9 ms·
America Faces a Debt Nightmare
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Exuma 4y agoWow, no... really?
- forgingahead 4y agohttps://archive.ph/oCvhG https://archive.ph/oCvhG
- ur-whale 4y agohttps://archive.is/oCvhG https://archive.is/oCvhG very much worth a read in that context: https://comprehensivemoney.com/blog/thriftville-squanderville-a-true-story-1 https://comprehensivemoney.com/blog/thriftville-squandervill...
- pastacacioepepe 4y agohttps://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:O8_OP82Zz0MJ:https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2023/05/03/america-faces-a-debt-nightmare https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:O8_OP8...
- nugget 4y agoDemographics are destiny. America can probably attract and assimilate enough immigrants to be OK. That has always been and continues to be America’s superpower. As global birth rates continue to plummet, most of the rest of the world seems headed for a hard landing.
- cpursley 4y agoThere's several places poised for good demographic growth. Egypt, parts of Africa, Mexico. Not China, most of Europe. USA should be fine as long as the quality of the human capital stays high (education, law and order, etc).
- justrealist 4y agoFleetingly few places that have both the demographics and the institutional stability to capitalize on demographic growth though. Maybe a couple places in Latin America, but those countries have a habit of electing the wrong autocrat and utterly collapsing.
- zyyyyyy 4y ago[flagged]
- cpursley 4y agoThose are certainly big factors but don't underestimate their future potential. There's some big mega projects happening in Egypt that most people in the west are not even aware of, for example. I think Mexico is the really interesting one to keep an eye on as the world bifurcates (huge near-shoring manufacturing potential).
- twelve40 4y agoMexico is below replacement, that's the opposite of good demographic growth
- dirtyid 4y agoGrowth =/= divident. Demographics is more than just pyramid, have to consider workforce / productive composition and actual ability to realize potential, especially when comparing polities with order(s) of magnitude difference in population and human capita catchup/potential. > Not China Hence especially China. Scale of PRC moving workforce from currently 25% skilled to 70-85% over (developed economy level) next few generation even with net population decline is roughly creating 3-5 new Japans, or another 1-1.5 US worth of high productive divident. Within a few generations, through system largely with good track record ability to move up skill/value chain. Most other developing countries have been spinning wheels for too long to take face value postive prognosis seriously. But PRC doing so at PRC scale is special case, no other country is structurally able to replicate this feat, because they lack scale (US even with immigration), or coordination (India on other in same pop class but systemically incapable and not trending towards being so).
- starkd 4y agoBut new immigrants will need a vibrant economy they can assimilate into and pay taxes. If not, we will just be swamped and become another shithole country. That helps no one.
- zeedude 4y agoThe West has been importing its population for decades, full gas since 1965. Not only is this strategy failing, it is a significant contributor to the West’s current decline. The core problem is more centered on the dynamics of the 20th century that led to mass immigration.
- maerF0x0 4y ago> it is a significant contributor to the West’s current decline. Can you explain this further please?
- dirtyid 4y agoEconomically OK, but expect more social fissures between cultures and generations, especially when welfare and upward mobility will diminish with more bodies.
- candiddevmike 4y agoThis is only an issue when we have a democrat as president: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/gop-debt-ceiling-trump-presidency/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/gop-debt-ceiling-trump-pre...
- ur-whale 4y ago> This is only an issue when it's a democrat president. You'd think that indeed (dems are indeed, in a long leftist tradition, always ready, willing and eager to spend other people's money). But, very unfortunately, the last few so-called "fiscal conservative" presidents have been anything but: https://www.thebalancemoney.com/us-debt-by-president-by-dollar-and-percent-3306296 https://www.thebalancemoney.com/us-debt-by-president-by-doll...
- Bukhmanizer 4y agoI think that’s what they’re saying.
- ur-whale 4y agoWho's "they"?
