9 ms·
Reassessing relative temporal lobe size in anthropoids and modern humans
- vixen99 4y agoThe surprise would be if it wasn't.
- 13of40 4y agoActually, it's just a primate brain.
- the_third_wave 4y agoThat, minus the "just".
- triyambakam 4y agoOriginal title is "Updated imaging and phylogenetic comparative methods reassess relative temporal lobe size in anthropoids and modern humans" which to fit HN title submissions could maybe be condensed to "Reassessing temporal lobe size in humans and anthropoids with updated methods"
- tiborsaas 4y agoChatGPT to the rescue: Provide an alternative title for "Updated imaging and phylogenetic comparative methods reassess relative temporal lobe size in anthropoids and modern humans" so that layman people would understand. "Reevaluating Brain Size in Humans and Primates: New Techniques Show Surprising Results" Without clickbait "How Modern Imaging and Comparative Analysis are Helping us Understand the Evolution of Brain Size in Humans and Primates" :)
- pferde 4y agoUnless we're already living in Idiocracy, the original title was perfectly understandable by a layman. Do not underestimate your fellow humans. :)
- spywaregorilla 4y agoLaymen won't be definining anthropoids or phylogenetic...
- HPsquared 4y agoNeither does ChatGPT, it seems.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoPrimates seems like a good sub in to me for laypeople. Phylogenetic seems safe to remove. Where do you disagree?
- HPsquared 4y agoJust that it seemed to drop the "phylogenetic" part. The importance of the word depends on what's actually in the article, I suppose.
- alexvoda 4y agoWhat is wrong with laypeople learning the words "phylogenetic" and "anthropoid"? I am not a biologist, and my knowledge in the field is limited to what I learned in high school plus afterwards self study out of curiosity. I did know what "phylogenetic" refers to but I do not remember ever encountering the word "anthropoid". Yet I was perfectly able to infer what it means based on the meaning of the base and suffix. If I don't know a word I look it up. Have people stopped doing this?
- AndrewKemendo 4y ago>If I don't know a word I look it up. Have people stopped doing this? You should feel lucky that you are surrounded by curious people because it's not the norm for the world - though it's a great thing obviously. The process you describe is only done by an extreme minority of people. I'd challenge whether most ever did it.
- dang 4y agoI've changed it now. Thanks! Submitters: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize" (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) If a title doesn't fit HN's 80 char limit, please shorten it in a way that preserves the meaning of the original title. If you do need to change it because the original title was misleading or linkbait (not the case with this submission), please do so using representative language from the article itself (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=representative%20article%20by%3Adang&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...). (Submitted title was "Newer data once again shows: the human brain is just a scaled up primate brain".)
- drewcoo 4y agoSomehow HN-ifying the title made it more click-baity. Humans are primates. And those scientists know it. https://www.britannica.com/animal/primate-mammal https://www.britannica.com/animal/primate-mammal
- dang 4y ago"HN-ifying the title" should be the opposite of rewriting it to be more clickbait - from https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." The submitted title was "Newer data once again shows: the human brain is just a scaled up primate brain". I've HN-ified it now :)
- mkl95 4y agoLast time I checked we shared something like ~99% of our DNA with chimpanzees. Finding differences must be way harder than finding similarities.
- justinator 4y agoThat 1% is actually quite important.
- enw 4y agoI have to admit I never got the “99% similar” and “octopi are so smart” thing. May sound like an ignorant meme, but if they’re really so smart and similar, why can’t they build cities or create cultures or do anything better than just survive?
- tanbog5 4y agoMaybe thumbs are really just that awesome.
- block_dagger 4y agoLack of fire, perhaps.
- lmpdev 4y agoBecause genes are more complex than gene A causes trait B I stop listening most times people use the "99% similar" as the basis for an argument on phenotypes
- pocketarc 4y agoIt might just be a threshold thing; that the brain just crossed a size threshold where it could actually make useful connections that led to where we are now. Similar to how GPT finally crossed a size threshold where its responses are actually useful to us now rather than just random words. The models are just bigger. It’s worth noting that a human living in caves and hunting 20k years ago would’ve been perfectly capable of being a modern-day software developer hanging out on the internet. So it’s not even the cities part that matters, it’s something more fundamental, something that must be impossible to achieve without that extra 1%.
- neximo64 4y agoCan there be different versions? scaled up Porpoise brains, scaled up Corvid brains
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yarg 4y agoYeah, but how the subvolumes are scaled is highly fucking evolved. Then there're some nasty little contradictions like FOXP2.
