10 ms·
Portugal proposes to end Golden Visas, curtail Airbnb rentals
- bitsinthesky 4y agoWould putting a low price ceiling on airbnb listings do the trick? Let home owners rent out a room if they have the extra space or go on vacation, but not let them make any real profit on any substantial allocations of rooms or whatever.
- tayloramurphy 4y agoAs someone who was considering this for the future (10+ years) its disappointing, but I understand it. Both Portugal and Ireland were on my list. I could 100% imagine how this program was ripe for abuse and would have side effects that citizens would not want. I suppose dual citizenship will have to come the old fashioned way!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ivanmontillam 4y agoYou mean, by buying a passport from any of the Caribbean islands?
- nadermx 4y agoBirth
- atyppo 4y agoTheir program for Sephardic Jews was far more open to abuse than the golden visas ever were. From having looked into it, the wait times for appointments were insane. I can’t imagine having tried to do it.
- rcarr 4y agoI’m pretty sure Spain just started a golden visa program. These things probably move in cycles depending on the economic conditions and the governments. If you’re really loaded, you can just buy your way into become a citizen of Malta an get your passport that way. I think Cyprus might also have a similar program: https://www.citizenshipinvest.com/en/programs/malta-citizenship/ https://www.citizenshipinvest.com/en/programs/malta-citizens...
- renewedrebecca 4y agoSpain just started a Digital Nomad visa, not a Golden Visa.
- rcarr 4y agoAhh my bad! Still might be useful if you’re looking to move to the med
- stkai 4y agoIf you want to get in soon, you probably still can. GCS is accepting applications until March 16. https://www.globalcitizensolutions.com/portugal-golden-visa-ending/ https://www.globalcitizensolutions.com/portugal-golden-visa-...
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> which is one of the poorest in Western Europe It is so weird to read this, when Portugal used to be a major colonial power. Times, they have a-changed...
- jdfellow 4y agoPortugal started to collapse, slowly, after the 1755 Lisbon earthquake and it's just been one setback after another since.
- grugagag 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1755_Lisbon_earthquake https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1755_Lisbon_earthquake
- pyuser583 4y agoPortugal was one of the poorest nations in the world in the early 20th century. A poor, backwards region in a more prosperous country was called “The Portugal of <country name>.” Portugal got out of its funk when a vaguely fascist dictator took over. Salazar. He sacrificed prosperity and liberty to achieve stability, which was a good deal because Portugal didn’t have much prosperity or liberty. The last of Portugals overseas (non-Atlantic) territory’s was ceded to China in 2000. It’s been a long, strange trip for Portugal, but they haven’t been a wealthy empire since they gifted Mumbai to the British.
- balia 4y ago"ceded to China" is a strange way to phrase that Macao was returned to China after colonizing it
- GuardianCaveman 4y agoThe Portuguese owned it for what, 500 years? At what point does something become someone else's? Modern China was created through invasion and bloodshed by various political groups just like every single country in the world.
- testfrequency 4y agoAll the wealthy influencers who moved to Portugal, and sell content around “escaping america to live the american dream” - great work. I’m sure the locals all appreciate and love you.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoMoving somewhere permanently without any local friends or family is a horrible idea for most people. It’s a fantasy. Edit: Since I’m already being rate limited because I’m on dangs list because I argued with him… It’s not easy for everyone to find new friends and romantic partners. Please don’t brush off the harsh realities of immigrating. My immigrant friends all tell me how hard it was to move to the US.
- davchana 4y agoYes, only if one is in an good economy country (or first world country). Otherwise, economic migrations happen all the time, and I myself moved multiple times in life (temporary) for better job prospects and permanently for personal reasons to other countries, with not a known single soul in new place.
- jacquesm 4y agoIf you're mostly self reliant where you live today and the climate sucks then it can work out just fine, especially if you are willing to really learn the local language.
- JCharante 4y agoYou can just make new friends though. In my experience it’s infinitely easier to make friends abroad because in a way it’s you guys vs the locals
- robjan 4y agoIt really depends on where you move. I would never move to suburban America, for example, because of what you mentioned. But if you're young(ish) and/or don't have too many family commitments it's pretty easy to find a hobby based or cultural community in most cities.
