16 ms·
Want anonymity? Make a persona not a mystery
- behringer 4y agoNow I want to make a persona a just because.
- mikece 4y agoAnonymity is impossible, especially online. About the best one can do is to engage in clever obfuscation though there's a benefit to creating multiple personas for online activity: it makes it easier to keep your silos of interest separated. It's not for everyone but it can be handy.
- blfr 4y agoWhy would it be impossible online? You can pay anonnymously for Mullvad VPN, or use Tor, or open wifi. It's online that anonymity is even attainable.
- mikece 4y agoAnd then connect to which accounts?
- onetimeusename 4y agoWhat about signing in to apps which often uses a phone # and email? Also, betting on Tor is like betting there there are no 0-day exploits in browsers or Tor's network. Not a bet I would make.
- ghaff 4y agoIt all depends on your threat model at the end of the day. I could create a blog and social media accounts in a few hours and, unless I do something stupid, it's going to be pretty hard for Joe Random on the Internet to figure out who I am. But if I start writing things that catch the attention of the FBI? They'll figure things out quick enough.
- JohnFen 4y agoThis. If you're trying to hide from governments, that's Next Level stuff. You have to be prepared to actually live underground, which involves sacrifices most people aren't willing to make.
- onetimeusename 4y agoI am assuming you are talking about Tor. This is a sophisticated view of things and it's correct. Tor provides as good security and anonymity as a public VPN. But Onion Routers and therefore Tor were built with the intention of protecting against powerful adversaries that can perform MITM attacks. You could argue that the FBI is an even more powerful adversary I suppose but I think there is a mismatch in what Tor was intended to do in theory versus what it provides in practice and without knowing that you could be making a mistake. So I think it's unfortunate that people have to know how to do this analysis before making decisions.
- ghaff 4y agoReally more generally. If I create a blog on Blogger and a Twitter account--sure my identity is very discoverable by law enforcement, etc. But Joe Random isn't going to find it especially easily.
- haroldp 4y agoYou can set up a VOIP phone number that accepts SMS for about $2/mo + $0.01/minute.
- onetimeusename 4y agoyes, I am not saying it's impossible. This is what I do. It's just a nuisance and it took me a long time to find a VOIP provider I actually wanted to use. But that said, I've seen SMS verifiers reject VOIP provider networks.
- rsync 4y ago2FA mule: https://kozubik.com/items/2famule/ https://kozubik.com/items/2famule/
- kube-system 4y agoAnd those carriers are blacklisted by many apps that require phone number verification. e.g. https://www.twilio.com/docs/lookup/v2-api/line-type-intelligence https://www.twilio.com/docs/lookup/v2-api/line-type-intellig...
- jacooper 4y agoYou could use email aliases
- jerf 4y agoAs always with a security discussion, it's about threat model. Preventing a random internet person from tying a particular nym to you is easy. Fooling a bunch of people is harder, but doable. Being a top-tier youtuber would probably be effectively impossible. And if your concern is nation states, well... good luck with anything.
- pr337h4m 4y agoWorked for Satoshi Nakamoto :)
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lonelygirl15 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lonelygirl15
- ghaff 4y agoI'm not convinced that a plausible pseudonym is more privacy preserving than something that's obviously just made up. But it's not bad advice in general to post personal stuff on social media and blogs under a pseudonym if you want to be controversial.
- JohnFen 4y agoEverything I post online, controversial or not, is using a persona. I have several, each for certain areas. I've been doing this for decades.
- ghaff 4y agoThe thing is that a lot of what I post online is either directly or indirectly related to my day job. So I've always figured if I was going to have a moderately high profile public presence anyway, it wasn't worth maintaining a separate identity.
- JohnFen 4y agoThat makes a lot of sense. My case is different. When I've run my own companies, I'd post stuff online related to that. But even then, it's under a persona -- I feel it's even more important then, actually (I also use personas in real life in that circumstance. It's very useful to be able to identify as the secretary, the sales guy, whoever, in order to dodge time-wasters such as salesmen.) But if I'm working for someone else, I'm not posting anything directly related to my work.
- ghaff 4y ago>But if I'm working for someone else, I'm not posting anything directly related to my work. Obviously depends on the company and role. I was hired in part because I had a pretty big online presence on tech topics. (In part, I was writing for CNET at the time when they still had some enterprise computing coverage.)
- 4y ago
- JohnFen 4y agoAbsolute anonymity may be impossible (it's not, actually, but it is prohibitively difficult and you have to be highly motivated to have it), but useful anonymity is absolutely attainable. The key thing is -- who do you want to be anonymous with?
- minsc_and_boo 4y agoThe fact that you take any action to obfuscate your identity only makes you stand out more from the herd, not blend in. It's like wearing a ski mask in a store. Your profile(s) are more noticeable even if you're not immediately identifiable.
- SyrupThinker 4y agoMaybe to some actor that has sufficient data to correlate identities. But if I introduce myself to someone with an alias or claim false traits, they will not immediately just know it’s fake unless they have additional contradicting information. Most people do not casually wear ski masks, but they tend to not lie when asked for a name.
