25 ms·
I definitely don't think the big schools like Harvard/Yale/etc. need any more money, but I will play devil's advocate here. > "he donated $300 million in such
by crazygringo 4y ago
I definitely don't think the big schools like Harvard/Yale/etc. need any more money, but I will play devil's advocate here.
> "he donated $300 million in such as a way as to do as close as possible to zero good with it."
Oh there are a lot worse ways to spend it with the best of intentions. The Turkana frozen-fish plant is a classic example, a charitable project where back in around 1975 around $150 million (in today's money) was spent on a frozen fish factory next to a lake... a lake that regularly disappears... and in a location without reliable electricity [1] [2]. It was utterly useless.
There's a shocking amount of charitable money that just winds up having utterly no impact whatsoever.
On the other hand, giving $300 million to Harvard is probably going to have a good chance of some long-term impact. It is ultimately funding education for smart people who are well-positioned to use that education productively, and for research and arts that are meant to benefit humanity. It's not just throwing it away. I absolutely agree there are many institutions with a much greater need for the money, but "zero good" is extreme exaggeration. People have done much, much, MUCH worse with donating money.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1986/04/05/how-not-to-aid-african-nomads/df2edbff-7294-46dd-abf1-fc3dc13b36ff/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1986/04/05/h...
[2] https://www.ibtimes.com/kenyas-turkana-learns-failed-fish-project-194573 https://www.ibtimes.com/kenyas-turkana-learns-failed-fish-pr...
- tempestn 4y agoI'd go one further. There are plenty of actively harmful donations one could make. As one example, most people would probably feel that way about roughly half of political donations.
- VanTheBrand 4y agoPolitical contributions are not donations and are not tax deductible.
- tempestn 4y agoThe OP didn't ask what was the least impactful tax deductible way to spend.
- pdpi 4y agoActively harmful donations at least have an impact (Classic example: Hitler had arguably the greatest impact of anybody in the twentieth century). This donation probably won’t do much of anything at all, which is notable in and of itself
- Kon-Peki 4y agoPlaying devil’s advocate is a great antidote to this article. I also agree that Harvard doesn’t need any more money, but… You notice something in that article, which is that Harvard is almost twice the size of the next largest school in that article’s list of richest schools per student. The undergraduate part of Harvard is extremely small and exclusive. Griffin gave the money to the graduate school of arts and sciences, which is actively building the capacity to serve more students. They’re building what is effectively a second campus on the Boston side of the river, with even more land than they have in Cambridge.
- 27153 4y agoNah the money he gave was unrestricted. They just decided to name the grad school after him. The money isn’t earmarked for anything in particular.
- JoshTko 4y agoA donation to Harvard only accelerates opportunity inequality. Harvard benefits only rich kids.
- odd_perfect_num 4y agoHarvard and it's peers are some of the very few academic institutions that have need blind admissions and generous need-based financial aid. For poor students, Harvard and its peers are pretty much the only free college options besides merit scholarships.
- jonifico 4y agoOnly 1.8% are students from poor families: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/college-mobility/harvard-university https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/college-mobilit...
- fancy_hammer 4y agoThat is 100% not what the link says.
- bagacrap 4y agoHey, 82% are not 1%ers! That distribution really is extremely heavily skewed, so I think the original comment is correct, I can't see how it's improving equality. If 1.8% were poor and Harvard helped them become rich adults, probably 65% were rich and Harvard helped them stay rich as adults.
- wahnfrieden 4y agothey have plenty of money given tiny, static class sizes, and that population you're referring to is already a small one of a small overall student body.
- celestialcheese 4y ago20% of Harvard students pay nothing. [1] 55% receive needs based scholarships, with families making less than 150k per year paying less than 15k per year. Sure there are a lot of rich kids and legacies. But to say it only benefits the wealthy is just wrong. 1 - https://college.harvard.edu/guides/financial-aid-fact-sheet https://college.harvard.edu/guides/financial-aid-fact-sheet
- jimbokun 4y agoHarvard produced many of the people that built a society with staggering and increasing levels of income inequality. Consultants, hedge fund managers, architects of super addictive social media platforms, politicians who write laws favoring corporations over workers, etc. etc.
- voz_ 4y agoWhat is your point?
- RoyGBivCap 4y agoIt's an oligarch's school for oligarchs? I can't speak for him, but that's my guess.
- layman51 4y agoProbably he means that by giving money to an “elite” school, it just makes it more likely that it will end up hurting the “non-elites”. I don’t necessarily agree with that point by the way because there are students who will have their cost of attendance potentially offset by this donation.
- charcircuit 4y agoIncome inequality doesn't hurt the nonelite.
- nonethewiser 4y agoBut what? What would be lost without the 300 million? If you can’t be specific then I think it’s to the authors point. I mean, just consider that he spent 300 million and the impact isn’t obvious. At least in your fish example they used it for the intended purpose for some period of time and there is still some low utilization for dried fish. It’s also half of 300 million so it seems they did more with less despite it being a failure. Regardless, effective altruism is bullshit. They can donate the money however they want. They wouldn’t be a better person or even more charitable if they were an “effective altruist.”
