11 ms·
StarFighter 16 inch: 4K Coreboot/Ryzen Linux laptop
- teddyh 4y agoRYF certification or no sale for me.
- mattl 4y agoI’d love to know about a good laptop for Linux that has 32gb RAM and a decent amount of IO and a decent keyboard.
- fmajid 4y agoThe HP DevOne goes up to 64GB. Terrible screen, however. https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/16189462 https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/16189462
- lhl 4y agoLast year I made a list of options when I was looking: https://github.com/lhl/linuxlaptops/wiki/2022-Framework-Laptop-DIY-Edition-12th-Gen-Intel-Batch-1#alternatives-options https://github.com/lhl/linuxlaptops/wiki/2022-Framework-Lapt...
- shmerl 4y agoPretty cool especially with Ryzen CPU option. Does it support USB 4 with Ryzen too?
- lhl 4y agoIn September they said the Ryzen versions wouldn't have USB4 support [1] but in November they said it would. If it's important for you it might be best to contact their support to confirm which it is. [1] https://twitter.com/starlabsltd/status/1574860315254263830 https://twitter.com/starlabsltd/status/1574860315254263830 [2] https://twitter.com/starlabsltd/status/1593525807682568192 https://twitter.com/starlabsltd/status/1593525807682568192
- hedora 4y agoThis Linux laptop looks too good to be true. It's available with an AMD or Intel processor, there aren't any strange ergonomic decisions (other than the stow-able web-cam). In particular, they centered they trackpad + keyboard, and it looks like it has decent thermals. The battery is rated for 18 hours. You can choose between a medium resolution, high frame rate display (UHD @ 165Hz) or a 4K 60Hz display. The screen is matte. They claim it POSTs in under a second. The only real downside is the 4-5 month lead time. Am I missing something?
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoHave they actually made one yet? The pictures on the site all look like renders; and I couldn't find any pictures of an actual prototype anywhere.
- azangru 4y ago> Have they actually made one yet? Exactly. No real laptops so far; no videos with honest in-depth reviews; no information on the dirability of these machines. If something is too good to be true, it likely is.
- LesZedCB 4y agoI guess it was for the discerning - but not too discerning - buyer
- koonsolo 4y agoYouTube has review videos
- tsmithe 4y agoI am typing this on their latest StarBook. It's a great machine. As for durability, it has an aluminium body and seems sturdily built. I expect it to last a good few years.
- ddalex 4y ago
- x11vnc4life 4y agoToo bad it's only available as a 16 inch option. I'd be all over it if there was a 13/14.
- azangru 4y agoThey have a 14-inch model; it's called Starbook.
- ChuckMcM 4y agoCannot see if the 64GB option has ECC. That would be a nice feature for such a big chunk of memory.
- wyldfire 4y agoGood luck defending against Xur and the Kodan armada without 128GB of RAM. Sounds like Centauri sold you on another one of his Excalibur tricks.
- japanman425 4y agoIs this a chatgpt response. What do these words even mean
- b0afc375b5 4y agoI was confused as well. I looked it up and apparently it's a reference to The Last Starfighter movie.
- wyldfire 4y agoDon't trust the posts above! These were written by spies from Rylos! Once we smash the Frontier we will be able to rid ourselves of the Star League!
- thaumaturgy 4y agoCentauri! Is that you? It's been a while.
- japanman425 4y agoDown voted for not knowing the film inside out, great.
- Dylan16807 4y agoDownvoted for bringing up chatgpt out of nowhere as part of a complaint.
- wpietri 4y agoFor sure. People really need to stop complaining about the obscurity of things they can Google. The first hit for "Xur and the Kodan armada" is a page from a fan wiki: https://thelaststarfighter.fandom.com/wiki/Xur https://thelaststarfighter.fandom.com/wiki/Xur As somebody who plays very few video games and is forever looking up references, I promise that basically everything is now documented.
- photonbucket 4y agoPlease let this be real.
- mouse_ 4y agoIf it still has Intel ME, this is all simply marketing.
- BugsJustFindMe 4y ago$800 for 2 extra warranty years? Uhhhhhhhhh.
- lucb1e 4y agoAnd about half that for the afaik EU minimum legal warranty of 2 years. Their warranty page says they'll honor local laws, though, which I expect to mean whatever flag is displayed at the bottom of the page for you as opposed to their local. They probably won't be pleased to learn that the Netherlands, which they seem to have a custom page for so apparently support, doesn't have a minimum duration specified, so you could take them to court if the CPU fails after 5 years since who's ever heard of a CPU failing? Those things usually last decades and so that's what one is also lead to expect if not otherwise advertised. (I don't know of case law in this area, but that's how I've heard consumer law being explained by the consumer market authority consuwijzer and others.) "1 year limited warranty" for a 2000€ device that usually lasts at least 3, if not 5 years. Do people in the UK commonly put up with that or is the 1 year thing due to their small scale?
