14 ms·
Why was Roman concrete so durable?
- legitster 4y agoChemistry might be important, but we don't necessarily need that deep of an analysis. Romans didn't mind over-engineering with massive, inefficient structures. They didn't worry about complex/thin shapes, or any tensile elements. No rebar, no "piping" cement, etc. And they could put up with extremely long cure times. The end result is very, very dense concrete. We could probably recreate the durability of their concrete if we were actually willing to put up with the compromises they represent. https://practical.engineering/blog/2019/3/9/was-roman-concrete-better https://practical.engineering/blog/2019/3/9/was-roman-concre...
- titzer 4y ago[flagged]
- DenisM 4y agoPlease don’t do this, it’s against the rules: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that".
- starfallg 4y agoIn this case, the original poster went on a complete tangent without addressing the topic of the article at all. So my vote is for the person who pointed this out as he's most likely right in his deduction.
- ghshephard 4y agoI don't think there is any requirement to read an article - that's implicit in the guideline that you don't comment on whether a poster read the original article. I would say 75-80% of the time I read the comments first, and probably close to 25% of the time I never read the posted article. Also - I found that comment regarding modern concrete, and the pointer to PracticalEngineering to be, by far, the most interesting comment so far - significant contribution. (And yes, I did read both in their entirety) Perhaps a better response might have been, "The PracticalEngineering article is missing the key detail regarding the exothermic hot baking associated with using quicklime instead of, or in addition to, the slaked lime, and the self-healing properties associated with that. Though the lack of corrosive iron, long curing times, and large structures might be more important - and its unfortunate the original article doesn't mention those as an important detail to at least demonstrate the authors were aware of this."
- starfallg 4y agoThat link is 'old news'. What the poster of that link effectively said is that I know all there is about this topic, then post an 'interesting' link as his source, without realising that the current topic is new development not covered by it.
- bob29 4y agoPlease don’t do this it’s also against the rules: Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead. Live by the sword die by the sword
- Zircom 4y ago[flagged]
- samstave 4y ago100% disagree with flagging. Have the knowledge balls to respectfully disagree. flagging just looks like throwing rocks as opposed knowingly refuting something. its also why I am very conservative upvoting anything, anywhere, any site.
- maximus-decimus 4y agoBut... you also just did it
- mortehu 4y agoI think we can make an exception when someone essentially says "we don't need this article" without addressing its contents.
- samstave 4y agoI dont know if in a minority ; I always read the comments on a post before I read the article... I do this here and on reddit as well... I still read the articles, but I like to grab the gist from comments first, it allows me to be able to read the article faster as I can skim and search at the same time.
- teilo 4y agoWe do need a deep analysis. Roman concrete is self-healing, and this article explains why. And the reason is exactly the opposite of the one you postulate.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoSounds like the chemistry is important > Previously disregarded as merely evidence of sloppy mixing practices, or poor-quality raw materials, the new study suggests that these tiny lime clasts gave the concrete a previously unrecognized self-healing capability. > As soon as tiny cracks start to form within the concrete, they can preferentially travel through the high-surface-area lime clasts. This material can then react with water, creating a calcium-saturated solution, which can recrystallize as calcium carbonate and quickly fill the crack, or react with pozzolanic materials to further strengthen the composite material.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trynewideas 4y agohttps://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.add1602 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.add1602 > ... evidence that the Romans employed hot mixing, using quicklime in conjunction with, or instead of, slaked lime, to create an environment where high surface area aggregate-scale lime clasts are retained within the mortar matrix. Inspired by these findings, we propose that these macroscopic inclusions might serve as critical sources of reactive calcium for long-term pore and crack-filling or post-pozzolanic reactivity within the cementitious constructs. The subsequent development and testing of modern lime clast–containing cementitious mixtures demonstrate their self-healing potential ... Or, this study finds that Roman concrete regenerated using water-reactive calcium carbonate introduced through hot mixing–transformed lime clasts. This included observations of Roman concrete used in structures that weren't characteristically massive or inefficient, and reproducible in reformulated modern concrete. > In the present study, we demonstrate the calcium enrichment of matrix phases adjacent to the lime clasts, supporting the hypothesis that the lime clasts are a source of calcium for leaching and recrystallization within the pore space of the mortars. Microcrack filling by calcite has been recently observed in ancient Roman mortars from the tomb of Caecilia Metella (29), and the self-healing tests carried out on our modern samples described in the present study further support this hypothesis.
