36 ms·
Bicycle
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- naillo 4y agoAwesome stuff as always. Don't forget to support his patreon: https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski
- pranshuchittora 4y agoMind blowing simulation.
- scastiel 4y agoEvery post on this blog is so impressive! Love it!
- BrianHenryIE 4y agoBeautiful article. There's a similar neat video, "Most People Don't Know How Bikes Work", where they fix the steering so the handlebars can only be turned left, and people then aren't able to turn left. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cNmUNHSBac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cNmUNHSBac
- marai2 4y agoPshh, I know how to ride a bicycle, why is ciechanowski writing an article about riding a bicycle?! Holy moly!! I didn't realize I didn't know how I actually ride a bicycle!! Obligatory sound track for this excellent post: https://youtu.be/KwvWtZl2ICY https://youtu.be/KwvWtZl2ICY
- JALTU 4y agoDang, you beat me to it, I was busy inflating my tires to 120 psi.
- samstave 4y agoGo tubeless! https://youtu.be/skW_Ysew3zw https://youtu.be/skW_Ysew3zw
- exabrial 4y agoWhen I first started MTB in 2020... I tried to inflate my tubeless rear tire to 60psi once, because that was the "max pressure" written on the sidewall. There are times you are incorrect, and wow, there are times you are very very wrong. They should make tubeless sealant in blood red just for fun.
- IIsi50MHz 4y agoSimilarly, a Honda Fit with tires inflated to 90% ofthe sidewall's max pressure is /very/ fuel efficient, but you better plan on replacing tires pretty often. After a few potholes, usually.
- flavius29663 4y agoYou probably know this...but the song is not about a literal bicycle...it's about Freddie being "bi". I only say this because it took me too long to realize that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- divan 4y agoOther soundtrack option: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLUX0y4EptA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLUX0y4EptA
- sha-3 4y agoGreat, this is the best way start the day!
- lbussell 4y agoThis is the greatest explanation of two-wheeled vehicle dynamics I've ever seen. Anyone who rides a bicycle or motorcycle should read this whole thing!
- Brajeshwar 4y agoYou will love the interesting video, "Most People Don't Know How Bikes Work" by Veritasium - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cNmUNHSBac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cNmUNHSBac
- js2 4y agoWorth watching but for folks who want a TL;DW: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countersteering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countersteering
- birdyrooster 4y agoVeritasium is some low quality trash, next.
- philipwhiuk 4y agoIt's actually linked deep in the article.
- GaryNumanVevo 4y agoAnother instant classic from Bartosz Ciechanowski!
- graypegg 4y agoThis is such a well made explanation! Tons to learn from this. Good job!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- margalabargala 4y ago> The further away that line is from the center of mass, the easier it is for the force to rotate the object. In the following demonstration, you can apply two forces of the same magnitude to two identical boxes. The only difference is the distance to the center of mass at which these forces act: > When the distance between the force-line and the center of mass is large, the box spins faster as well. That distance doesn’t change the acceleration of the box to the right and both boxes move with the same linear speed. However, that distance affects the angular acceleration of a box – the longer that arm, the faster the box spins. This does not make sense to me. If the two forces are truly of equal magnitude, then shouldn't the one that is in-line with the center of mass accelerate it faster, since 100% of the force is being converted to linear momentum, while the off-center force is being split between increasing linear momentum and rotational momentum? This would appear to violate the conservation of energy.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago> This does not make sense to me. If the two forces are truly of equal magnitude, then shouldn't the one that is in-line with the center of mass accelerate it faster, since 100% of the force is being converted to linear momentum, while the off-center force is being split between increasing linear momentum and rotational momentum? Forces don't "split" that way. 100% of the force goes into creating linear acceleration, and 100% of the force goes into creating torque. > This would appear to violate the conservation of energy. It's not. The off-center force does more work, putting more energy into rotation.
- amluto 4y agoLots to unpack here. First, there is no splitting between linear momentum and angular momentum per se. They have different units, you can't add them, and it makes no sense to say "this is 30% linear momentum and 70% angular momentum". But you can calculate how much energy is stored in linear motion and how much is stored in angular motion, and (at least at non-relativistic speeds), you can indeed add them. So you are on to something here. But Newton's Laws don't lie. If you apply a force F, then a=m/F, and the fact that the object is spinning doesn't change the acceleration. Yet applying the force off-center does indeed seem to add more energy to the object: you're accelerating it just as much as if you applied the force on-center and you're also spinning it. So how do you resolve this? A piece of general advice in physics (and math, and many other fields) is to state your assumptions and your questions precisely and unambiguously. The question is: if you apply an equal force to two objects of equal mass, and there are no other external forces involved, how can one accelerate faster? But just because the forces are equal doesn't mean that the work (energy applied) is the same. In fact: W (work) = F (force) * d (distance) Divide by a small unit of time: P (power, which is work per unit time) = F * v (velocity, which is distance per unit time) And that's the velocity of the point that receives the force. And if you look at the animation, you will see that the off-center force on the rotating box is applied to a (variable) spot on the box that is moving to the right. So the power needed to apply the force is larger, and more work is done. (In fact, the excess velocity is ωr, so the excess power is Fωr = ωτ (angular velocity times torque), which is exactly the power needed to produce angular acceleration. So energy is conserved and all is well.)