- minsc_and_boo 4y agoWe're talking about fingerprinting here. Even a person wearing a ski mask could give a name, they still stand out because they have a ski mask on. Deviations from the norm make you stand out, even if it's lying.
- SyrupThinker 4y ago> We're talking about fingerprinting here. I think the whole subthread is more mixed in terms of fingerprinting and social interactions. But if you only consider the the former then yes, one would probably only care about what I called "resourceful actors" to which you would end up standing out. I was more referring to the social aspect, were if you give someone a name they will (usually) not immediately assume it is false. Thus giving a false name does not make you "stand out" unless there is already other information in play. But I'm just clarifying what I meant, considering your point was meant for a different context.
- zirgs 4y agoIt's not impossible if you don't attract attention of law enforcement/intelligence agencies. If you use different usernames everywhere and don't reveal private information then a random civilian is unlikely to find out who you really are in real life.
- jxf 4y agoNow this makes me wonder if Derek Sivers is a real person or not.
- alx__ 4y agoMy new online persona will be Derek Sirvers
- TremendousJudge 4y agoNice to meet you Derek, I am Serek Dirvers
- minsc_and_boo 4y agoDirk Servers here, just saying hi.
- Derek_Sivers 4y ago[flagged]
- runjake 4y agoThis wasn't as funny as you thought it'd be.
- EGreg 4y agoCool, mine too! I used to go by Satoshi Nakamoto and be in the group Anonymous. I put out a few of those videos, but people kept challenging whether I was the "real" Anonymous. Interesting thing, I was in Barcelona last week, and just out of the blue I meet Bill Murray and he buys me ice cream. He said "no one will ever believe you!" Before he left, I told him my name was Satoshi Nakamoto. I'm just carrying on the work of my grandfather, Nicolas Bourbaki. Just like David Belle was doing what his father, Raymond Belle, began in Viet Nam.
- runjake 4y agoDerek Sivers is definitely a real person. You can trace his history, well, back when he was in America, using public records. But, I think as even he has admitted, his online presence is a well-crafted persona. And, aren't we all doing that?
- photoGrant 4y agoOkay 'Derek', good advice.
- blurbleblurble 4y agoSimulacra 101
- uoaei 4y agoWant to cover your genitals? Make a beer gut not a pair of shorts
- gbN025tt2Z1E2E4 4y agoThe social media equivalent of fuzzing basically.
- O__________O 4y agoAs a counter example, I have been largely anonymous online and offline for awhile; yes, aware it is nearly impossible to be completely anonymous, that’s fine, largely a “hobby” for me. Very direct about it, and yes, some people completely shut you out once you tell them, but vast majority don’t; while my opinion, those who do aren’t people I am interested in knowing. Very similar prior to me being largely anonymous, people would ask me what I did, I would respond saying I did nothing, which at the time was true and did not feel the need to make something up. Oddly, discovered their response almost immediately told me a lot about who they are as a person; they might think I am: cool, on-the-run, lying, nomad, spy, wealthy, homeless, etc. As for making personas, long ago I tried that, though now it to me feels like lying, especially in context of establishing long term relationships. That said, with personas I created, other than generic names, I would keep them true to myself, though never complete representations of myself. In doing so discovered that the variety of personas rarely played a factor in people engaging me, but it did appear to make a difference if I just happened to contact them randomly in close proximity to them having free time. All and all, being anonymous really is not that hard. Not even something at this point I spend lot of time thinking about.
- erstorreyk 4y agohttps://stylometry.net/user?username=O__________O https://stylometry.net/user?username=O__________O
- O__________O 4y agoYep, like I said, I have very healthy expectations of how to maintain anonymity. Fortunately GPT will largely fix the issue of statistical analysis of variations in writing style between one writer and another. Stylometry been around a long time, as with all security, you have to know you threat model, and adjust accordingly. To my knowledge stylometry never made me less anonymous.
- jacooper 4y agoAssuming your GPT prompts aren't logged
- BTBurke 4y agoNow no one will believe my real name is Gill Bates.
- EGreg 4y agoMany people have a hard time believing these folks when they introduce themselves: https://www.facebook.com/a.m.Jain.meenambakam/posts/for-other-people-named-bill-gates-see-bill-gates-disambiguation-bill-gates-gates/555461074568984/ https://www.facebook.com/a.m.Jain.meenambakam/posts/for-othe... Or these guys to get elected: https://www.ranker.com/list/funny-politician-names/nathandavidson https://www.ranker.com/list/funny-politician-names/nathandav...
- chaboud 4y agoAh yes... I'm Skimmington Harborough, Esq., I come from a family that made its fortune in philanthropy generations ago. This seems like a pretty straightforward mechanism for covert operatives, to generate a believable (and memorizable) cover that pulls attention away and maintains coherence. That said, as someone who prizes ethical behavior, it's not possible to practice this and remain wholly honest without some sort of ethical loophole like "character work for entertainment only". A persona requires misrepresentation, which is not the same as de facto anonymity. So, while I love the write-up, I don't think it's saying what they think it's saying.
