31 ms·
Changes at YC
- auggierose 4y agoI am wondering if "impacted" is used because really lots of different things have happened to these 17 team mates. Or if "impacted" = "fired", and "team mates" = "ex-employees".
- MattGaiser 4y agoThat is the point of writing it that way. So you have to do the mental work yourself of translating "impacted" to "fired."
- sagivo 4y agoIt's much easier to spray and pray than to dive deep into business fundamentals.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- greatpostman 4y agoWonder if this is related to the current down turn in risk assets and the venture capital blow up
- doodlesdev 4y agoI find it almost impossible to not see them as related. Take a look at [0]. Long-term this could be a good decision, I believe early-stage investing really is different to late-stage investment, but of course the moment to make this decision makes it evident there are other factors at play that influence this. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35114009 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35114009
- dang 4y agoThe timing does make that almost impossible! But if you want the actual connected edge in the directed graph I believe it's https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32637686 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32637686.
- doodlesdev 4y agoHmm, that does make sense. The other comment here said that this kind of change is almost impossible to happen is such as short amount of time, which makes sense. Maybe they were already planning for a change in strategy by the new CEO, and this just happened to be an appropriate time to get done with the change already. edit: Oh well the other commenter was the new CEO LOL, not used to reading usernames. I guess that adds a bit of bias but I believe it's a true statement.
- garry 4y agoChanges of this sort cannot happen in a very short amount of time. The timing was coincidental.
- bigbraintheroom 4y agoI have made changes with other C-level employees in under 30m which had more than 30m of impact. Can you explain how that would not be the case here? Not understanding how this timing is “coincidental”, it doesn’t appear to be that way at all.
- garry 4y agoIt's not, this is about making YC awesome for early stage founders right at the beginning.
- echelon 4y agoYC does early stage well. Spreading out focus and capital over other stages takes energy away from this. Other firms already have a good grasp of late stage and it'd be a battle for YC to improve over this. Maybe YC can return to late stage later when the environment changes.
- dang 4y agoIt's not—my understanding is that it's been in the works for quite a bit longer than that.
- bobleeswagger 4y agoI don't think the timing is random considering the climate. I have a feeling these seventeen will land softly compared to 99.9% of those caught up in recent layoffs.
- zamnos 4y ago"current down turn in risk assets" is almost as wonderful a phrase as "17 team members were impacted". The fact is that SIVB shares are now worth $0, and that many VCs and LPs were surely holding those can't be a total coincidence with today's "changes".
- johnbellone 4y agoThis wasn't the announcement I expected.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoSorry to everyone who lost their jobs. It can feel like the end of the world and your worth. But I’ve seen throughout my career people land somewhere better. Someone once wise told me the most important saying in the world is “this too shall pass,” which applies to all things, good and bad.
- whitemary 4y ago[flagged]
- CyberDildonics 4y agoYou realize they can get a different job right?
- whitemary 4y agoThe question is whether all families can sustain healthy and dignified livelihoods. And the answer is in fact they cannot. By definition, a capitalist economy has a hard dependency on labor surplus. Remember when the Federal Reserve literally said they were raising interest rates to increase unemployment? That's why.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoThey couldn’t in Soviet Russia either. I also don’t consider livelihood synonymous with dignity. If you’re going to advocate, I’d fall on the UBI side before I fall on the “meaningless command economy labor for the sake of laboring”
- CyberDildonics 4y agoThe question is whether all families can sustain healthy and dignified livelihoods. And the answer is in fact they cannot. This story is about 17 people being fired. I'm not sure what rants about capitalism have to do with that.
- aketchum 4y ago
- cheeze 4y agoWeak wording the same as every other company > Unfortunately, this means we will no longer need some of the roles > Seventeen of our teammates are impacted
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- everybodyknows 4y agoIs "impacted" the euphemism of the 2020's? In the past I've seen "affected", but maybe that's passé now. So hard to keep up with all the progress in our language ...
- layer8 4y agoI mean, aren’t founders always touting that they want to have an impact in the world? ;)
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoPG and crew have been very proud of the way they've been able to scale YC. This seems to be one of the first times where YC has failed to scale?
