11 ms·
The gas industry is paying Instagram influencers to gush over gas stoves (2020)
- h2odragon 4y agoSo who is paying for this week's "gas stoves should be banned" PR push, then?
- api 4y agoThe makers of high power battery stoves maybe? For those who don't know these are stoves that have on board batteries allowing them to generate, for a period of time, far more heat than an ordinary house circuit would be able to power. This replicates some of the advantages of gas. But honestly I think the ban gas stoves thing is brought to you by the same people who gave us bans on plastic straws. "Let's maximally inconvenience people for extremely tiny environmental gains while ignoring huge contributors to pollution and climate change. That way we alienate as many people as possible and drive them into the arms of the far right." See the problem is that the far right is so ridiculous and repellent that the left is having to work really hard these days to lose. They're having to push for things like banning gas stoves or the word "field" to have any chance at losing to the people who brought you Qanon and January 6th.
- fvdessen 4y agoThe reason why there’s a battle about gas stoves is that people care a lot more about the way they cook than the way they heat their house, but if they cook with gas, then they heat with gas. So if you want to push people away from gas heating towards electric heat pumps, then you need to attack gas stoves
- Philorandroid 4y agoThat would be the pragmatic solution; but in states like CA, where rolling blackouts are already commonplace to reduce the strain on the grid, the implications of mandating the use of more electricity seem dire.
- resoluteteeth 4y agoHuh? The reason people have been talking about stopping use of gas stoves is that they put out pollution inside people's homes, which is pretty separate from the overall dialogue about fossil fuels or how to heat homes.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoApproximately a year ago several jurisdictions banned gas hookups in new developments. The pushback was significant and severe, and it was all focused on how awesome gas stoves were. Now we're seeing the pushback for the pushback. fvdesson is right.
- ryukafalz 4y agoIt's both, the climate impacts are absolutely part of it too.
- ufmace 4y agoSince when is there pollution inside homes from gas stoves? How have all of the millions of gas stove users been cooking multiple meals with them on a daily basis and nobody noticed this supposed pollution?
- cinntaile 4y agohttps://oem.bmj.com/content/60/10/759 https://oem.bmj.com/content/60/10/759 There's an article from 2003 so this isn't exactly new.
- smileysteve 4y agoBecause establishing a direct link to childhood athsma takes many data points, especially with a dirty sample group, such as parents who may or may not have had athsma also caused by gas stoves.
- sokoloff 4y agoIf you want to push people away from gas heating, just tax the shit out of gas. No household uses enough gas for cooking that it would matter that much to them. (We cook a fair amount and heat domestic water with gas. In the summer, our bills are around $30/mo, including about $12 in fixed charges. Quadruple the usage charges [add a 300% tax], and if I want to cook with gas, I still will, but I sure as hell will get rid of my gas water heater and boiler.) If you roll out the tax as 25% starting in July, increasing 25% every 3 months after that until it hits 300%, people have some time to plan for it and you don't hit them this winter. Maybe you need to return 1/3 of the tax money to low-income households who are having a hard time getting their equipment upgraded in a timely fashion and 1/3 of the tax money in incentives to that same group [and landlords of affordable housing] to help them cover the capital costs. Trying to backhand it by making people "not want" gas stoves seems like a longer and less certain path than just giving people economic incentives to do the thing that you want them to do.
- ryukafalz 4y agoTwo things: - That would have an immediate financial impact on people with gas boilers in a way that banning new gas appliances does not. This kind of thing would need to be rolled out very slowly over time if you want to avoid extreme backlash. Constraints on new construction don't have the same effects. (EDIT: Ah, you edited your comment to address this one - sure, if you can reliably distribute funds for lower-income people to replace their appliances then maybe. I bet you still get a lot of backlash from people who can afford it but don't want to though. Unless it's rolled out very slowly.) - Ultimately we need to get rid of the infrastructure piping all that gas around too, as that's where a lot of the climate impacts come from. Any new gas usage at all, whether for cooking or heating, makes it harder to do that.
