18 ms·
The TikTok ban is a betrayal of the open internet
- rvz 4y agoFirstly, the Verge is trash source, no better than the Daily Mail in their reporting alongside their affiliate marketing grifting with clickbait. Secondly, a better solution is a multi-billion dollar fine for TikTok's egregious invasion of privacy and the like, worse than the other tech companies and they also got massive fines. Either TikTok pays a multi-billion dollar in the US or they exit the US market. This is much better than a ban and a win-win-win for TikTok, US gov. / regulators and the users and the ball is in TikTok's court.
- fsdaklj32 4y agoThe threat is the CCP using TikTok for algorithm-directed propaganda, extortion based on video history, and anything else you can imagine. A one-time fine doesn't fix that, and you can't get the oversight to make sure consumer data is protected because you're dealing with a state actor. But maybe you're thinking of some sort of recurring fine, like a "Sell Americans As A Service?" SAAAS? Innovations like that could help with the national deficit.
- rvz 4y agoIt can be recurring for repeat offences. Still spanning in the billions.
- Jochim 4y ago> Secondly, a better solution is a multi-billion dollar fine for TikTok's egregious invasion of privacy and the like, worse than the other tech companies and they also got massive fines. Where is the evidence that TikTok has been much worse than their peers in this regard?
- rvz 4y agoIf you watched the congressional hearing, the evidence of this was already presented here [0] and here [1]. [0] https://futurism.com/tiktok-spy-locations-specific-americans https://futurism.com/tiktok-spy-locations-specific-americans [1] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-tapes-us-user-data-china-bytedance-access https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/emilybakerwhite/tiktok-... Could not have been more clearer and is worse than the rest of the US social networks.
- insomagent 4y agoThe congressional hearing was hilarious. I thought the TikTok CEO did great, and the vast majority of questions Congress asked were pants-on-head ridiculous. They are so out of touch.
- Jochim 4y agoTo be honest it sounds like you've only read the titles of those articles. Your Futurism article directly contradicts the claim that any of this behaviour is unique to TikTok: > This isn't the first time that a major social platform has been caught spying on specific individuals. In the past, Facebook and Uber have both been in the hot seat for tracking the locations of journalists and political figures. The byline of your June 2022 Buzzfeed article implies that TikTok was already actively working to remove foreign access to the data: > an external auditor hired to help TikTok close off Chinese access to sensitive information, like Americans’ birthdays and phone numbers. This largely appears to have born out based on the PBS article regarding the recent congressional hearing[0]: > As of October (2022), all new U.S. user data was being stored inside the country. The company started deleting all historic U.S. user data from non-Oracle servers this month, in a process expected to be completed this year, Chew said. > access to U.S. data is managed by U.S. employees through a separate entity called TikTok U.S. Data Security, which is run independently of ByteDance and monitored by outside observers. The hearing itself was mostly evidence of how unfit many of your elected officials are for office. From a previous comment of mine: > Buddy Carter confidently believes that TikTok is tracking it's users emotional response through pupil dilation but has no comprehension of why you'd need to identify someone's eyes to put a motion tracking filter over them[2]. According to Mr. Carter, TikTok isn't doing enough to protect younger users but thinks that asking a user their age and checking whether or not the users public videos align with the age they declared is "creepy". > Dan Crenshaw used his time to state that Chinese law requires it's citizens to co-operate with their national intelligence agencies. That might have been a good point if not for the fact that TikTok's CEO, the person Crenshaw was questioning, is not Chinese. > Richard Hudson proved himself unable of forming a coherent question as to whether TikTok attempts to access other devices on a WiFi network. Instead asking "So if I have a TikTok app on my phone and my phone is on my home WiFi network, does TikTok access that network?" [0] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/watch-live-tiktok-ceo-testifies-before-house-committee-over-security-concerns-connection-to-china https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/watch-live-tiktok-ceo-... [1] https://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/25/tech/tiktok-user-reaction-hearing https://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/25/tech/tiktok-user-reaction... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sZDpJHl6amo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sZDpJHl6amo
- mantas 4y agoChina is a betrayal to open internet. And West's BigTech oligopoly. TikTok ban would be a tiny fix for both. Maybe a good starting step...?