- nbevans 4y agoSo what you're saying is... /it's aliens/ ... right? (:
- yarg 4y agoNah, we've just spent a long fucking time not dying with increasing efficiency. Distributed autoadversarial algorithms have honed our minds over millions of years. You may be able to show that something is largely a scaled form, but you're leaving out optimised mass/volume/energy scaling optimisations that have one hell of an impact. Feedback loops of minor advantages tend to cascade and the propagate across the entirety of breeding populations. (Some advantages are more aggressively curbed, such as the sickle cell trait.) Then it's missing things like FOXP2 - weird shit happens to language capabilities when you break it. Not only that, but: Three amino acid substitutions distinguish the human FOXP2 protein from that found in mice, while two amino acid substitutions distinguish the human FOXP2 protein from that found in chimpanzees,[17] but only one of these changes is unique to humans.[10] Evidence from genetically manipulated mice[22] and human neuronal cell models[23] suggests that these changes affect the neural functions of FOXP2. So there are major mutations that make differences on scales that they aren't even looking at it. Topological theory has its limits.
- psychphysic 4y agoBig brain primate has big brain of primates! What a blinder of an specious insight. We don't even understand scaled up LLM let alone brains to make a meaningful inferences here. It's also a disingenuous title for the linked article.
- aydyn 4y agoWe dont understand LLMs but we certainly understand matrix multiplication.
- wongarsu 4y agoWe also have a good idea of how individual neurons work, but struggle a lot with understanding brains. Both LLMs and human brains have a lot of emergent behavior, which is why our understanding the low-level primitives only provides very limited insight.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 4y agoWe still don't have a good lower bound on the complexity of matrix multiplication.
- echelon 4y ago> What a blinder of an specious insight. We are on track to potentially learn there's no deep mysterious secret to human cognition. If and when we crack that, this planet will experience the technological singularity. I thought the singularity was a crackpot idea not much different from string theory in how it tries to sell itself. We were stuck in the post WWII, post globalization, smartphone incrementalism age. Now we're moving on to something exciting again. What I'm getting at is that you'll not only see more articles like this, but that collectively as a species we're going to start feeling a whole lot less special.
- toyg 4y ago
- ar9av 4y agoThe above is interesting because it highlights the fact that humans do not have truly unique cognitive abilities, and hence must differ from other animals not qualitatively, but rather in the combination and extent of abilities such as theory of mind, imitation and social cognition. Moreover, viewing the human brain as a linearly scaled-up primate brain in its cellular composition does not diminish the role that particular neuroanatomical arrangements may play in human cognition. Rather, such arrangements should contribute to brain function in combination with the large number of neurons in the human brain.
- Drakim 4y agoIndeed, simply saying that it's just "more of the same" misses the point that quantity has a quality all its own.
- est 4y agoI think the comment is AI generated.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoIts speech. Its basically a meme-bootloader, that allows for a cognitive super charging. Again, its the software, not the hardware, making all the difference. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_deprivation_experiments https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_deprivation_experimen...
- junon 4y agoI propose a new law - the "Above Law". Similar to Poe's Law, it's sufficiently impossible on the internet to determine if a comment referencing "the above" is referring to a LLM prompt, or is a real human using an unusual way of referencing the content in question.
- 6510 4y agoEvery time the hardware gets better we compensate with more bloated software. Fragile code, countless bugs, poor patches. We keep adding more and more features that spend more cognition as if it's an unlimited free resource. From walking to a tree to grab some fruit to a complex network of farmers, merchants, machines, oil drills etc From fighting with fists over simple basic things to intercontinental ballistic missiles and autonomous drone fights over issues we don't even understand anymore. The most complex mating dance on this side of the galaxy. I'm happy we didn't lose our monkey sense of humor[1.4.42] [1.4.42] - https://youtu.be/FIxYCDbRGJc https://youtu.be/FIxYCDbRGJc
- kybernetyk 4y agoSo intelligence is determined by genes?
- Synaesthesia 4y agoYes of course. My daughter will grow up to be a human, not a chicken. Humans are genetically all very similar though.
- seydor 4y agoPaLM vs GPT
- ChatGTP 4y agoWhy am I seeing more of this lately? "just a", "just a meat bag", "just monkeys". I think it's a degrading and disrespectful way to speak, not so much that I'm offended, but I think it's actually a non-intelligent way to view the world. Also probably not very healthy. Feels like there is a little bit too much of this self-degrading language used in science and technology circles now.
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoThe logos with which they apply the rationalism of the position that as biological creatures we do not hold a special place in the cosmos is not the offensive part. It's the ethos part that they really don't want you looking at. Human history has always been tumultuous, and now we get to the present day, where we have extreme inequality, world-ending weaponry, and destabilizing global climate, contracting resources, and social upheaval as a result. There's no pretty solution to be found. Now we have the latest zeitgeist of AI, already threatening the economic wellbeing of the multitudes if you believe Altman & co. The rights of humans throughout history has been predicated on the idea that humans are special somehow, deserving of dignity. Get enough people to really lean into the idea that they're just a meaty LLM and the foundation of human rights crumbles. You can get away with quite a lot of evil if you take care to dehumanize those you want gone.