- rdl 4y agoIt's not completely certain the golden visa program is closed (it has some other routes -- donation, fund investments, R&D investments, and it might also remain open for some commercial real estate options.). The citizenship pathway through that has been uncertain for a while; since the communist government got elected a few years ago, they started delaying processing on all immigration related stuff to the point where many question if it was intentional vs. incompetence, and the risk of not getting citizenship after 7 years is higher than ideal. (The cool thing about the Portugal program was you only needed to be present 7 days/yr, which means you could retain residency somewhere else, e.g. Puerto Rico, during the 6 year wait for permanent residency or the 7 year wait for citizenship. Real estate also doesn't have FATCA reporting, and thus isn't restricted from US persons; the fund investments, etc. are more annoying. The 250k EUR donation route is not actually that horrible IFF the citizenship is certain, but it does not seem to be certain.) Caribbean CBI is $100-200k but is faster (6-12mo, easy) and doesn't include right to reside in Europe, but it's just from a marketing/aesthetic/brand perspective worse than Portugal. Turkey is another option, although it's USD 400k RE investment now, vs. USD 250k, and Turkey's current politics are...spicy, although I'm pretty bullish on Turkey as a country in >10 years (and sooner if changes happen.)
- jacquesm 4y ago> and the risk of not getting citizenship after 7 years So, like Canada then?
- yieldcrv 4y agoSchengen or nothing
- cmrdporcupine 4y ago"communist government was elected" uh...? no? That never happened.
- loeg 4y agoThe Socialist Party won a majority in 2005-2011 and a plurality again in 2015 (before gaining a majority in 2022): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Portugal#XVII_and_XVIII_Constitutional_Governments_(2005%E2%80%932011) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Portugal#XVII_and_... GP is probably referring to one of those (maybe the more recent).
- Tiktaalik 4y agoSeems like the era of these sort of visa schemes is ending and hand in hand the notion of luring foreign wealth being a good idea. Not just Portugal but Ireland, and of course Canada ended its wealthy visa class (Quebec pausing theirs) and BC brought in its foreign buyer and empty homes taxes. For a while there it was clear that policy makers seemed to think that foreigners buying real estate was somehow a quick and easy way to turn around the economy. Somehow thinking foreign wealth merely being around would induce more wealth to appear as if by magic. 1. bring in a bunch of wealthy people to buy real estate 2. ??? 3. Tide lifts all boats and economy does great! Unfortunately what actually seems to happen is that you end up with a bunch of mostly empty pied-a-terres, the rich foreigners leverage the opportunity purely for a passport and don't invest or start new businesses, and the home building industry pivots increasingly toward building turn key pied-a-terres that are useless and expensive for locals. It all results in a situation that's worse for the economy, a spiking cost of housing and living. What policy makers should really be striving for here is an extremely low cost of renting which keeps money in peoples pockets that they spend and invest in creating their own local busineses.
- rcarr 4y agoThe world needs more comments like this. Nail meets head.
- KptMarchewa 4y ago100% agree. The fact that giant majority of the last X years of economic progress have ended solely in the pockets of the landowners and landlords is a tragedy of our times.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoWhy not keep the visa but let them build homes in economically depressed areas? The golden visa did have recent restrictions that are similar to what I am advocating for but they didn’t go far enough.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoI think they actually did this a little while ago, changing the rules such that Golden Visa only applied to home buying in inland rural areas. No longer applying to the main coastal cities. Hopefully a Portuguese person who knows more can chime in here because I'm not really that familiar with the issue beyond the high level.
- renewedrebecca 4y agoIt's just the Golden Visa that's getting scrapped. Portugal recently created a Digital Nomad Visa that's less ripe for abuse.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoDoes one pay taxes on foreign sourced income on that visa? I haven’t been able to find a good answer. Also, can one bring a spouse?
- renewedrebecca 4y ago1) I think it depends, but look into the NHR. 2) I think so, under the reunification Visa.
- petesergeant 4y agoIn almost every other case I’ve seen (including Spain), the answer is yes, although often at a slightly reduced rate, and some also depend on how much time you spend there.
- golemiprague 4y agoDoes it really matter if it is golden visa or any other visa? at the end of the day increasing the population cause increase in house prices, it happens everywhere. Maybe countries should learn from Japan, the only sane country which doesn't push for population growth by immigration or any other means. It is no surprise that house prices there are reasonable, even in major cities like Tokyo. It is easier to just stop population growth rather than increasing the rate of building new houses and infrastructure, at least in the developed world where there is so much regulations and barriers.
- rr808 4y ago> Maybe countries should learn from Japan, So weird hearing that because when I was growing up in the 80s Japan was famous for having the most unaffordable property anywhere in the world. https://www.scmp.com/magazines/style/news-trends/article/3091222/japan-1980s-when-tokyos-imperial-palace-was-worth-more https://www.scmp.com/magazines/style/news-trends/article/309...