- sovietmudkipz 4y agoSomething I find odd is the focus on “data security” in basically all media coverage and politician statements. Is that what’s at issue, or is it the influence the CCP has over people through tik tok? Securing customer data isn’t really what’s at issue… It’s the fact that the CCP have one algorithm for its own people that pushes and popularizes science, economics, and other good subjects but for other countries like the USA it’s basically the polar opposite. Data security is a red herring. The true danger is that the CCP and business are one and the same, the CCP is in a Cold War with the USA, and the CCP will do whatever it can to gain any advantage it.
- mistermann 4y ago> Something I find odd is the focus on “data security” in basically alal media coverage and politician statements. Is that what’s at issue, or is it the influence the CCP has over people through tik tok? Notice, for the sake of high level rationalism, that this is a false dichotomy. CCP influence over TikTok is a subset of the bigger problems: - TikTok, or the medium it operates on, is extremely persuasive, it's the most potent way to spread ideas from one mind to another (for example: the beliefs you hold about China's intents, which you do not actually possess knowledge of). - The US government does not have a means to exert control over it like the other social media giants. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_medium_is_the_message https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_medium_is_the_message
- andrekandre 4y ago> it's the most potent way to spread ideas from one mind to another even more than facebook? any studies/links about that?
- mistermann 4y ago> even more than facebook? Well, consider the capabilities of the two platforms, as well as the demographics of users, and so forth and so on. > any studies/links about that? Not that I know of, but I have a feeling these discussions have been held at very high levels of the government and various 3 letter agencies, resulting in the mass theatrical spectacle we saw in Congress the other day.....did you watch any of that? Is it not blatantly obvious that in this case, "democracy" is an illusion?
- leric 4y ago[dead]
- andy_ppp 4y agoI don't understand why China is allowed to have web products in our markets but we don't seem to be allowed Google, Facebook, WhatsApp etc. in theirs. We need to just make it a fair playing field and if they want to have software startups on the Internet and in App Stores they need to open their markets to our products too.
- troad 4y ago> I don't understand why China is allowed to have web products in our markets but we don't seem to be allowed Google, Facebook, WhatsApp etc. in theirs. Because we're a democracy with free speech and open markets, and China is not? Banning foreign speech and competition is not the victory for our way of life that some people seem to think it is. There is a problem with TikTok - like ALL social media it uses opaque ranking algorithms that serve nefarious interests, and like ALL social media it spies ruthlessly on its users. How about we address those issues, thereby indirectly resolving the TikTok issue too?
- andy_ppp 4y agoThere's no such thing as a free market, regulations are everywhere. One such regulation that I think is perfectly reasonable is that if you want to sell us things we need to be able to sell you things. This is largely true with hardware (e.g. Apple, Tesla sell into China just fine) but most software companies and especially social media have been outlawed. Just because we are a democracy with different values to the CCP does not mean we should be taken for fools.
- ROTMetro 4y agoBut we aren't banning foreign speech, we are banning a foreign platform for information dissemination. I don't see anyone promoting not allowing Chinese citizen's posts to be viewable in the USA. That is what banning foreign speech would look like.
- max51 4y agoIf you don't like how the chinese government operate, you probably should not want your government to imitate everything they do.
- cabirum 4y agoThe US can not tolerate competition. Tiktok gained audience and market share because it happened to be a better product in its niche. Inventing any excuses to ban it is unadulterated hypocrisy. All the words like "censorship", "free", "CCP", "national security", "china bad" are just euphemisms for childish protectionism of an oversized ego.
- unethical_ban 4y agoThey made a better opium that happens to also track and read the minds of users. Some of us think all social media is trash for the mind and society, and think it's doubleplusungood when a hostile foreign power controls the algo. You're implying that I root for Instagram. That's not the angle.
- wpasc 4y agoLet's say TikTok was the same exact company founded in another country, do you believe that the conversation about banning it would be the same? With some exceptions (maybe Russia, for example), I seriously doubt it.
- BlackjackCF 4y agoOk. Why can’t we use Google and Facebook in China again? Ah yes, because China can totally tolerate competition.
- none_to_remain 4y ago[flagged]
- the_third_wave 4y agoI never saw publications like The Verge proclaiming that e.g. the ban of Parler was a betrayal of the open internet. Either the term open internet is to be interpreted as the internet which reflects my ideology or (to paraphrase a term made popular in the early days of the public internet) my way or no digital highway or there is just not enough money to be had from tiny players like the aforementioned Parler. No matter what it is it does not bode well for these TikTok-astroturfers. Checking Wikipedia's Perennial Sources list [1] I notice that The Verge is listed as 'green' with a green checkmark, i.e. 'reliable': There is broad consensus that The Verge is a reliable source for use in articles relating to technology, science, and automobiles.. Here reliable probably serves the same function as open in the title of this thread, i.e. that which follows my ideology. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Perennial_sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Per...
