17 ms·
Introducing the HUD. Say hello to the future of the menu
- sp332 15y agomore conversation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3504974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3504974
- ericb 15y agoIs there some way to browse this new type of menu? How do you shop for functions that you aren't aware of?
- azernik 15y agoFTA: > There’s still a lot of design and code still to do. For a start, we haven’t addressed the secondary aspect of the menu, as a visible map of the functionality in an app. That discoverability is of course entirely absent from the HUD; the old menu is still there for now, but we’d like to replace it altogether not just supplement it. Basically - they're looking for some other interface to replace that aspect of the menu, but in the meanwhile the menu is still there for discoverability purposes.
- Symmetry 15y agoLet it never be said that the people at Ubuntu are trapped by convention...
- nickolai 15y agoI may have missed it, but have they actuelly had real users(i.e. not ui designers) do some usability testing (i.e. actual real work) on this? Coming up with it an pushing it into a public release in 4 months looks risky to me. Given how frustrated some users were with Unity, I really hope they learned the lesson. This as presented this has a very high risk of turning into a "guess what the designers were thinking" game. While very flattering to the designer, it is frustrating as hell to the user. Arguably the current interfaces offer pretty much the same issue : a "guess in which menu I put the option" game - however there is one crucial difference : we got used to the current one, and actually have a really good idea how the designers were thinking - and where they put that option. EDIT : Right. I did miss that. Thanks.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoLook under "Even better for the power user": at least some testing was done.
- andrewgodwin 15y agoMy main concern with this is discoverability - menus are helpful in that they convey a very precise listing of the app's possible actions (when designed well), something that's hard to otherwise come by. Blender is perhaps the extreme example of this - it has an incredible amount of features, so they can't be placed into menus, and you spend some time learning where (in the hundreds of panels) or which of the thousands of keyboard shortcuts to use. That said, I find keyboard-driven user interfaces very powerful, so I'm curious to try this out. Fortunately, there's been a way to turn off Crazy Ubuntu Features in most releases if you know how, at least so far.
- ConstantineXVI 15y agoMark says that's their concern as well: > For a start, we haven’t addressed the secondary aspect of the menu, as a visible map of the functionality in an app. That discoverability is of course entirely absent from the HUD; the old menu is still there for now, but we’d like to replace it altogether not just supplement it.
- jamesgeck0 15y agoBlender actually has a HUD-like feature already. You can just hit space to bring up a searchable list of every command in the program. As a new user, I found it a lot easier to find things with the HUD than with the enormous menu and panel system.
- teraflop 15y agoFunnily enough, my experience was the opposite. I spent a while playing with Blender 2.49, and although its UI wasn't the most intuitive, at least I could use the menus to get a feel for what functionality was available. This new unified drop-down has the effect of grouping commands by textual similarity instead of conceptual similarity, which is much less useful. Even if you know what action you want to take, there doesn't seem to be an easy way to do it unless you know exactly how Blender spells it.
- 54mf 15y agoWhenever I see anyone write, "say hello to the future of the ______", my immediate reaction is to assume the author is an idiot. The only person or company who has ever been able to say that with any authority is Apple, and that's only because they have a track record of consistently creating the future of ______ for decades. Considering this HUD is basically "let's take Quicksilver and make it for menus", I think my immediate reaction was correct again. The idea isn't completely terrible, but it's not "the future" and it's riddled with problems. Hope you're the type who likes keeping cheat sheets around, because unless you know the exact name of every single command in your application, you're going to be in trouble. "We’ll resurrect the (boring) old ways of displaying the menu in 12.04..." This guy's hubris is astounding.
- stevelosh 15y agoIf you want something similar in OS X right now (though not with super-fuzzy matching like this seems to have) you can just use the search box in the help menu to search for menu items. It looks like this, and you can press return to activate the item: http://i.imgur.com/uJPgD.png http://i.imgur.com/uJPgD.png I've mapped Ctrl+M to move me there instantly with Keymando: map "<Ctrl-m>" do send('<Ctrl-F2>') send('<left>') send('<down>') end EDIT: Turns out there's already a shortcut for this: Ctrl-Shift-/. XCode overrides it though, so I'll be keeping my mapping. EDIT 2: Ah, yeah, it's Cmd, not Ctrl. I still like my two-key version though.
- felideon 15y agoCmd, not Ctrl. Cmd-? (? as in help)
- navs 15y agoqsb-mac, which I think is now dead, was great because it allowed you to access menu items for any app with minimal fuss. Quicksilver also has a plugin called 'User interface+' that gives you the same option. Combined with proxies for current application, its a powerful tool. Great alternatives to cmd+Shift+/ which can be really slow especially on browsers where menu items include history and bookmarks.
- miles_matthias 15y agoOne big downside to cmd+shift+/ is that it doesn't work with full screen apps.
- ashishgandhi 15y agoIt's not Control it's Command. Command + ? And I generally always use this to find something buried inside menus. But then usually after that, everything has a shortcut of it's own on OS X.
- SpikeX 15y agoSo basically... it's like the Windows 7 start menu search functionality, put into applications. It's not a terrible idea, but it should extend the current menu-based UI, not replace it.
