow is still 2023 and we have some time left.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 4y agoEV's use about the same amount of energy as an air conditioner, they both average about 10kWh per day. Is it a challenge? Yes. But it's a challenge we met before when we went from 10% of homes being air conditioned to 90% in under 2 decades.
- atleastoptimal 4y agoIs 300M EV's the best use of manufacturing resources over the next 7 years to minimize climate change? Wouldn't it make more sense to upgrade old factories in Asia with advanced equipment to minimize their carbon footprint?
- nine_k 4y agoPeople who want to upgrade their cars anyway will pay form 300M EV cars. Who will pay for upgrading an old coal plant in Asia to a new nuclear + solar plant, or something like that?
- atleastoptimal 4y agoTaxpayers will, just like taxpayers have been paying for EVs
- xboxnolifes 4y agoIf it weren't for the last minute, nothing would get done. Even if not perfect, the tight schedule will get people to stop pushing shit down the road.
- ouid 4y agoA gas pump fills a car at 20 MW, many gas stations operate at capacity for many hours a day with a dozen pumps active. EVs are ~4 times as efficient, but even being very generous, you've still got gas stations with the sustained power draw of an industrial arc furnace. This is not a trivial infrastructure problem to overcome. Very high power draw like that requires very high voltage transmission, which is dangerous and difficult. Plug in hybrids are an extremely sensible intermediate step, and perhaps the only feasible endpoint. They solve almost every problem that electric vehicles solve, and also almost every problem that electric vehicles have.
- PuffinBlue 4y agoNah, solutions are already built and operating: https://youtu.be/FoN4WCpuxHY https://youtu.be/FoN4WCpuxHY Pretty easy to stick a big battery in between grid and cars and balance the load. Not to mention you can’t top up your gas car at home everyday like you can an EV. EV charging will end up far more distributed than gas car filling. I actually worked in a gas station for quite a while. Demand is never constant 24 hours a day. There are always peaks and troughs as the daily cycle of life revolves. EV charging will be just fine.
- ouid 4y agoload balancing doesnt work like that. the draw on a high throughput gas station is hundreds of megawatts for hours. Are you proposing 100MWh batteries installed at charging stations? Sure people can top up their cars overnight, but what about people who street park? Charging a tesla battery to full overnight (16hr) is still 5kW. On the other hand in the world where gas is very expensive, and you have a PHEV, you can pkug in most of the time and solve almost all of your gasoline demand, while still being able to fill your car at 20MW in critical situations
- PuffinBlue 4y ago> the draw on a high throughput gas station is hundreds of megawatts for hours. Did you watch the video? For a 36 charger station they’re using a 6Mw battery. It works because the assumption that draw from the chargers is constant is wrong. > What about people who street park? They can go to the charger station. And all the people who don’t need to because they do it at home…don’t go to the charger station. Reducing demand even further. > Charging a tesla battery to full overnight Do you use your entire gas tank everyday? Because 90+% of vehicle users don’t. So there’s no need to pull that much power, again reducing peak demand and spreading out the load. The things you are highlighting are rooted in fear, not reality. The reality is that ev’s work without the downsides of PHEV. And i say that as a ICE owner jealous of the ease of use, lower maintenance and savings being made by friends with ev’s.
- moomoo11 4y agois there any investment in moving power from say a massive solar array in some Arizona desert to Colorado and Texas? I remember reading somewhere that a 100x100 miles sq plot of solar panels would be enough to power America. That doesn’t seem so bad. Or maybe we put massive arrays in the atmosphere and have a 100 mile cable to earth (maybe in the desert) as a precursor to a space elevator. Solve global warming and energy needs two birds one stoner lol.
- Vecr 4y agoYou can't run a cable from earth to the kind of orbit solar satellites need to be in. If you want to know more about actual plans for something similar, look at the 1970s plans for power beamed from orbit using microwaves, and the massive Star Raker space planes that would have been required.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThere's no way the grid will be ready for EVs unless we can somehow provide about 300M batteries of roughly 50Kwh storage that can absorb some of the cheap renewable power we'll be building. I just don't see any way of doing one without the other.