- sokoloff 4y agoI just installed a new gas boiler (I wanted to go electric but it was massively economically disadvantageous). That thing is probably going to run for 20 years. If you have patience to wait a handful of decades, attacking gas stoves and waiting for trickle-up in consumer preferences to happen could be a good play. If you want faster change, tax and rebate is probably a better plan. Utilities already have the means to bill and tax fuel. Most already have conservation rebate schemes in place. Many already have low-income billing plans and rate cards (probably all have multiple rate cards). I think you could reliably administer a tax, rebate, and capital credit scheme using mostly existing mechanisms.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- astura 4y ago>if they cook with gas, then they heat with gas Not true, at least not by definition. I heat with oil and cook with gas. My gas stove is fed by an outdoor propane tank that's filled once a year. When I was house hunting there were plenty of houses with gas ranges but I didn't see a single one with gas heat, that's really uncommon here.
- fatnoah 4y agoSame. My neighborhood has lots of gas stoves, but no gas service. Nearly every house has propane for cooking and oil for heating.
- yetihehe 4y ago> For those who don't know these are stoves that have on board batteries allowing them to generate, for a period of time, far more heat than an ordinary house circuit would be able to power. Depends on ordinarity of a house. My ordinary house has 3phase power and my pretty cheap induction stove outperforms all gas stoves I had. When I was living in a flat, I only had single phase power, but 4kW should still be enough for a stove. In USA you typically only have 110V (or 220v for those daring), so anything electric is straining your circuit breakers.
- XorNot 4y agoThe US has 240VAC though it's just not a common household appliance circuit. My induction cooktop (in Australia) draws 7kW and is supplied by a dedicated 20A circuit for it (because that's what you over-spec the wiring too). It was put in to replace a gas cooktop which was there when we bought the house, and vastly out-performs that unit in speed and heat output. If you converted you'd be pulling a dedicated circuit through anyway - no one's tying induction cooktops off to just whatever line you already have. The one area gas can be better is if you're doing wok cooking, but that's more to do with how wok's are shaped and heat up then any limitation on the ability to get heat into them (I've not been able to find one of the adapters which apparently exists to solve this).
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoYou can find wok ready induction cooktops in China. It’s not an adapter so much as it is a bowl shaped induction surface. Also, if you are really serious about wok cooking, you’ll go with propane rather than natural gas. https://www.amazon.com/Induction-14-inch-tempered-precision-temperature/dp/B077GL6BJY/ref=asc_df_B077GL6BJY/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=241996626851&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=6900705816115204770&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=m&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9033311&hvtargid=pla-535785773470&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/Induction-14-inch-tempered-precision-...
- kwhitefoot 4y ago> In USA you typically only have 110V Surely stoves are connected to the 220 V connection? Same for washers and dryers. 110 V in the US is one arm of a centre tapped secondary.
- cinntaile 4y agoI don't think this is similar to the plastic straws at all. The focus for banning gas stoves is on the (respiratory) health issues associated with gas cooking of the household. It is not about climate change.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoSo says the climate change institute who funded the study. The real reason seems to be elsewhere: people care about cooking with gas, but they use gas heaters if they have gas. If you can stop people from cooking with gas, you can switch entire houses to electric more quickly.
- cinntaile 4y agoSomebody else mentioned the same argument but I'm not buying it. Gas use for heating has a much bigger impact on your personal finance than just a gas stove, but you're saying gas stove cookers have an almost religious devotion to using gas because it's so much better? The problem is... If it's almost religious then rational arguments won't reach them anyway.
- rsynnott 4y agoGas stoves aren't a significant _environmental_ problem, certainly in terms of CO2 (in fact, unless your electricity is almost entirely renewable or nuclear, they're probably marginally better than electric from a CO2 perspective). There is a concern that they're a health risk, though (though the evidence that there's a large effect is somewhat weak). Personally, I like my gas stove, though I expect to have to adapt to something else in my lifetime (the big push in Ireland is towards heat pumps, and once gas heating goes it will not be economic to maintain the home gas network just for stoves).
