21 ms·
Social media is a cause, not a correlate, of mental illness in teen girls
- muddi900 4y agoFuture generations will regard Jon Haidt the same way we regard Paul Ehrlic
- warner25 4y agoI'm still reading it, but this is great so far. As a father to four little girls, though, it makes me feel really defeated. I can already see that social media has eroded my wife's mental health. I just don't know what to do in the next few years when our girls approach the age when everyone else will get an iPhone and have an Instagram account. I want to say no, but that leads to many other issues, including what the author describes perfectly in this passage: "Suppose that... a 12-year-old girl decided to quit all social media platforms. Would her mental health improve? Not necessarily. If all of her friends continued to spend 5 hours a day on the various platforms then she’d find it difficult to stay in touch with them. She’d be out of the loop and socially isolated."
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- mixmastamyk 4y agoIt’s ok for a 12yo to be out of the loop for a few hours. They see their friends every day at school.
- mulmen 4y agoDo they? Is social media being used in morning classes to plan lunch? Will a socially isolated student even have friends? I haven't been in school for many years so I don't know the social dynamic but it isn't hard to imagine.
- swader999 4y agoThey do seem to live on Snapchat lately.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoNo, phones not allowed on in class. Might be able to do for 3 mins between classes while walking.
- mulmen 4y agoYeah and no games were allowed on my ti-83.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoDo you really think kids are “planning lunch” over social media, when they sit at the same tables every day? And the cafeteria is providing it? Sounds like you’re grasping at straws to make it seem relevant. The kids here communicate via imessage and rarely during class.
- mulmen 4y agoI absolutely believe that lunch seating is a manifestation of social hierarchy and that positions are determined in advance, yes.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThose things are chosen via looks, athleticism, and charisma in person. Not planned each morning via internet points, right?
- mulmen 4y agoNo? If the communication can happen in person it can happen online. There was no shortage of gossip on MSN Messenger when I was in school. If social media is as important to these kids as it sounds then follower count or posting style may be as important as athleticism and charisma.
- sdwr 4y agoKids are a lot more susceptible to feeling left out of stuff. They don't know it's all the same crap everywhere yet ;) There's also a spectrum of FOMO, from accidental to intentional. Some people feed off of excluding others.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago"Oh my god, did you see what Stacy posted last night!" But your daughter missed it because "you didn't let her have an Instagram account!" It seems to me that such worries are well-founded. At best, she made the decision herself and still feels the pain of it.
- IncRnd 4y agoThat's letting kids parent themselves.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIt's universalizing agency.
- anigbrowl 4y agoYou're looking at it in isolation because you are not privy to the kids' social circle. What the gp is describing is a social cost imposed on the non-participant kid. If repeated often, this will lower their status within their social circle and (much like chickens) the least popular kids become the default target for emotional abuse and bullying. If they withdraw form their social circle to cut their losses, then they potentially become a general bullying target, because they are not part of a protective circle. It's easy to be dismissive of these ideas, but there is an extensive and rigorous literature on network topology and dynamics. A good introduction with a strong quantitative/mathematical orientation is Social and Economic Networks by Matthew Jackson. Arguing on the basis of your own developmental experience in which significantly different conditions obtained (eg the non-existence/availability of social media or the internet) is equivalent to just wishing the problem away.
- concordDance 4y agoThe problem comes down to putting kids in forced confinement with a bunch of other kids for 6 hours a day with no way for them to escape. Mandatory "education" of teens is harmful on the net. It wastes some of the most energetic and productive hours of life while teaching very few useful skills (and those could be taught in a fraction of the time).
- acedTrex 4y agoBut then they are out of loop in the in person discussions that are predominantly focused on the happenings of whatever is on instagram at that time
- heavyset_go 4y agoWhen I was in school, kids whose parents chose not to expose them to cable TV were ostracized. I can imagine something similar happening today with social media.
- nerdponx 4y agoI definitely felt left out not having an N64 or Playstation growing up, but in hindsight I didn't actually miss much. What stings at the time is the feeling that you're missing out.
- metalliqaz 4y agoSame. It have no idea what I'm going to do about it.
- theGnuMe 4y agoSo we know that social media causes depression and anxiety and we know that kids will want to be on social media so we have to teach them the skills to regulate their emotions. Most importantly that they can identify when they need to ask for help and will ask for it. We need to normalize asking for help. Right now kids can learn these skills in therapy but that is not the only place those skills should be taught or reinforced. Schools for example are a good place for that. Remember that cliques in school were reinforced by the telephone and just like the game of telephone a lot gets lost in communication. Social media is an extension of that.
- metalliqaz 4y agoI don't even have the skills to regulate my emotions
- theGnuMe 4y agoSo I guess you know where to begin then and that is with you.
- barbazoo 4y agoIt must be frustrating to see this problem approaching and not knowing what to do. I wonder if at some point the only way out is to radically change one's family's lifestyle. Maybe homeschooling, very limited technology at home, living in a community with like-minded people, something like that?
- flerchin 4y agoLet's find a solution that does not involve expanding the Amish model.
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoThe Amish kinda slap, they didn't invent addictive social media, put a game show host in charge of nuclear weapons, or have a bunch of corporations change their icons to rainbow icons while still being shitty. They literally realized 300 years ago that they should opt out of the nonsense America descended into
- bavila 4y ago> The Amish kinda slap For anyone else who was confused by this: https://www.dictionary.com/e/slang/slap/ https://www.dictionary.com/e/slang/slap/
- TheGeminon 4y agoSlap means really good in this context, e.g. "this song really slaps". This makes me want to make a generational/chronological slang chart now
- bavila 4y agoThanks, just edited my post to link to the definition. Guess I'd fall under the generation that would have said "rock" instead (although the Amish most definitely do not rock).
- 4y ago
- neogodless 4y agoDisclaimer: Not a parent, did not grow up during the era of social media (and my own childhood experiences cannot be extrapolated!) As a kid, I was bullied, outcast, left out. Oddly enough, I don't think I was depressed. Sure, I was sad sometimes. But given that my options didn't include doing things with kids from school, I did things on my own. Fortunately for me, I also had access to a (relatively) safe outdoors to explore. Or if the weather wasn't cooperating, I would play with toys inside. But it sounds like social isolation can lead to mental illness/depression, so I don't know if enduring that is an acceptable alternative to the near certain mental illness that being part of the internet-connected social scene seems to cause. Should we redirect our attention to figuring out how to keep kids mentally healthy despite likely social isolation that's going to happen no matter what? Is that possible?
- warner25 4y agoThis is an interesting thought. It sounds like your childhood was similar to mine. A big turning point in my life was finally realizing or accepting, at 15 or 16 years old, that it was OK to not be popular or be part of a big group of friends. It was OK to have just a few close relationships. It was OK to sit quietly by myself in the cafeteria during lunch and do my homework if my few friends didn't have the same lunch period. Ironically, I started to have more conventional social success after that, in addition to doing much better academically after a rough freshman and sophomore year of high school. I've shared that advice with younger people, but not my own kids yet. I don't know if it helped, or if you can really teach that.
- shagie 4y agoWhile the generations are a bit dated - https://waitbutwhy.com/2013/09/why-generation-y-yuppies-are-unhappy.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2013/09/why-generation-y-yuppies-are-... > Social media creates a world for Lucy where A) what everyone else is doing is very out in the open, B) most people present an inflated version of their own existence, and C) the people who chime in the most about their careers are usually those whose careers (or relationships) are going the best, while struggling people tend not to broadcast their situation. This leaves Lucy feeling, incorrectly, like everyone else is doing really well, only adding to her misery: > (image) > So that’s why Lucy is unhappy, or at the least, feeling a bit frustrated and inadequate. In fact, she’s probably started off her career perfectly well, but to her, it feels very disappointing. > ... > Ignore everyone else. Other people’s grass seeming greener is no new concept, but in today’s image crafting world, other people’s grass looks like a glorious meadow. The truth is that everyone else is just as indecisive, self-doubting, and frustrated as you are, and if you just do your thing, you’ll never have any reason to envy others. --- Thus, the "set reasonable expectations" along with "realize that what is on social media is a constructed reality reflecting the masks people wear in that environment." The "what people see on Facebook" is almost as scripted as any romcom movie - just that most people realize that the movie is a constructed fabrication yet tend to expect that they can live day to day the same as what people project into the constructed reality of social media.
- nerdponx 4y agoThis article is the classic "millennials are sad because they have unrealistically high expectations" drivel that I thought we had buried for good. Even for 2013 it seems pretty trashy. Lucy doesn't think she's unusually wonderful, and to assume so is completely unfair to Lucy. Lucy was told over and over and over that all she needed to do was go to college and work hard at anything somewhat respectable, and financial stability and personal comfort would follow. She only ever wanted a decent liberal arts education, and after that a decent career. You know who fed her that BS? Her delusional parents. Yes, it's easy to get unrealistic expectations from social media. But that's not the point of the article, for anyone tempted to click and read.
- 4y ago
- giantg2 4y agoThey wouldn't be out of the loop if enough other girls did the same thing. They you'd have your own group.
- bazmattaz 4y agoLet’s be honest though. That would simply never work. You’d have to get a group of teen girls to make a pact to all be out of the loop. Not one of them can sneak a peek at social media! Knowing what teens are like I’d say that experiment would last a week. Social media is addictive probably even more so for teens and fomo is real
- ericlewis 4y agoI have witnessed the same with my wife, we only have one girl.. the only thing I have imagined could work is keeping her busy and teaching her how to be attracted to decent communities that may not necessarily be who she goes to school with. edit: but I have literally no clue what I am going to do, I have like another 5 years or so.
- austinl 4y agoI once sat next to a dean of private school on a plane—she mentioned that the ~100 parents that sent their children to the school signed an agreement that they would restrict their children's access to social media until 9th grade. I have no idea how well it was adhered to or enforced, but it surprised me that the parents of the school and the dean were trying to collectively organize action around this issue to prevent the problems described above. I had never heard of that before.
- mcbuilder 4y agoAnd at 9th grade it's a free for all? Looking back the high school years would have been the worst for my own self esteem, angst, etc. Glad none of it was recorded. :)
- throwaway1777 4y agoMaybe, but middle school is often thought to be the worst. Kids are so young at that age but also smart enough to be exposed to all kinds of things.
- dilznoofus 4y agoAs undeveloped mentally as highschoolers are, they have years more development more than middleschoolers Middleschoolers are suddenly blasted with hormones, and are basically accelerating at breakneck speed. Everyone's body is changing wildly, you're thinking and feeling new things every day, and it's all a total mindfuck. By highschool, the hypernovelty has worn off. Yes, they're still developing and figuring things out, but it's not quite as much of the surreal existential body-horror that middleschool is.
