18 ms·
Is infinity an odd or even number? (2011)
- ioslipstream 4y agoYes
- remram 4y agoInfinity is not a number. If you want to extend even/odd to it, you can pick whatever you want.
- sukilot 4y agoI suggest you reread the OP and ask questions, because you seem to have overlooked some of the ideas explained therein, such as transfinite ordinals.
- remram 4y agoYou can build those and then pick if you want them even or odd, which are regular-number concepts. That is exactly what they did, and what I described. You go and re-read it.
- Sharlin 4y agoThere's always someone who sees a question in a submission title and feels the need to comment simply to answer said question in the most boring, banal, and least insightful way possible. Most people realize that if an article that poses a seemingly-simple question makes it to HN frontpage, there's almost certainly some unexpected, interesting, and/or insightful discussion there that reveals that the question wasn't so simple after all. Almost everything interesting in mathematics stems from a simple question: "How could we extend a concept to be more generally applicable?" Saying that infinity is not even or odd because it's not a number is like claiming that matrices can't be multiplied because they are not numbers.
- remram 4y agoI am not preventing the discussion or claiming that you shouldn't extend this concept, just objecting to the way to question is formulated ("is infinity an odd or even number"). The stackexchange comments agree with me, and do this extension by pointing out reasons it would be useful to pick one or the other, but I found it important to point out this caveat that there is no logical answer (in terms of numbers) and whatever you pick would be an extension, not a conclusion. Nowhere in my comment do I say that this is a silly submission or suggest that it shouldn't be in the front page.
- r0uv3n 4y agoOrdinals are often also called ordinal numbers. Both ordinal and cardinal numbers are very much generalisation of natural numbers to a more general concept of number, depending on if you see counting sizes of sets or denoting position (e.g. first, second, etc.) as the fundamental thing numbers do. Of course there are also other notions of number that focus on other aspects (e.g. number fields). But I think it's definitely not wrong to call all of these things numbers. So it seems weird to me to object to the form of the question, it is perfectly fine as it is. If the question was "is infinity an odd or even natural number?", then of course you'd be right. All of these things are also stuff one could discuss with a 6 year old (i.e. tell them that there are multiple notions of numbers that focus on different aspects, and that the question has a different (probably interesting) answer in each of these different contexts). Insisting that infinity is not a number seems like a less interesting way to talk about this, without even being necessarily more rigorous. Edit: See also [0], linked in the second answer [0]: https://math.stackexchange.com/a/36298 https://math.stackexchange.com/a/36298
- billpg 4y agoNo
- sukilot 4y ago[dead]
- zadler 4y agoYes|no
- pxx 4y agoIn IEC 60559* floating-point arithmetic, pow(-1, ∞) is 1. This is because all large binary and decimal floating-point numbers are even, and thus so is infinity. *this is the successor standard to ieee-754 and shares text in recent revisions, though I don't have direct access on this phone. You can find the specific pow specification in Annex F of the C99 standard.
- layer8 4y agoIs the “thus” for ease of implementation? I.e., so that all floating-point numbers comparing greater than some threshold can be considered even without having to check for infinity?
- pxx 4y agoIt's not that they are considered even, they just are. There's no way to encode a large odd even-radix floating point number. You have some (small, compared to the range that the exponent can encode) bits of significand and once you exhaust those all numbers are even (or divisible by ten in the rare decimal case).
- layer8 4y agoIEC 60559 could have defined pow(-1, ∞) as -1 if they’d wanted to. Hence my question what the “thus” is about.
- AdamH12113 4y agoNo, it comes from the fact that floating point is binary and has limited precision. Think of it in terms of scientific notation. Here's an example in decimal. If we limit ourselves to four significant digits, then a number like: 3.101 * 10^3 is odd -- it's equivalent to 3101 (three thousand one hundred one). It's followed by 3.102*10^3 (3102), which is even, and 3.103*10^3 (3103), which is odd. But a number like: 3.101 * 10^5 which is equivalent to 310100, is even. It's followed by 3.102*10^5 (310200), which is also even, and 3.103*10^5 (310300), which is again even. If you have four significant digits and an exponent larger than 3, then you the value in the ones place will always be zero. Thus, the number is always a multiple of 10, and therefore even. Floating point is the same, except it's binary. In a 32-bit float, you have 23 bits of mantissa after the decimal point. If the exponent is larger than 2^23, the ones place is always zero, so the number is guaranteed to be a multiple of 2, and therefore even.