- b800h 4y agoPart and parcel of the desacralisation of the human being, unfortunately, which is so hot right now, and has been since the start of the twentieth century.
- ChatGTP 4y agoFairly dangerous view, I feel it's definitely going to ramp up now we can apparently be replaced with LLMs.
- dorchadas 4y agoIt is, absolutely. Even to the level of socialisation where chatbots start to replace in-person connections. I truly feel things are about to get a lot worse for most people (.i. Those who don't control the systems) and it won't be pretty. Sadly I don't think those who do do this stuff care one bit. The whole 'Did it because we could without asking whether we should' type problem.
- est 4y agoIMHO, there could be a tipping point of scaling "primate" brain. For a given task, when size of brain can handle so much knowledge that unknowns are fewer than knowns, the advantage grows exponentially. Because you can deduce outcomes correctly by eliminating the wrong answers without actually "understands" the problem itself.
- extasia 4y agoDo you have any literature on this?
- est 4y agoJust my own thoughts. Add `IMHO` prefix.
- ivxvm 4y agoIdk. I think the real tipping point is being able to succesfully use external memory so that you don't have to keep everything in your working memory when doing reasoning or solving problems.
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoYes, humans have been around for 300,000 years and only in the last 10,000 years human crossed that tipping point to be able to think higher order things.
- kaba0 4y agoDo you have any evidence for this claim? Just because people didn’t start agriculture doesn’t mean they weren’t as smart as people today. Hell, 300000 years is nothing from an evolutionary perspective, they were for all practical purposes genetically identical. It was just most probably a nurture thing — there was not as much accumulated knowledge to “bootstrap” a more advanced civilization (or perhaps, no will to do so. Why change when your system works just fine?). It’s not like Einstein could have achieved much back then without “standing on the shoulder of giants” before him.
- t344344 4y agoSo is mice, lizard and so on. But there are huge differences: * Primates can not sweat and self regulate body temperature through perspiration. * Primates can not fast, most humans can go 40 days without eating, chimps would starve to death after couple of days. * Primates can not run for several hours and outrun a horse! Scaling up brain is not a problem, but keeping it supplied with energy is.
- adrian_b 4y agoAll these are normal and necessary adaptations when switching from a vegetarian diet to animal hunting. All predators need the ability to fast. All non-ambush predators, like wolves or hyenas or humans, need adaptations that ensure enough endurance to pursue their prey for hours, without overheating or becoming too tired.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoWe generally can't outrun a horse[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_versus_Horse_Marathon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Man_versus_Horse_Marathon
- t344344 4y agoMarathon is too short for this, try for 24 hours...
- iamacyborg 4y agoMost folks can’t run 5k, let alone run for 24 hours.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoAlmost any human trained from a childhood would be able to do endurance hunting. Human endurance thanks to sweating and other traits is especially advantageous in hot climate: horses can't ourtun humans indefinitely as they overheat and can't cool down as effectively as humans, so eventually a trained human will catch up a horse (and eat it).
- mqayx 4y ago[flagged]
- jdthedisciple 4y agoAnd it's sickening.
- _xnmw 4y ago“Just a scaled up primate brain”? And so a nuclear ICBM is “just” a scaled up bow and arrow!
- HPsquared 4y ago"Rods from God", the most advanced form of the bow and arrow: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment
- EGreg 4y agoWow these AI people are really shilling for their “scale is all you need” hypothesis eh? Now they are planting this stuff to gaslight us into thinking the same? :) https://lastweekin.ai/p/the-ai-scaling-hypothesis https://lastweekin.ai/p/the-ai-scaling-hypothesis
- mtrycz2 4y agoLooks like it. The linked article does NOT show what HN title does. Even the original title does not imply what the HN title does. The article is about one specific area of the brain, which is not the most obvious difference.
- imtringued 4y agoThere were bigger models than ChatGPT 3.5 before it was released and they didn't perform better. In fact, the hype isn't built around large parameters but in fact on an interactive LLM architecture. ChatGPT and GPT do very different things but it is ChatGPT that gets the hype despite essentially having the same parameter count. The parameter count thing appeals to people believing in linear scaling per parameter.
- EGreg 4y agoWhat do you mean by interactive LLM architecture?
- stormfather 4y agoI assume they mean trained on human feedback to understand human intent and answer questions, and then glued to a front end that lets us chat with it.