- synergy20 4y agofrom another perspective: open internet does not live in a vacuum. and the world is not perfect. China has banned so many US applications starting more than one decade ago. a free and open platform only works when all players in general are following similar rules, if a few big players exploit the system and you do not act about it, you're a fool and doomed. One example is that, you're rich and liberal and you feel for the poor, that does not mean you will share your luxury house with them or pay more tax voluntarily, point is that, there is never a pure open internet, and there is no pure anything, everything has a limit.
- boomlinde 4y agoSince the sudden apparent concern for users' privacy IMO casts doubt on the intent, I think discussion on this issue should start with determining whether we should take those concerns at face value. Is there a legitimate concern for privacy or is it just another form of economic warfare? Are the governments protecting you as an individual or are they protecting FAANG? There is little point in discussing this if we are all just pretending that it is an issue that it's not.
- _chu1 4y ago"We need to ban TikTok to protect users and the open internet!" 1 year later "Keeping a service owned by the CCP that spies on people in hostile countries and purposefully feeds them garbage and incorrect information is against the open internet!"
- lakomen 4y agoExactly this
- toss1 4y agoThe entire premise is backwards. TikTok (and other surveillance apps) are what is the betrayal of the open internet. Banning TikTok alone will not fix it. But, it is a good start. Banning everything from China would be a better start, considering the insane asymmetry the CCP enforces on everything, and the degree to which they consistently and systematically lie, cheat, spy, and steal from their trading "partners" in order to gain military advantage (and no, don't start with the false equivalency about US companies' surveillance capitalism; although it is also evil, it isn't even close to proportional). Yes, we've got to fix all of the exploitative surveillance, but banning technology seeded by another nation-state actor like CCP because of it's both data harvesting and asymmetric warfare capabilities does not threaten the open internet. And certainly, since CCP has banned most US technology because they won't do their dirty work of surveilling and spreading disinformation in their population, banning all CCP tech (which is all China tech) in response is a good step.
- imiric 4y agoExactly. Most people don't realize that this isn't about free speech and banning some harmless meme videos, but about information warfare and protecting American citizens from hostile aggression. In the age of social media, information has been weaponized to an alarming extent, with the power to influence masses, incite violence and topple governments. Those Russian troll farms and Chinese bots and CCP shills aren't just doing this for the lulz; they're paid agents working for a government who's found that the easiest and cheapest way to harm your enemy is via the same channels they've built and opened for everyone to use. The East and West have been at war for decades now, and these operations no longer require sophisticated IT knowledge and expensive hackers; they only need thousands of agents willing to spread disinformation and propaganda on the internet. This sows division and panic, which eventually causes societies to crumble from the inside out. There's no doubt in my mind that the mass hysteria we've seen in the past decade has been stirred in part by foreign agents. I encourage everyone to watch this interview of a former KGB agent[1]. He explains the power of psyops and information warfare. This was well known and in widespread use in the 1980s. Imagine how sophisticated these operations have become today with the internet. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ol0M6P9LLY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Ol0M6P9LLY
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- tinus_hn 4y agoThe open internet is a mirage. There used to be barriers against distributing encryption, there’s bans for copyright violations, there’s blocks for adult imagery and revolutionary (‘terrorist’) speech. There is no such thing as a truly ‘open’ internet and the real internet is open enough that any constructed really open network will be overrun by content no one wants to host, like racist extremism and pedophilia.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- e63f67dd-065b 4y agoMy personal approval of TikTok ban efforts is based on a more nuanced view: yes TikTok is not currently nefarious, but in the event of conflict with China, it will almost certainly be an outlet of CCP propoganda beamed straight into the US, and that is exactly when banning it would be the most politically contentious. Better to ban it now and not when the CCP uses it to influence domestic politics, at which point the optics of banning TikTok will come with the optics of banning political speech.
- uc_banana 4y agoIt turns out, the "open internet" is, in general, a terrible idea. Edit: I'm serious. From a national and personal security perspective, as unpalatable as it is, China has the right idea - what sane country allows any stranger from anywhere in the world detailed access to any of their citizens' thoughts and decision making processes?