- Eisenstein 4y agoI want to know if there are more decimal numbers between 0 and 1 than there are integers between 0 and infinity.
- warent 4y agoMy understanding is that this is true because there are infinite decimals between every decimal, infinitely. For example, there is infinity between 0.1 and 0.2, and infinity between 0.1 and 0.11, etc. i.e. infinite sets of infinity rather than one set of infinity. In the end it's all infinity, but their sets have higher cardinality described in Aleph terms ... (or something) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aleph_number https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aleph_number
- daef 4y agoYou can uniquely map all rationals onto the natural numbers, thus they are of the same quantity. That doesn't work for all real numbers thou.
- warent 4y agoOh right this is only true for irrational and transcendental numbers
- aimor 4y agoMaybe this is misguided cheat, but couldn't you map any real number (between 0 and 1) to a natural number by mirroring the decimal digits across the decimal point. So 0.123 -> 321, but also sqrt(2)/2 -> ?601707 where ? is the rest of the decimal representation. This creates infinitely large numbers, but it's still a 1-to-1 mapping.
- dangond 4y agoUnfortunately, numbers with infinitely many digits are not natural numbers. You cannot count to ?601707, even with an infinite amount of time.
- 4y ago
- warent 4y agoIn my experience with children, one of the easiest-to-grasp concepts of infinity is provided by the transfinite ordinals, since it can be viewed as a continuation of the usual counting manner of children, but proceeding into the transfinite: 1,2,3,⋯,ω,ω+1,ω+2,⋯,ω+ω=ω⋅2,ω⋅2+1,⋯,ω⋅3,⋯,ω2,ω2+1,⋯,ω2+ω,⋯⋯ Presumably this person has no experience with 6 year olds? This explanation is horrendous haha
- alexb_ 4y agoNo it isn't. If you ask a child what comes after infinity, "Infinity + 1" is pretty much the default answer. Any kid who knows multiplication knows "Infinity + Infinity" is the same as "Infinity Times Two". The answer of "Infinity TIMES Infinity" is also popular for kids to say when they know a number bigger than their friend (who just proclaimed infinity is the largest number).
- warent 4y agoSix-year-olds know multiplication?
- jasonjayr 4y agoSome do, yes. If they have an aptitude for basic sums then pointing out that 3 x 3 is the same as 3 + 3 + 3 sets them down the right path ...
- hammyhavoc 4y agoI had it explained at a very early age as "three lots of three", and to imagine it like three boxes of three ice-creams. Treating the multiplication symbol as one would to indicate quantity in a list, thus calculating how many ice-creams there are.
- aaronharnly 4y agoFound the Brit! As an American I’d never heard the “lots of __” phrasing until I watched Numberblocks (a British show) with my kid…
- irrational 4y ago>To explain the idea to a child, I would focus on the principal idea: whether finite or infinite, a number is even when it can be divided into pairs. For finite sets, this is the same as the ability to divide the set into two sets of equal size, since one may consider the first element of each pair and the second element of each pair. The answer this quote came from is amazingly obtuse, but it does make me think that infinity must be even since infinity can be divided into 2 pairs, each of which is of equal size since both are infinity.
- tlarkworthy 4y agoBut zero is in the middle, so it must be odd
- amanj41 4y agoCouldn't you trivially say zero is in "the middle" of any even split? 2 + 0 + 2 = 4? Edit: perhaps you meant one is in the middle?