- tempsy 4y agoI’m not sure why YC is an example of something that has scaled well. There’s so many companies now in each batch with 95%+ never amounting to much success. It’s not clear how the scale is helping anyone.
- garry 4y agoI will say that large % of the batches turn out to still be good companies later, sometimes much later. The journey of being a founder sets people up to do a lot more: YC alums are often great C-level executives at other fast growing startups, and/or just because their first startup doesn't work doesn't mean they don't go on to create great companies later. The key thing about networks is Metcalfe's law: the power of a network is the square of its nodes. This is also what makes the Internet more and more valuable over time. Those things together mean scale increases value for founders, and what we've learned is those effects are most potent early.
- subarctic 4y agoDid YC used to have a better record when they were smaller?
- tylermenezes 4y agoThere have been plenty of scaling problems (my batch, S12, has been publicly referred to a few times as "the batch that broke YC" for example). Scaling is an iterative process :)
- pbreit 4y agoOr perhaps writing pro rata checks doesn't require that many people?
- dvt 4y ago[flagged]
- Zetice 4y agoLiterally none of the investors in SVB were bailed out, as you cannot bail out a failed bank.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kgwgk 4y agoThe investors in depositor companies were (indirectly) bailed out (if there is indeed a shortfall).
- Zetice 4y ago"indirectly bailed out" is not "bailed out". The US economy as a whole was "bailed out" by not having a cascading effect of bank failures, does that mean you were "bailed out" too? Are we just devaluing the term entirely?
- dvt 4y agoImagine thinking that billionaires actually bought SVB stock or held cash in there. Protip: their capital is tied up in dozens of companies, which were, indeed, bailed out.
- Zetice 4y ago"Their capital" is vastly different from "them", as it has been given out for others to use, so again no, they were not bailed out.
- 4y ago
- ftxbro 4y ago> Seventeen of our teammates are impacted today. guys maybe they were impacted in a good way tho?
- tropicaljacket 4y agoMaybe your question is a joke but I assume "impacted" means laid off in this context. Kind of like when people say someone "passed away" to mean they died
- karamanolev 4y agoCan we please just use "fired", "let go" or even "we separated with"? Impacted is just soft wording taken to a comedic level.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago“As of today, we are no longer buying labor from 17 people we previously bought labor from”.
- smugma 4y agoFired implies with cause. In the US, it would be "laid off" and in the UK it's often "made redundant", which is itself more ambiguous than need be.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoWhoosh.
- xqcgrek2 4y agono, they meant the way when a car impacts a wall, or when stool gets impacted in a colon
- djyaz1200 4y agoI'd be very interested in the specifics of how and why late stage investing is so different that the success of YC in early stages doesn't translate.
- xyzelement 4y agoI am not VC but I think this is kinda apparent from the get go. In early stage you are betting on and nurturing a small team with a full-of-hope business plan. They need relatively small bits of help that can go a along way. So both "who you are chosing among" and "how you are helping them" is very specific. With bigger companies, the team and the business plan is more proven and they need help navigating size and scaling their offering - a very different set of people you are chosing from and what they need from you. I am sure there's a lot of additional nuance.
- roflyear 4y agoIf it is, bad look for YC: obviously they did not think it was apparent, and they should be the experts.
- cm2012 4y agoYC took a risk with a new division and then closed it when it didn't work. That's not a "bad look" at all.
- roflyear 4y agoIt's a bad look if it's "obviously why it didn't work"
- xyzelement 4y agoTo be clear, my grandparent post is about how the two domains are obviously different. That's not the same as "obviously wouldn't work out"
- 4y ago
- tempaccount420 4y agoIn an already difficult economic climate, it's heartbreaking to hear that these individuals will be impacted by this change in strategy. I hope that YC will do their best to support these team members during this transition.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoWould YC be willing to share more about the effectiveness of the Continuity Fund? A post mortem would be welcomed and valuable imho.
- eimrine 4y agoThat's great (from my sofa's PoV)! If your mission is to fund youngsters and we know the story about that bank from the Silicon valley so this is the best way to save some resources.
- roflyear 4y agoHow much $ does YC make per employee?
