12 ms·
Ageing studies in five animals suggests how to reverse decline
- marstall 4y agoI follow the longevity space a bit and I believe the implication of nucleosomes in the aging process is a new idea? Wonder why nucleosomes become less frequent as we age ... I know cancer mitigation can sometimes be the reason for these kinds of dimunitions.
- BulgarianIdiot 4y agoAll this research will be wasted only to learn we age and die as it's the best tradeoff for our performance prior to death. That is, unless we're content being a collection of dysfunctional, amorphous tumors and call this a "life", or be passive and unmoving, and do and achieve nothing, but do it over centuries.
- justinclift 4y agoSo, you're saying don't solve any of these problems because it's all too hard?
- BulgarianIdiot 4y agoNo, I didn't say that. I said "you're not trying to solve a problem, you're trying introduce problems into a working solution". I see I got downvoted up there, as if I'll steal your life by openly sharing a valid opinion. Humans are such a sorry species sometimes.
- RivieraKid 4y agoI don't consider it a working solution. To me, it's a bug.
- ChatGTP 4y agoI guess that’s just an opinion? I’ve spent time with friends and relatives who were 80+, many of whom told me them were tired of life and ready for “something new”, they had good lives but had enough. Sure if they had younger bodies they might feel differently but most were quite able bodied and just felt it was time. Perhaps you should be careful what you wish for ?
- RivieraKid 4y ago> they had good lives but had enough Yes, many people don't enjoy life, especially when their health deteriorates. I'm saying that to me, the fact that your health gradually gets worse until you die is a bug. > Perhaps you should be careful what you wish for ? Nah, I don't think so.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoThe major religions all try to answer the question of death. Singularitarianism answers it by pointing to longevity research and saying death won't happen, that death is a bug (despite being omnipresent in biological nature and in accordance with entropy), and that anyone who doesn't adhere to this belief is an evil deathist.
- jiminymcmoogley 4y agoWere they as able bodied as they were aged 20-25 though? If 80 years is the cutoff at which we get bored with staying alive, would you rather spend those 80 years in a "biologically" 20-year-old body then make the conscious choice for "something new" or gradually deteriorate for about half of those 80 years then die without the choice not to?
- justinclift 4y agoWhat's the "working solution" you're talking about?
- BulgarianIdiot 4y agoChildren. And death. You can't have the former without the latter indefinitely. And you need the former for progress to happen. Old people aren't merely a less healthy version of young people. They're also people who have settled mentally and now they DEPEND on the environment staying the way they're familiar with it. They will try their best to prevent change. This means children can't thrive & take the next step. Notice I've not mentioned yet also that we can't have infinite people on that planet. But we can't, anyway.
- justinclift 4y agoUgh. That's not really a solution, and you're generalising way too much about old people being stuck in their ways. While some definitely are, they're not all like that. Condemning everyone to death, even the not-stuck-in-the-mud old people sounds pretty abhorrent, or maybe "tragic" might be the better word. > Notice I've not mentioned yet also that we can't have infinite people on that planet. Well, fortunately there's more than a single planet in this universe. How feasible it becomes to live on planets-other-than-this-one over time is clearly not something we can say with any certainty at the moment though. Hopefully that works out to be possible (in some good way), otherwise we're stuck with what you're suggesting. Which would suck. :(
- BulgarianIdiot 4y agoThis reads kinda like "these facts are getting in the way of blind hope." Be extremely suspect of patterns of the kind "we'll do X now, which will work when we invent Y far in the future". Say, electric cars can use clean energy now, so they'll be clean when we move to mostly clean energy in the future. OK, but today they indirectly run on oil, gas & coal. Or "we'll work on immortality now, which will be fine when we spread over the galaxy in the future". These things need to co-happen at the same time, instead of dooming us all to a fruitless endeavor only to then realize the second critical part of the equation may never happen the way we thought it would. Did you know your neurons can't go through mitosis? You can't regenerate a damaged brain. And it does get damaged in time, nothing can fix that. When you use something you wear it down, it deals with harsh environment that the organism tries to prevent as much as possible, but something's gotta give eventually. When I said people settle mentally I didn't mean it CULTURALLY. I meant it BIOLOGICALLY. In ignorance one can claim that dead neurons may just get better and maybe we'll find ways to make them regenerate, but that's because they're clueless, so every implausible scenario seems equally likely to them as what's plausible. In theory, a "life" may be possible to factor so it's infinitely flexible in infinite time. Whatever that life is, it won't be human at all. It won't be you, or anyone your know. We're built the way we're built and you can't change this without losing yourself in the process. We have an 80 year old president in the US, Trump was also old, Putin is old, Xi is old, everyone is going incredibly old up there among the ruling elite, and may they be blessed with great health and all, but even when healthy, their decisions are firmly planted into the 20th century, you can't help that. And this matters. It's holding us back and in some cases threatening world peace and safety. And by the way! The reason our biology makes us SETTLE DOWN in our concepts, knowledge, behavior, is because the alternative IS EVEN WORSE, and it is degradation, mental illness, loss of memory and so on. This is not about some problem with our health. It's a problem of entropy and it includes also machine models, not just human brain: https://www.nannyml.com/blog/91-of-ml-perfomance-degrade-in-time https://www.nannyml.com/blog/91-of-ml-perfomance-degrade-in-... We're all doomed to "either die a hero, or live long enough to see ourselves become the villain". I prefer to die a hero, and let other heroes grow in my place. How about you?