- dkarl 4y agoIn mathematics, you can define things in different ways to get different answers. Ways of defining things tend to be highlighted as true (in at least some context) if they are interesting and useful, and ignored if not. I don't think the definition based on "dividing into pairs" is particularly interesting or useful in the context of the child's understanding of numbers, because it's too vague to be useful, and it doesn't lead to any insights. The definition based on transfinite ordinals explained in the same answer does seem interesting, and I wouldn't be surprised if it were useful. I think this is a case of simplification gone wrong, where everything interesting was lost in the translation to more accessible terminology. A more honest thing to say to a child would be that the way even and odd are defined only make sense for finite numbers. It's true for the definition they know, and it introduces them to the important insight that logical rules that are created for one kind of thing might not work when applied to something else. I think this would be more accessible and stimulating for a six-year-old than giving them a half-baked verbal imitation of a result from transfinite mathematics. They'll be thrilled later if they study math and discover that there are definitions of "infinity" and "even" that yield an answer to their childhood question.
- NKosmatos 4y agoI've seen the last number at the end of infinity and I could tell you if it's odd or even, but by doing so I would break this simulation :-)
- have_faith 4y agoIn JavaScript we're spoiled by having both. There's Number.NEGATIVE_INFINITY and Number.POSITIVE_INFINITY.
- warent 4y agoDon't forget -0 (negative zero)!
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoFloats are approximations of the reals and -0 is just the limit towards zero from the left.
- remram 4y agoWhy, is it odd?
- remram 4y agoBoth what? The question is about even or odd.
- myhf 4y agoNegative Infinity is even, and Positive Infinity is odd.
- Sharlin 4y agoThose are simply the bog-standard IEEE/IEC.754 floating point infinities, so they're the same thing in essentially every mainstream language.
- pelagicAustral 4y agoIn js you could just: npm install is-odd const isOdd = require('is-odd'); console.log(isOdd(∞));
- compressedgas 4y agoInfinity is equal to the product of all the primes. It is even because it has 2 as a factor.
- drexlspivey 4y agoIt’s also equal to the product of all primes except 2 so it’s odd.
- kibwen 4y agoThis just implies that infinity is both even and odd, which means that the statement "infinity is even" is still technically correct by this reasoning.
- tabtab 4y agoNext you'll tell me light is both particles and a wave. This scientific saucery must stop! Order it to pick one or jailit!
- paulddraper 4y agoOdd is defined as not even.
- drexlspivey 4y agoin javascript maybe
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jstimpfle 4y agoI find that primes are an odd thing to bring into the discussion, not even mildly relevant.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y ago
- xwdv 4y agoTl;dr: it’s even
- elif 4y agoNope. Just because one infinity passes one test for evenness does not imply they all infinities do.
- pm2222 4y agoIs infinity an integer?
- bell-cot 4y agoNope. Nor a rational number. Nor a real number. Nor...
- caturopath 4y agoInfinity, is, of course, weird. David Deutsch expanded on Hilbert's hotel in this chapter https://publicism.info/science/infinity/9.html https://publicism.info/science/infinity/9.html of one of his books, one of the funnest little discussions of (mostly countable) infinity I've seen.
- bitL 4y agoI really hate these mathematical technicalities spawned from material implication, chosen way of making a definition and vacuous truth - why can't we even consider some questions to be marked as non-sense/non-relevant like in relevance logic?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cruncharoo 4y agoNot to be obtuse but isn't all of mathematics spawned from a chosen way of making a definition and vacuous truth?
- bitL 4y agoNot really. One could argue some math is innate and we are just rediscovering it. See the disconnect between natural language and math which happened early 20th century because of material implication bringing vacuous truth, leading to "impedance mismatch". Medicine is still using counterfactuals precisely because of weirdness introduced by Russell in order to make all Boolean values defined for inference.
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoThat has nothing to do with relevance logic. Someone has written a smart-ass answer about transfinite ordinals to a question about infinity; and people upvoted it for right or wrong reasons. To me personally the answer looks witty but misleading.
- bentcorner 4y agoThere are an infinite number of questions, answers, and topics that were considered nonsense, not written about, and impossible to post to HN.
- bitL 4y agoCountable or uncountable? ;-)
- charlie0 4y agoIt's both until you can observe the last number. ;)
- DonHopkins 4y agoI don't get mad, I get odd.