- lostapathy 4y agoGP you originally replied to. He’s not saying the debt doesn’t go up regardless of who is the presidency, but that republicans only make it into an exercise in brinksmanship when a democrat has the Oval Office.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- api 4y agoThe debt goes up continuously under both parties. It's structural.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoStrange article. The first few paragraphs are written as if we haven’t raised the debt ceiling repeatedly. The latter graphs show debt as a % of GDP as a negative number… so the chart shows lines going down to mean debt will comprise a larger portion of GDP.
- sophacles 4y agoNot just "as if we haven't raised the debt ceiling repeatedly". It's also "as if we haven't had a republican congress pull these shenanigans every few years for as long as I've been alive". Anyone who is pretending this entire story is new and different or anything other than the R crowd posturing for their base (as always) is trying to sell you beachfront property in Arizona. It may get as far as a short term government shutdown (austerity measures, furloughs) before enough donors make big enough threats for it to pass. Learn your history and remember the events of your life - this is an established pattern and if it surprises you, it's your fault. (Not that it should be the pattern, but "what is" and "what should" don't often intersect).
- starkd 4y agoAs if Democrats aren't postering here? This isn't a dem/repub issue. If you can't see that, you are falling for it just as much as anyone else. Its that kind of thinking that is forestalling reasonable measures that could be taken now instead of fear-mongering that the other side is going to leave old people eating catfood.
- sophacles 4y agoI'm not saying they aren't posturing. Im saying that an R congress did this twice during Obama, at least once during clinton, and they are doing it now. I never seen a D congress try to stop the debt ceiling being raised. Both sides will go dirty over budgets, but this specific detb ceiling thing has a pattern. Show me how I'm wrong, don't just throw nonsequiturs at me that aren't about the thing I actually said.
- 4y ago
- mooreds 4y agotl;dr, the federal government is spending beyond its means and needs to either cut spending, increase taxes, or both. > How to avoid this sorry fate? The economic prescription is straightforward; the politics of delivering it are anything but. Even before the interest-rate shock, it was easy to anticipate that deficits would increase over time. The biggest share of federal spending is mandatory expenditures on social security, health insurance and the like, which are prescribed by laws and not subject to the vagaries of the annual budget-setting process. Already big, they will bulge as the population ages. Annual spending on income support for the elderly will be as much as all spending on education, the environment, national defence, science and transportation by 2033. > The government estimates that trust funds which help bankroll both social security and health programmes will be insolvent by the early 2030s. At that moment America would face a basic choice between slashing benefits and raising taxes. A similar calculation will apply to all other aspects of the federal budget: some combination of reducing expenditures and raising revenues is the only way to prevent a crippling rise in the federal deficit.
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> tl;dr, the federal government is spending beyond its means and needs to either cut spending, increase taxes, or both. What is the federal government's track record past 30 years at achieving a balance of either of these things?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- padobson 4y agoThere was a surplus from 1998-2001[0], so in living memory of most people reading this. It's worth mentioning this happened under a Democratic president and Republican congress, not far from what we have now. [0]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFSD https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFSD Edit: added citation
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CPLX 4y agoNo it doesn't, and the Economist, as an iconic neoliberal publication, has been saying the same thing since I was a kid and Carter was president. Nobody cares. The whole thing was a scam, it never actually mattered that much and the entire argument about government debt has basically just been an organized effort to have a reason for the government not to help people. The debt ceiling is complete bullshit, a totally manufactured crisis that doesn't even make sense on paper. They only reason it's happening at all is because the right-wing Democrats thought that instead of just killing it when it was easy to do, they'd use it as an excuse to cut social programs by pretending it had to happen to compromise with Republicans. Then that clever idea fell apart. But it still doesn't matter. It has never mattered.
- bbarn 4y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted, because you're right in principle. (Probably because you insulted both parties at once). Where it does matter is as an excuse to push other agendas through with "emergency" bills to raise it.
- r00fus 4y agoIt's interesting who the USG owes money to. A non-trivial portion is to social security - ie, the government borrowed from the social security trust fund and has yet to pay it back. So politicians vote to borrow against this fund to pay for an astronomical defense budget then unsurprisingly start "sounding the warning" that social security will run out of money...
