11 ms·
Amazon starts flagging frequently returned products that you maybe shouldn’t buy
- giantg2 4y agoOverall this is great. This might have some problems though. Some frequently returned items might not have any issues, but might be getting ripped off more. For example, I bought a warehouse deal controller. I opened the controller box and instead of a controller I found 2 bars of soap.
- ysavir 4y agoThat's true, and admittedly, there's a part of me looking for a reason to dismiss this action. But at the same time, after a decade or more of doing nothing, Amazon is doing something, so credit to them for finally making an effort. I'll still never use the site or service, but it's good to know they're finally taking some action against unethical sellers.
- dxuh 4y agoI think if I knew something like that about a product, I would also not want to buy it. Those false positives are probably fine.
- giantg2 4y agoWhy wouldn't you want to buy it new if this problem only affect the used products?
- kingforaday 4y agoAmazon's product management criteria has a threshold of (number of returns) / (number sold) within time-frames and if you hit the threshold (which is about 10% iirc), your product is automatically removed until you file an appeal. I guess that isn't sufficient enough.
- mint2 4y agoI thought clothing bought online normally had return rates far higher than that?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI order 1 size above and below what I think I will need, so I return at least 2 items for every 1 item I keep. But usually much more, I just returned 15 to 20 clothing items and kept 5.
- spetapeta 4y agohttps://archive.is/RIQwy https://archive.is/RIQwy
- blendergeek 4y agoEdit: It seems that it is easier now to see the feedback broken down by seller than when I had last used Amazon or I didn't fully understand how it worked previously. Will these be separated by seller? Last I checked there was no way to review a seller on Amazon (or if there was, it was so well hidden that a week of effort and calling customer support only got me a refund). Rather Amazon lets you review "products". Given that a "product" can differ between sellers (either because the products are of varying natural quality like with used items or because one seller straight up sells fakes and broken items), it is much more useful to review the seller than the item. Knowing that DVD copies of Jurassic Park are frequently returned (or that Jurassic Park has amazing reviews) helps me not one iota when I am buying from an unknown seller who might be sending out pirated DVDs with always-on Arabic subtitles. Until Amazon breaks down user feedback (reviews, return rate) by seller, I will continue to urge friends, family, (and everyone else) to stay away from Amazon at all costs. You just never know who you are buying from or whether they are trustworthy.
- CSMastermind 4y ago> Last I checked there was no way to review a seller on Amazon You can: https://www.amazon.com/feedback https://www.amazon.com/feedback Just only for orders that are not "Fulfillment by Amazon". Ultimately the problem is inventory comingling and Amazon not actually knowing which seller your product is from.
- dilyevsky 4y agoIt may not know when you order but surely knows when the return happens whose inventory was used
- d23 4y agoThis happens to be yet another way they end up protecting scams and their bottom line. Scammers co-mingle fake inventory, consumers get screwed, they try to review the seller negatively, and amazon removes the review because it's not the sellers fault because it was FBA. Try to post a review about the product itself being a fake? Well that's not about the product either! Removed.
- ctvo 4y agoI know other retailers are already doing this, but Amazon adopting it will force behavior change due to their size. It's possible to game listing details, product titles, brand names, and reviews. It's much harder to game customers are dissatisfied and constantly return your item. I can't wait for a bespoke service in China that will mass order a competitor's products and return them for a refund to get them tagged with this warning. Kidding aside, I'm hoping at Amazon's scale, it'll be too much of a lift for someone to attempt it.
- srmarm 4y agoI don't get they don't crack down on the product switcheroo scam [0] - it seems like a trivial problem to solve. I've reported items to them before and they don't care. [0] this product for example, loads of the reviews are for something totally different - https://www.amazon.co.uk/WERPOWER-Windscreen-Invisible-Windshield-Star-Shaped/dp/B0BTNQVRWP/ref=sr_1_5?th=1 https://www.amazon.co.uk/WERPOWER-Windscreen-Invisible-Winds...
