16 ms·
What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jamujamu 4y agoHopefully what’s also left is a 27-inch iMac with M2 or M2 Pro chip inside. The current 24-inch iMac just doesn’t cut it, and the Mac Studio + Apple Display combo is way to expensive compared to the price point of Intel iMacs.
- eastbound 4y agoThe lack of proper 27-inch displays with the quality of Apple (apart the $1800 Apple Display) is the reason I’m not replacing my iMac…
- kergonath 4y agoI had to replace my 27-inch iMac anyway (it just died). But I agree with you, I haven’t found a display as good as the iMac’s that isn’t €1500. I settled with what was supposed to be one of the best Dells for that size (4K, which is itself a compromise); the viewing angles are suboptimal and luminosity is not that great.
- Joyfully8173 4y agoYeah, I was going to mention 27 inch iMac as well. I used to work for a design agency and we used to buy 27 inch iMacs with upgraded CPUs and 16GB of RAM, and then we would install another 32GB of RAM ourselves. The quality of the 5K screen was good enough, savings on the RAM upgrade were significant, they were quite good computers for the price. We used them for all designers that didn't need to attend too many meetings. More senior people got laptops. During COVID we moved everyone to laptops, but I was still curious what Apple will do with the powerful iMac. Let's not forget they also offered iMac Pro, with a Xeon CPU and 128GB of RAM.
- esskay 4y agoI'd imagine most people going for the Mac Studio arent touching the balked Apple Display. It's been riddled with problems and at that price point you can get far better displays now. The panel they're using dates back to 2017 so it's not exactly like you're getting the latest and greatest in screen technology.
- muro 4y agoOther displays have higher refresh rates, but the resolution is still special. Color accuracy is also great. The annoying bug with choppy repeating audio stays unfixed 8 months after introduction and fix with the hassle of disconnecting the monitor from power for an extended time is just ridiculous.
- brailsafe 4y agoWhen you really look into what's available, there's a fair bit of variation in the market for different customers, but there's incredibly few 5k+ displays at 27 or ~30 inches. Like zero if you discount the LG. Everything else is kind of ok, but not always a good replacement.
- xoac 4y agoThis is about to change with higher spec connectors being more widely available.
- jsjohnst 4y ago> This is about to change with higher spec connectors being more widely available. Thunderbolt 3 has been around for over five years on mainstream Mac (and Windows) machines, so what’s the excuse again? I can count the number of monitors in the same resolution space (or higher) on one hand! ;) There’s the insanely priced XDR 6K, there’s the not much better priced Dell 8K, then there’s the LG 5K that’s cheap plastic build quality and hasn’t been refreshed in 5 years. Anyone else? … Bueler?
- softjobs 4y ago
- akamaka 4y agoHow will Apple recoup the cost of designing a powerful chip for a product like the Mac Pro, which is presumably their lowest-selling product? Most of the M-series chips are shared across multiple products, but the Mac Pro seems to be a clear case where using a powerful off-the-shelf Intel chip makes more business sense right now. I don’t see Apple doing it simply as a vanity project, so there will have to be some innovation or new product line coming if an Apple Silicon Mac Pro is to ever exist.
- nickolas_t 4y agoI expect the chip to be used in the upcoming Apple XR/MR headset.
- frankchn 4y agoA high-end chip usable in the Mac Pro will draw more power than the M1 Ultra at 60W. I don’t think they are gonna fit a chip like that into any wearable unless the device comes with a backpack with the processing elements (and battery) in it.
- teruakohatu 4y ago> clear case where using a powerful off-the-shelf Intel chip makes more business sense right now. It will simplify MacOS when they end Intel support.
- lapcat 4y agoExactly this. There's a cost to supporting Intel forever only for the Mac Pro and nothing else. Not only a cost to Apple, but also a cost to 3rd party Mac developers, who would be even less likely to have the resources to support the Mac Pro for its own sake. Apple dropped PowerPC support in Mac OS X (10.6) 3.5 years after the Intel transition started, and they dropped Rosetta support in Mac OS X (10.7) 2 years after that. IIRC the last PPC Mac hardware was discontinued very soon after the Intel transition started.