- golemiprague 4y ago[dead]
- pipeline_peak 4y agoIn Portugal we take legal heroin at the Holiday Inn!
- somewhereoutth 4y agoGolden Visas probably didn't cause too many problems - they are easily palmed off with peculiar concrete and glass boxes in odd places, not like they'll be living in them much anyway. AirBnB is what has been causing the problem with affordable accommodation in the city centres. Tourists want easy access to everything downtown, same as students and young professionals, and at 100 euros a night or whatever the going rate is is unbeatable for yield. The trick now is to start turning these places back into HMOs / family apartments. It's nice that they've been done up, now time to give them over to local residents. If some 'funny money' gets royally screwed in the process, then all the better.
- kelnos 4y agoYeah, it smells too much like the Golden Visas are being used as a scapegoat, to make it seem like the government is Doing Something. I agree that GVs are probably a net negative for a local economy, but I doubt they contribute significantly to housing unaffordability.
- ghiculescu 4y agoAnecdotally, when I visited Lisbon last year, every taxi driver was extremely friendly and constantly encouraging me to buy some property and move to Portugal. Obviously this is a small sample size, but my impression was the people I talked to all genuinely welcomed foreigners (and their money, sure) in a way I haven’t experienced in many other places. Other expats I talked to in Portugal agreed with this. I think the Portuguese may find that the only thing worse than positive net migration is negative net migration.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI was in the northern part of Portugal in 1996; didn't get farther south than Porto. I actually saw ox carts on the roads. If I had to guess, I'd guess the main AirBnb action is in the south. It was a very nice country, and I totally support their desire to keep it that way. With the understanding that it's hard to get foreigners' money without making some tradeoffs (namely, your main industry becomes catering to their needs). With the few natives I talked to, a common dream was to go to America and save up enough money to come back home and be wealthy.
- xiphias2 4y agoIt was the dream everywhere in the world last 20 years, but all of us had face the fact that by the time we went back home, home price have risen much more than what we expected.
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> With the few natives I talked to, a common dream was to go to America and save up enough money to come back home and be wealthy. That surely is one reason prices are skyrocketing right now, as many who went abroad in the 70s and 80s are returning for their retirement.
- AlbertCory 4y agoWell, that should be subject to empirical testing, at least: how many emigrating Portuguese returned to Portugal? Versus, how many non-Portuguese have bought property there?
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoYou would think. Although those boomer expats probably never gave up their citizenship, so they have the right to retire in Portugal right?
- InvaderFizz 4y agoSo the article is misleading at best. The Golden Visa isn't over. The real estate route for residential property investment is proposed to be axed. Nothing will be certain till March 16. From a Portugal visa group I frequent (I'm looking at doing the golden visa in 2028 or so): OK, so this article doesn't mention that these are proposals, which will be debated and then approved on March 16. I know the government has an absolute majority, but some changes may still happen. (One could reasonably infer from this article that it's a fait accompli.) The article also only refers to a small part of a raft of proposed changes related to housing pressures, whose aim is to reduce the increasing unaffordability of housing, notably rental housing, for existing citizens/residents. Many of the measures would not have a direct impact on members here, and available information is limited at the time of writing. However, key points (based on reliable Portuguese sources) include: -Golden Visas - new GVs would not be issued in respect of property purchases, and conditions for renewal of existing GVs would be tightened (to be renewed only in the case of owner- or owners' children-occupied, or where rented on the long-term market). -Alojamento Local - new AL licenses would not be issued, except in the rural interior where no urban pressures exist. Existing AL licenses would be re-evaluated in 2030, and every 5 years thereafter. This is what I have been able to establish today on these points. There is no suggestion of retrospective action regarding existing approved GVs/AL licenses, until such time as they come up for renewal (or, in the case of AL licenses, are re-evaluated). As a side note, GVs may still be available for investment in businesses and/or which lead to creation of jobs and/or in connection with some form of cultural sponsorship/investment, it seems - this is further outside of my field, so I can't say more on that point.
- joaofiliperocha 4y agoHere the houses prices are higher that average wages... the average salary is 900€ .. in Lisbon there are rooms (not houses) at 1000€ to rent There are news about landlord that throw out elder people to turn the house into airbnb And about Golden Visa, they dont create jobs But we are still frendly and welcome you all So make some vacations on Portugal leave some EURs ... and f*k off
- throw03172019 4y agoWhat does this mean for people that were in the queue for golden visa processing?
