16 ms·
Get The TLDR Of Any YouTube Video
- rado 4y ago“You've reached the daily limit of summaries allowed”
- messe 4y agoI built a similar thing with the GPT-4 APIs a few weeks ago; thanks for the reminder that I must put it on GitHub at some point, as it's only about 30 lines of code.
- drewrbaker 4y agoI need this, but for Vimeo videos.
- messe 4y agoIt should be doable. What I built only works for videos with transcripts, but I've been looking to improve it using OpenAI's Whisper for Speech-To-Text. I'm just lazy so I haven't gotten around to it (...which is why I spent an hour throwing together a 30-line script to summarize youtube videos for me)
- f0e4c2f7 4y agoFor you or anyone else reading this I recently ran across this video documenting setting up and using whisper. It's probably a little overdetailed, but I found the github docs a little underdetailed so might be useful. Whisper is pretty powerful. One of the more useful open source ai tools available right now. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XX-ET_-onYU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XX-ET_-onYU But as you implied in your comment, it should be possible to do it quite well with any video by transcripting with whisper and then sending the text to gpt or another LLM to summarize.
- messe 4y agoI'll check it out (or maybe let my script check it out first), thanks. From what I remember the Whisper API docs weren't too bad, but I didn't try actually implementing anything, so you could be right that they're underdetailed.
- cced 4y agoI’m currently working on this with the caveat that I want to do the work locally. Using whisper but the summarization portion if this task is not straightforward given the limited context size of models. Does anyone have any additional insight into this problem?
- sethgecko 4y agoI’ve done something similar here https://github.com/mcdallas/summarize https://github.com/mcdallas/summarize it feeds an audio file to whisper and then summarizes the transcript. You can easily wrap it with yt-dlp to download the audio portion of a video
- mkagenius 4y agoI also did the same but its a web app, https://github.com/mkagenius/audioGPT https://github.com/mkagenius/audioGPT (i also have it hosted but I am afraid if i post the link, it would eat through all my credits)
- belter 4y agoMaybe one for TikTok videos? Would be the scourge of influencers...
- wand3r 4y agoThe GPT4 API is not generally available yet right? At least for the public?
- messe 4y agoYou can apply for access, and you'll be added to a waiting list. I only have access to the GPT4 API with 8K context, not 32K.
- permo-w 4y agoit’s accessible via the beta. they gave me access after a day or two of waiting, but I don’t know if that’s typical or not
- sebzim4500 4y agoThere's a waiting list. I applied on the first day and only just got access.
- rolisz 4y agoNo :(. I applied several weeks ago and I still don't have access
- gregw134 4y agoPlease do. Curious how you transform a YouTube video to text before sending to chatgpt?
- sva_ 4y agoShouldn't it be TLDW? (Too Long, Didn't Watch)
- lisper 4y agoYes, it should. Does it matter? No, it does not.
- ehsankia 4y agotechnically it's not summarizing the video. It's summarizing the transcript of the video. So if it's a silent video with no spoken words, it likely won't do anything. So it is tl;dr of the spoken words, as parsed by Youtube ML since most videos don't have provided transcripts, though some do.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- f0e4c2f7 4y agoWow! I love everything about this! Great product, great pricing model. I tried it out on a video I had recently watched and can confirm it works well. Giving away free summaries without even requiring a login feels very generous whereas the videos I really want to pop in are longer than the free tier allows. But the pricing still seems more than fair. Very cool product, excited to use it more. Have you considered adding browser extension functionality? A one click button on each youtube video might be nice.
- dang 4y agoRelated: Show HN: You-tldr-Summarize and Interact with YouTube Videos in your language - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35280312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35280312 - March 2023 (2 comments) Show HN: You-tldr – easy-to-read transcripts of Youtube videos - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26048946 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26048946 - Feb 2021 (72 comments)
- belter 4y agoDo you ever sleep? :-)
- MikeSchurman 4y agoLooks useful. Suggestion: as a non-paying user I don't immediately know what the chat tab does. You can find out under the pricing tab but it's not obvious where to find this information. Might be good to say what it does on the chat tab if you're not a paid user.
- bena 4y agoSo first I tried it on a video that was too long. It produced a transcript though. Which is something. But it was an easy test. I chose an episode of a television show that is uploaded to YouTube. So I said, "fuck it", and chose a more difficult example. A video with no talking. It's just music and images. Some algodoo/Unity physics sandbox marble competition our son likes to watch. It just gave up. Then I was going to try another short video with talking, but apparently you only get one summary. So, it seems like it's a way to generate transcripts of videos and have that summarized. Neat, but not exactly what's being advertised.