- bilbo0s 4y agoAll of what you say is true. But it's even worse than that. A persona won't even confer anonymity these days. So now you're dishonest and attributable.
- RajT88 4y agoIndeed. Despite your best efforts, they know that Sir Olivier Stubbingwicke lives at the same address as Bill Swerski, who pays for the Comcast internet. Similarly, very few people are unaware that XFinity is the pseudonym for Comcast.
- hyperdimension 4y agoI know I'm running with the off-topic comment, but I like to point that out whenever possible. Companies know that if they just change their name, they lose any bad connotations they had with the previous name. Comcast changed the name of its Internet service to "Comcast Xfinity" for a few years, then silently dropped the "Comcast" at one point. Spectrum is also Charter, and Altria is Phillip Morris. It's crappy that it actually works most of the time, so I like to point it out to try to counteract that.
- chaboud 4y agoThat is so.... meta...
- onetimeusename 4y agoI've noticed the number of places that let you use ephemeral accounts has really dwindled. Spam, marketing, LE, and I am sure other reasons have it so persistent accounts are more common. So creating a persona is probably the easiest way to be somewhat anonymous online but it's getting harder to create unlinked accounts (using new phone numbers and unlinked to your other accounts) and when it crosses into the real world like with shipping products it gets weird. Your mailman might think a stranger is living with you.
- ghaff 4y ago>when it crosses into the real world like with shipping products it gets weird. Your mailman might think a stranger is living with you. Not really a problem. A friend of mine used my address (with permission) when they were doing a lot of international travel. Mail (and packages) were never an issue. These days you'd probably be advised to have some sort of burner phone. In general, the closer you get to the physical world, the harder it is to maintain anonymity.
- philwelch 4y agoA fun book about this stuff is Michael Bazell’s Extreme Privacy: What It Takes to Disappear in America. With extreme effort you can keep a surprising number of things unlinked from your government name if you really want to.
- ghaff 4y agoThanks for the link. I went down a bit of a rabbit hole on this a few years back after seeing on of the hosts of the reality show Hunted (former White House CIO) give a talk. There was a long Wired article on this topic years ago too. https://www.wired.com/2009/11/ff-vanish2/ https://www.wired.com/2009/11/ff-vanish2/
- JohnFen 4y ago> Your mailman might think a stranger is living with you. All the better! I don't know why this would be a problem.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI had an idea for a funny little startup once: “Adopt an alter ego” Essentially a marketplace where you can buy and sell prebuilt identities - complete with associated, aged, and populated social media accounts, email accounts, pictures, websites, etc. I just like the idea of being different people online.
- wongarsu 4y agoSounds like a side project idea: you enter a description of a persona, the bot buys some phone verified social media accounts, as well as gmail/msn/whatever (plenty of market places around) add uses GPT3 to periodically generate posts on said social media accounts, using the persona description. Then you just need to fill the pipeline with persona ideas, and get nice account packages after a couple months.
- forgotpwd16 4y agoHeh, persona as a service. Sounds a bit like the "new identity" thing in Breaking Bad. But online, and an alter ago.
- boffinism 4y agoI love the idea that social media accounts, like wine, are more valuable if they're sufficiently aged.
- timerol 4y agoThe main roadblock here is the crime. You would need some safeguards to make sure these people aren't real enough to receive any government benefits, or open a bank account.
- severak_cz 4y agoCrime is a largest potential customer ofc.
- kerkeslager 4y agoI disagree. The idea that we should nerf our security tools to prevent them from being used unethically just results in people using nerfed security tools for ethical purposes, while the people doing unethical things go elsewhere for their security tools. Put another way, if your crypto isn't used by child molesters and terrorists, it's probably not very good crypto.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y ago> It’s human nature to want to know who’s speaking. If they don’t say, it creates a mystery. Yes it's human nature to want things but, socially, one might learn to go without something if it's at odds with what someone else wants. If someone doesn't let me keep private things which I would prefer to keep private, unfortunately I will simply learn to avoid that person. That's to say, "make a persona" is being offered as a panacea to when those around me don't allow for privacy but it is a panacea I would not choose.
- gre 4y agoMaybe Adam Johnson of the Citations Needed podcast is just an entirely made up persona? https://twitter.com/adamjohnsonNYC?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor https://twitter.com/adamjohnsonNYC?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7C...
- xapata 4y agoThe trouble is when you've been using your alternate persona, chatting with a stranger, and encounter someone who knows your real name that wants to say, "Hello." "Oh, uh, ... that's my middle name."
- kibwen 4y ago"Hush, that's my truename, and there may be witches about."
- hot_gril 4y agohot_gril is my real name, honest.
- O__________O 4y agoYeah, have a friend that opted to stop using their real name online. We were on a group call with random strangers and girl randomly yelled out his real name when she heard his voice.
- Animats 4y agoEncountering someone who knows you is one of the big risks for people working undercover. Read "You're Stepping on my Cloak and Dagger", by Roger Hall.
