11 ms·
> It’s important no doubt but moving beyond the prohibition drug war approach (which is failing in places going hard as it is weak like Canada)to dealing with t
by seanmcdirmid 4y ago
> It’s important no doubt but moving beyond the prohibition drug war approach (which is failing in places going hard as it is weak like Canada)to dealing with this requires a serious reckoning and public investment that we aren’t ready to accept yet but will be imposed on us whether we like it or not.
There are lots of contradictions here. Voters don't understand how they can be asked to liberalize hard drug use (and even decriminalize dealing) on the one hand, and are asked for billions of dollars for drug addiction treatment on the other. In Seattle, we have a particularly bad mess, where the biggest thing now is trying to fentanyl smoking off of public buses and light rail. They are even talking about studying the dangers of second hand fentanyl smoke to bus drivers.
Hopefully we can learn something from our neighbors up north, but frankly it doesn't seem to be that much better in Vancouver.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoIt's pretty deliberate failure to understand, in my opinion, driven by a core belief that bad things happen to bad people and they need to be punished out of it, not helped. The goal for many people is absolutely not reducing deaths, or even getting rid of fentanyl smoke on buses. It is expelling fentanyl users from society and expecting that will stop new users appearing. That's why they don't want to spend money on treatment or services. They think enabling the existence and recovery of existing users will encourage more.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> or even getting rid of fentanyl smoke on buses. The burnt peanut butter smell is pretty rancid. Voters, even in Seattle, only have a finite amount of empathy to spare on this problem, and it has mostly been expended. > It is expelling fentanyl users from society and expecting that will stop new users appearing. That's why they don't want to spend money on treatment or services. They think enabling the existence and recovery of existing users will encourage more. We (King County at least) spend around $100k/junkie per year on services. And that still isn't considered enough. So should we double our property taxes or something to spend even more money on this problem? > They think enabling the existence and recovery of existing users will encourage more. If Seattle is the only place these people can get help across the whole country, that would definitely occur. You can't fight a national problem with local resources and not expect distortions (people are mobile).
- pstuart 4y agoThis is a national problem and needs to be addressed (and funded) as such. The war on drugs has failed miserably (for it's ostensible purpose (to "protect" us from dangerous drugs). We need to legalize and regulate them all, and make their abuse a medical issue rather than a criminal issue. For those that have no desire or ability to quit, we can put them in camps and hand out dope to keep them sedated and "safe" from questionable supplies. If they want to get clean, they can have the support to do that but otherwise are effectively interned on work farms. This is the cheapest, safest, and most humane way of dealing with this problem.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoYou still fantasize about a world where everything and everyone is ”clean”. That will never exist but you will destroy the humanity of yourself and others in an attempt to delude yourself.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoNah, getting dangerous people off the street is its own reward. If they could get high without causing problems I couldn't care.
- pstuart 4y agoExactly. Way cheaper than jail too.
- pstuart 4y agoI have lots of fantasies but that ain't one of them. The gist of my point is that there's going to be a subset of the population that is "broken" and is unable to function as a "productive member of society". We are going to spend money on them one way or the other; my way would be far more effective than how it happens today (both in cost and in actual remediation). How would this destroy my (and others) humanity? It's currently challenged by watching people live in tents, shit on the sidewalk, and pass out in public on dope. How is my suggestion worse?
- zo1 4y ago> "They think enabling the existence and recovery of existing users will encourage more." It's also a timing issue. I think a lot of people that are currently in the "just get rid of them" camp would have been in the "let's help them rehabilitate" camp when the problem was in small or controlled scale. But we are way passed that. It's a downright epidemic and needs to be dealt with in more drastic and immediate terms for some of us. I'm not going to wait 5 years while my children are innocent and in school and wandering around for the problem to get better. I want my neighborhood safe and clean and innocent for them now. This is why suburbs popped up on some level. People just want to be left alone and in relative calm and clean surroundings.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoGated white communities still exist, if you want a drastic immediate change then move there.
- kerkeslager 4y ago> Voters don't understand how they can be asked to liberalize hard drug use (and even decriminalize dealing) on the one hand, and are asked for billions of dollars for drug addiction treatment on the other. It's easy to communicate this: We spend billions to incarcerate people for drug crimes, and then send them out with a criminal record that pushes them right back toward drug use. OR we spend fewer billions on drug addiction treatment and housing. It's not confusing or contradictory at all. People who end up in prison don't get help, and people who get help don't end up in prison. "Voters" wouldn't be confused if certain interests didn't keep them confused. It's profitable to keep housing scarce and prisons full. Until we start prioritizing sick people over profiteers we won't fix this problem.