- 4y ago
- BooneJS 4y agoXeons have many, many PCIe lanes. Apple Silicon only needs enough HSIO for SSD and Thunderbolt ports, and they’ve released all of the non-internally-expandable machines already. They needed a chip that added 48+ PCIe lanes to the package so they could satisfy the relatively few Mac Pro customers. And without external DRAM, they’ll never be able to provide as much memory as a low-end Intel chip in the Mac mini at the same price point. In-package DRAM is better performing but it changes the price/perf graph. Apple simply optimized their silicon packages for 90% (or more?) of their users over the outliers.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoThere’s some very interesting speculation on the ArsTechnica forums about how expandable RAM on a Mac Pro might look. It’s not my speculation but it’s definitely not all said and done from what I’ve read.
- blkhp19 4y agoAny links?
- mrtksn 4y agoConsidering that Mac Pro is a special purpose machine, maybe it can be possible to have an architecture with multiple M2 Ultra chips and expansion options for special purpose hardware? Highly parallelizable workloads and use cases with special hardware requirements(like encoding media, ML computations etc.) can benefit from this stuff. Apple already sells cards like this for Mac Pro. Surely that would require architectural changes and the software would need to be adapted but since these machines are niche, so is the software and Apple can sponsor the development of the few software people are using on that kind of machines. Apple is sponsoring Blender for example.
- zozbot234 4y agoWell, the Ultra is already multiple silicon dies (chiplets) on an interposer. So this would have to be multiple packages, sitting in separate sockets on the same logic board. I agree that this seems like it could be a viable strategy to get around any packaging constraints that they might have.
- dwaite 4y agoIMHO Mac mini isn't going to die any time soon; it is there in the lineup to be hostable/rackable operations glue for running old software and (old operating systems) headless. I doubt they will release a M2 Pro Mini. They will instead update the Mac Studio. Conversely, if they make a M2 Pro in the current Mini form factor, they'll likely use that as an excuse to redesign the regular M2 Mini to be smaller (Mac Micro) and more compatible with DC-power data centers.
- eastbound 4y agoI buy Mac Mini because OSHA once demanded (and I find it’s not a bad idea) that I use screens instead of laptops to avoid employees spending 7hrs bending to neck. So they have 2 displays at work and 2 displays at home, and a Mac Mini, total 2300€, better than a 2800€ Macbook Pro + screens. What is the state of the art, do all of you simply buy a top-notch Macbook Pro and work on it all day?
- methyl 4y agoI have a Macbook Pro but keep it plugged in for longer stretches of work. I couldn’t give up the convenience of being able to just unplug and sit on a couch from time to time. Not mentioning working from places outside of office and home.
- microtonal 4y agoI use a MacBook Pro and hook it up to a Thunderbolt dock + external screen at whatever desk I’m working. It’s more convenient than a Mac Mini, since I have the same machine everywhere.
- brigade 4y agoOSHA didn't consider a properly adjusted laptop stand acceptable? Well, I only use one to reuse the laptop as a second display...
- noduerme 4y agoCan't say I'm state of the art, but I pretty much work on an M1 Max MBP all day, and I'm completely happy with it as a dev + art/design machine. Plus a tablet screen for drawing and sculpting. It's the best machine I've ever had. But then again I've only owned laptops since 1998. Still keep my 2014 Macbook Air on the desk just as a conferencing / music box. [edit] I also only work from my home office when I have to... the rest of the time I'll be working on the porch, at the kitchen table, out at a cafe, etc.
