11 ms·
A bacterial culprit for rheumatoid arthritis?
- jmclnx 4y agoInteresting, I new someone who had RA in her 20s, by the time she reached here mid 30s, it was gone. This was a long time ago but the doctors then were a bit surprised.
- 0x486566e7279 4y agodid she have children? pregnancy suppresses the immune system, many women find that auto-immune conditions go away (temporarily usually) when they are pregnant.
- oaththrowaway 4y agoI know a lady who has 9 children. She loves being a mom, but she also loved being pregnant because it was the only thing that helped her RA
- jmclnx 4y agoNot until after it went away.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoThat really is interesting. I started developing it in my early 20s, and I still have it (mid 30s now), but in some ways it has improved quite a bit. I have no idea why or how. I'm grateful, though I assume it'll eventually get worse again rather than go away. It has been useful in motivating me to use my hands before I can't, which is bitter sweet I guess. Certainly sweet in that I've appreciated my hands in ways I likely wouldn't have known I should otherwise. Here's hoping that it continues to fade!
- eastof 4y agoSame story here but with my feet instead, now I slackline to keep up my foot stregth. Do you use TNF inhibitors?
- steve_adams_86 4y agoNo inhibitors or medications of any kind during the onset or most of the progression. I find exercise useful too. Not much can keep the cold and wet conditions from making my hands scream, but when I climb and deadlift it has the odd effect of reducing pain after a half hour or so, and keeping it at bay for hours. People have told me this means it can't be arthritis, but I've met others with a diagnosis who have the same experience. So long as the activity doesn't involve impact or to much opening and clenching of my hand while under stress, it's very relieving (though painful at first).
- bbojan 4y agoI had psoriatic arthritis and it just went away after several years. The only thing that could keep it in check was comfrey ointment (I tried everything conventional medicine had to offer except biologics). But since about two years ago I am symptom free.
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago> Some people at risk for the disease have antibodies against this bacteria, and Subdoligranulum activation of T cells was more prevalent in people with RA than in healthy controls. Very important to qualify (through studies) whether this is the cause of rheumatoid arthritis, or just one of a number of precipitating things. The answer will tell us whether treating/preventing Subdoligranulum is a silver bullet, or whether, like cancer, we have a lot more work to do. > “It's hard to know how big of a player this specific isolate is,” he said. “It could be the dominant player, and that's why they came across it first. But it could be that if they went back and did larger screens, that they would come up with more — that [Subdoligranulum] would be just one of many.” > In keeping with this, the researchers only found this Subdoligranulum strain in 16.7 percent of people at risk or with early-stage RA, indicating that this strain is likely not the sole driver of disease. Regardless, given the results mentioned here, I would bet that "infection" with this strain would exacerbate RA through increased production of antibodies. So it seems a good target to reduce severe RA.
- davidjones332 4y ago[dead]
- kstrauser 4y agoAnd it's not unprecedented. It was in my lifetime that we found out that stomach ulcers could be caused by H. pylori infections. For many people, what'd previously been a chronic condition could be cured with a round of antibiotics.
- darkerside 4y agoLyme disease also causes symptoms that overlap with RA, due to the Borrelia burgdorferi bacteria. It is latent in some people and causes serious symptoms in others. I truly wonder sometimes whether antibiotics are actually underused in medicine (while simultaneously being overused in the food supply chain).
- hospitalJail 4y ago
- so-and-so 4y agoI know someone who has it. How lond does it usually take to go from a research like this to a medicine available to patients (if the hipothesis turns true)?
- cornhole34 4y ago~8 years at best if everything goes well (rarely ever does), there are outliers like Polio took ~4 years, and Covid took ~1 year. But those are much different than RA.
- newprint 4y agoUnfortunately, few months ago, my gf who is in her very early 30s, was diagnosed with RA. She was immediately placed on the very expensive medication - $5000/month (you read it right, a month). It helps a lot, but not 100% effective and we don't know how it will work long term. We are hoping, that some new treatment might be available in the future.
- Rimintil 4y agoThat's cheap. $12K/month for two self-administered biologic injections.
- newprint 4y agofor RA ?
- cellularmitosis 4y agoThat’s probably Humira, so RA, Crohn’s or UC. Many of the immunomodulator drugs are in a similar price range.
- spondylosaurus 4y agoPraying for generic adalimumab to finally hit the US market. People overseas have been getting this stuff for a hundred bucks a pop for years now, but AbbVie's done everything in their power to extend the US patent for as long as possible. They'd milk us forever if they could.
