13 ms·
He who submits a resume has already lost
- wildpeaks 4y agoIn short, having someone on the inside recommend you is better. Thanks, Captain Obvious.
- quickthrower2 4y agoGood point and this is some of the reason I am getting a bit more serious about open source coding and writing on a blog. Although friends and coworkers are good they tend to work in the kinda places you already worked, so it is harder to make a quantum leap that way.
- eashish93 4y agosounds like `He who remains`
- andrewstuart 4y agoOverly generalized rant. Sure some jobs happen outside the resume submission system, but most of the employment market works via resume submission. There’s no value in reading this post.
- elihu 4y agoThinking back on my life, I can't remember a single example where I ever got a job just by submitting a resume. Either I already knew someone in the organization or otherwise had a relationship with it to begin with (e.g. I got a summer grounds job at a University because I was already a student there), or I met someone at an event who was looking for people to hire.
- carabiner 4y agoI've gotten all of my offers from cold applications. Didn't know anyone, just submitted an app through the ATS and got an email that led to an interview then to an offer
- IshKebab 4y agoExcept my most recent job where I used a recruiter, I've only got jobs by submitting a CV. One was a huge company with an official application process (Dyson) and the other two were startups via email. You definitely have higher odds with a more nepotistic route, but I think he's still right - most jobs go to applicants that apply using the standard process.
- derbOac 4y agoMy experience is sort of in-between on both sides. That is, there's some submission process people go through, but connections of some sort definitely draw attention to some applicants more than others. Sometimes someone is brought in with no obvious connections, but sometimes someone is basically brought in sidestepping the open process too. Usually it's a bit of both, leaning towards connections of some kind. Sometimes the interviewers or interviewees aren't aware of the connection, although usually one of them is.
- 9530jh9054ven 4y agoAnd I've only ever gotten jobs through resumes. I have no family, friends, or acquaintances. Most people wouldn't willingly be in my presence were it not for the fact that I can occasionally be useful to them. And I rarely leave my home for anything other then absolute necessities to eat and maintain personal hygiene. I assume you at least have some level of charisma that would make others think of you positively at combined with skill. As well as some willingness to go to events as you say. You and I think though are somewhat exceptional in that regard; I assume most people would have gotten their jobs with a bit of a mix of the two in varying ratios.
- ryandrake 4y agoBut how does that even work? Even if you know someone at the company, at some point you have to apply online, to get into the real HR pipeline. I occasionally have people I used to work with ask me for help getting a job. I usually encourage them and give them some interview pointers, but ultimately I have to say “Here is the link to the posting, go apply and good luck!” I am just employee number 52214. I don’t have an HR button I can push that says “fast track this swell guy!”
- tukantje 4y agoMost companies have a referral system. You also know the structure inside: meaning you can say hi to a hiring manager you may or may not know, and say “check this guy out - I vouch for him”
- elihu 4y agoMy most recent job was with Intel. I got invited to some kind of recruiting event, I'm not sure how. One of my friends was trying to get me to join, so maybe he sent them my email address? Or maybe they spotted me on LinkedIn? I have no idea. Anyways, I ended up talking to one of their senior engineers on the project they were hiring for. I can't remember if it came out then or later that that senior engineer was a college friend of a guy that founded a startup I had previously worked for. Not sure if that made any difference or not, but I had relevant experience in the area they were hiring for, so they brought me in for an interview. (Which turned out to be an all-day ordeal, but I passed.) The startup I had worked at before, I was hired because I went to a local un-conference, Portland BarCamp. I ran into someone I know from the Personal Telco Project, which started back in the early days of 802.11 wireless networking and was trying to promote free access points around town. Anyways, he knew someone else there that was hiring for a startup, so he introduced me and we talked and I went in for an interview and got the job. In either case, it's not like friends are directly getting me jobs (as far as I know), it's more that my network of acquaintances aligned in a favorable way and I was in the right place at the right time.
- saganus 4y agoWhat is an un-conference? Never heard that term before.
- programmer_dude 4y agoAs a counterpoint, every single job I've ever had I've got by submitting a resume. I have worked for six companies at this point.