- i_love_cookies 4y ago[dead]
- pwmanagerdied 4y ago[dead]
- O__________O 4y agoDoes this also mean YC is killing off their YC Continuity Programs: >> Series A Program: Help founders achieve the best possible outcome when raising a Series A via year-round workshops, fundraising guides and 1:1 support. >> Post-A Program: Batches for YC startups immediately after their Series A to share best practices for growth: managing a board, building a team, key metrics for a Series B and more. >> YC Growth Program: Graduate school for startups. We bring together cohorts of CEOs of rapidly growing YC companies to focus on the challenges of company building: the changing role of a CEO at scale, setting strategies and success metrics for the organization, hiring and managing great leaders, and more. Source: - https://web.archive.org/web/20220812233728/https://www.ycombinator.com/about/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220812233728/https://www.ycomb... _____ EDIT: Related comment from Garry on the topic: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35143443 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35143443
- gingerrr 4y agoYes https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35142261 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35142261
- O__________O 4y agoNot seeing anything related to the programs I referenced, am I missing something?
- gingerrr 4y agoSorry - the link in that thread is to a tweet, not the article the tweet links, which is what I wanted to link - that article indicates the partners leading the fund (and program) left YC. Also, the continuity program page (provided info for all 3 programs) is completely gone: https://www.ycombinator.com/continuity https://www.ycombinator.com/continuity I haven't heard specifics about those programs but with the partners leading gone it seems difficult to imagine them continuing - fair point though, no solid news.
- 4y ago
- breck 4y agoI like it. Double down on what people love about YC—getting more people to become entrepreneurs. The later stages there's plenty of YC companies out there that can help (WeFunder, Mercury, Brex, Clerky, Stripe, LSTE, etc).
- voz_ 4y ago> Seventeen of our teammates are impacted today. Never allow corporations to speak in passive, weak, blameless terms. Use direct, honest, language, and force them to do the same. "Seventeen of our teammates are impacted today." - > "We laid off 17 employees today" "I was impacted by layoffs" -> "Google laid me off" etc
- bovermyer 4y agoPassive voice afflicts many people's writing, not just corporations. Yes, it's a bad practice, but I don't feel it's egregious in this case.
- comte7092 4y agoThat is a reasonable argument if one assumes that this is an unconscious choice, however, passive voice has become the standard with these types of press releases. It is a conscious, intentional choice.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pastabol 4y agoPassive voice is a tool. It’s perfectly valid and grammatical. The problem is the abuse of it to misrepresent one’s agency or responsibility, but there’s nothing wrong with the sentence, “I was hit by a car on the way to work.” The issue with corporate passive is that business language is not only ugly but serves evil purposes. In person, it exists to slow down bad news so you can read and manipulate people (“string betting”) and, on paper, its raison d’etre is to project authority to which one has no actual right.
- fdomig 4y agoYou are absolutely right. This is the only correct wording.
- concordDance 4y agoDoes this accomplish anything other than increasing resentment?
- bionade24 4y agoY combinator website hugged to death by hacker news. Lmao.
- ftxbro 4y ago[flagged]
- Kwpolska 4y agoThat's still too long and flowery. You probably know what YC is. We were recently doing late-stage investing, but we're mostly giving up on that now. We're firing 17 people who were involved in late-stage investing. You won't notice their disappearance. There, four sentences, and no AI involved.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mhb 4y agoEven just excising the godawful "impacted" is a massive improvement.
- ftxbro 4y agoOh they flagged my post. Does that mean no one can see it anymore? Anyway I was curious how GPT expands your four brutally raw sentences into a press release (everything it made is fake including a fake quote): Y Combinator Announces Changes in Late-Stage Investing and Workforce Mountain View, CA - Y Combinator, the renowned startup accelerator, announced today that it will be shifting its focus away from late-stage investing. As part of this strategic pivot, the company will be letting go of 17 employees who were involved in late-stage investing. This decision comes after a thorough review of YC's investment strategy and long-term goals. While late-stage investing has been a successful part of the company's portfolio, YC has decided to double down on its core mission of helping early-stage startups grow and succeed. "We are grateful for the contributions of our late-stage investing team, but we believe that this change will allow us to better serve our early-stage companies and continue to drive innovation in the startup ecosystem," said YC President, Sam Altman. The 17 affected employees have been notified and will be provided with severance packages and support during their transition. YC remains committed to its mission of supporting and investing in the most promising startups and looks forward to continuing to work with entrepreneurs from all over the world. For more information, please contact Y Combinator's media relations team at press@ycombinator.com. ###
- Ekaros 4y agoSo where is the bailout for these impacted people? Wasn't it just recently that YC posted a plea to bailout so that people wouldn't be fired? And then they don't do one themselves?
