7 ms·
Why buying furniture is so miserable
- CalRobert 4y agoIt seems fine to me?
- aabajian 4y agoI came to the same conclusion. The article explains why small-scale U.S. furniture businesses must court designers, and the customers who employ them. It explains essentially what we all know: You can't build furniture at-scale with U.S. wages. I'd be curious to know how a robotic factory for mass-producing furniture would be able to compete with overseas salaries.
- jonstewart 4y agoYou can’t build -cheap- furniture at scale with US wages. It is only relatively recently that furniture became cheap. Historically it was expensive, and it was built to last, and it was handed down between generations. Furniture-as-fashion is a fantastic way to go broke, and hugely wasteful.
- midoridensha 4y agoFurniture in the old days was like cars: a way to show off. (Rich) people would have their guests tour their homes so they could show off all the expensive, hand-made custom furniture.
- linuxftw 4y agoYou absolutely can build competitive furniture products at US wages. Companies that outsource overseas might only be seeing a 5% greater margin, but it's enough to move production because that's money that goes straight to the executives.
- Workaccount2 4y agoI don't know about furniture, but in my industry where we have mechanical and electronic stuff built both domestically and in china, the difference in pricing is _insane_. It's not uncommon for things to be a difference of 10x, or 1000% more expensive to be built in the US. And it's not like these shops in the US are swimming in cash. The infrastructure (for manufacturing) sucks and the labor is much more expensive. And frankly the quality has been slipping a lot too, Chinese stuff is now often overall better quality at a fraction the cost. Perhaps if you are a megacorp and can arrange economical supply lines and leverage economies of scale, you can get down to small differences. But for small to medium production runs, China is just so overwhelmingly dominant.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI, too, just buy Ikea and used turn-of-the-(20th)-century furniture (I'd prefer mid-century, but so would everyone else, so it's too expensive). The stuff at other major chain furniture stores, or sold at Wal-Mart or Target (or Big Lots, as in the article), is indeed so low-quality that it's basically just a scam. Usually ugly as sin for no good reason, too.
- ajkjk 4y agoYou might have different (er, lower) standards for quality.
- CalRobert 4y agoI suppose. I'm on an Ikea couch right now and happy with it. My wife built our hutch, floor to ceiling bookcase, etc out of planed white deal (spruce) and I like it. A kreg jig and mitre saw do wonders.
- BigCryo 4y agoWhy support global capitalism by buying their overpriced furniture anyway? I get free furniture off Craigslist anytime I want it
- Tagbert 4y agoSounds like you are still supporting that global capitalism just second-hand and on the cheap.
- trgn 4y agoGetting something for free from some rando not wanting to bother with emptying their apartment does not really fit into my mental model of capitalism.
- convolvatron 4y agothis might sound socialist. but the truth is the stuff you get for free is generally older and higher quality. so in the spirit of competition - why wouldn't you optimize for quality and price
- programmarchy 4y agoDon't let the bedbugs bite.
- felipemnoa 4y agoIt is a real concern. I imagine you could heat treat the furniture to be safe.
- BigCryo 4y agoI sometimes wonder whether the bedbug scare is a psyop by Big Furniture
- idopmstuff 4y agoI don't understand why a lot of people go through the sort of run-around described in many of these articles. If you order furniture and it doesn't show up on time, you give them a hard deadline of a week or so to get it to you or give you a refund. If they don't cooperate, you charge it back on your credit card. If you order furniture and it shows up damaged/missing pieces/broken/etc., you call them once and tell them to make it right. If they don't immediately give an acceptable response, you tell them that they'll make it right or you'll charge it back. If they don't make it right, you charge it back. The only thing you have to keep in mind is the 60 day limit that most CCs have on chargebacks. Since furniture sometimes takes a while to be delivered, you just need to be sure to initiate the chargeback on day 59 if there are any issues remaining. You can always withdraw it, but as soon as that clock runs out, your leverage is gone (you can still go to court, but the threat of a chargeback is a better one because it's so easy for you to do any costs nothing).