- ksec 4y agoIt seems strange to include the Mini. As it is more of an Intel Mac for those who somehow still need Intel macOS for whatever reason. The memory capacity is limited in ARM Mac. So if you want high capacity memory you go to Mac Studio. And with Mac Studio, which brings us the next question. What are the Market Mac Studio couldn't compete with Mac Pro. If it is not powerful enough now, will possibly another doubling of LPDDR6, that is 512GB with 1.5TB/s of bandwidth with M3 Ultra be enough? The only market I could think of right now is Audio Professionals with specific Plug in Sound Card. Could that market not be served if Apple had made a few more Thunderbolt 4 port available?
- pjmlp 4y agoThe market of VFX, which without an Mac Pro, might end up going back to Windows or custom built Linux desktops, like many Hollywood studios did when migrating away from SGI, and Pro wasn't still an option.
- spookie 4y agoI assume the tile based rendering architecture is the biggest footgun in the new Apple SoC's. It just doesn't scale with a lot of polygons. I don't see how they can solve this either.
- dagmx 4y agoTile based rendering wouldn’t matter for VFX work. They use path tracing. Nobody is really using rasterizers except for viewports, where it’s rare to be pushing so many polys that you’d bog down the GPU first (you’d almost always hit memory limits or CPU limits first dealing with that many transforms). I’m not sure I agree that a TBDR is bad for high poly counts. There’s nothing inherent to the architecture that I can think of that would limit it for pure polygon work. Usually the biggest hold up is full screen effects that need to work on the entire buffer but those are rare for VFX.
- dagmx 4y agoVFX has largely been on Linux workstations since the demise of SGI. There’s never really been a Mac presence at the workstation level at those studios. Windows is already in many studios due to VR or Virtual Production work, since Unreal Engine kind of sucks on anything that isn’t Windows, and the same goes for VR. However there are a few areas that Macs are used heavily and where I don’t think Apple need to be worried: - artists that need to use Adobe products or anything non Linux. Macs offer better Linux like workflows for pipelines since it’s Unix like, so is favoured for pipeline integration and macOS has much better colour handling than windows. So you’ll see in house concept artists, matte painters and the like on macs. VFX editors tend to be on macs for the same reason. Those are the folks that a Mac Pro would be handy for. - dailies review boxes. Macs again are better for playback and the arm macs are so quiet they’re perfect for a review room. More RAM is always welcome here. - coordinators and producers are almost always on Mac laptops. They’re unparalleled for battery life in a compact body. Plus since macs need to be supported for the above two use cases, it makes sense to use them as well. - conform machines to handle media conversions often are macs. Though this depends greatly on what formats are being used
- samwillis 4y agoThe Mac Studio was a new product category, sitting just beneath the Mac Pro. I suspect during development they were unsure of if it would actually be the Mac Pro, that would have probably been another 2013 Mac Pro debacle though. The Mac Studio must be decimating Mac Pro sales, it must fit what 70-80% of Mac Pro users wanted. It's going to be incredible hard to Apple to justify development of an extended M architecture for a product used by a tiny fraction of their customers. It wouldn't surprise me if they didn't press go on full Mac Pro development until they saw how the market reacted to the Studio. One possibility is they reintroduce the XServe (and maybe XServe Cloud) with the larger expandable architecture to help justify its development. The only other option is expanding the Mac Studios capability with external "stackable" peripherals, such as eGPUs.
- stephen_g 4y agoI think it would be enough for the Pro to just be the same as the highest spec of the next generation Mac Studio, in a form factor that has PCIe and RAM slots. (I wonder if they could do some kind of memory hierarchy where you have, say, 32GB of the on-board unified memory soldered on to the processor like they have now, and then another eight slots or something of regular DDR5 sticks).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- esskay 4y agoXServe would probably be pretty popular with the recent shift to ARM based servers for their lower power consumption. The problem would be their insistance for them to run full blown macOS instead of a dedicated Linux based server OS.
- solarkraft 4y agoI think there's a chance they'd give you a thin iOS-based server OS (think watchOS or tvOS) with Hypervisor.Framework and let you choose what you run on it.