- 54mf 15y agoRight. Or OS X's Help menu search functionality, or Quicksilver plus menus, or Alfred plus menus, etc etc etc. This has been the future for half a decade now.
- davidw 15y agoI upgraded to Ubuntu 11.10 yesterday, and the experience sucked. It broke Firefox and Emacs, and it took me a lot of fiddling to get back to a desktop I can live with. Turns out, for instance, that you have to alt right click the bottom and top bars in Gnome classic, to modify them. Not exactly an easy thing to figure out if you've just been right clicking them for years. Time for Ubuntu to stop dicking around with all the UI stuff and go back to making something that is solid. I really liked it when it first came out: it was a fairly dependable system that had regular updates, and was 'good enough' in the polish department. I could use it on desktops and servers alike and be pretty happy with it.
- 54mf 15y ago"Time for Ubuntu to stop dicking around with all the UI stuff and go back to making something that is solid." Yeah, no kidding. Their problem isn't that they're just not X steps ahead of everyone else, it's that they aren't even close to the same level as OS X or Windows. They need to stop trying to be so clever and focus on the basics.
- phren0logy 15y agoHow do they get close if they don't try? Perhaps it's just the contrarian in me, but I'm glad to see some movement here. Admittedly, though, it does seem a bit "shoehorned" in, and not terribly discoverable, but I'll withhold judgment until I've tried it. I can't live without something QuickSilver-like at this point, so I should be well within their target audience.
- RobH 15y agoI quite like this it reminds me of Firefox Ubiquity project. Which should act as a warning to Ubuntu as that never gained any real traction beyond power-users. The fact that Mark mentions that they one day wish to replace menus is odd. Menus work and are universally understood. This system could be great in a complimentary fashion, the blender example seems like a great use of the system. I really hope that Ubuntu don't throw the baby out with the bath water in their attempt to innovate.
- imurray 15y agoUbuntu's current (11.10 oneiric) menu cleverness breaks things for me using a non-standard window manager. (The gnome-terminal menu appears even when set to hidden.) Solution: purge every package with appmenu in the name and reboot. I hope it remains as easy to opt out from the next batch of little-tested, slightly buggy innovations.
- casca 15y agoIt's Google vs Yahoo on the menubar! Currently we use the Yahoo method (hierarchical information based on someone else's curatorship), Mark is proposing the Google model (everything through a single search box). Either one will not be as universally useful as combining them.
- tdoggette 15y agoThe site isn't loading-- does anyone have a mirror?
- agumonkey 15y agoNot really a mirror but webupd8 host a quote and a video : http://www.webupd8.org/2012/01/hud-ubuntus-new-smart-menus-announced.html http://www.webupd8.org/2012/01/hud-ubuntus-new-smart-menus-a... I'm still not sold, I found the UL-Corner positioning greatly aggressive. I'd put it in the bottom personally but I'm used to the Unix 'bottom command line' habit. Otherwise it's one step closer to a contemporary desktop command line, in the video the guy even typed 'undo' in inkscape, made me smile. I guess having this common iterative search of nested menus will greatly help users, as it helped many of us in the shell or emacs (or any system providing this idea)
- agscala 15y agoOne quote from the article which I found interesting: “it works so well that the rare occasions when it can’t read my mind are annoying!” I interpret that as, "While it's great being able to search for commands, it's an absolute pain in the ass to find the command if the search fails." He mentions being able to look at the list of commands like a "table of contents" for an application, but I really don't see how that is possible considering what he has described. All I know is that I'm going to be even more lost in GIMP with this update.
- alexchamberlain 15y agoI have yet to find anything I like about Unity. As many of the other commenters have said, was there any real user testing on PCs the users actually own?
- david_a_r_kemp 15y agoTo this, this seems like a lot more unix-y way of doing things, and certain for someone like me who prefers to keep their hands on the keyboard, this is top-banana (yes, I know there's ctrl+alt+shift+X to doing something in one app or other, but remembering every combination in every application is a PITA). If you've used Cloud9IDE's command line, I see this more like that -> you type git, and a popup shows you the completions for git. There's a lot of haters, but I'm really keen on unity. It's like having gnome-do baked in. Sure, it's not quite polished, but at least it's trying different things than the identikit window managers out there.
- hotice 15y agoBy the way, you can already test it in Ubuntu 12.04: http://www.webupd8.org/2012/01/hud-ubuntus-new-smart-menus-announced.html http://www.webupd8.org/2012/01/hud-ubuntus-new-smart-menus-a...
- tnajdek 15y agoSeems like there have been mostly negative comments here, admittedly I haven't used this yet but I think it's a great idea. Ultimately this is not supposed to replace key-bindings but rather allow me to quickly access features that I normally don't access without hunting for it in the toolbar menu. Sounds especially useful in applications where you heavily use keyboard (like text editors for example). I believe/hope that experience will be similar to the 'command palette' of Sublime Text 2 where you can execute a feature that you don't use very often (e.g. convert to lower case <ctrl+shit+p> low<enter>) without hunting for it in the menu. For me theory sounds good, I need to test it myself to decide whether I like it in practice or not.