- yamtaddle 4y agoThere's a slump in classroom performance and psychological well-being around 6th-8th consistently-observed enough that it's got one or more names in the fields of education and psychology ("middle school slump", "middle school malaise", "middle school plunge", et c.) Mention it to a teacher and they'll likely know what you're talking about.
- prepend 4y agoAs a parent to a 12 year old girl, I’ve been fighting the “no social media” fight since she requested at 9. Every single one of her friends have social media and I think it is negative to be isolated in that way. But I also notice that she seems to have positive benefits over her friends, but of course it’s tough to measure. It’s strange to me because I’ve talked about this literature and whatnot with other parents and they just shrug and say that their kid won’t abuse it and will withstand the negative effects. Of course, many of these are posting on social media quite a bit themselves. It’s tough for parents but I’m encouraged by more evidence on this subject and hope that there’s soon public health guidance about when to allow social media.
- theshrike79 4y agoThis is really baffling to me, because social media sites have an age limit of 13 in most western countries. ...and this is by the companies themselves, if they are found out to be "marketing to children", they get hit with a whole another set of legal issues. Epic just got hit with this because of Fortnite and has to pay over $200M fines. The only issue is that there is zero oversight on the age limit, there is no way to report underage users on social media sites - and even if there is, nothing happens until someone goes through the courts.
- lozenge 4y agoYou definitely can report an underage user.
- theshrike79 4y agoI tried to do it on WhatsApp (age limit 16 in the EU), but guess what? You can only report YOUR OWN CHILD: https://faq.whatsapp.com/695318248185629 https://faq.whatsapp.com/695318248185629 Other Meta properties are better at this though.
- MertsA 4y ago> if you're not the parent of this child, then we strongly recommend that you encourage a parent to contact us using the instructions above. Given that the instructions are to prove ownership over the phone number as well as trying to at least somewhat link that to an underage child how exactly could this reasonably be accomplished by someone other than the parent? If you know enough to be confident that a given account is linked to a minor then there's basically zero chance that you won't also know of a way to contact their parents about it. Given the e2e nature of WhatsApp any other implementation would be akin to the "But think about the children!!!" reactionary calls to ban e2e encryption.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoIn mid 2022 I started doing what I called Facebookless Fridays. Eventually that progressed to also on a Saturday afteroon-ish I'd update my status to "See You Noon Tuesday"* and then not do FB til noon Tue, in addition to FL Fridays. It was odd at first. But then it's liberating in the sense you realize how much junkfood for the mind and soul it is. Mind you I'm not a 12 y/o but perhaps if it was a group / family effort you can pull back enough to develop healthier perspectives not based on SM and only SM? * Yes, it's any intentional play on see you next Tuesday ;)
- samstave 4y agoAs the Father of Three girls ; I propose a screen-age limit. Just like the drinking limit, and I think that certain sites should have a limit of 10 years old. Only educational sites and videos should be available to anyone under 10. I KNOW this is a horrendously hard problem to solve - but kids should EARN sceen time by 'playing outside time' or something. Kids born to cities are fucked. kids born to dense 'no-nature'access' environs are fucked. But growing up in the forrests of california and being a latch-key kid in the 80s was a godsend to my imagination and thus my IQ.
- autoexec 4y ago> Only educational sites and videos should be available to anyone under 10. I don't think you could enforce this anyway, but it's also a terrible idea. I can't imagine what my life would have been like if my local library or bookseller felt like you do about the internet and I was trapped reading fiction way below by level. The solution to the problem isn't censorship and holding inquisitive children back, it's parenting and guiding children safely while they explore their interests and the world they live in.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bart_spoon 4y agoThis assumes that children are “held back” by not having unlimited access to screens. It also equates books with the internet which is absurd. Social media, and the internet as we know it, have only been a part of children’s lives for about 15 years, less than a single generation. The idea that it is now an indispensable part of their development, and that depriving them of it is going to harm them us utterly ridiculous. As if every generation before now consists of drooling ape-men that could have been what this current generation of apparent Uber-children will become if only they too had access to TikTok and YouTube.
- autoexec 4y agoIt assumes that children would be "held back" by not being able to access content they are mature enough for until they reach an arbitrary age determined by someone other than the child or the child's parents. Nowhere did I suggest that children should have "unlimited access to screens". In fact I explicitly mentioned that it should be parents who ensure that their children are exposed to things safely. I have no doubt that the children growing up with access to the internet (including youtube and twitter) had greater opportunity to be better educated, more exposed to art and culture, and to be better prepared for their life as an adult in the world than the children who grew up without the internet. Those things were made much easier by having access to the internet. I say that as someone who grew up without internet access for many years. I know not having access to the internet we have today as a young child placed limitations on what I could have reasonably attained. That doesn't mean we should set every child lose on the internet without any thought to what they're seeing. Also, the internet is very much like books, but I'd remind you that libraries and even bookstores offer many other forms of media as well.
- somethoughts 4y agoOne strategy that should help is to load them up on extracurriculars. Keep them busy with extra math tutoring (russian school of math, kumon, etc.) and physically active in a healthy way with enough sleep (swimming, track, soccer). That way there is not a lot of dwell time to be depressed about missing out on stuff. Also taking away privileges due to not passing grades, not keeping up with math tutoring, etc. is a great way to get them out of the social media loop. It gives them a highly plausible and relatable reason to not be active on these platforms (i.e. uggh, I "wish" I could have seen that instagram post but my parents are soo strict!). Having a big important swim meet or soccer game early Saturday morning is a great reason for not being at Friday's drinking party (i.e. I would have been too tired to go anyway).
- andrewflnr 4y agoSo much for the "play based childhood", then. (And no, of course assigned sports don't count)
- oblio 4y agoIs he wrong though? If the other kids aren't really playing, what's the point? Play for the sake of playing toxic social media social games?
- jrumbut 4y agoIn another thread I mentioned the need for organized (in the sense of same place, same time) unstructured activity. Gather at the basketball court, if practice or a game break out that's good, if not that's OK. It seems like everyone wins in that scenario, it's healthy but playful and low stress while accommodating parents' need for scheduling. Is such a thing common? I don't hear about it much.
- somethoughts 4y agoAgree, its unfortunate that most of the after school sports program start getting to be like prepping for professional/collegiate level sports once they reach high school. Middle school sports and junior varsity high school sports coupled with math tutoring is probably enough to keep them busy enough and out of trouble/off social media.
- nerdponx 4y agoThis effect is just as true for adults as for kids. I largely lost touch with the music scene I was involved in because I didn't want to do everything on Facebook, and now Instagram.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cassac 4y agoPart of it is never letting them start early in the first place. Stay strong and don’t give in. The old saying “If they were your real friends they wouldn’t care…” is more true than it is cliche. Try to make them understand that.
- waboremo 4y agoOr, instead of creating hyper rebellious kids who seek to go against your strong absolute rules - talk to them. Get them bored of social media. Explain what's really going on, what different forms of social media exist, how to talk to your friends directly in a safe way rather than go through the drudge of Instagram. What limits should exist when using any of these communication platforms. They'll understand. Often we want to protect our family through rigid rules, but all that does is make them want to pull away more.
- cassac 4y agoHaving absolute rules doesn’t mean having rebellious kids. I have an absolute rule to look both ways before crossing the street and nobody had ever rebelled against that. But I 100% agree you do have to explain and you do have to eat your own dog food and try not to be too much of a hypocrite. They need to see you believe it yourself. And try not to lie with tall tales. I think every time a non life threatening absolute statement is proven false by experience they will lose trust. I read or heard once that if you always told your child to put a coat on before they have actually experienced the cold they naturally don’t understand why they need it and will resist wearing one. But if you let them experience the cold and involve them in the thought process they will want to put a coat on. “Let’s see how it feels outside? Oooo it’s cold! What should we do?” Etc etc. I’ve tried to do that with most things (within reason and when applicable) and I think it gives them more confidence and understanding. Like the whole tell/show/include thing. The more experiences like this where you proved to be right the more they trust you even when the disagree.
- doubled112 4y agoSome people really just need to find out for themselves. All the talking it through will not convince them. Everybody is different. Even between my two boys, one is going to do it anyway, and one will be too busy thinking about it to do it. Speaking of different, I do remember friends as a kid that went through a phase where they believed "no, they won't hit me or else". The "or else" was the driver getting in trouble, being sued, going to prison, something. I never thought any of that would fix me, and continued to look.
- timst4 4y agoMiddle School educator here. I can assure you that your daughters will not be alone when it comes to a moratorium on social media. However, the girls they may very well want to be friends with may be very much into social media and group chats. My advice is to be firm but also take steps to create social opportunities for your daughters. I have a 12yo and I host board game nights with amazing snack trays. I help her to play video games socially using air console. You have to play defense. These apps are deleterious to your daughters self worth. I’ve seen too many hospitalizations and suicides to believe otherwise. But you also have to play offense. They will need guidance on how to be social in a world coopted by manipulation and deceit. Parenting these days is challenging but it’s possible to raise girls who thrive without phones.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- haydar_ai 4y agoIs it correct for me to assume that you have your daughter without a smartphone right? How is she communicating day-to-day with her peers in school then?
- lll-o-lll 4y agoThanks a ton for this. As a father of a pre-teen daughter who begs for a smartphone every day, I’ve been anxious about how I’m going to deal with this situation. I’d only been thinking in terms of defence, and this article had me really worried. Planning for how to create the social opportunities is just as important. Defence and Offence. I really like it!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrei_says_ 4y agoiOS has excellent parental control tools, down to time allowance on per app level. Of course a decision to use restriction would ideally be one made together with the child so that they can truly consent.
- e40 4y agoYou've hit on the conundrum. Damned if you do join the social network (for the known reasons) and damned if you don't (isolation from friends). Until a major of parents remove access, this will always be the problem. Btw, I had the same issue with games and my son. I could not let him play, but then he wouldn't have had access to the sole socialization his peer group had. Both decisions were bad, but one was worse. Letting him play video games was the least bad choice. Interestingly, we've had discussions about this, now that he's an adult and (I believe) he agrees with this analysis.