- 123pie123 4y agoUK law is not straight forward since it uses the word "reasonable" in the duration. "The Consumer Rights Act 2015 states that items must be of satisfactory quality, as described, fit for purpose and last a reasonable length of time. You have these rights for six years in England and Wales or five years in Scotland. Items must be of satisfactory quality and fit for purpose as described and last a reasonable length of time. So, for example, if you have bought a washing machine and it breaks after two years you should still be able to claim. However a consumer is expected to use the appliance reasonably. For example, a washing machine may be expected to be used a few times a week. It will show if it has been used every day twice a day for two years and this may be considered unreasonable and you would not get a repair or replacement. For an item such as a washing machine, or a car etc., the retailer can take off money for use. This needs to be a reasonable “amount”. You should familiarise yourself with the Consumer Rights Act 2015 before paying for any warranty being offered. It is worth stating I have never paid for or used a warranty. I always assert my legal rights. A retailer may try and fob you off saying that you should have bought a warranty. But your consumer rights are worth more than any warranty." https://thecomplainingcow.co.uk/what-is-a-warranty-what-is-a-guarantee-and-what-are-my-consumer-rights/ https://thecomplainingcow.co.uk/what-is-a-warranty-what-is-a...
- NayamAmarshe 4y agoThis looks amazing! My next laptop will definitely be from them. They also ship with ZorinOS, perfect match!
- bvinc 4y agoWhy did they feel the need to move the backslash key?
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoYou're looking at the UK keyboard. For some reason they have it next to the left shift.
- jonplackett 4y agoWe like it there
- yellowapple 4y agoThis is why my country declared its independence.
- jonplackett 4y agoIndependence Day. 4th of Ju\y
- fmajid 4y agoI live in the UK and can’t stand that crackpot layout that thinks the paragraph mark and the negation sign trump bacquote and tilde, so I buy my laptops from the US, except for Apple who allow you to choose your keyboard layout as an option.
- winterqt 4y agoThat's the UK layout -- if you go to customize it and select the US one, it's where you'd expect it to be.
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y agoNow imagine having to hold Shift to type numbers. AZERTY is a crime against humanity.
- neatze 4y agoIf this laptop is real deal, for me, it will be really hard decision which one to buy; StarFighter or Framework.
- ahoya 4y agoPractically as upgradable and maintainable/repairable as the framework. They sell all of the components separately, and this runs a fully up-to-date coreboot and even esoteric linux systems get tested on it. It is a significantly better Linux computer.
- commoner 4y agoThe StarFighter has soldered memory, making it significantly less upgradeable than the Framework Laptop. (Star Labs also sells the mid-range StarBook with upgradeable memory.) The Framework Laptop also has the advantage of swappable port/storage modules. However, the StarFighter has higher specs than the Framework Laptop at a higher price, and Star Labs is Linux-first while Framework is Windows-first.
- LtdJorge 4y agoIf you went for the 64GB option, there wouldn't be any RAM upgrade possible. Although that's very pricy.
- lhl 4y agoWell, it might be a better Linux computer when it ships. The StarBook Mk VI ran about 6 months behind schedule (pre-orders are still shipping now: https://support.starlabs.systems/status/f38fed83-e6a1-454c-88f2-2c34fc66bd45 https://support.starlabs.systems/status/f38fed83-e6a1-454c-8...) though so I wouldn't set your watch to it...
- ahoya 4y ago[dead]
- coolspot 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- japanman425 4y agoWho is this targeting besides the 100 or so hackernews commenters who will actually go through and buy it. Why would I buy this over a lenovo for instance. Okay so privacy nuts who think that removing their webcam and microphone protects from the perceived spyware that is next to them on their desk in the form of an iPhone. I see nothing good about this. Inexperienced company, inexperienced in manufacturing and hardware design.
- 12345hn6789 4y agoactually agree. Also considering their "kill switch" marketing. Who needs to turn their internet off on a whim who doesn't already have some sort of keybind to do this? Why buy this over framework / other laptop for 25% more money. Don't really understand
- lucb1e 4y agoBecause Framework is only available at, what seems to me like, tablet sizes. I know a lot of people love that size and that's fantastic, but I'm happy to see a ~15.6" option also being offered for those that prefer it.
- regularfry 4y ago
- lucb1e 4y agoThis is definitely cool stuff. When you want official vendor support on something like coreboot + various linux distros, I've come to expect you pay double of today's prices but get hardware from a few years ago. This looks like modern hardware and the premium is honestly manageable. Slightly above what I'd want to spend but I could see myself paying this for a great product, also because you get more than just 2 USB-A ports and more than just 1 USB-C port (that seems to be the best most other vendors have to offer)! However, what made me close the tab is the "we are not even going to give you a shipping indication other than to expect close to half a year" (knowing how these types of things like to change deadlines anyway, starting off at four months... no). If I spend thousands of euros now, I also want the product in a reasonable amount of time (say, 3 weeks including customization and shipping; 0.5-2 weeks for a stock product plus shipping). My current laptop is still performing well enough unfortunately, but ask me again in six months when the units are in and available to be shipped, and good odds that I'll hit that purchase button!
- Infernal 4y agoI’m really curious to know what piece of hardware you’re talking about, as you’ve apparently replied to the wrong post. But I really want the hardware you’re describing!
- lucb1e 4y agoOh crap, yeah you're right. Can't delete it now and move it to the right thread because of the comment heh. I thought I had the thread about this laptop open in this tab: https://starlabs.systems/ https://starlabs.systems/ | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34759507 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34759507 Not sure whether to re-post it there or flag my own comment or something.
- dang 4y agoNo worries! I've moved it now. You should be able to remove your /edit bit if you want to.
- psudohadex 4y agoI need an LTT review on this.