- jwestbury 4y agoI've gotten my last two offers -- as a senior engineer at Dropbox and as an engineer at a top-end quantitative trading firm -- from cold resume submission without any networking. I also got interviews in this last round from both Jane Street and Hudson River Trading based purely on a cold resume submission. Admittedly, my resume is excellent, but jobs can absolutely happen from just sending in an application and a resume. Even really good, high-paying jobs.
- antonvs 4y agoAside from which, the post is just very misguided. The author seems to believe that writing a resume involves “committing a significant amount of time doing unpaid labor for a company to manage the company’s risk and hiring costs.” You could say the same thing about an interview. It just makes no sense. The post also claims that a hypothetical “golden curriculum vitae” literally created by angels would not “increase your chances of getting hired at all.” This seems completely oblivious to the actual role resumes play in the hiring process. There’s no question that a good resume can make an applicant stand out, and predispose interviewers to favor a candidate. The reason the author gives for his strange belief is: > The employer is very, very clear in terms of everything they do that they don’t trust your resume even a little and give it exactly zero weight - else they wouldn’t waste manager time interviewing you to get you to rehash it. But I’ve never been in an interview, on either side, which involved a “rehash” of the resume. Resumes and interviews serve different, complementary purposes.
- jacobqe 4y ago> That leaves a field of 40 more-or-less qualified people who have at this point all committed a significant amount of time doing unpaid labor for a company to manage the company’s risk and hiring costs. Ahh yes, the "significant amount of time doing unpaid labor" of sending my resume via email, which took me all of 5 minutes.
- Out_of_Characte 4y agoLets say you're someone who has changed careers alot, it means finding and applying is your full-time job for months on end. Despite people who have changed careers, succesfully, are often the best kind of people you'd want to hire.
- totetsu 4y agoI wonder if there is some atonement ritual that those of us who have strayed from the career path can go through to be accepted back,.. like bathing in the Living Waters beneath an amazon data center..
- namdnay 4y ago> significant amount of time doing unpaid labor for a company That’s such a strange way to look at it… if a company advertises, are they doing “unpaid labour to help me manage my purchasing”?
- iopq 4y agoMy dad's friend emailed over 400 companies looking for a job. The response rate is atrocious
- jensneuse 4y agoI keep giving this advice on how to significantly increase your chances of getting to the interview stage. Most candidates really only submit a resume. The chances of getting to the interview stage with this approach are almost zero. Because everyone does this, you can easily stand out. Simply answer the following 2 questions briefly in plain English. 1. Why do you want to take this role? 2. Why are you a good fit for this role? Example: 1. I've read through your website and documentation and are truly inspired by your vision. Especially that you're working and X thing really got my attention as I know that Y and Z are super important for the customer segment you're working on. 2. I have previous experience in this field and wrote an open source library to solve some of the issues you might be facing (link). Simply out, show interest and explain why you're a good fit. I've had too many candidates who never checked out our landing page (https://wundergraph.com https://wundergraph.com). We're doing a lot of innovative stuff in the API segment. If you apply for a job with us and you don't have an opinion whether you like what we do or not, it's really hard to gauge interest. The question I'm asking myself is. Why should I read your CV when you didn't bother skimming through my landing page, docs, or open source repository. What's the purpose of sending a CV when I have to do all the hard work?
- carabiner 4y agoWhat evidence do you present, besides your own company, that any of that works at increasing one's chances?