- paddim8 4y agoMine cost about 350€ or so for 6 pens. I only pay 240€ a year though.
- alistairSH 4y agoYup. Family member is on Remicade. It's administered in two doses (IV infusions) every 4 months, so 6 treatments/year. And retails for something like $12k/treatment. And many insurance companies have removed it from their list of preferred drugs due to the cost, leaving patients to fight for medically necessary treatment. It's a fucking nightmare (as if RA on it's own isn't bad enough).
- quantumwoke 4y agoAlthough the title is definitive, it should really say "possible". > In keeping with this, the researchers only found this Subdoligranulum strain in 16.7 percent of people at risk or with early-stage RA, indicating that this strain is likely not the sole driver of disease. Still, exciting work. The gut-brain axis is so important.
- drewg123 4y agoI'm curious if there is a similar bacteria that triggers Crohn's disease and/or Ulcerative Colitis. I'm wondering this because there is a large crossover in the biologic "TNF Blocker" drugs that treat RA, Crohn's and UC (Humira, Remicade, etc).
- hanniabu 4y agoAs someone that's been dealing with SIBO (small intestinal bacterial overgrowth), I'm confident that most diseases are the result of your gut microbiome. Really looking forward to research in this field and I hope the US starts putting more focus on phage therapy.
- colordrops 4y agoDid you take rifaximin, and did it work? I'm currently on my fourth day, and am finding that all of my joint pain has disappeared. Could be coincidental, but now there's the coincidence of this story in Science.
- hanniabu 4y agoBeen dealing with it 3 years now, took the first 1.5 years to figure out what it was. So far took 2 rounds of rifaximin. The first round didn't do much, but the second round (with neomycin) got rid of my methane overgrowth. I still have a hydrogen overgrowth and waiting on insurance to improve another round of just rifaximin. Do you have a methane or hydrogen overgrowth?
- pazimzadeh 4y agoYou could try some over the counter herb-based supplements: Herbal Therapy Is Equivalent to Rifaximin for the Treatment of Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4030608/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4030608/ Subjects with newly diagnosed SIBO by lactulose breath testing (LBT) were given two open-label treatment choices based upon individualized treatment preference; either two 200 mg rifaximin tablets three times daily (TID) or 2 capsules twice daily of the following commercial herbal preparations; Dysbiocide and FC Cidal (Biotics Research Laboratories, Rosenberg, Texas) or Candibactin-AR and Candibactin-BR (Metagenics, Inc, Aliso Viejo, California) for 4 consecutive weeks immediately followed by a repeat LBT. I have been taking Candibactin-AR and Candibactin-BR with my meals and have seen an improvement in my stool consistency (I have recently diagnosed SIBO/Crohn's). I was given the metronidazole for one week and it helped as well, but symptoms came back.
- lostlogin 4y agoI’m not a warrior for animal rights and actively trap pests including mice. But the animal testing here gives an uncomfortable feeling. However it’s hard to think of an alternative that doesn’t end up with things like coerced adults or poorly consented paid volunteers.
- virgulino 4y agoAnkylosing Spondylitis is a closely related disease, treated with the same anti-TNF biological drugs. There is 30 years of contradictory research on the association of the disease with the bacteria Klebsiella pneumoniae. So far, it has come to nothing. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1561397/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1561397/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29438717/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29438717/
- spondylosaurus 4y agoCame here to mention AS and the klebsiella hypothesis. Like you said, nothing conclusive has come out of it (and certainly no evidence of using antibacterial treatment successfully to treat AS), but I still find it super interesting considering the high comorbidity between AS and intestinal diseases like Crohn's and ulcerative colitis. IIRC some of the more recent "AS is a form of reactive arthritis" truthers have focused on gut infections specifically as the pathway. Big grain of salt, of course. Thankfully even if we can't pinpoint its exact etiology we still have a million proven drugs to throw at this thing.
- virgulino 4y agoI started with a diagnosis of reactive arthritis (still called Reiter's Syndrome at the time), after an intestinal infection. After 10 years of feeling fine and unmedicated, but with occasional flare-ups, I suddenly went downhill and my diagnosis was changed to ankylosing spondylitis (modified New York criteria). To my knowledge, there is very little research on the separation or progression between reactive arthritis and ankylosing spondylitis.
- spondylosaurus 4y agoThat's brutal. I hope you're doing alright these days.
- virgulino 4y agoI loved your username "spondylosaurus", it made me laugh, thank you. I wish you well too. Cheers!
