7 ms·
Whether this is a reasonable law or not, my big problem with it is that it puts the burden of enforcement on tech platforms rather than the kids' parents. There
by paxys 4y ago
Whether this is a reasonable law or not, my big problem with it is that it puts the burden of enforcement on tech platforms rather than the kids' parents. There is no way for any company to check for something like this without also affecting every other user of the site, whether they are in Utah or not and whether they are a teen or not. What do they do exactly, start collecting government IDs from us before every visit?
- taylodl 4y agoCall their bluff - don’t make your service available in Utah.
- ars 4y agoThat would be nice wouldn't it - mental health would improve so much.
- MBCook 4y agoHonestly this seems like the best idea. You can’t get accused of letting a kid access outside approved hours if you don’t allow people in Utah on. What about adults? They may be lying kids. So either no access (safer) or strict age checks involving checking licenses and stuff. But that’s expensive. No Utah is easier. How do you know they’re in Utah? IP addresses. Blocks people outside Utah? Sorry, our lawyers made us do this. Complain to your reps that Utah is messing with your state’s citizens. VPNs? Maybe gotta block that too. Utah is not a big state. The social networks could easily use this to try to “teach a lesson”. Just say you’ll let Utahans back in when their government makes a foolproof age verification system. And wait. I don’t necessarily disagree with the intent of the law, it just seems unenforceable/unimplementable, as usual. No benefit to the social networks but huge legal downsides.
- meghan_rain 4y agoLmao imagine Utah becoming the most mentally healthy region on earth, suicide rates plummeting, productivity up 300%, people spending time with parents and grandparents again? record sign ups in sports clubs, record birth rates etc. Be careful what you wish for ;-)
- paxys 4y agoIf the state has total control over every aspect of their citizens' lives they can model the population into any perfect utopia they desire. I'd still not like to live in that world.
- barbazoo 4y agoIsn't this the opposite though? They're not telling people how to live their lives. They're taking away the power Facebook has over many people's lives so people might enjoy their lives in more social and healthy ways again.
- staunton 4y ago"any legislation restricting behavior actually frees people to do what they always wanted (the government knows best what that is) but just couldn't because of all these other possibilities misguiding them"
- throwaway290 4y ago"there should be no laws against tobacco, alcohol, drug abuse, gambling because people can't possibly be misguided by powerful corporate interests for profit or otherwise"
- staunton 4y agoThat's not what I said. There is a balance to be found. I only objected to "this restriction actually makes everyone free (to do what I think they should)" being used as an argument. If enough people agree, sure, you can ban social media. The reasoning should be a cost benefit analysis though, not "my laws shall make you free".
- syklep 4y agoSoftware Developer is the most common job in Utah, it's kind of surprising this happened despite that.
- Jensson 4y agoSoftware developers are more anti tech than most.
- monksy 4y agoIt's not surprising at all for Utah. That is a highly Mormon run state that has strong stances on how you should live your life. Even if you are a "goi" (I use the word loosely to illustrate the cultural metaphor in a us v them mentality) to them. What is amazing is that they have this strong stance on how to restrictively govern the people inside their borders, but yet expect to have a western lifestyle support them. More organizations should stand up and say "I'll pass" in a blanket ban on them.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- yeahsure22 4y ago[dead]
- smooth_remmy 4y ago> That is a highly Mormon run state that has strong stances on how you should live your life. Even if you are a "goi" (I use the word loosely to illustrate the cultural metaphor in a us v them mentality) to them. I think you're crossing a line here. You are accusing the Mormons in Utah of having a us-versus-them mentality. But your own comment tries to turn readers against Mormons. Never forget: The Missouri Executive Order 44, also known as the Mormon Extermination Order, was issued on October 27, 1838, by Governor Lilburn Boggs. The order authorized the expulsion of Mormons from the state and is sometimes referred to as the "Mormon Kill Law". However, the order was rescinded by Governor Christopher S. "Kit" Bond in 1976. I think we should all be more charitable to Mormons after what they've been through.