- Maxburn 4y agoNiagara makes HVAC control software and there's a big push to get it Mac compatible. Seems like a terrible time to make the investment now with two architectures involved. Prolonging the transition isn't in anybody interest.
- Maxburn 4y agoPeople that are downvoting, what am I missing? Developers either target apple silicon and ignore intel, ignore apple silicon and rely on rosetta2 for as long as that's here, or invest in both to optimize performance and just eat all the extra work both require? I'm not a mac user, is there such a thing as making a app targeting apple silicon work on a x86 machine? If someone is looking to add their application to Mac it really seems like a bad time to do it, wait a year and more apple silicon will be out there and you could reasonably target just that and be OK. Apple prolonging the transition is not good for anybody, but I guess we can blame this on supply chain.
- wtallis 4y agoWhy would anything in HVAC control software be written in a way that is at all specific to a particular CPU architecture? Most software really doesn't need to use inline assembly or SIMD intrinsics, so usually the only extra effort to support both x86 and arm is in configuring the build system correctly.
- Maxburn 4y agoI admit I don't know the software at that level but I think you would be surprised, it's a web server, db engine, and all sorts of things rolled up into it. This is commercial/industrial HVAC, it has more in common with emulating a PLC on PC hardware than say a nest thermostat app. I know it interacts with serial and ethernet ports to speak multiple languages (BACnet/LonWorks/Modbus/hundreds more) and they like to have some close relationship with the hardware, some of which is for licensing... They currently support windows, redhat, and just added Ubuntu. Very much similar version of the software runs on their "native" jace 8000 (PLC lite) hardware, which is ARM under it all so you would think they already have experience in that area.
- klelatti 4y agoJust looking at the economics of the Mac Pro based on sales of the machine itself doesn't quite capture the full picture. An Apple Silicon Mac Pro could have many roles: - A flagship product that demonstrates just how powerful Apple Silicon can be. This in turn could enhance the Apple / Mac brand for a certain group of users. - An aspirational product for users who think that they might need more power in the future. - A means of keeping companies that need a small number of powerful machines in the Apple camp. - A proving ground for technology that ultimately makes its way into volume products. All of these factors could make the product justify its development costs even if actual sales are small. I doubt that the highest end models of some premium car brands recoup their development costs but their value to the brand offsets those costs.
- UltraViolence 4y agoThis will hold as long as Apple makes tons of money from its iPhone business. The minute however that this starts to sag they'll start cost-cutting and they'll start with unprofitable vanity products like Mac's.
- jb1991 4y agoIs the Mac actually unprofitable? I don’t think that’s true.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- physPop 4y agoAmazing mac haters still exist in 2023. The products have proven themselves in the market and with developers. Ignoring that is head-in-the-sand behavior. edit: 2023!
- jb1991 4y agoWhat I find most surprising is that people think the computer industry is somehow immune from the most basic of human qualities: choice. It's perfectly fine if some people don't choose or don't like Apple products. Just as it is perfectly fine for some not to want to use Linux or buy Windows. It's just choice. How silly that for some it is a strange, almost religious, war.
- esskay 4y agoI think its fairly obvious they've hit some problems. I know they lost a lot of key people in their silicon development team so perhaps thats the reason. Whatever it is they're struggling to get the performance they need for a Mac Pro level machine. I'd imagine part of it is going to be that they'll want to continue using Nvidia or AMD GPU's to allow for higher performance. That can't be an easy or simple thing to get working with their custom ARM based architecture.
- matwood 4y ago> I know they lost a lot of key people in their silicon development team so perhaps thats the reason. Maybe, but people are always coming and going on any team. This whole story felt like a tempest in a teapot type of thing. IMO, given the typical lead time of hardware, we're finally seeing Apple have issues stemming from covid/supply chain breakdowns.