- NaN1352 4y agoVideo games and social media are two entirely different things. Some of my best times with my friends is LAN parties as well as going together at demo parties, traveling, coding together. Frankly, a ban on videogames is stupid as hell. Even today on discord and over the network, it?s stil entirely unlike social media. /smh
- e40 4y agoI agree they are different, but they definitely share some things. Moderation with video games is hard for young people. Same for social media. That's why I mentioned it. And, I wasn't suggesting a ban on video games.
- Shocka1 4y agoI have a four year old boy who absolutely loves games, just like I did at a young age. Any and all advice is welcome in handling this, so I appreciate your comments. My current strategy has been steering him towards games that require a bit of thinking - like Kerbel Space Program, flight simulators, Kings Quest, etc. He gets to play a little Roblox as well, but only in very small doses. I have to help him a lot with them right now, but once he starts reading I'm hoping he'll choose these types of games on his own. In the warmer months this is easier to manage because he loves playing outside, but it can sometimes be challenging in winter.
- ljm 4y agoI would contest one point in the article, and I admit this is dependent on where you live: > But social media is very different because it transforms social life for everyone, even for those who don’t use social media, whereas sugar consumption just harms the consumer. In countries with single-payer healthcare (or socialised healthcare), it's not true that it harms only the consumer. If it turns into obesity, diabetes, or other medical conditions, then it may transform social life by virtue of adding pressure to the healthcare system. This is a rephrasing of the argument against smoking, where the argument that was smoking harms nobody else, and the counter was that smokers created a healthcare burden. Arguably this is the same case in insurance-based countries, but the payment structure keeps the onus on the individual, not the overall system. The point being that social media has damaging externalities no matter how it's framed.
- AndrewUnmuted 4y ago[dead]
- thfuran 4y ago>This is a rephrasing of the argument against smoking, where the argument that was smoking harms nobody else, and the counter was that smokers created a healthcare burden. Smoking also has much more direct second hand effects from releasing smoke into the area of the smoker. Poor diet lack such effects.
- ljm 4y agoWhich most people would agree - smoking in public is not a personal activity; but this debate raged on throughout the 90s and early 00s. The secondary effect is on the healthcare system some time after the fact, which is the same for sugar, alcohol, smoking...where it is a new generation that is funding the care. I don't mean to distract from the main point, but sugar is not an innocent example, especially when lobbying happened to use sugar in favour of fat.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> In countries with single-payer healthcare (or socialised healthcare), it's not true that it harms only the consumer. This is a fallacy. Public health measures benefit some individuals more than others; but everyone benefits. Free treatment catches TB infections, for example, which occur overwhelmingly among homeless people. We're all better off if there are no homeless people wandering around with TB. I'm glad my neighbours all benefit from the NHS, and that I'm not surrounded by sick people.
- sayrer 4y agoI can recommend the book “American Girls” by Nancy Jo Sales. I don’t have any daughters, but I’ve worked at some big social media companies, and this was required reading at one of them. The boss there did have daughters, but it wasn’t only so we would understand. It was so we wouldn’t build Trust and Safety headaches in the first place.
- lettergram 4y agoMy parents always told me “we can only control what goes on in our house” I’d have that attitude — show your children this study and explain why they can’t use it in your home. “I won’t support making you mentally ill” In reality, your kids will likely subvert you to some degree. That said if you set the clear boundaries and alternatives it might not be bad. Particularly, if you’re upfront and explain. I personally send my kids to a school that where we signed an agreement for no tech in the classroom (or generally limit it at home). At the very least, that ensures kids can be kids at school. After that; I suggest getting them in activities and keeping them active. In many ways connectivity is great, it’s the algorithmic enhancement and broadcasting that’s at issue. I doubt there’s mental health issues related to texting one-on-one for instance (or very limited issues).
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoI had my 12 year old daughter read the article and after she argued a while I said: Ok, write up your rejoinder and I will post it and see what others think. For context we severely restrict access to social media in our house, but of course they find ways around this as expected (I don't pi-hole because I want them to learn to be hackers) ----------------------------------- *Why I think it’s reasonable for me to have social media :)* After reading the article, I still believe that I should be allowed to have social media for several reasons. First of all, the article stated that people using social media moderately (half an hour to one and a half hours a day) had little to no decline in their mental health, compared to a large mental health decline in those using it a lot (3-5+ hours a day), and with the limit on my phone, I would be using it minimally, especially because I use a lot of my phone time daily to listen to music (like 5 [REDACTED], which I am listening to right now) and to text my friends, so I would only use it for 20 or so minutes a day, which is very low. Another thing that the article mentioned is that people these days who do not have social media may feel excluded or left out, and may even miss things because they don’t have social media, which can lead to a decline in their mental health as well. It was also mentioned that not every social media user’s mental health is impacted, especially those who use it in moderation. Yet another point was that people will compare themselves to other people on there. In case you hadn’t already noticed, I don’t really do that. I do find people pretty, but I don’t usually compare myself to them. Plus, most of them are significantly older than me, so I don’t expect myself to look like them anyway. I believe that using social media could actually have greater benefits for me, such as being able to record Tiktok dances with my friends, or messaging people on Snapchat. I could also follow my friends and then help support whatever they do (for example, one of my friends has an account for [REDACTED]). Also, studies have shown that when people don’t get to do something as a child/teenager isn’t allowed to do or have something in moderation, they are more likely to do or have it in excess as an adult.
- throw_pm23 4y agoThat's a very well-argued response, congratulations. I will only take issue with the last sentence. I don't know the studies, but most of my friends from school who were smoking in moderation back then, ended up as heavy smokers as adults. Those who avoided it completely (partly due to stricter parenting) largely seem to stay smoking-free in later life.
- lumb63 4y agoI’m not a parent yet, but I worry the same thing. It’s also bigger than parenting. I know a lot of folks in their mid-late 20s who suffer from self esteem problems due to social media. In addition to the overt and obvious depression, there is a constant “not-good-enough”-ness and sense of nihilism that comes with having the best of the best in hobbies, the most social, most active, etc., people shoved down your throat day after day.
- fleddr 4y agoI would add that beyond the effects of it crushing one's self-image, it also messes with your world view. Social media presents the world as nothing but doom and gloom whilst in reality it's not that bad.
- luckylion 4y agoIt may be a bit cynical, but the other option might be to make sure they're validated by social media, not depressed. Pay for photo shootings and makeup so they look larger than life and get lots of likes. Do that enough and they'll be the ones with the seemingly perfect lives, body and beauty that others get depressed by while liking their pictures, and thus sending them positive signals that will improve their self-esteem. Might trigger some narcissism issues, but that might be an acceptable trade-off. In the end, it's a game like private schools and universities. You're not the ones making the rules, but if you want your children to succeed, playing by the idiotic rules might be your safest bet.
- dudul 4y agoThere are schools where phones are forbidden until high school. If you have the means and the problem is important to you try to find one. You can't pick your kids friends but you can do your best to curate the pool they are picking from.
- fleddr 4y agoI'm childless so it may come across as arrogant to give any advise. One thing I learned from observing the teenagers of my friends is that they don't want this either. We're adults and talking and a bunch of kids sit in a row on the couch, playing with their iPads. For hours on end. And yet they hear everything you say. They're paying attention. And when you show a genuine interest them just by asking a few question, the iPad is quickly ignored. That's a sign of hope. They want to engage and be engaged in something more meaningful. The iPad fills a void. This artificial divide of the situation between adults and children does not help. Sending them outside does not help either because nobody else is outside. Engage with them. They have a bunch of free time on their hands but no meaning to fill it with. You can't stop the draw to the device unless that time is filled with things that makes them forget the device. It doesn't take much. A conversation, a board game, a small game of sports in the park, whatever possible for you. I would admit though that the situation for girls is not this simple. They will be dragged into a games of thrones style social battle of self-image/worth.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoWhile I like your comment I would also couch it in a context that I'd guess most parents are familiar with. How your kids act when "outsiders/non-family" are around can be different. Simply the fact you are NOT from the immediate so-intimately-familiar-they-know-the-smell-of-your-farts family means that what you say and do has novelty and therefore engagement right there. Even if you are a friend who drops by every day. Not saying that parents shouldn't engage - we should. But it isn't easy keeping it fresh from inside the fart bubble. :-)
- fleddr 4y agoVery fair point and agree.
- unrealp 4y agoI think addiction is about meaning. Addiction activities are always meaningful activities. May not be pleasurable activities but always meaningful. To quit a meaningful activity, you need to replace with another meaningful activity. like exercise, help someone, do something good..whatever is meaningful to you.
- 2devnull 4y agoAs someone who years ago decided to never use Facebook, I can confirm that abstaining from social media is socially damaging. It’s a bit like the automobile. You can’t opt out of the technological society. I suppose the silver lining is that social media apps aren’t owned and controlled by totalitarian communist regimes, or at least not all of them.
- zarkov99 4y agoI have a 13 year old who just got a phone. I do not think things are as hopeless as you seem to believe. My daughter mocks social media (including my own use of it) and, so far, wants no part of it. That is, I think, largely because her mother and I have been educating her since she could use a computer on how stupid and vapid social media is. As far as I know, none of her friends has any social media accounts either, I believe for similar reasons.
- Alex3917 4y ago> As a father to four little girls, though, it makes me feel really defeated. As a father of two girls who also runs a social network, this article is bullshit. They’re only considering social media that fundamentally looks and feels like Facebook. That’s like saying all outdoor activities are extremely dangerous, when only looking at wingsuit base jumpers.
- sibeliuss 4y agoYou clearly didn't read the article, because what they wrote mostly about was... Instagram.
- Alex3917 4y agoWhich looks and feels like Facebook.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoAnd is owned by Facebook.
- wonderwonder 4y agoMy kids play video games with their friends and while my 9 year old gives as good as he gets my 11 year old is always down for a couple hours if someone says something mean to him on their group chat. He is pretty much unable to ignore trash talk and takes it personally. There is no way I am going to let him get on social media until he is in 10th grade at least. Even then I am going to let him know its monitored and probably restricted. I trust him completely. I let him ride his bike to the park by himself, or with friends, go fishing, go to 7-11 etc. Social media is the devil though and seems tailor made to wreck kids self esteem. Heck it even turns previously rational adults into conspiracy following hateful loons.
- rayiner 4y agoAs Haidt points out, the problem isn’t social media per se but how social media amplifies toxic culture that already exists: https://www.thecoddling.com/ https://www.thecoddling.com/ You can’t realistically ban phones, but you can control the culture they’re exposed to by where you live and send your kids to school.
- logicchains 4y agoIt's never too late to teach them some values. The vast majority of religions and philosophies teach that striving for material things and to satisfy the ego is not healthy, you could research some of the arguments behind it and educate your girls on the harms of comparing themselves to other people. Teach them to value other people (and themselves) by their moral character, not their material possessions or achievements.