- dexterdog 4y agoHey, at least you got one. I tried one and it said my limit was reached.
- okdood64 4y ago> It produced a transcript though. Which is something. You can get those directly in YouTube, so not really something. It's a shame; it said throttled on the first and second video I tried.
- amiga386 4y agoFor those that don't know how: 1. Watch a Youtube video which has subtitles 2. Click the "..." button below the video, then "Show Transcript" So many people don't know about this, it's crazy.
- davidthewatson 4y agoThe tool is solid and delivers priceless value proposition for someone like me who learns by reading not by listening. Bravo!
- ehsankia 4y agoTried it and immediately says I'm out of quota? Probably got hugged to death by HN?
- s3p 4y agosame here.
- tdiggity 4y agoIt said I reached the daily limit on the first video I entered and didn’t even give me a summary :(
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agosame, not a great user experience, why would I pay money when you've already shown me you fail at doing the thing?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _the_inflator 4y agoOk, someone has to mention it: TLDW would be more precise. ;)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 404mm 4y agoI’m not sure. I tried one video and got: Something went wrong! The video could be missing subtitles for the language you selected. So it was TLDR in my case. Almost.
- throwbadubadu 4y agoTLADW actually.. (A for the ad) - great service! Now please we need a bot that posts the summary under every youtube submission.
- textninja 4y agoChrome extension maybe?
- joanne123 4y ago[flagged]
- swampthinker 4y ago@dang serial spammer
- hasseldahoff 4y agoThis seems to be a spam account for hacking services. This account should be nuked.
- rsiqueira 4y ago"Summarize Tech" is a similar tool: Get a summary of any long YouTube video, like a lecture, live event or a government meeting. Powered by ChatGPT. https://www.summarize.tech/ https://www.summarize.tech/ Pros: It can summarize larger videos for free. Cons: no chat, English only, no full transcript viewer, no settings, no transcript download.
- chpatrick 4y agoHow does that handle videos longer than the token limit?
- ashellunts 4y agoSplit to smaller chunks, summarize them. Then summarize summaries.
- prettyStandard 4y agoYou might want to overlap the first pass of chunks, something could get lost at the chunk boundaries. Not any sort of expert on this sort of thing, it just seems like an obvious pitfall for the context length.
- textninja 4y agoI really like this idea. It’s basically applying similar principles as are used in image based nets - i.e. sliding window convolutional kernels - to text.
- peterhunt 4y agoI built summarize.tech Yes it's a great idea and I have a version that is basically a convolution over the transcript. It works much better than the current version - it can automatically create cohesive chapters and summaries of those chapters - however, it consumes an order of magnitude more ChatGPT API calls making it uneconomical (for now!)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ajhai 4y agoWe let users build similar apps at https://trypromptly.com https://trypromptly.com without writing code When YouTube urls are used, we extract audio and transcribe it so users can either save as datasource or pass that content to other LLMs. Ask YC (https://trypromptly.com/app/bd0a3f40-44a9-4789-b3d6-ec185134c27f https://trypromptly.com/app/bd0a3f40-44a9-4789-b3d6-ec185134...) is an app built with content from YC startup library and some of them are YouTube videos
- jdthedisciple 4y agoExcuse me sir, but why does your website have such God awful colors and contrast that I almost need therapy for my eyes after looking at it for 2 minutes? Do feel free to hire me and have it fixed no problem. Message here if interested.
- XCSme 4y ago[dead]
- themodelplumber 4y agoIt's really restricted for free-tryout users. I'm not sure why it's so restricted though. Seems like it might be helpful to offer a 1-5x try-out of videos up to 2 hours and then go down from there? I went straight for 1+ hour YT videos that came to mind, but was told to upgrade. Ideally this experience could be smoothed out a bit, especially since the transcript is in some cases functionally unreadable and jarringly different from a summary.
- kodt 4y agoAppears to only work if the video has subtitles.
- jerpint 4y agoI made a version which works on any video, uses whisper to get the transcript. Might be time to whip it into a demo Video: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WtMrp2hp94E https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WtMrp2hp94E Blog: https://www.jerpint.io/blog/yougptube/ https://www.jerpint.io/blog/yougptube/
- raverbashing 4y agoLooks useful There are creators that put out videos with potential but they're very bad at editing or just drag on and on about stuff. As much as Shorts have, well, pushed for shorter videos, a lot of the longer videos need to get better at getting to the point. It doesn't have to be a short video, but think about the value you're adding by keeping something in the video instead of taking it out.