- O__________O 4y agoInteresting, never heard of the book, thanks! While it’s been awhile, whenever I ran into that situation earlier on I first attempted to avoid them being aware I was nearby and would immediately leave the area. Once thought had no option, but to politely ask if we might talk for second and let them know not to say anything, which they were happy to do. Soon after for unrelated reasons ended up moving and have not run into issue again. All and all, while whole informant, undercover agent, spy, witness protection, etc - type things are tiny bit similar, having know real people in all those situations and read about others, it’s not comparable to what I am doing. Since those situations might not only end in you being killed, but anyone close to you. For example, once met a fellow who went under cover in well known gang as a journalists, they found out and he was lucky to end up in hospital for months instead of dead. For me, worst case is I lose being anonymous as a hobby.
- rlt 4y agoSatoshi is the only very high profile person I’m aware of to remain completely (pseud)onymous. Many others have tried and failed (though they often broke the law, so that might be the main distinguishing factor)
- ghaff 4y agoLaw enforcement/intelligence services involvement raises the bar on maintaining anonymity a lot. They can access a lot of information that even an army of armchair sleuths probably can't.
- quickthrower2 4y agoSatoshi could be a government persona.
- philwelch 4y agoSatoshi also dropped off the face of the internet almost as soon as he became famous.
- zem 4y agoBanksy is way more famous than Satoshi and has remained pseudonymous
- j0hnyl 4y agoFrom what I understand art world folks very well know who Banksy is, but I don't think such is the case for the tech world and Satoshi.
- zerodensity 4y agoLiked the write-up was a fun read. But I really don't get the point of being anonymous on social media.
- moffkalast 4y ago> Create a believable persona This is also a lot harder than it seems, once you start lying it's easy to slip up or provide details that are aren't self consistent. As long as you rely on people just accepting the answer and being immediately satisfied with that it'll work. Inb4 "oh hey I'm also from <town suburb name you lied being from>, remember that one thing?".
- itchyouch 4y agoIf one's town had a neighboring rival town/school growing up, using the rival town could provide a semblance of cohesiveness due to still being intimate with many of the details of said town as a rival.
- ghaff 4y agoI agree with your general point. But, assuming I wanted a fake background that would pass casual scrutiny, I'd make something up that was close enough to the truth but not close enough that anyone would think anything was off if we got to casual chatting. I'd probably say I was from and/or lived in some city I knew extremely well but had never actually lived in. Maybe say I got an undergrad degree from somewhere I got a grad degree. Etc.
- JohnFen 4y agoThe key is to avoid lying. Don't try to make up things that aren't true, just emphasize and deemphasize different aspects of your true self. That's plenty enough the majority of the time.
- jacooper 4y agoSaying what you want without worrying about being canceled in 10 years.
- dfxm12 4y agoMaybe it's because I'm the kind of guy who took the "On the Internet, no one knows you're a dog" comic to heart, but I don't assume truth about any type of online profile, and I usually don't go cyber stalking anyone just because their online handle sounds mysterious. Picking a new identity might be a good branding decision (especially if you can get NewName dot com!), but I'm also the kind of guy who looks at the message, not the messenger, so whether I focus on what you're saying or not has nothing to do with the online persona you've created for yourself.
- Octokiddie 4y ago> Use an AI face generator to create a completely believable face to match your new name. Download it once and use it everywhere. Run it through face aging software to use this same persona for the rest of your life. This approach will need a plan for dealing with Zoom. It has normalized, in a very short time, the video component of what used to be strictly audio - the phone call. If you don't display your face, people get mad.
- aendruk 4y agoComing soon, and recently discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34622699 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34622699
- adenozine 4y agoI love Derek's writing. He's so casually eloquent, without being up his own ass like PG. I've learned a lot from reading what he's produced, and I can certainly attribute (in part) a few successful endeavors to being a "slow thinker" as he calls it. We live in such an insane, reactionary world these days and I find it very refreshing to hear from people who've clearly thought hard about what they're about to say/write. Sometimes, I even wish HN worked this way. I wish the front page was about 10x as slow, and that we could discuss things for a week or two instead of a day or two. It'd be messier, but I think the fruits, separated from the weeds, would be juicier.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dingosity 4y agoHmm. Makes me wonder if Derek Sivers really is his given name. Maybe it's a pseudonym? I guess I could email him and ask. And before you ask, yes, Dingosity is not the name I was born with.
- class4behavior 4y ago>Once people start wondering, they need to know. You're projecting. >That’s a problem if you really want to be anonymous. Large emphasis on really. Stop conflating secrecy with privacy. The former is another pair of shoes entirely.
- misterprime 4y agoVery good, Old Sport!
- drcongo 4y agoI have an alter-ego that I release music as. I like that nobody knows who that is, but weirdly I think my alter-ego is a much more likeable character than me.
- qbrass 4y agoI share the same name as a semi-famous, semi-local musician. That made for a couple interesting phone calls over the years.
