10 ms·
France's baby bust
- franky47 4y ago> In 1700, almost 1 in 25 inhabitants on Earth, and one in five in Europe, was French. Today, less than a percent of humanity is French. Why did France’s population decline in relative terms so dramatically, and did it really mark the decline of France? It seems far-fetched to use global population as a relative indicator of France's "decline", where the global population exploded after the industrial revolution.
- eastbound 4y agoAlso, why would we want to overpopulate? The whole premise is wrong. We need to weigh less on the environment, and currently farmers are receding in France, and it’s the first profession for suicide; All tells us that the next generation will be full-urban, which is an extremely bad thing. Of course, empires with more dense populations have more ability to dominate others, at least thanks to the variety of skills and the sheer mass of the population. There’s a reason why politicians work to increase population: It increases levied taxes. The system wouldn’t be balanced with stable population. But even if we equate population with domination, is dominating the world what we want? As for the “but they’ll pay your retirements!” argument, well, retirement-by-next-generation-paying is a pyramid scheme and the elderly should have thought of it before they set it up.
- rippercushions 4y agoIf you want to weigh less on the environment, you want to go urban: it's far more efficient to live in shared housing (apartments), commute by public transport, etc.
- throwaway049 4y agoThe person you replied to was arguing for a smaller total population - for humans in aggregate to weigh less on the environment even if individuals weigh more.
- jstanley 4y ago> why would we want to overpopulate? Half the reason we got out of the Malthusian trap is that we finally got enough people that specialisation and economies of scale start to pay off. Wanting to reduce the global population is like saying you want to eliminate economies of scale, which would make life harder for those who remain, not easier.
- kubb 4y agoEconomies of scale can happen with a billion people just as well as with 8 billion. The food production grew because of the invention of synthetic fertilizer, not because the more people we have, the cheaper the food can be.
- Aaargh20318 4y agoOur current economy is a pyramid scheme on a gigantic scale and dependent on an ever growing population. Since we live on a planet with a finite amount of resources we know infinite growth isn’t sustainable. If we don’t intervene at some point the whole system will inevitably collapse. The longer we wait, the more difficult it will be. Unfortunately we live in a gerontocracy where our leaders don’t care about what happens in the future since they’ll be dead in a few years anyway.
- mastax 4y agoEconomic growth can mean accomplishing more with the same resources. Very frequently, it does. Very frequently, it doesn't.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Aerroon 4y ago>Also, why would we want to overpopulate? Because population is key for the level of influence a country can have. A high population doesn't guarantee it, but a low population will likely sideline the country when important topics come up.
- uonpopular_th 4y ago[flagged]
- 4gotunameagain 4y agoI think this was intended, to show the relative decline of the birthrates compared to other countries at the time which was the point of the data analysis
- rzk 4y agoIf the explosion of the global population is driven by the industruial revolution, then it would've impacted France's population the same way. So it makes sense to compare this way.
- bmacho 4y agoFrance's population exploded sooner.
- kortilla 4y agoBut it should have kept exploding.
- bratbag 4y agoWhy? There are diminishing returns on industrialising.
- bumby 4y agoNot just that, but in cold economic terms there are diminishing on having large families in industrialized societies. A large broad is an asset in agrarian societies but largely a liability in an industrialized one.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoA large family is an asset in industrialized societies too, but in the long run. For example, having lots of siblings can help you later on for networking or being able to go someone to depend on, assuming a decent number of them obtain useful positions in society. But in the short term, it is a lot of sacrifice, especially for the woman who has to give birth and raise all those babies. And of course, it is a lot of work to instill values such that the family stays close, and luck such as being located in a location that is experiencing an economic boom.
- 4y ago
- wouldbecouldbe 4y agoOf course it's not far fetched, it's an interesting way to look at the macro changes that happened in the last centuries in the world.
- MakeUsersWant 4y agoSo this is why Europeans were able to colonize the entire world roughly in the 1700s.