- bryanlarsen 4y agoA CCGT is about 60% efficient, and an induction stove is about 3x as efficient as a gas stove. So cooking directly with gas uses over 50% more gas than cooking on an induction top using electricity generated from gas.
- rsynnott 4y ago> A CCGT is about 60% efficient Depends exactly where you live, but it's unlikely that all the gas generation is by CCGT; a lot of places would use far less efficient plants for peaking at least. > and an induction stove is about 3x as efficient as a gas stove Hmm, where are you getting this? From a quick look, gas stoves are about 40-50% efficient, induction about 85%. You also have to consider transmission loss, and the possible (in many places likely) presence of coal in the electricity supply. In any case this is all pretty irrelevant; stoves just aren't a big enough piece of peoples' energy consumption.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIt was a quick Google that I can't find again. Efficiency numbers vary widely, since the size of the pot makes a big difference in the efficiency of gas or conventional electricity. In one experiment, using coal fired electricity to boil a pot of water on induction released 0.29 pounds of CO2. Using natural gas to boil a pot of water released 1.16 pounds. https://zeroenergyproject.com/2016/10/24/induction-cooks-better-gas/ https://zeroenergyproject.com/2016/10/24/induction-cooks-bet... As you said, it's fairly irrelevant. The point is to reduce natural gas heating and methane leaks. Natural gas cooking is a side effect.
- fullshark 4y agohttps://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/20/1/75 https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/20/1/75 Rocky Mountain Institute - Carbon Free Buildings paid for funding of study. https://rmi.org/our-work/buildings/ https://rmi.org/our-work/buildings/
- Philorandroid 4y agoNo One Is, It's Spontaneous™
- freen 4y agoAhh yes, Big Induction. Well known astroturfers. They’ve known since 1970 that climate change due to induction stoves… wait, sorry, confused them with Exxon. Easy mistake.
- Philorandroid 4y agoBecause there's no platform or ideology on earth capable of paid advocacy besides the oil industry, and certainly no political movements ostensibly grounded in "green" advocacy.
- freen 4y agoIf you are going to claim that a position is invalid due to financial influence, you really have to do the basic math of how much profit is actually at stake on either side of the argument And weight the impact of said influence appropriately. Who has deeper pockets and more to loose if anthropogenic climate change is real and caused by co2 emissions? If you truly think it’s the folks that are cutting grant checks to climate scientists, I have a bridge to sell you.
- Philorandroid 4y agoYou're getting really possessed over things I never said.
- freen 4y agoI’m responding to an argument you dismissed with a false equivalency and in turn you now avoid addressing the point I just made. My brother in Christ, re-examine your priors.
- MrMan 4y agogas stoves should be banned
- osigurdson 4y agoBig electron no doubt. There is a cabal behind everything these days.
- Dutroli 4y ago[dead]
- glanzwulf 4y agoToday I found out I'm a paid influencer. Shame nobody told that to my bank account or my instagram followers. To me gas stoves are the best, and now that I don't have one I miss it even more.
- ceejayoz 4y ago"I'm not paid therefore no one is paid" is an odd argument.
- glanzwulf 4y agoNah, that's not what I meant. It's just that I've been seeing these posts against gas stove pots in social media, and I'm always there being all "pro gas". I guess I can now send bills to the gas industry.
- jsdalton 4y agoDo you have an induction stovetop now or a regular convection? Because in my experience induction is vastly superior to both convection and gas stoves. It provides far more and faster heat, cools nearly instantly and the nice ones at least give you flexibility where you put your pan. The downside of induction is it doesn’t work with all pot types. The big advantage gas retains is the ability to see with your eye exactly how much heat you’re producing. I do love being able to precisely tune exactly how much heat I’m cooking with. I assume this is why gas is so prevalent at restaurants. But I’ve also found that at home once I get to know an electric stove (what does level 5 do vs 6?) I’m just as capable as I am with gas. (I’m opposite of you btw. Had electric for a long time and just moved to a house with a gas stovetop.)