- convolvatron 4y agoare you claiming the system is working just fine...we just have to spend some amount of our lives combating overt fraud and just sucking up the general level of poor quality that isn't strictly fraudulent I'm checking out. you enjoy that.
- Klinky 4y agoI think he's saying consumers need to actually hold sellers accountable for not following through. Though this is arguably one of the biggest reasons market capitalism often gives us poor results. People tolerate too much, are gullible, and/or have too little time/money to hold business accountable.
- mistrial9 4y agoDeterimined commercial abusers know how to delay, lie and deflect . It is a daily occurrence.
- idopmstuff 4y agoWhat is the alternative you're suggesting. I'm saying that it is inevitable in life that when dealing with businesses, you'll end up in bad situations. It sucks, but the point is that you have relatively straightforward recourse, which is good. I encourage you to try to improve the whole system, but I don't know how to do that, so I'll use the tools I have.
- StrangeATractor 4y agoThe cost of curtains for non-standard sized windows is insane too. I just bought canvas and I'm hand-stitching my own. All the materials needed for a dozen windows, including the tools, comes out to less than two curtains made by somebody else. As a bonus, you get to learn a neat skill that carries over to other things. For reference: https://www.theartfulsailor.com/catalogue/the-sailmakers-apprentice https://www.theartfulsailor.com/catalogue/the-sailmakers-app...
- nonethewiser 4y agoSame for blinds. Priced something out recently for 1 square window and it was $400.
- jedberg 4y agoI don't like to shill companies here, but I've used these guys a few times: https://www.selectblinds.com/ https://www.selectblinds.com/ They custom cut everything so odd shaped windows don't add a lot of cost, they quality is good, and they do in fact honor their warranty. I had someone destroy a blind and they still replaced it under warranty!
- nonethewiser 4y agoDefinitely glad you shared
- midoridensha 4y agoThis begs the question: why are the windows non-standard sizes to begin with? As with most other things, a lot of problems are avoided by sticking with standards.
- StrangeATractor 4y agoThey were old and the builder got them for free from someone. I'd rather have these tbh, adds character.
- bell-cot 4y agoVs. the Good Old Days... I'm currently using an ~80-year-old bedroom set. It's been moved ~7 times, and is still rock solid. It ain't new, nor trendy, nor did I ever get the thrill of shopping & buying exactly what I wanted - it's a hand-me-down from an aunt & uncle (who were born ~1895, if I recall). Back in the day, that's what families did with good furniture. Physically, I'd guess that my bedroom set would be good for another 120 years or so. But since the younger generations, these days, are mostly set on buying all-new stuff for themselves, no matter the quality...
- bobthepanda 4y agoPart of what's changed, is that moving out of multigenerational households has become the norm in the US. Can't take mom and dad's furniture while they still need it.
- yunwal 4y agoThe younger generations are absolutely not set on buying all-new stuff. Go in a thrift store and nearly everyone shopping there is younger than 35. Craigslist is much more popular among younger people. The reason younger people end up buying shitty, disposable furniture is because they can't afford houses.
- fetus8 4y agoI am not sure about your idea here, I'm under 35, own my home, and insist on buying second hand furniture for vastly different reasons. I scour craiglist, thrift stores, and my local flea markets for vintage furniture, and have almost entirely furnished my small 2 bedroom house over the last 6 years. A big part of this simply deals with build quality and real wood. I know furniture built before 1980 tends to be real wood, and I'd much rather have solid wood construction over particle board nonsense that won't last 10 years. My searching and insistence has required a lot of patience, but it's ultimately been worth it for me. My holy grail was a 1970's Danish Teak dining room table (w/ 8 chairs!) that someone locally was selling for $800. Anything modern that's of comparable quality would easily be well above $2500. As of now, almost everything in my house is from the 1960/70s, and made of real wood. I'm willing to spend the money on these things instead of junk from Wayfair.
- renewiltord 4y agoIs it just that the same high quality costs more, but that cheaper is available and people are price-sensitive? It wasn't obvious from the article but I got a few paragraphs in until the US-made graph and stopped there because it was a lot of human interest stuff and I couldn't extract value.