- johnwheeler 4y agoI own Meta stock, but that’s not why I want the ban. I want the ban because they ban our anchor platforms. They do that not because of propaganda like everyone says. They do it for long term economic advantage. The more the world relies on Chinese infrastructure, the more they rule the world. The US wants to keep ruling the world. I’m on the side of the U.S. not because I’m patriotic so much as I live here, and I’m rational.
- lakomen 4y ago[flagged]
- tw1984 4y ago> Someone at Tiktok decided that I had to receive this kind of content, no matter what, because of my age and location and sex probably. They were pushing an agenda. love your conspiracy theory
- lakomen 4y agoIt's not a conspiracy theory. Also why was this truthful post flagged? Who flagged it and why?
- t-writescode 4y agoFriendly reminder that the TikTok ban is actually the Restrict Act, and that is a much larger, more aggressive and powerful piece of legislation that's being pushed through than just a "TikTok Ban": https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/686/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/686...
- concernedsoft 4y agoIt's pretty scary. I wrote down some thoughts on this with regard to general purpose computing: https://concernedsoftwareuser.github.io/software-freedom/ https://concernedsoftwareuser.github.io/software-freedom/
- jhallenworld 4y agoThe latest enemies list: (i) the People’s Republic of China, including the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region and Macao Special Administrative Region; (ii) the Republic of Cuba; (iii) the Islamic Republic of Iran; (iv) the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea; (v) the Russian Federation; and (vi) the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela under the regime of Nicolás Maduro Moros.
- t-writescode 4y agoTo add, sections 9 and 10 read to me (very paraphrased) "Any telecom, etc, product where someone in the parent post's list has partial ownership, including voting stocks and has >= 1 million users" So, that includes a lot of video games (Genshin Impact, League of Legends, Gunfire Reborn, etc) and also Reddit and Epic Games, maybe? I'm sure an argument would be made that since the CEO of Telegram was born in Russia, it would count, too, somehow. Edit: whoever downvoted the above comment, that's literally section 8B Addendum: I'm not a lawyer, I'm just a layperson trying to read this thing.
- aaroninsf 4y agoThe titular claim is not the problem. The problem is that an open internet is incompatible with [the politics of] the world we live in. In that world, state and other actors seek to use contemporary surveillance data to drive sentiment and behavior in targeted populations. To put it directly, we (the US) are engaged in memetic warfare both internally and externally. Tik Tok is correctly being singled out as a singularly powerful platform for surveillance of and control of Americans by a state rival. Should we come to war (e.g. over Taiwan) hot or cold, it's not viable to have a Tik Tok and its well-publicized ability to determine what goes viral, in the hands of the foe. This is at heart a conflict between aspirational principles which are incompatible with the reality of human nature and the tools we have built as force multipliers. This is unfortunate. Much is.
- tempodox 4y agoI don't think it's a betrayal of the open internet to be non-open to mass-murdering despots.
- t-writescode 4y agoShall we ban every single company that has owns a voting-sized stock amount of Tencent, too? ( read the RESTRICT Act. That's my layperson read of what it says. I'm not a lawyer. )
- tempodox 4y agoI have no sympathy for supporters of the Chinese surveillance and propaganda apparatus.
- blindriver 4y agoBanning TikTok is a completely rational thing to do, given the control that the CCP has over the app. We can't poison our minds with letting China control the algorithm and affect hundreds of millions of Americans. We aren't talking about a company motivated by money, it's motivated by power and control. It is 100% a national security threat. We should absolutely ban it, the same way China bans Instagram, Facebook, Google, etc for the same reasons: national security threat. And I personally love TikTok, I'm active on it for a couple of hours a day, but I know that it's a threat.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- s3p 4y agoBanning TikTok is not the point. The point is about stopping the bill congress is creating to enforce the ban.
- nicbou 4y agoFrom a European perspective, I don't see TikTok as any different from American platforms. America has been caught spying on other countries and interfering with democracies before.
- abirch 4y agoCompletely fair. Why not ban both?
- livelielife 4y agocounterpoint: why instead not ban anything? why ban at all? or did you mean why not ban TikTok AND america?? hmmm that's a more interesting proposition
- abirch 4y agoBan CCP spyware and US spyware. I'm not sure of a country I'd trust with my data, maybe a Swiss company.