- abofh 4y agoDoesn't look like it's passed yet, so probably nothing - but you can probably just go the D7 route if you've got the liquidity for the golden visa regime.
- Loic 4y agohttps://archive.is/rlGXE https://archive.is/rlGXE
- rhuru 4y agoLawmakers have not even voted on this yet. So a bit premature.
- dang 4y agoThanks - that was far from clear from the article. I've made it explicit in the title above. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20bills%20propos&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- rjtavares 4y agoWell, the party in government has a majority in parliament, so they can just approve by themselves (and there is no history of members of the ruling party voting against any government measure).
- LatteLazy 4y agoAirbnb is a convenient scape goat for deep rooted social, political and economic issues.
- iechoz6H 4y agoIt's also the facilitator par excellence that flips 'bad' into 'unsustainable' in the housing domain, all else being equal.
- neom 4y agoExacerbate would be an understatement. For example: https://shorttermrentalz.com/news/realpha-investment-homes/ https://shorttermrentalz.com/news/realpha-investment-homes/ https://skift.com/2022/02/16/avantstay-creates-a-500-million-fund-for-investing-in-short-term-rentals/ https://skift.com/2022/02/16/avantstay-creates-a-500-million... https://skift.com/2022/03/15/short-term-rentals-may-prove-right-fit-for-private-equity-seeking-new-asset-class/ https://skift.com/2022/03/15/short-term-rentals-may-prove-ri... http://insideairbnb.com/reports/platform-failures-how-short-term-rental-platforms-like-airbnb-fail-cities-en.pdf http://insideairbnb.com/reports/platform-failures-how-short-... https://www.dropbox.com/s/u4s1fcync2gseyl/AirBnB_Report%20FINAL.docx?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/u4s1fcync2gseyl/AirBnB_Report%20FI...
- marvel_boy 4y agoExactly, Lisbon is destroyed beyond repair due to this madness.
- fxtentacle 4y agoIn some countries, AirBnB is like "tax evasion as a service" so I'm not surprised that politicians choose them as their target. Also, people usually hate it if their neighbor starts inviting strangers every day, because it causes thrash and misbehaviour on a level that permanent residents wouldn't.
- brmgb 4y agoThe slowness with which the biggest European cities with housing issues have tackled the problems of both short term rentals, second home ownerships and properties as investments tell you all you need to know about whose interests the main European parties are really serving.
- sergioisidoro 4y agoFinally! The situation is getting to ridiculous levels. Yes, influx of foreign talent and investment is good, but it's an extreme situation that is out of control. Expats were able to evade all taxes due to crypto exemption, and rules for income from foreign country companies. Locals fund social infrastructure while expats use it, dry out the housing market, and raise prices through gentrification. Golden visas are a loophole for sanctions against Russia's aggression (at least one well known oligarch has a Portuguese golden visa), and it's ironic that you can buy a visa with 200k while refugees die in the Mediterranean trying to seek asylum and safety.
- splix 4y ago> golden visas are a loophole for sanctions against Russia's aggression No. Portugal doesn't accept Russian citizens for golden visa since the war started. And do not process applications started before. > one well known oligarch has a Portuguese golden visa No. He didn't do the golden visa. He got it in a different way. He have got it "under a law that offered naturalization to descendants of Sephardic Jews who were expelled from Portugal about 500 years ago during the inquisition". And he received it about a year before the war and the sanctions.
- cromka 4y agoThere's a reason why VAT is not enough and we also pay income tax to fund any country's budget and all the infrastructure. Being a digital nomad is basically a taking advantage of a bargain that is getting away with that VAT only.
- seper8 4y agoDigital nomads dont pay income tax?
- jwestbury 4y agoIn most countries, I believe they should, but if they're being paid from another country, it may be relatively easy to get away with not paying income taxes -- since the country of residence would have no record of the income in the first place.
- dmurray 4y agoThe Irish program was suddenly ended just this week too. Coincidence, or someone high up in the EU pulling all the strings at once? https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ce9570w0eyeo https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ce9570w0eyeo
- biorach 4y ago> Coincidence, or someone high up in the EU pulling all the strings at once? That's a pretty hilariously optimistic view of the effectiveness and cohesion of the EU.