- IgorPartola 4y agoIt’s miserable because the price of furniture is actually quite high but availability of furniture-like products at places like Wayfair and Overstock makes you think it can be had for less. I recently had to fix a small two seat couch I bought, so I turned it over and it was entirely built out of plywood and staples. It was such a poor design that I can’t imagine why it cost $450. But to be fair, a good quality couch of that same look would cost me about 7-10x as much which I wasn’t willing to spend so…
- jstarfish 4y agoEverything at "Rooms to Go" is built this way now. Didn't used to be, so we returned as customers. The front cross-beam on a $1000+ couch of ours split in half within a few months.
- joshspankit 4y agoThe front cross-beam? The single most structurally-important part in the couch? That is telling.
- inconceivable 4y agoi'd imagine at least half of that is shipping and handling and import duties. tack on retailer margin and that seems about right. couches don't exactly flat-pack. i do a lot of sleeping on my couches so i've always had extremely sturdy units, even when i was sort of poor. i went from extremely cheap ikea metal frame futons to a pretty legitimate solid wood couch when i got my first job.
- wheelinsupial 4y agoI think a lot of it is margin. There is a furniture company where I live that advertises a 45% off as an employee discount perk. I’ve seen employee discounts usually priced at cost plus 5%.
- einpoklum 4y agoMy problem - and that of many - with buying furniture is that of _precarity_. If I knew I would be living in the same apartment or house for the rest of my life, or at least several decades - I would take the time and spend the money to get high-quality, long-lasting items. But - I don't own a home; tenants have close to zero rights in most places I've lived; my job isn't stable either - I might get fired or the business might go south, forcing me to move for another reason. So even the _time_ investment, ignoring the money, often doesn't make sense. If I could be sure the next tenant, or the landlord, would buy decent furniture off my hands at a decent price, I might still do it - but often you can sell your second-hand items even at a fraction of their cost, and have to just give it away. So, even though I hate the IKEA-style rickety woodchip/papier-mache furniture, I've ended up buying more than a bit of it for some of the 6 rental apartments I've lived in over the past decade or so. Of course I try to keep existing furniture when I move in, if it's not too sorry of a sight; and I opt for better quality second-hand over crappy first-hand. But that means it's hella difficult to get materials and colors to match.
- Reventlov 4y agoDoesn't America have Ikea shops? I mean… you get what you pay for, and it's durable enough…
- ajkjk 4y agoThat would fit in the category of the cheap crap that people want to be able to do better than. For the most part. Ikea has some randomly good stuff but... yeah... mostly not.
- Ekaros 4y agoI think there might be two or three bottom tiers at Ikea. The absolute cheapest poor quality junk, you get what you pay for. Then up there somewhat reasonable stuff. Not best, not worst. And here you end up paying more for same or the cheaper stuff in other places.
- jstarfish 4y agoIkea's wood is actual garbage. Anything of theirs that is made of metal is pretty solid, especially if you apply some Loctite. As a comparison, a drink spilled on a wooden end table ended up absorbing it, swelling and warping. Then I left one of their indoor metal-frame couches outside for a couple years and it's only now starting to rust. Their plastic-and-metal chairs seem to be the best of all worlds except comfort. They survive heavy use by children, so it suits my needs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lettergram 4y agoI can’t recommend amish furniture enough. Solid wood, highly customizable, built to pass down. In terms of cost, you can look at getting a queen mattress From mattress firm most people will be spending $500 - $1800 https://www.mattressfirm.com/search?q=Queen https://www.mattressfirm.com/search?q=Queen From ikea your probably going to get a decent frame $500 https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/hemnes-bed-frame-black-brown-loenset-s29129620/ https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/hemnes-bed-frame-black-brown-lo... Neither of those include shipping, so let’s assume another $200 Total: $1200 - $2300 If you get the Amish bedrame you’re talking maybe $1000 - $1600 https://www.dutchcrafters.com/Bed-Headboards/cat/776#1-731 https://www.dutchcrafters.com/Bed-Headboards/cat/776#1-731 I went to a local Amish shop and it was $1000 for a beautiful queen frame. Let’s just assume same shipping Total: $1700 - $3600 Yes there’s increased cost, but if you’re already over the absolute base (mattress + frame) it’s worth it. For most people, I suspect spending the extra few hundred for very good quality is worth it. Often these can be resold and keep a decent margin (I mostly buy furniture used, but quality is expensive)