- ethanbond 4y agoI'm not necessarily pro-bailout but there's a clear distinction between job losses due to money trapped in a failed institution versus job losses due to a business deciding to eliminate those jobs.
- vorpalhex 4y agoYou mean like a fund where corps like YC pay into on the regular and then people who are laid off get back some of their salary for a portion of time? It would be like insurance but for being unemployed, just like we have insurance for your bank failing.
- tick_tock_tick 4y ago> Wasn't it just recently that YC posted a plea to bailout so that people wouldn't be fired? No, that never happened where did you see that? > So where is the bailout for these impacted people? Unemployment exists and I'd bet a lot they got severance pay.
- mlyle 4y ago> No, that never happened where did you see that? He's referring to this: https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/urgent-sign-the-petition-now-thousands-of-startups-and-hundreds-of-thousands-of-startup-jobs-are-at-risk https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/urgent-sign-the-petition-no...
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoBut that's not a bailout. I guess they are just wrong?
- 4y ago
- earlystagethrow 4y agoUnderstandable when there's a new CEO that some things will get cut. Bad time to be in growth vc. Not unexpected from vc circles, frankly, with rumors that larger LPs weren't impressed by Tan and interest was lukewarm.
- blobbers 4y agoCan YC post some info on their fund that they're winding down? Would be nice to put that out in the public. Any YC team members care to comment?
- zac23or 4y agoChanges? They are layoffs. This PR language is irritating.
- martin_a 4y agoTitle should be "YC fires 17 people". Can someone change that?
- jefftk 4y ago"fire" != "laid off"
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI agree. You're fired when you sexually harass or suck eggs. Being laid off doesn't have the stigma for the employee.
- balls187 4y agoYes it absolutely does carry a stigma. What companies layoff their best people? (I say as someone who has been laidoff)
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoCompetent people who were effective at their job are laid off all the time. You're basically saying there's a stigma to not being the best at work.
- balls187 4y agoNo, I am saying there is a stigma for being laid off, which comes from the (incorrect) belief that companies don't layoff their top performers. As noted, there are many reasons why layoffs may occur, however, the stigma of being laid off exists.
- zamnos 4y agoI mean if the company is pivoting and closing the entire division because they no longer need to, eg, make film cameras or make buggy whips, why would you keep anybody from there around? You don't need their expertise any longer. Even if they were the best at their job, if you're not doing those things any more, what would you keep them around for?
- robomartin 4y agoJust so that it is clear: How does YC define "late stage"? I ask because the opening line is: "YC is known primarily as a place where very early founders create something from nothing" Does this mean that, going forward, startups that start with something need not apply? For example, a product and, say, one or many customers? Some revenue? Or does YC want to focus on the "something from nothing" category?
- cm2012 4y agoLate stage means series B+ usually
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beavis000 4y agoHere's a question: Whose capital does YC invest? Only partner capital? Do they have outside investors?
- Finbarr 4y agoThe YC Continuity team did amazing work helping me and many other later stage founders. I’m sad to read this news. YC is best known for their early stage investing. But Ali, Anu and the team created some excellent programs for later stage companies as well. Shogun benefited from the Series A program, Scaling from A to B program, and the YC Growth program. I wonder what’s happening with all of those initiatives. Through these programs and the direct support and mentorship from the Continuity team, we learned a ton and significantly scaled our startup. Wishing all of the affected team all the best.