- Forgeties79 4y agoI use VPN's when I can, I mix up my browsers, and I've largely abandoned social media. Hopefully it helps shrugs
- aliqot 4y agoUse a PURDAH, like in "Fall; or Dodge In Hell"
- Waterluvian 4y ago> If you defiantly refuse to say who you are, it can make people angry that you’re upsetting social reciprocity. Citation needed. This entire post/idea seems to be based on "you can't just make up an obviously anonymous avatar/username anymore (like BakedPotato138)" and I frankly don't see why not. It's been working fine for decades. The only people who are upset over this are authorities and corporations. And in those cases, making up a fake person is quite possibly criminal fraud.
- rco8786 4y agoWait what, the entire post is literally "just go make up an avatar/username". > If you don’t want any attention, just pick a very common name like Mary Kim or Adam Johnson. > Use an AI face generator to create a completely believable face to match your new name. Download it once and use it everywhere. Run it through face aging software to use this same persona for the rest of your life. > Pick a city and say it’s your location, to avoid that question too. > For email, Mailbox.org is great, and doesn’t care who you are. > Create social media profiles with your new name, email, city, and face. > Nobody will wonder who you are if you answer that question. Instead of block and battle, deflect and settle. That’s better anonymity.
- Waterluvian 4y agoThe entire post is about making up a deceptive human username and AI generated human photo. What I'm talking about is making a name like rco8786 and using the avatar of whatever... a delicious ham sandwich. There is nothing novel about making up an avatar. The point of the article is "trick people by making it a believable one so they'll think that's you, and not just an avatar." Ie. there's an incredibly important social signal in having a name that's obviously not your actual name.
- SpeedilyDamage 4y agoHe isn’t saying you can’t do that, he’s saying if you do, people will wonder, which is risky. If you give them answers, even false ones, they’re less likely to wonder. It’s just tapping into the natural human curiosity, and you want to avoid that kind of attention to maximize your chance of staying anonymous.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jimkleiber 4y agomakes me think of disinformation and differential privacy: too hard to hide the truth so fill the space with lies so it takes too many resources to find the truth.
- jabroni_salad 4y agoMy strategy for this is actually to use other people's names. You can try to dig in but if you try to look me up on any other website you're gonna be playing the wrong game.
- jimkleiber 4y agoAh, yes, I forgot about identity theft
- PragmaticPulp 4y agoOne very important thing to keep in mind: If you generate a fake persona and present it as entirely real, you are being dishonest. This may not matter for inconsequential things like the pen name for your SubStack or something. However, it definitely matters if you plan to engage in anything serious or do any business under that persona. If you run into situations where you're forced to switch to your real identity (e.g. employment relationship, legal matters, or even an accidental leak) then you could lose a lot of credibility. People will naturally wonder if you were trying to hide something from them, regardless of your initial intentions.
- rodolphoarruda 4y agoThat is a good approach. My persona is going to turn five years old now, but it looks much older. In fact, my persona looks older by design, which reduces the need for profile maintenance but, in turn, is often targeted for age prejudice. I'm called "old fart" many times a week, and it kinda sucks.
- sovietswag 4y agoCool... this post reminds me of Fravia's "enemy tracking" essay from his pages of reverse engineering: https://www.darkridge.com/~jpr5/mirror/fravia.org/enemy.htm https://www.darkridge.com/~jpr5/mirror/fravia.org/enemy.htm. If you've never browsed this site, prepare to enter the mother lode of rabbit holes...
- EamonnMR 4y agoAww hell yes, copyright 1999 and HTML to match!
- userbinator 4y agoAlso the identity of Fravia himself.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI don't really bother hiding anything. Anyone who wishes me harm, can figure out who I am, fairly easily. I own a home, and I'm not sure if people know how much that exposes folks. I want people to know who I am. I don't think that I have much bad about me (although a number of folks think I'm a stuffy old boomer -they're probably right). It also helps me to behave better. I was not always a stuffy old boomer, and I behaved ... not like an adult ... on the Internet. I'm big on Responsibility and Accountability. I'd like to see more of it in others (but am frequently disappointed). I find that it's best for me to act like I'd like others to act; whether or not they do, is not my business. I was told "We teach people how to treat us."
- boring_twenties 4y ago> I own a home, and I'm not sure if people know how much that exposes folks. OT but even more maddeningly, only those of us not rich enough to own our homes outright are subject to this stupidity. If you don't need a mortgage, you can just buy your home under an LLC or other entity. If you do, this becomes difficult or maybe impossible.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoWell, around here, the tax rolls are public. That's how I find out who owns the crack house down the block, etc. > difficult or maybe impossible. For now. There's a lot of movement to expose the Principals of LLCs. Too many bad actors hiding behind them. This is why we can't have nice things.
- boring_twenties 4y agoFinding the name of the owner of a given address is one thing, but at least in my current and previous city, you can get the address (as well as other details) from just the first few letters of the owner's name. Anyone in the world can do this, anonymously, using the county records website.
