32 ms·
NYPD urges citizens to buy AirTags to fight surge in car thefts
- aetherane 4y agoUnfortunately air tags only work in the Apple ecosystem.
- smoldesu 4y ago"Buy your mom an iPhone" - Tim Cook, 2022
- vrc 4y agoYou’ve misspelled Tim Apple, sir.
- Manjuuu 4y agoSee this regarding android phones: https://www.youtube.com/live/Vuw72THyXsQ?feature=share&t=947 https://www.youtube.com/live/Vuw72THyXsQ?feature=share&t=947 "Why would anyone have one?"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oh_sigh 4y agoThat's not true - Tracker Detect is available for android, so even car thieves with an android can find your airtag.
- commoner 4y agoTracker Detect only scans for AirTags when the user manually requests a scan. Car thieves and other users who do not want to be tracked by AirTags would be better off using the AirGuard app on Android, which scans for AirTags and other Bluetooth tracking devices in the background automatically: https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard AirGuard is a FOSS project developed by the Technical University of Darmstadt.
- politelemon 4y agoThis article throws up many flags for me, not necessarily red, but of a worrying color. It first celebrates surveillance devices as a net positive and hand-waves away its problems. But most importantly, it is awfully shortsighted to allow a single company to entrench itself further into societal transactions. However, hearing it is inconvenient, so I am often dismissed for saying so. > They're made by Apple, which means they're very platform-agnostic. You mean platform-specific. > "Why would anyone have one [an Android phone]?" Mayor Adams responded. Again... this level of ignorance and short-sightedness is surprising coming from someone in such a position of authority, and seems to ignore the realities of the world. Perhaps Mayor Adams spends too much time on HN?
- tohnjitor 4y agoYou must not be familiar with American politicians.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoHave they always been this way or have they all become wildly out of touch more recently? To an outsider, American political discourse looks like it is completely divorced from reality.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoMaking a joke about how iPhones are better is basically the opposite of out of touch. Most new yorkers agree, and 90% of the others are used to the joke.
- hot_gril 4y agoI forget which late night show this was, but the guy said he wouldn't switch from his iPhone even if it punched him in the face every morning. That's not offensive humor anywhere except here and maybe within Google.
- morkalork 4y ago
- Logans_Run 4y agoFrom TFA Mayor Adams was asked during the press conference if AirTags work with Android (they don't). "Why would anyone have one [an Android phone]?" Mayor Adams responded. Oh and given that this in New York we're talking about here, the vigilante mob are gonna go wild for this, especially after Citizen worked out so well .... But by last month, Frame was enthusiastically backing the idea of manhunts, according to screenshots of internal company communications seen by NBC News and first reported by Motherboard [1] [1] "Inside Citizen: The public safety app pushing surveillance boundaries" https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/citizen-public-safety-app-pushing-surveillance-boundaries-rcna1058 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/citizen-public-safety...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Why would anyone have one [an Android phone]?" Mayor Adams responded This is a New Yorker’s response to a stupid question. AirTags have a recognised brand. Messaging “buy AirTags” comes through cleanly in a way an inclusive statement would not. Given nobody is burning city funds for this, it’s literally a PSA, a reporter asking the mayor technical questions the answer to which they know is fine to be answered dismissively.
- stefan_ 4y agoNYC is burning tons of city funds on police to solve ever fewer cases.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoHow is that relevant?
- WheatMillington 4y agoDid you miss the part where the city is giving away 500 air tags? It's right at the start of the article. You did read the article, didn't you?
- 4y ago
- platevoltage 4y agoI use Airtags for this purpose with my car and my bicycle, but they're not designed for this purpose. You can pull the speaker coil out of them fairly easily, but they will still notify the thief that they're being tracked if they have an iPhone on them. Not ideal, but it beats having a huge epidemic of stalking.
- pnw 4y agoThey will also notify an Android phone if they have installed the app which Apple created for this purpose. I have to imagine thieves would know about this.
