10 ms·
SVB insider says employees are angry with CEO
- miguelazo 4y agoI really love that they used a pic of CEO Becker from a recent Michael (ex-con, Junk Bond King) Milken Institute event. >For their part, Sonnenfeld and Tian argue Jerome Powell, Biden’s pick to lead the Federal Reserve, and his colleagues deserve at least some of the blame. “There should be no mistaking that Silicon Valley Bank’s collapse was a direct result of the Fed’s persistent and excessive interest rate hikes,” they wrote. Why? Because the Fed’s war on inflation depressed both the value of the bonds Silicon Valley Bank was relying on for capital and the value of the tech startups the bank catered to. Of course, Silicon Valley Bank had more than a year to prepare for both of those issues. Exactly.
- uejfiweun 4y agoYeah, to "Sonnenfeld and Tian", it's like gimme a break. The fed is in no way responsible for the results of every single bank out there. This is on SVB and SVB alone. More broadly, I'm sad that this event is likely going to disrupt the war on inflation and interest rate hikes. It might be time to start preparing for more inflation, or as Dorsey predicts, even hyperinflation.
- tqi 4y ago“You’re in business for 40 years and you are telling me you can’t raise $2 billion privately? Get on a jet and fly to Kuwait like everyone else and give them control of one-third of the bank.” A lot to unpack there...
- paganel 4y agoFor those wondering (like I was), the Kuwait quote is actually real, from the article itself. Maybe those "SVB insiders" should have just been better at doing their jobs.
- djaouen 4y agoI am super happy this employee lost his job lol
- tqi 4y agoTBH i think this is just saying the quiet part out loud. Everyone wants to trumpet their commitment to a higher mission and their core values and whatever else during the good times but when their backs are against the wall, none of that matters.
- hackernewds 4y agowhat's wrong with raising money from Kuwait? raising money from shady nation-states with an agenda seems to have worked out for Twitter
- s1artibartfast 4y agowhats wrong with it?
- SoftTalker 4y agoSounds like how the mob used to “help” businesses that needed cash.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mc32 4y agoIt’s probably taking a cue from SoftBank some years ago when they sought investment from MBSs sovereign fund.
- testfoobar 4y agoWhat this person is saying is that a going concern of 40 years right in center of Silicon Valley can easily raise capital from anywhere on the planet. SVB should have raised capital in 2021.
- missedthecue 4y agoI feel like flying to Omaha might have been an option too
- pjc50 4y agoAn equity issue would absolutely have solved the problem, although $2bn for 1/3 of the bank would have been a pretty hefty discount. The surprising thing is that nobody in SV VC circles decided to raise capital to save the bank. Raising capital is literally what they do - and in many cases, they'd encouraged companies to use SVB! (Were there kickbacks for this?)
- Loughla 4y ago>“That was absolutely idiotic, They were being very transparent. It’s the exact opposite of what you’d normally see in a scandal. But their transparency and forthright-ness did them in.” This doesn't sound like a great employee to quote. >Get on a jet and fly to Kuwait like everyone else and give them control of one-third of the bank. Or this. >“The saddest thing is that this place is Boy Scouts,” he said. “They made mistakes, but these are not bad people.” Which makes me question the point at the end of the article. It's fascinating watching these articles come out and trying to guess who is behind them and for what purpose.
- riskneutral 4y agoI think you are missing some context around this story. Banking can be a confusing topic. What that employee is referring to, and it is a great employee quote, is the fact that SVB's unexpected announcement that it was selling HTM securities at a loss and publicly raising equity is the singular event that really triggered the whole crisis. The CEO's poorly calibrated communication and lack of action in the midst of a run on his bank had sealed the bank's fate by Thursday afternoon. The point this employee is making is that instead of this kind of "Boy Scout" transparency about its efforts to shore up its balance sheet (which only served to cause panic), the CEO should have quickly and privately closed a deal to raise capital only announced the deal after it was done. I don't know if doing a deal with a Middle Eastern Sovereign Wealth Fund would have helped avoid an accidental panic. But they could have very easily sold SVB to a larger bank before the CEO's own-goal of causing a run on his bank by announcing forced selling of bonds at a loss and a public capital raise. Once the bank run had begun, it was impossible for a buyer to step in. I believe that it must have been greed and overconfidence at the core of their problems. They didn't want to hedge their IR exposures, didn't want the expense of raising capital quietly, didn't want the expense of diversifying their funding sources away from volatile depositors, etc.