- justinator 4y agoI reached the daily limit on the first video I tried to summarize.
- dean2432 4y agome too.
- eimrine 4y agoI would like to get a sum of "Linux Full Course 11 hours" but in 666 words.
- Animats 4y agoYeah. I tried two videos. The site demanded money because it was too long. Then I tried a shorter one, and the site demanded money because I'd reached my daily limit. Is this for real?
- fallat 4y agoWhere's the one that takes screenshots, I like that better
- super256 4y agoI wish there was pay for usage instead of a monthly sub.
- fmeyer 4y agoI've built the same thing using chatGPT, it doesn't handle large content yet, but it's good enough to filter the majority of videos and help me decide if I should watch it or not. some sample here https://gist.github.com/fmeyer/87fce5279bb06e215828e7732fed740e https://gist.github.com/fmeyer/87fce5279bb06e215828e7732fed7... code: https://github.com/fmeyer/tldw https://github.com/fmeyer/tldw ps: don’t mind my crappy rust.
- kpennell 4y agodidn't get to try - Daily Limit Reached You've reached the daily limit of summaries allowed. Please upgrade to Pro to continue using the service.
- sunshadow 4y agoJust made open source version of it (core): https://github.com/musabgultekin/youtube-tldw https://github.com/musabgultekin/youtube-tldw
- sdjcse1 4y agohttps://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7057961285484744704?updateEntityUrn=urn%3Ali%3Afs_feedUpdate%3A%28V2%2Curn%3Ali%3Aactivity%3A7057961285484744704%29 https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7057961...
- ta1243 4y ago> Daily Limit Reached > You've reached the daily limit of summaries allowed. On the first successful video (the first video I tried didn't have subtitles)
- numpad0 4y agoSame here, maybe they ran out of trial budget for a day considering it's been 3 hours since this is posted.
- andy_ppp 4y agoI was starting to build this! Great idea, all we need is a flawless talking head to read it to us before every video to see if we should watch it!
- nullsense 4y agoTortoise TTS + SadTalker
- thr0waway001 4y agoWanted to summarize "Stu pickles makes Pudding at 4AM in the morning" but I reached the daily limit. First video. Ok then. shrug
- niels_bom 4y agoWould be a nice product to offer to media companies that have a lot of video content.
- _cenw 4y agoThe transcript is really bad for a podcast I tried, I'm almost certain that's OpenAIs whisper, which when I tested wasn't very accurate when people don't speak extremely clearly or over each other.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoIs it the small or large model? Whisper is leagues beyond anything previously available, while being runnable on consumer grade hardware.
- technics256 4y agoDo you have the source? Would like to try it through my tools
- ashellunts 4y agoI have also built similar thing. https://github.com/ashellunts/youtube-summarizer https://github.com/ashellunts/youtube-summarizer From time to time, it is useful for me. https://youtube-summarizer.ashellunts.repl.co https://youtube-summarizer.ashellunts.repl.co
- pdevr 4y agoI got an internal server error. Looks like your site was also hugged to death? Will try later.
- ashellunts 4y agoIt may be due to not supported url format.
- pdevr 4y agoYou have a typo ("wihthout") in both prompts, which are both (apparently) handled correctly by OpenAI - too lazy to send a PR :)
- adamkochanowicz 4y agoI use https://kagi.com/summarizer/index.html?url=&target_language=&engine=agnes https://kagi.com/summarizer/index.html?url=&target_language=... which summarizes YouTube, articles, books, links...
- _puk 4y ago"You can summarize many types of web content, including: Text web pages, articles, and forum threads PDF documents PowerPoint documents (.pptx) Audio files (mp3/wav) YouTube URLs"... It doesn't actually state video, do you know if it's summarizing the actual YouTube video, or the subtitles? Whilst they may seem the same, I can see the former being able to be refined over time based on e.g. in scene visual context
- textninja 4y agoIt appears to summarize the subtitles alone. I asked it to summarize a video that didn’t have subtitles (silent film) and it refused. Edit: I missed some of the context, comment above is re you-tldr, not kagi which I haven’t tried.
- hackernewds 4y agoif it is based solely on subtitles it would seem that those with conversations between characters would get very confusing summaries.
- syngrog66 4y agosummary. or synopsis lets kill that already-anachronistic hipster acronym. ideally with fire (LKTAAHA;IWF) also: kids, get off my lawn
- umaar 4y agoIf anyone wants to self-host these YouTube summary tools, made a video on exactly how to do that here https://youtu.be/dqtliRSLmQo https://youtu.be/dqtliRSLmQo
- lukeasch21 4y agoThis tutorial video is way too long... If only there was a tool to summarize it into text using AI....