- sofixa 4y agoHow is it trivial to solve? They either need to prevent sellers from modifying product pages (which would be a disaster because any mistakes could no longer be fixed without losing all reviews) or gate it behind human intervention(slow) /algorithm (complex). There's nothing trivial about the issue.
- yencabulator 4y agoHow often does a seller need to modify the product category from Dog toys to Electric toothbrushes? Needing to go through a review, or losing previous review juice for that seems reasonable to me.
- jjoonathan 4y agoRules + flag & review + punitive measures. If they wanted to figure it out, they would have figured it out.
- candiddevmike 4y agoDo they allow sellers to reuse an ASIN? If not, seems like they could not allow sellers to change the ASIN associated with a product page.
- tyingq 4y agoPreventing sellers from changing the UPC code would be trivial, and would tie in with other existing controls.
- dilyevsky 4y agoAre you saying that in the age of ai it’s impossible to tell whether the page is now featuring a completely new product without human review?
- oidar 4y agoOh my gosh, this is actually a huge improvement for customer-facing webpages! They used to be all about coaxing you into buying even if the product was garbage, but maybe the returns were costing them too much. I'm just wondering why they haven't gotten rid of these products altogether though. Hopefully, they keep making changes like this for other product pages too. Do you think they have any plans to tackle fake reviews or reviews for totally unrelated stuff? For example, mascara reviews on a kettlebell listing.
- gspencley 4y agoI figure returns have to cost them. What I don't understand is why they don't already do this yet, instead of "flagging", just down-rank the product when it comes to search results and recommendations. If the return threshold hits a certain level, the product gets dropped entirely.
- davidkuennen 4y agoA step into the right direction. Win for Amazon as they have to handle less returns and win for customer as he can make informed decisions.
- sebsebmc 4y agoI had this come up recently, the issue is that it seems that products with multiple "styles" will show the same alert across all "styles". The problem is that often times the "styles" may be significantly different products, in my case they were monitors with extremely different specs all from the same manufacturer.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoThis is probably not the correct use of the "styles" feature on Amazon in the first place. Maybe I'm wrong, but I'm betting Amazon would prefer items with different specs to be different listings, with styles being limited to differences like color, finish, etc.
- xen2xen1 4y agoLike how sellers on eBay throw an unrelated product in as a "style" or some such so that their listings go to the lowest price without actually selling the price you searched for the low amount? Annoys me constantly.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoYeah that’s annoying. Then I read reviews and they’re all for a wildly different product because they decided to list 10 under the same item
- dcdc123 4y agoAs long as sellers can still take a listing for one item and switch it to another with all of the stats and reviews retained this is going to have limited impact.
- mikeortman 4y agoI really wish Amazon would flag products who using images very similar to other listings. I'm tired of seeing dropshippers putting a random company logo on an alibaba listing. Leads to crap products and a poor experience.
- anaganisk 4y agoWhat do you mean Xichickenmomos USB c 65W cable is crap? It's the best product ever with 5 star ratings and 100s of orders.
- d23 4y agoAnd some people are even using them as barbecue grill plates and pet cemetery headstones! What a versatile product.
- olalonde 4y agoOn the other hand, it increases the range of available products on Amazon (at the cost of lowering the average quality). What they really need is to make those sellers easy to spot and filter out, if necessary.
- notahacker 4y agotbh I much prefer the Alibaba images which I can reverse image search to something with just enough use of cropping and watermarking to fool Amazon's filter...
- dehrmann 4y agoThese annoy me too, but they're not necessarily crap. In a sense, this is exactly what Amazon Basics is, only I trust Amazon's curation.
- crazygringo 4y agoThis is great, but another thing they really need to do is create and enforce two more rules: 1) Lister must provide all dimensions of actual product (not just packaging) 2) Photographs must show product as actual sized, not photoshopped into a stock photo environment at 3x scale Especially for home items, it's astonishing the number of items that just provide NO WAY to know what the size is. It seems like such an easy first step to reducing returns. I wouldn't have to return it if the page did a better job describing the item in the first place.