- thallavajhula 4y agoI saw the domain name "ciechanow.ski" and immediately upvoted it even before I opened it. The quality of posts by Bartosz is just next level.
- captainmisery 4y agoSame here. What an amazing content he makes.
- rom1v 4y agoSame. The blog is just incredible.
- b212 4y agoRight? His posts are an equivalent of new GTA releases when I was a kid.
- leeoniya 4y agoi'm a simple man: i see ciechanow.ski, i press "like"
- antupis 4y agohttps://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/ https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/ this is still my all time favorite blog post.
- ftxbro 4y agoAlso see the work of Jason Moore (referenced in that blog) for whom it seems modeling bicycle dynamics in open source scientific python has been a huge passion for him for more than ten years. I remember in the scientific python development in those days there were these guys from like the hubble optics correction division and like the asml metrology department and then this one weird bicycle guy lol. https://moorepants.github.io/dissertation/ https://moorepants.github.io/dissertation/ https://github.com/moorepants https://github.com/moorepants
- davnicwil 4y agoI've always loved that little fact about having to initially turn the handlebars the opposite way to initiate a turn. It's pretty much impossible to believe without thinking it through, and yet everyone naturally intuits it. It's one of my favourite examples of how the brain can just 'feel' forces and make the right adjustments incredibly fast. So amazing.
- gtop3 4y agoThis effect has a big play on motorcycles. Riding a bicycle is considered prerequisite knowledge for learning to ride a motorcycle, largely because of this counter steering. One thing that is more pronounced on a motorcycle is that counter steering only occurs while the bike is moving at speed. As in, you only counter steer a motorcycle above ~10mph (higher for some motorcycles). It's really cool to think about how intuitive this switch is, almost everyone picks it up quickly and it becomes second nature.
- Gracana 4y ago> As in, you only counter steer a motorcycle above ~10mph I don’t believe that this is true. Can you explain the physics?
- poorbutdebtfree 4y agoThe "counter steer isn't real" debate about to start again!
- gowld 4y agoThe debate is whether countersteering is something you have to consciously do by turning the steering column ("yaw"), or whether it's an automatic effect of pushing/leaning down on the side you want to turn toward ("roll"). "countersteering isn't real" because "steering isn't real", cycles at speed turn by leaning/rolling, not steering/yawing.
- 4y ago
- yeknoda 4y agoyay
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eshnil 4y agoAnother great interactive explanation. I wish physics teachers start using geometric product of vectors, instead of the cross product. This allows forces and torques to be combined into a single concept "Forque". Really, translations are just rotations around infinity and rotations are just composition of two reflections. If we allow the algebra to take care of rotations, physics becomes a lot simpler.
- samstave 4y agoWait until (all) teachers start using AND SHARING really well crafted prompts for teaching aides /r/coolguides lesson material. There should be a central repo for all subjects where topics can be looked up to find a guide like this one - and the prompt is public, with revision edit logs (like wikipedia) such that a standard agreed upon response can be adopted by acedmia for explaining a particle concept. Let the acedemics expand upon, tangent from, deep dive into the sub components of each topic. The University.ai
- not_the_fda 4y agoA great book on the science of bicycles is "Bicycling Science" from MIT press. https://www.amazon.com/Bicycling-Science-Press-Gordon-Wilson/dp/0262538407/ https://www.amazon.com/Bicycling-Science-Press-Gordon-Wilson...
- bmelton 4y agoA much worse book on the science of bicycles is "The Third Policeman" from Flann O'Brien. Some of its wisdom: “The gross and net result of it is that people who spent most of their natural lives riding iron bicycles over the rocky roadsteads of this parish get their personalities mixed up with the personalities of their bicycle as a result of the interchanging of the atoms of each of them and you would be surprised at the number of people in these parts who are nearly half people and half bicycles...when a man lets things go so far that he is more than half a bicycle, you will not see him so much because he spends a lot of his time leaning with one elbow on walls or standing propped by one foot at kerbstones.”
- kitkat_new 4y agoLink to the book directly from MIT Press: https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262538404/bicycling-science/ https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262538404/bicycling-science/
- eDameXxX 4y agoI see new post from Bartosz, I upvote. Simple as that.
- adverbly 4y agoI always find it interesting to think about bicycles and just how recently they were invented. Compare bicycles with steel making, for example. Steel making happened thousands of years ago. The modern bicycle was what - under 200 years ago? Bikes seem like such a primitive technology, and yet as this article demonstrates, it takes a lot of engineering to design even primitive products. It makes me wonder how many other simple or primitive products are out there which have yet to be discovered.