- zeagle 4y agoI'm surprised to see an article on rheumatoid arthritis (RA) at the top of HN. RA is a complicated disease. This is interesting but there is already data implicating infections like P. gingevalis, EBV, Parvovirus B19 with plausible mechanisms like citrullination of proteins, molecular mimicry contributing but there is no direct evidence and issues with these being prevalent in the general population. The question to ask when reading this are: Does this antibody/evidence of prior infection raise or decrease the probably of developing pre-RA? clinical-RA? Is it pathogenic or just an interesting finding? What's the prevalence of these antibodies in first degree relatives without disease or healthy controls in the general population e.g. can you reasonably use it for screening? I'd say the answer is no / we don't know to all of these and they it needs more research before this is clinically interesting. RA is a complicated disease but ultimately a clinical (/imaging) diagnosis based on synovitis and extraarticular features supported by investigations. There are mouse models of arthritis e.g. collagen induced but sometimes hard to translate to humans. If you are interested in the topic. Think of RA in terms of a susceptible host progressing to benign autoimmunity, subclinical disease, then clinical disease. Factors like HLA-DR4/DRB1*0401/0404 increases an individual's lifetime risk but are seen in 20-30% of population vs 0.5-2% of the population having disease so aren't helpful from a screening point of view. Environmental exposures like smoking (the data says in shared epitope + individuals) raise that risk significantly. Other exposures like microbiome are clearly important and they interact with the immune system (e.g. via TLRs) so they probably make a difference but aren't well studied (this work would fit in here trying to address it). There is good cohort data that many patients develop detectable autoantibodies years ('benign autoimmunity) before becoming patients with clinical disease. But even with everything Ive said this is still a two-way street: some of these individuals don't develop disease and can even lose their autoantibodies. In at least one real world cohort I'm aware it's been shown of you can be very high risk with ethnicity, CCP+, RF+, have a family member with RA (in some sense controlling for genetics, environmental exposures) and you still have even odds of progressing to disease vs. losing your double seropositive status and not developing disease. So what do you do with that? (It comes down a clinical diagnosis with prompt recognition, treatment to target of remission.) The (very important) trials so far for treating/preventing preclinical RA in ~similar high-risk individuals have been sadly negative or at best may delay onset slightly (abatacept, hydroxychloroquine).
- fswd 4y agoIf I take antibiotics, my back pain 100% goes away.
- sec400 4y agoAs a side note/additional area to explore, some antibiotics do also have anti-inflammatory effects
- kvgr 4y agoI have same anecdotal evidence about my mood. I had some tooth infections and took some strong horse dose antibiotics couple times in my life and my mood and “adhd” symptoms got better.
- 7speter 4y agoA lot of people (me included) report this when they induce ketosis after eliminating carbs and sugar. It would seem reducing carbs and sugars would drastically change the biotic makeup of one's gut, so this is all seeming to be tied to ones gut... microbiota is very interesting.
- manmal 4y agoAnecdotally, I‘ve experienced these benefits after ca 9 months of strictly no sugar (not even fruit). But just a couple weeks of eTRF (stopping to eat at 3PM) gave the same results (normal IF did nothing of the kind for me).
- funnym0nk3y 4y agoThat does not surprise me at all. For depression there is the chronic inflammation hypothesis which states that depression is caused by subacute inflammation in the brain. Some antibiotics work as antiinflammatory agents. Although a recent study did not show significant evidence for the treatment of chronic depression with antibiotics. Then there is something along the lines of underexpressed BDNF genes which get more expressed by butyrate which in turn is produced by gut bacteria. And there have been some case studies for treatment resistant depression where they did a stool transplant which improved the symptoms considerably.
- Keyframe 4y agoHope there will be advancement for RA. It took my father away, doctor, at 71 years old. RA led to lung fibrosis which ultimately gave him a heart attack.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoWould this cause arthritis in hips too, or just hands?
- spondylosaurus 4y agoArthritis in the hips sounds more like a form of spondyloarthritis. (Ask me how I know, lol.)
- dukeofdoom 4y agoHow do you know? I know someone that had this, which led to difficulty walking and inactivity, which resulted in blood clots in legs.
- spondylosaurus 4y agoAw, I'm sorry to hear that. AS can absolutely wreck your mobility over time. (And the reason I know is because I also have AS—I should've been more clear and gestured towards my username :P)
- dukeofdoom 4y agoNot sure if it was the same thing, or just worn out hips, Osteoarthritis? But in retrospect, I've been thinking about it. A timer and getting up from the computer every half hour or wearing compression socks and maybe a foot massager would have helped. But I'm not sure if it would have been enough to prevent DVT.