- teruakohatu 4y agoLinus has been very upfront about investing in Framework, so I am not suggesting he is doing anything untoward, but I still assume there is some unconscious biased in his organisations reviews of competing laptops.
- scns 4y agoWrite them or LTT about, maybe you'll get one.
- haspok 4y agoNo, we need a notebookcheck.net review instead. LTT doesn't know anything about Linux anyway.
- sneak 4y agoFINALLY a linux-focused powerhouse laptop with a decent screen. PC laptop screens seem to be stuck in the early 2000s. And only a short while after the M1/M2 are out and Asahi got GPU acceleration working. :D Intel was so close. (It also maxes out at 4TB of flash; the MBP can be configured with 8.)
- aetherspawn 4y agoHonestly as a business customer I can’t justify buying this unless there is an option to unbrand it. (Actually if you had a unbranding option we could sticker it with our own company logo and that could be pretty cool) Can you imagine the backlash if there’s some IT issue and someone realises that it’s not a Dell or Lenovo (why didn’t you just buy from big 2?), or how embarrassing it might be to go to a profile business meeting with an obviously random and non-corporate laptop (oh that looks like some random cheap overseas brand, uhh ok, are you sure you can afford us)?
- chungy 4y agoIs your company so hardwired to Dell and Lenovo that they can't understand competitors exist?
- aetherspawn 4y agoBuying anything outside the Dell or Lenovo business ecosystem really puts your head on the chopping block to be announced a crazy person the minute some business critical function (like dual monitors through dock) doesn’t work…
- chungy 4y agoYou need to find a better company with a better corporate culture.
- yellowapple 4y agoThose are in much shorter supply than you seem to imply.
- chungy 4y agoI've never previously encountered one so perverse that choice of laptop is basically tantamount to a fashion choice and causes ridicule.
- 4y ago
- OptionX 4y agoBack in the old DDR4 people used to say extremely high frequency ram (lets says above 3600MHz), that normally was O.C'd, would make your system unstable. Any one knows if it still happens in these DDR5 days? I'm asking because 6400MHz seems ludicrously high for a guy like me that just last week got some good old 2400MHz sticks for my home server and I'm wondering if it isn't marketing just to show high numbers.
- wtallis 4y agoThe speeds officially supported by a CPU's memory controller tend to lag behind the speeds officially supported by the fastest available memory modules. This gap got pretty wide toward the end of the DDR4 era: Intel's current CPUs that support both DDR4 and DDR5 only officially support DDR4 speeds up to 3200MT/s, but there's little reason to equip a desktop with slower than 3600MT/s memory given the state of the DDR4 market. 6400 MT/s is similarly beyond the fastest officially supported DDR5 speeds for CPUs. But the fine print reveals that this machine is actually using soldered LPDDR5, which is officially supported at 6400MT/s or higher by pretty much every processor or SoC that uses LPDDR5(x). Ditching the DIMM slots really does make it easier to operate the memory bus at higher speeds. Star Labs needs to correct their site to not refer to LPDDR5 as DDR5, because they really are different types of memory and only one of them is upgradable by the end user.
- freeAgent 4y agoI don't have an answer to your primary question, but I can say that latency has gone up dramatically as speed has increased. I remember back in the original DDR days, CAS 2 was the stuff to get. Now, we see CAS latencies in the 30s and even 40(+?)!
- Dylan16807 4y agoLatency, as in time spent, has not really changed. Memory numbers are just dumb. CL32 at 6400MHz (3200MHz doubled) is 10 nanoseconds. CL2 at 266MHz (133MHz doubled) is 15 nanoseconds.
- ajb 4y agoThe actual ram internally doesn't clock that fast, and many in fact run at the same rate as in the ddr4 days. The interface tackes the high rate down to a much lower rate but with more data flowing in parallel. But the ratio is locked, so if you overclock, the ram rate has to go up too, which is most likely what makes it unstable. So the upshot is that if this 6400Mhz device is not overclocked, it shouldn't be unstable.