- avidphantasm 4y agoAlso, there’s a tension between the tightly integrated M1 Ultra and the expandability implied by the Mac Pro in its classic form (which the 2019 model revived). It almost seems like they need to go multi-socket with NUMA to scale CPU and memory further. This presents a very different programming model than the shared everything model of the Mac Studio.
- kilroy123 4y agoIt could also be an issue on the China side. The whole COVID/lockdown debacle has probably set things back a lot longer than they would have hoped.
- UltraViolence 4y agoI have famously predicted that sales of Mac's will decline and could even lead to a rout. Many professionals need Intel CPU support in order for them to run Windows on their Macbooks natively. And no, emulation isn't an option. I predict that Mac sales will sag and that this will lead Apple to slash more and more models, eventually undermining the legitimacy of the platform. Most users will switch to Linux on Intel laptops from various other vendors.
- zozbot234 4y agoThere's an ARM64 build of Windows. And Linux on Apple Silicon is getting to the point where it's almost viable as a daily-driver OS. It's not there yet but quite close.
- bzzzt 4y agoWhile Bootcamp worked admirably I hardly ever see it used at work. I don't think 'professionals' would be buying Macs to run Windows native very often while Windows laptops exist and would be providing much more value for their money. Meanwhile, Mac sales are up and the current crop of M1/M2 machines get top review marks.
- alkonaut 4y ago> Most users will switch to Linux on Intel laptops from various other vendors. Who exactly will switch to Linux on an intel laptop outside of a fraction of software developers/IT professionals?
- scarnie 4y agoFamously It would be helpful if you have facts or data to back your statements up.
- shapefrog 4y agoDell will be shipping SOC ARM computers before that happens.
- matwood 4y agoWhen will this decline start? Last quarter was the best quarter ever revenue wise for the Mac.
- runeks 4y agoWhat excites me about apple Silicon is this: performance that is roughly on par with competing x86 CPUs combined with ~5x lower power usage. My M1 MacBook Pro can run full throttle on all 8 "performance" CPU cores for an hour without the fans ever spinning up. This tells me that Apple could fit 32 performance cores in a laptop CPU, which is simply not possible with x86 (unless you severely compromise on the definition of "portable").
- cyber_kinetist 4y ago> This tells me that Apple could fit 32 performance cores in a laptop CPU I'm not too sure about that. The current 20-core CPU from Apple is inside the Mac Studio, and it has quite a monster of an air cooler. It's obviously going to be much harder to put that (or something more powerful) inside a laptop, even with all the chip improvements...
- zozbot234 4y agoWell of course it does, who wants to be thermally throttled on a desktop-class machine? You're assuming that desktop and laptop use must support the exact same scenarios which is not true among x86-64 users either.
- runeks 4y agoInteresting. Something’s not adding up here, though. 8 cores = “tiny fans basically always off” vs 20 cores = “two huge fans”. Either those two huge fans are running at a very low RPM, or the fans in the laptop are almost as efficient as the huge ones. I highly doubt the latter, so I assume the former is the case.
- sharikous 4y agoReally? MBP 13: 4 performance cores + 4 efficiency cores Mac Studio: 16 performance cores + 4 efficiency cores Not to mention that the more cores you have, the bigger the overhead of e.g. synchronizing between them becomes
- 4y ago
- SpacePortKnight 4y agoWhat I like about Apple is that they have such a clear product lineup that it allows for speculation like this article. On the other hand Microsoft's surface lineup makes no sense and is super confusing. That's true for Samsung as well. Even if these companies had the engineering capacity to make chips like M1; I doubt they would attract even a fraction of the media attention enjoyed by Apple.
- chaos_a 4y agoApple has done this since Steve Jobs returned to apple the late 90's, they cut down all of the unnecessary models and products lines that were causing this kind of confusion. They've kinda gone that way again with sticking the "Pro" and "Max" terms onto everything, especially the iPhone models.
- victorelu 4y agoExcept the iPad lineup which is quite confusing and weirdly speced and priced.
