14 ms·
Europeans drain billions from banks, fed up with shrinking savings
- rntn 4y agohttps://archive.is/6EaU1 https://archive.is/6EaU1
- LinuxBender 4y agoI do not believe this is limited to the EU. Anecdotally a grocery store clerk was venting to me here in the U.S. that everyone was paying in cash.
- ghaff 4y agoI'm not sure how keeping your cash under the mattress and paying for groceries with it is an improvement. That said, there's a pretty clear bifurcation between a lot of retail banks that are happy to make money off all the small accounts and lazy money in checking accounts and the brokerage money market and other accounts paying around 4% or so these days which are actively pursuing deposits.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI'm not sure how keeping your cash under the mattress and paying for groceries with it is an improvement. Not to mention peoples money would smell like their beds. I prefer using safes for quick access things and deep unmarked holes for longer term storage. One of my methods is to pay extra for services so that I keep a credit on each account such as internet, power, etc... I also keep about 100 gallons of fuel with fuel stabilizer and SeaFoam. I believe the logic is that if one has enough cash on-hand and their bank gets into trouble, they can still pay for food, fuel and other basic things to get by. It probably won't help for paying large bills like rent and mortgage unless people risk keeping a lot more cash on-hand. One can go into their brick and mortar bank to pay cash for their mortgage. It's good to do this periodically to pay extra towards the principal and shorten the loan duration.
- majewsky 4y ago> It probably won't help for paying large bills like rent and mortgage For what it's worth, where I live (in Germany), it's usually just plain impossible to pay rent or mortgages in cash. The landlord or mortgage provider will instead use SEPA Direct Debit to pull the money out of your bank account directly. When I see a US-made movie where the landlord knocks on someone's door to collect rent in cash, it's rather bewildering. In Germany, any sentence that includes the phrase "paid rent in cash" probably starts or ends with "this is how I got scammed".
- rootusrootus 4y ago> When I see a US-made movie where the landlord knocks on someone's door to collect rent in cash, it's rather bewildering That might be the result of thinking movies bear any resemblance to reality. Approximately nobody pays rent in cash in the US, either. But movies are about telling stories, not describing how things really are.
- ghaff 4y ago>Approximately nobody pays rent in cash in the US, either. At least above a certain income level if they're not paying someone off the books or maybe splitting a bill with friends/family (and even that is often some digital payment or a check) cash is increasingly uncommon. I don't think I've withdrawn money from an ATM in a couple years. And, certainly rent/mortgage, it would be almost unheard of in most situations. No one wants to be handling thousands of dollars in cash in an urban area.
- ethbr0 4y agoI'd hazard to say a fair amount of low-income rentals are still paid in cash. It's not like the "don't declare income" slice of the economy disappeared. If you're paid in cash but not declaring it, you probably want to pay rent in cash too. Quick search, but unbanked seems a good proxy for "pay with cash": https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html From the above, somewhere between 4.5% (average) and ~8% (low income African-American and Hispanic) people do not have a bank account. Add in some more who choose not to declare, and it's a small but significantly non-zero number.
- bushbaba 4y agoA lot of people sent paying taxes. I the recent reporting of digital payments. Cash had become more Common
- ta988 4y agoYeah a lot of money is not declared, like tips (another reason this should be banned). So people need to use it for less trackable by IRS things.
- devjab 4y agoI think you should see this more as people putting their money into different investment platforms rather than people withdrawing massive amounts of cash and keeping it under their mattresses. When you invest a minimum of 100k Euro your options open up significantly in Europe. This is because our consumer protection laws have lower requirements for what is deemed semi-professional investors and up, which makes it easier for companies to be caretakers of your money. Right now things are slowing down, and have been for a while. Not so much because demands are declining, but because interest rates are increasing. Which means a lot of people are looking to put their money into safer options than what they have been for the past decade or so. Traditionally this would have been (or at least involved) banks, but because many banks have been slow to drop their negative interest rates on in-loans, they are also very unattractive options when you're looking to store your savings. At the same time, banks have been a little slow to react to the fact that there are now a lot of stable options for those €100K+ investments because their primary focus has been on loaning and not in-loaning. I wouldn't worry too much about the banks unless you have stock options in them or work for one. Especially if you don't have more savings than what is covered by your government. But pulling money out to keep as cash would only really make sense if you're paying a lot of money to keep them in the bank, and if that's the case, I'd probably look for a different bank first. Depending on where you live in the world of course.
- thatguy0900 4y agoI wonder what the actual process is for if your bank fails. Does the government cut you a check or do you have to wait a couple months with no access to your money before seeing any kind of insurance payout?