- jerpint 4y agoFunny enough, I also made a YouTube video explaining how to summarize YouTube videos, and used it on my own video! YouTube: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WtMrp2hp94E https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WtMrp2hp94E Blog post: https://www.jerpint.io/blog/yougptube/ https://www.jerpint.io/blog/yougptube/
- Technetium 4y agoI've been using Glarity to do this for free without leaving YouTube. Site: https://glarity.app https://glarity.app Source: https://github.com/sparticleinc/chatgpt-google-summary-extension https://github.com/sparticleinc/chatgpt-google-summary-exten...
- youniverse 4y agoI've been using https://youtubetranscript.com https://youtubetranscript.com and then having GPT4 summarize but admittedly it will miss some things and for example a marketing video you it might miss the one interesting thing that I'd want to hear in the summary. Will give this and other things in the thread a shot!
- itsthecourier 4y agoTrying to summarize "Rick rolling"
- AkBKukU 4y agoI am a person who produces videos to publish on Youtube, and I want to add a different perspective to this. Here is where we are currently at: - Everyone complains about the ads, so they install adblock. - Ads become worthless on Youtube for smaller creators, so they start taking sponsorships. - Everyone complains about the sponsors, they call creators shills and sponsorblock is gaining traction to block them. - Smaller creators shift to being dependent on direct support (Patreon, etc.) Here is where we are going: - People complain a video is too long, so they extract the data directly avoiding youtube. - The creators don't get ads, don't get people to understand the effort put in and support directly, and don't get views. The videos just don't get watched. A feedback loop is happening here where every possible method that allows making quality Youtube content sustainable is becoming impossible. The fact that anyone here is willing to pay for this service that will destroy the last shreds of this is extremely disheartening. If you stop watching videos, there will be no reason to make the videos.
- sv123 4y agoI wouldn't feel too disheartened just yet, if people wanted to read instead of watch videos then we all would've stuck with blogger, or even just go back to usenet. As you can see in the comments here, these services are a dime a dozen. Seems like everybody and their mother have made a youtube summarizer, its like the todo list app of the ChatGPT api.
- jagged-chisel 4y ago> … if people wanted to read instead of watch videos … Eh, I think it’s also “if creators wanted to write instead of shoot videos,” but it really is easier to just talk to the camera (with all the nuance of vocal and facial expressions) and put that online than to spend time deliberating on how to write is as a blog post.
- account42 4y agoIt's also some degree of Google prioritizing videos in searches over written results.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bazinga30 4y agohttps://videohighlight.com/ https://videohighlight.com/ is another option, mostly focused on note taking. There are no limits so at this stage.
- omoikane 4y agoThis looks like a paid service, do they have any way of sharing the revenue with the creators who made those videos?
- thenerdhead 4y agoTLDW?
- anonu 4y agoReally cool. I tried one of the primitive technology videos: https://youtu.be/JsObuHO1tMA https://youtu.be/JsObuHO1tMA They are silent but have pretty good captions explaining what is going on. Seems like this site is also reading the captions.
- lakomen 4y agoShould be TL;DW I watch videos , don't read them, you?
- Dwedit 4y ago[Music] you know the rules [Music] gotta make you understand [Music] goodbye [Music] we've known each other for so long your heart's been [Music] going aching [Music] never gonna say goodbye [Music] never gonna make you gonna say cry [Music]
- funnyfoobar 4y agoI wanted to make something like this, but I think youtube is going to send them a notice sooner or later, correct me if I am wrong, there is no official way to download a video from youtube https://stackoverflow.com/a/8081778 https://stackoverflow.com/a/8081778 The site is super fast, wrt generating transcript and even the summary is super fast. I am very impressed with this. If I want to generate a summary on bunch of text? do i have to use embeddings? anyone has done something similar?
- gumby 4y agoThis is the wavefront of a bunch of useful tools to come. I very rarely watch video (for many reasons but mainly because the value/unit time is so low, especially compared to reading) and never listen to podcasts. I get a lot of redundant articles in my various streams (RSS feeds mainly, but twitter, FB, HN, slack, even email and messages). Would love to funnel all that into a huge summarizer that would pull out the interesting stuff, combine scraps from otherwise mostly overlapping articles, and, yes, even YouTube etc, so I could get the gist plus get to “the” original if desired. I expect to be able to do this very soon (and expect some of those channels to resist…which will simply finish driving me away.