- pkoird 4y agoWould love to talk to you some!
- spondylosaurus 4y agoHN doesn't have messaging features, does it? Feel free to shoot me a DM on Reddit then, I'm -ThisWasATriumph over there. (Just don't forget the leading hyphen in my username!)
- dghughes 4y agoThis reminds me of my GERD when it was bad and if I had the flu (yes I was vaccinated) my GERD symptoms disappeared. It was flu not a cold and I didn't have a runny nose if anyone is assuming it was post nasal drip causing a antacid effect. I developed hypothyroidism a few years later too. I know people can develop type 1 diabetes from influenza I had a first aid instructor tell me of a local incidence of such a thing after a block party. The pancreas and thyroid both being part of the endocrine system it's tempting to guess of wild things going on inside me. So GERD and hypothyroidism and viruses who knows what is going on. It's hard to not sound like a nut telling stories that are just anecdotal!
- spondylosaurus 4y agoAlso anecdotal, but I know a lot of people with autoimmune diseases report feeling "better" when they're sick. Might be because your immune system finally has a real target to set its sights on and takes a break from attacking your own tissues.
- vjk800 4y agoI also have relatively bad GERD and I've also noticed it getting better when I have flu or some other minor illness. I think this is just because I eat less and move less. Moving less helps because sometimes random movements in a wrong way can trigger the reflux. GERD is also one of those ailments that seems to be sometimes cured by weird random lifestyle changes. Low/no carbohydrate diet is something some people swear by. I also know someone whose GERD was completely cured after an antibiotics treatment to an unrelated disease. For GERD there seems to be one clear structural factor that has something to do with its development: hiatal hernia. However, the link is not perfect so it's possible other factors (such as some microbial imbalance) affect it too.
- dghughes 4y agoActually also the recent Parkinson's breakthrough reminded me of when Fox and three crew of a TV show he was on as a young teen all developed Parkinson's disease. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leo_and_Me https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leo_and_Me
- broguinn 4y agoThe gut-brain axis is so important. It's only natural that commenters here would want to know when a treatment for RA is available based on these findings. Nothing's for certain, but it wouldn't hurt to improve your gut biome. - Take a probiotic and prebiotic daily. Swanson sells a bunch of cheap and high-quality ones. - Some people have had luck improving their gut health with supplementing collagen peptides. YMMV. Obviously, the gold standard is a double-blind study that proves the effectiveness at eliminating rheumatoid arthritis through intervention. Both of the above suggestions are well-tolerated in the general populace.
- bighoki2885000 4y ago[dead]
- kytazo 4y agoFor me it was electricity, make sure you're not exposed to high currents and strong electrical fields. Especially things like a modern macbook charger plugged in is capable of producing fields up to 1000v according to the emf meter I got on hand. My own experience is very consistent confirms it as well. Check how can a two hour session where you get your body voltage close to 0 can reduce inflammation. Imagine the opposite effect, possibly multiples. https://yewtu.be/44ddtR0XDVU?t=1667 https://yewtu.be/44ddtR0XDVU?t=1667 You can also check this lecture by Dr Jerry Tennant which may give you a better understanding overall. Hope this helps someone.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoyou can "get exposed to a field up to 1000v" by rubbing a balloon against your hair
- jodrellblank 4y agoThat's not a strong counterargument because people use laptop chargers for hours at a time many days of every week, compared to rubbing balloons against their hair maybe ten minutes total spread out over a lifetime.
- zabzonk 4y agoonly if you don't have your tin hat on
- culopatin 4y agoAny papers on the topic?
- bgribble 4y agoI know anecdotes aren't data, but I would not be surprised if this was hitting close to the truth. I had a friend who had RA starting in her teens and was on very heavy medication for it, with no real hope of improvement. In her mid-20s she changed her diet significantly -- I think she went gluten free, maybe it was some other restriction. I thought it was silly TBH, why would changing what you eat affect arthritis? After about 6 months her RA was entirely in remission and she was off all of her medication. As far as I know has not recurred. I can very easily imagine that dramatic diet changes affect the gut biome and could have tipped the scales to make her gut less hospitable for specific causes of RA. I hope so!
- zzedd 4y agovery similar experience with me. after frustration with medical treatment over many years into my mid-60s, i went gluten-free and symptoms cleared within weeks.