- barbazoo 4y agoThat whole specifications sections is broken for a huge subset of products.
- lostapathy 4y agoThe worst are items that are photoshopped not just into a background, but containers holding things that are the wrong scale. The other day I saw some 1.5oz shot glasses with a drink with 3 or 4 lime slices floating in them. The person editing that clearly had no idea the scale of the item they were editing in the first place.
- crazygringo 4y agoYes exactly! It baffles me so much because I could at least understand if they did it only in cases where bigger is better -- deceitful, but there's a logic to it. But nobody wants a shot glass the size of a whiskey tumbler. That's not going to drive sales of shot glasses.
- fswd 4y agoThe best one for me was a photoshop of elderly lady casually handling a 300lb pack lithium server rack battery.
- amerkhalid 4y agoAnother example[1]. We were looking for a dolphin stuffed toy under $20. My 5 years old kid saw the photo and got so excited. Correct dimensions are in the title but I didn't pay attention, unfortunately. We ordered it. He was so disappointed when he opened the box. 1: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09FJLQ866 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09FJLQ866
- amccloud 4y agoLooking at smoke detectors as they are somehow also often tampered/previously used and non-returnable because of hazardous materials in device :/
- paxys 4y agoWhy on earth are people buying stuff like smoke detectors from Amazon? Across most of the US your fire department will likely hand them out for free, and even if you have to pay you can at least be assured that someone is monitoring the supply chain and product safety. Your life isn't worth the $5 Amazon discount.
- Eisenstein 4y agoAmazon isn't really cheaper for anything (unless you count getting a Duwuu 'brand' cable instead of a reputable brand as a discount). Why do people (I?) order from amazon? 1. I don't mind taking $8 electronic devices apart and resoldering connections or doing basic troubleshooting 2. Often get a product in a day or three 3. I have no idea where I would buy a sediment filter (or similar specialized thing) that isn't walmart (and I live in a big city) 4. No need to go all around town to get things from different places (drive to the fire department for an alarm and then go to the pet store for a scratching post then go to best buy for an HDMI cable 5. They have all my details so I just click 'buy' and don't have to make a new account and deal with another retailer sending me a newsletter 6. I know that amazon will take my returns with no questions and I can drop it a few blocks away at the UPS store and I don't even have to put it in a box That said -- there are definitely lists of things I would never order from them. SD cards/thumb drives, any easily 'adulterated' food product like honey or olive oil, cosmetics, anything I want to last that isn't a specific brand that I know for a fact isn't counterfeited and is a seller...etc
- vel0city 4y agoAs for buying somewhat specialized parts I usually find retailers I trust and buy from them. For your example, I usually buy filters from AllFilters.com https://www.allfilters.com/sedimentfilters https://www.allfilters.com/sedimentfilters Or, I might buy direct from the manufacturer's parts website https://www.geapplianceparts.com/store/parts/spec/FTHPM https://www.geapplianceparts.com/store/parts/spec/FTHPM Expanding on that idea, I often buy electrical components from a retailer like Mouser or Digikey or Adafruit or others before I buy off Amazon. If I'm lucky there's some nice local retailers and I'll buy from them. There's a few local comic and game stores nearby, I'll practically always buy from them even if they're a few bucks more than Amazon for some particular item. Amazon is almost always my last retailer I go to. I've had so many bad experiences with Amazon over the last few years. The majority of Amazon orders I've had in the past 5 years ended up involving Amazon support.
- clircle 4y agoSeems like a great move for consumers, but I'm worried about how it will be automated and gamed.
- we_never_see_it 4y agoThe thing I like most about Amazon is its dedication to customers. This is a very long awaited feature and Amazon has delivered it. Amazon could have let users buy from its marketplace and make profit. Instead Amazon has made the right call and decided to protect its customers.
