13 ms·
What does Silicon Valley Bank’s collapse mean for the financial system?
- zabzonk 4y ago[flagged]
- tomhoward 4y agoIs there any point to this comment other than snarkily signaling contempt for anything to do with Silicon Valley? Do you have any thoughts about what nascent startups should have done with respect to banking when other banks wouldn’t help them?
- aaomidi 4y agoWhat banks are saying no to money?
- tomhoward 4y agoPlenty of banks will refuse to do business with, or impose onerous conditions on, companies with such characteristics as: - founders from outside the U.S. or from certain countries - operations/investments in certain countries - operations in certain industries/market segments (including ones that are completely legal but are considered high-risk) - founders/directors with previous bankruptcies/insolvencies or any criminal history - activities anywhere near any legal grey areas or risks including things like cannabis or hallucinogenic substance sales/research even if legal in the company’s region of operations Those come to mind now but I’m sure there are others. It’s not just about accepting deposits but offering lines of credit, credit cards even with low balances, international transfers, insurance and other services crucial to the smooth functioning of a company. Banks are inherently risk averse, and mainstream banks just don’t have the expertise or resources to look at startups and evaluate their risk profile, so will just refuse service based on anything slightly outside very narrow safety criteria. Silicon Valley Bank is a bank too and still has to be quite conservative, but has been far more willing to do the work to accommodate the more risky/unconventional aspects inherent to startups. A low-quality take is that if a company is in any way suspect it doesn’t deserve to be in business, but that position just wipes out swathes of innovation, research and wealth creation, and leads to a scenario where only people who are already rich (and American) can start startups.
- replygirl 4y agothis was my reaction too. but TIL a lot of people around me took it seriously
- twblalock 4y agoIt is (was) a bank in Silicon Valley that primarily served businesses in the tech sector. What's weird about that?
- rixrax 4y agoSort of related question, if you have a brokerage account in a bank that goes the way of the SVB, what happens to the securities account? Will it get liquidated and you will then eventually be paid some cents on a dollar of your brokerage accounts value?
- dr_dshiv 4y agoA cliff, not a valley?
- alex_young 4y agoYou see a price recovery for $SIVB?
- TacticalCoder 4y agoParent is quoting the name of the graph in the article from The Economist showing the value going from it's peak to nothing, no need to downvote him.
- nmca 4y agohttps://archive.is/Qg2FI https://archive.is/Qg2FI
- greenthrow 4y agoIf i screw up my investments i am stuck with the consequences. SVB screws up and we are all forced to bail them out? No thank you.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoYou’re not bailing them out, you’re bailing out their depositors who had no say in the investments. The principals of SVB just lost it all to the FDIC, they weren’t bailed out in the least.
- greenthrow 4y agoRead the article. I am not talking about FDIC insurance. I am talking about the bailout that is discussed at towards the end of the article.
- crazygringo 4y agoThe article is talking about a bailout of depositors, not investors. Not letting the bank fail is a form of bankruptcy in a way. The owners lose most or all of the value of their ownership, but the bank is sold to new owners so it can continue to run.
- dsugarman 4y agoThat's not how this article reads, I think the right course of action would be to make the depositors whole and let the bank fail.
- mertd 4y agoThat's exactly what's happening but many depositors need to be "made whole" faster than the liquidation would allow because they need to make payroll in literally a few days time.
- bagels 4y agoMost of them don't need to be made whole to make payroll in the short term. The FDIC is talking about a dividend for next week.
- rvz 4y agoAsk Stripe. They are strangely quiet today.
- kashnote 4y agoThey actually sent out an email about 2 hours ago: Hello, Silicon Valley Bank was taken over by the FDIC [0] today, Friday March 10th. We’re monitoring the situation closely and it saddens us to see the closure of a bank that partnered with many of you. If you’re impacted by the SVB closure and need to open a new bank account, we are here to guide you through it. Choosing a banking partner - We’ve worked with startup-friendly banking partners like Mercury (mercury.com/partner/atlas) and Novo (novo.co/a/stripe-atlas) to get Stripe Atlas companies priority access to signing up. - You can also choose to use any bank such as JP Morgan Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, or PNC, and often your personal bank offers business services.
- loopdoend 4y agoNever mind
- xur17 4y agoThis implies they are: https://mercury.com/security https://mercury.com/security
- tekla 4y agoSeems like they're doing some shenanigans to be able to say that *Mercury is a financial technology company, not a bank
- darkerside 4y agoProbably just means they partner with a bank on the back end to custody your assets. It's not uncommon for neobanks.
- DesertVarnish 4y ago
- cm2187 4y agoI wonder why they were not bailed in.
- stuckkeys 4y agoThey fucked with the wrong people, that is why. I just hope this is not a chain reaction. 2008 all over again, but this time it is going to be extra juicy. Alot of shady stuff is going to be unveiled in the next few months.