- otabdeveloper4 4y agoBall-bearings? Primitive?? Surely you jest!
- ejensler 4y agoAgreed. Bicycles are kind of a miracle of seeming simplicity hiding a ton of important developments of the industrial age. 99 Percent Invisible did a recent episode on just this topic: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-safety-bicycle/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-safety-bicycle/.
- kube-system 4y agoI guess perspective makes it a lot less surprising that the first airplanes were made by bicycle manufacturers.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoDon't even get me started on airplanes though - there was only 66 years between the first airplane (Wright Flyer in 1903) and the moon landing (1969). Disclaimer: that's of course a cool anecdote on the surface, but rockets have been around since the 13th century so they're two mostly different technologies.
- johannes1234321 4y agoAre rockets and planes related? Quite different requirements regarding aerodynamics and propulsion.
- davidw 4y agoBicycles are truly beautiful machines. They are the most energy efficient form of transportation. You can travel pretty long distances with not that many calories.
- dheera 4y ago> They are the most energy efficient form of transportation. If the cyclist is vegan or even an average diet, yes. If the cyclist is paleo, a Prius with 2-person occupancy may actually be more carbon-efficient: https://keith.seas.harvard.edu/blog/climate-impacts-biking-vs-driving https://keith.seas.harvard.edu/blog/climate-impacts-biking-v...
- prmoustache 4y agoAt equal diet, the bicycle always win. You don't eat significantly more meat because you are using a bicycle to move vs a total couch potato that would use a Prius and eat the same.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dheera 4y agoI disagree with this. On days I cycle 100km+ in a day I do eat vastly more than if I drive 100km and don't exercise. The energy does have to come from somewhere. If you're only cycling 5km in a day the reason you don't notice the difference in food quantity is because the amount of energy used for that small amount of cycling does not really exceed the amount of energy your body uses in a day for everything else. When you're cycling 100km, it's a different story. It's an interesting question, and in fact the conversion of food to mechanical energy isn't actually very carbon-efficient compared to electricity generation or even gasoline. Cars are actually very efficient at what they do, it's just that what they do (hauling around a 1000kg metal box) is an inefficient way to transport a human, and that's where the inefficiency comes from. If you fill up a large car with full occupancy and go on a long road trip, I'd venture to say it's carbon-wise likely to be more efficient than all of the occupants cycling, regardless of diet.
- kazinator 4y agoNice demo of countersteering. When you jerk the slider quickly to the right, you can see that the right handlebar briefly lunges forward (left steer) before the steering recovers to the right. It's still noticeable with smaller/slower movements of the slider, but not as much.
- umvi 4y agociechanow.ski pages are usually super performant for me, but this one is super laggy, especially widgets with the bicycle man/mesh. Anyone else experiencing this?
- nfriedly 4y agoI'm using Firefox on a mid-range Android phone and it seems to behave fine. Maybe reboot your computer and see if the site is less laggy?
- wiredfool 4y agoThis is a really impressive article -- he went quite far into the physics of bikes and wheels and didn't say anything that I could point to as being wrong.
- martopix 4y agoFantastic for teaching high school physics
- tambourine_man 4y agoIf you don’t know Bartosz Ciechanowski‘s site yet, checkout his archives. Be careful if you have deadlines for today though, you may be there for a long and awesome time.
- NGC404 4y agoSomewhat related: How many neurons does it take to ride a bycicle? https://paradise.caltech.edu/~cook/papers/TwoNeurons.pdf https://paradise.caltech.edu/~cook/papers/TwoNeurons.pdf
- jjcm 4y agoBartosz is the quality bar I aspire to when I write my blog posts. I've always added interactivity in mine, but they in no way approach the detail and polish that he puts into them.
- thomasfl 4y agoThe most important fact is that riding a bicycle is 3 to 5 times more energy efficient than walking. Depending on the road, bicycle, terrain and weight of the rider. Riding a bicycle is the most efficient self-powered means of transportation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_performance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_performance
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI had a look and the source cited for it being the most efficent self-powered means of transportation is from March 1973; I wonder if there's been any new developments since then. Random things off the top of my head: Some time ago they built a self-propelled helicopter, which also used bike technology (gears etc). I vaguely recall that people did state that rowing is what you should use to get the most energy out of a human body - it is (or can be) a full-body motion, including the large muscles in the back and legs and the smaller ones in the arms, while cycling mainly uses the legs. But the mechanism to translate rowing energy into the propellers was too heavy, or something like that. Actually it might have been a HN thread. Here's one from 10 years ago, and it just so happens that I had made my account by then so this was probably it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6028326 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6028326
- fnfjfk 4y agoIn terms of efficiency of bicycles alone, aero frames, deep wheels, carbon fiber. Clipless is also an incredibly significant change, but not as much of efficiency as the others.