- barry-cotter 4y agoThe Industrial Revolution was why they were able to colonise the world. Being much, much more productive means you can afford a lot more bullets/cannon/artillery/small arms and you need less of your population as a share growing food. Europeans were better at war than anyone else because Europe was always at war somewhere. It was geographically fragmented enough that any one power becoming hegemonic never happened again after Rome. The difference wasn’t big enough to explain conquering most of the world though. They Sikhs came very close to defeating the British and Japan was almost certainly outproducing Europe in firearms by the end of the Sengoku Jidai. The Industrial Revolution made European conquest possible.
- Retric 4y agoThat line of thinking only goes so far, industry also allows one to simply buy resources from foreign locations without the bother of conquest and administration. It’s really a combination of many factors including Europe’s relatively high population that made it both viable and desirable.
- inawarminister 4y agoAnd tbh the European demographics expansion between 1500-1800, before industrialization properly spread out from Britain [0], was the Columbian Exchange. Potatoes unlocked lots of land in the northern part. And the other unsung botany, too. And the ability to send surplus men (and women) to an empty (because of disease) continent instead of having them warring against each other like pre-Columbian Europe and East Asia (looking at Sengoku) is also decisive... [0] Remember one reason why Britain was able to fight Napoleon even when the entire continent was conquered was because of industries.
- 4y ago
- genman 4y agoIt is actually not true. The global population exploded after industrialized nations developed after WW2 new types of high yield crops and then gave those away to non-industrialized nations.
- Scoundreller 4y agopost-Colombian exchange, adoption of potato also helped Europe as a whole. "By feeding rapidly growing populations, [it] permitted a handful of European nations to assert dominion over most of the world between 1750 and 1950." "Because potatoes were so productive, the effective result, in terms of calories, was to double Europe’s food supply." "Routine famine almost disappeared in potato country, a 2,000-mile band that stretched from Ireland in the west to Russia’s Ural Mountains in the east." https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-the-potato-changed-the-world-108470605/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-the-potato-change...
- genman 4y agoTrue, partially. But the growth was much slower over longer period of time while after 50s the population of developing nations almost quadrupled in 1/2 century. https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth
- flooow 4y agoTLDR: > In my research, I argue that the diminished sway of the Catholic Church, nearly 30 years before the French Revolution, was the key driver of the fertility decline
- 4gotunameagain 4y agoSo, the demographic transition took place exceptionally early in France, but why? In my research, I argue that the diminished sway of the Catholic Church, nearly 30 years before the French Revolution, was the key driver of the fertility decline. It more and more seems like "traditional", conservative societies are more successful on aggregate. If they are beneficial to the individuals comprising them, this is a matter of heated debate though. But regardless of that, does the apparent higher fitness of conservative societies (in a global point of view) mean that more "open minded" and "liberated" societies will always be overtaken by the conservative ones ? Are we cursed to an eternal dance between perceived personal liberty and societal success ?
- izacus 4y agoI'd love to see some citation for that since most of the ultra conservative countries around the world are failing states both economically and societally. Everything from Iran, Iraq to European Hungaries to US bible belt states, you can pretty much directly map failure to fringe conservatism.
- 4gotunameagain 4y agoI am not talking about fringe, weird, or internationally blockaded societies, but ones like the comparison of Provence and Brittany of the article.
- adaml_623 4y agoCan you quickly specify what you mean by successful. And which "conservative" societies you were thinking of as successful
- mytailorisrich 4y agoWell, by the metric of Conservative and high birth rate Afghanistan is currently the most successful country on Earth, as I believe it has the leading population growth rate...
- langsoul-com 4y agoThe book, "shall the religious inherit the world" is relevant. I'd be interested what happens when general birthrate declines and a religious group, that massively encourages tons of children, take larger voting percentages.