- miles_matthias 15y agoI like it too. I'm just worried about what I would do when I open a new application for the first time. How do I scan what it can do? How do I learn the functions of the application?
- Raphael 15y agoRead the help file.
- hemancuso 15y agoIt sometimes feels that Linux developers haven't ever seen a non-Linux user interact with a computer before. This seems doubly true for the folk who do UI/UX.
- asdfpoiu 15y agoSo far, a lot of Ubuntu-specific software has been very buggy and low quality for me (indicators, Unity). Why should this be any different?
- Derbasti 15y agoHmm, I did not like the idea initially, but then I started thinking of how Emacs and (more importantly) Sublime Text work ... I must say, this very system works amazingly well for Sublime Text, why am I presuming that it is an automatic failure for menu bars? Actually, I think that menu bars in general are a horrible crutch for pretty much every task. There is a reason why Windows introduced the "Ribbon". The Ribbon is Microsoft's way to get rid of the menu bar. Maybe Ribbons are not perfect, but they definitely improved discoverability of content. ido-mode in Emacs introduces fuzzy matching for file navigation and it is awesome. CMD-T is a similar mechanism in Textmate. Sublime Text is pretty much built on the concept of fuzzy matched palettes. All these are programs I very much like. Maybe Ubuntu is actually on to something there.
- spontaneus 15y agoIt reminded me of Sublime as well and I must say that the fuzzy match saves me a lot of time when switching between files. Having this functionality built into the OS could be very beneficial.
- tintin 15y agoChange the status of your chat client: Normal: klik on icon right top -> set status HUD: drop your mouse/stylus -> type the HUD command -> type to change your status. In the future you will be less productive but have the gloss.
- jiggy2011 15y agoThis doesn't seem like it would be very good for using with applications that you are familiar with. With context menus you can remember the ALT + <key> combinations required to navigate to a feature quickly. With this you would have to type the name of the feature and then select it which might involve navigating a fair way down the list. The only other option would be for all apps to assign keyboard shortcuts to everything Also for applications that you are not familiar with you will have to guess what a particular feature is called and if it even exists in the first place. They would have to load all the apps up with synonyms and since Open Source developers can't agree on anything I'm not sure how many would even design their app around this. Not to mention problems with users who have poor english or just poor spelling. Having said all this, this feature is an excellent idea to supplement existing UI functionality. I've been integrating "feature search" type functions into some of my web apps for a while now and I'm surprised Apple and MS haven't done this more.
- Tichy 15y agoHow do you discover and explore, though?
- ColdAsIce 15y agoMark Shuttleworth, promoter of the worse UX changes for GNU/Linux since 1892!
- justnearme 15y agoWhat a horrible idea. What happened to thinking about international users, for whom typing is a hassle? Learn from Japan, where Yahoo is more preferable over Google because you can find what you want rather than type it out...
- jamesgeck0 15y agoWhat about them? There will be a mouse-driven fallback UI, just like with the current application launcher.
- gooddelta 15y agoOS X has had this since Snow Leopard -- you can go to any application's help menu, and begin typing the name of a menu item, even if it's nested. Using the arrow keys, you can navigate down the list of results, and as you select each item, the menus expand to show you the location of the item with a large, blue arrow next to it. You can then either click the item next to said arrow, activating it -- or simply press enter. Apple had this years ago; they just made a conscious decision to keep using menus.
- tmelot 15y agoThe best part is you can Command + Shift + ? to open the Help menu (if the keyboard shortcuts haven't been remapped by the app) and start typing. It's how I do a lot of stuff in Photoshop actually.
- mbq 15y agoThis is based on a stupid idea that keyboard shortcuts are fast only because they are done on a keyboard. But this is simply false -- they are fast because they are simple gestures I can train and perform without thinking about it. Same applies to mouse -- in a well designed GUI, one can easily train to select an option or go through a dialog box with a blink of an eye. Now, typing anything is just a complex procedure involving quite a lot of attention; what's worse, it cannot be trained since this HUD's response for a certain input will be mostly unpredictable depending of the state of its fuzzy AI. Not to mention that it additionally makes one constantly waste time on reading HUD window to check what action it is planning to execute. Finally, when drawing or using any heavy mouse-dependent application one usually can fire keyboard shortcuts with one hand while the second is constantly holding mouse -- typing requires two hands, so it makes one waste additional time to grab the mouse back and re-adjust hand.
- macco 15y agoHave you ever used things like QuickSilver, Gnome-Do, etc. The work great and complemnt Shortcuts and Menus. I think this is very clever. Think you are using a complex software like OpenOffice - you know some feature you want to use, but don't recall the shortcut, just type in the name and to can use it. No movement away from the keyboard neccessary - very powerful idea.
- mbq 15y agoI'm not saying that it is a bad idea on its own -- the terrible idea is that they will most likely remove menus and shortcuts because "HUD is better". Not always.
- agumonkey 15y agoFunny cause HUD reminds me of Maya who has one hell fast mouse based UI/Widgets. Unfortunately, almost nobody in the software industry (I mean beside some 2d/3d progrmas) knows or follows this kind of design. You make me wanna design a keyboardless system, or maybe a two thumb only input system.