- rglover 4y agoIt's been said elsewhere in here but I'm going to parrot because this caught me by surprise and this is on the level of importance of the SOPA [1] craziness back in 2012. The TikTok ban has very little do with TikTok. It's yet another Patriot Act (now, the Restrict Act [2]) style back door to slip in some seriously heinous legislation that could find you fined to the tune of millions, or worse, thrown in jail for 20 years. > A person who willfully commits, willfully attempts to commit, or willfully conspires to commit, or aids or abets in the commission of an unlawful act described in subsection (a) shall, upon conviction, be fined not more than $1,000,000, or if a natural person, may be imprisoned for not more than 20 years, or both. I do view TikTok as a covert military campaign (ideological subversion) and do think it should be limited in the West, however, not via this bill. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fgh2dFngFsg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fgh2dFngFsg [2] https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/686/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/686...
- rglover 4y agoFor those interested, the important stuff can be found in the bill on these pages: 1, 10-22, 32, 36-46, 50-52.
- Terretta 4y agoUnless you're making apps that run on one of the named platform types, you don't have to worry. No need to be interested unless you develop for: ... [critical infra] ... ... [telecom / internet] ... ... [services] ... ... [IoT anyone uses] ... ... [unmanned vehicles] ... ... [apps] ... ... [anything important] ...
- 411111111111111 4y agoSo the people that create and maintain the foss libraries such as SQLite and libcurl should worry and you think that's okay?
- mtrovo 4y ago
- didip 4y agoI never use TikTok, but banning it seems fair game. China banned a lot of apps made in the US.
- abirch 4y agoThey banned them because they knew the US Government would probably use the data, either by asking the companies nicely or by using NSA.
- jhallenworld 4y agoI'm subscribing to TYT's view on this: they want to ban TikTok because it gets young people to vote. The CCP angle is just a good excuse. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQK1LAtRh7Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQK1LAtRh7Y Republicans hate it because they lost both the president and the senate by thin margins due to, arguably, too many young people deciding to vote. You would think Democrats would welcome more young voters, but only a few do (AOC is one..), because they are corporate democrats and don't really want young people to vote in primaries. Mainstream media will be on board since they don't want another competitor.
- Miner49er 4y agoIsn't this backwards? AOC is against the TikTok ban and benefits the most from young people voting.
- Gunnerhead 4y agoIsn’t that what OP said?
- spamlettuce 4y agoThis is weak take
- colpabar 4y agoI do not understand how anyone can listen to cenk uygur for more than 30 seconds and believe he is worth listening to. He sounds like an emotional teenager who just got into leftist politics and wants to stick it to his conservative parents. I do enjoy compilations of him freaking out though.
- jhallenworld 4y agoWho would you suggest as the voice of reason?
- colpabar 4y ago
- adventured 4y agoThe premise that the Internet is open or was ever open, is fairly absurd given the actual history in question. It started out nation state controlled (ie restricted), and the core difference between then and now is that those controls have become highly localized down to a given nation (and often entirely localized; versus the US previously having dominant control over much of the whole of the Internet). To argue it's a betrayal of the open Internet, is the same as pretending that somehow nations weren't going to apply their real-world laws, beliefs, economic or political restrictions on the Internet space just as they do in their physical space. Whether we're talking about moral/religious type matters, basic speech issues, human rights issues, commerce/trade, and so on. The Europeans often think the US is crazy for having something reasonably close to true free speech. There must be restrictions they'll proclaim. Britain has far tighter controls over offending public officials online for example. No open Internet for the Europeans? They'll universally disagree with the premise. To make that argument, you have to say that every single localized control over the Internet is a betrayal of the open Internet. And even if I agree that that is true, good luck, because it's going to get dramatically worse over the next decade (and all 50 US states are likely to get further into the regulation party). Morally the US should ban TikTok just on economic reasons alone, in response to China not allowing various foreign competing products into the country (in the social media category in this case). Not just ban it in the US, we should lobby for its economic wipeout across all spheres in which the US has economic influence. The US is in a severe confrontation with China (economically, politically, culturally, etc), and it's only in the 2nd or 3rd inning, there's no sense in pretending at this juncture. That confrontation ends, one way or another, in Taiwan.
- d_sem 4y agoI think comedian and recent guest-host of The Daily Show, Al Franken summarized it best: "We don't need a Chinese company stealing our data and spying on us. That's a job for American companies. USA! USA! USA!" Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zps3gz0krC4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zps3gz0krC4
- 29athrowaway 4y agoThe people at Verge should interview of the victims of the dangerous TikTok challenges such as the ones that have killed people or left them disabled for life. They should also should condemn the controversial content such as questionable dance videos from underage teenagers. And how depressed teenagers are as a result of using TikTok and Instagram. Or how the entire thing is run by the CCP. But of course they don't care about any of that. Even during a time where CCP is invading US airspace.