- atyppo 4y agoYou don’t think they were motivated by the cost of return processing and wasted fulfillment usage? All of these things are significant costs at the scale of returns that Amazon receives.
- Symbiote 4y agoI can't tell if this is sarcasm or you really belive it.
- mint2 4y agoPerhaps they’ve finally estimated the cost of having their reputation turn to shady flee market. And As the other commenters point out, this is pretty inadequate when there are 100 trivially easy other things they could do which would be even better to help consumers avoid scams but choose not to.
- criddell 4y agoI bought a $50 item and a couple of weeks later I received a letter in the mail offering me a $35 Amazon gift card if I leave a 5-star review with a video or picture attached. I'm surprised Amazon allows these kinds of bribes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mbreese 4y agoThey don't, but it's hard to crack down on. The only way for Amazon to know is if the people who get the gift card notify Amazon, which isn't likely to happen. Here's a story about how Amazon banned a popular battery/charger maker because of the same thing you're talking about. (I have one of their batteries... it was pretty good too). https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/16/22536976/amazon-ravpower-battery-charger-removed-amazon https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/16/22536976/amazon-ravpower-...
- SkyPuncher 4y agoIt'd be far easier if Amazon didn't provide my contact information to sellers (unless they're large enough to be "trustworthy")
- chihuahua 4y agoUnless it's FBA (fulfilment by Amazon), it's difficult for the seller to send you the item you ordered, unless Amazon gives them your address as part of the ordering process.
- aftbit 4y agoI have actually tried to report this to Amazon customer support a number of times. Most of the time, the CS agent either entirely does not understand what I am complaining about, or openly says this is allowed. Last time they told me I would only get the gift card after I left a 5 star review, and to chat back if I did not get it!
- 4y ago
- haunter 4y agoThe craziest scam I saw on Amazon was ordering an expensive GPU > people change the card's backplate and return a cheaper/broken one. Unsuspecting regular Joe will order the returned GPU ("open box deal!") and they get a fake one. And now you have to fight against the Amazon customer service too. It's incredible. Amazon is basically a "premium" Wish/Aliexpress nowadays. Might as well I order from China becuase I at least _willingly know_ getting a fake.
- joering2 4y agoI like getting products I order online delivered overnight. And return them for free by dropping off at local UPS with my money back in less than 48 hours. Can Wish/Aliexpress do the same?
- redox99 4y ago> people change the card's backplate and return a cheaper/broken one People really have to ruin everything
- coffeebeqn 4y agoI wonder do they ban people’s accounts for doing such things? That’s basically theft
- bogwog 4y agoI think the term is "mail fraud", and it's very illegal
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIs it mail fraud if it does not go via USPS?
- jamincan 4y agoThe wiki page on mail fraud quotes the definition and it would seem to include the USPS as well as any private/commercial carrier crossing state borders.
- padjo 4y agoIf they think maybe I shouldn't buy a product maybe they shouldn't be selling it in the first place?
- FrameworkFred 4y agowhatever, too little too late. amazon wouldn't accept my bad review on a $12 beer faucet adapter with a thread pattern that made it 100% useless. I'm done with them.
- captainkrtek 4y agoI’ve given up on Amazon shopping years ago. I much prefer to buy things directly from specific retailers, eg: outdoor gear from an outdoor retailer, clothes directly from the brand, etc. This has resulted in never having to return anything, not rolling the dice on product legitimacy, and pretty great customer service who is knowledgable of the products.
- bob1029 4y agoI hope that others can find a path too. I worry for some friends & family who seem properly addicted to the idea that stuff can magically appear on their doorstep within 24-48 hours. I know some who receive multiple shipments from all 3 major carriers every single day. Just the slightest amount of planning ahead would prevent the need for the kind of retail model they provide. Everything about Amazon is intended to increase the amount of time you spend with Amazon. The 50% chance of broken crap keeps you coming back to their support center, with all sorts of dark patterns designed to send you right back into their store again.