- fatnoah 4y agoAs a very frequent cook (with a high CFM vented range hood) I'm very excited to move to induction, but the main issues I had when checking a while ago was the lack of an ability to eyeball the level of heat and the lack of front control knobs (vs buttons or some other controls). I'm confident that I can adapt to the former and the latter seems like it's not an issue any more as induction becomes more widespread. Of course, I won't make that change until it's time to buy a new stove.
- throwaway22032 4y agoI open the window and turn on the extractor fan when I use my gas hob. It uses a fraction of the fuel that my car does. Easily less than 10%. Frying on an electric hob is hardly good for your lungs either. This is just rage porn.
- CalRobert 4y agoBut you don't operate your vehicle indoors I assume.
- shapefrog 4y agoI open the window (car) when I roll coal in my living room.
- throwaway22032 4y agoSure, I'm addressing both air quality and carbon emissions in the same comment.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> I open the window and turn on the extractor fan when I use my gas hob. Good. One of the possible interventions is to make ventillation a building code requirement.
- throwaway22032 4y agoIsn't this just a requirement for a kitchen? You cannot fry indoors without ventilation unless you enjoy choking on smoke. Neither can you boil indoors without ventilation unless you enjoy coating everything in the room with moisture. The combustion of a gas stove IME is a smaller contributor to ventilation requirements than both of the above. Maybe the moisture one is less relevant in low humidity environments like parts of California? edit: I just checked, here in the UK new kitchens require extractor fans regardless of fuel used, which makes sense to me.
- 4y ago
- mikrl 4y agoIt’s politicized too which is ridiculous. I’ve seen takes that being pro gas cookery is right-wing. Yes, it’s obvious that gas heat and cooking could cause respiratory issues due to combustion. As a gourmand though, cooking on a gas range is the best experience wrt temp control and convenience. I prefer an electric oven, and the heating system I’m impartial to, though radiant hot water is what I fondly remember from youth.
- rs999gti 4y agoAre any right wing EU, US, or CA parties supporting the gas stove ban or is just lefties and greenies doing it?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThat's not the point - only a few loonies on the left are pushing it. Most of the left and the right are opposed. That makes it not a left/right issue.
- rs999gti 4y agoNo, I'm asking has any right leaning party or politician came out in the media and said yes we should ban gas stoves? I've only seen the tweet from Biden appointed Trumka - https://mobile.twitter.com/TrumkaCPSC/status/1612553459462721536 https://mobile.twitter.com/TrumkaCPSC/status/161255345946272...
- shapefrog 4y agoFossil fuel gas hobs and boilers BANNED in all new-build homes from 2025. UK Government legislation ... from a right wing government.
- Lutger 4y agoYes. This doesn't mean gas stoves are banned (existing ones are not outlawed). In fact its not about stoves at all. It means some countries are doing at least something to address climate change. Eventually we all need to move away from gas, this is about that. Not banning gas stoves overnight, but gradually banning all fossil fuels, which you can't do if everybody is still cooking on gas. You need to gradually reduce your dependency on it.
- alamortsubite 4y agoThe "Rappin' with Gas!" video is featured in this Climate Town at about the 2:45 mark: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hX2aZUav-54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hX2aZUav-54
- xiphias2 4y agoGreat, it explains the reason quite well: if somebody installs gas ovens, they probably get gas heating and water boiler as well at the same time (which is where the real money is at)
- dsr_ 4y agoInterestingly, I have a gas hookup from the street that is not large enough for heating, only large enough to run an oven.