- marcosdumay 4y agoInterestingly, the article founds out that their concrete cured quickly. Anyway, no, our usual concrete completely breaks down in a few centuries. No matter how it's structured, it does not match the durability of that concrete without ongoing maintenance.
- samstave 4y ago>>A few centuries Sounds good to me? Although, many centuries old sound structures also sounds better to me...
- User23 4y agoLike the Pantheon[1]? It's still got the world's largest unreinforced concrete dome and it's in active use as a church not to mention major tourist attraction. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheon,_Rome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheon,_Rome
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gerdesj 4y ago"Chemistry might be important" Conc is nearly all about chemistry. You mention curing rather than drying so you surely have some idea about what is going on. The Romans did not have electron microscopes so could not watch the way the matrix develops around the aggregate etc etc from the get go. To be fair, I fried my first sample in the beam at college by over focussing. They didn't use rebar because they generally built in compression - arches etc. Rebar and pre-stressing enables members to cope much better under tension. A PS beam or slab is a modern marvel and even protects the steel from fire - bonus. Cure times: weather/environment. In hot climes you need to stop the water buggering off the surface and leaving cracked and spalling surfaces before it even cures. It may also over heat (exothermic reaction). Cold - slower curing, too cold - no cure and frozen water (total disaster). Underwater - watch your fines wandering off and going for a smoke behind a reef and your structure collapsing, unless you keep them in place. Concrete curing is not like smoking a joint of meat! A quick or slow cure may be indicated depending on conditions. We have admixtures and all sorts to fiddle with parameters. Then you have things like grading and composing your agg. and other exciting stuff. I could go on at some length - it is really, really complicated. Roman engineers managed to invent an ancient wonder of chemistry and physics that was concrete. Their approach to its use and improvements was obviously rather better than what passed for science and medicine at the time! They do seem to have experimented and gone with what worked best but it was never deliberately developed from first principles. The self healing thing was probably a happy accident. A Roman engineer had some rather different design constraints than a modern Civil. For starters, failure could quite legitimately be blamed on the god's displeasure. "When that bridge was commissioned, we made all the correct sacrifices and anyway, you are holding it wrong, I mean walking on it incorrectly". (sp)
- UncleEntity 4y ago> Roman engineers managed to invent an ancient wonder of chemistry and physics that was concrete. Technically, the ancient Egyptians used concrete in construction long before the Roman engineers were a thing. The difference is they used it for mundane things like wine cellars while the Romans integrated it into their whole architecture system. Once in a while that art history degree comes in handy…
- 4y ago
- knodi123 4y ago"Anyone can create a bridge that will hold up under a maximum load. It takes a real engineer to create a bridge that barely holds up under a maximum load."
- sph 4y agoIt takes an accountant with a tight budget, you mean. Engineers will tend to make the most durable thing ever, if given enough time and money.
- User23 4y agoYeah, I can't imagine a municipality letting their concrete roads cure for a couple years before letting cars on them.
- interfixus 4y ago> massive, inefficient structures How does a building, an aqueduct, or a bridge still in use after 2000 years manage to be inefficient?
- egberts1 4y agoNow onward to replacing the roads and bridges on freeways and highways with these new concrete.
- insane_dreamer 4y agocobblestones for the roads
- jcadam 4y agoThat is... not a smooth ride.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cameronh90 4y agoSounds like a good way to make people slow down.
- naniwaduni 4y agoThe problem with making people slow down is that it slows people down.
- r00fus 4y agoSometimes that's what's needed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess%27s_paradox
- naniwaduni 4y agoBut usually, it slows people down. > In 2012, Paul Lecroart, of the institute of planning and development of the Île-de-France, wrote that "Despite initial fears, the removal of main roads does not cause deterioration of traffic conditions beyond the starting adjustments. The traffic transfer are limited and below expectations".[4] He also notes that some private vehicle trips (and related economic activity) are not transferred to public transport and simply disappear ("evaporate").[4] > The same phenomenon was also observed when road closing was not part of an urban project but the consequence of an accident. In 2012 in Rouen, a bridge was destroyed by fire. Over the next two years, other bridges were used more, but the total number of cars crossing bridges was reduced.[4] It seems a lot like the real-world examples of the phenomenon look like close cousins of "if you remove the smallest values in a set, the average goes up".