- ryankshaw 4y agoI live in Utah. If that's what happens, that would be awesome! "Sorry kids, no fb/tiktok/insta and there's nothing I can do about it. None of them work where we live" Would be a huge win for all parents. No social media, and we don't have to be the bad guys taking it away.
- arpowers 4y agoYa would be awesome
- sbrother 4y agoAnother Utahn here and I feel the same. I don’t really see how this could work and think it will probably go away quietly, but I’d kind of love it if these platforms (and the social pressure our kids feel to be on them) just went away.
- Buttons840 4y agoIs love to see Instagram, etc, replaced with a static site in Utah asking people to vote for better leaders.
- seandoe 4y agoUtahn with two young kids, yes please!!
- veec_cas_tant 4y agoHopefully this is hyperbole. Seems a bit extreme to hope the government legislates away industries because you don't want to handle the parenting yourself.
- acover 4y agoYou have to show id to buy cigarettes. How hard is it to id people before account creation?
- veec_cas_tant 4y ago
- jfengel 4y agoThat is the goal. It's not a bluff. The kids are just an excuse.
- kerpotgh 4y ago[dead]
- bdw5204 4y agoThe solution is actually simpler than that. Just shut down any company operations in Utah, refuse to accept any payments from users with Utah addresses and require all of your employees that are located in Utah to relocate. But people in Utah can continue using the service. It's also quite possible that this law gets thrown out as unconstitutional by the federal courts since it seems similar to the California video game censorship law from Brown v. EMA.
- dumbotron 4y agoRemember the time Facebook blocked news in Australia?
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoOr be a company based outside the US. "Your laws, your problem: my government doesn't care"
- wrineha2 4y ago> What do they do exactly, start collecting government IDs from us before every visit? That’s the idea actually.
- throwaway5959 4y agoSubmit thumb for verification.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoI would say that anonymity on social media currently has a serious, real-world price to pay. Teen girls and Instagram don’t mix - the numbers reporting depression and suicidal thoughts since it took off is heartbreaking. They made us wear masks due to a threat to our physical health. Social media is currently having extremely acute effects on the mental health of a generation. It may have reached the point that losing anonymity and requiring ID is better than suicides and depression. At this point, if you look at the numbers, it’s like claiming the government is infringing your rights to buy alcohol anonymously. We should stop pretending that mental health damage is of lower priority than physical health. (And don’t get me started about the parents - outside of SV, only a few percent even know parental controls exist, let alone how to use them effectively without loopholes.)
- prawn 4y agoIs anonymity the key issue for your example of Instagram and teen girls? I'd guess that a lot of the pressures come from their peers and professional users who are quite openly using their own identity.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoCyberstalkers use phony IDs. Consider the case of the mother who harassed her own daughter last year.
- prawn 4y agoI would suggest that those cases are a minor issue and the major negative pressure comes from general interaction with peers (whose names they know) or comparing themselves and their lives to professional social media users (almost always openly using their name).
- heavyset_go 4y ago> I would say that anonymity on social media currently has a serious, real-world price to pay. Teen girls and Instagram don’t mix - the numbers reporting depression and suicidal thoughts since it took off is heartbreaking. I wouldn't say that anonymity is the problem here, but rather that social media sites are crafted to abuse the psychology of their users for attention, engagement, ad impressions etc. It isn't a given that social media has to make teens depressed. If the psychologists and researchers that are hired by these companies to hone in on engagement were instead were paid to make their platforms less psychologically harmful, we could see better results. Hell, platforms have the potential to improve people's lives if they were optimized for those outcomes. Civil and criminal liability could be introduced to social media operators to ensure that their products aren't causing harm, as well. Incentives to achieve those results can come from legislation and the judicial system.
- bparsons 4y agoYou could say the same thing about cigarette and alcohol sales.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoThose have been solved by requiring ID. Personally, I find online storage of my ID to be a lot less acceptable than a bored teenager giving it a 2 second glance while I'm picking up beer.