- Gareth321 4y agoVery similar for me. Mid 30s, chronic arthritis in multiple joints. Lots of other issues as well. I had previously derided those on gluten free diets, but in desperation, I tried it. After two weeks my symptoms abated significantly. A year on and I feel like a million dollars. I have no idea if I had some kind of intolerance to gluten, or if some bacteria really liked that gluten, but it worked.
- miek 4y agoI experienced the same, although my gluten-induced inflammation is linked to something with my gut bacteria. If I take a certain antibiotic that targets the digestive tract, I can eat anything for 9 months, including gluten, without problems. After about 9 months, I can no longer eat gluten. And then about a year after that, I can't eat corn. This has repeated 3 times, and unfortunately, I'm with a gastro doc now who won't give me the antibiotics and wants to test me for celiac (which will be the 5th time - I've always been negative).
- bastardoperator 4y agoI was diagnosed with RA, I ignored it forever until I was having issues functioning normally. I was prescribed prednisone for a week and then methotrexate/folic acid. The methotrexate helped me feel fine despite decimating my hairline. After about a year into the pandemic I just stopped taking the methotrexate/folic acid after a couple of years of using it regularly, and I haven't had an RA issue since. I had tried this way in the past, but I would get flair ups, but this time around no symptoms.
- 300bps 4y agoI’ve had mild psoriasis since I was a young teenager. One day it disappeared. Then about 15 years later it came back. In one particularly stressful time of my life it progressed to psoriatic arthritis. Then that went away when the stressful situation was resolved. I’m now trying to retrace my steps to try to make it go away again. Low inflammation diet, lots of sleep, low stress.
- Havoc 4y agoTIL hairline. My doc never warned me about that
- bastardoperator 4y agoMine either, I would have opted for something else. I didn't understand that methotrexate is chemotherapy.
- codeaken 4y agoI have been following RA for years now. There is a small public company (OMX:SYNACT) I found that are in its Phase 2b with a medication that looks very promising. They completed their Phase 2a with statistical significance in a couple of key indicators. It looks like to be on par with JAK inhibitors but with a cleaner safety profile and no need for injections. Unlike the JAK inhibitors that suppresses the immune system, their pill instead resolves the inflammation by activating receptor 1 and 3 in the melanocortin system. Phase 2b completes this summer and I am personally super excited to see the results.
- deeel 4y agoHad a major flare up of RA after a particularly stressful moment in life. Went to doctor who prescribed steroid lotion - a non starter. After research and some trial and error what solved it fairly quickly were high doses of extremely high quality fish oil (DHA & EPA) and an overall cleaner diet with less low quality gluten. As for the "spots" sunlight seemed to be the best disinfectant to the point where now if there is any flare up I just get a nice tan and they go away. I have no scientific basis for any of this so DYOR.
- michalu 4y agoWhich brand of fish oil did you use?
- vvram 4y ago+1 Would be great if you can share the brand
- deeel 4y agoOriginal brand was out of Sweden and I can't find it anymore. But now using Carlson which you can find at any Whole Foods and it has been great.
- miek 4y agoI use Carlson also; from everything I've read, that is the best. I eat fatty fish a few times a week too, but I saw no harm in adding a little extra oil.
- ctime 4y agoWhen you say "spots", are you referring to locations in your body (joints) where you are experiencing inflammation and swelling? How much fish oil are you taking? I think the normal dose is a tablespoon, how much did you have to increase the dose? Have you tried Cod Liver oil instead? Are you taking any other vitamins regularly?