- schrectacular 4y agoIn prison or dead means they aren't on the streets and people don't have to face or interact with the problem. I would guess that many voters are much happier with "out of sight, out of mind"
- moonchrome 4y agoAlso not a risk to you. Most drug addicts are not the kind of people you want around. There are highly functioning ones, but it often exacerbates mental health issues. Not sure prohibition is the correct approach but let's not strawman the other side of the argument.
- kerkeslager 4y ago> Most drug addicts are not the kind of people you want around. True, but how much time does the average non-addict spend in drug rehabs? Both prisons and rehab facilities isolate addicts from the general population.
- jibe 4y agoCalifornia has been at the vanguard of reducing prison population, and decriminalizing drug use, and so far the results look disastrous. That’s not a policy that needs any confusion to be unappealing.
- noduerme 4y agoPortlander chiming in here. I think it's almost universally accepted now that decriminalization was a stupid idea - and I myself voted for it at the time. I absolutely would still vote for anything that improved the availability of treatment for addiction, regardless of cost. But I think what we've learned is that every carrot needs a stick. And where there's excess supply, demand will catch up. All of which means, go after supply and possession again until this is under control.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoOr take your head our of your ass, stop enacting half-hearted measures like decriminalization and completely legalize the supply. Your prime issue is corruption, not drug use
- tayo42 4y agoi don't get why decriminalization keeps getting pushed by people my cynical take, entrenched people have something to gain by the grey area decriminalization offers.
- Jochim 4y agoMy point of view is that locking people up for drug use: * Hasn't reduced drug use * Makes them more likely to continue their drug use * Often leads to the use of harder drugs * Is expensive * Provides funding to cartels * Causes violence Decriminalising, or legalising drug use removes one of the main motivators of gang formation/violence while allowing the state to focus on helping addicts recover and contribute to society. The money spent on enforcement can now be spent on treatment, reducing the need for further funding rather than increasing it.
- noduerme 4y agoThere is another option, which is to leave the users alone and go hard after the suppliers.
- lostlogin 4y ago> Voters don't understand how they can be asked to liberalize hard drug use (and even decriminalize dealing) on the one hand, and are asked for billions of dollars for drug addiction treatment on the other We are increasingly spending more on drug treatment. The current approach has failed and <x> are dead. It's time to change our approach, and a radical change is needed for this massive problem.
- CaptainZapp 4y ago> Voters don't understand how they can be asked to liberalize hard drug use (and even decriminalize dealing) on the one hand, and are asked for billions of dollars for drug addiction treatment on the other. That depends on the voters. In the 90s Switzerland experienced a significant change in its drug policy. One of the pillars (arguably the most important) is harm reduction. At that time hardcore addicts could get heroin prescribed and paid for by health insurance. Getting into the program was not simple, but for those that were hopelessly addicted and not able to kick the habit it was fundamentally successful. The policy is still in place and was confirmed with significant majorities by the voters in multiple referendums.
- vintermann 4y ago> There are lots of contradictions here. Voters don't understand how they can be asked to liberalize hard drug use (and even decriminalize dealing) on the one hand, and are asked for billions of dollars for drug addiction treatment on the other. And understandably so. It's a textbook example of privatizing the profits, and socializing the costs. It's not enough to tax drugs. Certain products are so harmful, and their harmful use so profitable, that allowing any kind of private profit from it at all is a disaster. (Yes, the most prominent of those are tobacco, alcohol and gambling). Worse, addiction treatment is really expensive and not very effective - even the best addiction treatment programs have high relapse rates. Even the relatively cheap programs that only seek to limit the damage addicts do to themselves and others, can only be defended on humanitarian grounds, not economic ones. Yes, we need to help addicts. Yes, including in purely harm-reduction ways. But we're deluding ourselves if we think this is a solution at all, let alone one we can afford if we let private economic interests profit from addiction without obstacles.
- themitigating 4y agoWhy can't they understand this? Criminal enforcement and crime are apparently a major concern among voters. They are just the victim of right wing propaganda
- mrguyorama 4y agoA lot of those voters seem more interested in just letting """bad people""" die.