- roomey 4y agoWhat I read in RTE news made it sound like it was due to China relations, so naively I would imagine this could be US pressure more than EU. Also there is still an "entrepreneur" visa program still available I think. Edit: here is the link: https://www.rte.ie/news/business/2023/0214/1356617-immigrant-investor/ https://www.rte.ie/news/business/2023/0214/1356617-immigrant... International Organizations are mentioned (which is probably code for the EU)
- jwestbury 4y agoThe EU has been pushing countries to end their golden visa programs for years, because they're widely abused by money launderers and people avoiding sanctions. It's too bad, because I'd love to retire to a sunny country in the Mediterranean, but by the time I retire I suspect golden visa programs will have gone, and there aren't really a lot of options for visas in retirement.
- dmurray 4y agoPerhaps they'll be replaced with visas that don't lead to citizenship, so you can still live there but not travel on a European passport. It's tricky, because a lot of countries see "live here for a long enough time and of course you should become a citizen" as only fair. But it might keep everyone happy.
- thomasthetrain 4y agoAt least in the case of Portugal, the visa usually used by retired people is the D7 visa (not the golden visa), which requires a source of income not related to your work (eg: pensions). So you still have hope!
- throwaway13337 4y agoThe golden visa isn't causing the housing shortage because it's a very small program. I couldn't find a primary source but all sources say the same as this one: https://www.imidaily.com/datacenter/portugal-data/ https://www.imidaily.com/datacenter/portugal-data/ The program lets in on the order of a few thousand people per year. Other visa programs there vastly outstrip this is number. The golden visa is just a great marketing term for political ire. It implies wealthy privilege so it's easily targeted. Of course, the reality of things is that Portugal has recently rightly earned a reputation for being a great place to live and people (not many of them super rich) decided to live there. Housing is being built to compensate. The airbnb thing is more interesting and nuanced but harder to get a handle on. It might be that airbnb is causing some unhealthy things in the real estate market.
- JetSpiegel 4y agoOver 10% of houses in Portugal are AirBnB. That's just crazy! In some neighborhoods, it's over 60%. Plus, there's something like 700k empty houses, for some reason on another. There's no lack of houses for everyone, just hoarding and speculation.
- dorchadas 4y agoHow did you find that stat? I'd love to look it up for Ireland, Dublin and Galway especially.
- JetSpiegel 4y agoThe PM gave an interview a few days ago on local TV.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoYes, it's a small program but it has created some negative side effects - although you could also consider them positive, depending on your viewpoint. I've been living in Lisbon for 14 years as a EU citizen and currently have to renew my permanent residency card. Unfortunately, the authority SEF responsible for that is not reachable. Online processing doesn't work, making an appointment online doesn't work, writing emails returns auto-replies to call them, and I've given up via phone after more than 60 trials. Even when you get a connection, they don't respond. So I've contacted an immigration lawyer, and they several times mentioned "Gold Visas" and later sent me an offer: 500.- EUR for an appointment they would make with SEF. This might sound like nothing to people from elsewhere but these are substantial amounts for someone with a Portuguese salary. However, this would be peanuts for a Gold Visa applicant.
- rjtavares 4y agoThe measures announced are far more ambitious than this article suggests. The one that will cause the most controversy is the State taking over unused housing, making improvements if needed, and then renting the properties (with the money going to the owners after deducting expenses). Yeah, I'm sure that will go over well...
- potatototoo99 4y agoThat measure is not in the final list.
- rjtavares 4y agoI heard a few hours ago António Costa talking about it on RTP (state television), and it's in this document: https://s3.observador.pt/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/16165400/mais-habitacao-final.pdf https://s3.observador.pt/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/16165400... (as ARRENDAMENTO OBRIGATÓRIO DE CASAS DEVOLUTAS) Do you have any better source for the final list of measures?
- luckylion 4y agoI generally don't like state intervention, and I'd prefer hefty taxes on unused housing (at least where housing is needed, no need to punish empty buildings if there's oversupply), but I'm fine with the idea of curbing speculation in housing that doesn't include intent to actually provide housing.
- rjtavares 4y agoI'm fine with additional taxing of those houses, but having the state take over the renovation and renting processes is a recipe for corruption (which, given Portugal's recent history, makes me think it's actually the real purpose of the measure).
- luckylion 4y agoI assume that's already the case, everywhere, isn't it? Germany certainly has that issue, state-owned housing companies have some very nice flat and they're very affordable, but you need to be connected to have a chance to get them. It is what it is, corruption finds its way into everything everywhere.
- ETH_start 4y agoSingapore can fit 5.4 million people in 728 square kilometers. Portugal has two times the population (10.4 million) and 125 times the space (92,200 square kilometers). The problem isn't tourism (Airbnb) or retiree immigrants (golden visas) occupying Portugese residential units. The problem is inability to build the needed housing.