- amluto 4y agoCarbon fiber? As I understand it, reducing unsprung weight (which is not very much for a bicycle with no suspension beyond the tires) can have an outsized effect, but actually reducing weight mostly matters for ascending. For non-competitive cycling, other factors seem like they should be much more significant. A big one, which is banned in most competitive formats, is a fairing. This is much more effective than having a human hunker down and try to be aerodynamic. Even for an upright cargo bike (which is generally extremely heavy), a fairing in front can make a dramatic difference on level ground with no wind.
- thunderbong 4y agoAll the posts on ciechanow.ski are mind-blowing. The graphics, the gradual process of explaining from simple fundamental concepts to the complete picture. How I wish our schools would teach like this.
- krupkat 4y ago100% agree, incredible blog
- asah 4y agoelectric bikes have quietly revolutionized nyc delivery, with food deliveries now going halfway across manhattan and between boroughs, no big deal.
- gowld 4y agoGreat articles, no ads, except this one: Voluntary contribution of $3 or more per article, via Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski (Not sure what "per article" means though. How to donate for past articles? Will I get billed whenever a new article drops?)
- lom 4y agoI’m not even done with reading, but i’ve been very interested in bikes and how they work for quite some time now and I can confidentially say that this is on of the best writeups there is. Thanks to the author for making this
- auggierose 4y agoWow. Beautiful piece of art, but I am not going to read it. For someone who has, is the length of the article proportional to the gained knowledge, or could that be expressed much more succinct?
- macrael 4y agoI've loved every article he's done so far. He only publishes about once a quarter and usually his articles are ~2 hours long. I've yet to be unimpressed.
- aoeusnth1 4y agoIf you don’t have time to read it, why do you have time to comment on it?
- maximinus_thrax 4y ago> is the length of the article proportional to the gained knowledge It is. But I'm going to go against the grain here and say that timewise it's not worth it (I'm biased as I already knew most of the things I saw in the article while skimming it). I would just watch the Veritasium video and move on with my life. Or go down a wikipedia rabbit hole starting at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_and_motorcycle_geometry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_and_motorcycle_geometr.... I appreciate the author's work, but this type of content is not for me. I suspect it's also not for the other self-proclaimed 'nerds' in the comment section, I think people just appreciate the work put into it and the fact that it's not following the style of shallow short SEO driven content you frequently find online. I'm skeptical that even 50% of the people in this comment section actually read all of it.
- stefncb 4y agoN=1, but I read the ones I'm interested in top to bottom. I didn't read this one specifically, but I finished the ones about lenses and mechanical watches in one sitting. If it's about something that's really interesting to me, his work is absolutely fantastic. If it's not, I'll still take a peek because I like playing with the animations.
- loeg 4y agoThe first animation is sort of wrong. To turn right on a bicycle, you actually steer slightly left (and vice versa). It's very jarring to see the wheel rotated in the same direction of the turn at extreme lean angles -- if you do that in the real world, you'll crash. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countersteering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countersteering
- TeddyDD 4y agoCountersteering is explained later in the article.
- loeg 4y agoGreat. My complaint about the animation stands.
- mazugrin2 4y agoNo, I don't think it does. Counter-steering is only a feature of a turn being initiated. Once the turn is in progress, the front wheel will very much be pointed in the direction of the turn.
- loeg 4y agoBased on my experience, I believe that's not true. You counter-steer through the turn or your momentum would push the bicycle-rider system upright (centrifugal effect). Pointing the front wheel in the direction of the turn will initiate countersteer in the other direction (i.e., getting out of the turn). (I ride bikes most days of the year, if that helps.)
- topaz0 4y agoI believe you are mistaken. At steady state turning the steering is typically pretty subtle, and of course you can oversteer and have that mess with your balance in the opposite direction, but some steering has to be there to get the wheel to go in the right direction.
- dudzik 4y agoHow did he create the animations?
- aoeusnth1 4y agoCustom webgl, I believe. You can check the page source.
- azibi 4y agoAlso worth mentioning bicycle related is the lifework of Sheldon Brown: https://www.sheldonbrown.com https://www.sheldonbrown.com Not fancy looking, but very interesting.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoSheldon Brown is a great resource for bike information - lots of no-nonsense advice and explanations though it is getting a bit out-of-date now since his death. A particular favourite of mine is his chain cleaning method: https://www.sheldonbrown.com/chainclean.html https://www.sheldonbrown.com/chainclean.html
- sasawpg 4y agoThat would be something I'd personally consider out-of-date with modern chains. Apparently that makes me a "Lazy, careless cyclist" as I would never use grease on a chain. Nor would I ever follow this insane method of cleaning a chain. Guess I'd consider myself to be an efficient cyclist, which may be construed as "lazy" by some. edit: reading onward, he claims "Serious cyclists, who value performance..". I wonder what he considers "performance", because it sure appears he didn't consider or measure drivetrain efficiency.