- formerly_proven 4y ago"Big is cheap and small is expensive? What a country!"
- sylens 4y agoApple’s high end desktop strategy has been confusing to me for several years now. They made a big deal out of the iMac Pro, even though that seemed like an obvious quick fix for power users since the new Mac Pro wasn’t ready at the time. However, I never understood why Pros would want to pay more for an an all-in-one they couldn’t self service or upgrade when they probably already had monitors they preferred using. Then they finally released the 2019 Mac Pro at a cost that I thought was prohibitive to all but the highest end professionals. I don’t remember previous Mac Pros being targeted this exclusively; heck, somebody in my freshman dorm in 2006 had the cheese grater Pro at the time for music production. When they unveiled the Studio, I thought that they were replacing the Pro line with that product…but then they confirmed the Pro is still coming. I really do not know what differentiation there will be between the Studio and the new Pro. I’m curious to see what they do with expansion and dedicated GPUs, but considering they don’t play ball with Nvidia anymore it’s probably still going to be a niche product
- michaelt 4y ago> I don’t remember previous Mac Pros being targeted this exclusively; heck, somebody in my freshman dorm in 2006 had the cheese grater Pro at the time for music production. Well, even before the rise of covid-induced work-from-home, Apple has been shepherding almost all of their users onto laptops. That college student's 2006 Mac Pro might have had 1GB RAM [1] - but these days, Apple has a laptop for users wanting 64GB RAM. And it isn't a suitcase-sized mobile workstation either. People wanting more power than that for things like ML and scientific computing will often be shifting their workload to the cloud or a cluster anyway - it's only people doing interactive tasks like CAD and high-end video editing who are buying the Mac Pro. [1] https://youtu.be/l72MsGZQA8Q?t=418 https://youtu.be/l72MsGZQA8Q?t=418
- jltsiren 4y agoThe switch to working from home made high-end workstations a bit more relevant. While offices had fast and reliable internet connections, the quality of home internet is often much worse. You can't rely on the cloud as much from home as from office. I develop bioinformatics methods and software, and I see significant productivity gains when I can run tests with full datasets locally. So far I've been using an iMac with 128 GB RAM, but I'd like to upgrade to something with 256 GB or even 512 GB. As the Mac Studio is pretty underwhelming from my perspective, the options are basically a hypothetical Mac Pro and a Linux box.
- alkonaut 4y agoWhat is the biggest hurdle for the M2 Mac Pro? Is it connectivity that isn't suppported by the chip? E.g. when they want external DRAM and GPU, the M2 SoCs simply don't have that capability so a whole new SoC would be required, with features that would only be used in the Pro, making it a questionable investment? Or is there a more technical hurdle, e.g. that supporting external Dram and third party GPU would require more fundamental changes than merely building a new SoC?
- zozbot234 4y agoCouldn't you connect external DRAM to a Mac Studio via Thunderbolt if you really wanted to? Or is that still missing the same memory coherence semantics as actual DRAM sticks?
- formerly_proven 4y agoThunderbolt has around two orders of magnitude less bandwidth and two orders of magnitude higher latency than the DRAM in that machine. Viewed through the narrow <40 Gbit/s TB3/4 funnel, you'll have trouble telling DRAM and a PCIe 4 SSD apart.
- ngcc_hk 4y agoCould it be many still need CUDA and hence unless they can somehow fit in Nvidia they … But they do not want to. Hence not sure what is the point other than they can win the war against CUDA.
- alkonaut 4y agoCUDA or not, I don't think many will buy a mac pro unless it delivers what the last one did in terms of Graphics. And that probably requires at least using separate graphics card in the several-hundred-watt class. They obviously aren't going to shove a 400W graphics card into the SoC and they aren't going to shrink the power requirements by an order of magnitude for GPUs. An they also aren't going to enter the business of making discrete pro graphics cards. nvidia and AMD can afford to do that research work because it trickles down to consumer/gamer cards. But Apple surely can't motivate that research expense. So the only thing that makes sense is to either make no Mac pro tower workstation with discrete GPUs at all, or doing what they did last time, using third party cards.