- gowings97 4y ago"The debt ceiling is complete bullshit" It has an instant impact to value attributed to the currency, which then impacts imports/export prices, which then impacts economic activity. Look at what's happening in South Africa - they thought they issue debt/ print money to paper over social issues, and everything would be Ok. They are finding out that analysis was incorrect.
- s3r3nity 4y ago> But it still doesn't matter. It has never mattered. Following this logic, why pay taxes at all? If the amout of debt the USG taking on is irrelevant and a "scam," then why not just set tax rates to 0%?
- dahfizz 4y agoDon't we go through this like once a year? Everyone freaks out about hitting the debt ceiling and the economy imploding, and then congress just raises the ceiling.
- dboreham 4y agoThat's because the ceiling is a nonsensical concept. They money has already been spent.
- ur-whale 4y ago> and then congress just raises the ceiling. Sure, why worry about debt. If the debt is held internally, we'll just tell the citizens to get over it. If it's held externally, we'll send in the killer robots (via some loser proxy country, of course) until the debt is pardoned. Why worry indeed?
- bdcravens 4y agoMore likely we negotiate the terms of debt forgiveness, such as tariff reductions etc. Domestic debt could be traded in for a permanent tax credit.
- s3r3nity 4y ago> More likely we negotiate the terms of debt forgiveness, such as tariff reductions etc. So instead of controlling our own destiny, we have to hope for good terms from negotiations with the holders of that debt - who can apply increasingly more leverage as the amount of debt they hold increases?
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- api 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tpurves 4y ago[flagged]
- jjtheblunt 4y ago[flagged]
- api 4y agoThe parties flipped in the 1960s through the 1980s.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoYep but I'm being downvoted for being correct, as has become usual on HN the last year or so.
- lowercased 4y agoIt was pretty clear the GP was indicating that Republicans (today) are not satisfied with the outcome of the Civil War. If "the Republicans" and "the Democrats" of today would be in (violent?) disagreement with policies and actions taken by a party with the same name, but over 100+ years ago, why bother referencing their parties at all?
- fauxpause_ 4y agoYou’re being downvoted because your post makes a point that doesn’t matter and is distracting. The origin of the party does not matter.
- tootie 4y agoIt's really a very solvable problem if there was sufficient political will and right now there just isn't. Half the government (and half the voters) are intent on making things worse to secure short-term gains for those that are already in the top half of society. America could easily stand to raise taxes substantially without significantly slowing growth (long-term) and bring deficits back in line.
- thallium205 4y agoIncreasing tax rates will lower government revenues though as history has shown. It's a maximization problem under a curve not some simple linear equation to determine where tax rates should be set. We are arguably close to already having a rate that yields the most collection.
- FrustratedMonky 4y agoThis isn't true. To say Tax Rates go up lowers revenue, I'm assuming you think if Tax Rates go down, then revenue would go up? But during last tax cuts, Rates went down, and Revenue also went down, there was NOT some increase in revenue because people somehow used their extra money more efficiently and thus generating more growth to tax on. Anybody that thinks lowering taxes spurs growth and thus revenue, then what happens if taxes go to 0, shouldn't government revenue go to infinity. This whole, lowering taxes spurs the rick to create more growth is a false narrative.
- tootie 4y agoThat is stupendously untrue. The Laffer Curve is a meaningless tautology crafted by a political hack. No, we cannot set tax rates at 100%. But we can set them way higher than they are now and not cannibalize revenue. Just putting top margins in the 45-50% range would raise a ton of money and not discourage anyone from earning. Ending step up basis would not discourage billionaires from dying.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Increasing tax rates will lower government revenues though as history has shown. History has not shown that. An entirely unempirical claim and a napkin diagram are not the same thing as “history”. > It’s a maximization problem under a curve not some simple linear equation to determine where tax rates should be set. We are arguably close to already having a rate that yields the most collection. “Arguably” is a claim that a reasonable argument with some basis beyond pure speculation can be made for the conclusion offered, but…I’m not seeing the argument for the claim that there are no tax rates in the current system of taxes which could be increased that would lead to a substantial net increase in tax collections. Care to present the argument?