- nradov 4y agoWhy would they be bailed in? SVB is not systemically important. The FDIC will wind it up just like any other small failed bank.
- cm2187 4y ago200bn assets is a big bank. Lehman was 600bn and look what it caused.
- timy2shoes 4y agoLehman was a symptom of a larger problem associated with mortgage backed securities, not a cause of the problem.
- TheAlchemist 4y agoFunnily enough, the root cause of the problem for SVP are ... mortgage backed securities !
- giantrobot 4y agoSo you're saying I should invest heavily into mortgage backed securities? Got it!
- hedora 4y ago
- ofchnofc 4y ago[dead]
- paulpauper 4y agoWhen Peter Thiel yesterday said to get out it probably made things worse by having to sell assets at worse prices. People got spooked.
- twelve40 4y agoits fate was sealed way before that and if Thiel instead advised everyone to stay with the bank it would have only prolonged the agony, with more people losing their money
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hummus_bae 4y ago[dead]
- g42gregory 4y agoHere is what I don't understand: How is this even possible? If SVB buys $100B worth of (10yr?) T-Bonds and MBS, this will immediately show up as an enormous interest rate risk position on their internal risk profile. The Bank's Risk Manager, CEO and Management Committee are supposed to look at these things every day and should have very specific guidelines on market risk exposure bounds. Regardless of what those guidelines were, presumably $100B worth of 10-yr unhedged fixed income instruments will be way out of those bounds. How was this missed? This is not some sophisticated high finance, this is basics. What on earth happened?
- eclipticplane 4y agohttps://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/svb-hires-kim-olson-as-chief-risk-officer-301711529.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/svb-hires-kim-olson... - Jan 2023 The previous CRO resigned in April 2022.
- g42gregory 4y agoWow. I am guessing they discovered this mess in early 2022. The CRO bailed or was pushed out. They couldn't hire anyone qualified, once they've seen the balance sheet (or were refused to be shown the balance sheet, which would be a red flag). Tried to unwind the position throughout the 2022, but couldn't, with the rising interest rates.
- pgwhalen 4y agoThis is an interesting story but I'm not sure it adds up. What does it mean that they "tried to unwind the position"? It doesn't really make sense that you could fail to unwind a position in some of the most liquid markets in the world, over the course of a year. Maybe it wouldn't be at the desired price, but if they understood the risk as you imply, they'd just do the trade.
- tomca32 4y agoWhat are you going to do with MBS that aggregated averaged a yield of 1.5% when anyone can get a risk free bond returning over 3% now? Who’s going to buy your mortgages?
- nostromo 4y agoWhat a total clusterfuck from so many VCs. There was a moment where they could have mustered up a bridge loan to SVB, probably at very favorable terms, saved their companies and acquired some decent assets while they're at it. Instead they DDOSed their own bank, tanked a large portion of their portfolio, and now are asking for a bailout. It seems like the VCs should shore up their companies until SVB is wound down or take the losses. It's not like they don't have the capital.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> was a moment where they could have mustered up a bridge loan to SVB, probably at very favorable terms, saved their companies and acquired some decent assets while they're at it One, they couldn’t. It’soutside their mandates; they’d have to raise new funds from LPs. Two, why? Just have your start-ups pull their capital and bank with the countless other banks providing the same services as SVB.
- twelve40 4y agoif a bank becomes so toxic that FDIC had to parachute in in the middle of the day (couldn't even wait til closing) and shut it down, how can this bank be saved with a bridge loan? > SVB “didn’t have nearly as much capital as an institution that risky should have had” https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-10/svb-spectacularly-fails-after-unthinkable-heresy-becomes-reality https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-10/svb-spect... blaming the customers for wanting to save their money and claiming as if they were the cause of the bank's recklessness seems really strange.
- MrLeap 4y agoIf they had more capital, wouldn't that have made them _less risky_? Sounds like a tautology!
- vineyardmike 4y agoThey can be risky for other behavior, necessitating capital. If they held less "risky" securities, they wouldn't need incoming cash. Cash makes the risk go away, but so does holding other better assets.
- jacknews 4y agoThis seems to me like a crisis caused by the fed, and their ill-advised focus on inflation.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI might believe that if all banks were failing.
- jacknews 4y agoI have a bucket of popcorn for the coming week...
- dmn322 4y agoIt’s on purpose. They knew what they were doing
- jacknews 4y agohttps://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2023/03/silicon-valley-bank-fails-with-deposits-of-many-venture-backed-companies-frozen-how-bad-will-the-fallout-be.html https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2023/03/silicon-valley-bank-... "Christopher Whaler, Chairman of Whalen Global Advisors in New York, said: ‘I think the Fed badly miscalculated the impact of rising interest rates and so these are self-inflicted wounds and if we see more banks fail then the Fed is faced with a very tough situation which may force them to drop interest rates.’"