- naikrovek 4y agothe article talks about evidence which has always been present in evaluations of Roman concrete which was "disregarded as merely evidence of sloppy mixing practices, or poor-quality raw materials," and this kind of thing REALLY infuriates me, as a layman. if you don't know how to make Roman concrete, don't assume anything about what you see in Roman concrete while you're trying to figure out how it was made. The modern-day belief that we are superior to humans thousands of years ago is just an absolutely insane idea, to me. we are more technologically advanced because we have more shoulders of giants to stand on, and we are NOT smarter or more clever than humans of 5000-10000 years ago. we just aren't. as soon as you believe that we are superior to our ancestors, you dismiss the evidence you are looking for as "sloppy mixing practices, or poor-quality raw materials" and you prove modern-day humans as inferior, or at least you prove your own efforts as careless and incomplete. leave no stone unturned when you are trying to understand something you do not understand; your lack of understanding could be due to your false assumptions.
- sogen 4y agoAn extremely good example of Chesterton’s fence?
- sarchertech 4y agoThat depends on the what you mean by smarter. At least some component of what we consider intelligence is cultural. Just one example is that the ability to write/draw allows you to solve problems that are impossible without it.
- HPsquared 4y agoBeing literate definitely means some faculties get less practice. Practically nobody today can recite epic poetry like the Odyssey, for example. That lack of rote memorization skill may have unexpected side-effects. https://daily.jstor.org/how-do-we-know-that-epic-poems-were-recited-from-memory/ https://daily.jstor.org/how-do-we-know-that-epic-poems-were-...
- samstave 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adrian_b 4y agoThe research paper: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.add1602 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.add1602
- adolph 4y agoOne method to reduce cement’s carbon footprint (which accounts for up to 8% of total global greenhouse gas emissions), is to improve the longevity of concrete through the incorporation of self-healing functionalities. The resulting extended use life, combined with a reduction in the need for extensive repair, could thus reduce the environmental impact and improve the economic life cycle of modern cementitious constructs. I wonder: How much of an environmental impact this would make given the number of structures that are not useful before the concrete requires repair? How much of Roman concrete's reputation for durability comes from survivorship bias--the structures that lasted were just lucky?
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoSurvivor bias comes up every time this topic is mentioned, but it really has less explanatory power than most people think. If you meet a man born in 1932 who is still running marathons and doesn't need glasses, it's probably luck, although he might have some valuable diet tips to share. If you meet a man born in 1732 running the same marathon, it's time to rule out luck, and start collecting blood samples because he might actually be some kind of vampire. Furthermore, the "survivor bias" idea, as an attempt to explain the longevity of Roman concrete as a building material, implies that the buildings that survived were stronger than the ones that did not, so we're just seeing the upper end of structural strength. But that's not even necessarily the case. Many more were lost because they were deliberately demolished for other reasons (honoring the wrong gods, etc). And it's not like these buildings only survived in ideal environments for preservation; as the article mentions, they have survived in many different climates across a vast empire, standing in seawater, through earthquakes, and so on.
- moloch-hai 4y agoRight. Romans experimented with the formula for concrete for centuries, and learned a lot about how centuries-old concrete structures deteriorated. They didn't have modern chemistry, but they had observational skills and were serious about their work. It would not be surprising to find that most structures weren't built to last any longer than ours, but that some were meant for the ages. An important difference today is we don't build the latter sort, excepting maybe the Sydney Opera House. Many people act personally offended that it doesn't have steel inside.
- asah 4y agovery exciting! and I imagine there will be follow-on work delivering even greater results. There's also an interesting finance project here, to integrate the impact of this material into projects budgets, so that designers and investors can justify this material over cheaper alternatives. In particular, different construction projects have very different expected lifespans.
- HPsquared 4y agoI wonder if it could have relevance for nuclear waste installations.
- canadianfella 4y ago[dead]
- colechristensen 4y agoTl;dr: Old “riddle solved”: Romans used volcanic ash as an ingredient New “riddle solved”: the good stuff also includes tiny lumps of calcium carbonate that self heal cracks
- georgyo 4y ago> the good stuff also includes tiny lumps of calcium carbonate that self heal cracks According the article, they didn't use calcium carbonate directly. They use quicklime (Calcium oxide) which must be mixed in at very hot temperatures. When a crack forms, that stuff melts and forms calcium carbonate that seals the crack.
- taetaset 4y ago> which must be mixed in at very hot temperatures It gets hot when you mix it.