- mihaaly 4y ago> 1. Why do you want to take this role? > 2. Why are you a good fit for this role? These are the two most useless things to ask from yourself. You know almost nothing reliable about the role - except when have real insights from earlier, but that is the priority line, not in scope here with open competition of unknown persons - at the stage of interviewing apart from what is put into pompous public descriptions of the company and the role designed to amaze (basicly self praise, overstatements, no negatives, sometimes misdirections). Only broad scopes yet. Also you will only have chance knowing if you are fit after some discussion not before even the first contact! Come on! And that is only a chance knowing some, you will only know the culture, the procedures, the infrastructure, the mentality, the professionalism, basicly everything important about the organization affecting your fit after the first couple of months working there. Then you could determine if you are fit or not! Not at the submission, please! Be honest to yourself and to your future colleague! Good employers know this, they experience it from the other side (testing an employee fit takes time in action, and several times they fail predicting it). Also people can and have to form themselves into the role, no one born fit. Pretending to know the answers already when there could be none yet either shows a will to bullshit or being clueless. None of which are desirable (in most cases, bullshiting is useful for some organizations, of course). What are the honest and reliable answers here? (in generic case, not for those through backdoors) 1. I need to work for money pretty soon and you just have this open role which I think I could fulfill some way. 2. No chance knowing that at this stage however on the surface and based on both of our public history and things we project about orselves the chances are good. No way standing out by pretending along such vague or obvious questions, that is basically the generic approach at this elimination stage what everyone is doing. I straight up refuse writing childish essays called cover letter too, ranting about how good fit I am and how thrilled I am applying to this specific role and specific organization happened to have open position when I happened to look for jobs, what a great coincidence and life purpose! I send either nothing, empty page (when the submission system tries to enforce it), or contextual facts about the application. Role relevant facts are already in the CV/Resume. We could talk about intentions and fit in person, not through robotic HR elimnators. If this is no good for the employer then we are definitely no fit.
- keskival 4y agoIf you hire one out of 50 applicants, there is an implication that you're at least trying to hire the best 2%, and that there is an employer's market. That's of course incorrect if every applicant on average makes 100 job applications. That means you're lucky if you get one of those 50 before some other company makes them a better offer, which is why you have to keep a couple of choices open until the papers are signed. That means there are two open jobs for every applicant (with some fair assumptions).
- tjpnz 4y agoYes having someone vouch for you means a lot less BS - that's obvious. But you're still going to have to present a resume, and assuming you want the job you must take that part seriously.
- leipert 4y ago> A group of 50 applicants submit resumes for a job. 10 or so of them are delusional, and get cut. I think the author never worked in hiring for an org that got a lot of applicants. When I was a hiring manager, we sometimes opened reqs and got hundreds of applications within the first one or two days.
- danparsonson 4y agoNot to mention that a 20% delusional rate is pretty unlikely - more like 50-75% in my experience.
- jeffrallen 4y agoAnd that's before you even get to fizz buzz, where you lose all hope in humanity and start wondering if maybe the AIs should end software development as a profession.
- bdcrazy 4y agoGetting large numbers of applicants can definitely be time consuming and costly for companies. Trying to find ways to cut the crap out is tough. I recall reading about a manager who would just randomly toss half the resumes, saying he only hired lucky people. I've been around the block before and I'd take the lucky route anytime compared to some continuous interview cycles that never go anywhere.
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoI know some very underqualified poor performers who also appear to be excellent networkers. I have yet to see them however, get promotions internally based on networking alone.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoTrying to get internally promoted is a losing strategy. If you’re trying to develop your career, then all you want is for your next role to be better (and probably pay more) than your last role. Exclusively looking inside your current organisation for that next role is simply limiting your options to some tiny subset of all the potentially good options on the market. You just want to turn yourself into a good candidate for that next role, you shouldn’t care where you find it. Even if you’re successful at getting internally promoted, there’s a good chance you’re going to accomplish those goals slower than if you’d just looked elsewhere.
- suction 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 4y agoAs awful as the resume process is it has one advantage that the author seems to have ignored - it's 'fair'. It puts everyone in basically the same footing at the start of the hiring process. Using a system based on recommendations would give popular, attractive, well-connected people an advantage that's unrelated to their skill level. It would make job hopping more beneficial because you'd get to meet and connect with more people. Maybe it's unreasonable of me, but I slightly suspect the author would prefer recommendation based hiring because it'd benefit them rather than because it'd be a better system for everyone.