- eastbound 4y agoI don’t understand: Are you suggesting that it’s what France is currently experimenting, or did it not fall into your radar that France is currently experiencing this? If not, I’d be interested if you look at birthrate by religion in France (and please add stats of bullying at school if you find them) and see whether it fits your expected model.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe assumption that religion is something that people stick with is dubious, though. In the absence of coercion people will tend to abandon religion. Look at what's happening to Christianity in the US.
- rubidium 4y agoHighly recommend you study history a bit more. If you truly think religion only “sticks” in the presence of coercion… well there’s a lot of history that would be hard to understand.
- makeitdouble 4y ago“Coercion” might be a strong word, but there’s many form of “very strong incentives” applied in most religions. Not being included in the group and face critically harsher survival conditions by not participating in the religion is a form of that for instance.
- AdrianB1 4y agoI thought the same, but real life experience shows that in my country (Romania) there is an increase of religion with age, especially for women; in other words, most women start being religious when they age and these days most of the religious traditions are maintained and transmitted by old women. I know many women that were secular in their 20-30, become religious at 50 and are regular churchgoers at 70. My mother used to be a secular feminist engineer 40 years ago, she is none of these today. As a country we were over 50% secular 30 years ago, the last census tells over 90% declared to be religious (census is wrong, but how wrong?).
- maelito 4y ago> she declined over the next 250 years to be just another European power. Why would we want 300 millions inhabitants in France ? That's what we would have with the density of the Netherlands. Why couldn't France be on top of leisure, urban transports, ecology, natural ecosystems, technology, political innovation, and even military defense, with 70 million inhabitants ? Worlwide politics are biased, always considering GDP first, instead of a myriad of more relevant indicators.
- notyourday 4y agoWhat happens in the next 100 years?
- immibis 4y agoWe increase the human population by another 100x in the never-ending quest to increase GDP, then we run out of resources and die. Dolphins become the most intelligent life on the planet.
- hardlianotion 4y agoWhat dolphins?
- spongeb00b 4y ago"Thanks for all the fish"
- 4y ago
- twelve40 4y agoInteresting. Also funny that this pioneer of the child-free movement has actually the best fertility rate in Europe currently. Not by much, and still in the negative, but.
- hinata08 4y agoit's pretty easy to have children in France, like you have typically 25 + 9 paid days off per year (I personally can't use so many, being a company drone. So I have to take days off to see friends and family) And it's ok to leave work on time to take care of your children _your coworkers understand that they are more important to you, and they make you happy. You get a lot of assistance and encouragement from both the local governments and the social fabric. Like there are a lot of clubs to have children to do sports. They're managed by all the parents, by cities, schools,... So finding a hobby for your children isn't so hard. middle class and low income families can get a lot of subsidies to help them pay for a lot of stuff for their children (including the (in)famous allocations familiales, and 'allocation de rentrée scolaire', that are just spent of flat screens according to right wing ppl) And you can leave your children at some kindergarten or at they grandparents when you need. So you can have children without being crazy rich like in the USA, or without being a Rabenmutter like in Germany, and you have time to take care of them.
- kasey_junk 4y agoIn the US (and probably the rest of the world) number of children per household is inversely correlated with income[1]. Every time a discussion of birthdates comes up people claim it’s too expensive to have children, but the actual evidence suggests that isn’t a factor. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/241530/birth-rate-by-family-income-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/241530/birth-rate-by-fam...
- medvezhenok 4y agoIt's the opportunity cost (how much income are you giving up by having kids), not the absolute income. Also, people at lower incomes have subsidies, so cost of children can be different. For example - in VT, if your income < 150% FPL (federal poverty level), you pay $0 towards child care (versus some people paying > $2000/month in places like NY) https://outside.vermont.gov/dept/DCF/Shared%20Documents/Benefits/CCFAP-Income-Guidelines-Effective-2.26.2023.pdf https://outside.vermont.gov/dept/DCF/Shared%20Documents/Bene... If you calculate opportunity cost, the cost of a child increases dramatically as you go up the income ladder. From tens of thousands of dollars to hundreds (in income missed) or even millions (if you take time off + pay for your kid's schooling in private academies)
- nathan_compton 4y agoIn my estimation its worth a decline in standard of living to be free of traditional, conservative values.