- georgyo 4y agoIt's a little unclear to me about that, it is what I thought at first. But it appears that quicklime is not stable at ambient temperatures and recombines with CO2 to make Calcium Carbonate; which is how the self healing works.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- buttofthejoke 4y ago[flagged]
- johnohara 4y agoDisappointed that this article didn't at least give a "tip of the hat" to the dogged research done by Dr. Marie Jackson, et.al., over her career at multiple universities. Here is an excellent read on this subject from 2013: https://cedar.wwu.edu/geology_facpubs/75/ https://cedar.wwu.edu/geology_facpubs/75/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- urthor 4y agoSays a lot doesn't it. Marie Jackson makes it into the citations twelve times. Otherwise not mentioned by name. Academia: You thought capitalists were greedy for mere money? Come meet academics.
- next_xibalba 4y agoAgreed. But is this not an example of a fundamental attribution error? The structure and incentives of academia creates all the credit grabbing and back stabbing (IMO). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error
- trynewideas 4y agoThe lead author of this study, Linda M. Seymour, worked with Jackson on reference 29, on the mortar of the Tomb of Caecilia Metella, which is referenced repeatedly and the samples from which form a significant part of the hypothesis. That study: https://ceramics.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jace.18133 https://ceramics.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jace.18... Story on that study: https://als.lbl.gov/unexpected-transformations-reinforce-roman-architectural-concrete/ https://als.lbl.gov/unexpected-transformations-reinforce-rom... Jackson is quoted, if briefly, by Science's article on the new paper. https://www.science.org/content/article/scientists-may-have-found-magic-ingredient-behind-ancient-romes-self-healing-concrete https://www.science.org/content/article/scientists-may-have-... Jackson's work is focused on pyroclastic volcanism. Seymour's work has focused on Roman water infrastructure. Jackson works for the University of Utah, Seymour works for MIT. The linked source is MIT's PR department.
- w1nst0nsm1th 4y agoDawn, I just wanted to patent it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nimbius 4y agoon the other end of the spectrum, did you know concrete can be used to demolish concrete? dexpan is a special demolition concrete mix that, when poured into holes, expands at 18kpsi. it gets used when jackhammers and explosives cant be used, for example, in refineries and explosive atmospheres.
- hinkley 4y agoPresumably dexpan has lower tensile strength so it can be disposed of easily? Or is the piece excavated and hauled away intact?
- barathr 4y agoIt expands in the holes you make in the to-be-destroyed concrete, cracking it. You can haul it off in chunks at that point.
- hinkley 4y agoThe destroyed concrete, yes, but what about the dexpan? <Peregrine Took>
- Dylan16807 4y agoThe dexpan never existed as big pieces.
- masklinn 4y agoThe dexpan is not a huge concrete structure, it's just a cylinder the size of the hole it was poured in.
- hinkley 4y agoOh, I see, just a bore hole and hydraulic concrete. Sort of like the metal shims you see used in pre-industrial stoneworking. I was picturing pouring it into a void for some reason.
- dang 4y agoRelated: Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29366911 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29366911 - Nov 2021 (67 comments) 2,050-year-old Roman tomb offers insights on ancient concrete resilience - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28833525 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28833525 - Oct 2021 (101 comments) Why Roman concrete is stronger than it ever was, while modern concrete decays - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25690803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25690803 - Jan 2021 (7 comments) A chemical reaction in ancient Roman concrete makes it stronger over time (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22580920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22580920 - March 2020 (64 comments) How Ancient Rome’s Concrete Has Survived 2,000 Years (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20482050 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20482050 - July 2019 (81 comments) How Did the Romans Make Concrete That Lasts Longer Than Modern Concrete? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15544128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15544128 - Oct 2017 (3 comments) The Rock Solid History of Concrete - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15480165 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15480165 - Oct 2017 (12 comments) Why Roman concrete still stands strong while modern version decays - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14699652 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14699652 - July 2017 (1 comment) Ancient Romans made world’s ‘most durable’ concrete - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14695876 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14695876 - July 2017 (4 comments) New studies of ancient concrete could teach us to do as the Romans did - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14690329 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14690329 - July 2017 (72 comments) Ancient Roman Concrete Is About to Revolutionize Modern Architecture - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5883443 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5883443 - June 2013 (23 comments) How the pantheon has lasted 2000 years without steel in its concrete - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1852000 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1852000 - Oct 2010 (35 comments) Also: The problem with reinforced concrete (2016) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27282927 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27282927 - May 2021 (186 comments) The problem with reinforced concrete - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11975695 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11975695 - June 2016 (147 comments)
- jonnycomputer 4y agoour obsession with Roman concrete.