- gus_massa 4y agoThe problem with transfinite is that you lose commutatively. Flowing the standard notation, where the usual infinite in the integer or the real line is "ω = ∞ = 1,2,3,..." ω+1 = ω+1 , i.e. "the next thing after infinity" 1+ω = ω , i.e. "the same infinity as before" 2ω = ω , i.e. "the same infinity as before", so it's even 1+2ω = ω , i.e. "the same infinity as before", so it looks odd, but don't fall in that trap ω2 = ω2 , i.e. "two infinities chained together", that is weird Two more weird example from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Even_and_odd_ordinals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Even_and_odd_ordinals > Unlike the case of even integers, one cannot go on to characterize even ordinals as ordinal numbers of the form β2 = β + β. Ordinal multiplication is not commutative, so in general 2β ≠ β2. In fact, the even ordinal ω + 4 cannot be expressed as β + β, and the ordinal number > (ω + 3)2 = (ω + 3) + (ω + 3) = ω + (3 + ω) + 3 = ω + ω + 3 = ω2 + 3 > is not even. For a six year old, I'd tell that infinite is not a number so it's not even or odd. If s/he even get's a Ph.D. in math, s/he will understand. Moreover, I remember when I was a graduate T.A. that one day before lunch I went to a class to learn about the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexandroff_extension https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexandroff_extension in the morning. (The idea is that you add one ∞ to a set of numbers to get a compact set. And in the new set ∞ is (almost) a number as good as the other numbers.) After lunch, I went to teach limits to first years students, and with a total straight face I told them that ∞ is not a number.
- SAI_Peregrinus 4y ago> The problem with transfinite is that you lose commutatively. Depends on which transfinite algebra you're working with. If you restrict "number" to mean "element of an ordered field" (thus excluding things like the "complex numbers" but matching the usual intuition of how numbers should behave) then you can't include Cantor's ordinals but you can include the Surreal Numbers. Those include infinite ordinals and (due to being a field) have commutative addition and multiplication operations.
- NegativeK 4y agoI'd say that the problem with transfinites is that you lose intuitive understanding of what's going on, and one of those intuitions is commutativity. People seem to assume that they know a couple of tricks about infinity (adding, multiplying) and don't stop to think that there should be a much more rigorous definition. Which, they shouldn't -- the average person will never _actually_ care about transfinites.
- plexer 4y agoNeither, Infinity % 2 = NaN
- gigel82 4y agoIs the last digit of Pi odd or even?
- paulddraper 4y agoTrick question. Pi is irrational and does not have a last digit.
- faceloss 4y ago[dead]
- w0mbat 4y agoInfinity is not a number, it's the absence of a limit.
- MetaWhirledPeas 4y agoNaN
- cubefox 4y agoYeah. Though the defenders of transfinite (ordinal and cardinal) numbers do in fact assert that there are many infinite numbers, such as aleph zero or omega. They are just usually somewhat embarrassed about this and therefore only talk about "ordinals" or "cardinals". It's like trying to hide that you drink beer by saying you merely drink lagers and ales.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mkup 4y agoAbsense of limit is not always an infinity, e.g. for sequence (-1)^n. Even if sequence is unbounded, it does not always converge to infinity, e.g. n^((1+(-1)^n)/2): 1, 2, 1, 4, 1, 6, 1, 8, 1, 10, 1, 12, 1, 14, 1, 16, 1, 18, 1, 20 ... Convergence of sequence x(n) to infinity by definition is: for each real number ε>0 there exists a natural number N(ε) such that for every number n≥N(ε) we have |x(n)|>ε.
- cubefox 4y agoWhat would be x in case of the natural numbers?
- lisper 4y agoTo explain to a six-year-old I would start by telling them that there are many different kinds of infinity, not just one. Some infinities are odd, others are even, and others are neither. It matters whether you are asking "how many" (cardinals) or "in what position" (ordinals). For regular finite numbers, cardinals and ordinals are (more or less) the same, but for infinities they behave differently. Then, if they want to get into the weeds, you can introduce them to transfinite ordinals, diagonalization, and all that fun stuff.
- Georgelemental 4y agoFor a child, I think the simplest kind of infinity to explain is the cardinality of integers—"how many numbers there are."
- lisper 4y agoOK, but then where do you go from there? There are infinity numbers. Then what?