- barbazoo 4y agoIt's nice if you have local business that actually know their products. Especially with outdoor/sports equipment. I know I'm paying a premium but I happily do it. Electronics on the other hand, sure I'll try to go to bestbuy for stuff because that's the only electronics store we have that's close but they have no clue about the products they're selling.
- verteu 4y agoI would, but it's such a hassle to enter my address and CC info on every manufacturer's site. The last 3 things I bought were shaving cream, toothbrush heads, and a cheap tennis racket. Do I really want to signup/purchase/unsubscribe-from-spam for a Proraso account, a Philips Sonicare account, and a Wilson account? Perhaps Google Pay could add a useful layer here.
- abruzzi 4y agomost of the online places I shop at allow account-less purchasing using PayPal. I know PayPal has some negatives as well, but those rarely impact buyers. Probably 95% of my online shopping passes through PayPal, though I do maintain accounts at a few online shops like B&H or KEH and with them I usually use direct CC/DC purchasing.
- waltbosz 4y agoWould this new policy create a new attack vector for scammer sellers trying to damage the reputation of good legitimate sellers. The scammer would organize a distributed buy-and-return of their victim's product, which would trigger this flag. It's complex, but if returns are free and the competitive advantage of the flag is worth it, I could imagine it happening.
- carimura 4y agoya that's the problem, every action has a reaction in the new world order of massive marketplaces. It would seem like there needs to be more buyer focus on the sellers reputation rather than the product.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoThere are other products on Amazon you should probably not buy either. Namely, products from randomly named companies, or companies that claim to be American but it their address is a warehouse and their Internet presence is hosted on Alibaba Cloud. Most of what they sell is toxic, like PVC figures for children cakes, toxic kitchenware, counterfeit refrigerator filters and other magnets for penny pinchers. It is almost as if they were intentionally trying to poison people. Most of the furniture sold by Chinese vendors and their intermediaries are so toxic that fucking HCHO meters max out when you open the box. Including kids furniture. Sneaky fucks should all go to jail. I would much rather prefer buying products from countries with real customer protection, real compliance with regulations with real consequences when someone gets sick from a non-compliant product.
- stackedinserter 4y ago> It is almost as if they were intentionally trying to poison people. This, this, this. Just look at what are dollar stores selling us. To me it looks like China packs their garbage in form of children toys and useless things like so called "squishees" that smell like they fished right out a toxic river. Story time: my wife tried to import toys from EU, high quality wooden building blocks. I remember that regulatory hell, she needed to have a safety certificate for each SKU, they have to pass lab tests for phthalates, lead and other shit, there was a never ending list of requirements, like "you can't have this rope because it's strangulation hazard". And after you comply to all that regulations, you need to buy a business insurance to even have a chance to get into chains. So we have piles of paperwork for good products and seemingly completely unregulated Dollarama that sells whatever they want without following any rules. "This SKU doesn't explode before leaving a store – it's good to go". We need a law that would obligate sellers to accept their garbage back, including packaging (looking at you, Costco).
- 29athrowaway 4y agoMost returned stuff goes to a warehouse and then gets destroyed. You can buy pallets of that stuff for a reduced price.
- GartzenDeHaes 4y agoIt seems that this would just flag Amazon as an unsafe place to buy anything valuable. For example, if someone buys a GTX 4090 and receives a GTX 3070, will Amazon will flag the 4090 as a frequently returned item? https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/11q8mjw/i_got_a_4090_but_its_showing_up_as_a_3070ti_fresh/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/11q8mjw/i_got...