- twelve40 4y ago> following all of the detailed recipes that had been optimized over the course of many centuries i wonder how all those detailed recipes were passed around for many centuries and now all is gone. Was it all passed down verbally?
- coryrc 4y agoSome of it was "stone from this volcano" and then it was mined out. They didn't know how to choose a substitute.
- eole666 4y agoIn the 6th century, big volcanic eruptions, low temperatures and plagues bringed a dark age in Europe and other parts of the world. A large part of the population died. Maybe those recipes were lost during this period.
- dreen 4y agoI don't think the knowledge is gone, we could make that or maybe even better. The point is nobody wants it, most things we build need to be torn down after at most a few decades anyway.
- ricardobeat 4y agoThe knowledge is actually gone, like Damascus Steel (what we have today is just a visual reproduction) and Greek Fire. For a more recent example: we already "forgot" how to make the spaceships and rockets that went to the moon. Even if you had the full plans - and apparently we don't, a lot of the materials and processes are not around anymore and would have to be 'reinvented'.
- aidenn0 4y agoWe have a pretty good idea of Damascus steel at this point: - We know that early Damascus examples were made from imported Wootz ingots, which we absolutely can recreated. - The high quality of the blades were due to naturally occuring impurities of molybdenum, vanadium, and chromium, all of which are used in various modern alloys. - Forging and heat treating processes varied greatly across historical blades called "Damascus" and we have sequences that create both visually and metallurgically similar results.
- Toutouxc 4y agoThis is from the article: > Masic wondered: “Was it possible that the Romans might have actually directly used lime in its more reactive form, known as quicklime?” And this is from Wikipedia, with the source dated 2011: > Gypsum and quicklime were used as binders. Volcanic dusts, called pozzolana or "pit sand", were favored where they could be obtained Is it just me or are popular science articles really so simplified that they often completely misrepresent the point of the research?
- sebmellen 4y agoGell-Mann Amnesia is real.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 4y agoRoman concrete was durable mainly because they didn't yet hit upon that silly idea of adding steel rebar.
- rootusrootus 4y agoHow does this concrete compare to a state-of-the-art mix -- not just the stuff they use to pour my driveway or the highway, but the best we know how to make?
- devoutsalsa 4y agoPractical Engineering can answer all your questions with their series on concrete. It’s extremely well done, including a video on “Was Roman Concrete Better?”: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLTZM4MrZKfW90PdaBFt70BLTbz1bTF6Mn https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLTZM4MrZKfW90PdaBFt70BLTb...
- ogogmad 4y agoFor people who don't know the difference between cement, mortar and concrete: Cement is a substance used for producing mortar and concrete. It's never used on its own. It is a "binding agent". Note that the term "cement" is often not used correctly in everyday speech, with people talking about gluing bricks together with cement, when bricks are actually glued together with mortar. Mortar is the glue between bricks. You can see it between the bricks in any brick wall. It is produced by mixing cement with sand. This results in a paste which hardens after being applied to a brick. Concrete is a substance that can be put into any shape, and then hardens. The bricks in a brick wall can be made from it. (More examples?) It is produced by mixing cement with sand and gravel (which are larger rocks). There is also reinforced concrete, which the Romans didn't have. While concrete by itself can in principle be moulded into any shape, this can sometimes fall apart after hardening. Reinforcement refers to putting the concrete around metal wiring, which allows for more versatile shapes while maintaining stability. Feel free to provide corrections.
- ggm 4y agoReinforced concrete in part is designed to provide structural strength under tension forces. Concrete is stable in compression but has weak resistance to tension. Pretensioned reinforced concrete permits longer unsupported spans but even vertical concrete can benefit from reinforced bars, to prevent spalling. (I believe). Not all reinforcing steel has to be tensioned to be useful, that's a technique for long spans. Reinforced steel bars hence rebar.
- LegitShady 4y ago>Reinforced steel bars hence rebar. More like reinforcing bars, rather than reinforced bars. And technically the overwhelming majority of what is sold today are actually deformed reinforcing bars, since the intentional addition of ridges on the outside of the bar helps the concrete adhere as compared to smooth mild steel.
- ComputerGuru 4y ago> but even vertical concrete can benefit from reinforced bars, to prevent spalling. (I believe). I liked your comment but this bears correcting. (Corrosion of) rebar is actually the biggest cause of spalling in vertical concrete structures.