- jbellis 4y agoMore generally, searching for solid wood furniture should turn up some high quality local options in most places. Here in Austin, that includes Amish Furniture, Furniture in the Raw, and a couple other places that I'm less familiar with.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI was really surprised, when we re-designed our kitchen, that the price tiers for cabinets were basically, lowest to highest: 1) Very-bad premade, 2) mid-range custom made(!!!), 3) mid-range premade (worse than tier 2 on quality), 4) high-end custom made, 5) high-end premade. You'd think the mass-manufactured stuff could win on price, but it only did at a quality level so low that nobody bothers having anything that bad custom-made. Ended up going with some local shop, paid the tier-2 pricing, easily the best bang for the buck. The custom stuff we bought was barely more expensive than getting Ikea cabinets! And it fit perfectly to our floorplan, allowed some custom extras to make better use of space, was exactly the color we wanted, et c.
- karaterobot 4y agoWhen searching for new bookshelves, I was surprised to find there was not much correspondence between price and build quality. The $150 Kallax bookshelves from IKEA were made out of the same material as some $2700 Room & Board bookshelves I also liked: both were medium density fiberboard with a wood veneer. Maybe someone prefers the design of the R&B bookshelf, or maybe they like their choice of veneer better, but fundamentally these are very similar products with an 1800% price difference. I suppose another thing you're buying is the notion of "Not IKEA", the sort of brand identification that is a luxury for certain kinds of people.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI've settled on just getting Ikea or used (and usually quite old) furniture for most things. To get consistently-better quality than Ikea, you have to go up to like 10x or more their price. There's a whole middle-range of furniture that's largely complete shit, as bad or (more often) worse than Ikea, but with massive mark-up. The market's super-weird.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI recommend being cautious. We recently bought a couple Hemnes dressers, which are solid wood mid-range furniture from Ikea. They're trash. Nobody expects Ikea furniture to be great, but usually it's just cheap materials that assembly nicely but aren't necessarily that durable. In this case, the wood was mostly okay, though several pieces were slightly warped, and after it was all put together more than half the drawers jam. Something is very wrong with their manufacturing tolerances.
- vsskanth 4y agoIt’s hard to believe but the walker edison brand of furniture sold online actually has solid wood options and is cheaper with better tolerances than ikea. Ikea tolerances are indeed trash. I have the same hemnes dresser
- rootusrootus 4y ago
- nemo44x 4y agoThe truth is most anything of quality is unaffordable to most people. People are so used to cheap, imitation versions of things that they are blown away at the prices of quality goods. People are shocked when they find out a quality front door costs $3,000 and can go way higher, for example. Most people don't realize it but most homes are made out of cheap materials today or a lack of expensive materials. How many houses do you see with no windows on the side?! If you shop for quality furniture you will pay many thousands for quality couches that are well constructed from furniture grade wood. Proper joints cost a lot more than screws holding things together. Don't even get me started on rugs! If you're looking for high quality things, it's worth checking out the second hand market. Often these items were well cared for and you can get really nice things if you do the legwork.