- yongjik 4y agoThe current title of the article is: > As more electric vehicles hit the road, our charging habits must change - here’s why With these bullet points: > The race is on to decarbonize road transport and get drivers to switch to electric vehicles (EVs). > There were 16.5 million electric vehicles on the world’s roads in 2020 - this is expected to rise to 300 million by 2030. But with these rising numbers, the US grid could struggle without investment and changes in charging habits, a Stanford study finds. > Modelling this future scenario, researchers predict that peak net electricity demand could increase by up to 25% and by 50% with full electrification. I'm not really sure why OP decided "The grid isn’t ready for 300M EVs by 2030" as submission title. (I mean, I can guess, but... shrug) Seems like a violation of HN's "no editorializing titles" policy.
- juujian 4y agoWell what a coincidence. Chances are there won't be 300M EVs on the streets by 2030 anyways, because by then we will have moved the goalpost far into the future anyways.
- Ccecil 4y agoTemporary fix for some places Convert current remote gas stations to high efficiency turbine generators, still "dirty" but should be able to be made cleaner than the same number of cars. Once the charging structure is in place...then you have a bit of time to get the proper power lines and/or alternate power generation running. Might seem dumb...but the stations are typically where cars go, have large tanks...etc.
- dghughes 4y agoI'm not in the US but my idea of a good system is EV vehicle, solar panels, home battery storage, and a ground source heat pump w/ water heater. That to me is the perfect set up since the energy production is only at that single home. The exception being very cold winter days, hot humid days, and EVs away from their home base needing to charge. But even with rebates it's too expensive for nearly anyone who owns a home. Anyone of those items is minimum $20K to $50K and beyond multiplied by each of the four items.
- asdfman123 4y agoWhy would we necessarily need the small scale storage systems when we have the whole energy grid, though? Solar panels on homes, sure, because that’s free real estate. But generally, if something is cost effective for a single home, it’s probably more cost effective for the full grid. The solution seems almost certainly to just reduce prices at night and during the day, installing more chargers at workplaces, so people are incentived to charge at off peak hours. If I can reduce my electricity bill by 30% by smarter charging, I’m going to do that for sure.
- foogazi 4y agoThen you can disconnect and not put any pressure on the grid
- asdfman123 4y agoBut someone has to pay for the energy storage and generation: either you or the power companies, but you don’t benefit from economies of scale.
- foogazi 4y agoEconomies of scale on panel and battery manufacturing
- therealdrag0 4y ago
- grokx 4y agoI would argue that EVs are just the tip of the iceberg. >The race is on to decarbonize road transport and get drivers to switch to electric vehicles (EVs). Actually the race is on to decarbonize all the things (at least here in France). My wife works at RTE (Réseau de Transport d'Electricité), which is the grid company here. She makes studies for customers that require more power, so she basically see where new power lines could be placed, whether a new high voltage station is required, etc. These last years, she noticed a rise for such demands, as the whole heavy industry has been decarbonizing their processes: chemicals, metallurgy... Coal and other fuels (used for heat production for instance) are being replaced either by electricity, or by green hydrogen (so even more electricity).
- xnx 4y agoAs others have pointed out, the title of the article is "As more electric vehicles hit the road, our charging habits must change - here’s why"
- xyst 4y agoMaybe, just maybe. We should design our cities around more sustainable and scalable forms of transportation. American (yes, Canada is included) city planning and design is terribly inefficient.
- dubcanada 4y agoYa we should just say 300M EVs by some point maybe in the future. That's how you make progress, hopes and maybes. The whole point of this is to force a change, otherwise it will end up being let's do it tomorrow, and than it's 2050 and there has been zero progress.
- cco 4y agoTo echo others here, its always strange to me when (non-status quo beneficiaries) people react like this. Is this not a great thing? We need to invest in our grid, that means lots of relatively well compensated folks tackling interesting problems at a huge scale. More (good) jobs for tradesmen, engineers, a net benefit to our environment, cleaner air...it just sounds pretty good all around? The grid wasn't ready for laundry machines and power tools in 1910.