- treebeard901 4y agoAn unexpected side effect of continued employment gains is that the employees expect to be paid... A series of bank failures puts payroll in doubt, and could quickly lock up the system with extreme inflation and a liquidity crisis. More money will be created to bail out the banks which will cause more inflation and more inflation will mean higher rates to fight it, which could freeze credit more and draw down savings and so on, all of which leads to more job losses and liquidity problems. It's numerous things in a feedback loop and if the bank runs and failures continue to spread then it's going to put serious strain on a system that never fully recovered from 2008. The reverse repo rates are kind of fascinating when you look at what happened around 2007 and where it is today. Maybe SVB is an outlier and can be contained but another hidden issue is how much Fintech has worked its way into normal finance. There are many online only banks and companies like Chime and Cash app which could broaden a crash. I really believe we are about to experience a financial crisis worse than anyone alive has experienced. It will be unique as well in that so many of these factors have never happened before or all simultaneously. This also doesn't consider global reserve currency changes and ways for the world to conduct trade without the U.S. financial system being involved. All of this provided liquidity in the past, the safe haven effect and so on. Or maybe a few banks will get bailed out and it will be no worse than the savings and loan crisis. The next few months should get interesting. Oh and if that's not enough, there is the potential for Ukraine to do poorly in the summer and a potential conflict with China on the horizon. The U.S. could be in a two front war with near peer competitors at a debt to GDP ratio higher than at its highest point during WW2. Quantitative easing kicked the bucket down the road but it seems to have been a band aid only making the disease worse in the long run.
- ok_computer 4y ago(I hope this comment doesn’t age poorly.) Lessons were learned following the 2008 financial crisis to sure up major banking risk exposure. Dodd Frank act was reversed a little but there are regulations and stress test simulations to improve banking system resilience if there is a cash or credit shortage. Who knows how valid some of the assumptions changes in these marginally higher interest rate times but we cannot be in pre-2008 credit swap nonsense. SVB represents $200B assets and the customers are in large part revenue negative or growing startups. That doesn’t make it Ok but it cannot be representative of the greater economy. I’m sure fintech in personal banking, credit, and mortgages is far more popular than it was in the 2000’s but it by and large does not represent a majority or even large minority of retail banking. My hope is there isn’t some sneaky financial engineering marvel in large corporate debt that this fringe instability snowballs and we find out we’re back in a state where the market is propped up by sketchy extrapolations of value estimates. But I don’t think a bank run by a bunch of VCs or startups is a picture of the greater economic engine.
- dmfdmf 4y agoFrom the Article> Thankfully, loan books make up a much larger share of assets at most other institutions. I got a laugh on this one. Sure... other banks are safe from loss of client deposits and a bad bet that interest rates won't rise. I'm not so sure that with rising interest rates and a shaky economy these institutions with large loan books won't see too many loan defaults. We are seeing a lot of commercial property defaults already in the big markets. Can't pay your mortgage if you can rent out your skyscapper.
- hedora 4y agoPeople holding large fixed rate loans are extremely unlikely to refinance, and are likely to weather inflation and rising interest rates pretty well. It’s almost as good as buying bonds! No one’s gone broke doing that, right?
- dmfdmf 4y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear. With the rising inflation and interest rates and deteriorating economy people lose their jobs and can't pay their mortgage. My point, and why I thought the line was funny in that article, is that the way SVB failed isn't the only way that banks can fail. Moreover, Tech is currently in a massive round of layoffs and if this spreads to the general economy (which I think it will) then holding large loan balances could become a problem for the banks.
- locusm 4y agoWhat regulation was watered down that ultimately led to this?
- Redoubts 4y agoBasel III https://www.ft.com/content/c95e7708-b903-405d-a017-963844eb3dc3 https://www.ft.com/content/c95e7708-b903-405d-a017-963844eb3...
- not_the_fda 4y agoLoopholes in Basel III. Community banks have been arguing the rules don't apply to them. https://www.ft.com/content/c95e7708-b903-405d-a017-963844eb3dc3 https://www.ft.com/content/c95e7708-b903-405d-a017-963844eb3...