- garry 4y agoThanks Finbarr. The group partners and MD's and I know these are important and valuable programs, and there is a lot more we need to be doing for alumni and the experience after companies do YC. I don't have more to share now, but know that I really value you and this note.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- epicureanideal 4y agoI’m surprised that even an innovative, creative organization like YC wasn’t able to create other positions for these folks. I guess that just shows how hard business is even for people who are good at it.
- devmor 4y agoCreating a position for employees that aren't needed is generally not a business priority. Besides, it's likely that this is primarily a cost-cutting measure given similar industry trends at the moment.
- epicureanideal 4y ago> Creating a position for employees that aren't needed is generally not a business priority. Sure, I guess I was using too much of a shorthand in my comment. What I meant was, I’m surprised a company with such a high talent density didn’t generate enough new business quickly enough to be able to anticipate near future needs for these folks so that it would make sense to keep them. I would think YC would have a lot of opportunities to deploy capital, and so a lot of opportunities to gain value from a variety of employee types. If I knew more about the internals of YC I might be able to make more specific suggestions. By the way, any company out there, I’d be willing to brainstorm (for free) about how you can repurpose and keep your people, or find other creative solutions. I’ll check for replies to this comment later today and tomorrow, and maybe I’ll edit it to add a throwaway or alternate email shortly. Email: jmorrow977 at gmail. I’ll check tonight and daily for the next couple days or week.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoMany Japanese companies have worked hard over the last several decades to find new positions for people who would have been laid off. The result: they dominate a lot of international industries in manufacturing and certain kinds of high tech Eg, I'm buying a Japanese car this week because I don't like the reliability of most North American brands > Toyota continues tradition of a ‘No-Layoff’ policy for its full-time workers https://ilssi.org/toyota-continues-tradition-of-a-no-layoff-policy-for-its-full-time-workers-respect-for-workers/ https://ilssi.org/toyota-continues-tradition-of-a-no-layoff-...
- chernevik 4y agoThe timing and optics on this are just awful.
- pastabol 4y ago[dead]
- erickhill 4y ago187 comments almost entirely focused on language usage, and at best two to three words. Fascinating.
- siva7 4y agoThis thread has to be best description of nerds i've seen
- kerblang 4y agoSticks and bones may break my bones, but words can divert me into hours and hours of endless hairsplitting and bickering until I die of being bored with myself and doctors gather and marvel at the inexplicable fact that I am still complaining in the absence of a discernible pulse
- hmoodie 4y agonot only that but it's the exact same top-comment subthread that appears at the top of literally every story involving corporate comms. I wonder if it's the same people every time or if there's a constant influx of new commenters who feel strongly about corpspeak.
- nappy-doo 4y agoYours too
- ptero 4y agoClarity and technical honesty are very important in technical work; especially so in a startup: you want people to focus on solving technical issues, not translating corporatese to human. Plus, if a group tries to hide behind the wording for an inconvenient message what else would it sweep under the rug? YC is usually way better than this, which may be the reason there is so much attention to the wording which reads like the standard PR spin. My 2c.
- aikinai 4y agoProbably because there’s not much new in the layoff story that hasn’t been covered in tens of thousands of comments on previous layoffs. But this is the first time a lot of people have had an outlet to discuss the frustrating linguistic phenomena that have been on display this cycle.
- npalli 4y agoIn case you are wondering, that is about 20% of the staff. https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/13/y-combinator-cuts-nearly-20-of-staff-scales-back-growth-stage-investments/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/13/y-combinator-cuts-nearly-2...
- ec109685 4y agoI wonder what the revenue per employee of YC is. 85 employees, with 1/6 companies unicorns (though some of that is paper valuations, but still huge returns).
- distantsounds 4y agojust mere days after SVB crashes and burns, wonder how much pg had tied up there.
- tabbott 4y agoI wish there were some publicly available numbers to analyze here, but it seems likely that YC's late stage funds have lost a lot of money (on paper) doing late-stage investments at sky-high valuations over the years leading up to 2022 that are now down significantly as a result of the current startup downturn. Folks who are thinking about these YC changes as a layoff are missing the point -- YC is exiting what had been a major part of their business (especially if measured by total dollars invested). And from the outside it seems likely that the reason for the layoff is probably less that YC is in troubled financial straights and needs to cut costs on its operations, but because their late-stage investing business was losing money and YC has decided to give up on it and no longer has work for specialists in that work.