- peanuty1 4y agoJust curious, how has social media "eroded your wife's mental health"?
- silisili 4y agoDon't be afraid to be the bad guy. Sometimes, as a parent, that is exactly your job. My child will not have social media for as long as she lives in this house. The interesting thing to me was her reaction, which actually may mirror yours based on your writing. She said she had no interest in Facebook, because she sees how much time mom wastes on it and doesn't like how she acts. That was before our come to jesus moment as husband and wife... which I also highly recommend. But you'll have to be the bad guy again.
- throwaway2474 4y agoControversial take: why not teach your daughters to embrace and win at the social media game? It’s not going away, and being able to successfully navigate that world is going to be a tangible advantage to them later in life. Self worth and happiness, despite what we might want to believe, are largely tied to social status. As parents it may be kinder to help our kids succeed at the game rather than pretend it doesn’t exist.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoIt isn't universal. Some want to become superstars and famous and some do not. Acceptance with your position in society is more conductive to happiness. But social media very strongly underlines another reality. Not everyone can become a star, stardom is often very short lived, stars may not be the happiest people, fans might not be the nicest. Those smart enough to last a long time in public would probably be able to tell you a lot about necessary the sacrifices too. But the fear of missing something or being left out is probably exactly what drives anxiety, especially in those that might have a bit more self-awareness. Parents could support social media use, of course, but I would compare that to putting children up for a beauty contest.
- cauliflower99 4y agoA friend of mine has two girls in their teenage years. They have a ban on certain websites and have to get permission to add new social media apps to their phone. They regularly discuss these topics which is an important point I think. My friend reports that they laugh at their friends who are obsessed with their phones and do not have any of the anxiety problems that are rampant in their classrooms. As a father of a young girl, this gives me hope for her future. I think parents need to step up here. The excuse of "everyone else does it so I'm not going to introduce any discipline" is an irresponsible decision on the parent's behalf. I little more thought, effort and discipline could go a long way. Our job is to prepare our kids for the real world and maximise their opportunities (which anxiety and depression destroys). We are not here to be their friends.
- d1sxeyes 4y agoI have to agree with you that it's terrifying. I have a young son (under a year), and likely by the time I need to handle this myself, the challenges I will face will be very different. That said, there's some good news buried in the footnotes which gives me quite a lot of hope. "We found that controlling for [psychological variables such as negative attitudes about school and closeness with parents] heavily suppressed the relationship between social media use and poor mental health." Although it's almost a throwaway comment, my reading of it is that parents are not helpless. The effect is 'heavily suppressed', meaning that these variations have a significant impact. It is not a huge jump to conclude that there are steps that we as parents can do to mitigate the negative impact of social media, especially by being involved, engaged, emotionally available and supportive (and whatever else might be hiding behind this other 'psychological variables' mentionedsorr). It's also important to consider that we don't know why the mental health outcomes are so negative (as others have highlighted). However, there are some obvious likely causes of mental health issues caused by social media: - 'Andrew Tate'-like personalities, who intentionally use controversy and creating feelings of inadequacy to drive engagement - 'Dream body' type posters, who are not necessarily intentionally creating feelings of inadequacy, but nevertheless, they do by deliberately showing off parts of themselves or their lives that others cannot reasonably or easily attain (designer clothes/bags/shoes, expensive holidays, etc.) - 'The Joneses' type posters (which actually I think most people end up being themselves), whose posts are innocent in motivation, but create feelings of inadequacy by only showing one facet of their lives. For example, photos of the family laughing together, dogs playing in fields, beers in a pub garden in the sunshine. For me, my approach today would be: - Small groups of 2-5 people are fine. - For larger groups, create limited 'societies'. Class groups, church groups, scout groups, etc. Only allow my kids to be part of groups that they *really* belong to, and which are moderated to ensure that only people who really belong to those groups are able to join. - No 'reposts' or content which is not original. Only share photos which you've taken yourself (or which have been taken by someone within the group). Links to external services like YouTube, Spotify, etc. should be possible but limited to those where parental controls can be implemented. - Community moderators. Either parents or trusted community members should in place as moderators to manage harmful discussions. It seems as though there is an absolute minefield to navigate going forward, and I wish you (and myself!) the best of luck with it.
- DevKoala 4y agoI wasn’t aware that there is a media campaign to discredit this finding. Teen suicides exploded in growth YoY the moment smartphones became cheap enough around 2009.
- rco8786 4y agoRemember the pro-cigarette media campaigning of the 90s and 00s?
- SoftTalker 4y agoNo. Can you point to some history on this?
- hn_version_0023 4y agohttps://apnews.com/article/ce9e3e9c7595bae5034193112a75bb7e https://apnews.com/article/ce9e3e9c7595bae5034193112a75bb7e
- anoonmoose 4y agoThat's about a '97 settlement of a '91 lawsuit...don't see how it is relevant to a discussion of "90s and 00s" media.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoParent is drawing a parallel. We collectively agreed that the tobacco industry played a role in the consequences of tobacco addiction by marketing to minors. The parallel being drawn here is that social media platforms, being presented with the consequences of their products ie: teen mental health declines with use, are complicit in those consequences at some point in the value chain, either by marketing, product design, accessibility, etc. If the assumptions hold, then the conclusions are sound and valid. There's two ways to disagree with this. Either the assumptions are not valid, or the argument is not sound.
- 4y ago
- BulgarianIdiot 4y agoThe article promises evidence, but it starts by repeating the premise half a dozen times, then offering correlations and loose theories. If there was evidence in there, I missed it. Maybe there was. But even if there was this was a badly formatted article. Why can't people succinctly describe their thesis and then have a nice outline for the fine details on the proof? Is this not something we learn at uni, or even high school?
- politician 4y agoAsk ChatGPT to summarize the article for you?
- grunmble 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 4y agoI think he's trying to simplify it for a general audience, vs putting out an academic paper that might be discussed and nodded over, only to be misrepresented or over-simplified in health/science reporting and largely ignored. I don't fully agree with his argument and have said so before (briefly, I think it overlooks other major contextual factors like increasing international violence and political polarization that are less obvious but just as deadly). Nevertheless I think his argument is worth examining because mass networking is resulting in huge social changes but many of these seem to be making most of us less happy.
- xbar 4y agoI am completely convinced that international violence does not now, nor has it ever, caused much depression in US-based 12-year-old girls. Further, I find the notion that it is was an increasing trend from 2010 to 2022 compared with 2001 to 2010 is maximally revisionist. Same for political polarization (sidebar: the notion that political polarization is an "other...factor" outside of social media seems poorly considered.)
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoI wonder if online dating tends to lead to similar impacts to mental health for some groups of people as social media does to teen girls. Just like in Haidt's examples, it's impersonal, phone-based, leading to constant social comparison, feelings of rejection, ostracism and ghosting. I wouldn't be shocked if a few years from now research came out showing that it has similar effects to adults, but they're just better at withstanding it than teens. This is purely anecdotal with my group of friends, but we all can safely say that we feel mentally so much better when we're not on those apps, and yet the pull is always there when you want to expand your dating reach beyond your immediate circle and you hope that maybe this time around you'll get lucky and find the right partner. As a regular CBT practitioner I can detect many unhealthy conclusions that my mind makes any time I'm on these apps.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Ancalagon 4y agoTinder was definitely a contributor to my last bout of depression
- AussieWog93 4y agoAnecdotal, but dating apps sure helped crush the self-esteem of my sister. She still gets on them occasionally, because there's no alternative now. Guys in the post-#metoo era just won't approach a girl at a bar the way they used to.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoI don't think we need to go as far as to point fingers at MeToo for this. We have an entire generation of young adults who hit puberty after smartphones, social media and dating apps became standard. They might have never had to ask someone out in person, and going to a bar to meet someone would be the last place they think of. https://www.statista.com/chart/20822/way-of-meeting-partner-heterosexual-us-couples/ https://www.statista.com/chart/20822/way-of-meeting-partner-... To be fair I'm actually shocked by how high bars are on that chart, at least given my anecdotal experience.
- Aloha 4y agoI have a generalized view of social media - Humanity has not yet evolved adequate social and cultural defenses for the ability for every Tom, Dick and Harry sitting on their sofa to reach an audience of millions in real time. One the rumor mill went from days or weeks to real time, once the ability to present a.. diorama of life to a large online audience became commonplace - it in my opinion breaks a bunch of cultural and social factors in human life.
- Ergo19 4y agoYes, the rate of cultural adaptation is challenged by the rate of technological progress. I feel like we haven't even settled the basic question of smartphone etiquette.
- Aloha 4y agoI dont think we have, yeah - it took about 50 years to settle on just telephone etiquette - and thats not completely settled.
- largepeepee 4y ago"It also creates a trap—a collective action problem—for girls and for parents. Each girl might be worse off quitting Instagram even though all girls would be better off if everyone quit." I like this part, it is quite clear quitting social media alone is probably even worse and self-isolating than not taking part. The solution would be to address it on a societal level, but that requires pretty strong societal/political will to put such a policy in place. Such is the dilemma of the age, no doubt this is only one aspect, boys and even dating are affected on similar levels.
- IncRnd 4y agoNo. It's not "quite clear" that "quitting social media alone is probably even worse and self-isolating than not taking part." It's clear from my experience as a parent, and from the experience of many others, that that isn't an issue. The child may whine and throw a tantrum, but that's not a reason to let the child be the parent.
- aidenn0 4y agoI took my phone away from my daughter for a few weeks because she violated her technology contract. She literally did not meet up with friends a single time outside of school during that time because it was all arranged on iMessage. I don't regret what I did, but it definitely was isolating. Granted this is not my most socially pro-active kid (the most socially pro-active kid used a friend's phone to sign up for social media and meet up with strangers).
- Spivak 4y agoWas that your intent? You effectively grounded her. Actually worse because if she was grounded she could still talk to her friends. Trying to equate all "technology" and confiscate it like it's an extra nonessential thing like video games or toys is a mistake a lot of parents seem to be making in an environment where most social activity happens online and where everything is planned. It's fine I guess if that's what you wanted out of it but it's a pretty harsh punishment all things considered. I would have taken the grounding every time.