- devjab 4y agoI suppose it depends on where you live. In Denmark when some of our banks failed in 2007-2008 the government simply assumed ownership of the banking operation until the healthy business (regular people) could be sold and transferred to other banks. I think something similar happened with Silicon Valley bank, didn’t it? It’s typically not too disruptive for regular people. For investors, institutional loaners and people who have more money than what is covered by your country’s laws or the banks insurance, you will likely have to wait for a lengthy bankruptcy process to see what remains of your money beyond what is covered. Typically in-loans will be quite high on the bankruptcy priority list, but sometimes there won’t be enough money to cover much of it. Often there will also be various lawsuits in the wake of a bank failing, as investors try to get what they can. Where it can be severely disruptive is if your company has money in the bank exceeding the “regular people” amount. Because that would mean your company would have to wait for the bankruptcy process to obtain access to its funds.
- ab_testing 4y agoSo, where are they putting in the money. Reading the article, it is not very clear, but it looks like there a slight shift from Savings Accounts to Money Market Accounts. In the end, I think it is just shuffling money between banks. Nobody is stuffing their money in the mattress anymore.
- hgsgm 4y ago"people moving money to higher interest accounts now that those have returned" is not a clickworthy headline.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lifeonlars 4y agoThere are much higher rates available for brokered deposits via Raisin or Zinspilot. These are also with banks. They're just less well-known banks and not typically in the countries which have the most and richest savers.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>So, where are they putting in the money. Mostly real estate that can be bought in cash without a mortgage. Everything that's under 300k seems to be bought instantly in cash and put on the market for rent. In case you wonder why real estate prices haven't dropped significantly in Europe that's why. The demands is still high and many people with inherited wealth are still liquid enough.
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Mostly real estate that can be bought in cash without a mortgage. So then where are the sellers putting their cash? This is a closed system.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 4y agoI must admit it looks like I will be proven wrong; I was assuming when the crisis hit cryptocurrencies would collapse immediately. Relative to the more traditional markets though they seem fine. If the ecosystem keeps doing what it does, in a few years people will have settled on a fair price for hash power and then it'll be quite competitive against these unreliable financial institutions. Someone is going to be subsidising all the largess the regulators are going to have to distribute. That might make the cost of sustaining Bitcoin's energy burn look like the cheap option.
- WrtCdEvrydy 4y ago> I was assuming when the crisis hit cryptocurrencies would collapse immediately. It depends on faith in the system... if the green line stays green, why pull? same argument for any other market like the stock market or housing market.
- pjc50 4y agoCryptocurrencies operate as their own universe, which is only loosely tied to the real world's "good news" and "bad news". In either direction. Which makes it risky to bet against. At least Balaji paid out on his ridiculous hyperinflation bet. > the cost of sustaining Bitcoin's energy burn look like the cheap option No, this needs to have the plug pulled on it if we're to keep global warming to 2C.
- mvuksano 4y agoI wonder if all the banks in the world consume more energy vs Bitcoin network? What if we didn't have these big institutions that employ hundreds of thousands of people to basically increment and decrement a counter in a computer. Imagine all costs that we wouldn't have to incur (e.g transport to work, operating buildings, etc). Today's banks seem very archaic.
- kibwen 4y agoThis misses the point of a bank, which is not to increment a value in a database, but to provide risk management.
- hnburnsy 4y agoIf Europe is like the Fed then... >Deposits into MMF flow right back to the banking sector https://fedguy.com/primer-a-deposits-life/#more-6181 https://fedguy.com/primer-a-deposits-life/#more-6181
- H8crilA 4y agoFriendly reminder that you cannot remove money like that from circulation (unless you literally burn it), it just goes into another account or transforms from the digital form to the printed form. Only reducing the overall debt level reduces the amount of money.
- hestefisk 4y agoWell, you can certainly withdraw cash and stash it in your bed, pillow or mattress at home.
- H8crilA 4y agoYeah, and at the margin all it does is it incurs a small cost at the bill printing facility. Nothing else changes, since the central banks can and will freely convert base digital money into bills, without limit.
- neilwilson 4y agoYou can, but that is just a receipt for a part of a deposit held by whoever issues the notes. It's not actually the money...
- pjc50 4y agoThe difference between the various "Mnumber" values for money supply can be affected by where you put it, though.
- timthelion 4y agoActually you can remove money from circulation by buying T-bills from the fed.
- H8crilA 4y agoNo, because the money goes to whoever sold you the tbills. This may or may not be the Treasury.