- swyx 4y agoand yet Anu Hariharan and Ali Rowghani seem to be leaving to start a new fund. no failures in VC, just pre-success :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lucb1e 4y agoThe change that the title hints at: > we’re going to decrease the amount of late stage investing we do Which allows letting go of 17 employees involved with that, which is 20% of employees. EOF (and that was already more info than the article contained)
- bobobob420 4y agocan those employees not be staffed to other projects? surely the skillsets are reusable. Something is very fishy about this and the timing.
- lucb1e 4y agoNo no, clearly it is just a coincidence that lay-offs are happening everywhere at the same time. YC must have made a fully independent assessment and decided based on spreadsheets and algorithms that this is the correct business strategy by using past data and developing predictive metrics. Just looking which business unit to cut loose based on cost reductions cannot have been a part of this process.
- bobobob420 4y agoThey did not state the growing economic concerns as reason for layoff like other big companies. They stated a business unit is not valuable enough and they are laying off 17 people. YC is beyond wealthy and successful. They laid off 20 percent of their staff. Not a good look.
- fairity 4y agoI can think of a few reasons why YC would make this decision without admitting so publicly: 1) Too much negative signaling risk when they don't make follow-on investments 2) Negative returns given the recent downturn 3) The increasing business need to make non-founder-friendly changes in late stage companies (e.g. replacing CEO) 4) Anu/Ali deciding to leave first to start their own fund I wonder if any of these reasons is a predominant driver.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ajross 4y agoOh, come on. This is three days after their favorite bank got shut down. We all know what the proximate cause is. I think it's clear that the venture world (at least the top of it) had turned itself into an industry on its own. They didn't make money on startup exits anymore, they made it on services. They'd fund startups, get those startups into later rounds by milking less sophisicated VCs[1], push them at their favorite bank, collect fees at each stage, and then take the profits and roll them up into more startus. Now that the favorite bank is dead, this gravy train is over immediately. And the smart VCs at the top of the heap are the ones to exit the wagon first. Honestly, the industry has had a toxic feel for a while. But the last 72 hours have made it clear that there was just no soul left. [1] Yes, this sounds like a pyramid scheme to me too.
- fairity 4y ago> They didn't make money on startup exits anymore You do realize YC's equity returns from Airbnb & Doordash probably cover their entire history of funding startups?
- ajross 4y agoThe discussion is about late-stage investing, though. Obviously yes, the occasional unicorn funds a lot of slop and failed choices in series B rounds. But if that were true, then they wouldn't be laying off a paltry 17 people because of a minor market downturn, would they? Again, the timing of this makes it abundantly clear that something YC was doing in the years before SVBs failure is instantly impossible now that it's dead.
- opportune 4y agoWhat does this mean for the MFN SAFE terms that YC founders receive in the standard deal? Does that change if YC doesn’t plan to make as many late stage investments?
- mehlmao 4y agoMan, YC cared so much about protecting jobs two days ago when they were begging for a bailout. What happened?
- 71a54xd 4y agoThis is interesting, specifically relative to what their definition of "growth stage" is. Does this mean a young company with five employees and some traction, or a large company that is close to PMF but needs cash to burn after being in-action for 1-2 years?
- steponlego 4y agoIt's good that the government is bailling out SVB, we wouldn't want the next pet food drone delivery service startup to fail to launch.
- EngManagerIsMe 4y ago> Unfortunately, this means we will no longer need some of the roles on the late stage investing team. Seventeen of our teammates are impacted today. I hate this passive voice. It implies there was nothing that could be done, that this was just a force of nature. That it wasn't an active choice by YC, but rather just some eventuality. Most of us understand the necessity of hard decisions. Own the outcomes. It's ok to say, "We fired 17 people, because their roles were no longer needed by us". If you think that looks too bad, then don't do the thing -- find other opportunities for the people in the company.