- putnambr 4y agoKnowing how much of a PITA even modern in-depth chain cleaning is with solvents... I can't read that article as anything but satire. Even with old roller designs, an overnight soak in paint thinner followed by an ethanol bath should get the whole thing close to bare metal. Maybe the disassembly is specific to getting roller grease applied properly, unlike how he mentions manufacturers just dip the chain in a homogeneous lubricant? I'm surprised Brown didn't advocate for chain waxing over using grease for performance and maintenance reasons.
- sasawpg 4y agoI hadn't actually read the chain cleaning page before but I did read his page on chains, which to an extent is contradicting with his chain cleaning page: "New chains come pre-lubricated with a grease-type lubricant which has been installed at the factory. This is an excellent lubricant, and has been made to permeate all of the internal interstices in the chain. The chain and this lubricant need to be warmed during application. This factory lube is superior to any lube that you can apply after the fact -- well, unless...see below." Hard for me to tell what is original content vs. new. It has been empirically demonstrated that factory lube and grease are considerably inferior when it comes to drivetrain efficiency (performance) compared to a wet lube, which is less efficient than either dry lube or wax (with or without additives). I've waxed chains for a while in the past but stopped a couple years ago. I now do a "good enough" quick clean of a chain using an undiluted degreaser, rinse with water and a final rinse with isopropyl. The whole process takes 5 minutes and the chain is clean enough for new application. Not clean enough for waxing, you'd want to throw in a solvent before ethanol/isopropyl, but good enough for wet/dry lube. I've no science to back longevity of chains following above procedure, I generally swap between 2-3 chains during a season to keep wear reasonable and then start fresh in the fall before indoor.
- smoyer 4y ago> Since our planet is very heavy, the acceleration of the Earth and the wall attached to it is effectively non-existent. If the applied force is anchored to the ground too, if doesn't matter how heavy the planet is.
- ubj 4y agoBeautifully illustrated and brilliantly explained. Derek Muller (Veritasium) on YouTube has a related video diving into the mechanics of bicycle riding. It shows what happens if you prevent the rider from performing the countersteer before leaning into a turn [1]. [1]: https://youtu.be/9cNmUNHSBac https://youtu.be/9cNmUNHSBac
- LanceH 4y agoTry just leaning before steering. Countersteering is not required.
- wintogreen74 4y ago>> Once mastered, the simple action of pedaling to move forward and turning the handlebars to steer makes bike riding an effortless activity. Except you don't really turn the handlebars to steer, movement is far more than just pedaling and it's never an effortless activity if done right. Everything else in this sentence is correct though ;)
- nntwozz 4y agoImmediately made me think of Steve Jobs and this great clip: "Computers are like a bicycle for our minds." https://youtu.be/ob_GX50Za6c https://youtu.be/ob_GX50Za6c
- dejawu 4y agoAnd its counterpart quote by Bill Gates, "Bicycles are like a computer for our legs."
- jagrsw 4y agoHmm.. the acceleration part. E=(mv^2)/2 - so we put more energy accelerating the bike from 10-20m/s than 0-10m/s, no? Yet a=F/m - which suggests the acceleration is proportional to force, which would suggest that applying force F for time t should speed you up 0-10m/s the same way as 10-20m/s? I suspect the force applied to the pedals is not the force which is acting on the bike (counter-force of the ground-bike system) and this second force is somehow relatable to the current speed of the bike, no?
- topaz0 4y agoCommon mistake: you are confusing energy and momentum, or power (rate of energy/work) and force (rate of momentum change). In fact, power at constant force is F.v (force time velocity), which solves your question.
- aoeusnth1 4y agoIf you don’t shift gears, then your pedals increase in speed as your bike accelerates. So your power consumption goes up with speed even though force is constant.
- wiredfool 4y agoWork (change in energy) is F*d, so the force you're applying to go from 10->20m/s happens over a larger distance if it's the same force.
- comment_ran 4y agoHey there fellow bikers! I've been having some trouble adjusting the tension in my spokes lately. It seems like no matter how much I try, I just can't seem to get it right. Does anyone have any tips or tricks they could share with me? On a related note, I've been wondering about the differences between mountain bikes and road bikes. One thing I've noticed is that when you take a sharp turn on a mountain bike, you tend to move the bike away from your body. But on a road bike, you maintain that alignment with your body and the frame. It's fascinating how these small differences can have such a big impact on the way we ride. What do you all think? Have you noticed any other differences between these two types of bikes? Let's chat and share our experiences!
- acomjean 4y agoI've never built or adjusted a wheel. My understanding its not for the faint of heart. The late husband of one my CS professors (Sheldon Brown) put together a solid bike resource on the web... He has some hints on wheel adjustment (after describing building) https://www.sheldonbrown.com/wheelbuild.html https://www.sheldonbrown.com/wheelbuild.html sometimes local bike shops have wheel building classes.