- kccqzy 4y agoRight. The problem with teaching infinity by starting with cardinal numbers is that it's either too trivial or too hard. You can establish that several other sets of numbers are identified by the same infinity but there's not much you can do. An old HN comment echoes the same sentiment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17677010 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17677010 If we really are teaching kids, teach ordinals not cardinals.
- lisper 4y ago> You can establish that several other sets of numbers are identified by the same infinity but there's not much you can do. Well, you can introduce them to the diagonal argument and the idea of a one-to-one correspondence. That's nothing to sneeze at. But I think the real trick here is to teach them that numbers can stand for different kinds of ideas, and in particular, they can stand for "how many" or "what position", and that these are different. I would start, not with infinity, but with negative numbers. You can't have "one less than zero" because you can't take away anything from zero. That is the definition of zero. But you can have "the thing before zero", or, to be more precise, "the thing before the zeroth thing (where the zeroth thing is the thing before the first thing)", which we call -1. Likewise you can't have "one more than infinity" because that's just infinity. That's the definition of infinity. But you can have "the thing after infinity" (or, to be more precise, "the thing after all the things that are the nth thing for all finite values of n", which we call ω.
- fsckboy 4y agoi think making the odd/even distinction is a mistake. It makes people say things like "2 is the only even prime" as if that's somehow different than "3 is the only prime evenly divisible by 3". Even is a quality of division when the remainder is 0; even is a quality of making a rectangle with discrete integral sides.
- lo_zamoyski 4y agoIt isn't clear to me infinity is a number in the first place. Reification and category mistakes are as much a danger in math as anywhere.
- snotrockets 4y agoInfinity isn't a number, but it is an ordinal (and the answer does mention how you can have an even/odd property on the ordinals)
- breck 4y ago[flagged]
- yjk 4y agoWhich is also incorrect. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordinal_numeral https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordinal_numeral vs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordinal_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordinal_number.
- NegativeK 4y agoCardinal numbers (size) and ordinal numbers (ordering) are both numbers. The numbers we're familiar with represent both concepts, sometimes simultaneously. I really don't think that block quoting ChatGPT is a good contribution.
- breck 4y ago> I really don't think that block quoting ChatGPT is a good contribution. It's the first time I've done it. I agree with you. But didn't know until I tried!
- breck 4y agoI agree. It's an interesting intellectual exercise, but I am not sure if we would miss out on anything if we just had a symbol(s) for specific really large discrete numbers. Sometimes I wonder if there's a better math language waiting to be invented that eschews the non-discrete.
- sampo 4y ago> In the context of transfinite ordinals I don't really find that transfinite ordinals match my childlike intuitive concept of infinity. Transfinite cardinals match better.
- eternalban 4y agoInfinity is the twin of zero ∞ | ∅ .
- shadowgovt 4y agoThe key insight when dealing with infinities is that the tools we use to deal with finite numbers extrapolate to infinite sets by talking about relationships between numbers, not individual numbers. This is also how we get to the notion of infinities larger than other infinities.
- crazygringo 4y agoSo there seems like a glaring hole in the answer, but maybe I'm missing something. Because: > It is easy to prove from this definition by transfinite recursion that the ordinals come in an alternating even/odd pattern, and that every limit ordinal (and hence every infinite cardinal) is even. Sure, if we use the natural numbers and start at 1, then we can group: [1, 2], [3, 4], [5, 6], ... and prove infinity is even. But we could also just as easily group: 1, [2, 3], [4, 5], [6, 7], ... and prove infinity is odd. It's the same if we try to split into two equal subsets, because we can split into: [1, 3, 5, ...] [2, 4, 6, ...] and say it's even. Or we can divide: 1 [2, 4, 6, ...] [3, 5, 7, ...] and prove it's odd because we have two equal subsets plus one left over. So I'm missing the reason for why the second versions aren't just as valid. (Of course, I'm more inclined to agree with many commenters here that it's just a category error, and asking whether infinity is even/odd is as useful as asking whether democracy is blonde or brunette.)
- silasdavis 4y agoOmega is the lowest countable infinity. There's no parity within a countable infinite as you describe. It's only even or odd with respect to other infinities which the cardinal numbers can count based on the presence of a bijection or not. It's a kind of relative parity.