- RC_Blog 4y agoAuthor here. I don't think any of these points are unreasonable. I think the apparent conflict comes into play when we treat your point and my point like they are mutually exclusive. But they don't have to be - the resume system can be horrific and the alternatives can be bad in other ways, all in one swoop. It would honestly be weirder if it weren't so - it would imply a perfect process. For what it's worth, I'm not exactly proposing a "system based on recommendations", and I'm not sure how that would really work if I was proposing it. I'm more saying that the kind of treatment people get when they can bypass the resume-first system is much more human - ideally, there would be a fix that would bring the resume-first system up to the nepotistic treatment level, but I don't claim to know what that is.
- iopq 4y agoNever got a job by submitting my resume. It's always some connection or some recruiter that does more work than just submitting a resume.
- shadowofneptune 4y agoGoes without saying for Hacker News, but this seems specific to one industry. I did get hired off of resumé and a phone interview in my first application—but that's nursing, where right now they'll hire anyone who moves. I think the old rules they talk about in interview guides still work, absent any sector-specific distortions.
- keiferski 4y agoI have also found that Jobs Acquired by Submitting Resume are almost always worse than Jobs Acquired Through Network. Which makes sense, as the network jobs mean you usually know at least one person working at the company and are friendly/culturally compatible with that person. And if that person works there, chances are that there will be other similar people.
- RC_Blog 4y agoAuthor here, and agreed. For different reasons, though - I think that when you've picked someone out of 400 applications, both you and they feel like they got "lucky", as opposed to being the handpicked winner of at least a couple hundred mostly-qualified applicants. I contrast this most heavily with, say, someone the company has done cold outreach to get in touch with; like, yeah, there's a reason you did the cold outreach, they probably look like a good fit. But more importantly the power dynamic is different - the employer had to go to the applicant and ask for their attention. The applicant feels like something the employer might "lose" if they don't play their hand right, as opposed to someone who should feel honored to take the lower-mid of the payrange.
- r_hoods_ghost 4y agoLet's be honest, the alternative to having an open hiring process, i.e. resumes, is nepotism and hiring your chums and the chums of your contacts. Which does describe the hiring process in a lot of startups. Ethical issues aside, the problem with this is that it shrinks the pool of potential hires down drastically, to people who look like you, think like you, and know roughly the same things as you. Great if your customers also fit into this bracket, not so great if they don't. However I think the OP drastically underestimates the proportion of wholly unqualified on paper people who apply for most jobs. I'd put it at 50% for most and up to 90% for some. So you can see why people go down the nepotism + chums route. As someone who has a deeply weird CV and life experiences / social circle that is pretty much orthogonal to most techies it can be difficult, as the nepotism / chums route is not available. But just writing a cover letter to the JD and company gets me a fair way usually.
- heleninboodler 4y agoBut let's also be honest: startup founders aren't hiring "their chums" out of some unethical sense of helping their friends who don't deserve it, they're hiring people they know and who they have good reason to believe are going to help them succeed. The fact that their chums tend to be people who look like them and think like them is an unfortunate side effect of this, but the idea of getting candidates via networking is not fundamentally wrong when the goal is finding people you think are going to contribute. Personal experience with a candidate is a very strong bit of signal in an otherwise very flawed process.
- r_hoods_ghost 4y agoIt's not a fundamentally bad idea from a practical point of view (like I said, I'll leave the ethics out of it), but I think it is not as good an idea as a lot of people think as it narrows the field so much. Also the signal that people get, unless they have worked directly with a person, rather than just chatted with them at a networking event or know them from their childhood, is I would argue "belongs to my tribe", rather than "good at x"
- 4y ago
- yawboakye 4y agoparkinson’s essay on the principle of selection[0] is relevant here. concerning cv submission/job application being a negative signal he says, and I quote: Heaped on the table before this committee are 483 forms of application, with testimonials attached. All the applicants are Chinese and all without exception have a first degree from Peking or Amoy and a Doctorate of Philosophy from Cornell or Johns Hopkins. The majority of the candidates have at one time held ministerial office in Formosa. Some have attached their photographs. Others have (perhaps wisely) refrained from doing so. The chairman turns to the leading Chinese expert and says, "Perhaps Dr. Wu can tell us which of these candidates should be put on the short list." Dr. Wu smiles enigmatically and points to the heap. "None of them any good," he says briefly. "But how--I mean, why not?" asks the chairman, surprised. "Because no good scholar would ever apply. He would fear to lose face if he were not chosen." "So what do we do now?" asks the chairman. "I think," says Dr. Wu, "we might persuade Dr. Lim to take this post. What do you think. Dr. Lee?" "Yes, I think he might," says Lee, "but we couldn't approach him ourselves of course. We could ask Dr. Tan whether he thinks Dr. Lim would be interested." "I don't know Dr. Tan," says Wu, "but I know his friend Dr. Wong." [0]: http://www.geocities.ws/films4/parkinsonselection.htm http://www.geocities.ws/films4/parkinsonselection.htm
- ManlyBread 4y agoAnother one of these articles written by someone who seems to live in a completely different reality than most people.