- rolenthedeep 4y agoI can't help but think this gas stove thing is a distraction being propped up by the government, but I can't figure out what they're trying to distract from
- MrMan 4y agoa 100 IQ statement
- 082349872349872 4y agothree (by no means exhaustive) possibilities: (a) https://www.theonion.com/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-nation-where-this-r-1848971668 https://www.theonion.com/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-na... et.al.? (b) any suggestion that the US is neither colour-blind nor all middle-class? (c) the quaint custom of an electoral college?
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoNo shit they're paying for some marketing. IDK who was expecting otherwise. They're not stupid. They're not so apathetic they're just gonna roll over and take it. Sure most of the manufacturers are also in the electric stove business but they've got huge capital investments in manufacturing they don't want to lose so when the executive announces out of the blue they're considering a ban of course they open the marketing floodgates in response.
- _djo_ 4y agoMarketing is one thing, astroturfing is another. Companies are free to do it, of course, but others are also free to call it out as the deceptive practice it is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hospadar 4y agoInduction maaaan! Switched from gas to induction and love it. I miss my stove every time i have to cook elsewhere. Mine is pretty much the cheapest induction range on the market (and i bought it used). Heats up way faster than gas (WAY FASTER, will get cast iron glowing if i leave an empty cast iron on the stove for a while at the highest setting), low/medium control is excellent and precise, and i really appreciate the lack of waste heat (pot handles don't overheat, kitchen doesn't quickly heat up from cooking - small kitchen). The fact that the stove is more expensive is really the only downside. Not being able to use fabulous copper pans seems like the only meaningful downside but I'm not rich enough for that anyways.
- _puk 4y agoThe Induction Industry Is Paying HN Influencers to Gush over Induction Stoves (2023) Tongue in cheek, but nowadays it's so hard to establish what is a genuine appraisal and what isn't..
- kelipso 4y agoYeah really, that's why the smart thing to do is to attack the other side first haha. Also the anti gas stove thing feels like the most blatantly astroturfed indoctrination project in quite a while.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoStill can't understand the OUTRAGE. And I'm no-ones shill. Just happy to have them, because once you've tried them(good ones, with appropriate electrical installation) you're hooked, and don't want to go back, ever. Maybe it's a cultural thing, Wild West, Cowboys, camp fire, which turned into phrases like 'Now you are cooking with gas!'. From the outside it just looks like slum, favela, ghetto-style, third-world. Uncivilized. Like much of your electrical installations, no matter if on the in- or outside :-)
- pandaman 4y ago
- jbotdev 4y agoForget climate and respiratory issues, I’ve gone induction out of pure convenience and don’t miss gas at all. My induction cook top heats up faster, has more precise control, retains less heat on the “burner”, and is way easier to clean. The only downsides I’ve found are you can’t char things on a flame, or use copper pots. It seems like people keep comparing gas to “regular” electric stoves, which are definitely inferior in many ways. The biggest issue is they’re very inefficient, and take forever to heat anything.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> The only downsides I’ve found are you can’t char things on a flame... Grab one of these: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004FPZACE https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004FPZACE They're great for creme brulee, among other things.
- paulette449 4y agoArticle is from June 2020. I know why it is re-surfacing now, but I can't imagine why it was a big deal when originally published. So-called influencers earn their income from paid sponsorships from many industries, whether they admit to it or not.
- bob1029 4y agoThe respiratory argument I really don't understand with specific regard to gas vs electric cooking. I don't care if my range is powered by alien technology that magically sequesters carbon somewhere else - When you heat something above a certain temperature, you are producing all kinds of chemical compounds that are not going to be good for you. It doesn't really matter how the mass was brought to that temperature. The contribution of a gas range to indoor air quality is absolutely negligible compared to what comes out of a deep fryer or frying pan once you hit 400F+. If the primary concern is everyone's health & safety, we should mandate high CFM extraction hoods be installed above every range and run public information campaigns to encourage their use.
- bombcar 4y agoI suspect that of measuring “particulates in the air” pressure cookers and microwaves easily win.