- crazygringo 4y ago> There's no parity within a countable infinite as you describe. That directly contradicts the quoted text I included from the original answer though, as far as I understand. It directly asserted that "every infinite cardinal is even". > It's a kind of relative parity. What is relative parity? The original question was whether infinity is even or odd... I don't know what you mean by relative parity.
- sdenton4 4y agoI would weaken the definition of even/odd to say that a set is even if /there exists/ a way to pair things off, and odd if /there is no way/ to pair things off (ie, not even). So the countable numbers would be even.
- mnunez 4y agoWell, I asked ChatGPT: > Infinity is not a number, odd or even, but rather a concept or a mathematical idea that represents an unbounded or limitless quantity. Infinity is not a real number that can be used in ordinary arithmetic operations, but it is used to describe a quantity that is larger than any finite number. Therefore, the concept of odd or even does not apply to infinity.
- seiferteric 4y agoImagine if we had ChatGPT a couple hundred years ago: "What is the square root of -1?": "The square root of -1 is not defined because you cannot take the square root of a negative number."
- JdeBP 4y agoSo you are proposing that a couple of hundred years ago, in 1823, a hypothetical ChatGPT would not have been trained on the works of Leonhard Euler, from 80 years before that. That actually sounds about right. (-:
- awestroke 4y agoMuch more reasonable answer than the others in the thread
- cushpush 4y agoDepends on where you start counting =).
- zac23or 4y agoI see infinity and perfection as a direction, not a place. That's how I explain it to kids.
- emrah 4y agoInfinity is a concept not an actual specific number. How could it be even or odd?
- KingLancelot 4y ago[dead]
- jedberg 4y agoI think the best answer is the first comment to the question: Infinity is neither even nor odd, just like 1.4 isn't even or odd.
- JdeBP 4y agoAh, StackExchange! The answer that says "Here is a simple example that has some hope of being comprehensible to a 6-year-old." and then begins "Consider the ring of polynomial functions with integer coefficients, ..." gets upvoted tens of times. Even the answer that uses "numerocity", "refined cardinality", and "logarithm" as the explanation to a 6-year-old gets upvoted. The answer, https://math.stackexchange.com/a/49065/13638 https://math.stackexchange.com/a/49065/13638, that says as the answer-to-a-6-year-old the same thing that several commenters have actually posted here (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35790064 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35790064 for one of many), on Hacker News in just the past hour or so, and that explains in terms that a 6-year-old has at least a chance of having encountered, gets 5 votes in 12 years and the submitter is banned from the site.
- Spivak 4y agoThe answer is using big words but the concept is simple. Like talking about fractions as a quotient ring over a field. A six year old can absolutely grasp that even means "being able to be split into two equally sized piles" where equally sized means each thing in the left pile can be matched to something in the right. 6 apples is even because you can split them into 3 and 3. Then for infinity you separate them into the even and odd numbers, boom. Infinity is even. Saying "infinity isn't a number", to me, is so much worse an answer because it's not satisfying. Because both you and the 6 year old know that isn't right. The 6 year old is grasping at a bigger concept but doesn't have the words.
- steveBK123 4y agofeels smooth not spiky, so going with even
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mkup 4y agoInfinity is out of domain of integer numbers where notions of even and odd are defined and make sense. Notion of infinity is applicable when we are discussing sequences and their behaviour, such as convergence. Convergence of sequence x(n) to infinity by definition is: for each real number ε>0 there exists a natural number N(ε) such that for every number n≥N(ε) we have |x(n)|>ε. Convergence of sequence x(n) to plus infinity by definition is: for each real number ε>0 there exists a natural number N(ε) such that for every number n≥N(ε) we have x(n)>ε. Convergence of sequence x(n) to minus infinity by definition is: for each real number ε>0 there exists a natural number N(ε) such that for every number n≥N(ε) we have x(n)<-ε. For example sequence of natural numbers 1, 2, 3... converges to plus infinity and to infinity; sequence of negated natural numbers -1, -2, -3... converges to minus infinity and to infinity; and sequence of sign-alternating numbers (-1)^n * n: -1, 2, -3, 4, -5, 6, -7, 8, -9, 10... converges to infinity. So notion of infinity applies to behaviour of sequences, whose elements remain finite nevertheless. If we consider other mathematical objects, e.g. integer numbers, then notion of infinity does not apply. If we consider convergence of sequences where notion of infinity is applicable, then notion of even/odd is not applicable. While discussing sequences converging to an infinity with a child, it may be useful to consider some interesting counterexamples: sequences which are unbounded, but still do not converge to infinity, e.g. 1, 2, 1, 4, 1, 6, 1, 8, 1, 10, 1, 12, 1, 14, 1, 16, 1, 18, 1, 20... (formula is n^((1+(-1)^n)/2)).