- glonq 4y agoI had presumed that the tiktok ban was simply "we only want companies that are domestic or from allied countries to monitor and manipulate US citizens" ...which kind of makes sense given how easy it is for a social media platform to deliberately influence peoples' thoughts and feelings.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zactato 4y agoWhat are all the teens/20 yos going to do when they wake up one morning and TikTok is turned off? I’m not saying that TikTok or other social media is great, but it would certainly be an interesting social experiment to suddenly force millions of kids to go cold Turkey on something that they’re addicted to. Maybe they’ll turn to other social media, maybe they’ll start painting, maybe they’ll burn down a city.
- exolymph 4y agoIf it goes through, they'll just use Instagram Stories and Reels instead. Possibly also Snapchat.
- djha-skin 4y agoTikTok is not the open internet. IRC, self-hosted blogs, the fediverse -- that is the open internet. Banning a walled garden is "fair game" as far as I'm concerned. They excercise controll over their users but don't like it when they're controlled.
- lazyeye 4y agoAll the people here desperately trying to find some argument in favor of an absurdly one-sided relationship in China's favour. Silicon Valley truly is the enemy.
- Miner49er 4y agoWhat? The people here defending TikTok (myself included) are probably more likely to not be fans of Silicon Valley. Why wouldn't Silicon Valley support the ban? It gives them back their monopoly over Americans' data.
- lazyeye 4y agoI think they feel more threatened by any kind of regulation, regardless of the target.
- brodouevencode 4y agoSome points to consider: 1. TikTok has a "heat" button. It can make anyone go viral. This is not uncommon to other platforms artificially boosting some content, but this is much more deliberate than the other methods. https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2023/01/20/tiktoks-secret-heating-button-can-make-anyone-go-viral/?sh=5027ed9e6bfd https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2023/01/20/tik... 2. Persuasion is two things: exposure and frequency. The native way that TikTok works allows for this to happen easily. Imagine a tool that is very good at this being controlled by a government that is hostile to most of the rest of the world. 3. The idea of the open internet was based on actors working in good faith. The CCP does not do this (the Great Firewall of China). 4. Bytedance (TikTok's parent company, and directly controlled by the CCP) has donated substantial amounts of money to various US-based political caucuses.
- cardosof 4y agoI'm against a TikTok ban and here's why: if user-level data collection and fingerprinting are wrong, ban that. If algorithms to show certain things for certain people are wrong, then ban that too. If a company being owned by a foreign entity who is a "frenemy" at the eyes of the military, then sure, ban it. If US social networks are banned in country X, then ban X's social networks in the US. Again, that's Ok. But those are rules made for any company in any place, not just TikTok. Just banning TikTok now seems more like making some convenient excuses for doing what some folks already wanted to do anyway as soon as TikTok started getting their cookies and slices of ad revenue and media relevancy.
- FredPret 4y agoThe CCP control of TikTok is a betrayal of the open internet
- babypuncher 4y agoBanning TikTok won't fix anything unless you also ban Facebook, Instagram, etc. If you make the underlying data collection practices illegal, then TikTok will stop being a problem.
- jtode 4y agoNothing corporate and capitalist like TT has a whit to do with the open internet. Siddown.
- stametseater 4y agoThe betrayal occurred when American tech companies assisted the CCP in creating their national firewall, creating an imbalance in the information war which has yet to be redressed.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoIs forcing the sale a betrayal of the open internet? Do keep in mind that the US forced the sale of Grindr away from a holding company that had golden shares in an actively homophobic regime.
- lucasyvas 4y agoTikTok is a proprietary piece of mental malware driven by a malicious state actor - it has nothing to do with the open Internet.
- hzhou321 4y agoThe ban is not having an issue between China and US. US can do whatever to China, and only need balance potential retaliation. There is no moral debate between countries, just power play. The ban is an issue between US government/politicians and US people. There are some nominal moral contract between the government and people, and the ban need to be justified and satisfied by people's moral belief, such as open internet. Without sufficient moral justification, people's trust against the government is at risk.