- vmoore 4y ago> Am I talking with someone from Australia? Philippines? Brazil? Are they 20 or 60? Male or female Well due to how easy it is to create a fake identity on social media, knowing who someone /really/ is, is the real quest. I've experimented with creating completely false identities on social media, and populated the profiles with plausible information. I went the extra mile and created fake domain names, under my alias, fake AI created profile pictures, fake family members, even fake boyfriends. I avoided anything that could be unraveled like saying I work at such and such a company, when there is no employee records under my name at that company (Fake LinkedIN profiles are a hard problem).
- lormayna 4y agoCatfishers are thanking the author for the great suggestions!
- xivzgrev 4y agoPst, “Derek silvers” - sounds exactly like a fake but believable name
- throwaway4837 4y agoI had an idea a few years ago around anonymity, but now it seems even more possible with things like billion parameter LLMs. A service where you enter text that you want to post on Reddit/Twitter/etc. but you instead give it to your locally-running model, which is trained to output the text with the following transformations: 1. Writing style change 2. Degree of extra/reduced fluff 3. Degree of typos 4. Typing style change (e.g. using semicolons a lot, misusing commas consistently, conventions like S.O.S vs. SOS) All in an effort to further anonymize your text. The idea is that people have different, consistent grammatical habits and mistakes, writing, concision, etc. You create a "profile" for each identity you want, usually one per account. Another interesting concept to explore is platform style. Have you ever noticed that everyone on Reddit sort of sounds the same? People on HN sort of sound the same. I think there's an emergent platform-based profile that top comments hover around, because adhering to this style is more likely to get upvotes. The hive mind is real!
- warner25 4y agoI just want to say that this is a really interesting comment and set of ideas. I'm a PhD student in the area of privacy and anonymity, so I think about this stuff a lot. To your point about the emergent style of Reddit and HN comments, developed through the timely feedback of upvotes, I've often wondered how tools like suggested or predictive text are changing writing styles; like when I'm tapping out a quick email or text message on my Android phone and the keyboard suggests the next word that I probably wouldn't have come up with on my own, but it sounds good enough or better so I accept it. I thought the analysis that people have done on the writing style of Satoshi Nakamoto was the most persuasive evidence of his real identity, and I think you're correct that someone could now mask or morph their writing style in a very convincing way with these tools.
- throwaway4837 4y agoIncidentally, I first learned about Stylometry when reading about people using it to decipher the identity of Satoshi Nakamoto, so I'm happy you brought it up. I had my suspicions that bot farms for Reddit (even before 2019) were doing something similar to this to generate massive amounts of fake account activity to make subreddits appear popular. Now it seems like a piece of cake to do this with things like GPT-3.
- rspeele 4y agoArt Vandelay, importer/exporter.
- mxuribe 4y agoThat's funny, we have the same name! I must be the next Art Vandelay in the phonebook, right under you...But i'm an architect! :-)
- wmeredith 4y agoThis is one of my favorite features of 1Password (no affiliation, but I've used them for 10+ years and am a fan). They have an identity section that you can use to store all kinds of personas securely and even use the information to autocomplete forms. With the ability to add custom fields, you can easily store more than just the standard metadata like name, dob, etc.
- hnthrowaway0315 4y agoI guess it's useful to drive away curiosity from laymen but how does it stop corporate knowing me by crosschecking multiple docs? For example the banks for sure need my real name and id and phone number, all other services need those too.
- O__________O 4y agoThere are ways around this, but requires time, effort, and resources to do so.
- prepend 4y agoThis reminds me of Taleb’s story about how he says he’s a limo driver at cocktail parties. He chose this to be boring but plausible and move the conversation on. To me it seems like if you dodge the topic of employment some people will get curious and dig in. If you say what you do, they might be curious and nothing is more boring to me than talking about my job to “normies.” I think there’s a concept of digitally hiding through being normal. Evading Google leaves a black hole around your activity. Making a digital “Bob” who just does boring, normal stuff creates an ad profile that no one cares about.
- patientplatypus 4y ago[dead]
- didgetmaster 4y agoI feel so much more comfortable when someone cold calls me with a thick Indian accent and tells me his name is John (or Mike) before trying to sell me an extended car warranty or life insurance!
- sircastor 4y agoIn one of his novels Cory Doctorow talks about his bad guys doing astroturfing with persona management software to help them track who said what to whom. As the advertising and tracking arms race escalates, I wonder if there’s a burgeoning industry for personal persona management. So you can isolate your private life from your public life/lives.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoPfff... people have been doing this online forever, especially furries. Most people don't know who Kayodé Lycaon is. I'm quite literally a (painted) dog on the internet.
- some_furry 4y ago> Most people don't know who Kayodé Lycaon is. I do: A good boy uwu
- somecompanyguy 4y agobeen explaining this security policy of mine to people for years in different words. when people think they have answers, they stop looking. this is why when you look up my dox or grep for my passwords, its not hard to find my fake social security number, address and password in the usual place. in the future i want to build this into a server. What kind of server are you? Oh, I'm IIS running ASP (not rlly). send your ops down rabbit holes to nowhere instead of depriving them of the feedback they rely on. i love it.
- userbinator 4y agoI was reminded of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8336036 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8336036 which was in the pre-AI era.