- pwinnski 4y agoLike many things, this seems to reflect a difference in philosophy. Personal story: I grew up poor, living on the cheapest possible option for everything, and no option at all for many things. Then I wasn't poor anymore. So I would spend time researching the absolute best toaster oven, say, reasoning that paying more would mean not having to worry about a toaster oven again in my life. Later still, I got married to someone who grew up in Hong Kong, a city famously filled with tiny living spaces and street markets filled with goods from right across the border in China. Her philosophy, shaped by her upbringing, is that things are generally disposable. She will happily buy a $20 toaster oven from Walmart[0], and do so again whenever she decides it needs to be replaced. At $20 every three years, it would take several decades before she spent more than I did, and in the meantime maybe she has decided she wants different colors, or uses a toaster oven much less and doesn't even need one anymore. While I look and see waste and a deleterious effect on the environment, she see flexibility and cost savings. Back to the furniture: part of me wants to see if Ethan Allen is still making high-quality long-lasting furniture here in the USA, and buying a new couch there whatever it costs. Another part is on board with my wife's approach, which is pick the style of couch she wants, buy it cheaply, and just know it's going to need to be replaced in five years, but that's okay, because she'll want a different style then. 0. Literally, $19.96! https://www.walmart.com/ip/Mainstays-4-Slice-Toaster-Oven-Black/110900228 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Mainstays-4-Slice-Toaster-Oven-Bl...
- ghayes 4y agoThere is an advantage on the high-end which is a) safer, b) higher functionality, and c) better customer service. The philosophy many follow is buy the cheap one of something, and once it breaks (from extensive usage), replace it with the high-end version.
- rluhar 4y agoCan confirm that Ethan Allen is still selling decent, US made, furniture - though at high prices. We got a couch for an awkward sized space from Ethan Allen and were very happy with the shopping experience, installation, and the quality of the furniture.
- Domenic_S 4y ago
- mpdehaan2 4y agoNorth Carolina person here and yes, all of that going to mexico/elsewhere did lower the quality of everything, as well as the expectation that furniture should be cheap. Highpoint now has a furniture market without much production. Since people here probably have the means, sharing some tips - If you want good solid-wood hand-built furniture in the US, a couple suggestions might be https://roomandboard.com/ https://roomandboard.com/ - which is a frontend on a lot of small makers and has extremely good delivery fees, or finding a local (perhaps modern) furniture store that deals with smaller USA-made companies (like American Leather is pretty good for couches/chairs or Copeland for case goods). Regardless of what you do, often there's a bit of an ordering delay - sometimes up to 3-6 months, but it's always worth it than the obvious online options. You may also have some nearby stores that sell Amish-made wooden furniture, particular in terms of kitchen tables and casegoods, and the quality is usually exceptional. But yeah, stop ordering cheap MDF-stuff and then maybe factories will start producing good stuff in volume again, for a slightly higher price. Maybe.
- andrewstuart 4y agoI decided a long while back to never spend another dollar on garbage furniture like Ikea. Furniture is something worth spending some money on. Look around auctions and second hand stores for nice stuff at lower prices.
- dahwolf 4y ago"...but the real reckoning came almost as soon as the ink dried on the 1999 trade agreement the United States signed with China. Wages were so cheap there that (aided by the occasional World Trade Organization violation) Chinese companies could import U.S. lumber and ship the final product back by the container load and still sell their goods for less than U.S. companies paid in material costs." It's easy to skim over this section without realizing how insane this is. Example: my brother works in the wood industry for a company producing wooden floors based in the Netherlands. They source the wood from a production forest in Belgium. From Belgium's Antwerp harbor it would be an extremely short route to Rotterdam, after which the wood can be processed. No. Instead, from Antwerp it's shipped half-way across the planet to China. There it is sawed into boards, grinded, and shipped to Rotterdam, again crossing half the planet. Back in the Netherlands, they do some finishing touches like sawing custom sizes and applying polish. Can you fucking believe this? We're talking about trees here, they're absurdly heavy. They're making a full round trip across the planet. Whilst 75% of the work on those trees is machine-based. The trees and the people/machines are right next to each other. And still we can't make the economics work. That's because the economics are a scam. Trade deals, subsidized shipping, state sponsorship from China. You can't compete on wages when everything is asymmetrical.