- woeirua 4y agoThere’s definitely going to be some major fallout from this. I don’t think SVB will be bought, and depositors certainly are not going to be made whole anytime soon. Why? Well check out SVBs most recent 10-Q. Everyone knows they had $90B in MBS but most people haven’t commented on the fact that they also had $70B in loans as part of their assets. Normally loans are considered pretty safe assets, but as others have commented a good part of these loans are to the same depositors (startups) that SVB owes money to. Additionally SVB lent money to founders to buy homes, cars, etc. Hopefully you can see where this is going now… The real question is going to be how much if any of those loans SVB can recover to cover their deposits. This could mean calling in all kinds of credit instruments from startups that are ill prepared to suddenly pay them back. Unless the loans are forgiven, in addition to making the depositors whole, SVB will still take a whole bunch of startups down with it. Those companies vendors will feel the hit too. It may take some time for the full repercussions to be felt but this is going to be a big deal. Also, for those of you who didn’t live through 2008, there were plenty of people who assured everyone that everything was OK right until the music stopped.
- ericmay 4y ago> Unless the loans are forgiven, in addition to making the depositors whole, SVB will still take a whole bunch of startups down with it. This is fine. Healthy even. There are risks inherent with investing whether that’s a startup or otherwise and so letting them fail leads to better, safer, and more innovative business models that don’t rely on low interest rates and excess cash. Ultimately SVB isn’t contagion because SVB unlike many other banks was heavily reliant on investments and securities that were highly exposed to interest rate increases. Shit happens. Businesses including banks and startups fail. World keeps spinning. Any argument for bailing out investors here is an equal argument for bailing out homeowners or any other person who was affected by high interest rates for any reason.
- hedora 4y agoThis isn’t a case of startups failing for being poorly run. In some cases, the issue is literally (using small numbers to make it work for individuals), you have a steady job, $200K in the bank and owe $200K in loans, partially secured by the cash and partially by your income. Tomorrow, the bank calls, and says “we spent your future paychecks and life savings, so we really need you to continue making payments on that loan”.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoThe answer of course is nothing. But it's worth it to read the article to get to this gem of a final sentence. "Larry Summers, a former treasury secretary, has said that so long as the state steps in, there is no reason to worry that svb will harm other parts of the financial system. Lots of people will be hoping that it does, and that he is right. fS" Nevermind that no one outside of the "tech" company crowd cares what Larry Summers thinks, the sentence is cringingly ambiguous. What does "it" refer to: (a) the state stepping in or (b) SVB harming other parts of the financial system. Did ChatGPT produce this article. Not only is there no need to worry about SVB harming other parts of the financial system, there is no need to read "articles" like this one. The amount of useful information is negligible.
- synu 4y agoWhat was the question for which the answer is no?
- jcadam 4y agoI've got some really bad news: Earlier today, Jim Cramer tweeted "JP Morgan is a fortress" https://twitter.com/jimcramer/status/1634222320398086145?s=20 https://twitter.com/jimcramer/status/1634222320398086145?s=2...
- smallnix 4y agoWhat does that mean?
- pharmakom 4y agoInverse Cramer
- hypothesis 4y agoApparently, he was recently hyping up SVB, the one that just went under.
- remarkEon 4y agohttps://twitter.com/WatcherGuru/status/1634039856924860416 https://twitter.com/WatcherGuru/status/1634039856924860416
- xg15 4y agoI think that guy's financial advice is so legendarily bad that people are using him as a predictor of what will not happen. In this case, certain banks staying solvent... https://mobile.twitter.com/CramerTracker https://mobile.twitter.com/CramerTracker
- Balgair 4y agoPet Theory: Cramer being very bad is part of his appeal. If he was giving out good advice, then who would watch him? Just like Howard Stern was back in the day, you watch Cramer to see what stupid idea he's got next and the anger at his finely calibrated dumb being so widely broadcast is what keeps you coming back. Honestly, it's a great shtick, hard to pull off or replicate for so long.
- DeathArrow 4y agoWho cares about the financial system? What does it mean for the startup sector and companies that trusted SVB with their money? And what if SVB is just the tip of the iceberg? Maybe the governments should start better regulating and supervising the banksters and offer no bailouts using public money. Let the wrong doers be the only ones suffering from their mistakes.
- philjohn 4y agoI mean - if we have another widespread banking crisis, people will die - literally. When GDP falls, excess deaths go up.
- rco8786 4y ago> And what if SVB is just the tip of the iceberg? > Who cares about the financial system? Genuinely confused. We care about the financial system because “what if svb is just the tip of the iceberg”
- jzellis 4y agoWait until spooked investors start looking at other banks and realizing how much they've sunk into agricultural mortgage backed assets, when half of American ag is facing the largest megadrought since the Byzantine Empire was a thing and the other half doesn't know what it's facing because tornadoes and floods knocked it ass over teakettle. Not to mention all the billions invested into property development in the Colorado River Basin. Ooops! Tee hee.
- replwoacause 4y agoMy wife's employer banks with SVB. I'm still trying to understand the implications for her and her colleagues. It's hard to imagine they won't be affected.
- Simplicitas 4y agoMaybe another reminder that we Americans really need the Glass-Steagall Act back.