- snickerer 4y agoProgrammer here, who worked as a freelance technical interviewer for the automotive industry in Germany. I did many interviews, and stopped to read the CVs after a while. I tried to find a pattern between the CV and the candidate's programming skills, but found none. Nothing.
- mihaaly 4y agoI like this writing about the necessary evil of resumes and processes around employment, when have to resort to people not known (cannot find one through network). One amendment: > This leaves five candidates - a hand-picked elite, a top 12.5% of qualified candidates. This is still an idealistic case. The 12.5% is the top sounding applications, not the top applicants. No one knows about who is the best at this stage based on the self praising and only the good included documents that candidates submit. It happened to my wife with a job she desired that she was the 12th pre-selected candidate (10 main applicants, 2 reserves) of a 70 or so applicants based on the submissions documents. Then after the interviews and tests with the 10 'top' applicants she jumped to place no.2, no.1 got a better position meanwhile so she got the job eventually. What kind of bullshit could have been in those 10 submissions that those got prioritized but none of them found suitable enough after the first round of interviews? I do not dare to imagine. And what was the HR thinking while eliminating the 58 other candidates coming up with 10 unsuitable on top? What are their criteria, nice words and pretty bulletpoints? I honestly been worried what kind of organisation will this be to work for based on their high level of selection mistakes, if it is wise accepting a position there. But it turned out most people there live up to the needs of the organization and it is a pretty ok place (no perfect place exists). Even if no real top gets in - get eliminated among the 58 misfortuned not having pretty enogh submission paperwork for the HR's taste - those do could learn to do the job decent enough in the end, apparently. The recruitment could not ruin things too much. : )
- saxelsen 4y agoLife-hack for applicants: stand out with a cover letter. Life-hack #2: Use ChatGPT to write it in 2 minutes Alternatively (shameless promotion): Use a special-purpose tool I wrote for it, which uses the GPT API https://aicoverletter.me https://aicoverletter.me
- surgical_fire 4y agoNot the hero we deserve, but the hero we need
- sph 4y agoResume-based hiring is dehumanising and terrible under any aspect. There is nothing redeeming about it. There is an incredible number of factors that determine how good a prospective employee is to a company, and none of them can be easily represented with a list of job titles and qualifications. You can find people with impressive resumes and they are terrible employees: lazy, stupid, unmotivated. There is a vast amount of people with unimpressed job history that would be perfect candidates even to work on a very specific piece of technology if they are smart, quick to learn, driven, ambitious, enthusiastic or any other soft-skill. My best interview is my first, as a 19 year old high school dropout: I must've mentioned that I had played with Linux and knew C and PHP. They asked me something along the lines of "what does ifconfig do?", "can you configure Apache?" and "tell me a little about your projects in C", and got hired. They only needed to know I was able to learn undirected, was passionate about computers in general. Of course this was for a junior position, but still, none of that 3 interviews, whiteboard leetcode bullcrap that is so common nowadays. tl;dr: Candidates are to their resumes what a chef's meal is to the list of ingredients.
- Terretta 4y ago> Candidates are to their resumes what a chef's meal is to the list of ingredients. It sounds as though you're saying it's not the list of ingredients, it's what you make of them. On the contrary, the interesting chefs, you can tell from the list, as there are delightfully unexpected choices and twists on the list. This absolutely POPS on a resume, and is one of the indicators I look for.