- Zircom 4y agoWe just don't care enough. The amount of apathy the average person in a developed country has for the rest of their fellow man is astounding if you stop and think about it for a bit. People love to go on and on about how capitalism is good and paying them pennies isn't exploitation, we're lifting countries up into the "first world" and that's true to an extent, while conveniently ignoring that the countries being lifted up are either suffering for it themselves or are just shifting the exploitation farther down the line. Eventually we're gonna run out of people to shit on in order to make our lifestyles possible, and that's when it'll get interesting. I've already written about this before on here so I'll just plop that down instead of rehashing it more: I've read that there is a certain number of people that we're basically optimized to coexist within a societal structure, and modern civilization passed that a long time ago, and human beings in general just aren't capable of empathy on the scale of modern civilization. And I mean, it makes sense when you think about it. On some abstract level you have to know that even meagre standards of living in western society requires someone, somewhere to be suffering to provide it. $1 for a pound of bananas shipped from across the world before they even have a hint of yellow on them? That shit don't come without a cost, and our $1 sure as hell aint paying it. But we all just kind of don't think those people just to get through the day, because dwelling on the extent of suffering and horror we've wrought upon our fellow man in pursuit of whatever fresh hell the guys over at Oreo have managed to shape into the general form of a cookie would leave us a broken shell of a person and unable to show up for our next shift at the Big Mac factory.
- anonuser123456 4y agoWhat a completely bizarre story and comments. “Unnecessary lifestyle goods are hard to buy for people who struggle with agency. Market capitalism has failed!” This is truly one of those first world tinniest violin problems.
- evancox100 4y agoYes I couldn't really understand what the thesis was. Definitely the shift to overseas production has affected local manufacturing, a story we have seen over and over. But the consumers are unhappy because... It is cheaper? And $reasons? It's not like there isn't quality furniture available, they talk a lot about it. It is just more expensive than people want to pay given the cheaper alternatives available. So from a consumer angle, what's the problem really? Lacking is any sort of inflation/quality adjusted comparison of prices from "ye goode olde days" vs now. That's really what I want to know, has it gotten both more expensive and worse? Or only cheaper and worse?
- larrymyers 4y agoAt the end of the day most of the moderately priced furniture from IKEA is actually pretty good. When looking for some new living room chairs we visited 2-3 local furniture stores first, and gave up and went to IKEA after suffering through a miserable shopping experience. Sure, IKEA may not have furniture that is going to last you 20+ years, but at least you know you'll get a fairly standard base level of quality for the price. Who knows what you're going to get from Wayfair. It's all just random imports with no real way to figure out what level of quality you are paying for.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoI think a lot of the buying experience is made miserable by sales people, just the same as in car dealerships. I wonder if that is why Ikea is so popular. You get the time to look.
- fragsworth 4y agoA friend of mine made https://feasier.io/ https://feasier.io/ to try to at least make the search process easier. It's hard to get users, though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sacnoradhq 4y agoBuying new furniture, with some exceptions, is a wasteful use of money. Especially often wasteful is unrepairable, landfill-destined IKEA. If you want durable furniture that retains value, invest in (likely used) fine furniture. In terms of usability, doesn't matter where it comes from, so long as it does its job. For resale value, brand matters unless an item is obviously well-crafted. Durable goods are cheaper when not paying for initial depreciation.
- zihotki 4y agoI'm not sure why you think that Ikea furniture is not repairable. It is repairable. There may be some challenges depending on the damage, though. I repaired it many times over the years when I was moving around EU. And it also lasts tens of years for me.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoArguably, highly repairable. Lots of spares, lots of ikea-hacking guides, and the low cost and middling materials mean there isn't a ton of risk. Replacing my DIY "lack rack" would literally cost $20 + a couple bucks worth of screws & brackets. Replacing my teak sideboards if my drill slipped would be... unpleasant.
- orwin 4y agoOne of the advantage I got for coming back near my hometown is that: - I know a farmers shed where I can store my stuff for free and build furniture even when the weather is shitty, - I know the sawmill where I can find cheap but good quality wood/planks - I have access to my father's festools, paint, sewing and over lock machine, as well as his expertise, - I have access to metal drill/mills (sorry if a specific term exist) if I need a specific shape for basically free. I know those advantages are fromy social class too, 90% of the people I've met in college won't have access to that, it's coming from the blue collar 'red and black' culture of sharing the mean of production and popular education where your most important professional skill is how to pass/share knowledge. But still, I have great furniture.