- lucb1e 4y agoDoes anyone here run any of these OSes on any of the offered screen densities and resolutions? I have questions. - Surely not every old program available from the repositories will work with display scaling, will they? I've never had to use it, maybe Xorg has some hack to scale certain windows at 2x so you don't need support from individual packages. I'm also thinking of things like Burp Suite, which have window-like objects that interact horribly with things like i3 (from what I see with colleagues), so those might have similar issues when you have to tell Xorg to scale individual windows up. Is this something you run into? - How much of an impact does that resolution have on battery life and GPU performance? I do not need more than 1920x1080 pixels on a 16" diagonal, my eyes can hardly read small fonts on that DPI as it is (I'm ~30) and they're not going to get better with age. This laptop ships with either double or quadruple that, making me wonder what the trade-off is like of having this (for me) gimmick. Surely it doesn't double/quadruple the battery drain or halve/quarter the performance compared to a normal screen? - I also don't see flickering at 60 Hz (heck, 24 Hz TV looks smooth to me), so 165 Hz seems again like a battery drainer and performance reducer. How much of an impact does it have to try and render 2.75x as many frames per second on a GPU? Does it simply use 2.75x more power for the GPU or reduce the number of drawing operations you can do on the GPU by 2.75 times, or does this not work that way? Edit: this is currently at the top, but I don't want the top comment to be criticism. This product is awesome in virtually every other regard besides shipping time. Good physical size, decent number of USB ports, customization of the keyboard, c-c-coreboot?! Officially supported? I am definitely impressed. Heck, even the payment methods impress me, being able to select iDeal at a small foreign shop.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vladvasiliu 4y ago- AFAIK, it's usually the toolkits that do the scaling. So, it's indeed possible that very old apps, if they're still using old versions of the toolkits, don't support scaling. They'll appear non-scaled, so "at 100%". - I don't have a 4k display on a laptop so can't comment on battery life. But for "desktop use" (read: non gaming) GPU performance has been fine for a long time. I have an old desktop at work with a 4th gen i5 and whatever the integrated GPU was at the time. It can drive a 4k panel at 60 Hz just fine. A somewhat newer laptop, 8th gen i5 with a uhd620 integrated GPU could drive its internal FHD panel and an external UHD display without any issue. - For your eyes comment: the small fonts may be illegible because they're blurry. On FHD screens, I've found that bitmap fonts are much more legible at small sizes. I've seen some Dell with a 4k display at work, probably 15", and the small text was much more legible than on my 14" FHD laptop (compared using Windows 11 - the guy was a Windows dev). - TV has a blurriness to its movement, so it looks smooth enough because it's never actually sharp. The point of higher refresh rates is not "flickering", but a smooth movement. Try reading a scrolling page on a 30 Hz, 60 Hz, 120 Hz screen. I mostly look at static text on my screens, so 60 Hz works well enough for me, and I prefer higher resolution / better colors to higher refresh rates. Don't know how this affects GPU usage, though I don't expect it to be "free".
- ETH_start 4y agoI emailed System76 in 2013 asking them to accept Bitcoin. They said no, and continued to say no every couple of years when I emailed to ask again. Glad to see Starlabs is accepting crypto, but a little puzzled by there's no option for stablecoins like USDC. In any case, I'll take it.
- philliphaydon 4y agoI hope places continue to not accept Bitcoin. I can’t wait till it fades away.
- emrah 4y ago18 hrs battery life with an Intel processor would be great but seems unrealistic
- initself 4y agoNeeds a little red nub in the center of the keyboard.
- deusum 4y agoReference is old enough that we're not sure if you're joking.
- nine_k 4y agoNot joking at all, I hope. The trackpoint is very convenient: you don't have to move your hands off the home row just to move mouse pointer.
- commoner 4y agoThinkPads are still popular, so I don't see this as a joke. A pointing stick (TrackPoint) is excellent for people who want to use both the keyboard and the mouse while moving their hands as little as possible. Unfortunately, the StarFighter has soldered memory, which is one of the main drawbacks of new ThinkPad models. Star Labs also sells the mid-range StarBook laptop with replaceable memory and the low-end StarLite laptop with soldered memory. On the other hand, Star Labs is Linux-first and pays the developers of the pre-installed Linux distribution configured in the order, which is an advantage over Lenovo for Linux users.
- scns 4y agoAs Billy Tallis from anandtech explains, soldered memory has its advantages too. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34760461 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34760461
- fmajid 4y agoThe HP DevOne has one. Shame about that washed-out glossy screen (some say it has a built-in privacy filter).
- commoner 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ForFreedom 4y agoDoesnt have GPU to run machine learning?
- pachico 4y ago+150€ to change the keyboard layout? That's surprising!
- rl3 4y agoThey're selling a privacy-conscious Linux laptop with open firmware that's assembled in a place that isn't so privacy-friendly.[0] I think a lot of people would pay extra for assembly in a western country. These appear made to order, so the risk of hardware implantation targeting is almost certainly real. [0] https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2059/5897/products/StarFighter-13x2000.png https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2059/5897/products/StarFig...
- speed_spread 4y agoGoing all-in on privacy and hardware trust, one could also wish for a Raptor Talos portable workstation running a POWER CPU. I don't think they'd scale down to proper laptop size though.
- Transisto 4y agoCombined with the high risk of being a high target honeypot I'd be worried of that Chinese MITM.
- rl3 4y agoUpdate: https://us.starlabs.systems/pages/why-choose-us https://us.starlabs.systems/pages/why-choose-us Assembled, imaged and programmed in the UK. Configured by our own engineers, giving you peace of mind that you get what you want with no hidden extras. Not sure if that's outdated or what to believe.
- teo_zero 4y agoI laughed when I read this > Media keys for playback, volume, brightness, screenshots and more and realized they're the usual function keys doubly purposed. Do you even need to mention it as a feature?
- LeonM 4y ago> Do you even need to mention it as a feature? It wasn't, untill Apple intoduced the Macbook Pro with touchbar. Luckily Apple has finally accepted that people don't want it, and is no longer forcing it upon its customers.
- stuckkeys 4y agolol…why would anyone buy this? It is more overpriced than an apple m2 machine.
- LeonM 4y ago> It is more overpriced than an apple m2 machine Is it? The 16" M2 starts at €3049 and maxed out it is well over €6000. The 16" Starfighter starts at €1553 and maxed out it is ~€3500.
- coolspot 4y agoTo support Linux-friendly hardware? For many people extra $1000 here or there doesn’t matter.
- stuckkeys 4y agoGood point and all but shit is still too pricey.