- GeekyBear 4y agoWhat's needed to complete the Apple Silicon transition is TSMC's recent start to 3nm volume production. Originally, TSMC projected 3nm risk production to start at the tail end of 2021, so Apple would have had chips for multiple product lines that were designed to be fabbed at 3nm in 2022.
- uni_baconcat 4y agoI’m really curious about how Apple could make Apple Silicon has expansion ability. Not only provides PCI sockets, but also SoC upgrade ability.
- yakubin 4y agoI don’t know if it’s the fault of Apple Silicon, but on my Mac applications regularly crash. That includes ACDSee, IINA, qBittorent, Edge, KeePassXC, Sublime Text, Sublime Merge… There is at least one crash every 3 days. Nothing like it happens on my Windows, Linux or FreeBSD systems. It’s my first Mac, so I can’t compare this experience to Intel Macs, and so I don’t know if it’s just that MacOS is so unstable in general, or if those are still pains of migration to a new ISA. (Often, when one application crashes, a couple others follow not long after.)
- ErneX 4y agoNo crashes on mine, maybe you got a lemon?
- avidphantasm 4y agoYeah, compared to my 12th-gen i9 XPS laptop, my M1 Pro *never* crashes. Granted, the XPS now crashes much less since I switched to Linux 5.19, but it still hangs (mostly due to wake from sleep issues) much more often than my MBP.
- manmal 4y agoThere was info a while back that memory management issues become more obvious on Apple Silicon, problems that x86 is more forgiving of. Can’t find the source unfortunately.
- CTDOCodebases 4y agoHow much memory do you have? I would suspect faulty ram or a faulty SSD that is causing issues when virtual memory is used.
- yakubin 4y ago16GB.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI can tell you my MacBook Pro with the M1 and Mac OS Monetary does not crash. But without knowing the machine and OS version that you have my data point is perhaps not very helpful.
- msoad 4y agoGiven how efficient Apple chips are, doesn't it make sense for them to make a chip that can be used both in the next Mac Pro and in the cloud servers? They can at least use their own chips in their data centers and save on power usage
- idontwantthis 4y agoWhat if instead of the pro they brought back the server. Since they own all the hardware and the OS, I wonder if they could make some kind of magic task scheduling engine to seamlessly run jobs on the MServer. It sees you are rendering 3d animation so it just sends it to the server for you.
- uptown 4y agoI’m fine with the current mini but need to be able to use three 4K displays. That either means using some kind of hack to do that or buying a Studio. Or waiting for maybe a Mini Pro.
- a2tech 4y agoI'm in the same boat. I have no problem with the processing speed of the Mini but I want to be able to drive my 6ft of monitors on my desk. Right now I'm using a hackintosh, but I'd switch in a heartbeat if I could
- retskrad 4y agoApple literally had the Avengers of the chip industry working for them until the M1, which was a groundbreaking chip and still is for its unmatched performance per watt. Just like sports, a team can’t stay at the top forever. Now that Apple has lost many of their Avenger members in their chip division, they need to be humble and go back to the drawing board. AMD and Qualcomm are getting closer to their performance per watt. The M2 showed that the M1 architecture is done. They need to build something new up from the ground up but that’s going to challenge. Let’s see if they can pull it off.
- trenchgun 4y agoWhy did they lose those key employees?
- dpflan 4y agoAdd on: who are the key employees?
- amelius 4y agoApple doesn't want to speak about them. In fact the only recent Apple employee other than Jobs or Cook that I have ever heard about is Jony Ive.