- ggm 4y agoCannot recommend enough "the new science of strong materials: or, why you don't fall through the floor" by JE Gordon. Old, but amazing.
- FairDune 4y agoThanks for the suggestion
- nkurz 4y agoThe formatting is a little off, but a fully text PDF is here: https://edisciplinas.usp.br/pluginfile.php/3975708/mod_resource/content/3/The%20New%20Science%20of%20Strong%20Materials%20Or%20Why%20You%20Dont%20Fall%20Through%20the%20Floor%20Penguin%20Science.pdf https://edisciplinas.usp.br/pluginfile.php/3975708/mod_resou...
- jesuspiece 4y agoIt is a testament to the ingenuity and expertise of the ancient Roman engineers. It will be interesting to see what other insights this research may lead to and how it could potentially be applied to modern construction techniques.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- I_complete_me 4y agoThe subject is complicated. For example see this paper[0]. The setting of concrete goes on for a long time and the Romans were probably not aware of how long their concrete(s) was/were going to last. There is a type of 'survivorship bias' going on here. But still, I guess, they knew something important. Adding reinforcement to concrete may well be a source of shortevity - or what ever the complement to longevity is. [0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0022509616305919 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00225...
- UncleEntity 4y agoIt’s not like the Romans started out in a place where there weren’t thousands of years old structures nearly everywhere they went. Assuming they didn’t want their structures to last as long as the ancient ones (at their time) is just laughable.
- akolbe 4y agoHere is a nice picture of the Pantheon, mentioned in the article as a prime example of these incredibly durable Roman concrete structures: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pantheon11111.jpg#/media/File:Pantheon11111.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pantheon11111.jpg#/m... Not bad for something built nearly 2,000 years ago.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI wonder what percentage of the original stones are left (given that it was repaired and restored over the centuries)
- ggm 4y agoI don't believe the dome structure was radically altered across time. It's possible I misunderstood but my belief was it was only cosmetic changes to the dome itself. Other structural changes were made to the portico and doorways.
- helloworld11 4y agoUnlike many ancient structures, the Pantheon has mostly been left intact across the millennia. The Dome is entirely original and so is most of the remaining structure. From what I know, the majority of the restoration and renovation work has been to the interior ground-level walls and some of the exterior along the ground level, but even these are mostly minor renovations. In this case, what you see truly is for the most part what always was, and especially for the main awe-inspiring part, the great dome.
- Bayart 4y agoThe Pantheon is very notable among Roman monuments for having little done over the years other than cosmetic upgrades.
- peoplefromibiza 4y agoof the original Pantheon from 27 B.C. very little remained. It was rebuilt after the fires of 80 A.C. and 110 A.C. damaged the original structure. It's been mostly unchanged after that.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI read the article quickly but couldn't see whether this discovery is applicable to modern concrete (in other words, could the same technique be applied to modern methods for making concrete that would make it more durable)?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- novosel 4y ago"To prove that this was indeed the mechanism responsible for the durability of the Roman concrete, the team produced samples of hot-mixed concrete that incorporated both ancient and modern formulations, [...] cracked them, and then ran water through the cracks. [...] Within two weeks the cracks had completely healed [...] As a result of these successful tests, the team is working to commercialize this modified cement material."
- insane_dreamer 4y agothanks
- avereveard 4y agosea water + quicklime was known to be the "secret" for concrete for a while, this is a 2017 article https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/speaking-of-science/wp/2017/07/04/ancient-romans-made-worlds-most-durable-concrete-we-might-use-it-to-stop-rising-seas/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/speaking-of-science/wp/2... can we put this to rest already?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ricardobeat 4y agoIf you pay attention to the article, the previous theory of seawater + volcanic ash turns out to not be the main reason for it's durability. The lime clasts being a feature, not a bug, and hot mixing, are the new discoveries.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- t3estabc 4y ago[dead]
- boogoob 4y agoIsn't the particularly short lifespan of modern concrete construction mostly a combination of its use in areas with regular freeze-thaw cycles and using a reinforcement material that rusts (and in doing so expands, damaging more concrete and hastening further water inclusion)?
- oakwhiz 4y agoThe rusting and getting wet is cyclical in nature and part of what accelerates that is the formation of cracks in the first place. Part of the maintenance of concrete is to fill any cracks that you can find to prevent it from getting worse. The cracks typically start small, and they might form in places that are hard to get to as well as being too small to see, so if the concrete is self-healing it will prevent some of these small cracks from getting worse on their own which should reduce the effect of expanding water (ice) as well as expanding rust. The reinforcement material (rebar) already has a very close thermal coefficient of expansion to concrete and this can be thought of as kind of a lucky coincidence.