- fifilura 4y agoRepresentatives from Alecta, the swedish pension fund that was big owner said the same. That SVB had presented a plan that was agreed upon with the owners but instead they sold their assets with a loss and went out publicly to seek investment without having an agreement with anyone. They declared this a "big mistake"
- henry2023 4y agoIs it me or this insider is pissed off because his shares (or options) went to zero while the deposits of the creditors were matched 100% No mention of zero risk management. No mention of possible contagion effect. No mention of hundreds of workers not knowing if they’re going to be paid Individualism at its finest
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- quantified 4y agoThe weird thing is that transparency about the difficulty at the bank is exactly what leads to the run. The incentives of the banking system are to hide reality in case of a financial breach. Whereas for a security breach, the incentives need to be to be forthright. How's an executive supposed to keep the nuance of when to lie?
- iaabtpbtpnn 4y agoWhat good is a bank executive who can't?
- yellowstuff 4y agoThere's a 2014 paper that describes this dynamic. Clients want deposits (bank liabilities) that act like cash, but they are backed by assets that have fluctuating values. Banks need to be "optimally opaque" to make this work. https://economics.sas.upenn.edu/pier/working-paper/2014/banks-secret-keepers https://economics.sas.upenn.edu/pier/working-paper/2014/bank...
- bentcorner 4y agoDo they really? Isn't it only the interest rate that decides how much risk a bank wants to take on? Couldn't I could open a bank, stuff your cash into my vault and charge you a negative interest rate to pay for guards.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYou could, but that is not what "clients want".
- jsjohnst 4y agoI’d definitively signup if that was available, just ideally as a monthly fee vs a negative interest rate. Just like I’ll pay for my content over it being “free” with ads and/or worse dark patterns.
- deleted 4y ago
- dahdum 4y agoOf course they'll want to blame anything other than the stupidly high risk strategies that got them there. SVB had the highest compensation in the industry for 2018, and averaged ~$293k/employee last year while hitting top scores for work-life balance, remote options, and employee satisfaction. For fun...here are the top paying banks in 2018: 1. SVB - $250k 2. First Republic - $247k 3. Signature Bank - $216k SVB and Signature just failed, First Republic is down 75% over the past 5 days. https://archive.is/3QXIO https://archive.is/3QXIO
- nerdponx 4y agoI remember seeing a list on Reddit the other day showing other banks that also were heavily invested in MBSes similar to what SVB were invested in, and First Republic was on that list. I assume the market quickly lost confidence in all of the banks on that list.
- logicfiction 4y agoWas MBS (mortgage backed securities) a typo here? My understanding was SVB had a huge long term treasury position on the books from before interest rate hikes that was in the red against the market. And their second largest tier was direct loans to things like startups that weren't asset backed but instead default to warranties on the companies taking the loans (I'm not close enough to this to really say that more specifically).
- dahdum 4y agoThey had over $80 billion of MBS as HTM. > SVB’s mistake was investing in longer-term mortgage securities with more than 10 years to maturity, rather than shorter-maturity Treasuries or mortgage issues maturing in less than five years. This led to an asset/liability mismatch. https://www.barrons.com/articles/svb-silicon-valley-bank-rates-securities-693c931c https://www.barrons.com/articles/svb-silicon-valley-bank-rat...
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThey had several MBSes on the books, too. Both MBSes and treasuries are long-term fixed-income products. It's not as bad as they used to be in 2008 - they have largely fixed the "gamesmanship" that got everyone in trouble then.
- wolverine876 4y agoIt says some people are blaming the Fed's interest rate hikes. Should the Fed adjust the people's monetary policy to help some bankers? SVB couldn't, and isn't responsible for, anticipating interest rate changes (who could have seen those hikes coming? /s) and managing the risk? What else are they paid to do?
- gnicholas 4y agoOther banks saw the hikes coming (and plenty of regular people did too), and bought insurance hedges. SVB was relatively unique in not doing so.
- ROTMetro 4y agoIf only there was some sort of 'insurance' to hedge against this that the bank could have availed themselves of.
- paulddraper 4y agoI mean, it must be hard to work in an industry subject to the whims of a single organization.
- p0pcult 4y agoEspecially if you don't have a risk management team.