- matsemann 4y agoYeah it's an art. Sometimes you true a wheel and it just works. Sometimes it's like you're stuck in some local minima and can't get out; The wheel is egg shaped, so you tighten the long sides, then it's round but suddenly the wheel is tilted instead, you fix it but now it's off center, you fix it but the tension is wrong, you fix it but now it's egg shaped again..
- StayTrue 4y agoYou offer a good description of adjusting a wheel that is tensioned beyond its natural limit. Sometimes the art is making an assessment of the rim and deciding the best set of trade-offs given the rim's limitations.
- StayTrue 4y ago
- zerr 4y agoIt might not be intentional, but does anyone think that this article might be a well executed act of trolling?
- sixstringtheory 4y agoIf you meant nerd sniping, then yes, absolutely!
- zerr 4y agoSeems like a right term. I mean, if anything, the length of the article rings the bell.
- skeltoac 4y agoWonderful work! While I was reading, the HN points went up 500% and my battery fell by 50%.
- ertucetin 4y agoI saw the link to this article on Twitter and came here to double-check that it is indeed in the top 5
- duckmysick 4y agoRelevant link that I saw on HN earlier this week: someone asks people to sketch bicycles and then renders the sketches. https://www.gianlucagimini.it/portfolio-item/velocipedia/ https://www.gianlucagimini.it/portfolio-item/velocipedia/ > Little I knew this is actually a test that psychologists use to demonstrate how our brain sometimes tricks us into thinking we know something even though we don’t. > I collected hundreds of drawings, building up a collection that I think is very precious. There is an incredible diversity of new typologies emerging from these crowd-sourced and technically error-driven drawings. A single designer could not invent so many new bike designs in 100 lifetimes and this is why I look at this collection in such awe.
- sneak 4y ago> how our brain sometimes tricks us into thinking we know something even though we don’t The way I try to avoid this is to remind myself that knowing the name of something is not knowing about something, only about the existence of that something. There are lots of things I know the names of, but relatively few things I actually know about. The classic example is asking people to describe the process that causes the phases of the moon. Most (myself included the first time) describe an eclipse, which is wrong.
- jagthebeetle 4y agoWhat a great example! As a recent astronomy enthusiast, I found myself doubting this comment initially ("well, eclipses ARE related"), and this despite the fact that I have a toy tellurion right by my desk. But hearing a particular phrase in the below video helped correct my model. One sanity check is that you can see non-full moons during the day (although I definitely would have just assumed it was still a matter of angles). Related video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jip3BbZBpsM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jip3BbZBpsM
- tellurion 4y agoSide comment: This is the first time I've seen my preferred username used for its actually meaning. And I've been using it for almost 3 decades. Neat. I was going to use tellurian, which means an inhabitant of the earth, then saw that tellurion was sometimes used as an alternate spelling in an old Webster's dictionary I was looking through, and preferred it. And yes, I did search through a dictionary to find a username.
- m3kw9 4y agoSurprised that the reason the frame is hollow is for structural reason rather than to just save weight.
- NickC25 4y agoThis guy's content is seriously top notch. His recent article on Sound from a few months ago was astounding and probably the best article I've seen posted here.
- fnord77 4y agothe animation is wrong. It shows the wheel of the bike turning into the turn as the rider leans over. In reality, the wheel turns slightly away from the turn. This is called "counter steering" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countersteering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countersteering
- matsemann 4y agoAll those mechanics are explained further down. There is a whole segment in the visualizations dedicated to steering and how you steer the othet way first.
- mariopt 4y agoSuper intuitive learning physics this way
- matsemann 4y agoI wrote my master thesis on optimizing bicycle wheels / spokes. I actually see I'm cited in the phd he cites, quite a fun surprise! This is a great article. It showcases lots of the "simple, but surprisingly advanced" things surrounding bicycles. Which was what got me hooked in the first place. The visualization of how you have to turn right to go left is excellent. I've mentioned that fact multiple times here on HN, it's not commonly known, you just "do it" when you bike! And it explains why you sometimes can feel the curb "sucking" you towards it when you try to avoid it: you unconsciously avoid turning the wheel towards it, but that actually makes it so that you're unable to actually steer away from it!
- thealienthing 4y agoThat’s gotta be a cool feeling to see your work cited in other research. Kudos!
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoUnicycles have a similar counter-intuitive control method where you need to accelerate the wheel to slow down and vice versa. Turning doesn't work quite the same way though as you can do sharp turns by twisting your hips and thus changing the direction that the wheel is pointing.
- matsemann 4y agoNever thought about, but yeah I guess it makes sense. If you were to suddenly stop you would be jolted forward, so need to get a bit behind the wheel first. (too late to edit my original comment, but here is a link to my thesis discussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10410813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10410813 )
- oblak 4y agoNever heard of it. Show us this... the wheel
- QuotedForTruth 4y agoVeritasium did a great video on the opposite direction turning. They even show a bike that prevents you from turning the wheel one way to show that its essential. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cNmUNHSBac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cNmUNHSBac
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoSome (good) e-cars burn ~250Wh per mile. Humans burn something like 750Kc per hour on a bike, and go 15 miles A Wh is ~1Kc (0.8:1 but ok) That makes bikes, what, 5X more efficient?