- 4y ago
- PaywallBuster 4y ago> Money market funds are proving popular among savers seeking bigger returns on their cash as high levels of inflation persist. so, basically the same thing happening in the US
- hospitalJail 4y agoAnd if you have enough money, buy real estate. Wonder why real estate is so expensive... There is some narrative I've seen here and on reddit that inflation is 2-4% because the government says so. People are so confident about it. Meanwhile big brains and small brain meme are saying "no way are these inflation numbers real". Something something Bitcoin(no not other coins, just bitcoin, no not blockchain, just bitcoin), something something federal reserve/fractional reserve banking, something something we are supposed to believe inflationary currencies are good for me.
- ketzu 4y agoThey nicely provide an anchor point for reference on how much money is held in accounts: > 9.45 trillion euros held in current, or checking, accounts at banks across the euro zone. Deutsche Bank, one of the examples, reported higher reductions in deposits, offers 0.4% interest with no daily access. [1, 19th of April] One of the popular directs banks (DKB) offers 1% [2] A popular free trading platform (trade republic) offers 2% for uninvested money [3] So I wonder what the overall change in deposits actually is compared to those 9.45 trillion euros, it doesn't seem that surprising when the big examples in the articles have the lowest interest. Are people also leaving the higher interest banks? [1] https://www.boerse-online.de/nachrichten/geldundvorsorge/postbank-und-deutsche-bank-erhoehen-schon-wieder-tagesgeld-so-viele-zinsen-gibt-es-jetzt-20330388.html https://www.boerse-online.de/nachrichten/geldundvorsorge/pos... [2] https://bank.dkb.de/privatkunden/sparen/tagesgeldkonto https://bank.dkb.de/privatkunden/sparen/tagesgeldkonto [3] https://traderepublic.com/de-de/zinsen https://traderepublic.com/de-de/zinsen
- timthelion 4y agoThere are no high interest banks. 2% in EU is very high interest.
- ketzu 4y agoSorry, I don't understand what you mean by that. Could you explain? The 1% and 2% examples are not from the article as one of the losing deposit examples, just my comparisons because I am familiar with them. So I wonder if they also report reduced deposits. (I am probably not even using the correct financial instrument to compare, it's just one easy to look up.) So I wondered if consumers using the low interest banks (like Deutsche Bank with 0.4%) are mostly just switching to higher interest banks (like DKB with 1.0%) and the actual change to those 9.45 trillion euros is not in the tens of billions, as suggested by the article (e.g. Deutsche Bank with nearly 5% in change in deposits), but instead is closer to a few billions. In context of 9.45 trillion, that would be ~0.1%, which does not sound too worrying.
- sandstrom 4y agoIf I lock my money with the bank for 3 months, I can get 3.5%. Otherwise it's currently 2.6%. (those are vanilla rates offered to everyone, btw, nothing special)
- sschueller 4y agoGood thing Switzerland kept it's CHF 1000 notes while the EU dumped their EUR 500 notes. Of course it's stupid to keep cash with inflation at the current rate but you should always keep some emergency cash around. Then again some banks have such high fees you might as well keep the money in cash in a safe.
- canadiantim 4y agoGold/Silver is best in this situation. Don't have to worry about inflation, but you still have it in case of emergencies
- prottog 4y agoThe bid/ask spread is too wide on precious metals to be useful as a transactional currency. I guess in a true societal collapse-type emergency maybe it'll be useful, but at that point canned food, guns, and ammo might be more valuable.
- horv 4y agoRight, I think it's helpful to define the most probable types of emergencies where having a non-electronic form of payment is useful. In the US that's likely some sort of natural disaster (hurricane, snow storm, blackout or brownout during the summer). Going to your local grocer and using cash won't raise any eyebrows where I'm not sure how likely anyone is to accept gold or silver in one of those situations.
- kipchak 4y agoVenezuela is one example before societal collapse where gold has been useful as a currency.
- flerchin 4y agoVenezuela has pretty well collapsed.
- 4y ago
- MrDresden 4y agoThe percentage Icelandic banks (by memory) have had on normal deposit accounts, locked somewhere between 3-36 months has been around 2-3% over the last few years, and effectively 0% on checking accounts. Now, with inflation running rampant, the percentages have reached up to 7+% (Central Bank interest rates are 7.5% and inflation measures at 9.9%). I am in the privilaged position to be able to gain more in interest on a considerable deposit at a local bank (which is unlocked I might add) then what my total monthly mortage interests now come to (close to 1.8x). In addition since the mortage allows for direct deposits into the principal without incurring any additional cost, each Krona that gets put into it has effectively the same buying power as when the loan was initially taken. It is a peculiar state of affairs.
- noja 4y agoIceland should offer high interest savings accounts to non-Icelanders! Oh wait...