- cm2187 4y agoIt seems to me that from what I read, the root cause is that the bank was funded with corporate deposits and deposits from institutional investors, both of which are known to be volatile in a stress, and treated punitively by the liquidity regulations imposed on larger banks (in fact financial institutions deposits cannot be used to finance anything else than liquid assets). And they funded buy and hold positions of bonds with these deposits, not hedging the interest rate risk. All of which are internal fuckups and none of which I read in this article...
- more_corn 4y agoYa think? I bet the shareholders (ex-shareholders ?) are pissed too.
- dragontamer 4y agoThey're mad at the match, but they aren't mad at the powderkeg. SVB didn't have a Chief Risk Officer from April 2022 through January 2023. They were flying blind. While the Fed raised interest rates, the bank seemingly moved forward without any risk assessments. A new Chief Risk Officer was named in January 2023. The top insiders then sold tons of shares in February, suggesting that they all realized something was wrong. In the next public report on March 8th at 4pm, they announce a capital raise to offset their now booked losses. This sets off a bank run on March 9th. And the rest is history. ----------- Maybe instead of blaming the bank run on March 9th (the lit match), they need to focus more on the 10+ months of poor risk assessments and blatant insider-trading in February (suggesting that the higher-ups discovered the issue and acted upon it for personal financial gains). -------------- Sure, the email / press release on March 8th was poorly written. So poorly written it set off a bankrun. The CEO deserves some of the blame here for such shoddy writing that set off the stampede. But that wasn't the issue. The issue was all the "dry powder" that the bank accumulated over the past year.
- aaomidi 4y agoThe CEO is responsible for lack of CRO too
- kurthr 4y agoThey wouldn't have been legally allowed to be out of compliance without a change in regulations. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-dodd-frank/trump-signs-bill-easing-u-s-bank-rules-into-law-idUSKCN1IP2WX https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-dodd-frank/trum...
- listenallyall 4y agoWhat exactly are you saying, that it would have been illegal for a bank to allow its risk officer to resign or to leave?
- berkeleyjunk 4y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoLots of comments questioning the wisdom of this quote, but I think it's essentially spot on, albeit lacking some tact: > You’re in business for 40 years and you are telling me you can’t raise $2 billion privately? Get on a jet and fly to Kuwait like everyone else and give them control of one-third of the bank. That is, despite the fact that the run on the bank was the culmination of bad risk management, not the start, it was absolutely not a foregone conclusion the bank would fail. They definitely should have already had any asset commitments signed before they went public. Then they would have been able to say, truthfully, "we are in a stronger capital position than we've ever been in" as opposed to "please don't panic". SVB had a lot of value in their unique expertise that an outside investor would have valued before the run on the bank - it's really sad that institutional knowledge will be lost now.
- TheRealPomax 4y agoGet in line, I guess.
- twawaaay 4y ago> “That was absolutely idiotic,” the employee, who works on the asset management side of Silicon Valley Bank, told CNN in an interview. “They were being very transparent. It’s the exact opposite of what you’d normally see in a scandal. But their transparency and forthright-ness did them in.” This is pretty ironic. Not only people constantly complain at lack of transparency but when they actually get honesty and glimpse into workings of a large bank they panic and withdraw their money and do themselves in. The irony part is that any bank will fall if people take a peek and realise the bank does not have their money. As for banks, fractional reserve banking is a fraud that is made and tolerated in the name of economic progress. But other than suspending withdrawals there exists no way to safeguard a bank against bank runs. And it is not possible to prevent the bank from losing your money as long as the bank is free to invest your money into financial instruments -- there exist no financial instrument that are free from risk. There exist no way of combining financial instruments to hedge against risk completely. The only thing that you can do is to shovel your risk from place to place and make so it looks that you don't have any risk until it happens. And then you loose catastrophically.
- sulam 4y agoIn other news, journalists announce that water is wet.
- ggm 4y agoIsn't the fundamental problem here wanting to have your cake (earn interest) and eat it too (cash at call)? It's a niche belief that you can keep money liquid, and earn on it. If you want it liquid, you're actually a liability not an asset: you have all this money sloshing around, which can't be put out for long term growth because you want it NOW. That actually kind-of "costs money" to do. If not money, then risk. SVB had more money on call, than most banks. A lot more. Why? because it was over exposed to clients who needed money at call. Why? because herd mentality and costs. Because startup culture legitemates bleeding money, to build belief. If it was economically easier to use SVB to fund day to day operations of startups than "traditional" banks, what does the failure of SVB say about the operating model of the startup sector? If it was catastrophic for Thiel to send mail telling his "friends" to pull out, what does that say about the sector and SVB?