- yellow_postit 4y agoWhy would this be unique to this point in time versus others say, pre antibiotics? To assume we’ve reached the upper limit of longevity and medicine is a bold claim.
- throway_009988 4y agoUnlikely. Life is optimized for species evolution/survival. From a logical perspective, individuals should be optimized for transmitting beneficial traits to the next generation and, after this, it's better if they don't stick around to fight for resources - nature Planned Obsolescence.
- jvanderbot 4y agoNot always so, see "Grandmother effect". It's highly beneficial to keep around older members that can 1) work for their offspring or 2) provide important guidance and knowledge transfer.
- throway_009988 4y agoThat could be the partial exception that proves the rule (partial because there seems to be no "great(N+1) grandmother effect" as great grandmothers would start to compete with grandmothers, with low to none returns to human species). Are there other examples, besides high level primates? Moreover, that precise example hints that it shouldn't be so difficult to tweak the human substrate to improve the lifespan since Nature was able to do it in such a short time.
- tjpnz 4y agoThe goal is to prevent and possibly reverse aging so you would remain healthy. What you do with those extra years is your business.
- amackera 4y agoWell, if that's what the research shows than the effort wasn't "wasted". Don't confuse your opinions with facts.
- sholladay 4y agoHuman lifespan and healthspan have increased notably in recent centuries. I also expect there to be tradeoffs, as there so often are in life. Perhaps, though, we will be able to trade those costs for other costs that we prefer or can more easily afford.
- RivieraKid 4y agoWhat's the current status of longevity research? Do we know what causes aging and what allows some animals to love much longer than orders?
- rybosworld 4y agoI think the simplest answer is that aging is an accumulation of dna errors and your body reaches a point where it doesn't know what the "correct" dna was. Some species have adapted better error correction.
- fbn79 4y agoSo if we backup our DNA at 20, we can use CRISPR at 50 to restore it and return young?
- thrwwy5685865 4y agoThis is very hard to do. How do you get CRISPR to every cell in the body without incidentally killing you?
- p1esk 4y agoIronic that you're worried about doing something that can "incidentally" kill you - to prevent something that will definitely kill you.
- mr_toad 4y agoDepends on how old you are. If you’re 50 and contemplating a procedure that could make you 20 but might kill you, you’d probably defer. Maybe when you’re 70 or 90 you might see things differently.
- p1esk 4y agoIf I'm 50 I would probably wait 10-20 years until the procedure becomes more reliable, but if I'm 70 I'd probably go for it even with 50/50 chance.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoWe're "solving" longevity right as the climate crisis gets really bad and we really start feeling the crunch of nonrenewable resources. Not keen on living until I'm 200 if the best I can get past 2050 is preindustrial squalor.
- fallingknife 4y agoAlso solving aging leads to a necessary choice. Mass famine and civilization collapse, or draconian population control. That will get messy fast, and I can see us choosing the former because of people deluding themselves into thinking such a choice need not be made at all.
- mholm 4y ago> we really start feeling the crunch of nonrenewable resources This really just feels Malthusian. Many of the elements that are currently 'scarce' are not actually scarce, just not found in extremely high concentrations elsewhere. There's essentially a maximum price that these resources will reach (often not much higher than they currently are), before other methods/locations of extraction become viable. To suggest we'll revert to preindustrial squalor is absurd.