- tssva 4y agoA thief can use the Apple provided app to discover if there is a tag, but I don't know that I would say it notifies them since unlike on an iPhone it would require the thief to actively open the app and perform a manual scan for the tag.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThat's a distinction that doesn't really matter, because a thief is going to have that app installed and open after they've stolen something.
- commoner 4y agoThat's true for Apple's Tracker Detect app, but any thief or other user could simply use the free and open source AirGuard app on Android, which has more functionality than both Tracker Detect and the AirTag anti-tracking features built into iOS: https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard https://github.com/seemoo-lab/AirGuard For example, AirGuard lets the user activate the alarm on any AirTag in range immediately without waiting any period of time. iOS and Tracker Detect only let the user do this if they determine that the AirTag is following the user, and Tracker Detect adds another 10 minute waiting period for no good reason.
- dom96 4y agoPrecisely what I did when I got my first car. Though I often wonder how effective it will be, wouldn't be surprised if the thief notices the AirTag's presence fairly quickly.
- dinkblam 4y agoi am unsure how AirTags can be recommended by anyone in any situation to prevent theft. their "anti-tracking" features make them completely useless in any situation where theft is involved (or theft happens after loosing the item). the thief is alerted to their presence automatically and can disable them quickly. perfect for thieves! AirTags can only be used for misplaced items, any utility for situations involving theft is completely negated by their "anti tracking" features. another case where giving a 0.01% case too much attention makes the normal 99.99% use case completely impossible..
- briffle 4y agoI have a 'family' setup in our iphones for my wife and kids. My wife bought some airtags and put them in the cases for our kids expensive musical instruments, her keys, etc. We are configured as a family to share apps, set screen times, etc, but I can't see where those tags are, only my wife can on her phone. Worse, I get warnings every time I use her car for the day, that it found an uknown airtag riding with me. Or when she rides with me in the passenger seat of my vehicle, and has her purse with her. They are essentially less than worthless, and cause a ton of false alerts, so 3/4ths of our family have them blocked and ignore any airtag alert, because we assume its one of hers.
- rootusrootus 4y agoAnd if your kids are young enough not to have their own phone, when they go to school with an AirTag it'll start beeping a while later just to make sure nobody is stalking them. It was a nice idea until all the people worried about stalking got involved. Never mind that a skilled stalker won't waste time or take the risk with an AirTag.
- DaveExeter 4y agoWhat if the thieves don't have an iPhone?
- dinkblam 4y agothieves using Android can just install the "air tag anti tracking" app for Android.
- yieldcrv 4y agomake sure to get a decoy airtag, so that your other airtag doesn't get found
- zzzeek 4y agowho here can already see clearly the NYPD officer's completely blank stare when you show them exactly where the car thief took your car. "did you see them do it? otherwise it's not our problem"
- beembeem 4y agoHave already seen this with other stolen property with other PDs across the country. - "It's too risky" - "not valuable enough" - "could be dangerous" - "can't prove your stolen item is where the GPS says" - "can't dispatch an officer or detective just because you have a GPS location" etc etc
- oh_sigh 4y agoDon't forget: "Are you sure you didn't let them borrow the car?"
- sitkack 4y agoI had someone steal my keys with an airtag on them in Seattle. Cops said they were going to send someone after making me file a police report, screenshots of Find My, etc. Call them an hour later, "oh yeah, no officers responded, we are too busy, good luck!" and this was on a slow-ass sunday around Greenlake. Recovered the keys myself. Good thing they have a 355M budget. https://www.seattle.gov/documents/Departments/FinanceDepartment/22adoptedbudget/SPD.pdf https://www.seattle.gov/documents/Departments/FinanceDepartm...
- icelancer 4y agoSPD does much the same for me. I had my laptop tracked using Prey software (prior to Airtags) and they refused to send cops to a location I personally scouted out, took pictures of, and identified my equipment. When I told them I might confront the thief on my own, they strongly cautioned against it. Basically they aren't interested in doing their job, or anyone taking action themselves.