- Pxtl 4y agoYou folks know other countries don't do this silliness right? They don't have an arbitrary debt ceiling they have to constantly raise or else the government goes into torpor? That's just an Americans thing. Also, did The Economist write an article like this when Trump was doing his "big, beautiful tax cut" or does it only matter when Democrats are in power?
- sokoloff 4y agoThere was indeed an anti-GOP article on the debt ceiling in late Nov 2016: https://www.economist.com/free-exchange/2016/11/22/the-hole-at-the-heart-of-economics https://www.economist.com/free-exchange/2016/11/22/the-hole-...
- School-Cotton 4y ago> You folks know other countries don't do this silliness right? They don't have an arbitrary debt ceiling they have to constantly raise or else the government goes into torpor? That's just an Americans thing. The article says exactly this.
- s3r3nity 4y agoYeah that's what leads to situations like the Greek debt crisis [1]. You can't just rack up debt forever, and just assume that we'll pay it back later WITH INTEREST. You also can't just "cancel" debt; the bill eventually comes due. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoThe Greeks didn't have their own money printer though, which makes this situation quite different.
- bediger4000 4y agoIt only matters when Democrats are president.
- N1H1L 4y ago
- dv_dt 4y agoWhen the debt limit is discussed is telling of its use as a cynical political tool. It’s basically debating to pay the bills previously agreed upon to spend with the passing of the budget. If the budget passes so should the debt limit to spend that budget. Our politicians play this game then wonder why other nations are starting to coalesce around other reserve currencies.
- fundad 4y agoThe debt ceiling is as enforceable as false weather report laws are enforceable against sharpie gate. POTUS needs to nut up, issue an EO and see who is going to stop him.
- starkd 4y agoHe doesn't have the power to do that. If he does and gets away with it, don't complain when that power is abused by other presidents in ways you disapprove.
- fundad 4y agoJettisoning the debt limit is the consequence after were no consequences for changing federal weather forecast maps on a whim. The debt ceiling fights only started when BHO won the presidency, 15 years of this nonsense is enough.
- starkd 4y agoYou must be young. Debt limit debate has been going on longer than that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 4y agoI’m not an expert on wether this would be quite legal (or within the “calvinball” bounds of our political system - as the slightly more independent fed would have to go along with the treasury at least). But the point is, repeatedly testing legal corner cases and economic disruption on basic things like will our govt reps allow the govt to spend what they told it to spend is shooting ourself in the foot for political theatre. Nations want a stable financial foundation to transact between other nations. They want a stable reserve currency that doesn’t inject added disruption from political instability. Until recently that was the US dollar that was stable beyond all other currencies.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoBut ... MMT? Is it really Tax and Spend? Or is it Spend and Tax. So for example in 2020 QE cycle in UK the UK gov would spend something like 100BN a month, and would fund that out of borrowing - so it would put 100BN of bonds (gilts) onto the market - which were immediately bought not by pension funds but by the Bank Of England - so basically the UK government owes itself something like a trillion pounds worth of bonds - around 40% of total UK debt. Exactly how does the UK government owe itself money? Our debt to GDP ratio is about half of what everyone says simply because the government printed money. As long as that reflected real world purchasing - nurses and so on - then fine.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- davidw 4y agoThe Economist seems like it is incapable of not doing a "both sides!" with regards to American politics lately and I find it quite frustrating.
- briga 4y agoAre you saying you would prefer them to be more one-sided?