- Jnr 4y agoNot sure how exactly 16 inch 4K display is Linux friendly knowing that Xorg and Wayland still has plenty of UI scaling issues. And the fact that they expect you to power it with Pentium N5030 processor is laughable. Why even offer such combination? Also it's funny how on landing page it mentions 165Hz display, but in specs it is only available as an option and not for the 4K display. Not that it would even be able to drive it properly. Looking at the specs, it seems like they are trying to build one of the worst possible Linux experiences possible. It lacks only Nvidia GPU to make it absolute garbage. I have one like that at work. Thinkpad with 4K display, and dedicated Nvidia GPU. It's not supposed to run Linux but I tried it anyway and it was very bad.
- gmokki 4y agoI have Lenovo 14" with 4k display and Ryzen 4850. I really like the crisp and accurate display. I have used wayland since 2015 when it became default in Fedora. I'm not sure what you mean when you refer to scaling issues? And even Skylake iGPU was fast enough to drive the 15" 4k display 60Hz on Precision 5510 laptop smoothly in desktop use. Ryzen is obviously many times faster so there should be enough power for higher refresh rates.
- windsignaling 4y agoThere's a bug on the site where if you select a different amount of RAM, the price doesn't update and when you check your basket it still says 16GB RAM.
- LoveMortuus 4y agoIntel i3-1215U, 16GB RAM, 240GB SSD, 4K display for €1.565,81, which is the cheapest that I could select feels a bit expensive... A quick look on Geizhals[1], gives many alternatives, with better CPU and storage. The only thing that's probably different is the Linux aspect of the laptop. [1]https://geizhals.eu/?cat=nb&xf=12_16384~2991_480~6752_Core+i-12000~9_38402160&sort=p&hloc=at&hloc=de&hloc=pl&hloc=uk&hloc=eu&v=e https://geizhals.eu/?cat=nb&xf=12_16384~2991_480~6752_Core+i... But 240GB of storage... That's so little, even my phone (POCO X3 Pro) has 256GB and I paid around 220€ for the entire phone. For a computer 240GB just feels almost unusably small, unless if you're running ChromeOS, but that's something completely different.
- localplume 4y agoYeah I was looking at those specs, and these seems very overpriced no? If you spec a Tuxedo Aura 15 Gen2 (https://www.tuxedocomputers.com/en/Linux-Hardware/Notebooks/15-16-inch/TUXEDO-Aura-15-Gen2.tuxedo https://www.tuxedocomputers.com/en/Linux-Hardware/Notebooks/...) to the same level (not sure what the equivalent to the CPU is for Ryzen though), and although the display isn't 4K its still much less (just over 700, so around half the price...). There are nice features that the StarFighter has than the Aura 15 Gen2 doesn't, but are those features worth basically 2x the price..?
- lhl 4y agoWhile the StarFighter is a much more expensive product, I think the argument would be that it's fairly unique, arguably the highest end Ryzen 6000 developer laptop that an end-user can order globally (but not get delivered, sadly) atm. Comparing the Aura 15 Gen 2: * One of the biggest spec differences is that the Aura uses a Zen2 based 5700U (Lucienne) vs the StarFighter's Zen3+ based 6800H (Rembrandt) so expect a +50% performance difference on MT workloads: https://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare/4156vs4749/AMD-Ryzen-7-5700U-vs-AMD-Ryzen-7-6800H https://www.cpubenchmark.net/compare/4156vs4749/AMD-Ryzen-7-... * iGPU is also a big improvement. The 6800H's GPU is about 70% faster on synthetic and 90% faster on gaming benchmarks: https://www.notebookcheck.net/Vega-8-vs-Radeon-680M_10313_11124.247598.0.html https://www.notebookcheck.net/Vega-8-vs-Radeon-680M_10313_11... - it also has a newer VCN engine that supports AV1 decoding among other things * The Aura has USB3 vs the Starfighter w/ USB4 (again, thanks to the new Ryzen generation), which will give you 40Gbps transfer rates, support for eGPU enclosures, etc * Better display panels can be hundreds of dollars more expensive (here's a discussion of a $250 price gap for upgrading to a 4K panel from a few years back: https://www.reddit.com/r/XMG_gg/comments/izg598/no_4koled_panel_on_schenker_via_15_pro_sorry/ https://www.reddit.com/r/XMG_gg/comments/izg598/no_4koled_pa...) - a 600nit vs 300nit display btw, is a world of difference * 49Wh vs 85Wh battery is a 73% bigger capacity battery. At an equivalent power usage, that'd be the difference between 7h vs 12h of light usage for example and IMO isn't something to scoff at. * Due I expect primarily due to it's Mg alloy chassis, the Starfighter is actually 250g lighter - 1.4kg vs 1.65kg, which is actually quite impressive for its size and battery capacity. The pogo-pin/removable webcam leads to a sleeker and compact frame that probably helps in shaving off size/weight even if you don't care about the privacy aspect * While I prefer replaceable SO-DIMMs on my laptops, the Starfighter at least lets you configure w/ 64GB of LPDDR5 so you get the better power efficiency, performance, and weight savings w/o sacrificing upgradability (64GB is the max the Ryzen 6000 platform supports) * coreboot option vs AMI BIOS - to me this is more of a neat nice to have, but I understand the sort of development commitment/investment in the future this thing is. Here's a discussion on Coreboot for Framework from their forums: https://community.frame.work/t/coreboot-on-the-framework-laptop/791/138 https://community.frame.work/t/coreboot-on-the-framework-lap... * Having been using a Framework w/ a fingerprint sensor that works in Linux for the past half year+ now, I will admit that it's hard to go back to something that doesn't have this, and I'd pay a fair amount extra for this... Anyway, while you do pay a hefty premium for maxing out the specs (more than the cost of each individual improvement), it actually seems not so egregious when I add it ll up, if only because it seems like no one else is doing it. Of course, this calculus I think changes if delivery gets delayed and/if someone were to release a high-end Ryzen 7040 Linux-friendly laptop (Zen4, RNDA3, Xilinx AI accelerator) before then. BTW, I think that the Tuxedo Infinity Book Pro 14/16 Gen7 (https://www.tuxedocomputers.com/en/TUXEDO-InfinityBook-Pro-14-Gen7.tuxedo https://www.tuxedocomputers.com/en/TUXEDO-InfinityBook-Pro-1... and https://www.tuxedocomputers.com/en/TUXEDO-InfinityBook-Pro-16-Mk1-Gen7.tuxedo https://www.tuxedocomputers.com/en/TUXEDO-InfinityBook-Pro-1...), while Intel-based (12700H), with a bigger battery, better display, better IO, and lighter chassis than the Aura is much more competitive with the StarFighter. Sadly the IBPs don't have a US ANSI keyboard layout...