- 4y ago
- rolph 4y agohow does this not become giveaway stalkerware, instead of vehicle tracking, remove the noisemaker thing, and its just a matter of victim not having an ios phone to out the stalker airtag.
- alexb_ 4y ago[flagged]
- ActorNightly 4y agoPolice do plenty good behind the scenes, you just never hear about it on the media. In fact, the solution is to increase funding specifically to attract quality people and provide adequate training. You want quality officers patrolling neighborhoods preventing the car theft happening in the first place.
- fdsavalkj 4y ago> Defund the police. Not for any socialist reasons, or because they're racist or whatever people are angry about - but because they are so incompetent at their job Who on Earth thinks the answer to attracting competent people to a middle-class job is lowering pay?
- teddyh 4y agoDefunding the police does not necessarily mean lowering their pay. https://mudcompany.thecomicseries.com/comics/148/ https://mudcompany.thecomicseries.com/comics/148/
- wskish 4y agoI wish more hardware products supported the "embedded airtag" feature enabled by the Apple Find My program that enables 3rd party manufactures to effectively embed airtags into their products. https://mfi.apple.com https://mfi.apple.com
- MikeKusold 4y agoI wish Apple supported that in their Airpod case.
- stereo 4y agoDo any hardware products support it at all?
- mataug 4y agoYea Vanmoof bikes and a few other products support this. TBH not enough products support it https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211331 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211331
- grumple 4y agoI've been doing this for a while with my car. Removed the speakers. Hid them in an inconvenient location that requires some minor disassembly of the car. I use it all the time to figure out where my car is since my wife and I share and have street parking and live in a busy area. I also slip airtags into my somewhat expensive jackets when going to events with coat check.
- whoisstan 4y agoHis infamous search your home video comes to mind as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sk2Wc4Y5CxE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sk2Wc4Y5CxE
- bagels 4y agoWho is putting all these drugs and guns in his house? Weird.
- laweijfmvo 4y agoHow is car theft in 2023 still a problem? What happens to a stolen car? It doesn't seem feasible or realistic to try to sell it for parts (where are you going to store all these cars before/after parting them out), and there's no way you can just sell the car and expect it not to get flagged. WTF is going on?
- Vvector 4y agoMany stolen cars are transported out of the country
- Blahah 4y agoThey either get reworked in a chop shop, stripped for parts and then the remainder used for scrap, or they get shipped abroad for resale
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rolph 4y agobody panels and related polymer. interior re-options, operations like that have established shops, and compounds. they just have to be wary of buying from a "heatscore" with cops on thier tail.
- rootusrootus 4y agoOn the contrary, pulling apart a car and selling it for parts is frequently worth more than the car itself on the used market. It's especially profitable when you've stolen the car. The hardest part is probably getting rid of the parts of the shell that have VINs stamped into them.
- bagels 4y agoUsed to be that they would drive it somewhere quiet, pull parts off, and leave the carcas on the side of the road. At least, that's what happened to my cars a few times in the early 2000's.
- pcurve 4y agoRemember Lojack?
- paulddraper 4y agoI mean....it's not a bad suggestion, right? Suppose you had the task of limiting and recovering of car thefts. Tracking the location from your phone would help, yes? I'm ideologically opposed to Mayor Adams in pretty much every way, but I don't see how this suggestion is a bad one.
- pnw 4y agoThis is a terrible suggestion because Apple has effectively removed the anti-theft features of Airtags in favor of protection against stalking. The thief will be notified of the tag in less than an hour usually. I see the alert anytime I mind my friends dog. Typically within 45-60 minutes of my friend leaving, I get an alert which includes a map of where I was tracked and my friends email address. The original Airtag use case included theft but you'll notice any mention of that has now been removed from the marketing material. It's really just for people who lose things.