- davidw 4y agoI'm saying you need to look at an issue and the people involved and actually form an opinion sometimes. Not every issue can be split down the middle. An extreme example from US history would be slavery. Most issues are going to have much more nuance than that, but there's usually a better course of action. The Economist has never been just 'straight up journalism', so I expect them to have an informed opinion. Maybe I disagree with it in some cases, and that's fine, but I find this "on one hand... on the other hand" stuff where they go out of their way to dig up something to say for both sides insufferable.
- slg 4y agoWhen one side is using the threat of what the article calls an "outcome [that] would be devastating for global markets" as a negotiating tactic, I would prefer if journalists were more forceful in their criticism of that approach. Sometimes there is an objectively bad option in a political debate. Failing to raise the debt ceiling is one of those. We can have all sorts of debates about the US's debt and how we should cut expenses or raise revenue, but defaulting on our debts to "win" that debate is an objectively bad approach and journalists should make that clear.
- bcrosby95 4y agoIf representatives in congress don't like debt maybe they should pass a balanced budget. The debt ceiling is political theater.
- zyyyyyy 4y ago[flagged]
- maerF0x0 4y ago> “There’s going to be a generation of voters that can’t get anything they want, because all the money has been spoken for.” Interesting to hear an expert take from someone with decades of experience show some empathy to what likely will be GenZ or Gen Alpha. I've been saying for a long time now that govt debt is a very problematic tool because it allows today's leaders to create obligations for folks who didn't vote for them (likely couldnt vote at all). Even in perfect intentions it's not consensual to burden future generations with debts they had no voice in choosing.
- starkd 4y agoI'm still waiting to see the results of the massive infrastructure package that was passed in 2008. We've had a few more rounds of such spending, supposedly because of outdated infrastructure. You have to wonder how many more times they are going to get away with that trick. Whenever they pass massive spending, its clear they are not talking to American people. They are talking to the corporations that are going to benefit.
- MollyRealized 4y agoThis heavily decayed rusty bridge support [1] is under the Chicago Metra Union Pacific Track UP-N line that has 34,000 passengers riding across this bridge on 70 scheduled trains at 50-70 mph each weekday. While it is admittedly just a single example, everyone else's experiences seem equally as anecdotal. [1] - https://www.reddit.com/r/TIHI/comments/u4inmp/thanks_i_hate_this_bridge_support_on_the_active/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TIHI/comments/u4inmp/thanks_i_hate_...
- bitsnbytes 4y agoThis. Some of my clients are in the transportation industry and they were scratching their heads on where that money went.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fundad 4y ago
- padobson 4y agoFor the curious, here's the debt limit bill that passed the Republican-led House of Representatives at the end of April, HR 2811: https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/2811 https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/2811
- tonymet 4y agoDebt and entitlements should be the primary issue for under-40 voters. You are sacrificing your prosperity to pay for an insolvent entitlement system. It’s been insolvent for 50 years and now it is bankrupt. Inflation isn’t a natural mechanism , it’s a way to get people to work harder and longer in exchange for a lower quality of life. The inflation curve shot up in 1971 as a deliberate policy to compensate for a doubling of the work force. Twice as much time spent at work for a lower quality of life. Money and debt are just proxy indicators for time. Vote like your life depends on it, because it does.
- N1H1L 4y agoThis is really not correct actually from an economics standpoint. The perfect inflation rate is not zero, and negative is definitely bad.
- tonymet 4y agofor all the down-voters – this isn’t endorsing the debt ceiling or GOP ( i know how that may startle hackernews readers). IT’s urging people to make debt a national issue, and to vote out the pensioners who are stealing our prosperity
- tonymet 4y agoalright i got up to 0. that's pretty good on HN
- djoldman 4y agoHad to look this one up: "swingeing": (chiefly British) : very large, high, or severe https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/swingeing https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/swingeing
- simonblack 4y agoThe current ceiling for gross debt is $31.4trn (117% of gdp), and America is careening towards it. If the debt is supposed to be no higher than set percentage of the GDP, and the GDP drops, shouldn't the debt-ceiling also drop? Or is setting a debt-ceiling just so much bullshit theatrics that should be done away with entirely?