- wormloaf 4y ago[dead]
- blueicelake121 4y ago[flagged]
- alephnerd 4y agoI am a guy but I was in middle school when FB first became popular (around the time of the recession). I was definetly quite lucky that my dad worked in the tech industry as well and was a bit of a luddite around social media (locked down accounts and parental controls) while also maintaining a non-social media related friend group (swim team, tennis, debate, hiking, boxing). By the time I was old enough to learn how to bypass these (around 12-13) I feel I was a bit more mature and able to handle the kinds of pressures on social media. But then again, my parents were also pretty pro-active in my life, so maybe issues caused by social media are due to lack of parental involvement leading to parents using FB/YT/IG/TikTok as a substitute for parenting.
- murat124 4y agoYou gotta feed yourself the likes. And there's no end to it. Like, it never gets full. It's like you're sending SYNs with the tweets and such, and need to be ACK'ed. As if just putting it out there for the sake of sharing was not enough. Though during Internet's early years with tons of personal sites and blogs, watching visitor counter as the owner of the site was like seeing all the ACKs. We were getting our kicks from watching that number go up. Now, social media's likes replaced that simple number with all bunch of numbers, and it is incredibly addictive. Internet is definitely connecting us people together, for better or worse, but it also amplifies some of our destructive emotions and urges. Interesting times.
- farmaway 4y ago[flagged]
- uoaei 4y agoEven just the use of the word "transsexual" in your comment demonstrates how little you know about this subject. Where do you shop for your opinions?
- paulpauper 4y agoIt's not just girls and teens. Fitness influencer culture promoted unrealistic expectations, body dysmorphia, etc. It's all bad. However, at the same time, social media is not the same as 'influencer culture'.
- jsonne 4y agoAnecdotally I removed all social media from my phone recently and I only am using Twitter for work on desktop. My mood has improved dramatically and my focus is improving. Towards the end I found myself getting angry at posts that showed curated idyllic lives and realized that it's all really a facade. To that end the last post I saw on Tiktok before deleting it basically said that social media is so insidious because it is both the sickness and the cure. You feel bad and then you feel better ad nauseum and that rang very true for me.
- jvolkman 4y agoDoes that include Hacker News?
- jsonne 4y agoHN falls under work for me (in the sense that I learn things, I have a company that employs engineers so there's a networking element etc) but point taken. I guess I don't think about it as much because it's significantly less problematic than say Instagram and at least I learn things here. Notably I did cut out reddit which imho is the most toxic social network I was a part of.
- jvolkman 4y agoGot it. Wasn't trying to call you out; just curious. I've read the "removing social media has made me much happier" claim so many times but haven't been able to do it yet. But I think I'm close.
- oomemoryerror 4y agoAnecdotally, I think using social media requires a sense of emotional intelligence in order to not be adversely affected. You have to be cognizant that the highlights of other people’s lives aren’t comparable to your own life. Otherwise, you go down the spiral of thinking that your life is so much worse than others’.
- floren 4y ago> social media is so insidious because it is both the sickness and the cure. You feel bad and then you feel better ad nauseum Go to an AA or NA meeting and you can hear the same stories.
- BryantD 4y agoThis is an important piece and I’m glad Haidt put it together. I do wonder if there’s room in this analysis for specific social media analysis. It seems like it would be very hard to separate out effects of Facebook vs. effects of Twitter and so on, but at the same time I worry about throwing the baby out with the bath water. A technology-intermediated social life is not inherently bad. Pen and paper letters are technology. Dumb phones are technology. We have been adapting culturally to new ways to communicate with each other for a long time; I want more about what’s driving this trend now, and I think it might be more than just feedback and cycle speed. Or maybe it is simply the democratization of platforms; it’s bad when speech is filtered through a few trusted authorities but that doesn’t mean the opposite doesn’t have risks. (Yay, it’s the free speech debate!)
- return_to_monke 4y agomy only nitpick is - if social media were truly a drug, as some suggest, studies asking participants to reduce time on it wouldn't work because of addiction. how do we counter this?
- staticman2 4y agoNot all drugs are addictive and some are more addictive than others.
- it_citizen 4y agoGambling, cigarette, alcohol, weed, cocaine or social media can all potentially get you addicted. It doesn't mean that on a random sample, most people cannot reduce their consumption. It depends of how hooked you are.
- wufufufu 4y agoI'd like legislation that acknowledges both the utility and harm that social media and more generally smartphones have. All I want is an internet-based texting only mobile-phone that doesn't have a browser or anything besides utilities. I don't want any feeds, reels, TikToks, etc. The fact that you basically need a smartphone to socialize, make payments, park, read menus, but it comes with a hamster-wheel for dopamine dispensing is like if the only way you could hydrate yourself is fountain soda -- you're just playing a game where you try not to get diabetes.
- AussieWog93 4y agoDon't forget that HN is also a form of social media. It will make you angry and emotionally exhausted. :)
- theGnuMe 4y ago"No it isn't and no it won't" :) lol.
- snovymgodym 4y agoIt's true, but the lack of curated feeds, semi-anonymous profiles, and the relatively strict moderation of topics and discussion style certainly make it seem less addicting and harmful than the others.
- mrpopo 4y agoI don't necessarily disagree with the conclusion, but the dismissal of other factors is insufficient: > Why did a measure of loneliness at school go up around the world only after 2012, as the global economy got better and better? The economy didn't get better for everyone, in fact inequality rose starkly; this might be a correlating factor. > It’s not because of the 9/11 attacks, wars in the middle east, or school shootings. As Emile Durkheim showed long ago, people in Western societies don’t kill themselves because of wars or collective threats OK, so let's dismiss societal violence because a 120-y.o. study says so. How about climate anxiety/eco-anxiety? Car-dependant suburban life? Ever-growing parental control? All these factors have been too easily dismissed.
- fullstop 4y ago> The economy didn't get better for everyone, in fact inequality rose starkly; this might be a correlating factor. One thing that I thought about this is that while unemployment might have been low, both parents were more likely to be working.
- culebron21 4y agoYou're arguing with the discussion section in the bottom. But in the middle, there's analysis on researches that made a clear experiment. Researchers asked students to restrict the usage for several weeks, and they showed some effect, while the papers where restriction lasted only one week, showed no change. This is rather clear evidence of causation.
- eastbound 4y ago> people in Western societies don’t kill themselves because of wars or collective threats The dozens of French white teens who joined the war in Syria in 2015. The thousands of English teens who freely enrolled against Franco, the dictator who took over Spain in 1936, while they absolutely didn’t have to, as it was not part of the conscription? And if, once there, they deserted, they were legible for the death penalty. While underage. Indeed, many examples of teens engaging into collective theoretical threats.
- 4y ago
- culebron21 4y agoThis made me think better of lurking at LinkedIn. The more I open it, the worse I feel about own achievements and skills. It keeps kindly reminding you that company X still hires but didn't reply to you; that friend Y got to that position that looks like what you dreamed of; or fellow Z got all those certificiations you have no time for.
- PaulHoule 4y agoMy son at age 20 refuses to own a smart phone or participate in social media for these reasons.
- ThalesX 4y agoMy little sister just started high school and in less than a semester is unrecognizable. There is no more her in her day to day life, everything is curated to perfection. There are no more hobbies, no more interestes, no more curiosities, there is just "me". I was so confident in her ability to withstand the impact of social media, due to her education, but ultimately I was just shocked at how fast the change was. I now no longer believe the human brain is capable of withstanding its effects. I guess it's a brave new world.
- ceedan 4y agoDamn that hurt to read. That's such a shame
- RangerScience 4y agoYou might check out a book called “Reviving Ophelia”.
- alar44 4y ago[dead]
- AlexandrB 4y agoI think it's important to remember that high school is a critical time where a lot of people shift focus to their friend groups and their own reputation therein. Social Media changes the terrain, but the game is not that different. I remember back to my own high school experience and how my range of activities narrowed dramatically and there was a lot more focus on who's dating whom and what the cool kids are up to. All of this is to say that most people outgrow this stage eventually. High school doesn't last forever.
- ThalesX 4y agoI also remember my high school times, it was at the bridge between the analog and the digital and it's a completely different playing field. I understand where you are coming from, but I am very close to my sister and what they are experiencing does not compare to what traditional high school coming of age scenarios had. You mention who is dating whom and what the cool kids are up to. Imagine what the global reach and competition do to this particular interest.
- colinrand 4y agoYMMV, but the thing that seems to work in my house (mid teen girl) is to actively be engaged with her social life and have the meta (not Meta) conversation about social media impact with her regularly. She will have to learn to deal with her reality and live with it on her own, but helping her have a set of tools to describe and analyze it is beneficial. Tools like being aware of how much time she spends on it, how other people are affected by it, how apps affect your behavior, etc. But it all starts with engaging as a parent with her on her level, not forcing her to be an adult with a fully formed executive function capacity.
- danbolt 4y agoI think this hits the nail on the head. Or, it sounds like you’re engaged to help give your child the self-advocacy they need to be responsible for their own life.
- swader999 4y agoI like your reply a lot. We turn the wifi off at bedtime too. Sleep needs to be sacred.
- stuckinhell 4y agoI have a daughter, I mostly agree. I like to remind people teenagers are not "little" adults, they lack full developed brains, and extremely susceptible to peer pressure. I restrict my kids social media very tightly, and make sure they have lots of real world activities and real world influences.
- Zetice 4y ago[flagged]
- stuckinhell 4y agoI'll do whatever it takes for my kids, and I can accept the consequences. I can assure you I've thought about it.
- moremetadata 4y agoSocial media is a psychological weapon that leaves no physical evidence which is why the state is making a big play on mental health. Its a control mechanism on the population because the state deliberately doesn't teach law and parents cant be relied upon, so social media can also be a way to psychological and biologically profile people before choosing to radicalise individuals, set them up for blackmail, or have them carryout a variety of Darwinism tasks, to help population levels or boost GDP through health care. Social Media is to the ego, as the Olympics is to the body, but parents are not sports coaches, managing the physical and mental aspects of failure. So do parents take the China route and limit gaming time to 3 hours a week Fri, Sat, Sun and limit access to the FAANG companies? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_China#:~:text=Internet%20censorship%20and%20surveillance%20has,VPN%20service%20providers%20as%20well https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_China#:.... Now enjoy your fortnite hot pics on youtube, some of you might find it xxx rated in all but name! https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=fortnite+hot+pics https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=fortnite+hot+pi...
- oomemoryerror 4y agoHave you ever read “The Chaos Machine” by Max Fisher?
- moremetadata 4y agoNo, but a precis on it suggests its the algorithms at fault, much like this Ted talk I have seen. https://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bubbles?language=ru https://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_b...