- MrDresden 4y agoI've always found it rather fitting that two previous European colonizers had a previous colony (though not one of theirs) do a bit of modern day financial pillaging on their shores. In the end though, they did get paid back all that they were owed. So all ended well. I wonder if the same can be said about any of their former colonies though...
- GordonS 4y agoI got caught up it this around 10 years back. Got my money back, but it took over a year to get it. Needless to say, since then I've paid attention to how deposits are guaranteed for any accounts I open.
- throwaway19423 4y agoRegarding 1.8x, what is your tax rate? I have the same situation in Canada but my marginal tax rate is approx 50%. As such, it is better for me to pay down my mortgage (through early payments).
- dharma1 4y agoBanks are in a tight spot. They have short term liabilities (depositors might want to pull their funds out whenever) and primarily long term assets (loans), except for the cash buffer they get overnight deposit rate for from central banks. Some of that long term debt interest is fixed at lower rates than current interest rates, so the banks can’t offer the same risk-free return on deposits as money market funds that collect the current rates from short term government bonds. The longer the high interest rates continue, the more deposits will flow out into money market funds and treasuries in search of higher risk-free yield. As time goes on, more and more banks are affected by this, potentially needing bail outs if they can’t cover the depositor outflows. They have higher cash reserves than before GFC, but if there are enough outflows, those reserves won’t be enough.
- candiodari 4y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/feb/21/banks-record-profits-windfall-tax https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/feb/21/banks-... If this is your definition of a tight spot ... I'd love to be in that sort of tight spot.
- chrisco255 4y ago^ this is a very thin piece, used to push a narrative. Cherry picking 5 particular banks and their Q4 2022 fiscal results does not tell you what is happening right now. Since that article was posted in February, we've had 3 major U.S. banks fail representing $532 billion in total assets and Credit Suisse collapsed in March, with Swiss government providing $108 billion to back a purchase by UBS. The banking system is in bad shape right now, and we don't really know how many more will fail.
- j-bos 4y agoMaybe the commenter is refering to small-midsized banks.
- dharma1 4y agoIf Berkshire sold out of most of their bank holdings, that should tell you something. Large banks are broadly fine for now (cough Credit Suisse cough), but there are a lot of small/midsize banks that are more vulnerable, enough to have some contagion effect. If more start failing, spooked depositors with more small/midsize banks start pulling their money out and move it to large banks - possibly collapsing more of the smaller ones. And we haven't even started seeing bad commercial real estate loans hit banks. https://www.ft.com/content/da9f8230-2eb1-49c5-b63a-f1507936d01b https://www.ft.com/content/da9f8230-2eb1-49c5-b63a-f1507936d... The next one in line could be this https://twitter.com/elerianm/status/1654073420328452096 https://twitter.com/elerianm/status/1654073420328452096
- NoboruWataya 4y agoWorth noting that policymakers in the EU have long recognised that Europe's small capital markets and over-reliance on banks is a problem and hampers economic recovery/growth. The Capital Markets Union project[0] is largely about trying to build deeper capital markets so that savers have other places to put their money and companies have other ways to raise financing. The rise of MMFs isn't necessarily a bad thing if that money can be effectively channelled back into the real economy. [0] https://finance.ec.europa.eu/capital-markets-union-and-financial-markets/capital-markets-union/what-capital-markets-union_en https://finance.ec.europa.eu/capital-markets-union-and-finan...
- pelorat 4y agoSeeing as society is mostly cashless here, what else should you rely on if not for banks?
- nikanj 4y agoCapital from wealthy individuals and private investment funds
- hsjqllzlfkf 4y agoWow this is super interesting! Thank you!
- tibbydudeza 4y agoOnly reason why I use a bank is for the payment of my bills, definitely not for their investment savvy or making my money grow, already getting nickled and dimed for card payments/cash withdrawals and printing statements.
- biztos 4y agoBefore Commerzbank unceremoniously canceled my account after more than a decade of business, they were charging me “negative interest” for quite a while, on anything over 50K EUR. That’s in addition to account fees. My current banks in the EU? One charges up to 1% percent per transaction and yes, that includes going to the bank to make a withdrawal. Another charges 40€ per month for a basic savings account. A third will probably kick me out soon, because I’m not an EU citizen. My first guess would be that Europeans have a perception that their banks are exploiting them, and given any other rational option they will try it out.
- rajin444 4y agoAren’t they? Banks are out to make a profit not better the lives of their customers. Certain industries are nationalized for good reason.
- wyager 4y agoAmerican banks don't rip us off to that degree. They aren't nationalized. The biggest rip-off in American banking is that narrow banking is effectively illegal (not the banks' fault), but HYSAs are starting to get around that.