- WWLink 4y ago> The thief will be notified of the tag in less than an hour usually. I see the alert anytime I mind my friends dog. Typically within 45-60 minutes of my friend leaving, I get an alert which includes a map of where I was tracked and my friends email address. To be fair, 45-60 minutes to track a stolen car is still a lot better than nothing.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI'm not sure how the notification stops the thief. If you're half decent at hiding things they won't be able to find it in less than half an hour, so they either stop and look during which time you can catch them or they abandon the car and you get it back since it's still being tracked.
- jtbayly 4y agoI don’t recommend going and confronting a car thief. And I doubt the police will be there in half an hour. You’ll be lucky to convince them you have the location sometime the next day, when it’s far too late.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoEric adams does recommend confronting a car thief I guess. Really it just depends on the situation, plenty of New Yorkers would be game. Might even prefer it to hoping the cops deal with it. Personally if my only choice was ask cops for help I'd consider the car gone. I can round up a few of the boys and confront the thief given an hour or two, and at least I'd get my car back. No idea if NYPD is as worthless as my pd though.
- bastard_op 4y agoThen directly before this article I see posted from slashdot "Apple and Google Team Up To Stop Unwanted AirTag Tracking". So which is it.
- meteor333 4y agoHonest question: why dont modern cars come with similar functionality as AirTags or 'Find my phone'?
- jonahbenton 4y agoSo sick of Adams. There have been some legendary lightweight NYC Mayors (and some heavyweights as well of course) but in modern times Adams takes the cake.
- vtashkov_oblon 4y ago[flagged]
- TheDudeMan 4y agoI assumed all new cars had GPS devices in them already, phoning home to the manufacturer. Is this not the case?
- tracker1 4y agoMany do... Although mine doesn't function anymore, since it is a 3G cell modem and well after 4G/LTE had become normalized (car companies and dated tech, who would figure). I never used it, so didn't bother to update last year when they finally offered an upgrade option. My SO's new car definitely has it (OnStar) although the Android Auto UX is better IMO.
- INeedMoreRam 4y ago[dead]
- nwellinghoff 4y agoBetter idea. Maybe car manufacturers could introduce 2 factor to start your car. Of course one could disable this. But when you feel you are in a shady spot. Your car prompts your phone to enable two factor to start etc
- thepasswordis 4y agoHere's an even better idea: car theft should be practically non-existent in a modern, western city and instead of the mayor telling people to put airtags in their car he should be announcing how the literal armed police force he commands will be dealing with the issue.
- alfalfasprout 4y agoAfter years of being subjected to property crime including multiple car breakins, getting threatened at knife point by crazy folks on the street, and seeing a woman on my street get forcibly abducted into a car with the police refusing to even report the crimes in all cases we left San Francisco. What's worse is bringing up how this is not OK gets you called some extremist nutjob. Sad to see NYC is now in a similar state where they'd rather penalize the victims than the perpetrators.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> What's worse is bringing up how this is not OK gets you called some extremist nutjob. I'm going to go ahead and bet you said something other than "this is not OK" about crime and bad policing, if you got that reaction. Or you put that statement somewhere with very bad context.
- brink 4y agoIf they could implement this on an open protocol, that'd be great too. The last thing I need is some proprietary cloud service that goes down twice a month to start my car. But what would be even better is just enabling a password.
- Animats 4y agoLoJack used to be the go-to company for this. No more. Classic LoJack had good privacy. It's a box hidden somewhere in the car, with a connection to vehicle power. It has a transmitter, but normally doesn't transmit. If your car is stolen, you report this to the police, which report it to LoJack. That broadcasts an ID over a subcarrier of some local FM broadcast station. The receiver in the Lojack unit listens for those IDs, and if its own ID comes up, it turns on. It starts loudly transmitting to units in police cars, giving approximate direction and range. If you see a police car with four short whip antennas on the roof in a square pattern, that's a Lojack-equipped vehicle. It's uses radio direction finding. The vehicle box has no idea where it is. It's a totally independent system - no cellular, no GPS. So this only tracks vehicles which have flagged as stolen. It's not constantly phoning home. Classic Lojack is a one-time charge, with no annual fees. The current product, LoJack AnalProbe™, which they call "Connected Car", constantly phones home, reporting your location, battery level, etc. to the mothership. There's an app to review where you've been. And, inevitably, the EULA says that Lojack may "share information with LoJack’s affiliated companies, Service Providers and/or third parties in conjunction with the Software and Services and for the purpose of providing You with any promotional offers and marketing materials as may be permitted by applicable law." You get to pay a subscription fee for this.