- thrdbndndn 4y agoI assume this works by letting AI (ChatGPT or alike) summarize based on subtitles/transcript? Unfortunately the auto-generated subtitles for some languages (e.g. Japanese) on YouTube is pretty bad so I don't think it's gonna work well for these languages.
- shauryamanu 4y agoWhy would I tldr max 30mins video, I tried tlrd'ing 2hrs video but not in the free tier.
- teutonic84 4y agoHey there are still some of us small hobbyist youtubers out there who don't run a single ad or sponsor ever. We're just harder to find due to youtube's ever changing recommended algorithm. :D Also there's more content than just informational videos on youtube. Video games are a big chunk as well.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI threw a Lex Fridman video at it. Summary: "The transcript is a jumbled collection of unrelated phrases and sentences, with no clear message or insights." I'm sold.
- andai 4y agoI built something similar for my own usage, to get an overview of long lectures. I prefer bullet points to summaries, find it much easier to read (especially skim for useful info). I have it as two command line tools right now: one to get the transcript[0], and one to convert a long text file into a bullet point summary (two passes) [1]: The token math is approximate so it fails on foreign languages, but for English it works fine. (Use Tiktoken if you want it to be exact.) [0] https://gist.github.com/avelican/4a161089b7391415a092833e7aca6989 https://gist.github.com/avelican/4a161089b7391415a092833e7ac... [1] https://gist.github.com/avelican/11f429d0bb62891439f144bd7c0941a4 https://gist.github.com/avelican/11f429d0bb62891439f144bd7c0...
- jdthedisciple 4y agoLooking through the comments here is a list of similar tools people have written that do this: - https://www.summarize.tech/ https://www.summarize.tech/ - https://kagi.com/summarizer https://kagi.com/summarizer - https://youtubetranscript.com/ https://youtubetranscript.com/ - https://youtube-summarizer.ashellunts.repl.co/ https://youtube-summarizer.ashellunts.repl.co/ - https://github.com/fmeyer/tldw https://github.com/fmeyer/tldw
- phil9l 4y agoI made a similar one, https://summatim.app/ https://summatim.app/ , it's an extension that adds timestamp block near youtube videos, and allows you to jump to these sections. Maybe I'm doing something wrong, but it was deleted from producthunt, so I'm scared to post it here. :(
- numlock86 4y agoSeems like the summary is just random parts from the transcript thrown together randomly, at least for the five videos that I tested.
- rvba 4y agoWhen I made an icon to have a link to that website - the icon is face of some guy. The miniicon seems to be setup wrong?
- pknerd 4y agoUnlike past, Youtube inserts Ads anyways. I am not eligible for Ads program yet Youtube inserts Ads and I get nothing. At the end, it's the Google who emerges as a winner.
- infinitedata 4y ago*Any youtube video that has closed captions False advertising, it doesn’t work with just any one
- Decabytes 4y agoI’ve always wanted to talk to people who make these tools and whether they realize the harm they can cause. A lot of people complain about YouTube videos having lots of fluff, trying to meet certain length requirements, having sponsor spots. Of course they do. They are trying to make a living on something that is free so they can continue to make content. Everything that they do is an adaptation to the fact that people don’t want to pay for content at all. There will always be super fans who will donate on patreon, buy merch, subscribe to YouTube memberships, do super chats etc. But even larger channels have a hard time doing that without constant calls to action. This is why reacting has gotten so popular. It takes a long time to shoot, edit and upload even a well produced 5minute YouTube video. Linus tech tips talks about how much easier it is to do that type of content in his video explaining why they were thinking of making a react channel. By reacting you get a constant stream of videos you can put out everyday that please the algorithm, and only take 1 take to do. Other high value content like FreyaHolmer’s video on Splines, which is a high quality, hour long video, get hundreds of thousands of views, take over a year to make, but do very poorly in revenue, making valuable educational content on YouTube that is actually useful unsustainable withought all the other tactics mentioned above. This is partly YouTube’s fault as people expect it to be free and I don’t think that will ever change. Which is a shame because I know Google would pull the plug if it stoped being profitable and the watch times plummeted, and the creators left. But if we kill YouTube we will have noone to blame but ourselves. I think Substack has a better model for creators, and there is an expectation that creators will monetize their Substack once it gets larger. Casey Muratori talks about this, and says it’s why he puts his educational content there instead of on YouTube for free.
- BiglandIT 4y ago[flagged]