- 15y ago
- tomp 15y agoOh my... > will ultimately replace menus in Unity applications Why? Obviously, HUD and menus have different functions, and different use. GUI menus might be more appropriate for GUI applications, since you have your hand on the mouse already and you don't need to move it to the keyboard to type the command. > fuzzy matching, and it can learn what you usually do so it can prioritise the things you use often. Every time that I saw something like this in any application/OS (Android is a prime example), it was such an epic fail that it is almost beyond words. 1) I usually learn faster than a computer, so the way I see it is not computer "learning", but computer arbitrarily "changing" its behaviour. So, instead of memorizing "to call Jack, I have to press J and Down and Down", I have to always pay attention when the interface changes... 2) If there are some actions that I do much more commonly, then give me a way to access these actions more directly (interface buttons, scripting, keyboard shortcuts). But, in any case, my shortcuts will be almost always better than "automatic" ones, and also, mine won't change. Fuzzy matching can be good, but I've yet to see a good implementation, and it, above all, has to be consistent! Not as in Android, where matching is "fuzzy" for calling, but exact for SMS...
- jamesgeck0 15y ago> Obviously, HUD and menus have different functions, and different use. A hybrid wouldn't be impossible. In the example screenshot, the menu breadcrumb trail is shown. One possible solution would be to show the top level menu items in the HUD when it's first pulled up and allow the user to navigate it via mouse.
- smithzvk 15y ago> I usually learn faster than a computer, so the way I see it is not computer "learning", but computer arbitrarily "changing" its behaviour. So, instead of memorizing "to call Jack, I have to press J and Down and Down", I have to always pay attention when the interface changes... Thanks for putting this in words. This is an example of an innovation that reduces the learning curve to a device, but almost certainly makes it slower for the experienced user. One of the reasons that I use GNU/Linux on my personal computers is precisely because FOSS interfaces tend to not make this trade-off (as evidenced by Emacs, Vim, Blender, Inkscape, and many more). So, I am a bit luke warm towards this new HUD interface (then again, I haven't forced myself to swallow the Unity pill yet, either). My keyboard doesn't randomly swap around the keys on my keyboard, and I appreciate that because I spent the time learning to touch type. Arguably, adaptively moving keys could be faster for 'hunt and peck' typists, but not for people who have spent some time learning how to type.
- tree_of_item 15y agoAlready in Emacs: http://www.emacswiki.org/emacs/LaCarte http://www.emacswiki.org/emacs/LaCarte
- agumonkey 15y agoEverything has been done in emacs, then forgotten.
- technomancy 15y agoYou don't even really need any third-party code; the stock minibuffer is really similar to this. Welcome back to the 80s.
- gojomo 15y agoIndeed, when I saw the HUD screenshot I thought of Emacs Apropos… but LaCarte + Icycles is an even closer match.
- tikhonj 15y agoEmacs has always been at the fore-front of UI innovation :). It's just that nobody wants to admit it because it's slightly weird, not shiny and--unlike all the other UI efforts--aimed at efficiency rather than ease-of-use.
- pnathan 15y agoThis is not a terrible idea. It could be implemented awfully though.
- EvilLook 15y agoHey Mark, how about you get the current user interface right and quell the anger of your users about Unity before you move your UI wankery forward?
- overgard 15y agoWho is this for? Is this actually solving a problem someone has stated they have? This feels like an attempt at solving a problem that nobody has. In an effort to differentiate themselves, I think they've lost sight of what users actually want. Here's what I want from ubuntu, as a (past) user: a solid distribution that gives me a reasonable default setup without a lot of fuss. I mean, I'm installing linux, you can probably already assume I sort of know what I'm doing. I want something that gets out of my way, not something constantly asking me to adapt and "rethink" how I go about using my computer. I know how to use my computer just fine, thank-you-very-much, leave me with my menus.
- grannyg00se 15y ago"Is this actually solving a problem someone has stated they have?" This is how I felt when the first iPods came out at much higher prices than other mp3 players on the market. With less flexibility in the way it operates.
- barnaby 15y agoI agree. This sounds like the same reaction. People were like "oh this is stupid because it's different". Turns out it did solve the needs of a different interface. HUD + Unity (just like iOS before it) will simplify how to use menus on a tablet interface... especially once the speech-recognition part is added.
- fader 15y agoWhat you want is a faster horse: http://www.slicedbreaddesign.com/blog/index.php/2009/10/a-faster-horse-when-not-to-listen-to-users/ http://www.slicedbreaddesign.com/blog/index.php/2009/10/a-fa... There's nothing wrong with this, but maybe you would be happier with something like XFCE. (sudo apt-get install xfce)
- jasonkester 15y agoEven casual users find typing faster than mousing. Casual Linux users, perhaps? I can't imagine anybody who's ever watched a casual computer user use a computer saying anything like the above quote. Most people have the mouse in their hand the entire time, and usually don't have their other hand anywhere near the keyboard. Typing involves not only clicking into a box and dropping the mouse, but actually leaning the entire body forward in order to reach the keyboard. Even I, computer programmer by trade, spend the majority of my life in "first person shooter mode" rather than "typing mode" because most of a web dev's life is debugging things that happen in the browser (a mousish place), and pretty much anything you need to do along the code-analysis line can be done with a combination of pointing and left-handing. If you make me drop my mouse every time I need to interact with an application on your OS, I don't think I'll use your OS.