- xp84 4y ago> to that degree An important qualifier! I get the impression that probably 95% of consumer deposits in the US either earn zero interest or some comically low rate like 0.00121% that all of the big banks offer on their savings, Interest Checking, and even "money market" accounts. And they also exploit people with monthly fees that can only be waived with minimum balances or by jumping through hoops like debit card usage. And "using other ATM" fees from 2 banks at once usually. But apparently it could be worse with transaction fees and negative interest! I feel like the few in the US who are savvy about personal finance have found the banks/CUs (i won't list them to avoid sounding promotional) that don't do any of the above. It doesn't say in the article where they are seeing these outflows actually go. I wonder if Europe also has good banking options that not everyone is aware of.
- FpUser 4y ago>"Andy Halford, chief financial officer at Standard Chartered, told Reuters he thought people would ultimately prioritise security over interest payouts." Security my ass when deposits effectively evaporate given inflation rate all while banks rake up the profits.
- EGreg 4y agoFor everyone deriding Web3 and Bitcoin etc. I'll make a prediction... We'll end up with decentralized money on secure, decentralized platforms owned by communities of people, instead of banks, soon. What's missing is simply scalability and user adoption of local community currencies. If you are curious how it could possibly happen, here are the steps to actually get it done in any community: https://community.intercoin.app/t/rolling-out-voluntary-basic-income-in-communities https://community.intercoin.app/t/rolling-out-voluntary-basi... Or in PDF form: https://intercoin.org/communities.pdf https://intercoin.org/communities.pdf What if our money supply would come not just from bank underwriters guessing how a business will do in 10 years, and risk managers guessing what interests rates will be, etc. Instead, it will come form communities of all kinds. ("But how will we pay for it?" By removing money from circulation via taxes and fees.) Each community can be the source and sink of its own money supply, instead of the banks, who are motivated not by social good but by profit motive. I know some people will knee-jerk downvote this because it's talking about Web3 again. I'm not talking about ponzi schemes or speculative bubbles. I'm talking about communities issuing their own currency to their own members, whether they're online (e.g. HN Karma) or offline (VegasCoin). Just because Web3 has been overrun by green and the profit motive doesn't mean the idea of communities having their own smart economies with their own monetary and fiscal policy is not good. Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. (Look at my posts... I'm essentially a libertarian communist going back years, so someone like me might buck the trend of assholes who are just in it for the grift.)
- secondcoming 4y agoHow can I pay for food or my electricity bill with HackerNewsCoin? Enough with this bullshit please.
- EGreg 4y agoSo self-assured. Did you even see the link to the pdf? It explains… 1) Give the tools for any community to release their own coin 2) Communities pay the coin for participation or doing something (eg Hacker News karma). Maybe have a UBI to everyone so they can vote with their wallet. Upvotes are coin transfers etc. 3) Make the coin usable for local advertising or by local vendors. This is the WORK the community has to do (not us) same as VISA and Mastercard network had to do!! 4) Allow people to buy the local coin in a decentralized way. Now each coin becomes exchangeable all for other coins. 5) Intercoin network. Converts any coin to any other coin. Once your local farmer and electric company accepts YOUR city’s local coin, then you pay for food or your electricity bill, using hackernews coin, transparently. Intercoin is to value what Internet is to communication. We are building an internet of value. It’s completely voluntary. If you don’t want to use it, don’t. If you want to shit on it, at least learn about it first.
- penguin_booze 4y agoFor those in the UK, checkout rcibank.co.uk: instant access saving accounts, currently offering 3.4% interest. I'd be interested to if there's anything that beats that rate.
- Duplo 4y agohttps://www.moneysavingexpert.com/savings/savings-accounts-best-interest/#easyaccess https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/savings/savings-accounts-b... Chip app with 3.71%
- Taurenking 4y ago[dead]
- kakoni 4y agoWonder what are typical interest rates for European mortgage loans currently? In Finland we are talking about 4-5% and interests are not deductible in your taxation(used to be, not anymore)
- e-brake 4y agoGood. It isn't competitive for these big banks to continue to offer 0% interest rates! In Portugal I landed on "Certificados de aforro" which gets you on the road to 3.5% on EUR, secured, with liquidity. Would love to see more daily savings options beyond risky fintech apps!
- moffkalast 4y agoJust a 0% interest rate and nothing else would be very competitive for the average EU bank, since the standard is a few cents of interest while being robbed with monthly fees, so the effective rate is negative.
- InCityDreams 4y ago[Threaten to] Open a gdpr case on them (as an eu resident). Article 15 iirc is always a good start.