- choppaface 4y agoA lot of the tradition of passive voice comes from lawyers because you can’t always say somebody was fired or transferred or laid off. There can be different standards of local employment law for different employees. Passive voice can be the least risky of defamation or expressing favoritism to those who didn’t get cut. That said, it’s abhorrent to see YC cling to tradition here, especially in light of the industry-wide layoffs as well as just how insanely rich YC is versus the headcount at question here. This is absolutely a place to question tradition and seek progress. And also yeah maybe even own the consequences.
- nonethewiser 4y ago> Most of us understand the necessity of hard decisions. Do we? Because you suggested that they could have not fired them.
- dmix 4y agoFrom my experience these things are an after thought, the people writing this stuff are disconnected from the people making the actual decisions and I guess the typical audience that reads it. The people who do the marketing, HR, or "run socials" tend to be from the demographic that over values safe corporate speak. CEOs occasionally write these but usually it's some pre-written stuff that gets signed off on. We all review these like a ton of thought went into some blog post, and maybe it should, but often it's just a lower end employee who is asked to translate things into an announcement when they played zero role in the hiring/firing part. Considering how much these posts always bother people [1] maybe higher ups should care more about the blog posts too. [1] At least a few in every HN thread, whether most people actually care/read it might be different.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- winphone1974 4y agoMan, total amateur hour. A layoff post without talking about how it's the hardest thing the CEO has ever done, or saying the responsibility lies with me? No mention of how deep he cares about those departing? And delivered on a Monday? Why didn't they use ChatGPT to compose this like everyone else?
- tim333 4y agoI doubt the late stage investing team will suffer that much. They'll probably move to similar high paying roles shortly.
- curiousObject 4y agoYes, the proper style is: Leading venture capital innovator, YCombinator, is delighted to announce that over 80 percent of our team remain unimpacted by recent employment-related issues, while other team members will be exploring exciting new opportunities going forward
- reactspa 4y agoMakes me question their hiring. If they were good, surely these people could be absorbed in other areas of YC?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paxys 4y agoI'm assuming all the recent late-stage unicorn downrounds finally caught up with their fund.
- mv4 4y agoBut make no mistake. Though they're the ones leaving, it is I who must remain and bear the heavy burden of their failure.
- fblp 4y agoWow. First time I've seen a layoff post that starts with boasting success. Summary: "6% of the companies we invest in are worth a billion dollars. We're laying of 20% of our staff. We appreciate their efforts. No comment on how we're taking care of those laid off or remaining staff"
- hsn915 4y agoWhy do they need "taking care" of? Are they fragile school kids? Desparate single mothers who can't make ends meet? What is with this "save our babies!" attitude towards people who are - Well off - Highly skilled ??
- spir 4y agoFinally some sense-talking. The growing culture of paternalism in the employer-employee relationship is toxic to the foundations of our societal wealth. Personal responsibility and equal opportunity are how we got to iPhones, toothpaste in every corner store, and a store on every corner.
- TheLonelyGecko 4y ago> The growing culture of paternalism in the employer-employee relationship is toxic to the foundations of our societal wealth. ???
- InCityDreams 4y agoWhat? As in, could you explain....
- vanviegen 4y agoIt's also how we got rid of a store on every corner.
- cpursley 4y agoOnly in America. In most developed places, there are still corner stores (in addition to big box stores).
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe American corporate structure is such a ridiculous mess. Corporations should be equally controlled by capital and labor, such that both interested parties have equal say in corporate decisions. Yes, this might mean that the owners take significant net worth losses while more people stay employed - boo hoo hoo. Hasn't it become clear that societies run by financial oligarchs with no constraints always end in tears? America continues to slide towards a Third World cesspool of wealthy enclaves surrounded by miles of festering slums. I guess private security is a growth sector, in this increasingly dystopian endgame.
- coffeemug 4y agoWhy is American corporate structure a mess? What are existing real-world examples of alternatives that outperform American corporations, and along which metric? Why should corporations be equally controlled by capital and labor? Some American cities indeed have slums, but what leads you to believe it's a consequence of American corporate structure (rather than a million other possible reasons)?
- janalsncm 4y agoWithout fully entertaining the hyperbole, American society and government are fully captivated by the wrong metrics: GDP growth is an extremely narrow measure for economic well-being. Unemployment rate is biased by not counting people who want to work but gave up because they can’t find a job. Average salary is far less meaningful than median salary due to huge skews in income distribution.