- osigurdson 4y agoA microwave and pressure cooker only future is the definition of dystopia.
- bedbot 4y agoI don't know the numbers, but the premise here is not (a) that gas is bad or that (b) cooking releases particulate, but rather that gas stoves are actually constantly leaking very small amounts of particulate that in aggregate can cause harm along the same lines of other sources of PM2.5 pollution.
- ectopod 4y agoGas stoves might be constantly leaking, but they only produce particulates when they are alight. Assuming you don't have an ancient appliance with a pilot light.
- stephen_g 4y agoI don’t think that’s true. The worry is the NOx emissions (that is a combustion product from the foams, not from cooking), the amount being produced by gas stoves which was previously under-appreciated until recently. Studies I’ve seen indicate that most domestic rangehoods (apart from the very high end ones) are not sufficient to effectively remove these gas combustion products.
- 0xblood 4y agoLooks like somebody is _really_ running a campaign against gas. It's fine if you like induction, like it's fine if you like Apple products. Just leave me alone about it, will you?
- smileysteve 4y agoIt might be more akin to smoking; cooking with gas at home, buy a rider to insur your health insurance and that of your kids for respiratory disorders.
- hermannj314 4y agoWho is pushing to ban gas stoves? First it was adding catalytic converters in cars, then regulating tobacco, banning asbestos, removing contaminants from drinking water. It never stops. This is nothing more than one more rung in a decades long campaign of using the democratic process to hold companies accountable for pollutants and slowly improve the health and well-being of millions of Americans. Sure, air is cleaner and these interventions have all been amazingly effective, but qui bono? Who are these people? What do they have to gain from all these laws? I'm worried my grandchildren are going to have to grow up in a healthy, well regulated world where when they buy products in stores they don't have to worry about how it will impact their health or the health of their community. Being American means slowly killing yourself and your neighbors for the greater GDP. I don't want us to lose that.
- treeman79 4y agoThe president is pushing this
- nickthegreek 4y agoNo he isnt.
- WithinReason 4y agoI often see people writing responses without even reading the post they are responding to. Why not read more than the 1st sentence?
- ceejayoz 4y agoNo; one of five CPSC commissioners gave an interview in which he indicated they're thinking about potentially doing something about the impact of gas stoves on interior air quality, in which he noted (generally) that the CPSC has the authority to ban products that can't be "made safe". There's zero indication gas stoves can't be "made safe".
- ryandvm 4y ago[flagged]
- guilhas 4y agoPeople could just use a mask around the stove
- nightski 4y agoThe vast majority of the electricity in our state comes from coal plants. I am all for slowly switching to electric in hopes of greener sources in the future, but if we all do it right now it would arguably be worse for the environment.
- juancn 4y agoIf you ever cooked both on gas an electric, electric is workable, but gas is much more controllable in terms of temperature transfer. Specially when there's no direct contact between the pan and stove. It also produces way more heat faster if you need to. My experience with electric stoves is that you have to coax them into cooking things right. Most of the particulate problems could probably be solved with better forced ventilation and air filters. For example, where I live, commercial kitchens have an electric gas valve connected to the forced extraction systems of the kitchen, so you cannot turn on the stove unless the ventilation is on.
- eddyg 4y agoIt's important to note that "electric" is not "induction" (which is also "electric"). Induction provides many of the benefits of gas.
- fatnoah 4y agoAs someone that has a stove that uses propane as a source, I'm curious to see any information specifically about that. My 30 minutes of Googling seems to find things that are focused on natural gas and make no mention of propane. The only real info I can find is that propane has approximately double the BTU per unit of volume, and is (obviously) not primarily methane.
- notyourav 4y agoI wanted to replace my old gas range with a good induction cooktop. Everyone told me that would reduce my homes value, electric ranges are a step back. I think problem is the induction ranges aren’t properly marketed. They have an image problem not a regulatory one.