- grannyg00se 15y agoHaving to switch back and forth between keyboard mode and mouse mode by moving your hand away from the keyboard is horrendous. Consider using a keyboard with a built in mouse pointer like this one: http://reviews.cnet.com/keyboards/ibm-usb-travel-keyboard/1707-3134_7-30901355.html http://reviews.cnet.com/keyboards/ibm-usb-travel-keyboard/17... Once you become proficient with the index finder mousing (it doesn't take long) you'll never have to remove your hands from the keyboard and may even find yourself typing and mousing at the same time on occasion. I really don't see how these aren't more popular. I just wish I could find a wireless one for my home theatre setup.
- jasonkester 15y agomoving your hand away from the keyboard is horrendous ... for you. Every laptop keyboard in the world has a built-in pointer, and yet there's still plenty of demand for mice. So yes, while I understand that you and many people like you keep your hands on the keyboard 24/7 and are therefore several orders of magnitude more productive than the rest of us, you should probably realize that you're a very small minority of the general population.
- 15y ago
- bryanh 15y agoStrangely enough that core functionality (searching menu items) is kind of built into OSX. Along with ⌘-space for Spotlight, I use shift-⌘-? to search the menubar from keyboard. Its a great multi-tool as it hooks into the stuff you already know.
- mrdingle 15y agoMan we really despise innovation attempts for some reason today on HN. Canonical is trying to push computing into the future and progress user interface by doing really hard stuff. They're sailing uncharted waters and giving us all a lot of good research, and all for free. This is honestly awesome. Not because it's going to be a UI revolution but because we get to see a well funded company, that cares about user rights, genuinely trying to innovate and make our lives better. Plus the HUD sounds great. Anyone here use Quicksilver or mac spotlight or gnome do? I use them non stop, I can launch/search/command my computer using a simple interface without leaving my keyboard. Now I have this built into each application. And soon developers will start to build applications with this in mind and it'll get even slicker. Theres no reason to poo on Canonical. They are trying super hard in the face of an ungrateful tech community. It's not about developing the system you personally would enjoy. It's about innovation and the future. Think different mother fuckers.
- zanny 15y agoI think the consensus is that everyone wants Ubuntu to be the "mainstream" Linux, which is most like the other mainstream desktop OSes and can be put up on a pedistal for its stability. All the recent changes like Unity and now this shake up a paradigm that has been in place for 2 decades. I know for a fact that things like Unity keep me from installing Ubuntu on every family members PC as a general purpose OS. They are too different from Windows (nobody on my side really got on the OSX bandwagon) and then because of these constant huge UI changes things break that they can't fix and it would frustrate them to no end. I don't want to speak for everyone, but I want to see experimental projects like this in some kind of Ubuntu test bad like Firefox has Aurora / Nightly to test new features. Things that work and are widely popular could be pushed into mainline releases, and things that aren't can be scrapped, maybe revisited later. But throwing these paradigm shifts into release products makes everyone lean away from Ubuntu as a general purpose OS, which is what it was becoming best at. I think everyone just mourns the loss of potential.
- freshhawk 15y agoI think they rightly don't care (or at least care less) about trying to convert older users who need a clone of the popular stuff. There are way more users in trying to innovate and attract younger or less experienced computer users. If they get it right of course.
- DrCatbox 15y agoAnother invention which will alienate even more casual users from GNU/Linux. Users, even I as a progammer, do not like to have to re-learn and assimilate a new interface-model every few months or years. Ive learned a few times, why cant people stick to what is working already? The menu is super nice, the global menu, not so much but fine thats what some people nice. Now Ill explain to my girlfriend that there is the HUD menu? And after that youll invent something else something new, for what!? All that work and you just have a different kind of menu. Too bad, too bad. Why not do some real user tests to find out where they are failing right now? Why users dont feel comfortable in Ubuntu? Yes, even those users, like me, and Ive used most distros for a decade. Its just something fishy about both Unity and Gnome2.
- daleharvey 15y agoHeh as with most announcments where ubuntu makes changes to the UI the tech community is pretty dismissive, I for one love the fact that canonical are pushing forward a linux desktop experience in a way nobobdy else is, I didnt like unity much, but I trust these guys to fix it. I find well done command interfaces much better than traditional menus for quite a lot of reasons * they scale better, 10 items is a similiar experience to 100 * they are more discoverable, just start typing a word and go through the list of match (where help can be included) * they can show information, each command can have a descriptive sentence (and a link to help), icons in a menu sometimes get tiny alt text * they can adapt to your behaviour, if I use firefox all the time, pressing f in alfred give me firefox
- tspiteri 15y agothey are more discoverable, just start typing a word and go through the list of match I don't think that's discoverable. That is searchable: they do make it easier to search for a command you require without having to know under which menu to find it. But they seem to be less discoverable in the sense that you cannot just browse through the menus to discover features. Having said that, there are probably ways to provide the discoverability of current menus, e.g., just list all the main menu items under each other, then typing a main menu item will show its items... Still, discovering new features is not something you do nearly as often as using features you are familiar with, so the trade off seems to be a good one.