- koheripbal 4y agoPoverty generates more conservatism, not less.
- nathan_compton 4y agoPoverty does, but not a small decline in standard of living. France isn't a third world country, its just not an imperial power. Seems great to me. On balance, I'd like to live in a modestly successful country without imperial ambitions. Lot of Glaucons at Hackernews, I guess.
- inawarminister 4y agoFrance is still an imperial power in West Africa, though certainly in the last few months it's changing.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoOne wonders if that’s stable long-term. The US is a relatively benign hegemon, but that’s just luck. The next one isn’t likely to be very nice at all, going by the standards of history.
- etothepii 4y agoIsn't the view of the article that you get both? The areas where the counter reformation was strongest had the biggest drop in fertility.
- ciphol 4y agoThe areas where the counter-reformation (i.e. theocracy) was strongest had the most secular populations. Do you call that religion or not-religion?
- yobbo 4y agoGDP in "real dollars" is irrelevant here. Any such measurement can't correspond to something meaningful. Rather "annual calories from agriculture per capita" would reveal much more of the reasons behind this and other upheavals in Europe during the period. There were climate/weather changes (not well understood or appropriate to research in light of current climate changes) in Europe during 1500-1850, which caused starvation, upheavals, migrations, wars, and so on. They did not affect all areas simultaneously in the same way.
- ciphol 4y agoWhy would the climate/weather changes stop right at the French border?
- yobbo 4y agoThey didn't. But if the amount of available calories drops below the necessary amount, then famine occurs. How bad this is depends on how much overshoot, and how prepared the population is to find alternatives. In Irish history, there is the "Great Famine". During the 1800s, maybe 20% of the population of Ireland and the Scandinavian countries emigrated to north america. The current trend of global warming and increasing harvests started in the later 1800s. Then came mechanised farming, artificial fertilizers, and science. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age
- pharke 4y agoBlaming the Catholic church specifically for high birth rates is a misstep especially since the author compares to England which has a long and varied history with Protestantism. The argument should be reframed around religiosity in general or he should show data for England that indicates a difference in fertility during the periods of stronger and weaker Catholic influence in England.
- jtbayly 4y agoHe never says the high birth rate is because of the Roman Catholic Church. Every place in Europe was deeply religious and had high birth rates at that time, regardless of the religion. He only blames secularization for the decline in birth rate. It just happens that the rapid secularization happened fastest where the Roman Catholic Church was strongest.
- pharke 4y ago> I argue that the diminished sway of the Catholic Church, nearly 30 years before the French Revolution, was the key driver of the fertility decline > ...the Catholic Church, threatened by the spread of the Protestant Reformation, took ‘be fruitful and multiply’ seriously and the purpose of marriage became explicitly multiplicative > The decline of Catholicism, and fertility, in eighteenth-century France turned it from a demographic powerhouse – the China of Europe – to merely a first-rank European power among several
- jtbayly 4y agoThe first and third quotes only say that the birth rate diminished as Catholicism declined, which in a Roman Catholic area means secularization is occurring. Again, this is logically not the same thing as saying that Catholicism itself is the cause of the high birth rate. A birthrate can be high because of one thing and decrease because of something else. The second quote still doesn’t show that the birth rate was high because of Catholicism. It doesn’t even say what the effect of that position was. Could catholicism have been the cause of the high birth rate in France before it dropped? Sure. But the article never makes that claim. And it implies otherwise, because it mentions high birth rates around Europe including places that weren’t catholic.
- amriksohata 4y agoThe changing male and female roles in society also has a part to play in any society where women are needed to work
- AdrianB1 4y agoFully agree with the first part, disagree with the second: women elected to work, they did not needed to work. Single income family was in a way better than dual income family, the world was in a great shape in the '60-'70 when women started to move to paid jobs. Now you have a lot more workers, more leverage to employers and a lot less time spent in the family and less time to have kids when you want to build a career at the same time (and that career is just a regular job in 90% of the cases).