- swalling 4y agoThis is a key example of the paradox of tolerance (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance) Saying we should tolerate the influence of a totalitarian state over a major communication platform (https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/10/21/more-americans-are-getting-news-on-tiktok-bucking-the-trend-on-other-social-media-sites/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/10/21/more-americ...) in the name of the First Amendment and democratic values is setting up our democracy to be weakened and fragmented even more than it already is. We already know that domestically-controlled networks like Facebook directly contributed to electing a demagogue President who tried to disrupt the peaceful transition of power. We'd be morons to accept the same thing but under the influence of an autocratic country which has clear intentions to erode American influence and power.
- sourcecodeplz 4y agoBan fentanyl first.
- reassembled 4y agoThe whole “ban TikTok” saga reminds me of the South Park episode “Chinpokomon”, where the Japanese were getting Americans hooked on a parody of Pokémon because of their not-so-subtle designs on taking over the world.
- mynonameaccount 4y agoOpen internet in this case is a one way street. How many times has China banned apps?
- pwndByDeath 4y agoOr perhaps we can take responsibly for ourselves and not use the ridiculous platform
- zephrx1111 4y agoOn the opposite, banning TikTok is to maintain the openness of the internet. Like Nassim Taleb puts: we should not let the Most Intolerant win.
- hakfoo 4y agoI wish our leadership would be more direct about their intentions. Don't dance around with claims of 'national security' and 'spying' and 'protect the children' which seem to always lack vital details on how they expect to use their technological foothold to... mobilize 82 million screen-obsessed teenagers to march across the Pacific and take back Taiwan? Don't propose bullshit "well, they could keep operating if they just..." standards that you either aren't going to honor, or are inherently unfulfillable. It's farce in the same vein as expecting Saddam Hussein to turn over the WMDs. Just tell us "the fix is in, we have no interest in actually getting to a mutually agreeable consensus." Then we can ask exactly why. Is it a single casualty as part of a long-term strategy of antagonizing a new Cold War with China? Or is it a smaller game-- responding because American social-media companies are butthurt that they can't capture TikTok's appeal?
- deepcyanide 4y agoIf you parrot "tiktok bad, china bad" in response to any pushback then you're hopeless and/or one of warner/thune's paid shills for the restrict act. We need privacy legislation that affects all sites not just tiktok. If you care so much about america then stop helping corrupt politicians turn it into the so-very-hated-china.
- fennecfoxy 4y agoBy that logic isn't the requirement for sites to use SSL (for security/safety reasons) otherwise a huge warning/blocking page is displayed also a "betrayal of the open internet?" Is having a password on my wifi a betrayal of the open net? Me having a firewall/nat? Let the devices be freeeee
- jdubz79 4y agoFuck the CCP. Straight up. The planet needs nothing from them. They do no good.
- retox 4y agoI find it rather alarming that, at least in my social circles, those defending TikTok tend to overlap with those people alarmed at the operations by Russian 'troll farms' on Facebook during the US presidential elections.
- laughingman2 4y agoCan't unseen the amount of double negatives in this article.
- ekianjo 4y agoFunny, the Verge did not complain as much when Parler was taken down in concert in the matter of 2 days. So much for defending the "open internet".
- deafpolygon 4y agoFollow the money.
- titaniumtown 4y agoParler was taken down because the companies that hosted their services no longer wished to because of the content on the platform. This is complete incomparable with a piece of legislation.
- gopiandcode 4y agoTo be fair, the distinction here is about actions by a government, versus actions by private entities. Opposition to the government banning a website does not necessarily mean that you would oppose private companies refusing to provide service to a bad actor.
- none_to_remain 4y agoThe distinction Verge used was that of "friend" and "enemy"
- prohobo 4y agoAt the behest of the government, no doubt. The Twitter Files show that the real situation is a lot more messy. Large internet "infrastructure" businesses are in partnership with government officials, so I have no reason to believe that the Parler takedown was anything but political censorship. Maybe not technically, but definitely in spirit and effect - and after all, that's all that really matters.
- charcircuit 4y agoThe internet is largely made up of private companies. If Comcast decides to not route traffic to you there is nothing you can do. Private companies are the ones who decide if the internet is open or closed. The government can influence these companies behaviour, but companies technically can do what they want.
- ChocoluvH 4y agoThere's no such thing as open internet
- mathverse 4y agoI see no reason to give China access to Western markets if we cant do the same with our IT companies.