- treeman79 4y agoSounds like a resurgence of Marshal protocol. My autoimmune condition Sjogrens (similar to RA)was initially diagnosed (later confirmed) specifically because symptoms always improved on antibiotics. Was an old optha-neurologist doctor who had noticed this trend over his life time. I later found the marshal protocol. But modern doctors have no interest in bacteria as a cause of problems. https://mpkb.org/home/patients/protocol_overview https://mpkb.org/home/patients/protocol_overview
- ekianjo 4y agoA word of caution for everyone talking about RA here. RA is just a simple name we give to a number of conditions that share similar symptoms but we dont really know if they are all related and if they share the same root causes or not. Its not a very specific disease that you can diagnose, so what may have worked for you does not carry much bearing on what would work on someone else with a condition labeled as RA
- zeagle 4y agoSeropositive RA is a specific but variable condition. Seronegative RA... you are quite right. It's almost easier to group by a rational treatment approach for a chronic inflammatory polyarthritis that looks like RA clinically rather than one diagnostic entity. Here is kind of a fun prospective study that illustrates your point well: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29998832/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29998832/ . The investors assessed what patients in their centre were reclassified into 10 years after a diagnosis of seronegative RA. "13 (13/435 [3%]) could be reclassified as seropositive or erosive RA: 4 turned seropositive (2 for ACPA and 2 for RF [> 2x reference level]) and 9 developed erosions typical for RA. " ... "Reclassification revealed 68 (16%) cases of polymyalgia rheumatica, 46 (11%) psoriatic arthritis, 45 (10%) osteoarthritis, 38 (8.7%) spondyloarthritis, 15 (3.4%) plausible reactive arthritis, 10 (2.3%) gout, 17 (3.9%) pseudogout, 6 (1.4%) paraneoplastic arthritis, 6 (1.4%) juvenile arthritis, 2 (0.5%) haemochromatosis, 3 (0.7%) ankylosing spondylitis, 2 (0.5%) giant cell arteritis, and 8 miscellaneous diagnoses. The other 140 patients (32%) could not be reclassified in any clear-cut diagnosis " Caveat: A big limitation is we don't know how many patients were diagnosed with seropositive RA in that time frame: I'd wager it's over an order of magnitude higher. These were probably less clear cut cases.
- kodah 4y agoI was diagnosed with RA a few years ago when my left knee kept swelling to the size of a grapefruit. It was incredibly painful; I have a very high pain tolerance and it put me in tears and made me bed ridden or on crutches for multiple days at a time. Doctors were unable to find anything in the fluid of my knee and the only thing that seemed to work was corticosteroids. Prior to that I was given the diagnosis of pseudo-gout. I took methotrexate in my twenties and thirties for years, my hair fell out, and I couldn't drink. When I moved I went to reup my prescription at a Rheumatologist who ran a research clinic and as she went over my paperwork she looked in shock as she read through it and asked me, "Have you actually ever had site testing for RA or did they just look for markers?" Turns out, all they'd ever looked for was markers, tried methotrexate, and my symptoms stopped. Doctors at Baylor Scott & White thought that was good enough. At the time, I was told repeatedly that we know "a lot" about RA and that I could trust the diagnosis. I was slowly weened off of methotrexate and we waited to see if I would have a flare-up. The flare-up never came and she told me not to come back after telling me more or less what you've said here. I also learned it's incredibly difficult to sue a doctor for a misdiagnosis, even if they put you on a drug like methotrexate and took years of normalcy from your life.
- mlhpdx 4y agoMakes me wonder if T1D would be of a similar ilk? Hypothetically, of course.
- bighoki2885000 4y ago[dead]
- twosdai 4y agoSomewhat off topic. But I felt like this article was extreamly well written. It summarized the science while also not going overboard in trying to convince the reader that the bacteria referenced was 100% definitely the main culprit. I really liked how the experiment was broken down so that a normal person could understand the high level logical steps between each section.
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- bighoki2885000 4y ago[dead]
- mrblah 4y agoMore anecdotes, I was diagnosed with debilitating pulmonary sarcoidosis several years back and after 8 months of steroids and pain killers wrecking my stomach I found some research on the 'immuno-modulating' effects of some broad spectrum antibiotics, with minocycline in particular being successfully used as therapy. I printed out some pubmed articles and convinced my pulmonologist that it was a relatively low risk thing to try because I was hating the standard by-the-book therapy. Within a few days I was feeling better and after a couple weeks started waning down, so just about a month total to remission. I've only had the feeling of flare-ups returning a few times since after drinking or being stressed out. I have no doubt antibiotic therapy helped me. There are so many biological pathways with everyone being different so for at least some people, bacterial problems upstream could be the initial conditions that put your system into chaos downstream. A lot of autoimmune diseases are just fancy words for 'unexplained inflammation' and doctors (who are trying their best), use a differential diagnostic funnel based on what's likely and what's worked as treatment for others. But if the standard treatments aren't working for you, do your own research and ask your doctor to try something else.
- th0ma5 4y agoAny links to these articles?
- mrblah 4y agoIt was over 10 years ago, iirc there were more case studies on skin vs pulmonary, but a quick search found this one https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18458989/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18458989/ another search term would be the broader class of antibiotics tetracyclines
- moremetadata 4y ago[dead]
- th0ma5 4y agoThank you!
- bighoki2885000 4y ago[dead]