- amriksohata 4y agoI dont know why people have down rated your reply, its a fair assessment on my original comment.
- roncesvalles 4y agoAs someone born in the 90s, it does seem like I was born in the "rubble" of a great societal shift from the family to the individual as the atomic unit of evaluating someone's societal stature. Although this shift has had benefits, it made the role of a housewife that of a worthless dependent. I'm not at all lamenting that this is a bad thing. Women should obviously be able to pursue careers the same way as men. However, it does seem that there is a lag between this change and how society is organized. There are some facts that are hard to ignore: 1. Raising young children without help is a lot of work. 2. Somebody needs to cook. Ordering 3 meals a day from a restaurant is unaffordable for most. There is also a trust/perception issue that "outside food" is not as good as homemade food. 3. If you work a full-time job you can give very little time for anything else. Some major societal change needs to occur that invalidates one of these three points.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> France appeared to be a stagnant society before the French Revolution. If culture was not changing, then how could it be responsible for such a climactic shift in such an important social outcome? > Using this genealogical data, I estimate that the decline in fertility took hold in France in the 1760s 1760s don’t look far from the French Revolution to me. Ending a regime that lasted more than a dozen centuries doesn’t happen from a one night cultural shift, and I’d argue a shift starting in the 1960s seems pretty reasonable. Of course the cultural itself is coming from other factors, but I’m not convinced it can be dismissed so lightly.
- yobbo 4y agoYes. French revolution was partly sparked by high food prices due to poor harvests. When there is surplus, the population can grow. If production does not increase in step with population growth, there will be shortage. When there is shortage, there is hunger and/or starvation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overshoot_(population) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overshoot_(population)
- RockyMcNuts 4y agoIn the 1700s France had John Law, wars, famines, and bad kings. Geopolitically France is an interesting place with one foot in Mediterranean civilization and one foot in Northern Europe, good natural barriers, and a fairly unified culture. After the religious wars of the Reformation, there was a period of pretty good kings and increasingly strong state, prosperity importing tech from Muslim world via Italy, and liberalization. During this period, Italy, Germany, UK, low countries had their own problems and France was pretty dominant. Before the French Revolution and the Industrial Revolution, France had 4x the population of Great Britain. After Napoleon's defeat, was never that dominant again. Mediocre kings and Napoleon III, played second fiddle to UK in industrial revolution, political unrest, and Germany unified under Prussia and Rhine industrialists and defeated France in 1870.
- Vaderv 4y ago[dead]
- makeitdouble 4y agoThe more I read this, the less I get his point on the religious influence. > It is unclear why the Catholic Church’s influence waned so quickly and why France was the first country to secularize. But then, if he doesn’t know enough about what’s happening in France during that period, how can he pin down the demographic decline as caused by the Catholic Church’s decline ? What if it was a completely different reason that he couldn’t find in his very limited set of documents ? > The decline of Catholicism, and fertility, in eighteenth-century France turned it from a demographic powerhouse – the China of Europe – to merely a first-rank European power among several Why wouldn’t it the other way round, with the core causes of the French decline also triggering less religiousness ? This article has a lot of data, but the base logical argument feels off, like starting from a conclusion and sticking correlated statistics to it without ever coming up with definitive causality.
- mardifoufs 4y agoI'm not sure about France, but the catholic church has definitely been a huge factor in population growth here in Québec. It's a widely accepted fact in academia here, though I agree the linked article does not make a great argument for a possibly similar effect in France.
- arrozconcosas 4y agoCatholic families tend to be very large. They tend to use contraception less and also have greater number of children per family. It’s still true today: https://ifstudies.org/blog/americas-growing-religious-secular-fertility-divide https://ifstudies.org/blog/americas-growing-religious-secula...