- carimura 4y agoExploitable marketplaces just seem to be seesawing back and forth between those closing exploits and those finding new ones. Anything that gets massive these days seems to get into this stage because of the profit incentive on both sides. I wonder if there's data on whether the general "arc of progress" is going in the right direction? I go back and forth depending on the day. Personally I've just established my own rules of the road to avoid the bad side, like deleting Facebook and all social other than Twitter, using browser extensions in Twitter to filter out trending stuff, and being very careful and methodical about purchasing from Amazon including avoiding almost everything isn't a reputable company that I can do a simple background check on. I've even been fooled here but it's generally pretty easy to figure out.
- twawaaay 4y agoI think we know why products are frequently returned. 1) Because some people just want to try stuff out at no cost. 2) Because some people made impulse buy. 3) Because some sellers sell defective/scammy stuff. Now, the issue is Amazon will not tell you which category this is. You still have to rely on user reviews which still are yet another field of abuse. I just don't think this move will change anything, only cause potential confusion.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoThey need to just ban random sellers. It should be an exclusive site.
- mabbo 4y agoThere is a famous story about Customer Obsession and returns that I used to tell during training sessions for new Amazon employees- Customer Obsession 101, which I was a teacher for. Jeff is in a call center for a day shadowing a customer support agent. A customer calls about a specific item and the CS agent is like "They're going to say it's broken in this particular manner" before the call even starts. Jeff later is like "How did you know?" and the agent says "Because this is like the tenth time I've had calls about this". There was some problem in the warehouse that kept breaking the item in the same way, but what can a CS agent do about that? File a ticket that no one reads? So Amazon introduced an 'Andon button' that let CS agents stop sales of a given product if they keep seeing the same problem. Customer Obsession! Crazy idea to empower entry-level people to have such impact! Only Amazon would do something like that! Anyways, that Amazon is dead, "Day 1" is long gone, and unless the item is a standard product of low value I personally do not shop there anymore.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoI am intrigued that such a button is superior to having someone read the tickets.
- owenmarshall 4y agoAndon is a manufacturing concept. It’s a button that, when triggered, stops the manufacturing line. You push it when things are systemically broken, and it has massive consequences because it costs companies meaningful cash. I can’t see how disabling sales of a single product is equivalent either.
- pjsg 4y agoI heard Jeff tell this story and it was about a dining table that often arrived with a gouge in the top surface. It was costing Amazon a lot to ship, and a lot to get it returned, and the table was essentially worthless when returned. Even if only 5% of the tables are returned, this makes selling this table a loss maker. Quickest way to increase profits -- stop doing things that make you a loss!
- macspoofing 4y agoHow long until this is gamed?
- londons_explore 4y agoI just hate the amazon empire, so whenever I have no option but to buy something I give an opposite review. If the product is decent, it gets 1 star and a scathing review. If it's shit, I give a glowing 5 star review.
- dgs_sgd 4y agohow is that helpful in any way?
- master-lincoln 4y agoIt makes Amazon an even worse place, which I assume is wanted by OP so Amazon dies.
- crazygringo 4y agoSo you mislead other buyers? That's not hurting Amazon, it's hurting regular people.
- 99_00 4y agoI only buy hard to find niche things on Amazon or low quality Chinese bootlegs when that's what I want. For everything else I buy elsewhere. It's usually a difference of cents. I'm voting with my dollars for a world where people can choose to not buy low quality jficushnrkf brand Chinese bootlegs.
- version_five 4y agoOne one hand this seems like a good thing, though it's really just a band-aid for what a low-quality bargain bin amazon has become. I see other comments about being able to dig into reviews by seller and whatnot. I don't want to have to do research like that to buy normal consumer crap. Some might, and that's cool, but I'm sad that any semblance of a curated experience is gone and it's basically just a street corner bazaar where you can't trust anything. It's interesting to me that amazon, facebook and google, (netflix I'm on the fence about and apple no) have practiced a kind of scorched earth capitalism where they made a lot of money and presumably continue to, but effectively destroyed the environment they operate in. I think most agree that google has hollowed out search into an SEO optimized ad-filled content farm wasteland. Amazon is doing exactly the same thing with retail, they're the biggest name and they've basically created this layer of garbage as the base layer of e-commerce.