- rglover 4y ago> Social media is a psychological weapon that leaves no physical evidence which is why the state is making a big play on mental health. Bingo. The entire thing is a psyop designed to artificially limit and homogenize groups to make them more predictable and easier to control.
- 4y ago
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoI'm not convinced how any of this shows causation. Probably the strongest point in this substack pointing to causation is the use of longitudinal studies. Haidt is using a meta-analysis of long-term specific (as opposed to short term studies which display no effect, there's merit here as a longer longitudinal study is probably better) longitudinal studies to make this point, so essentially saying that a meta-analysis of long-term longitudinal studies is required to show that causation can be established; this is all indirect. I still think that to prove this point we need to make an experiment that actually attempts to show causation. I'm also not sure if it's worth discussing this on HN because this topic tends to attract commenters of one opinion, but I also think it's worth making opposition known. I fully expect this opinion to be unpopular. EDIT: Indeed, doing a shallow dive into the referenced longitudinal study links shows that none of them establish any form of control. One of the studies linked's abstract (I don't have access to the full paper) has an intervention model but doesn't split the initial cohort in order to establish the causal effect. N.B. I am aware that in social science it's hard to find large enough cohort sizes to establish effects and that splitting a cohort to establish causality could destroy the statistical power of the study altogether.
- cubefox 4y agoDo you have an alternate hypothesis which could explain the results of all the studies the cites?
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoOf course, I have a few. The case for correlation is clear, and numerous studies of varying statistical power have proved it. The question is causation. So if social media usage isn't causal, then what is? I think most people who are skeptical of causation would point to a hidden latent variable that is actually causal. One way this could take place is some feature, say "susceptibility to fomo", that's actually causal. Folks who have a higher susceptibility might see frequent, sharp decreases in mental health outcomes from social media usage. Folks with low susceptibility might be relatively unaffected from social media usage. It could be interesting to see what the prevalence of this susceptibility is in the general population, whether there are certain cohorts that have high prevalence, and whether there are interventions that can be performed to decrease this prevalence. A similar analogous cause is the presence of schizophrenia in an analysis of psychedelic use. Most folks are fine using psychedelics infrequently. However, folks with a predilection for schizophrenia frequently have bad outcomes from psychedelic use and may even accelerate the onset of latent schizophrenia. The above "fomo susceptibility" might even be too simplistic a model. There might be a cluster of features, combinations of past experiences and perhaps biological traits, that actually act as "fomo susceptibility." I loosely think the real model works something like this. Age may be a controlling factor as well. Regardless, I'm not convinced there's causation here. Social media usage research is like a lot of other poorly understood psychological and mental health phenomenon where studies are underpowered, causality is hard to establish, and effect sizes are small which all lead to conflicting conclusions.
- Barrin92 4y agoThe reality of it is that social media, and our use of technology in general, isn't actually governed by any value system. Be it truth, human flourishing, welfare, health, what have you. We're completely on autopilot and are conditioned to accept all of it as inevitable. If we had an actual telos to our use of technology work like this by Haidt would be in the evening news and it'd inform decisions at every level. From parents keeping their kids away from harmful social media, to communities and institutions refusing to use these platforms for anything, to governments regulating the worst aspects of it. We're terminally screwed if the trend of letting technology (and profit maximizing firms) control design of social media rather than the other way around.
- cm2012 4y agoI am really doubtful. Everyone forgets that suicide and mental health issues are up the most for boomers, and they use social media the least as a cohort (yes, they use it less, even with FB boomer memes). I'm at -3 right now but look at the data yourself: https://afsp.org/suicide-statistics/ https://afsp.org/suicide-statistics/, scroll down to suicide rates by age range. And yes I think suicide deaths is the best measure of mental illness since it has the most life impact and is the least prone to measurement/diagnosis error and changes,
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoIt's up for all age groups since 2010. So it's not super convincing that social media is directly at fault. There seem to be some cyclical trends, and 1990-2010 was kind of a low period compared to the period before or after.
- ceedan 4y agoI'd been hoping that there would be a counter-culture generation at some point that says no to social media - but it seems like they're just saying no to one social network in favor of another
- dustedcodes 4y agoI keep saying it every time and there are no good faith arguments to not do it, what we need is: - Make social media illegal to underage kids, just like tobacco or alcohol - Enforcement through ID verification of every user (would solve the bot problem as well) - Jail terms for executives of social media companies who fail to enforce these rules and protect children from harmful content
- sidfthec 4y agoOf course there are good faith arguments, you probably just don't agree with them. The most convincing argument is that I don't want social media companies to have access to my ID. Remember, even websites like HN and Pornhub would need to verify your age with your ID.
- AlexandrB 4y agoHaving nearly every site require government ID for access would be a pretty grim end to the arc of de-anonymization that started with Facebook's "real name" requirement. Do we truly value social media as a product and an industry more than our privacy/anonymity?
- dustedcodes 4y ago> I don't want social media companies to have access to my ID You don't want them to know your real name and age? Then don't use them. Social media is harmful and so it needs more regulation and safety. You can't enter a casino right now without an ID. You either accept that the casino will know your name and age when you enter it or you don't go to the casino. It's so funny when tech folks think their little shitty thing is something special that should not have to follow any logical common sense laws like everything else in the world. Besides, the whole point of social media is to connect with friends, family and other real people. Being anonymous is anti social. People who are scared of disclosing their real name are the ones who shouldn’t be on social media anyway. If we all had real identities on social media it would be so much less toxic than it is today.
- 4y ago
- theshrike79 4y agoSchools should have Instagram Reality -classes pretty soon. Young kids really do compare themselves to the highlights of other people's lives. They don't really take in the fact that the fitspo model in the picture is sucking in their stomach, flexing like crazy and posing in a very specific way to get the photo. And in many cases looking good is literally their job, they can spend 16 hours a day to look a specific way and have sponsors and money to do it. Nor do they notice how that one influencer they are following just had one vacation to $fancy_location, but took thousands of photos in different clothes and keeps posting them all year round to give the impression of constant travel and luxury. (Social) Media literacy is more important now than it ever was in the past.
- sverona 4y agoHere's a question I don't know the answer to. How does an already depressed and dysphoric trans person --- who doesn't know they're trans --- with unsupportive parents ever, ever find out what the cause of their depression is without a robust network of connection to people from elsewhere? Let's assume they live in a deeply rural area in which variant sexualities and genders are frowned upon. They are the only person who feels this way that they've ever met. Their parents restrict the media they watch for whatever reason and they assume they're broken. This is not a hypothetical. Coming out saved my life. I don't use social media because I have better ways to spend my time, but I'm wary of taking away the one light in a tunnel that this only-nominally-hypothetical person might have.
- Animats 4y agoMost of them grow out of it.[1][2] [1] https://www.kqed.org/futureofyou/441784/the-controversial-research-on-desistance-in-transgender-youth https://www.kqed.org/futureofyou/441784/the-controversial-re... [2] https://statsforgender.org/desistance/ https://statsforgender.org/desistance/
- sverona 4y agoWhen you look into why they "grow out of it," it's usually because the world is so inhospitable to them that they cannot bear it. [0] The proportion that detrans because they realized they were wrong is estimated at 2.4%. [0] Also, previous studies that look into detransition have been methodologically wanting. [1] [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8213007/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8213007/ [1] https://psycnet.apa.org/fulltext/2021-80256-001.pdf https://psycnet.apa.org/fulltext/2021-80256-001.pdf
- kevwil 4y agoWow.
- gen220 4y agoIs the inevitable conclusion of this vein of research some public health program akin to the one that shackled big tobacco? The link between (early) smoking and cancer seems like it was about as difficult to measure as the link between (early) social media use and mental illness, but we have better tools for collecting and analyzing data in 2023. There's many gradations between what we have today ("Hey! How old are you? Under 13? Try again later") and requiring new accounts to be linked to a government ID attesting a certain age, but it does feel like the norm today might hem too close to reckless abandonment.
- golemiprague 4y ago[dead]
- ragetronic 4y ago[flagged]
- lsy 4y agoI think it's somewhat important to ask why this effect is more observable for girls than for boys, and Haidt does not seem to really reflect on that. Social media in and of itself is really just an accelerant for the particular set of social expectations we stack on girls and women around appearance and how that relates to self-worth. Boys have more capacity to transcend social media's focus on image and beauty by finding other ways to be valued as human beings. What does it say about our society that we are not equipping girls and women in the same way? I'm a little confused about Haidt's pearl-clutching in this instance, when he has elsewhere argued against "coddling" and bugaboos like "intersectionality" and "identity politics". While there is certainly much to criticize in these areas, you would think one solution to this issue would be to advance a society in which women are valued equally to men. Reading between the lines of his body of work, it appears Haidt wants to return to a type of mid-century traditionalism, where children and young people are both protected and challenged by traditional adult authority figures (who are conveniently mostly people like him and his collaborators). I'm not so sure that's the direction we should be going in, but heavy-handedly cutting off the exploration at "social media as cause" certainly precludes any further analysis of an underlying dynamic.
- eastbound 4y ago> Boys have more capacity to transcend social media's focus on image and beauty by finding other ways to be valued as human beings. Before absconding boys from harm, maybe we should check twice on their health. They are often forgotten or their difficulties brushed off in studies. How are addictions progressing? Obesity maybe? Why are they all on 9Gag? Let’s check their level of racism and misogyny, it might be a proxy for self-esteem. Have right-wing groups gotten more expressive recently? Are we taking proper care of the boys? Can we ensure, if we measure something where girls are particularly exposed, that we also measure an area where boys are particularly exposed, before assuming boys are exempt from harm.
- Zetice 4y agoBoys are for sure not exempt from harm, but the harm seems to be as a result of equity: https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/3868557-most-young-men-are-single-most-young-women-are-not/amp/ https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/3868557-most-yo... > “Today in America, women expect more from men,” Levant said, “and unfortunately, so many men don’t have more to give.” Powerful stuff.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoIn the future we will look back on unrestricted access to social media for children the way we look back at smoking ads targeting children today.
- mattgreenrocks 4y agoOf course it is! Existing in a constant evaluative state of mind is absolutely toxic to mental health. Think about it: would you enjoy your spouse grading you on every little thing you said? If they did, it would quickly discourage you from saying much at all. Most anyone who has quit social media can attest to the near-immediate benefit they get to their subjective well-being. And it persists even in spite of realizing they are missing out on some of the things social media does well. I REALLY hope we can eventually look back at this time and laugh at the incredibly high rate of addiction to what are worthless Internet Points. Everyone laughed at WoW junkies for staying up late to get epic loot, then turned around and did exactly that themselves, or worse! Social media persists because it fills a void in our increasingly atomized lives. And some people thrive on what is essentially a real-time status market. The real fix is we stop normalizing having lives so small they can be so easily filled with such worthless garbage like social media. Edit: really appreciate how Jon calls out how every damn journalist treats social media with such kiddie gloves because they are too scared to speak what is plainly evident: social media is toxic.