- inconceivable 4y agodo you know if the legacy system is still in use? my first 'nice' car had lojack installed in it. i remember it was about $200, and that's all, but this was 10+ years ago. i wonder if it's still out there...
- 13of40 4y agoCan you even get a car in the US these days that doesn't have a GPS and cellular connection? My 8-year-old BMW has both even though they're not exposed as features in the head unit. (I know because the thing malfunctioned last year, called the cops, and gave them my GPS coordinates.)
- jcrawfordor 4y agoToday you see four antennas on police cars for digital diversity reception, originally desirable for minimizing multipath issues but today just about required for P25 "phase II" operation of multiple repeaters on the same channel. These are usually 900MHz radios, one of the factors in the decline of traditional Lojack was many police departments shifting to 900MHz for P25 and no longer equipping all vehicles with VHF radios. Depending on the department, vehicles may not have any radio capable of receiving Lojack transponders. Whether or not they're programmed for it is also a question. When direction finding was used Doppler DF based on multiple antennas was rare due to the high cost of the electronics package, which also consumed a lot of trunk space. Most police departments did it the old fashioned way with a handheld log periodic they waved around. Another part of the decline of the original Lojack system was the high price of providing good DF receivers to police departments, so not many had them. LoJack never got big into having their own DF "hunters" on staff like other companies using transponders did.
- lancesells 4y agoIf you're a thief you could theoretically find the AirTags with the help of this article right? https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212227 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212227
- jcrawfordor 4y agoOne of the big practical problems in automotive tracking for anti-theft reasons is concealment. Some thieves know to check for common, especially factory-fit trackers, and so will take precautionary actions like storing vehicles under metal cover until they can disable the tracker. How effective this is depends on the tracker and the thief's knowledge level, but there is a cat-and-mouse game here where you want to prevent the thief knowing a tracker is fitted. With AirTags this is rather difficult because of the anti-stalking feature, but on the upside they are easy to conceal places so you will get a time window of good functionality. With more conventional GPS trackers a good way to install them is often under the dashboard plastics below the windshield, which offers a clear sky view and is a fair amount of work to get to in a lot of vehicles. Of course the labor on that installation method drives up price so it's not unusual for them to be somewhere far less discrete like in the engine compartment with an external antenna or glued to the bottom of the rear deck in sedans.
- alfalfasprout 4y agoI gave up on Airtags. Under the guise of "protecting against stalking" Apple has removed all of its useful functionality. For starters, any family that shares keys can forget about using airtags. You'll get spammed with alerts about an airtag following you and even if you mute them (for 1 day max) you can't use the airtag to find the keys. This also happens if the person next to you has an airtag and is riding in the car with you. If a thief steals your car they'll be alerted about the airtag too.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoThey'll be alerted to the airtag, but then they'd need to find it. You can easily kill the speaker in the airtag to make that hard.
- Aeolun 4y agoWhy would Apple alert you to an airtag following you? Is this like the stupid Beats headphone messages I randomly get in the train?
- sp332 4y agoIn case a stalker is using one to track you.