- 78x8cjfoJUx9 4y ago[flagged]
- Havoc 4y agoOf all the problems out there this, seems like a fairly insignificant one. They have built in connectivity and storage making them inherently suitable for demand side management and variable pricing. Hell they can even discharge into peak times and can thus be a net positive for grid stability. More concerned about how are we gonna get the energy source clean by then. Because without that all this "clean" EV stuff is a giant waste of time
- TexanFeller 4y ago> Hell they can even discharge into peak times and can thus be a net positive for grid stability. Batteries are the most expensive component of the car and won't get me as far as gas when they're at 100% capacity. If I were to buy an EV I would never allow discharging the battery back into the grid without hefty compensation, and probably not even then. I really don't want you putting cycles in my battery, I have battery anxiety from all my other devices already. Not an EV hater, I covet the Teslas but I'm not willing to pay the premium and charging is impractical in parts of TX that I visit family in.
- Atheros 4y agoThey'll never Ever discharge into the grid. If it's ever close to economic to do so, it'll be more economic for utilities to buy and install cheaper grid-scale batteries on their own. Batteries designed to move around safely will always be more expensive. Because of that, during the exceptional times when it would be economic to use the cars like you suggest, like the Texas freeze a few years ago, the infrastructure won't be in place to do it.
- Havoc 4y ago> They'll never Ever discharge into the grid. Tesla powerwalls already do [0] under some conditions so not that hard to imagine that cars will too. https://www.tesla.com/en_gb/support/energy/powerwall/mobile-app/powerwall-modes https://www.tesla.com/en_gb/support/energy/powerwall/mobile-... > Batteries designed to move around safely will always be more expensive. But if they get bought anyway the incremental cost of using them for this when not on the move is very low
- csours 4y agoDid you realize you can calculate how many horsepower your house uses on average? And you can calculate how far your house would drive if it were a car? Last August I used about 1500 kWh of electrical energy Horsepower = kWh/(720 or 744 [hours in 30 or 31 day month])= kW * 1.34 (hp/kW) = hp Distance = kWh * 4mi/kWh (Tesla Model 3) So last August my house used about 2.7 horsepower on average and "drove" 6,000 miles
- mozman 4y agoEveryone is different. Your calculation omits time. There will be a huge peak demand when everyone recharges which is the primary problem. Using your math above my house is 7hp, or 14,000 miles a month.
- csours 4y agoThat doesn't need to be a problem. We do have the internet after all.
- carabiner 4y agoThe wonders of unit conversions.
- llsf 4y agoIf cars drive by themselves by 2030, then would US still need 300M vehicles ? I own an EV now for 4 years. My commute is only 20min x 2 per day. I only charge one night per week. Not all EV charge every single night, and in full. It would be nice to charge at work during the day, even at lower rate/speed when sun shines and wind blows. Maybe by making it easier for companies to offer charging at their parking lot would help ?
- ezekiel68 4y agoThe US also didn't have 99 aircraft carriers in 1942. But it had that many in 1945. So I guess this is just a question of commitment, dedication, resouce allocation, and ingenuity.
- bevenhall 4y agoFucktards assuming they're the only ones on the planet.
- iudqnolq 4y agoLuckily it turns out capitalism is amazingly good at solving problems with the following characteristics (unlike many other problems): We need to incrementally invest money in expanding capacity. The investments will be profitable along the way. If one party underinvests the others will earn more. Remember when we were going to run out of rare earth metals? The shortage incentived innovation in extraction techniques and the problem was solved. In the 1960s-70s serious people actually thought we would run out of farmland and everyone on earth would starve.
- eatmyshorts 4y agoThe beauty of EVs with respect to the grid is they present an opportunity to make our grid much more resilient and reliable, all while enabling renewables much greater percentages of our overall power generation. Renewables (well, specifically solar and wind) are very peak-y, with peaks that can overwhelm a grid and blow out transformers, and troughs that require additional power generation from other sources. This limits the base load power that can be generated from wind/solar to around 40% of total demand. Unless you have a way to store and retrieve power on demand. You’d need enough storage to handle roughly 2 days of power usage needs in order to smooth power usage to cover peaks and troughs. And, lo and behold, the typical EV car has enough power to cover a typical home for about 3 days! If we incorporate inverters into home building standards today, we can guarantee that our EV fleet can be used to provide storage and auxiliary power for our grid and allow renewables to approach 100% of power generation. But we will need to deploy wind and solar in a distributed fashion so that power generation and storage is local to where the power is consumed. And a grid like this will be much more resilient to power outages and weather.