- edf13 4y agoI’m the market for a new laptop - considering MacBook Pro m2, but also looking at Linux alts. What’s the suggested options these days?
- heavyset_go 4y agoI picked up a Dev One and am very happy with it and its Linux support. If you can't find one, it's just a rebranded Elitebook 845 G8. Otherwise, System76/Clevo are the usual recommendations, along with certain Thinkpad models. Here's what r/linuxhardware recommends: https://old.reddit.com/r/linuxhardware/comments/1073j9f/recommendations_for_a_linux_laptop/ https://old.reddit.com/r/linuxhardware/comments/1073j9f/reco...
- toastal 4y agoWe running up on the next generation of laptops soon. I got a Lenovo Z13 and it's been pretty good. The performance is there, having hiDPI without 4K meant I wasn't needlessly wasting power. It offered 32 GB of RAM (with DDR5 making it higher bandwidth). The display upgrade covers 100% DCI-P3 for color work with decent accuracy out of the box. The integration with fwupd has been awesome—something I had yet to experience in the couple of laptops I ran through. My biggest gripe: I wish it came with 1 USB-A (maybe a micro SD slot).
- VectorLock 4y agoKudos to them for not including an accountant numpad.
- pmontra 4y agoThere are many great features in this laptop, mainly no numberpad and 16:10 screen. I didn't check weight and user serviceability. They don't have the keyboard layout for my county (Italy) but I can live with that because my fingers know where keys are and I work with the USA layout most of the time. The only showstopper is the touchpad without physical buttons. I copy and paste text the X11 way by selecting and clicking the middle button. How do you do that effectively without buttons? I always took care of buying laptops with three buttons above and/or below the touchpad.
- bombela 4y ago3-finger click I do that often even on thinkpad with physical buttons.
- darrenf 4y agoRegarding user serviceability, for the Starbook (which I own) they have a complete pictorial disassembly guide: https://support.starlabs.systems/kb/guides/starbook-mk-v-complete-disassembly-guide https://support.starlabs.systems/kb/guides/starbook-mk-v-com... I’d expect the same tbh.
- sounds 4y agoThis new laptop has soldered-down RAM. It's due to the LPDDR5 which is only electrically able to reach 6400MT/s if the memory socket is skipped, so no blame for it. Just be aware.
- pmontra 4y agoThank you, so it's on my no buy list now. Too bad. I elaborate: a faulty RAM chip happens. If it's socketed I buy a new chip and replace it. It might take a few days, about 100 Euros, problem solved. With soldered RAM I'm expecting to have to either buy a new motherboard from a company that by the time might even don't exist anymore or find some repair center able to dissolder the faulty chip and solder the new one. Time and cost are much worse. I would think about it if this was HP, with on site next business day support, but they are not. And even with HP, what happens after support is over, which is typically three cheap years plus increasingly costly extensions? Last time I checked I got a quote for (I think) some 400 euro for a keyboard replacement. I bought a keyboard myself and replaced it. This brings us to the availability of spare parts, which might be a risk for this brand. All considered this is not a laptop I can use to make money with.
- haspok 4y agoAny keyboard that doesn't have a traditional T-shaped cursor keys layout is pure evil and should be banned.
- ur-whale 4y agoVery, very nice. Weight is 1.4 kg so a tad heavy (my 17" LG gram is 1.3kg) If it had an NVidia GPU, it'd be perfect for my purpose. [EDIT]: argh, I take it back: no numpad, so can't use Blender seriously on it.
- thdespou 4y agoIf they can deliver and be alive this time next year I'm ordering one.
- fodmap 4y agoSorry but I can't take seriously a company who states 'that sets a new standard for privacy' and their web page is full of trackers. That shows to me they don't believe in what they're preaching.
- alkonaut 4y agoWake me when they have shipped 10k units and I’m interested in buying the 10001th. There seems to be a lot of wishful thinking involved in the lead time estimate.
- Brian_K_White 4y agoEveryone complaining about the soldered memory please show me a lpddr5 dimm.
- xorry 4y agoIn general, how far removed is a coreboot computer from a fully open-hardware computer? Is there any promise that the latter will be available at some point?