- 27153 4y agoYou don’t think doing more good with the same resources is a good thing? Is it not better to save two lives than one life, all else equal?
- scythe 4y agoConsidering the infrastructure deficiencies, I think a canning facility would have been better.
- boie0025 4y agoThis is a fascinating question. It's incredibly rhetorical, and I've sat here pondering it for a bit. It's very easy to reply to this question with "well I suppose it depends." And then tack on "What do we consider 'doing good/more good'? What is the nature/species/alignment of the lives being saved, and how are are they equal? Who decides which two lives are better to save than the one, if it's somehow decided that one is better than two? Does the two lives vs one life involve picking between the same two lives, or is it an entirely different set of lives?" and a whole mountain of other questions. It's like asking a magical wish granter to "save two lives" and it does something predictably spiteful like saving two single celled organisms and causing a kitten to die. Thanks for giving me that to chew on.
- bagacrap 4y agoYes good point. Would be better to save just one life if the two in question are Hitler and Stalin.
- atyppo 4y agoI'm sure it will have some impact, but a school that refuses to increase student body size at the expense of plenty of people trying to get in is disgusting to put it lightly. Not to mention their promulgation of a legacy system, which comprises nearly 30% of undergrads.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> It is ultimately funding education for smart people who are well-positioned to use that education productively, and for research and arts that are meant to benefit humanity. It's not just throwing it away. You have to account for it as the marginal dollar, not the average dollar. If Harvard had less money, and they're competent, they would cut the least effective programs. But because their budget is so large, they've already fully funded everything in their wheelhouse with high utility and the least effective programs would be mostly waste and vanity. (And if they're not competent then you obviously don't want to be giving them more money either.)
- hkt 4y agoI'm not generally in favour of elite universities so don't deeply disagree with the sentiment, but is there actually a way to justify more money under the pattern you established in your comment? I'm guessing your intention was to suggest that in the presence of a large surplus (Harvard's massive endowment etc) it is reasonable to assume this goes unspent because it can't be turned into worthwhile education or research. Is that about the sum of the argument? Meanwhile, somewhere with high impact research but nearly zero in reserves would presumably be more deserving?
- koromak 4y agoGod I just don't buy the "these people will go on to benefit humanity" argument anymore. We don't need more tech companies. We don't need more hedge funds. We don't need to feed our genuinely brightest minds into the wealth consolidation machine. Occasioanlly one of these people will find some one-off bit of brilliance that lifts an entire class of people out of poverty, but that ticket has an expiration date tied to the 19th century. Eventually those free spaces will run out. They're already starting to in the western world.
- blackshaw 4y ago> that ticket has an expiration date tied to the 19th century. Eventually those free spaces will run out. They're already starting to in the western world I'm sorry but I genuinely don't understand what you're saying here. What will expire? Which "free spaces" are running out where?
- lordnacho 4y agoThink he means low hanging fruit?
- monkeydreams 4y ago> Which "free spaces" are running out where? Not OP but the college entrance scandal is a great example. With the super wealthy taking up all the philanthropic entrance positions the "just" wealthy set had to resort to cheating and rorts to ease little Johnny Blueblood's way into society. There is only so much room at the top.
- coldtea 4y agoHuge impact technologies like the steam engine, the factory line, electricity, and so on, that are not just incremental steps, things nobody asked for with minimal utility ("smart fridge") or glorified stupidification engines (the social web).
- adrianN 4y agoSteam engines existed in ancient greece. It took a couple of incremental steps until they were good enough to kickstart the industrial revolution.
- eru 4y agoEh, education is mostly bad for society. In the sense, that most of education is about signalling, and funneling more money into education just fuels the arms race. See Bryan Caplan's Case against Education for more details. (The part of education that's actually about learning has mostly become cheaper than ever, thanks to the power of the Internet. But unless you got a piece of paper from a university, hiring managers seldom care. (Especially outside of tech.)) So donating money to further educational institutions is bad for society. It has a negative impact.
- thejman5200 4y agoI have a theory that every internet comment that starts with Eh is always wrong. So far I haven't been let down. I don't understand how you could possibly say education has negative impact on society. Top universities can and do hire faculty for the purpose of research alongside teaching. Top minds performing research obviously benefits everyone as they can make new discoveries and innovations. That has the side effect of a worse undergrad education as researchers view teaching as a side gig but ultimately necessary to fund the university and it's research ventures
- jliptzin 4y agoI think he’s talking about the institutional capture and monopolization of higher education…essentially coming away with the same skills for free from YouTube but they’re worth nothing in the market because you didn’t pay $50k/year to the higher ed cartel.
- never_inline 4y ago> coming away with the same skills for free from YouTube How can I become high energy physicist on YouTube ?
- eru 4y agoThink more along the lines of the degrees that companies like McKinsey require. They usually just say 'any degree is fine'.
- 3327 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]