- rconti 4y agoMy EV will do 250Wh/mile at 60mph. But it'll do a hell of a lot better at 15mph!
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis is another awesome post, although it doesn't address the one thing about bicycles I can never remember - which of the pedals has a reverse-threaded attachment to the pedal crank arm, and what's the complete force-based explanation for this necessity? I'm not even sure if the force responsible for this is friction-related, or torque related, or some combination of both (probably the latter). The force is transmitted to the chaindrive in an off-axis manner, but the pedal itself is further removed from the axis, so when you push down on the pedal axis that's ahead of the bottom bracket axis - one side will tighten clockwise from the pedal's perspective, and the other side will tighten anti-clockwise. Wow I got it right after going through this post! That's a first, though I'm still not sure I got all the forces right.
- matsemann 4y agoIntuitively I feel the right one should be reverse threaded, but I'm always mistaken. This question has the same thought process as me, and an answer https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/6488/why-are-bicycle-pedal-threads-handedness-left-on-the-left-and-right-on-the-righ https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/6488/why-are-bic...
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWhat a phenomenal explanation of forces. I wish I had this when I took my first physics class in college. I thought it was particularly excellent at explaining "how much the wall knows to push back", which is something I didn't quite grok (but just accepted) back in college: > You may wonder how the wall knows how much back-force to apply, so let’s look at the interaction between these two objects up close and in slow motion. As we apply the force, the box actually starts accelerating into to the wall, pushing its surface to the right: > As the box moves to the right, it compresses the molecules in the wall, which create a spring-like force that pushes the box back. If that force is too small to balance the pushing force, the box will continue to move to the right, which compresses the wall even more, creating an even larger push-back force.
- bilekas 4y agoOkay this is amazing. After checking the sources - I don't see any 3rd party libs.. This to my eyes looks like homegrown js (sources aren't transpiled). As a fellow cyclist I've always thought about the physics on rides, it's why changing up the gear and getting the difference feels so good, but I don't think I could ever go into this kind of detail. Beautiful creative work. Amazing effort. Top
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hyperthesis 4y agofunfact: The reason pedals are threaded in opposite directions is precession. https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Precession_(mechanical) https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Precession_(mechanical)
- xpe 4y ago> On their own, these dynamic forces exerted by the rider’s legs barely affect anything about the distribution of the ground reaction forces – one can’t make oneself heavier by just pressing harder on the ground. I'm not sure about this. Yes, static weight _is_ fixed, but a rider can vary their dynamic downforce considerably. Skilled off-road riders (i.e. mountain bikers) vary their dynamic downforce for various reasons, including traction. As always, I'm up for a discussion on this; it is possible the conventional mountain bike wisdom is a butchered version of the physics.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoI dream of building a bike with 1-2 dozen little wheels, and this frees up the design of the frame completely. Power would be given by little electric motors. The single point of failure represented by a single wheel would not be a problem anymore.
- xpe 4y agoA few observations: (1) Don't skip the textual explanations; (2) My favorite part is the wheel and spoke analysis; (3) Never stop improving your biking skills: it isn't just your legs; use your whole body! P.S. For offroad riders (i.e. mountain biking): some things to look up if you don't know them: the "attack" position; the "cockpit"; pumping; row and anti-row motions.
- ithkuil 4y ago> and even the seemingly basic idea that, for a bicycle to be self-stable, it needs to turn the handlebars into the fall, has not yet been proven. is it proven at least that "the bike needs to turn into the fall (the handlebars moving not necessarily being the cause of the bicycle turning)"?
- femto 4y agoNice. I really wanted the article to close its opening statement that "There is something delightful about riding a bicycle", by closing with the initial simulation, but with the rider embedded in an infinite procedurally generated landscape of rolling green hills and small villages.
- taneq 4y ago“To understand a bicycle, you must first understand Newtonian dynamics.”
- dirtyid 4y agoImpressive as always. Any other talent putting out this tier of projects to subscribe to?
- hanoz 4y agoI don't understand the first three-arrowed diagram with the wall. Why two pushing arrows, at the front and the back of the crate but only one pushing from the wall to the crate, seemingly unbalanced?
- bighoki288 4y ago[flagged]
- helsinki 4y agoThis article just made the global adderall shortage much worse.
- unrealp 4y agoRiding bicycle - as a skill is awkward and fascinating. It was established at very old times and so has remained. Imagine bicycles were invented today, its a product that nobody would buy. It takes lot of learning, falling, injuries, and for a lay person it looks awkward and risky. If we generalize this, we are missing out on some skills, which are awkward but which our bodies and nervous system can learn? but perhaps we are not trying to learn thinking its risky?