- openplatypus 4y agoCrap, I am in the market for laptop now. I can stomach 4-5months waiting time Meanwhile lots of brands are spitting 15"+ laptops with FHD dispalys like it is 2010s. eWaste :(
- woile 4y agoThis machine looks amazing! We now need a nix configuration for it! Congratulations on the launch
- Darmody 4y agoWhy would I buy this instead of a Tuxedo or Slimbook? I don't mind paying more for a laptop from an independent company with linux support, but the price is excessive and I don't even know if what I'm buying is actually good.
- michael9k 4y agoDoes it run Windows? :-)
- daveoc64 4y agoThey offer Windows as a configuration option, so yes.
- kleiba 4y agoDoes anyone have an idea what the profit margins on devices like that are? I still find it hard to believe that a laptop should cost north of $1000.
- Oxidation 4y agoI still find it hard to believe that such a device can be less that $1000, considering how many parts have to be designed, how many cutting edge components there are in there, the depth of the supply chain and the manufacturing quality. Modern manufacturing is insane. Probably the most complex single device humans can make is a CPU die and you can have a mid-range one for the price of a meal, and this consumer laptop presumably has manufacturing tolerances that would make the people who built spacecraft a few decades ago sweat.
- vitus 4y ago> you can have a mid-range one for the price of a meal Is that an expensive meal or a cheap CPU? A meal for a family? My mental model for a mid-range CPU is an i3 (don't forget Pentium / Celeron), and even for those Intel recommends charging $109-119 for the i3-13100F (they had a similar range for the i3-10105F). Even if you go all the way back to the first generation of Intel Core cpus, the i3-530 had a recommended price of $117. Even if you're buying used + several generations old off eBay, you're still probably paying at least $50. And, note that once you're looking at several generations old hardware, you're really not looking at a mid-range device anymore -- The i3-13100F scores nearly twice as high on PassMark as the i3-10100F, for instance, and higher than the i7-9700F. It's still orders of magnitude cheaper and more powerful than anything from the 80s, certainly, but new hardware is not _that_ cheap. Also, that said, I remember when the Macbook Air first launched -- I know some people who ran the numbers and were impressed they could fit that SSD + RAM + CPU + display + battery in that price envelope.
- toyg 4y ago> Is that an expensive meal or a cheap CPU? I don't know how things in Deep America are, but since Herr Putin started his little anschluss, a meal for two in a nice European restaurant can easily run in the 3-digits. And I'm talking nice, not Michelin-nice - for those you'll need 3 digits for each person.
- totalhack 4y agoPricing seems extremely high for the specs once you start to configure. I really want to see a company do something compelling here but there is always one thing that's off...pricing, screen, last gen processors. I switched back to Linux last year and ended up getting a $900 Lenovo that has been excellent. Would have tried System76 or Framework if their hardware could keep up.
- geraldwhen 4y agoPrices are extremely high before you configure. These are apple prices without an apple warranty. When I had keyboard issues I had my laptop flown out with 1 day overnight shipping and the same back to me. When the refurb I purchased has a loose hinge, I got a full refund with no hassle. When my laptop was stolen during delivery, I got a replacement sent out with a 12 minute phone call. I suspect this small operation cannot match this.
- totalhack 4y agoFair, but you certainly pay for this in other ways with apple. I can afford to buy 2-3 laptops for the price you pay for one. And in most cases those types of events never come into play. Apple crushes on battery life but I've yet to come close to needing that much, performance is similar otherwise.
- steelframe 4y agoI agree that pricing might be their biggest challenge. Matte 4k X1 Carbon ThinkPads in like-new condition go for around $1k on eBay, and they run Linux fine, so long as you're willing to install non-free firmware. I'm not sure what kind of premium I'd be willing to pay to get the faster boot and libre firmware from a company with no track record at all in the marketplace. I've recently upgraded the SSD in my T480s that's running Debian, and I figure I have another 2 or 3 years before I'll feel the need to go shopping for something better. Maybe when the used ThinkPad T14 Gen 3 AMD machines start hitting eBay in force. I also own a Framework laptop, and the 3:2 aspect ratio is a killer feature for me. It's really hard to go back to 16:10 after using that for a while.
- 4y ago
- pmorici 4y agoReally wish someone would make a laptop with a 2.5” U.2 slot instead of M.2.
- causality0 4y agoIs there a point to having a 165Hz display with no dGPU? Unless you're really addicted to high-framerate Minecraft or something.
- toyg 4y agoHigh frequencies reduce eyestrain. Source: someone who suffered through the CRT years.
- sim7c00 4y agomost features listed will add tons and tons to the price of the thing.... terrible way of marketing something. list of good stuff 1600 euro price to lure u, but if you select the specs listed via the configurator you get up to double that price easily...
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoI am loving the number of linux laptops coming out. And I like that this company has an option starting at £400. All we need is for schools or governments to buy in and we can kill windows
- toyg 4y agoLol, no. Hardware support is only a piece of the puzzle, arguably the first one. Then you have to find suitable, well-performing replacements for every software being used, from generic to specific to custom LOB.
- imagineerschool 4y agoLooking forward to QubesOS compatibility report :)
- platz 4y agoConsidering these two processors: Intel® Core® i9-12900H (2.50GHz 14-core / Turbo Boost up to 5.00GHz) and AMD Ryzen™ 7 (3.20GHz 8-core 6800H / Boost clock up to 4.70GHz) Would the Ryzen actually be faster on average on single-core workloads since it's base spec is 3.20GHz vs the intel's base spec 2.50GHZ? (Not sure how long single core's can Boost for) Or does the Intel outperform the Ryzen pretty much unilaterally?