- Animats 4y agoThe CIA's retired head of disguise pointed out, in commenting on a movie, that you can't really have a drawer full of fake personas (the intel community calls them "legends") ready for use. Good personas are high-maintenance. They have to have some reality behind them - mail drops, email accounts, phone numbers, social media presences, even physical offices. Those take time, money, and ongoing attention. You can't just create them and box them up for future use.
- O__________O 4y agoAgree. Unlike most people that lie in a one off situation knowing it wouldn’t come up again, if you’re lying about who you are, it lives on forever. All those little things add up and if you’re living out multiple identities, it’s hard to keep them compartmentalized. Even worse, much like actors that go too far with method acting, there is always risk you will buy into the lies and believe that’s really who you are.
- waboremo 4y agoThe compartmentalized problem is serious, it's not easy and therefore personas should be sparingly used. You have to increase the points of trust to create any sort of sustainable persona handling system. These points themselves becoming stress inducers! When it comes to believing your own lies, one way to prevent that is to take persona creation seriously as if you are really preparing for a role or writing this character. Method actors have a bunch of external factors encouraging them to stop that persona, but for the rest of us we really don't so we have to create those factors. Whether this is a dedicated device with dedicated software, or physical cues to remind us who we're being. Youtubers are a great digital example of persona creation not being taken seriously. So many "jerk" characters wind up being really abusive people who just used that character as an excuse. Unfortunately, they're also a good example of how being haphazard with persona creation can wind up leading people to desperately link pieces of yourself to find the "real you" and reveal all that private information.
- langsoul-com 4y agoI wonder if there's a service for online persons with other online persona friends. With AI generation, it wouldn't be impossible maintain fake networks then insert someone new in. It just has to seem plausible enough.
- MOARDONGZPLZ 4y agoThis is good advice that does feel borderline unethical. I’ve found that people don’t have to be defined by their actual names though, they can be defined by activities or what they enjoy or want. I personally have leaned into the latter framework.
- dailyplanet 4y agoThis works, as long as you don't have to paypal people. Is there a way to make paypal transactions anonymous to the other party?
- ahoya 4y agoThe only reliable use case of crypto
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kaashmonee 4y agoThis is so based. Now I don't know anything anymore is the author Derek Sivers from California who now lives in New Zealand even real. Is anything on his about page even true? How are we supposed to trust it? Then again, it doesn't matter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jasonjmcghee 4y agoDerek Sivers- rare, but believable.
- mxuribe 4y ago> ...Instead of block and battle, deflect and settle. I love that appraoch!
- jimbobimbo 4y agoI'm surprised to see commenters comparing use of made up personas to lying. There're communities that create/change their personas to match how they perceive themselves, encourage their members to experiment with presented identities, and expect the society to respect and accept presented personas without questioning. I'm totally OK with that. How is this different from presenting oneself as an alter-ego though?
- giaour 4y ago"Tell white lies to avoid awkward conversations" is perhaps not the revelation the author thought it might be.
- trinsic2 4y agoI like what this guy has to say and I like that he is centered on helping people. His writing reflects that. I have one of his blog posts on my wall "How to thrive in a unknowable future" and when this article came through Hacker News I immediately identified the name. If the original poster wants to chime in how he found this writer that would be of interest to me. Thanks for this post. Posts like this make the world a better place to live in.
- orangeyouglad 4y agoDerek's father is a wealthy property developer from Portland, and I'm sure that wealth came in real handy when CDBaby was in its growth phase. But Derek doesn't document that in CDBaby's history because I guess it doesn't fit with his "persona".
- nobody9999 4y agoPersonally, I have no problem not being anonymous online. But I do prefer to have privacy online. Some folks conflate them, but while they are related, they are not the same thing. Sites like HN provide privacy through pseudonymity (which is, essentially, the "solution" prescribed by the author of the blog post), allowing those I interact with here to know that "I" am "Nobody9999". Unsurprisingly, that's not the name on my passport. But on HN, you can be relatively sure (assuming I'm not also operating sock-puppet accounts as well) that my thoughts, ideas and expression are from the same person. I preserve my privacy by not using my "legal" name here. The combination allows me to freely express myself without being tracked down, doxxed or otherwise abused by those who might disagree with me. As for other places on the internet, I generally don't utilize sites that require verification of my personal details (an excellent example is ChatGPT, which requires not only an account, phone number verification as well), not because I'm engaged in evil/illegal/nasty behaviors, but because my business is my business and no one else's. That's at least an attempt at preserving some semblance of privacy, but doesn't really provide anonymity. While (as others have mentioned), my electricity provider, my landlord, my ISP, my mobile device service provider and my doctor all know who I am, where I live and an astonishing amount of information about my life, for the most part that's necessary to participating economically in society. As such, especially given the lengths to which ISPs and mobile service providers go to to collect information about my activities, my privacy is significantly curtailed. That generally pisses me off, not because I really have anything to hide, but because (and I'll say it again), my business is my business and no one else's. while I do understand the blog author's point of view, rather than creating an alternative persona online, I'm just me and mostly share my thoughts pseudonymously without trying to create an alternative backstory for those pseudonymous identities. However, those who choose to use online resources that require verification of their identity, may need to take additional steps to preserve their privacy/pseudonymity. I choose not to engage in those forums and, as such, my privacy is improved a little. Is that sufficient for me? No. Unfortunately, there's a limit to what I can do while still living "on the grid." And since I have no interest in squatting in a lean-to deep in the woods, I do have to give up some privacy. I'd love to live in a world where collection of PII was the exception rather than the rule, but those my countrymen (with a very few exceptions) elect to legislate and execute such laws as are legislated don't seem to give a rat's ass about privacy, unless theirs is impacted. And more's the pity. Edit: Fixed typo.