- hef19898 4y agoThat's not even an apple to oranges comparison. Also, Singapore is one of the most expensive cities on earth.
- eunos 4y agoI think it's the autos ownership that make it so. If you dont own cars, it's not that expensive.
- mejutoco 4y agoSingapore is benefiting from wealthy Chinese people leaving China, being a finance hub, and being a city state (small). I can double an investment of 1€ easily; with 100 Million, it is a bit more difficult. The problem is probably complex, and my bet is it has to do with incentives regarding tourism. When a desirable place gets an influx of people with a lot more purchase power than the locals, distortions happen. Prices, for instance, might reflect what tourists can pay, pricing out the locals. It is a delicate balance, and I guess it comes with globalization.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoHow is turning a beautiful country into a 'concrete jungle' ever a solution?
- sensanaty 4y agoSingapore is also an authoritarian concrete jungle, among one of the most expensive cities in the whole world. Let's try not ruin a beautiful country like Portugal by turning it into S'pore, aye?
- tin7in 4y agoIt's really sad to see some parts of Lisbon (not only in the city center) being completely taken over by airbnbs – often the whole building is owned by a company and then flats are rented out.
- nicolas_t 4y agoTrue, but on the other hand, I also remember how run down the historic center of lisbon was in 2008-2009. Airbnbs have improved the situation somewhat I feel.
- darkwater 4y agoI actually loved - as a tourist staying there 4 days - the sense of decadence Lisbon had at that time.
- zemvpferreira 4y agoWere you here (in Lisbon, where I'm from) 10 years ago when those same buildings were boarded up and on their way to falling down?
- tin7in 4y agoWhat was the underlying reason back then? Was it the financial crisis or something else?
- zemvpferreira 4y agoBecause no one had wanted to live in the city centre for decades. It was deserted and dangerous from the 90s until the tourism boom. The castle district, the epicentre of tourism in Lisbon, lost population every year for something like 30 consecutive years. Thankfully foreigners swooped in and ignored the dereliction and drug addicts for long enough to make the historic districts liveable again.
- johngladtj 4y agoCenturies of rent control
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoAirBnB should be controlled because it's annoying to have tourists in residential zones. But it seems weird to propose cutting the visas to help the housing crisis. If there's a housing crisis then build more houses to increase supply, don't cripple the economy to reduce demand.
- JetSpiegel 4y agoBuild more houses, where? There's no lack of houses in the sticks, you can't just raze the city center and build skyscrapers.
- srazzaque 4y agoSounds simple enough, but there's a small problem. Increasing supply might negatively affect property values. ... And people influencing policy are likely property owners, or at least represent property owners.
- jmyeet 4y agoOnly a few thousand golden visas are issued every year. This is performative. Portugal does have a housing crisis. The golden visa allows buying residential real estate as a qualifying “investment”. The government could simply end that part. Or even require building new affordable housing units. Historic cities like Lisbon don’t lend themselves to new units easily, which is an issue. Airbnb OTOH is cancer to housing markets and pretty much every government should kill it.
- tfrutuoso 4y agoQuoting a certain green ogre... "AND STAY OOT!"
- somewhereoutth 4y agoPortugal new resident (the terms 'immigrant and expat' are heavily loaded, and make less and less sense in the context of movement within the EU) of some years. AirBnB has wrecked city centres (Lisbon, Porto). Banning it, right now, is the only thing that will help. However AirBnB is putting money into the pockets of many Portuguese families who were lucky enough to own downtown properties (in what were previously undesirable locations e.g. by the river). Thus politically this may be difficult. Much easier to blame golden visa holders (correctly - but a lower order cause), but also Digital Nomads and other foreign workers (not including the foreign workers from the former colonies who do all the grotty jobs of course - they don't mind them). Sadly this has crept into online and public discourse. However Digital Nomads don't really earn that much in the grand scheme of things typically, and also tend to be paid from outside Portugal, tax breaks aside surely they are a net benefit.
- VieEnCode 4y agoFinally. For many years, Lisbon and Porto have been rendered totally unaffordable for average local residents by rampant Airbnb fuelled property speculation and general overtourism. And all of this under a supposedly left-wing government.
- throwayyy479087 4y agoDo countries exist to enrich the members of government on the backs of the 90%? Do they owe some duty to protect the populace from massive global changes? Or will cynical, strip-it-for-parts policies continue to win the day? Canada is a great example - lots of lovely policies, until you want to buy a condo.