- jiggawatts 4y agoPeople don't realise how ridiculously asymmetric the relationship between China and the rest of the world is. Spin up a cloud VM in China now. Go do it. Try. I can, literally in minutes, go create a virtual machine hosting a web site in some random middle eastern country I probably would not visit because they're anti... everything. Anti-female, anti-christian, anti-gay, anti-freedom, anti everything I hold dear. But I can create a virtual machine there, right now, no problems. China? Hah... no. That would require paperwork, in person, in chinese, paid for in renminbi, from a Chinese bank. I'd have to get a chinese id, and submit it to a police station to get an authorisation number, which I would then have to display on every page of that web server. Chinese companies can spin up whatever they want in any country they please. Every other country has to sign up to Chinese censorship laws to publish anything at all on that side of the Great Firewall.
- seydor 4y agoIn return for that china allowed the world to export its pollution and manufacturing . Those are trade-offs
- stanislavb 4y agoThis! Until China is fully open and non-totalitarian, they don't have any right to complain.
- dathinab 4y agoThere is a simple solution. _put up proper user protecting rules by law and enforce them fairly against any company_ it's simple, fair, and would either ban TickTock due to non compliance or cripple it's ability to do whatever they are afraid of it doing the problem is the US Government isn't against the things TickTock is doing, it's only against them being done under Chinese control
- mistermann 4y agoThis assumes that the government is sincere in its complaint that their concern is about user's data. I think that's cover for what they're really concerned about: user's beliefs. TikTok is arguably the most powerful means to spread ideas, and people in that line of business do not appreciate outsiders on their turf. The whole TikTok thing itself seems like a distraction from the contents of the bill they've drafted under the guise of only banning TikTok. Democracy as it is is a giant magic trick, and TikTok is pulling back the curtains in it, so it must go.
- creato 4y ago> This assumes that the government is sincere in its complaint that their concern is about user's data. I watched the hearing. The main concern voiced is manipulation of content by the CCP. User data is what cranky HN users care about.
- andrekandre 4y ago> The main concern voiced is manipulation of content by the CCP in what way has the content being manipulated?
- creato 4y agoI don’t know if it has been, and it would be extremely difficult to prove one way or the other. But the potential is obvious. China already heavily manipulates content for domestic consumption, and foreign information in other contexts. Why would TikTok be an exception?
- lm28469 4y ago> The claims that TikTok will become a covert Chinese Communist Party (CCP) propaganda channel are similarly possible but hypothetical. Isn't the claim the opposite ? tiktok china (douyin) is all about propaganda, education, tech, nationalism, success, &c. while the international version is dumb challenges, addictive content, memes &co > Douyin vs TikTok also differs in terms of popular content. The most popular on Douyin is definitely educational content, with videos helping to improve skills and grow personally, while on Tik Tok the most popular is narrating videos, which is a great opportunity for artists, singers, and music producers. Therefore, global TikTok is more art-based, with musicians, dancers, and so on, while Douyin is skills and lifestyle-tips-based, with automatic voiceovers with no personal touch. https://marketingtochina.com/differences-between-tiktok-and-douyin/ https://marketingtochina.com/differences-between-tiktok-and-... > “It’s almost like they recognize that technology is influencing kids’ development, and they make their domestic version a spinach version of TikTok, while they ship the opium version to the rest of the world,” Tristan Harris, a former Google employee, and advocate for social media ethics, said of China’s approach to TikTok. https://www.deseret.com/2022/11/24/23467181/difference-between-tik-tok-in-china-and-the-us https://www.deseret.com/2022/11/24/23467181/difference-betwe...
- Reimersholme 4y ago[dead]
- Jochim 4y agoI get almost no music or dance based content on TikTok. It's algorithm almost exclusively returns videos on topics I'm interested in. Usually a mix of politics, science, cooking, crafts, cat, and couples content. The simple explanation as to why content popularity varies across countries seems to be that there are cultural differences at play. Frankly, it feels like a lot of people are simply uncomfortable with seeing their cultural values reflected back at them.
- capableweb 4y agoI have no hate for TikTok, I'm sure it's useful for many. But I tend to get quickly bored of echo-chambers (HN included sometimes), where if I like some content, doesn't mean I just want to see content like that. I need to "reset" my history of YouTube sometimes after I "spend" watching 3-4 videos of some topic, and now my YouTube is overrun with just content related to that, instead of different topics. TikTok is guilty of the same, where after using it for a week or two, I basically see no other content than content related to a couple of videos I watched longer than others. I liked how the internet was before, where I stumbled upon content wildly different from each other, and could acquire new tastes, instead of just being served what the algorithm have decided I should surely forever like.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cosmin800 4y agoand theverge is serving the CCP
- Eumenes 4y agoThe open internet died a long time ago