- masklinn 4y ago> as well as expanding rust. Ideally they’d seal before the rebar is exposed and can rust. As long as the rebar is encased, unless you fucked up dramatically it should be safe.
- moloch-hai 4y agoThe rust is essential to bind it to the cement. Without, it adds little strength. Modern concrete isn't expected or designed to last more than a century. It could have been made to last longer, if they wanted, but that would cost a little more. Making no provision for when it will predictably fall apart is a modern failing. That major construction with concrete is about a century old should worry everyone. We have a very great deal of infrastructure that will fail on a predictable schedule, with nothing budgeted to replace it all.
- 4y ago
- TheMagicHorsey 4y agoSome day in the very far future, our descendants will ask, why is the code manually made in the 2020s with Rust so durable, while our modern PHP20457 code that is spit out by Tardpilot100 is so fragile? Our modern operating systems need to reboot 1000 times per hour just to function while ancient operating systems could stay on for months at a time without rebooting!
- BirAdam 4y agoNah. Rust evangelists of the future will still be fervently rewriting everything in Rust, and they’ll be researching why ancient code worked without being written in Rust.
- bachmitre 4y agoIt looks like ChatGPT already knew that (or I skimmed too quickly): Why was Roman concrete so durable? Roman concrete, also known as opus caementicium, was a highly durable construction material used by the ancient Romans for a variety of structures, including aqueducts, bridges, and buildings. There are several factors that contributed to the durability of Roman concrete: The use of lime and pozzolanic materials: Roman concrete was made from a mixture of lime, water, and an aggregate such as sand or crushed stone. The lime was derived from the heating of limestone, which produced a highly reactive form of calcium oxide. The Romans also added a pozzolanic material, such as volcanic ash, to the mixture, which improved the durability and strength of the concrete by reacting with the lime to form a cementitious material. The inclusion of a reinforcement material: Roman concrete was often reinforced with a material such as iron or lead, which helped to increase its structural strength and resist cracking. The use of a hydraulic setting process: Roman concrete was able to harden underwater due to its hydraulic setting properties, which allowed it to set and cure even in the presence of water. The construction of thick, monolithic structures: Roman concrete was often used to build thick, monolithic structures such as walls and foundations, which were able to withstand the forces of nature and resist deterioration over time. Overall, the combination of these factors made Roman concrete a highly durable construction material that has stood the test of time.
- itsthecourier 4y agoRead the article, they discover they should use a particular state of lime, quicklime. That's new
- dgoldstein0 4y ago> The inclusion of a reinforcement material: Roman concrete was often reinforced with a material such as iron or lead, which helped to increase its structural strength and resist cracking. Sounds like chatgpt messed up it's facts? If this means reenforced like with rebar, the Romans didn't do that - and that's part of why their concrete structures lasted so long - when designed to be under compression rather than tension (arches, domes, etc)
- longt1melurker 4y agothey used saltwater and added volcano ash. thats the secret sauce
- simonblack 4y agoThey didn't reinforce it with iron.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 4y agoI think the bigger question for me, and it comes up about half the time when the topic of Roman concrete comes up, is to what extent Roman concrete has a lower or higher lifetime carbon footprint than modern concrete. Stronger concrete means either less concrete or a slower replacement schedule, and the Roman formula absorbs a certain amount of CO2 out of the air as it ages. The second to last paragraph of this article talks about it: > Through the extended functional lifespan and the development of lighter-weight concrete forms, he hopes that these efforts could help reduce the environmental impact of cement production, which currently accounts for about 8 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions. Along with other new formulations, such as concrete that can actually absorb carbon dioxide from the air, another current research focus of the Masic lab, these improvements could help to reduce concrete’s global climate impact. As we reach the end of the petroleum economy we are going to have a problem with making asphalt, as it is essentially diverting a waste stream from oil refining. When we only use petroleum for materials instead of setting it on fire, that's not going to be a 'free' stream of materials anymore.
- ShredKazoo 4y ago>To prove that this was indeed the mechanism responsible for the durability of the Roman concrete, the team produced samples of hot-mixed concrete that incorporated both ancient and modern formulations, deliberately cracked them, and then ran water through the cracks. Sure enough: Within two weeks the cracks had completely healed and the water could no longer flow. So this method wouldn't necessarily work in a dry climate without much rain?