- agumonkey 4y agoI don't know if there's a direct line between this and the post ww2 service / office career for all (including women) so that people invested all their thoughts and time in work.
- makeitdouble 4y agoSure, but for contrast Italia is a largely more catholic country than France [0], yet France has a higher fertility rate [1] So religion can be a factor, but there are so many other factors than can weight in the balance. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Church_by_country [1] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/ddn-20210323-2 https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/d...
- t0bia_s 4y ago> Today, the political and economic prospects of an empty planet are a worry for many, as more and more countries reach fertility rates below replacement levels. Yea, it looks like another poltical topic that vary with party. Alarmism about overpopulation is also quite popular.
- no1groyp 4y agoNo worries. Plenty of North Africans to fill the dearth
- thriftwy 4y agoThat's the problem with demographic transitions colliding with modern political culture. You're not getting an 50 million European country out of 80 million contry: instead, you will be getting a 80 million African country occupying the same place.
- MichaelMoser123 4y agoThe article is very selective: For example there is no mention of the Napoleonic wars. Also there was WW1 - that's another big demographic shift. They built a big defensive line, the Maginot line, because they gathered that they would not have the manpower for another big confrontation, in the style of WW1. However France had a higher birthrate than Germany - in the period after WW2.
- eternalban 4y ago> Malthus’s prediction proved false due to two paradigm shifts working together So this guy makes a prediction, and his entire argument is proven false, but he apparently had an amazing PR firm so to this day his name is used in serious conversation.
- projektfu 4y agoIn the article he points to the malthusian dynamic operating in England during the same period-more productivity, more babies. Paradigms can be true in some time periods and locations while being false in others.
- mkoubaa 4y ago> From the dawn of humanity to the eighteenth century, human life was dominated by starvation, poverty, wars, and pandemics. Actually no, human life only started to be dominated by this after the shift from hunter gatherer to agrarian societies.
- Convolutional 4y agoMarshall Sahlins studied hunter gatherer bands, and many work less than forty hours a week. Programmers I know can't figure out how to get down to a forty hour a week workweek to survive, but these hunter gather bands in sub-Saharan Africa and the Amazon seem to have figured it out.
- klipt 4y agoI assume those groups are now protected and effectively have some government granted monopoly on their hunting and gathering land. Always easier to have a good life with extra help from the government :)
- Convolutional 4y agoNot really, they're being killed off by mining companies.
- klipt 4y agoThat's sad to hear. Suggests they don't really have it all figured out though. Being able to defend yourself from invaders is an important thing to figure out, too.
- therealdrag0 4y agoIve worked at a half dozen companies and never been pressured to work more than 40 hours as an engineer. So many have figured it out.
- pas 4y agoforaging only works if there's a sufficiently low population density. the Amazon is so plentiful it even allows these communities to stay relatively fixed, in other climates they had to move around a lot (after relatively exhausting an area) of course we work a lot more because we want some of that economic surplus to reinvest it back into things that we think will improve our life. a relatively constant life wouldn't require that. also our decision-making and surplus distribution system is very very inefficient compared to a few hundred strong community's. economically we can afford to build millions individual cars and houses and offices, fully furnish them, and do this again-and-again when old buildings get demolished, old stuff gets dumped into landfills. we can afford to build tanks and bombs and then do that again and again, and to maintain standing armies. unfortunately efficiency and longevity is just not a global concern :(
- AlbertCory 4y agoThis is a very thorough piece of research. In particular, if you're saying "in industrialized societies you don't need as many children" you've missed the entire point of the article: he's demonstrating that "having fewer children" began long before industrialization. > during the Franco-Prussian War of 1870, when France was defeated after a solitary battle against a single opponent. I was always curious about that war, since "Sedan" is the only battle you ever read about (plus maybe The Commune), so I read a book on it. There were quite a few battles leading up to it. The Germans had better artillery, and their field commanders had more latitude for improvisation.