- giantg2 4y agoI mean you can also go low tech with stuff like a hidden kill switch and all sorts of things that would actually prevent the theft.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI wanted to try to understand more context behind the "'Why would anyone have one [an Android phone]?' Mayor Adams responded." quote. Here is the relevant video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vuw72THyXsQ&t=949s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vuw72THyXsQ&t=949s So, I get that he's making a joke, but given that everyone just laughs and there is no follow up, it's clear to me it's one of those "The reason this joke is funny is because I actually think it's true" jokes. I've been an Android user for about a decade now, but I think I'm finally going to have to throw in the towel. Between iMessage (especially iMessage) and things like this, in the US having an Android essentially marks you as a second class citizen. And to be clear, I'm not saying this from an "Androids are uncool" or some silly "green bubbles" perspective, I'm saying from the perspective that owning an Android actually makes it more difficult to interact with friends and, in this case, with government services. No, I'm not happy about it, and I f'ing hate how Apple has used these walled garden techniques to force people onto their platform. But from a simple utilitarian perspective, owning an Android puts you at a distinct disadvantage in the US.
- seanw444 4y agoI have zero issues with running an Android, and I honestly see iPhones as being disadvantaged, personally. There's not a single thing I can't do on an Android that I could on an iPhone.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThen you have never tried to join a group chat where the other members of the group all have iPhones and use iMessage.
- chaosbutters314 4y agoall the group chats im in use signal
- hot_gril 4y agoThen you're probably missing out on some group chats others are in.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoDid we forget about this item just last week? https://www.cbsnews.com/news/truck-theft-suspect-fatally-shot-by-owner-tracked-airtag-san-antonio/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/truck-theft-suspect-fatally-sho... Maybe I missed it here.
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- angarg12 4y agoI find it a bit sad that most comments here focus on the Apple/Android war rather than the boring dystopia fact that the police department of the most populous city in the US idea to fight increase in crime is to encourage people to use surveillance devices. Must be the same people that say "just don't go out at night" when you point out the streets full of drug addicts and petty crime, as if it was a normal thing to say in a developed country.
- hackernewds 4y agoWhy are AirPods "surveillance devices"? Without being cynical or anecdotal I haven't seen any mention of how govt surveils citizens using them.
- enterthematrix 4y agoOr they could do their job...
- tetragramaton 4y agoPhilosopher ( me ) urges corporation known as United States of America, and it’s sworn so called “peace officers”, to implement the following pilot program for car thieves and catalytic converter thieves: When apprehended and proven guilty, drop them off 20 miles out in the ocean with an ankle gps bracelet, food rations, $100 usd, a raft, and life-jacket. IMO this would have a profound impact on the criminal, and would be an effective deterrent.
- post_break 4y agoHere's a pro tip. Get the chipolo version of the airtag, it doesn't have the ultrawide band part so you can't easily locate it on whatever you're trying to track. Remove the speaker as well, guides on youtube. The thief will still get alerted due to anti stalking crap, but they can't easily find the airtag and remove it.
- crhulls 4y agoI'm the CEO of Life360, Tile's parent company. I chimed in on another comment but adding to the conversation directly here. I'm biased, but I am surprised how little pushback this is getting as AirTags explicitly are NOT meant to deter theft - to combat stalking (which is exceedingly rare) Apple notifies you if a tag you do not own is near you. That goes for thieves - they will be told an AirTag is nearby. At Tile we just launched an Anti-Theft feature where you can turn off stalking notifications if you share your government issued ID and agree to extremely stringent penalties for misuse, including a large fine. All Life360 users are now scanning for Tile devices, and that equates to over 10% of all phones in the country, so our network in any moderately dense area is almost as good as Apple's. And, we are cross-platform. https://chrishulls.medium.com/tile-is-taking-a-different-approach-to-the-bluetooth-industrys-theft-and-stalking-problems-bd92d3ae4f3c https://chrishulls.medium.com/tile-is-taking-a-different-app... We've put a ton of thought into this problem so happy to answer any questions.
- scrapcode 4y agoWouldn't the notification that an AirTag is located somewhere in the vehicle they're thinking of stealing deter them from stealing it?
- jljljl 4y agoNot if it helps them find and remove the AirTag. It might have a deterring effect if the Airtag was somewhere hard to remove
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bhaney 4y agoThe notification doesn't fire until you've been moving along with the tag for a while, so the vehicle has already been stolen by the time the thieves are aware there's an AirTag present. I guess it might encourage them to dump the vehicle somewhere and abandon it, and you can then go pick it up using the AirTag's last known location. Doesn't really prevent the initial theft, but improves your chances for recovering the vehicle.