- dredmorbius 15y agoIf the commands correspond to some set of objects (reserved words, defined functions, builtins, on-disk executables), then discoverability is indeed high. Conventions also matter. Most Linux and GNU utilities offer: - manpages (or, deprecated, info pages) - a brief help with some variant of "-h|-?|--help" - package information under /usr/share/doc/, generally with a pointer to upstream. They'll often include readline command editing, command completion, and other features, all very useful. Systems such as Debian's 'dwww' (built in web-enabled documentation integration) allow accessing all of this and more through your browser, if you prefer. Not all utilities offer this. I've seen more than my share of proprietary CLI tools with very, very poor documentation and discoverability, so this isn't something that's inherent to CLIs. But it's certainly doable. I see some 3200+ commands available on my search path, plus shell builtins and functions. My shell history includes fewer than 200 ($HISTSIZE=3000). The situation for GUIs is very nearly always worse. Except for minimal interfaces, it's difficult to present more than a dozen or so options at a time. Some level of predictive completion may help, but in doing so you're starting to bridge the divide between a pure menu and a CLI. I've found myself preferring CLIs increasingly, even in nominally GUI tools. The vimperator plugin for firefox claws back crucially useful vertical real-estate while offering a very powerful interface to my browser.
- abahgat 15y agoSounds like a smart idea, to me. Since I started using Alfred on my Mac I'm able to control almost everything from the keyword and I'm faster at almost everything. Being able to guess the user intentions from the context would be a great advantage, but the challenge would be balancing context-dependent commands from the most general ones, in my opinion.
- jamesgeck0 15y agoI'm pretty excited about how this could make voice recognition a first class citizen on the desktop. The simple voice tool baked into Windows* is sorta usable, but changing contexts to find things in menus or click buttons is a huge pain. You're constantly reminded that the interface you're using was originally designed for a keyboard and mouse. This has the potential to eliminate a lot of the pain associated with that. * I don't know if Dragon improves the context-shift situation significantly. The last time I tried it was several years ago.
- samstave 15y agoThe only thing I dont like about this is that it appears that you have to type for everything you're looking for. With the example shown in inkscape - this is good if you dont know where something is -- but anyone who is proficient with a graphic(s) program knows that the more you can do with a left hand keyboard shortcut and a button which reduces the number of times you take your hand off the mouse the better. What I would far prefer is if the HUD would allow me to assign arbitrary keyboard shortcuts (contextually) in any program. This way - when Inkscape is active, I can use whatever shortcut I want to assign to "glow" and then that same binding can be set to a different command in a different program, say, GIMP - and I configure it all in one location. I dont want to type for everything I want to do...
- nkassis 15y agoLooks to me like we are going full circle back to the command line with this. I mean, what's the difference between this and a command line shell with fuzzy matching? I like Ubuntu being experimental but right now I'm having pains with Unity on my setup (multiple monitors and apps that don't quite fit with the UI). I'm seriously considering moving to a different distro while they sort the details out .
- ec429 15y agoI was thinking the same, and found it particularly amusing that "design" types are only now finally realising the virtues of the command line. What'll the next Ubuntu UI revolution be? No X11, just a 'screen' session in a tty? (I'd actually use that, were it not for the fact that (a) too much of the Web is overly graphical to be browsed effectively in text mode and (b) screen sucks) Moving to a different distro (and perhaps WM) is a good idea. I recently moved to Debian with Xfce and am enjoying the lack of gnomes.
- grannyg00se 15y agoThis seems useful for exploring menu options when you don't know where things are, but not as useful for executing frequently used menu options. For exploring, it's great to be able to type "pref" and have all menu options for preferences show up. But if I know that the preferences I'm looking for are under Edit - Preferences, I'll just hit ALT-E, P and be done with it in less than a second.
- brudgers 15y agoI think it's great to see Ubuntu innovating. However, I don't see search as the future of application interfaces. I've been using autocomplete in Quickbooks long enough to know that typing "Next P" to execute <next page> rather than <next layer> is just going to suck.
- Raphael 15y agoI doubt this will completely eliminate other forms of interaction. It would be a mistake to remove keyboard shortcuts or buttons for common actions such as changing pages. The point is to not get into a ribbon type situation where there are a ton of buttons cluttering the window.
- fdb 15y agoIntelliJ IDEA has this feature for years now. (Command-Shift-A) It shows a list of all commands and you can fuzzy-find through them. It is very useful and often faster than digging through the menus to find the right command. It also shows the shortcut for the command, which is useful for learning commands that you use often.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- DTE 15y ago3D modeling software such as Rhinoceros (http://www.rhino3d.com/ http://www.rhino3d.com/) uses this model with great success and I'm sure there are others. The program has a GUI that is very modular and customizable but the command-line interface is the primary interface. It takes a short while to get used to but after you do it scales very well as your experience grows. I have thought for a while that Photoshop/Illustrator would do well with a CLI but this is a compelling case for a contextual but system-wide implementation of this concept. The closest we have is Quicksilver or Alfred and while they are indispensable, making this part of the OS would open up some interesting possibilities.