- fdr 4y agoNot sure if this is common knowledge by now, but one of the mind blowing things about this blogger is he writes these WebGL interactions, seemingly by hand, no framework. Like, best I can tell, keying in the vertices. See https://ciechanow.ski/js/bicycle.js https://ciechanow.ski/js/bicycle.js
- spiderfarmer 4y agoI'm always in awe of everything he produces. I read somewhere that he uses helper scripts to generate some code, but it's still all manual labor. It's breathtaking.
- motge 4y agoI'd be very interested in a meta blog post on how these awesome interactive visualizations are made!
- divan 4y agoThey are available as commentary articles on his Patreon page. Quite insightful, so feel free to give some support and access these.
- danw1979 4y agoThat might explain why he “only” does 3 or 4 articles per year. He must be typing flat out.
- Zealotux 4y agoI love his articles; the one on lenses truly helped me understand how they work at all https://ciechanow.ski/cameras-and-lenses/ https://ciechanow.ski/cameras-and-lenses/
- Yhippa 4y agoOf all the classes I had the hardest time grokking, it was physics. I really wish I had visualizations like this growing up to help me out.
- jokoon 4y agoI remember Andrew Ng saying that there is no AI that can ride a bicycle
- globular-toast 4y agoI used to like thinking about things this way. When I first started using computers I started to question how it all worked. It started with high-level and vague questions like "how does an operating system work" and as I learnt more and more it went deeper and more specific until I eventually learnt how a transistor works. That was enough for me. But as I've become older I'm less interested in it and more willing to accept things "just work". I'm pretty sure that no part of the bicycle was invented by thinking about it this way. This is kind of a reverse engineering exercise. The inventors of the bicycle just knew that if you sat on a moving wheel somehow you could balance. They knew that if you put something soft around the wheel it would feel smoother etc. Nobody was sitting there thinking about crates moving and suddenly thought, what if it was two wheels with a person on it? I don't know. Maybe it's because I already knew all of this stuff too (I'm an avid cyclist who has studied Newtonian physics). But I found this one a bit exhausting.
- alexpotato 4y ago> It may seem obvious once pointed out, but the two elliptical regions under the two tires are the only places where the bicycle interacts with the road and almost all of the rider-controlled forces have to act through them. In the book Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson, there is a quote that goes something like this: "Most cars have tires that only contact the road in an area about the size of your tongue. Hiro's car had big radial tires where the contact area was the size of a fat person's thigh."
- invpix 4y agoIs this a proof of human created quality over AI generation? Seriously though, wonderful work.
- ck2 4y agoWow I love the sliders. Now do running?! https://fellrnr.com/wiki/Running_Form#Running_Movements https://fellrnr.com/wiki/Running_Form#Running_Movements I'd love to be able to see a runner in motion like the bicycle and then use sliders to adjust legs and arm movements with physics applied correctly.
- mkluge 4y agoI think I found a minor mistake. Close to the beginning, there is a paragraph "The further away that line is from the center of mass, the easier it is for the force to rotate the object. In the following demonstration, you can apply two forces of the same magnitude to two identical boxes. The only difference is the distance to the center of mass at which these forces act:". Below that is a simulation of two boxes. If you apply the same force over the same amount of time to both boxes, the same amount of energy goes into both boxes. As one box is rotating faster, it has a higher rotational energy than the other box. As both systems (boxes) got identical amounts of energy this means, that the slower rotating box should move faster to the right because more energy goes into this movement. Becaus E_input has always to be the sum of E_forward and E_rotation. Am I wrong and why?
- mkluge 4y agoOK, already resolved in another reply. Mixed up work and force.
- starbird3000 4y agoReminds me a bit of this old 1970 article in Physics Today: The Stability of the Bicycle. https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/abs/10.1063/1.3022064 https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/abs/10.1063/1.3022064
- souvlakee 4y agoBrowser died.
- Juliandorn 4y ago[dead]
- fatih-erikli 4y agoI like what you choose as the shifters, shimano 105, which the most well functioning and one tier less expensive than the most expensive one
- Cyphase 4y agoI was messing with GPT-4 and pasted the HN front page with a prompt. In the response, it mentioned "a creative visual explanation of bicycles". Based on just the text "Bicycle (ciechanow.ski)". It really had me going for a minute until I checked the archives at the site and saw similar articles from before it's training cutoff. I asked it (with no context), 'What is "Bicycle (ciechanow.ski)" referring to?': Response: "Bicycle (ciechanow.ski)" is referring to a blog post by Bartosz Ciechanowski, a software engineer and blogger. In this particular post, titled "Bicycle", he provides an interactive, in-depth explanation and visualization of the physics and mechanics behind the bicycle, covering topics such as steering, gyroscopic effects, trail, and more. The post aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of why bicycles are stable and how they function. In a different response it volunteered the correct URL.