- palata 4y ago> before other methods/locations of extraction become viable. That was an argument decades ago, but today, a) if we keep extracting more and more, then climate change will be worse and worse (all ready not looking good) and b) it seems like we are around the production peak of oil (of all kinds), while conventional peak oil was around 2008. So yeah, energy is going down, because we don't have viable alternative to fossil fuels. What is unfortunate is that the end of fossil fuels is coming too slowly, so we still have plenty to mess up the climate. And then we won't have it anymore to face the consequences.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoNick Bostrom has his analogy about technologies being like lottery balls. Most of the time we draw "white" balls and technology has almost no downsides, sometimes we draw a "gray" ball and there are pros and cons. We've never drawn a "black" ball technology out of reality's bag of tricks because we wouldn't be here discussing it if we had, although he suggests things like AI or homebrewed viruses could be a black ball. Drawing ball after ball has kept humanity progressing. Extend his analogy a little further. What if there are no more white balls to draw? What if we are "impeded" from drawing them by the fact that there are now more gray and black balls to draw instead of white? Or, since we have to reach further into this lottery jar, what if we don't reach them in time? Malthus rested his conclusion on the assumption that we would never hack agriculture the way we have (nitrogen, phosphorus, etc). You rest your conclusion on the assumption that we will always successfully draw a new trick out of the hat, like find ways to recover all the rare earth metals from phones for which we have no current mechanism for economic recycling. You rest your worldview on the idea that our potential is limitless, that humanity's progress is inevitable, a god-given right if you will. I rest my worldview on the idea that nothing is guaranteed, that complexity begets fragility and diminishing returns, and that entropy will always, always, have the last laugh.
- aantix 4y ago> inhibiting insulin signalling can delay ageing and extend lifespan in many animals Does this mean that the newer diet medications like Semaglutide could be accelerating aging since they increase the secretion of insulin from the beta cells?
- tempsy 4y agoYeah interesting question, though losing weight via caloric restriction is probably still a big positive effect
- rybosworld 4y agoIt's also associated with thyroid tumors so I'd consider it a life shortener for that alone.
- ericb 4y agoThat so far hasn't been documented in humans. Also, being overweight is a life shortener itself, so the question is just which is riskier on-balance.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoFuck me, I hadn't heard about these. Those are some scary side effects.
- 6177c40f 4y agoUnclear, but some really preliminary research suggests it might actually neuroprotective [1] and cardioprotective [2]. A lot more research needs to be done though, it seems. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36191807/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36191807/ [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36515811/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36515811/
- ChatGTP 4y agoHaven’t we solved aging by having children ?
- missingdays 4y agoNo?
- palata 4y agoSeems like you missed the point :-)
- AlecSchueler 4y agoIt depends on if you have a more communal or individualistic outlook. We are always roughly the same age, but the individuals in the group have to age and die.
- mdp2021 4y agoNo, I don't think that «having children» could inhibit the development of prostatitis or wrinkles.
- rossdavidh 4y ago"Ageing seems to affect cellular processes in the same way across five very different kinds of life — humans, fruit flies, rats, mice and worms — according to a study published in Nature on 12 April. The findings could help to explain what drives ageing and offer suggestions for how to reverse it..." Well, given that ageing seems to affect cellular process across five very different kinds of life, the most obvious conclusion is that defeating the process has some unavoidable, bad tradeoffs. I mean, I'm 55 years old and not looking forward to dying, but let's be realistic here: we're not going to "reverse" ageing. Evolution has had billions of years to do it, and for whatever reason the conclusion is that either it's not possible, or the cost is not worth it. I don't think we are smarter than evolution, in this regard.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoIsn't the entire field of medical science just a list of things we've managed to do for the body that evolution failed to manage over the course of billennia?
- Retric 4y agoNo, the majority of health issues are personal. Evolution optimizes species not individuals, so while some kids need glasses most kids don’t. Evolution’s response to massive physical trauma can be things like wariness of heights rather than a body that can fall arbitrarily distances.
- dheera 4y agoIt weren't for medical science I'd be dead multiple times over by now due to causes that someone with better genes would have survived. > Evolution’s response to massive physical trauma can be things like wariness of heights rather than a body that can fall arbitrarily distances. It can be either or both. Cats tend to survive falls very well, as do insects, but for different reasons.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoI don't really get the distinction. I do get your point but x% of a species needing glasses is a species level error. And our entire species was susceptible to things like smallpox before we had vaccines for that stuff.
- neets 4y agoDeath is a feature not a bug
- melling 4y agoYes, we should always leave death as an option. Conversation over.
- shadowfoxx 4y agoWell, even if we solve Biological decay, that doesn't mean we are impervious to damage.
- feoren 4y ago"Death should be an option therefore I demand that you die" Huh? Who said anything about prohibiting death? Nobody is going to demand that you take anti-aging therapies if you don't want them. Who are you to tell everyone else that they're not allowed to live?