- HardSphere 15y agoSo... the future of the menu is... Zork?
- drats 15y agoAfter two iterations of this I can se it being pretty good for my parents as they will be able to say "bookmark" or "back" to the voice recognition in the browser and not have to worry about the UI much at all.
- Pound6F 15y agoThis is a great idea and as they note its really beneficial to the power user, BUT I can't see it replacing traditional menus for novice users (and potentially some intermediate users). For novice users, discoverabiliy is extremely important. For any application new users want to learn what it does, and they aren't going to read the manual. Traditional menus allow users to browse available actions without having to know what they want to do. They don't know what they don't know, and well designed menus/UIs allow them to learn the application really quickly. I also wonder about the older generation and their ability to pick up on this. I would be very curious how well less technically skilled 40+-year-olds pick up on the keyboard-based navigation over the traditional mouse-based navigation/interaction.
- firefoxman1 15y agoThe only downside: you have to use Unity to get it :(
- chetan51 15y agoIt would be nice if the first option was always selected by default.
- strictfp 15y agoThis is awesome. The current system doesn't work so well since menu items don't fit well into separate categories. In fact, nothing does. One example is the quite arbitrary division into 'File, Edit, View etc'. A discussion I hear quite often between people sitting together in front of word is -'Try that menu. Oh, that one then? No? Let me have a look'.Another example is the windows control panel, who didn't switch to flat view straight away? And grouping on the start menu into categories of programs? Largely gone. Sorting your music collection on disk? Gone. Structuring your HD in general to avoid searching? Gone. Categorizing websites? Gone. This is just the last relic. As it is right now I'd rather google how to do something in Word than look through the menu, so this solution _has_ to be better!
- amalcon 15y agoDoes it bother anyone else that this is actually the opposite of an actual heads-up display? The whole point of a HUD is that the user is given information without going out of their way to get it. This gives you less passive information than a traditional menu does. I like the idea in principle. I just don't like nondescriptive names.
- newhouseb 15y agoPutting the keyboard back into computing is a strange direction to move considering the wild success of tablets and smartphones (namely of the Apple variant) that drop the keyboard entirely in favor of better touch interaction. An ideal interface has a low barrier between what you want to achieve and the way you achieve it, using a keyboard requires that written language always be between the two.
- rcthompson 15y agoI think there's an interesting behind-the-scenes change that is being demonstrated here: the transition from "every app handles displaying its own menu" to "apps just export their menu structure over DBus, and another program handles displaying them" is what makes it even possible to add the HUD to all applications instead of just developing a single app that uses a HUD instead of menus and leaving the rest behind. Now that all the applications are exporting their menus over DBus, if you don't like Canonical's menu interface, you can write your own and it will work with all applications. That's pretty cool. For instance, any one of the Quicksilver-alikes available for Linux could add a plugin that turns it into a frontend for all your application menus. The KDE Alt+F2 run dialog could do likewise. Hell, you could write a menu interface in Emacs Lisp if you really wanted to, and control all your applications from the Emacs minibuffer.
- jablan 15y agoI am not sure whether this would be possible, as menus are contextual - the launcher (QS-clone, Emacs, whatever) would have to keep your current application focused, i.e. not take over its focus in order to display its menu, right?
- rcthompson 15y agoI believe that all applications that support this do so by exporting their menu structures over DBus at all times, not just when they are focused. For context, a launcher could provide access to all application menus, but prioritize results based on which applications were most recently accessed. Or just keep it simple and go with only the most recently focused one.
- joebadmo 15y agoI'm not sure I agree with this direction, as this system seems like it has a high cognitive load, that doesn't allow a lot of relegation to muscle memory (ie it seems like you have to keep the feedback loop between your keying and the options that appear open for the duration of the command-invocation), which is what I find attractive about keyboard interfaces in general. But I could be wrong. I'll have to try and see. In any case, I'm glad that the direct-manipulation paradigm, which I find to be generally and intrinsically impoverished, isn't the only avenue UI innovation is going down. I have other ideas about a keyboard-oriented interface in this essay: http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/9325300749/a-different-kind-of-gui http://blog.byjoemoon.com/post/9325300749/a-different-kind-o...
- tikhonj 15y agoThis sounds like a good change. Also, just skimming the article and looking at the pretty pictures, it seems similar to ido-mode for Emacs. Just with more eye-candy. Since everybody I know loves ido-mode, I am fairly confident in this change.
- gte910h 15y agoUbuntu integrated Launch/Alfred into it's apps...
- Qz 15y agoThis is basically Search for telling your computer what to do. People currently do this all day long at google.com.
- ddemuth 15y agoSerious, you're going to try and get me to use an interface by using a website that has justified paragraph text that spans 70% of my 1920 x 1080 21" monitor? Much like these comments on HN, it's hard to read long, wide paragraphs. It makes me question the usability of a HUD's interface
- sciurus 15y agoDeveloper Ted Gould's description of how search the menu works: http://gould.cx/ted/blog/Searching_menus http://gould.cx/ted/blog/Searching_menus
- YoukaiCountry 15y agoHave they come full circle and reinvented the command line interface?