- jwally 4y agoWhile the idea of anonymizing product reviews might seem a tad idealistic, it could potentially reduce the prevalence of paid reviews. By concealing the identities of verified purchasers, it becomes more challenging for manufacturers to verify if their paid reviewers have indeed submitted their reviews. This approach may serve as a deterrent for unethical marketing practices, promoting a more honest review ecosystem.
- asciimov 4y agoI have been on a tear lately returning numerous Amazon orders. Often due to incorrect descriptions or being sent broken items. A recent "favorite" of mine was while trying to order a keyboard wrist rest, the first one arrived folded(!) up into a small plastic sack. The next had a very harsh smell, and the last, before I gave up, was uncomfortable to use. I've started to miss malls and the variety of electronics stores we used to have, just so I can pick up and see the physical item before I buy it. It's kinda sad that in the late-90's the small city I grew up in had more electronics stores than the metro I live in today.
- GrinningFool 4y agoI wonder if there's an opportunity here for comparison shopping showcase stores. They carry no inventory, only samples that you can get your hands on. Scan to find the best price, and tap to add to your cart from the site and seller with that price. Gets delivered. You'd make money via a membership fee, referral sales, and a tiny bit from direct sale of the display items once it's time to swap them out. The up front cost and rapid turnover of supplier inventory would probably make this a no-go. Not to mention that there are so many /things/ available, even a costco-sized warehouse packed for maximum number of display items would require extreme selectivity (and associated costs for research, etc)
- asciimov 4y agoI imagine there is opportunity, but it's gonna be for a big company like Amazon, and essentially be a modern Sears. A place where you can go in and buy now, get it if it's there otherwise it's delivered.
- alex_young 4y agoIf they can detect this stuff well enough to put a warning on the products, maybe they should just remove the listing until the seller does something to fix whatever problem they have?
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoIncentives which are misaligned from the customer's point of viewpoint.
- squarefoot 4y agoApparently, some people order stuff just to show them on social media, or even use them in monetized videos just before returning them. The service has been already abused to death; I would push for a badge to flag users who return too many items.
- ei8ths 4y agoMy go to for shopping is amazon -> walmart (in store only lookup) -> then local stores. And it depends on what i want, if i need a guarantee its a legit item, then i'll go to the vendor site and look up where they sell the product and get a direct link, or if its tech related and i need a guarantee then bestbuy or whatever the vendor says is their link to buy. I do walmart for price comparison and convenience, i live really close to a walmart. Amazon is like other have said more like aliexpress these days, my returns this past few year have gone way up because the items either break quickly or were garbage out of the box.
- pessimizer 4y agoHave they considered not selling products that people shouldn't buy? Works for Walmart.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoThat's funny, I bought the exact record player shown in that article, and it was indeed broken. Very high wow-and-flutter, a horrible scraping noise whenever the tonearm moved, and the clamp that was supposed to hold the tonearm in place during shipping was missing, so it was just flapping around freely inside the box. I did indeed return it.
- pcamen 4y agoOne thing I have seen mentioned yet is this change from the perspective of honest sellers. Amazon customers are notorious for not bothering to read the listings and because of the generous return policy for FBA items, will just buy something to see if it works. I also sell on my own website and don't have any of that type of problem, but my return policy is not quite so generous. So me, as an FBA seller has certain products that I've specifically added "DOES NOT FIT XXX YYY" and people buy it and then return it with the comment "DIDN'T WORK on my XXX YYY". I get enough of these stupid returns and Amazon suspends my listing, making my go through a contrition process telling them all the things I've done to remedy the excessive returns. I've got one very popular product, my best seller, that has gone through this 5 or 6 times in the last few years. While I understand the perspective of fraudulent listings swapping in sub-standard products, the big improvement I am hoping for is that the warnings will actually get people to read the damn listing so they understand what the item isn't to be used for.