- melling 4y ago"Death should be an option therefore I demand that you die" No one said that. People are arguing against immortality and in favor of death. People who believe that can still choose death
- feoren 4y ago> Death is a feature not a bug > Yes, we should always leave death as an option. Conversation over. Weird to say "no one said that" in the comment threat that literally opened with that line. "Death is a feature not a bug" means "we should make sure people continue to die." Then you seem to agree (that "yes" is rather out of place if you don't), but I admit to not being 100% clear on what you mean. Either way, it's absolutely not true that "no one" is demanding that I die of old age for the greater good. The originator of this comment thread is absolutely saying that, and he's not the only one.
- 4y ago
- theGnuMe 4y agoInteresting because pol II drives RNA transcription so not involved in replicating the DNA itself. Does pol II have a direct negative effect on DNA then or is it indirect or both?
- robbywashere_ 4y agoMeanwhile... the life expectancy in the United States is on the decline.
- epups 4y agoTrue, but to be fair it would be even lower if it wasn't for scientific research like this
- vorpalhex 4y ago> The declines in life expectancy since 2019 are largely driven by the pandemic. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/nchs_press_releases/2022/20220831.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/nchs_press_releases/2022/...
- Jochim 4y agoI don't think the world would be a better off if the Bezos' and Gates' were to live forever. Death provides an opportunity for change. Often in the form of upheaval to political structures but more frequently in opening up social opportunities. Removing death from the equation introduces either: stagnation, if it is made available to everyone; or a new kind of inequality that I can't comprehend being accepted.
- at_a_remove 4y agoOr, conversely, having to plan long-term because you'll be around for it. Imagine no statute of limitations on chucking barrels of toxic waste down a well. Humans do okay with certain rates of change, but right now, the more nightmarish business is a problem for your great grandkids.
- palata 4y ago> Imagine no statute of limitations on chucking barrels of toxic waste down a well. I think that's an unfortunate example: burning fossil fuels is a much bigger problem, and it is not even long-term (most of us will be around for the consequences). Still we do it virtually without planning at all.
- m_fayer 4y agoI grant all of your points. But I think there would be some very clear upsides as well, assuming that longevity is available to more than just a few billionaires. Years spent observing a field or topic with a well-trained eye is incredibly valuable. But by the time you're an expert, you typically have at best 3 decades and often much less to practice before serious decline kicks in. It would be a very different world where the number of experts and veterans rose by an order of magnitude. Also, as I've come to see with my own advancing years, humans are very good at forgetting history and its lessons. The best way to maintain historical awareness is to simply have people around who lived through it. The current historical moment is an illustration of this - the world is sliding toward large-scale war just as the last of those who saw ww2 with their own eyes are leaving the scene. I don't think that's a coincidence.
- 4y ago
- gautamdivgi 4y agoYikes - hopefully one of the mutant insects doesn’t escape. Having an insect live 20% longer as a species could significantly increase their dominance.
- mdp2021 4y agoIncidentally, while this is really interesting, what would be really useful is repairing, not reducing the pace of damage. I am not sure why the title is written as «reverse decline»: I have not read that in the article. (Did I miss something?)
- feoren 4y agoEvery single time the possibility of curing aging comes up, we get those misanthropes who demand loudly that It's Very Important That You Must Die, for The Greater Good, or something. And every time I say the same thing: say the situation were reversed: everyone is living forever, and it starts (arguably) causing those problems you have in mind. Your solution to those problems is to kill everyone over a certain age!? https://nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon https://nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon
- Upvoter33 4y agoIf you look around, you can pretty readily see what people in power do: consolidate power, consolidate wealth. I mean, seriously, look at the U.S.: rich country, but so many struggling in the middle or below. Even though we live an age of information, we are easily controlled by those who have the money and influence. Now, imagine them living forever. You could almost guarantee how crummy the world would become, with an elite few running everything. On top of that, if you believe that adding new people is important, eventually you run out of room/resources/etc. So, for these reasons, death as part of our life cycle is a good thing. Fortunately, we didn't have to invent it.
- elevatortrim 4y agoThen let's solve those problems as well? I do not think death is going away any time soon, we are not even able to extend lifetimes by a meaningful amount yet. For now, we can more meaningfully discuss a world where poeple are living for 150 years. Running out of resources is not necessarily an eventuality. Arguably, it would be possible to live sustainably but regardless of people dying or not, we are not doing that anyway. That's a separate discussion. Running out of room is a serious concern. I do not have a good answer to that.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoThere's unlimited space and resources available in space. Even on the Earth, we could sustainably support many more people with some very modest adjustments to the way we live. (Eating more vegetables, not being assholes about nuclear power, etc)
- kieranmaine 4y agoWhilst a lot of comments focus on death, I think it's important to also think about the benefits of treating the diseases of aging, such a cognitive decline. I'm sure most people have seen their parents or grand-parents decline cognitively. This is sad for the individual, the family and also effects society by draining resources. Any research that can mitigate this is worthwhile in my opinion.