- culi 4y agoWe use an airtag to track our cat who we allow outdoors every day until an hour before sunset. We initially used a Tile which I hated and would constantly try to get us to buy more tiles in their crappy app. After 4 months of the air tag we're looking to switch back. The larger network is barely noticeable. Most of what the tags do is allow us to know when we're within X number of feet of our cat. The Tile had a better range and was lighter. But most importantly, we could have multiple accounts track the same Tile. Somehow Apple's airtags are missing this really critical feature that has come up again and again for us. If one of us is not home we need to be able to have another one of us be able to track her down but we simply cannot I'm not a big fan of Tile as a company, but I'm sad to see AirTag's inevitable dominance rise. I would love to see an open-source solution to this problem. Especially if it can somehow hack into the Apple, Tile, etc networks. From what I've read the Apple AirTag network is actually quite insecure and can even be used to send arbitrary HTTP packets. Apple has a huge built-in advantage but also a ceiling that competitors don't have since Android phones can't tap into the network. A community-driven solution could be really effective, especially if it focused on a particular subcommunity like dogwalkers and outdoor cats
- brasic 4y ago> From what I've read the Apple AirTag network is actually quite insecure and can even be used to send arbitrary HTTP packets. Mind sharing a link on this? It doesn’t match the technical descriptions Apple has published about how the AirTag network operates. On the other hand I can see it being true about Tile…
- Gigachad 4y agoIirc someone worked out how to emulate an airtag and use the tiny amount of data they transmit to relay some data back to the owners apple account. It's not really insecure because it doesn't affect anyone but the owner of the device but you are relaying that data over other peoples phones, which is encrypted with your keys.
- stanwesley 4y ago[flagged]
- tomger 4y ago> Adams was asked during the press conference if AirTags work with Android (they don't). >"Why would anyone have one [an Android phone]?" Adams responded. Solid point
- sneak 4y agoReminder: the NYPD's budget is approximately $475 million dollars per month.
- itisit 4y agoAnother effective way to prevent your car from getting stolen in New York is to leave New York with your car.
- kelipso 4y agoDrive to Faraday cage. Scan car for outgoing signals. Remove source of outgoing signals. Move the stolen car to safe zone. I'm talking out my ass but is this even difficult?
- flowersjeff 4y agoReality check. Car gets stolen. You tell the cops the exact location of car. They tell you to fill out paperwork. You pick up said paper work two weeks later. Insurance does ( or doesn't ) do it's thing. I would have a totally different feeling - if I believed that the cops would 'do' anything. They have impressed me, and my five decades on this planet, at the lengths they will go to not do their job ( or flat out do the opposite if it fits their wants. )
- buro9 4y agoA steering wheel lock is better at preventing car thefts, something like this https://www.milenco.com/products/automotive-security/automotive-security-wheel-locks/high-security-steering-wheel-lock https://www.milenco.com/products/automotive-security/automot... Then it doesn't matter if someone gains entry to your car and is doing some of the more recent tricks involving the CAN or USB to disable built in immobilizers or convince the car a key is present, the ability to drive the car away is removed without a heavy and loud power tool in a very confined space. An airtag may help with deterrence if the presence of it is advertised, and may help with recovery if the police are actively doing recovery. But the car is still going to get stolen, it's still going to be inconvenient and involve dealing with the insurers (who do want to avoid paying out). A steering wheel lock is a far more effective deterrent and preventative.
- golemotron 4y ago> Adams, as the city did when announcing litigation against Kia and Hyundai on April 7, largely blamed the rise in car thefts on Kia and Hyundai, which he said are "leading the way" in stolen car brands. Love this. NYC's response to crime: sue auto manufacturers rather than make the city safer.
- l0ngyap 4y ago[dead]