- andix 4y agoAre there some parents here, who were able to convince their girls not to use social media? Was it a success? I think it’s very well documented, that social media can be really bad for kids. It seems to be much worse than drinking, smoking or bad relationships.
- watwut 4y agoI don't think social isolation of girls is reasonable knee jerk reaction to their issues.
- andix 4y agoI don’t know if that is even true. Maybe it’s the better call to give the kids a pack of cigarettes and send them to the kids who smoke secretly behind the gym, who just laugh about the instagram princesses. Or are those kids also a thing of the past?
- watwut 4y agoYou know, social aspect of smoking was fairly usual reason to start smoking. Because, people are social animals. And like it or not, there was period when smoking meant making networking connections non-smokers did not had access to. The proposed solution has nothing in it for girls. It does not make their lives better. It is not helping them in any way, except proposing new gender based restrictions on them. Yes, you can go on buy your son new gaming console to play with friends while telling girls they are not allowed to use technology to talk to people. In a world where no social media means no way to organize in person encounters too. That is what the proposal amounts to.
- LesZedCB 4y agosome of the comments from parents in this thread scare the shit out of me. apparently discipline society and father morality still reign supreme even in the postmodern era as long as you're a child :/
- stuckinhell 4y agoI agree. Between this article on young women being failed and young men being failed in this following article. https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/3868557-most-young-men-are-single-most-young-women-are-not/ https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/3868557-most-yo... I think its clear society is on the verge of failure. We've allowed radicals and a small minority to take control of culture, and break it for the vast of amount of normal people. We need to return to the first principles we know most societies are based on.
- kornhole 4y agoI assume the author is referring to the corporate social media full of advertising that makes people feel inferior so they buy what their selling to fill the hole in their sole that they created. There are very different kinds of social media that do not have advertising and dark patterns that do this to people of all ages. How can we encourage children to use these other than setting up firewalls that block them from the former?
- chmod775 4y ago> Boys are doing badly too, but their rates of depression and anxiety are not as high, and their increases since 2011 are smaller. Bullshit. These numbers are self reported and show exactly the opposite of reality. Boys aged 15-24 are about four times[0] more likely than girls to die by their own hands, so clearly relying on self reported cases of mental illness is not very helpful and is likely to shift focus away from those groups who most need help. Everyone who asks for help should receive it, but don't forget to keep an eye on those who stay silent. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/187496/death-rate-from-suicide-in-the-us-bygender-and-age/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/187496/death-rate-from-s...
- stuckinhell 4y ago[flagged]
- Zetice 4y ago[flagged]
- afavour 4y ago> The world is so dysfunctional with radicals trying to drag your children into their agendas This was always the case but it was incredibly difficult for those people to reach your kids. Arguably an equivalent of this is dragging children into "capitalistic" agendas via advertising on kids TV, that's certainly not new. Maybe an unpopular view but I think a lot of the blame lies with the tech giant. It's well documented that YouTube pushes you towards more and more "engaging" (and not so coincidentally extreme) content over time. Same with TikTok and all the others. In the ideal world we'd be removing "engagement" as a goal anywhere but good luck sealing that Pandora's box back up again.
- yotamoron 4y ago8 years ago, after realising how bad doom scrolling facebook made me feel, I deleted (not deactivated - deleted) the fb account. The mental relief was immediate. Facebook (and social media in general - including linkedin) is pure evil.
- smm11 4y agoThe sky is blue.
- ddmma 4y agoMaybe the algorithm that controls the newsfeeds are the cause. Social graph networks that were created by connecting billions of people was necessary human evolution but corporate management or dystopian government want to control the social parameters. So there u have it!
- bertil 4y agoI’m surprised to see so little distinction between what causes this, to help with addressing the issues separately and proactively: the need to curate your personality (which university applications seem to have cornered for a while), body image (which fashion magazines have been leveraging for a while), or pseudo-social relations that break validation circles (which seems new, at least the apparent intimacy of it, unless you count some personality on TV and radio). I think there are approaches to handle each aspect, many of which are never recommended in debate about this, seemingly because people want single, absolute solution: * I have no idea if anyone I follow on Twitter, or here too, has perfect teeth, a thigh gap, or whatever is the latest unrealistic goal; teenagers could be asked to use text-only media or one without humans presented as attractive: Reddit has a rule about selfie for instance. * social media companies can choose to let you see more friends over people with large audiences; I remember that was a big debate at Instagram when I worked there (and a couple of brilliant people left because the decision went for a stickier audience, slowly slipping towards pros over friends). There’s definitely an appetite to revert that decision.
- andix 4y agoIs HN also social media? My girlfriend always tell me to stop behaving like a teenage girl. Am I at great risk here?
- magwa101 4y ago[dead]
- tristor 4y agoUnfortunately, you can't just ban social media for teen girls. That has negative mental health impacts as well, including on your own mental health as you try to enforce said ban. Social media is integral to the lifestyle of teenagers now, and not having it socially isolates you. It makes you a "weirdo" in the same way that being homeschooled or being in a religious cult would 30 years ago, in fact if you try to do such a ban, other parents assume you're a conspiracy theorist, in a religious cult, or some other sort of "weirdo" yourself. Whether we like it or not, unfortunately social media is now an integral part of how people are expected to behave in modern society. So we have to figure out how to address the consequences of it on an individual basis in our home without resorting to flat bans. This is addressed to some extent in the article as well.
- hax0ron3 4y agoWhy "unfortunately"? I am quite happy that teenagers' access to information is not being banned.
- tristor 4y agoBecause I have a teenage stepdaughter, and I would like to make her life easier, not harder, and social media seems to be a net negative. It's unfortunately so integrated into the lives of teenagers they can't get away from it. I learned the hard way that social media was also bad for me, and I no longer use it (if you don't count HN and web-forums as social media). I also don't like restricting access to information in the general sense, but social media isn't "information" in anything but the broadest sense of terms.
- hax0ron3 4y agoSocial media absolutely is information. For example, I can tell you from experience that it is very hard to really learn about another country if you are not living there unless you go read what the people of that country are saying on social media. What journalists write about the country is usually a very narrow view in comparison to all the information that becomes available to you if you read what people who live there are writing on social media. Do you think that maybe you could make your stepdaughter's life easier not by restricting her access to information, but by teaching her how to interact with that information in a way that is healthy?
- oblib 4y agoI have been telling friends and family that they need to focus on things close to home and not worry or get all red in the face about stuff they see on the internet and "News". That they need to compartmentalize that stuff and keep in context. I learned this lesson back around the early 80s. When I got off work I'd stop and grab some food and then go home and watch the "News". The station I watched started off with local Los Angeles and State news for a 1/2 hour, then a 1/2 hour of National News, then another of World News. The station was a predecessor to "FOX News" and was purchased by FOX just a few years later. They focused almost entirely on negative news, car crashes, murders, rapes, robberies, etc. So by the end of 1.5 hours I had consumed most all the major tragedies for the entire planet, and I was depressed AF. I finally realized that it was consuming all that "bad news" was the cause of that because days when I didn't consume it I felt fine. That was just 1.5 hours a day, 5 days a week, of my routine back then. Nowadays I would offer you need to put your phone down and spend more time doing something you can learn from and enjoy, like friends and family, like people did before the internets.
- maerF0x0 4y agoSocial Contagion[1] is more prevalent in females. So is an affinity for people/relationships over objects. I suspect it's nearly as toxic for males if they were to consume on equal doses, but social media is naturally more tuned for relationship (and subjective) focus than object (and objective) focus. Would be great if we could start doing properly controlled trials with folks who _never_ use these things we're widespread experimenting across the population. A few examples that might make sense: social media, pornography usage, and perhaps any fast tracked vaccines. Might make sense to have even just a few randomized folks be controls for research purposes. As of now you likely cannot find even a single person over ~15 who hasnt used social media/porn ever in their lifetime. [1]:https://dictionary.apa.org/social-contagion https://dictionary.apa.org/social-contagion
- xchip 4y agoAny idea what the reasons are why teen girls are more affected by social media?
- golemiprague 4y ago[dead]
- notjulianjaynes 4y agoI think it's worth considering that we've already had a generation or two that have grown up with social media being pretty much ubiquitous. I'm in my early 30s (male) and was on myspace by age 14. Has social media contributed negatively to my mental health over the years? Probably. It's not something I think anyone views without a modicum of anxiety, but I have no frame of reference to compare the alternative to. I wonder though, assuming this isn't new just because it's not something that was previously not measured: If there's been a more recent and drastic decline in mental health due to it in young girls due to social media, is it the general concept that's the problem, or the current implementation?
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoIt's a bit weird that we only focus on it with the age of smart phones. Why wasn't MySpace/Facebook equally problematic? I acknowledge it's easier to spend many hours on your phone, but on the other hand I know people spent many hours on their computers on these sites even before smartphones.
- nvarsj 4y agoI kind of feel like social media is this generation's moral panic and we need to be careful how we react as parents. Setting overly strict rules is out of touch and old fashioned and the worst possible approach here. That's like what my parents' generation did - banning video games and DnD and rock music (I had my NiN CDs and DnD books confiscated from me and thrown in the trash in order to "save me"). It's a great way to break all trust with your kids and is lazy parenting. We need to be realistic - denying a teenage girl a phone and/or social media is akin to making them a social pariah. They will ignore your ridiculous rules and figure out ways to do things without you ever knowing. I feel the best approach is to aim for a strong relationship with your teenage child. Communication and trust are paramount. As a parent, you want to be in the loop on what's going on in their lives - so you can provide support and guidance, and be emotional support as they navigate this part of their lives. If your child is coming to you with their problems, then you have succeeded. This isn't new, it's just become more important. The influence of social media in a vacuum is very strong.
- realjhol 4y agoMental illness including gender dysphoria
- taurath 4y agoComparison kills. Humans are not supposed to be competing with other humans for attractiveness across the entire planet. Putting numbers on things has warped the value that we give to people. Will also note that the views of the author and their partners are pretty damn conservative having released a book entitled "The Coddling of the American Mind". The jist of the book is that american kids are too soft and too prone to victimhood, rather than having legitimate grievances about the capitalistic/individualistic social and emotional systems that exist. To me this completely ignores almost all of the positive advancements the younger generations have done especially in terms of stopping generational cycles of emotional, physical and sexual abuse - the current generation is the least abused generation in the history of the US. Its with that lens that I view the opinion piece and still agree on some level that social media is harmful.