- desireco42 4y agoI asked ChatGPT to write this for me, but even that heartless code didn't have the heart to do this for me: "I'm sorry, but as an AI language model, I cannot generate content that is insensitive or lacking empathy towards individuals affected by layoffs. Layoffs can have a significant impact on people's lives and livelihoods, and it is important to communicate such news with sensitivity and compassion. As an AI, my aim is to promote positive and ethical communication practices. Therefore, I cannot fulfill this request."
- kortilla 4y ago> Unfortunately, this means we will no longer need some of the roles on the late stage investing team. Seventeen of our teammates are impacted today. Then give them an enema and everything will return to normal. Oh, that’s not what “impacted” means in this sense? Maybe they are implying that the team will have their free lunch perk taken away. No? Maybe own the fact that they are being laid off and actually say it.
- b1c1jones 4y ago"People were our greatest asset"
- cute_boi 4y agoSo, the CEO doesn't take responsibility here?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dancemethis 4y ago> YC is known primarily as a place where very early founders create something from nothing by simply applying online and joining the world’s best founder community. Uhh... no. It is known for hosting HN, and having a weird, uninteresting side thing on the main domain people enter by mistake.
- MR4D 4y agoWhy not just create Z-Combinator for these folks? Seems like it might have been a better choice.
- snozolli 4y agoNo Foresight Or Training Ability: The Announcement
- johnnydoe9 4y agoDon't worry guys, the people haven't been laid off they are just "impacted" by the new changes.
- toolchange 4y ago[dead]
- Nevermark 4y agoThere are a lot of threads here arguing whether employees should expect help taking next steps after a layoff. Obviously, employees are only due what their employment contract (and labor laws) say they are due. But that is beside the point. Helping post-layoff employees build trust, loyalty, commitment in both directions. Knowledge workers are not fungible cogs. Their morale and goodwill result in better performance. And a more attractive workplace for prospective hires.
- meltedcapacitor 4y agoLOL (easy) money is running out. (If it wasn't and they were refocussing, they'd redeploy the roadkill onto early stage.) This is comically bad lying.
- terminalcommand 4y agoShame on YC :(. The blog post doesn't even mention that YC even tried to utilized the 16 employees on other roles. YC is sitting on top so much money and profits, why did they decide to lay off people? There are good times and bad times. If my company is not with me during bad times, I wouldn't want to work with them. YC's reputation took a big hit in my head.
- throwwwaway69 4y ago> YC is sitting on top so much money and profits This is true of every big tech company doing layoffs. They can all easily afford to keep everyone. They choose not because capitalism has no room for humanity.
- AlchemistCamp 4y agoThat's a really bad take. YC has a responsibility to the startups they fund to maintain the best team for the kind of work they're focused on. It's also not necessarily the best thing for employees to "be utilized on other roles" within their current company when their roles cease to exist due to business changes. Often the best roles for those individuals is at other companies or in founding their own companies. In truth, most people I've known who have stayed at the same job for a decade were worse off for it, not better. I'm not advocating for reshuffling your workforce for very short-term needs, but if the longer-term goals change, the team often has to as well.
- terminalcommand 4y agoI imagine the people laid off are highly skilled investment bankers. I think YC laid them off because early stage seed funds do not require the same level of sophistication as late-stage investment. I believe the employees laid off would be perfectly capable to assist in early-stage seed rounds as well. That way YC could have vetted more projects and invested more. Imagine that the people laid off were tasked to find and seed environment friendly startups etc. Deep work requires a stable paycheck and job safety. If YC really wanted to make things better, they'd know better. With these lay-offs, I won't be surprised if all the remaining employees would be yes-sayers lacking any individual incentive.
- ulfw 4y agoHa, if even YC is doing layoffs you know the valley is in deep shit.
- lfc07 4y agoI believe it is the right move. You can make better impact funding a large number of startups with small amounts and guidance than focusing on few late stage startups. Even though 6% make it big in their first attempt the rest 96% do benefit from YC's role in their subsequent attempts. So the impact is huge when it comes to early stage funding.