- thowei2i34234 4y agoReminds me of the Wootz Steelmaking (and much else) in classical India which was lost during the period of Anglo-Islamic colonization. Roman empire, Egypt and Greece, IMO is, contrary to current myths, is far closer in spirit to India than to anything of the 'modern West'. Indeed, the Greeks ruled parts of India for many centuries, and Rome had a great amount of trade with it. The loss of so much rich tradition across the world due to birth of religion and its obsession with tyrannical power over everything is such a tragedy on humankind... this was recognized by the thinkers of Europe during the wee end of the 'renaissance', but in light of post-WW2 plebification of intellectuals, is being rolled back because of the current crop's moronic obsession with another religion: Marxism. Such tragedy. tck. Such tragedy.
- kaesar14 4y agoWhat an atheist meme. These things were ‘lost’ because of breakdowns in trade networks caused by breakdowns of central authority and invasions by outside powers. If anything, the Church is what’s kept the Classics alive through its usage of Latin in the clergy and its preservation of Roman structures as churches.
- ziotom78 4y agoThe Pantheon is a perfect example. It has survived for 2000 years because it was repurposed as a church.
- pigsty 4y agoAnd lots of other Roman buildings didn’t survive because they were destroyed so the blocks could be repurposed into churches in other locations. The Parthenon is one (1) building that survived basically as-is while countless others were actively demolished. One thing that surprised me when visiting Rome is how little original buildings existed. But when you get increasingly far from the city of Rome, you’ll find quite a few well preserved Roman buildings that were out of reach of the long tentacles of the Catholic Church.
- beezlewax 4y agoThere is a Greek Hellenistic breakwater or port ruins in Sant Martí near L'escala in Catalonia, Spain that is sitting in the sea. It is still standing. Always amazes me that it's still there though I'm sure some minor restoration work has probably been done.
- af78 4y agoRelevant thread: https://twitter.com/cleptok/status/1611622181665923075 https://twitter.com/cleptok/status/1611622181665923075 Ok. Let's do a short thread on Roman cement for the 3 people out there that might be interested. You often hear that the Romans had some sort of superior and arcane knowledge on superior cement mixes that has been now lost. And still today we cannot replicate it. This is complete nonsense. Modern day cement (and any other building material, really) is far, far superior than anything from the past. There is simply no comparison. Above everything we understand the chemical composition, interaction and quality control for consistent results. Romans were making mortars based on volcanic ashes. There was no set recipe. Every builder had their own. Volcanic ash from Pozzuoli, crushed brick, slaked like, animal fat, hair etc. Some basic rules existed (as recorded by Vitruvius on the 10 books on Architecture). Millions of structures were constructed these way. With the exception of a handful, most of these do not exist anymore. But why the ones that exist are still standing strong? Usually via a simple Darwinian process. Most of these times those builders got it wrong. But in a few cases, out of luck, they got the chemistry just right. This would result in a ok-ish material, with decent properties. Not only that. Unreinforced (without steel) concrete will not suffer any serious deterioration, with few exceptions. (Pantheon in Rome) Also the very coarse pozzolan they were using, will chemically react very very slowly producing low initial strengths Vs any modern material. In the long term (centuries) though, it will continue gaining strength. Totally useless for the original purpose of the builders, but quite good for the few surviving buildings. So what the latest MIT research told us? That lime in very small quantities will be "self-healing'. And this somehow is something that the Romans knew and used to create a superior cement. This is simply not true. It is well known that lime expands (the pompous "self-healing" tag), so in very small and precise quantities it will counteract the shrinkage and cracking behaviour of cement binders. But you have to be pretty lucky to get it just right. So not intentional. Just survivor bias in the remaining Roman cement structures. Beyond this, lime is a definite no-no for any concrete with steel in it -it corrodes it. The reason we use concrete today is precisely the embedded steel. It allows to build all modern structures. And steel is the reason modern concrete deteriorates. It corrodes, expands and cracks the surrounding concrete. An unreinforced concrete (like the ones Romans used) with modern materials and understanding would last forever. But you wouldn't build anything worthwhile. Final. Remember. Cement = the glue, the binder that holds everything together, activated by water. Concrete= the actual building material with binder, water, sand and stones. Mortar= only binder, sand and water (maybe small stones)
- rapjr9 4y agoSo how difficult is it to destroy Roman concrete? If we start using it to build things are we going to be stuck with those things for 2000 years?