- paxys 4y agoLiquid and illiquid aren't just binary choices. There's a very wide range of risk profiles between the two. I want to be able to pull out my money anytime and earn something close to the fed's interest rate (minus whatever haircut the bank takes). This is a reasonable expectation for any banking system. The bank takes the money and instead dumps it into 10-year bonds, MBS products and loans to startups (among lots of other creative investments). They pay me the same low interest and keep all the extra returns to themselves. But those returns came with added risk, and that risk is being down to me whether they want to admit it or not.
- Aeolun 4y agoFeels like everything would have been fine if people had just not pulled their money out? Making up a 1.8B loss with 220B in assets sounds doable. People then pulling out another 42B sounds like a disaster.
- tschellenbach 4y agoSource for the loss? So far I haven't seen the real number after these asset sales.
- fludlight 4y agoLehman employees were also angry with their final CEO, Dick Fuld. At one point there was a now-debunked rumor that he got punched in the face at the company gym a few days after that bankruptcy. Dick was a dick even for a big swinging dick on Wall Street and he spurned several last minute lifelines, so, at the time, people in the industry universally approved. A fast, dramatic demise of a massive company leaves scars. Almost 15 years on, former Lehman lifers are still salty about what happened. Perceived mismanagement ("They squandered it!") and regulatory failure ("They bailed out our competitors but not us!"). The former are similar to the feelings of older engineers who worked at IBM, Intel, Palm, Yahoo, Nokia, etc during their heyday.
- shapefrog 4y ago> Almost 15 years on, former Lehman lifers are still salty about what happened. Many employees lost small - medium sized fortunes in the collapse. When you got your bonus, it was in Lehmans stock. When your stock vested, it was considered a career limiting move to sell your stock - even for such extravagant things such as pay your kids school fees or put down a deposit on a house. You were not a true believer in Dicks vision. Instead it was arranged for you to borrow against your Lehmans stock ...
- pjc50 4y ago> Instead it was arranged for you to borrow against your Lehmans stock ... Company scrip from the company store, but for rich people.
- jononomo 4y agoWhat I don't understand is why Moody gave this bank an A rating last week. What is the point of having Moody even rate them if they can't detect a problem like this?
- tjpnz 4y agoIf Moody didn't give them that rating somebody else would.
- hacker_newz 4y agoWere you living under a rock in 2008?
- TheMagicHorsey 4y agoRun a free money environment for ten years and all kinds of bullshit and mal-investments will pile up across the economy. Half of Silicon Valley is bullshit speculative nonsense funded with a river whose ultimate source is the Fed money faucet. We have not seen the end of this ... just the very beginning.
- paul7986 4y agoHow many banks went belly up in 2008 and is now a potential repeat of what all happened then?
- gumby 4y agoBoecker’s predecessor, a former professor*, of all things, was quite good. I didn’t like Becker, and as I’ve posted, I switched out of SVB last year. * German literature! Hard to see how that makes you a good banker.
- Panzer04 4y agoI’d imagine they’re pissed off the same way Credit Suisse employees are after Archegos blew up. Everything was going fine, but in a corner somewhere someone was making absolutely stupid investment and loan decisions that lead to a catastrophic blow up. The bank bought LT bonds extremely heavily at historically low interest rates, proceeded to not hedge the rate risk AT ALL, and held them while interest rates were pounding their value well below their carrying value. If they were marked to market they would have been forced out of their spectacularly stupid decision before the bank blew up, but instead they acted like a punter on margin and refused to reduce risk while losing all of their money. Make no mistake, even if the bank hadn’t blown up they still locked in ~15B in losses by holding those bonds while rates went up to 5%.
- sn41 4y agoActually I am a bit on the fence with the SVB situation. I think they suffered from bad timing and an excessively cautious strategy. To be fair to them: one week back, given the asset allocation of SVB, how many of us could have predicted a collapse in the next two days? I could not. In fact, I would have said that investing in bonds is better than an equity-heavy allocation for a responsible bank. Hindsight about liquidity issues is fine, but I doubt that it was as clear as it is now made out to be. Time to brush up on my Taleb again, sadly. Second time during my career.
- sokoloff 4y ago"$Recently_failed_company insider says employees are angry with CEO" is one of the least surprising headlines ever.