- osigurdson 4y agoI’ve always thought infinity is not a number but a concept that represents something which is ever increasing.
- paulddraper 4y agoIt is that as well.
- kccqzy 4y agoThat's the definition of infinity in calculus and analysis. Most of the comments in this HN discussion are talking about infinity as a set theoretical concept, i.e. cardinals and ordinals.
- taco_emoji 4y agoSimple, infinity is even, but infinity + 1 is odd.
- loganc2342 4y agoThis thread almost reads like parody to me. It perfectly encapsulates the Stack Exchange experience in that when a question is clearly asked by a beginner in a subject, they are likely to get responses only decipherable by experts, or at least people who know enough to not be asking that question.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zw123456 4y agoThe way I would explain it to a 6 year old would be like this: Infinity isn't a number really, it's a concept, like the word many or the word few. If someone says they have many of something, you don't think is that odd or even you just know they have a lot of it. Infinity is kind of like that, it explains the idea of things going on forever, not an exact quantity of things like the number 10 or 11.
- isitmadeofglass 4y agoIf I say someone had many of something, then I know for certain that they must have either an even amount or an odd amount. Same goes for few.
- zw123456 4y agoIt's an analogy, meant to show the similarities between two things in a limited way, to illustrate an idea. They do not have to be exactly the same in every way.
- Name_Chawps 4y agoThis is true until you introduce transfinite numbers.
- zw123456 4y agoThat might be a bit too advanced for a 6 year old perhaps.
- MengerSponge 4y ago6 year olds have an expert understanding in "I'm not touching you", so you might have a shot of teaching them
- gowld 4y agoOn the contrary, it's entirely natural. The technical definition is quite intuitive. "There are many infinities! The smallest one is bigger than all the counting numbers, so you can't count up to it, but it's out there! We call it omega. You can make bigger infinities too, like omega + 1!" Kids LOVE that, and it's good math too! (But gets tricky quickly, because addition of transfinite ordinals is not commutative, and standard transfinite ordinals don't allow subtraction) It's easy to draw as a "number tree" too: root / \ / \ 1,2,3,4... omega, omega+1,... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number#/media/File:Surreal_number_tree.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number#/media/File:Sur... (includes more numbers like rationals and reals and negatives and backwards counting from omega, but you can ignore those)
- paulddraper 4y agonpm i is-even const isEven = require("is-even"); console.log(isEven(Infinity)); TypeError: is-odd expects a number.
- Bilal_io 4y agoI read the title and I sarcastically thought "ask JavaScript!" Your comment didn't disappoint. Importing the is-even package is the cherry on top.
- paulddraper 4y agoThe amazing thing is that the is-even package depends on the is-odd package. I would have thought the reverse, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- sltkr 4y agoEven with plain Javascript, `Infinity % 2` evaluates to `NaN`, as it should. And if you implement, e.g.: function IsEven(x) { return x % 2 == 0; } function IsOdd(x) { return x % 2 == 1; } Then IsEven(Infinity) == false and IsOdd(Infinity) == false, as expected.
- dist-epoch 4y agoNice find. I will file an issue, this is a very used package, it's important for it to be accurate.
- omgomgomgomg 4y agoWell its not a natural number or real, its a concept entailing all odd and even numbers. Unless this is some sort of trick question or I am missong something.
- antiquark 4y agoInfinity is a direction.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- corn13read2 4y agoDefinitely even, no chance half of infinity is a decimal.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoI guess I would have thought the answer to this question would be "yes"?