- dpflan 4y agoAre they not visible on LinkedIn? Reminds me of Gibson novels like Count Zero with top technologists as key parts of sprawling interstellar corporations requiring mercenaries to extract a researcher to basically change jobs [1.]. - [1.] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Count_Zero https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Count_Zero
- jlokier 4y agoSeveral key M1 designers left to start a new processor design company called Nuvia, which was exciting for a while. In some respects it didn't work out well as an independent, as it was later acquired by (absorbed into) Qualcomm, which is already a large processor design company. But if it was cash the founders wanted, they got themselves a good exit.
- llampx 4y agoI don't see a reason the Mac Pro has to have a more powerful CPU than the Mac Studio. For example the Macbook Pro and Macbook Air also share the same CPU at certain levels. The difference could be in expandability (PCIe slots) and RAM if they are able to either move the RAM off-die or have a NUMA architecture. Interesting to speculate though. So far they also haven't launched a multi-socket product, maybe that's what the Mac Pro could launch with.
- ChrisRR 4y agoApple have really hit the marketing hard calling it Apple Silicon and not ARM
- daemontus 4y agoI'm seeing a ton of "nobody would but a $10.000 Mac Pro when Mac Studio exists" opinions here. But, like... why? Threadripper Pro exists and as far as I can tell, certain industries are practically begging AMD to keep updating it. A system with 32-core TR Pro and a few hundred gigs of RAM is easily $10k. With a 64-core CPU, you are probably closer to $15k. If a Mac Pro can give you 40-60 cores, 128-512GB of RAM plus a powerful GPU for $10-20k, its certainly niche, but not dead on arrival. I think the main issue is that while AMD can "justify" TR Pro by having disaggregated compute and IO chiplets, Apple does not. AMD can just "print" as many CPU cores as it likes (within the power budget), and then slap on a different IO tile depending on what product it's making. Currently, Apple isn't doing that. Furthermore, they put themselves into an even bigger corner by gluing their CPU and GPU onto one die. Most professional tasks are fine with a monster CPU and no/little GPU, or a monster GPU and an ok CPU. Adding PCIe with support for GPUs would help with that. For memory heavy tasks, you could add CXL memory expansions. But that then adds a new problem: what dies would Apple fab for this product? With M1, there were essentially 2-3 dies: The power efficient M1, the M1 Max/Ultra with the interposer, and M1 Pro (there were rumours some Pros are just failed Max-es with a part of the chip cut off, but afaik nobody was able to verify this, so 3 dies it is). For M2, we have only seen the power efficient die so far. If M2 Extreme would be 4x M2 Max, then the previous strategy could work. But if Apple wants PCIe or CXL memory modules on M2 Extreme, they have to put it on all of their Max (and maybe Pro) dies as well. Even though these will be in laptops/all-in-ones that won't use any of that. In other words, a ton of analog circuitry that's a complete waste of silicon. The only other option is to fab special dies for M2 Extreme, which might have been the plan, and what probably made it a very bad ROI. It's kind of like Sapphire Rapids: SR is certainly fast for what it's doing, but it's super expensive compared to EPYC and less scalable exactly because you need different dies to implement different SKUs (SR is monolithic up to afaik ~20 cores and the "chiplets" only appear above that, plus the IO you get depends on the chiplets). And SR doesn't even include a GPU... Finally, Apple's GPUs don't appear to be really scaling as great as they were hoping. I have yet to see a real-world M1 Ultra review that wouldn't end on a "it's +20-50% more performance for +100% price" note. The CPU cluster seems to be doing much better. But by tying four of them together for M2 Extreme, people who need CPU would have to pay for the whole thing, and people who need GPU would be probably left disappointed. My personal "best bet" would be to just keep releasing a power efficient "consumer" die, but disaggregate everything on the "pro level": A single CPU-heavy "Pro" die with a bit of GPU and a bit of IO, then a GPU-heavy die that slaps onto that to make the Max, and then an IO-only die for the Mac Pro mixed and matched with a combination of CPU and GPU dies. I wouldn't be shocked if this was the plan for M3/M4, the question is if the packaging technology will be there in time (and economical; wink wink Intel).