- lucisferre 15y agoAbsolutely love this. Really like the direction Unity is moving, was quite pleasantly surprised after using it recently to find all the hate I had read about was greatly overstated.
- codex 15y agoOnly Linux could turn the GUI back into the command line.
- sown 15y agoI'm leary. The reason we've used menus and windows for so long is because it just works. Improvements are always welcome but it's always going to be easier for me to say Alt-F, O.
- thesash 15y agoThis is a beautiful and interesting concept, but isn't this really just a dressed up command line interface? This is a feature I would absolutely love to have, but I don't see it replacing the menu in the form demoed for the simple reason that this violates one of the core principles of user-centered design: visibility. If the user has no visual indication of what is possible within the system, how can we expect them to learn the interface? One super simple example of this: http://cl.ly/082D441E2D0L1l3d3g2Y http://cl.ly/082D441E2D0L1l3d3g2Y Most readers of Hacker News are probably aware of the calculator feature in the Spotlight in Mac OSX, but if I had a dollar for every time I've blown someone's mind by showing it to them, I'd be counting money right now rather than writing this comment. The bottom line is, visibility is an extremely important design principle, because it informs the user what they can do within a system, so hiding possibilities is probably not a good idea. For detailed reading on the principle of visibility, check out Donald Norman's Phenomenal The Design of Everyday Things, which I firmly believe should be required reading for anyone thinking about building anything: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0385267746/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=discerningman-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=0385267746 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0385267746/ref=as_li_ss_tl?... [yes, it is an affiliate link]
- willidiots 15y agoWhat do I do when I forget the wording of a menu item? (or I guess a "HUD command") Menus form a strong spatial association - I remember a lot of options by their placement, and only recall the exact wording when I see it. (Is it "re-open last tab", "reopen last tab", "re-open closed tab", or "reopen closed tab"?) Not saying that HUD is inherently bad because of this, but I'm curious how they deal with it? Am I missing something?
- ekianjo 15y agoI fail to see how this will apply to tablets and mobile phones, where you want people to use their finger as a mouse and not as a keyboard to type. (since Canonical said they were moving towards tablets and phones in the near future, I expect they follow the same design guidelines, but I could be wrong...)
- tsunamifury 15y agoThis seems to illustrate how painfully how out of touch the linux community is. As all the other OSs head towards touch, Linux wants to become more keyboard oriented.
- jebblue 15y agoI think someone at Canonical ate some old pizza or something. Taking us back to the keyboard .. the keyboard? For menus? Seriously? Wasn't Unity bad enough? Lenses? Really?
- wind_whisper 15y agoAnother hyped super-feature which implementation quality likely will render it unusable. Dear Ubuntu developers! I respect you very much! Why aren't you respecting me? Why do you release seemingly untested stuff? Why your product is so unstable and buggy? Please stop making systems that hang when I lock my screen or fall apart when I switch to another window with Compiz enabled. I do not need your new fancy features. I need a system that just works. Thanks. And the other take. Did you ever use mobile tablet device with multitouch? And after that are you really want to use that 70-ish WIMP interfaces? If you saw it one single time, when you manipulate your photos/videos "themselves", when you interact with your information and not with some buttons or menus or stuff like that, you'll never want to come back. Ones who demand full support for multitouch gestures across modern OS interfaces are not "future-oriented" people IMO. They are now-oriented. Next-generation interfaces are already here! They are the state-of-the-art for many users right today. And are you really want to impress us with tinkering around that 70s stuff? Than you guys stuck in 90s. Come on.
- mariuolo 15y agoMadness goes on.
- yason 15y agoI think it would be better to offer the whole menu bar as an expanded tree in a vertical strip rendered to an overlay on the whole screen. This would help the user get an at-a-glance view of all the menus' contents, sectioned logically by each top-level menu entry. It would also reduce menu navigation to mere up/down (and pgup/pgdown), and allow for some sort of an instant search (start typing letters) would also work. It would even work for touchscreens because we've already observed that scrolling up and down is one of the best and natural UI concepts that you can do with a touchscreen.
- naughtysriram 15y agoHUD -> "Horribile UI Design" I guess
- yaix 15y agoThat's another novel thing for Ubuntu, publishing a major change first in an LTS. Until now the philosophy was that an LTS was more stable, a non-LTS was more experimental. Sad that this policy was abandoned. The "HUD" interface (silly name) looks like a good idea though, hope it is fast enough for netbooks and other small PCs. After using Unity for some time I abandoned it for XFCE because my netbook was just not fast enough.
- edanm 15y agoI once worked on a project with some friends that gave Windows this functionality. It basically scanned the menu of the current window, then gave a Launchy-like interface to choose any menu item. It worked pretty well, although some programs bypassed the Windows API so didn't work with our program. We also gave it one other awesome ability, which I have yet to see in other such tools - a "search for window by name" feature. This searched your open windows in a Launchy-style interface, letting you switch to Chrome by doing "Ch<enter>" or to Visual Studio by doing "Vis<enter>". It also searched open tabs in all your browsers, letting you switch to gmail by typing "gm<enter>", etc. The program was meant as a startup, way back many years ago when we didn't know any better :)