- SCUSKU 4y agoI've seen a few of these in the wild just as a consumer and I always wonder why people even bother leaving a review. My thought is you're just exposing to everyone how ignorant you are.
- Acutulus 4y agoOf the (generally) many things those specific types of consumers are ignorant about, their own ignorance is usually one of them. Whereas I read "Unsatisfied! I did not read the listing!", they feel they wrote "Unsatisfied! Seller did not explain the item in the listing!" to the benefit of the other consumers in their same category. In a perverse way I could see it actually curbing those unwanted purchases in the future, but sadly at the expense of the seller.
- core-utility 4y agoI'm somewhat guilty of this, but a lot of it comes down to Amazon's search. I'll search for "iPhone 13 case" and then window-shop with pictures. I get the case and realize that even though I searched for iPhone 13, it sent me to a product for the iPhone 14 and I didn't realize until I bought it.
- codeulike 4y agoI've posted this before but I'll do it again because it really highlights how unfriendly buying things at amazon has become, slowly over time as meanwhile we barely noticed, like frogs being slowly boiled in water... What Shopping On Amazon Feels Like - Ryan George https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQpxAvjD_30 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQpxAvjD_30 "roll the dice"
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoThis is what has driven me away from Amazon, except for purchases of name-brand specific things. I go to brick and mortar to browse, because they simply won't carry rubbish to begin with. It's not a function of buyer beware. Amazon outsources its returns entirely, so they are not incentivized to reduce it. Best Buy has to pay people to deal with it, so they strive for it not to be a problem in the first place. They do the curation, and it turns out, yes, there is actual value in that service, and our incentives are aligned.
- mattfrommars 4y agoLooking forward to the day Amazon decide to remove the option to return and have the cost to return Removed as well. This move will be a pro environment as well as it will make us do more research before buying and once item is in our hand, try to make it last as much as we can.
- bktkech 4y agoTinder/Hinge/Bumble should do the same.
- illumin8 4y agoRecently I’ve been having trouble with a few batches of cheap LED lights that were “Amazon’s choice” and advertised as having 23 year lifespan (3 hours per day) that died within 6-12 months. Amazon tells me I’m outside of the normal 30 day return window, but I’ve just complained and said “If I bought a bulb at Costco advertised as 23 year lifespan that died after only a year I’d return it and they’d refund me, no questions asked.” This usually gets a store credit from the customer service person. I think Amazon is going to have a huge problem with this because they’ve clearly been selling a lot of low quality merchandise from China (it’s actually marketplace sellers listing the products so quality is a race to the bottom). Because they don’t have any quality checks in their sourcing like other big box retailers do (such as Costco and Target) they just aren’t equipped to handle the inevitable returns and class action lawsuits that are coming their way when the 23 year lifespan LEDs and other product categories fail just outside the return window.
- rapjr9 4y agoNow on to the rest of the problems with Amazon's web site. Do a search on "canned shrimp" and then select "Sort by: Avg. Customer Review". I see seven pages of results, none of which include any canned shrimp even though it is obvious they sell canned shrimp from the page before you sort by customer reviews. https://www.amazon.com/s?k=canned+shrimp&s=review-rank&crid=1IL55AX941DLV&qid=1680062107&sprefix=canned+shrimp%2Caps%2C154&ref=sr_st_review-rank&ds=v1%3ASvKaKHZ3r1EXjs0XpfR%2BKgtuvwF%2BqNbJqAUV2qWqpoY https://www.amazon.com/s?k=canned+shrimp&s=review-rank&crid=... Also, since any search now includes randomly added items, when you sort by customer reviews all the higher rated things that do not match your search are listed first. The items you are actually interested in may not show up until several pages later. You also cannot sort by customer review AND number of reviews. The Amazon search engine is seriously broken and seems to keep getting worse in my experience.