- paulpauper 4y agoIsn't this what a pen name is?
- t0bia_s 4y agoAlso don't forget to hide whois on that created .com domain.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tqi 4y agoYou look down, they know you're lying and up, they know you don't know the truth. Don't use seven words when four will do. Don't shift your weight, look always at your mark but don't stare, be specific but not memorable, be funny but don't make him laugh. He's got to like you then forget you the moment you've left his side. And for God's sake, whatever you do, don't, under any circumstances...
- O__________O 4y agoRelated movie clip: https://youtube.com/watch?v=VTKgyZZP5KQ https://youtube.com/watch?v=VTKgyZZP5KQ
- grugq 4y agoWhat they’re talking about is called “apparent cover.” That is, a cover story which you don’t have to tell anyone, they make it up in their head from the clues you provide. For example, if you see someone at dawn on the docks with a tackle box, a fishing pole, and dressed for fishing, you don’t think “spy come to take photos of ships.” Providing a plausible identity is a good practice for hiding your identity. I wouldn’t suggest the AI face though. Firstly, it makes the face picture unique in that you can’t (currently) get other pictures of the same “person.” If you have a single picture of yourself it looks weird. Facebook without any pictures? Instagram with nothing? No other pictures of yourself, ever? Definitely weird. Better to just avoid it and use the plausible identity as a layer behind your online handle. Then use an avatar, but don’t hide your name. George Howell, aka “17forty” ‘from college, when I used to drink a lot of 40s, 17 was my personal best lol. Just dumb stuff.’
- triplesec 4y agoThis looks like what the classic russian bots do nowadays
- sacnoradhq 4y agoThat's pretty genius. I have no social media for socializing, it's purely a photo and idea box. It's now possible to: - Create a believable phony organization "Meet the leadership team" page using deep fake images and ChatGPT bios. In the near future, it will be possible to: - Generate significant history social media trail with random posts and shares of fake content of all kinds, joining groups, and participation to build up legends to be sold to customers in the future.
- rikroots 4y agoI am a real person. I have a birth certificate. My problem is that people, when they learn my name[1], don't believe I'm a real person, or they believe I'm a person hiding behind a pseudonym. I blame my parents. Examples? A dozen years ago Facebook went on a purging mission to get rid of fake accounts. I had to prove to the people behind the algorithm that I was real, and had an online presence dating back to the turn of the century. The same thing happened with Google+ (remember that?): to overcome their objections I had to supply links to real-life documents that cited my name. It was annoying at the time, but I can smile about it now. Same thing happens in real life. I've had people ask me if I changed my name by deed poll (answer: no). Some people have told me that when they heard my name they thought I must be some sort of wannabe rockstar (answer: no, but I do write poems). Sadly, a few people have confessed that they thought I was Black before they met me - I cannot even begin to understand the thought processes they used to reach that conclusion! I don't believe my name has been a barrier to my advancement in life. It does offer me some anonymity (evidence: I'm not famous) while at the same time making it very easy for people to find me via Google. [1] - Rik Roots[2] [2] - Okay, it's Richard Roots[3], but I shortened it when I was at school because people kept shortening it for me to 'Rick' and then asking me if I spelt my name with a silent 'P' [3] - Turns out that the Roots surname has a pedigree dating back to the Norman conquest of England[4]. The origins of the name come from the Old English word 'rot', which meant 'glad' or 'pleased' [4] - See https://www.houseofnames.com/roots-family-crest https://www.houseofnames.com/roots-family-crest - and yes, I was born in Kent. PS for Australians: please don't tell me the Wombat Joke. I've heard it many times.
- A6gYPfxNas 4y agothis is fucking brilliant in its simpicity
- notaigenerated 4y agoOne more use case for personas: As someone who owns a popular website, I often receive guest writing inquiries (probably for links and SEO). Most of the time it's either Indians or Eastern European guys. But for some reason they always use fake personas and names to sound/look more "western". When I asked why do they do that, the answer was "it increases the conversion rates" among "western" publishers. Who also happen to be the most valuable prospects. So, basically they exploit the conscious or subconscious xenophobic biases in people of western cultures towards people from other "foreign" cultures by creating fake personas. And it works! People are more likely to accept guest articles from someone who looks like them. PS. You would be surprised to know how many contributors at Forbes, Inc, Entrepreneur, Tech Crunch, Mashable, etc are completely fake personas.