- MBCook 4y agoID checks are far easier in person than over the internet.
- nonethewiser 4y agoCredit card.
- kxrm 4y agoWhy not require an ID to own a smart phone? Seems far more realistic to set up regulation around smart phone ownership than to require businesses outside of your state to check IDs.
- nonethewiser 4y agoWhich are illegal to minors.
- ars 4y ago> it puts the burden of enforcement on tech platforms rather than the kids' parents What else do you expect? When tech companies make phones secure enough for the NSA, every app has passwords, and most apps have disappearing messages, how exactly do you expect parents to monitor what their kids are doing? All the "parental monitoring" apps do is check how much time kids are using the phone. They give zero info on what the kids are actually doing. So tell me, you want to put the onus on the parents? OK, then require any app used by kids to make all messages available to parents, and forbid disappearing messages. You don't want to do that? Well, then don't say: "parents you watch them". You can't simultaneously make something someone else's responsibility, and also make it impossible for them to do it.
- MarkSweep 4y agoI’m not really sure if I disagree with you, but in the past we’re parents really able to see everything their children were doing? Like telephones did not record conversations, they were effectively “disappearing messages”. I guess the argument would be technology enables children to do secret stuff without any of the obvious signs, like sneaking out in the middle of the night?
- ars 4y agoTelephones did not record, but they did have a log of incoming and outgoing numbers. So it was possible to check if a child was suddenly talking to someone new. > I guess the argument would be technology enables children to do secret stuff without any of the obvious signs, like sneaking out in the middle of the night? Yes, it was rather obvious when a teen was behaving secretive, or there were middle of the night calls. Privacy is important, but if your teen was suddenly displaying secretive behavior you could tell.
- watwut 4y agoOf course they were not able to see everything kids do. They were not able to track kids movements via app either. Parents have huge amount of control that was impossible in the past now. They also lost some control, if you lived in ideologically segregated community, kids had no way to learn about ideas from outside. That was destroyed by internet. Your Utah Mormon kid can read pre LBGT materials now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ShamelessC 4y agoThat is precisely the solution. Tech platforms are far more culpable than parents in this matter. If that means your startup idea no longer scales - good riddance.
- judge2020 4y ago> If that means your startup idea no longer scales - good riddance. And if that means no startup can possibly compete against the existing players in the industry that have the bandwidth and resources to implement the regulation?
- raincole 4y agoAfter reading this thread I realized that's exactly what people (in this thread) want. They want "the old internet" back, whatever it means. Of course it means no more startup. Startups change things and we don't want that! We want the exact internet from 1998.
- BigJono 4y agoI don't know why they want the "old internet" in a thread talking about protecting children lol. When I was 13 I was playing CS 1.6 on dedicated servers with a small number of strangers that were like 30, I was also on I don't even know how many random forums with small numbers of users. It's like a 13 year old hanging out at some random adult's house vs walking around a mall. I can't see how a bill limiting access to websites with more than 5M users is going to reduce paedophilia.
- ShamelessC 4y ago> And if that means no startup can possibly compete against the existing players in the industry that have the bandwidth and resources to implement the regulation? I think starting a tech startup under a VC model is a high-risk, high-reward setup and that your idea should be strong enough to withstand regulations such as this, yeah. There has been a lot of false innovation lately and it has soured my view on the model. I think it also hurts the incumbents, even though they get a moat of sorts. But only a moat around "tracking teenagers for advertising data".
- nonethewiser 4y agoAbsurd objection. Tech platforms are obviously the only ones capable of moderating their users at an application level. Should we remove content filters on YouTube and ask parents to filter content instead?
- somethingreen 4y agoJust use BankID/GovID/whatever verified OAuth service and request a single age/date of birth data point once. No need to authenticate or store anything.
- japhib 4y agoFor exactly this reason, there is no way this law will stand in court
- sacnoradhq 4y agoUtah's political system, and by virtue, judiciary, is run by LDS. Don't consider anything rational will necessarily prevail when powered by magical thinking.