- ALittleLight 4y agoThere's also economics to consider. In the US spending on social security and healthcare for the elderly are two of the largest spending categories. Imagine reversing aging and cutting both of those out of the budget. Not only would we bring back a ton of experienced workers but we would also cut federal spending by ~30%.
- nirav72 4y agoWhat's the point of living a longer life if there aren't enough working age people to pay into a safety net for the elderly? - The U.S has largely avoided that problem due to maintaining the middle part of the population age pyramid. But Europe and Japan aren't going to do well as their population ages and there aren't enough young workers to pay into it.
- dumpHero2 4y agoLiving longer doesn't just extend the tail end of life, it extends the retirement age as well. Humans spend 20 years learning & work for 40. Imagine if we could work for 80 instead!!
- JamesBarney 4y agoNot to mention the productivity gains of having people who have the experience of workers in their 40's with the energy levels of people in their 30's would be a big productivity boon.
- bobolino123 4y agoYou mean work for 45-50 years :( they will likely move the retirement age from 67 to 70 in europoor. Some people start working fulltime at like 15-16.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoHopefully, if you live longer you'll be able to work longer as well... but then again, age discrimination is a thing.
- jiminymcmoogley 4y agoI feel like a lot of the underlying biases behind ageism come from its association with age related health issues though. The only "justifications" for ageism that'd be left once it becomes sensible to assume the average 95 year old has the same cognitive ability as the average 30 year old would be related to expectations of upcoming parental leave and maybe the idea that for two candidates with the same CV, the younger one has accomplished as much in a shorter timeframe and is therefore a better bet. I don't know if there's a solution to these two issues but I doubt ageism would have more of an impact on a person's employability after a hypothetical cure for aging than before. Not to mention the fact that you can always selectively disclose info to potential employers to conceal your age, to some extent.
- JPLeRouzic 4y ago> "When the team boosted the expression of histones in the cells, Pol II moved at a slower pace." Does this mean that this statement would not be true for cells that reproduce very slowly (fat, skeleton) or not at all (lens cells, neurons)?
- yodsanklai 4y agoIn the meantime, we're still waiting for a cure to baldness.
- crims0n 4y agoThe cure to baldness is hit the gym and pack on 20lbs of muscle, shave your head, and stop caring.
- nosianu 4y agoHmm... wes, but I, not yet bald but so little hair on top that I shave it cut it (myself, using an electrical haircutter) very short, have noticed one big disadvantage. I'm satisfied with my looks, but the heat (sun rays) and cold impact from the environment were significantly reduced with hair. I still notice the difference when I let my remaining hair grow longer during winter, and then cut it short again. This winter I even had to wear something on my head in my apartment after cutting the hair, because I kept it pretty cool and just wore a bit thicker clothes. Except, my head. It's a problem with sun and with cold. I now understand why people would ear it long in the past, before hats. It's such a great insulator!
- crims0n 4y agoI understand the struggle, I was never a hat person until I went bald - now that hats are necessary in the winter I have learned to enjoy them. I still opt for sunscreen in the summer though.
- bsder 4y agoFind a bucket hat that suits your style and wear it constantly--including indoors. Especially if you are tall, the hat will prevent you from walking into low-hanging obstacles and winding up with scars on your head.
- asciimov 4y agoHat's are wonderful, and it's quite criminal that they went out of fashion with Kennedy. That said, don't run off and by just any old fedora or bucket hat. Get something cool, that works for your head and body shape. Pick something that says you. Hats, along with socks and watches, are the only accessories that men can really show personality with in this day and age. It's a real same that so much of men's fashion is so devoid of personality.
- JPLeRouzic 4y agoDo they simply tell that if we slow the cell cycle (histones over-expression), then cells will age slowly?
- JPLeRouzic 4y agoSirtuins are histone deacetylases, so by the logic of this article, they should increase aging?
- examplary_cable 4y agoI wonder what immortality would do to fertility and demographics ... people dying often "gives" a place so someone new can fill the old place. But if everybody is immortal then the number of people on earth would just keep adding up, even with the demographic stagnation in developed countries.