- Macha 4y agoDepends somewhat on workload. Generally the 12900H wins but there are some loads (e.g. handbrake) where the 6800H wins: https://www.techspot.com/review/2487-amd-ryzen-6800h/ https://www.techspot.com/review/2487-amd-ryzen-6800h/
- 300bps 4y agoSimply looking at the clock rate has never been the most useful metric when comparing CPUs. Even back in the day a 33 MHz 486 DX was much faster than a 33 MHz 386 DX. It’s better to look at benchmarks. Passmark is a good one. Its headline number is good for comparing performance in software that takes advantage of multiple cores. For that reason they also show single core performance to see how a cpu will performance relatively using games and apps that don’t use multiple cores. Benchmarks for both chips: https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i9-12900H&id=4728 https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i9-12900... https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=AMD+Ryzen+7+6800H&id=4749 https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=AMD+Ryzen+7+6800H&i... In this case the Intel chip beats the AMD chip both in multi-core and single-core benchmarks.
- hajile 4y agoGolden Cove is a much wider core than Zen 3 and has decently higher IPC. I'd guess Zen 3 is faster at base clocks, but I believe the 12900H doesn't stay at base clocks very often.
- sfy 4y agoKey column to the right of the enter key, that's a nope for me.
- helij 4y agoI love the idea of this but don't understand how they couldn't fit numpad on there.
- ruph123 4y agoI wish they would show actual photos of the thing or a video instead of renders.
- Bud 4y ago[dead]
- layer8 4y ago“A keyboard that's pure function.” But neither the cursor up/down keys nor the top row are full height.
- Liskni_si 4y agoAlso, function keys aren't separated into 4-key blocks, and ins/del/home/end/pgup/pgdown are in the wrong place. :-(
- localghost3000 4y ago> removable webcam Mmhm... Having owned a couple "linux first" laptops now, the cynic in me is saying that they are trying to flip a design limitation into a strength. They wanted slim bezels and to maximize screen real estate. They can't afford to do a notch like apple to get there. The solution? Make the webcam a peripheral and sell it as a privacy boon.
- devit 4y agoMissing discrete GPU and ECC RAM.
- znpy 4y agoI love the fact that there is no discrete gpu. I don’t run games and proprietary drivers are more hassle than anything else.
- r00tanon 4y agoProduct description sounds like Luke Skywalker's description of Princess Leia's rescue reward to Han Solo. "More then you can imagine." To which Han replies, "I can imagine quite a lot."
- ldelossa 4y agoI really want to like this laptop but... If you go to their twitter, its a constant barrage of angry customers who havent received their orders in over a year. I dont think im okay with shelling out $3000, waiting possibly over a year, and being told "we are working on it" the entire time. I personally just went with Tuxedo for a linux first laptop.
- blagie 4y agoExcept for the wonky webcam (which I can live with), and the lack of GPU (which I'm less sure about; I do a lot of ML workloads), this laptop is exactly the laptop I'd buy, if I knew it actually existed. Problem is, I'm not confident it actually will exist. The webcam decision is wonky. My Thinkpad has a little cover I can slide over the webcam. I can buy aftermarket stick-on covers too. Why the complex magnetic mess + storage compartment?
- whamlastxmas 4y agoWeb cam is also mic and the ability to know it’s completely removed is good because you often see physical mic switches that only disable via software. Also there are facilities that don’t allow any hardware with either
- jerryzh 4y ago>To this day, we still haven't found a competitors laptop that performs faster with the same hardware. I am quite curious how on earth "a laptop specially made for linux" will enable to have more performance on same hardware? More thermal pipe or you write your own drive?
- toastal 4y agoAll the Linux-y/FOSS-y things are great. I wish my laptop had Coreboot. Luckily you can switch the keyboard to ANSI too. The biggest flaws are this is the tail-end of these CPUs being current gen with the newer chips already announced & the display panel only covers sRGB in a world that's been transitioning to DCI-P3. With the former, it's a shame smaller ODMs & OEMs can't get access to the latest chips like the bigger players. With latter, I just don't know—we have the tech and the eyeballs to perceive more colors but most laptops still aren't embracing it even if phones have latterly moved to wider gamut (which makes using them for content creation subpar).
- krimpenrik 4y agoI have a weird feeling these guys are the scammers of slide n joy, the dual screen addition to laptops where they siphoned off money of buys for years, started with a Kickstarter. Really hope these guys get investigated. From Belgium or French they were.
- ahoya 4y agoTteir laptops are great and i own one.
- krimpenrik 4y agoApologies then! Still hope the slide n joy guys will get justice tho
- JeremyNT 4y agoIsn't the idea of this pitch that they're going to design their own laptops now though? I was under the impression that the extant laptops from this brand are just rebadges (Clevo - like System76). It's a big leap from slapping custom badges and boot logos on a Clevo to designing something from scratch.
- ahoya 4y agoNo they’ve been designing in house for years, this is just their latest.
- Transisto 4y agoAlmost a 1000$ extra to get a decent CPU? Unless I'm missing something a 1.02 GHz i3 seems underpowered for a 2000$ plus machine.