- Terretta 4y agoIn my experience, the article is off base thanks to a fundamentally flawed premise: misuse of resumes by bad companies means don't use it for good companies. On the contrary, good roles need a good resume (CV) process to cast a wide enough net to find great teammates. 1. The idealistic teenager version of this does exit: at companies that value craft and domain know-how. 2. The ratio is not 10 delusional to 40 qualified, the ratio is 40 delusional to 10 qualified, maybe. (I've reviewed 5 figures of resumes.) 3. A bad company has unqualified screeners, in a disinterested department, as described in the blog. That's indeed terrible. Don't apply there!!! 4. A good company, screening is performed by people with mastery of the area, well qualified to pattern match resumes to the performers on their team. You can often tell from the job descriptions (or your network) when this is true. 5. Bad filter is as described in the article, while a good filter puts all plausible resumes through, regardless of any nonsense in the job description like "8 years of ChatGPT prompt crafting experience required" or "Masters required". 5. In good company, plausibles are given to the tech or team leads hiring who are interested in finding candidates with standout value adds, these generally are not on resumes. 6. This is done not by bullet match for "did this precise thing before" (the rubric from non-domain aka contentless managers) but by understanding candidate attributes (e.g. an attribute to learn new domains quickly) and is tetris-ing a well qualified cloverleaf of attributes for evolving solutions in the problem space -- and being able to see these attributes between the lines of how a dry resume is written. . . . Finally, most importantly, the candidate is not making a resume for the company, but for themselves. As a craftsperson in a domain, it's worth "curating" your CV. CV stands for curriculum vitae which in Latin means "course of life". From apprentice, through journeyman, to mastery, there is a roadmap, and the as-yet-unwritten portions of the CV are more important than those on the page. By writing this down for yourself ahead of time, you can chart a course that lands you where you intend, or keeps you on a path you find rewarding. Diff yourself against that path, making intentional corrections as you go. While at a job, journal the outcomes you delivered for the team, and the company, that made a difference. When you've gathered all the power-ups you need, crystallize them onto the CV, and start your own pattern-matching against the next role on your roadmap. When you find a role (internal or external), go for it. When you manage yourself proactively this way, and apply to roles at companies that value craft, you're not working for the resume process, the CV process works for you.
- sharas- 4y agoThere is a sentiment in the post that "poor" hiring managers have no other way to weed out the incompetent. At the same time it says that HR functionaries are not even looking at CVs... It is not a contradiction though, such idiocy is natural for those systems. But the sentiment about "poor" hiring managers is a miss. The system is by design: https://bitslap.it/blog/posts/playground-it.html#part-i---managers-dollhouse https://bitslap.it/blog/posts/playground-it.html#part-i---ma...
- pttrn 4y agoVery ranty, I’m surprised it got this many upvotes.
- pjmlp 4y agoWell, not everyone cares about passion and doing overtime outside work just to stand out for what is a labour per hour => money transaction. So that leaves out resumes for the rest of us that actually have a life outside work.
- raydev 4y ago> consider that everything the resume is supposed to do [...] is all stuff they are going to do again in phone screens, the interviews, and the reference checks Not just things you need to do again, but they might even ask you to solve an arbitrary problem you've never seen before in 40 minutes, with someone watching and not helping, knowing your livelihood is on the line if you fail. And they have a hard rule that states you must create a working program, so even if you can express your ideas and make it very clear you'd get to a correct and efficient solution eventually, if it doesn't run in under 40 minutes, you're out. It's a mini coding competition, and you are set up to fail. I recently got laid off from a job that actually boosted my resume quite nicely, the work made me a specialist that triggered several big name companies to reach out for this niche thing. I was told multiple times that I'd effectively passed 80% of the interview sessions, but their tests, for whether I'd been able to memorize all common algo approaches and my ability to regurgitate them in a short amount of time, were beyond my abilities.
- thynker 4y agoIt's seems very strange that the resume is not disrupted. The model and format seems ridiculously outdated. What are some startups that have tried to change this? Why didn't they succeed? The only thing I can come up with is Equalture.com, though it is more about generating more "fairness" between applicants rather than making the UX of applying better