- keyme 4y agoI think we're around the point in time where it would be reasonable to establish a kind of "nature preserve" for people who collectively want to reject most of the post 2005 (or so) technology. I want my car to have no ECU with an always on LTE backdoor I want my streets to be free of facial recognition CCTV cameras I want it to be normal to use physical cash for payments again Mostly I only want tech that people use as a tool, rather than tech that uses people... IIRC this "nature preserve" concept appeared in Brave New World.
- GuB-42 4y agoSo, like the Amish, but less extreme.
- arijun 4y agoAs controversial as China’s “draconian” governmental bans on these things are, I really think that is the right direction. Unilaterally restricting your child from social media would just serve to isolate them. It’s like a reverse tragedy of the commons—-we’re at the stadium and everyone is already standing. Trying to reason everyone into sitting down won’t work, we need someone to come in and yell at everyone until they sit.
- lebuffon 4y agoMaybe we should bring back cigarettes. The are less lethal to young people... How depressing.
- fleddr 4y agoI consider digitization in general to be destroying mental health. Social media, delivery services, dating using an app, virtual working, the list goes on. They create a touchless society where we no longer connect with real people and barely interact with the physical world. The price of this convenience is very high. Surely this can't be good for us. The difference between girls and boys are interesting. From my casual experience, I have a lot of friends with teenage boys, a distinct pattern can be seen. Almost all of them are gamers. That's their main digital channel. Many don't give a shit about social media and some don't even have any account at all. Nothing public anyway, just some basic chat account. As they game, they can at times be toxic and competitive, but that's "part of the game", they don't take it very serious at all. Likewise, none of them seem to care much about stacking each other by looks, the typical male trait of physical strength, or wealth. Surely, some of this is always present in the background, but it's all in a lax "it is what it is" vibe. Their main issue/challenge seems to be gaming addiction and how this comes at the expense of other aspects of their lives (sleep, school performance, physical exercise, socializing with girls). Also noteworthy: not politicized. Most don't seem to have much of an opinion on anything. Pure indifference. The teenage girls are so radically different. They don't game, they're literally self-imaging non-stop. Constantly recording themselves, watching influencer videos, gossiping on chat, stacking and ranking each other. Unlike a gaming addiction (which is fixable), their success or failure is existential. I would imagine that both tendencies between both and girls have always been there, it's just that they were naturally constrained by the physical world. Social media made it limitless.
- m3kw9 4y agoRoot of the problem is envy. Instagram, tiktok is made to show off and attracts the most eyes. Envy is like a disease
- justnotworthit 4y ago"If all your friends jumped off a cliff, would you?" Is now: "If all your child's friends jumped off a cliff, would you push them too?"
- mihaic 4y agoWhat I find so puzzling is how little talk there is about regulating social media, just like we do for instance with smoking and alcohol. With enough coordination we can push some collective control over most social trends, but now every parent is fighting their own David vs Goliath. I'm amazed the US is the same country that passed prohibition.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoPerhaps because Prohibition was an abject failure?
- Invictus0 4y agoMy girlfriend read this for about 60 seconds, gave up and went to browse Instagram.
- westurner 4y agoPerhaps Facebook should again require an email address at an approving college or university for sign up. But what about supporting the NCMEC National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, without biometrics due to new laws? Can you teach your daughters to be considerate of others on the internet? They used to tell us not to put any personal information online as kids; no real names, etc. Perhaps social media is a mirror from which we can determine parenting approach? Are violent video games less bad than social media for which unhealthily-competitive strata? "Please do not bully people on the internet because:" "Please be considerate and helpful on the internet because:"
- westurner 4y agoStopBullying.gov: https://www.stopbullying.gov/ https://www.stopbullying.gov/ "How to Make a Family Media Use Plan" (HealthyChildten.org (AAP)) https://www.healthychildren.org/English/family-life/Media/Pages/How-to-Make-a-Family-Media-Use-Plan.aspx https://www.healthychildren.org/English/family-life/Media/Pa... Internet safety: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_safety
- westurner 4y ago[after school] emotional restraint collapse: https://www.google.com/search?q=emotional+restraint+collapse https://www.google.com/search?q=emotional+restraint+collapse : ; It's exhausting for many of us to withhold nonverbal emotions all day; and so after school a minute to just chill without typical questioning may or may not help prevent bullying on the internet TIL Iceland provides vouchers for whatever after school activities: taxes pay for sports and other programs.
- darawk 4y agoIt's worth reading the response to Haidt and his coauthors re-analysis: https://sci-hub.se/https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-020-0840-y https://sci-hub.se/https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-02... I haven't read all of Haidt's position yet, or the original paper, but this response is fairly convincing.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoIsn't Haidt's claim that the problem is lumping all digital media use together? I don't see how this response addresses that
- ShredKazoo 4y ago>Each girl might be worse off quitting Instagram even though all girls would be better off if everyone quit. What's the solution then? Maybe we need some sort of "device-free summer camp" where teens just have fun with other teens in nature, without any devices to distract them? I'll bet this could be a profitable business at least...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mindvirus 4y agoSocial media is going to be looked back on as the smoking of our age.
- toss1 4y agoIf someone proves this in court, it'll be the end of Fbook and others; they'll get sued into oblivion. And Rightly So. Their entire business model is to poison the well of society to improve their quarterly profits; strip-mining goodwill and trust, leaving anger and ashes. A long damn way from 'just trying to connect people'.
- cbtacy 4y agoOne boarding school has gone as far as to ban smartphones for students AND teachers due to this issue. ABC story: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PSUrE4-zYzg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PSUrE4-zYzg
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoOne thing to note is that rates of depression/suicide were much higher in the 1980s. If you look at the data over a longer time period, the 1990-2010 period stands out as being unusually low, and more recently we see an increase back to the 1970-1990 levels. Now I'm not saying that social media isn't a cause of this, but any theory should have some reasonable explanation for why rates were just as high in the 1980s as today.
- acyou 4y agoWe reject the idea that events have causes. We even more reject the idea that there exist correlates distinct from causes. "Orthogonal" systems simply have their boundaries misdrawn. There are no orthogonal systems. We are all connected.
- raffraffraff 4y agoI gave my nephews "air-gapped" laptops (old ThinkPad t430s). Technically they're connected to the internet, but the hosts file blocks so much that even if they could figure out how to get past the locked down KDE desktop, find a terminal, install a browser and open it, they still wouldn't be able to access anything. I downloaded block lists for ads and porn, and manually added social media sites. However... They can still join my xonotic server and play against each other. They have a bunch of games that work on LAN (one creates a server, the others join). This includes Minetest, which they find indistinguishable from Minecraft. So they've completely stopped pestering their parents to buy them consoles and phones that are "forcibly online". I suppose they're lucky that there's three of them to play together. Lone kids couldn't do this with their friends without multiple families getting together and sorting it out. I'm going to follow this up with cheap phones that I can lock down. I'll add a bunch of hand-picked games and maybe set up a slack account and get their friends to join. Then disable the play store. Again, this will shut them up for a while and let them have access to technology without the brain-rot. And their parents will be in slack, so they'll be able to keep tabs on them. (I don't have kids, so I have the spare time and the inclination to do this, unlike their dad)
- Mentlo 4y agoDisclaimer: I work in social media, and am convinced it has negative effects on mental health, which is why I limit usage. This review is a lot less than a smoking gun though. The author goes into large detail on the quantification of associations and correlations in the first section (association review) - and limits towards communicating only qualitatively that there was an effect when getting into the longitudinal and experimental reviews (the causation-proving ones). Reading through the actual google review doc, this is present in the review as well. Very little quantification, and when quantification is given it's the wrong type of quantification. Even in an experimental study, showing mean comparisons rather than distribution comparisons is misleading, even when statistically significant. This is a bit of a problem, as it doesn't go into the effect size of the causation. The author is quite cleary rooting for causation to be there. This is not uncommon in science (a strong conviction into an unproven hypothesis) - but when this happens, we have to be extra vigilant in looking at the results. EDIT: Also, for sth to be a major cause we would need to demonstrate that the effect of social media is in the top quantiles of all known effects. The most we can get out of this review (and I'd even challenge that) is that there is enough proof that social media is a causally proven contributor to mental health deterioration. Nothing presented indicates anything to say that it's a large contributor or that it's a major contributor, it just isn't discussed at all.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]
- fennecfoxy 4y ago>Boys are doing badly too, but their rates of depression and anxiety are not as high Separate issue, I know. But it could be much lower because men/boys often refuse to report such feelings, out of a fear of being perceived as weak/having been taught that "that's not what men do". Self-reported data can always be a little flakey, especially on sensitive topics like this.
- oakhaven 4y agoWas the data of Orben & Przybylski (2019) public? It seems that if it would be public, and it was properly labeled (social media vs digital media, boys vs girls), the obscured relationship between social media and the quality of girls' mental health could be discovered by anybody looking at a simple correlation matrix of the data in Jupyter and Pandas.
- sagebird 4y ago1. Do you believe that legislation and fear of legislation to protect mental health will cause a crisis to Meta's viability in the next 10 years? 2. Suppose legislation limits Meta's freedom in attempt to advert mental health issues. How difficult will it be for Meta to maneuver or adapt to survive in this environment? 3. Meta's market cap is 442 billion usd. What do you guess Meta's market cap to be in 2033 (ie, the average of your expectations)?
- jasmer 4y agoThis is extraordinary. Imagine the political fallout here given how powerful Meta is and the competing narratives. This is the kind of thing that should be front and centre in media discussion, but Meta has too much money. It's just not. This, and the Opioid push by Big Pharma have to be taken much more seriously. I suggest there might be some massive lawsuits on the way.
- Nursa90 4y ago[flagged]
- Reptur 4y agoSocial media merely a communication system, the information that transmitted is the problem. Much like money isn't the cause of corruption, like some people in high places would want you to think about certain digital coins. The social hierarchies, the bullying, has all existed previous to social media. The only thing social media has done is be a magnifying glass on those things and put you in an addictive loop exposing you to them. Ridding or reducing social media to solve the problem is akin to the logic you get in therapy, just think about something else, notice your bad thoughts and think about something else in its place. Or what I like to call, ignoring the root problems, which is the toxic social hierarchies and bullying.