- pk-protect-ai 4y ago-- the first comment here is the correct one, sorry for posting it without reading the comments. Infinity is not a number.
- activiation 4y agoIs zero a number?
- yarg 4y agoHere's one that gets me: what's the sign of infinity? What do I mean? 1/d retains the sign of d across all finite and infinitesimal values. 1/ε = +∞, 1/-ε = -∞ So what about 1/0? Neutral infinity.
- zeven7 4y ago1 / 0 = ±∞ Or if you must, you do that thing where you pick the positive option à la √
- yarg 4y ago± is useful for ambiguities, such as the the result of the antifunction of a symmetrical function. But there's no ambiguity here - those signs that you're suggesting popped out of nowhere.
- drexlspivey 4y ago1/0 is not defined. There is only lim(1/ε) when ε->0+ = +∞ and lim(1/ε) when ε->0- = -∞
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- czbond 4y agoI enjoyed watching this Netflix "show" on Infinity. Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNFm_DzHDaE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNFm_DzHDaE
- ForOldHack 4y agoAhh, the mis-uses of infinity again. Infinity, is both simply because inf+1 = inf, so if infinity is odd, then infinity + 1 is even, which equals infinity which is then odd. Think of sets. Inf and -inf are in both sets. You can prove this with deltas and epsilons, but that is beyond the scope of explaining it to 6 year olds.
- ForOldHack 4y agoThere are twin primes, and the number of twin primes is infinite, so now, the number of twin primes should be even... because by definition they always are. Also the number of primes is infinite, so there is both a even number of primes, and an odd number of primes. Infinite sets are indivisible, and also have infinite magnitude. i.e. you cannot sub divide them into anything, and loose its infinite property, you also cannot multiply them, and change the infinite property, so, If someone says Infinity = 1/12 its useful, but tricky. if you multiply both sides of that you get infinity * infinity = 1/12 * infinity. i.e. it reduces to infinity = infinity.
- nologic01 4y agoEven if its odd, infinity is not a number
- hypertexthero 4y agoIt’s an even number that fell on its side: ∞
- davrosthedalek 4y agoProbably ate too much.
- EGreg 4y agoI don't think that aleph0 + 1 is odd, because I can make a 1-1 correspondence between two of its subsets. They're ALL even, by that definition!
- dathinab 4y agowhich infinity? ;=)
- entropicgravity 4y agoNo
- knowingathing 4y agoChatGPT response: Infinity is not considered an odd or even number. In mathematics, odd and even are properties of integers, which are finite numbers. Infinity, on the other hand, is not a number in the usual sense. It is a concept that represents an unbounded or limitless quantity. Therefore, the concepts of odd and even do not apply to infinity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- khitchdee 4y agoIt's definitely an odd number. If it were even you could divide it into 2 parts which, by definition, is not possible. You count up from 1 in steps of 2 and never stop. Infinity is the process of this never-ending count.
- chasd00 4y agoI would say it’s even. If it’s not then the fact that infinity = infinity + 1 means it is :)
- r0uv3n 4y agoIn the ordinals infinity != infinity + 1 (but 1 + infinity=infinity). You are right that infinity is even, and in fact infinity+1 is odd. All this is explained in the first answer of TFA.
- lngnmn2 4y agoIt is not a number, it is a separate concept, and the current consensus that it is part of the Set of numbers and of a Monoid is just wrong.
- m3kw9 4y agoIs like asking if pi is even or odd
- 1nvic7u5 4y agoWhy can't infinity be both even and odd? The field of numbers should allow a possibility for both even & odd to happen at the point of infinity. Of course, infinity would then be a point where the definition of a number could break down. If it doesn't, then it can be both even and odd.
- afarviral 4y agoNo its not an odd or even number; its infinity.
- Anders_A 4y agoThe short answer to this question is "No".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- racl101 4y ago> To explain the idea to a child, I would focus on the principal idea: whether finite or infinite, a number is even when it can be divided into pairs. For finite sets, ..... Pretty sure if I tried to explain this to my kid niece she'd just say: "I'm uncomfortable. Can I go now?"