11 ms·
The Zen anti-interpretation of quantum mechanics (2021)
- nielsbot 4y agoMakes me think of this book: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tao_of_Physics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tao_of_Physics I remember enjoying it a lot (not a physicist).
- ngoilapites 4y agoThis book surely is good and nice to read, but has no evidence beyond coincidental anecdotes.
- akomtu 4y agoWhat does it have to do with zen?
- _0w8t 4y agoOne of Zen ideas is that thinking hides the true nature of the world since it is based on models and interpretations. So not doing interpretations is a step towards enlightenment.
- green_on_black 4y ago"true nature" -- I'd say that this idea of a "true" nature (even existing) is quite arrogant.
- astrange 4y agoA Zen response here would be to hit you on the head. Did that exist? If not, are you still going to complain about it?
- Finnucane 4y agoFirst there is a mountain, then there is no mountain, then there is.
- wrycoder 4y agoOh Juanita, I call your name
- pasquinelli 4y agogo ask the pillar
- cuteboy19 4y agoAka "Shut up and calculate" interpretation of QM. But yes, an interpretation is only needed because we need to square the theory with our intuition. Once we say that our intuition is hopelessly wrong, interpretation is not needed
- jetrink 4y agoThe essay doesn't agree. > You shouldn’t confuse the Zen Anti-Interpretation with “Shut Up And Calculate.” The latter phrase, mistakenly attributed to Feynman but really due to David Mermin, is something one might say at the beginning of the path, when one is as a baby.
- gizmo686 4y agoFinish the paragraph: > but after years of study and effort you’ve returned to the situation of the baby, who just sees the thing for what it is.
- FeepingCreature 4y agoI think his view is less "shut up and calculate" and more "to calculate is to know."
- dilap 4y agoThis feels like a cop out. Like sure, you can just do the math and get results and not worry about it. But what's the motivation here? When you get down to it, he seems to believe many-worlds is true, BUT holds the philosophical position that you shouldn't, like, care. Because there's no practical benefit to caring; because it doesn't help you with the calculations. But, hey, I still care! What the real nature of reality is is an interesting question! It's fun & satisfying to think about, even if has no direct physical practical implications. Plus, it can certainly have psychological implications, dramatically impacting how we feel about the things that have happened to us and life in general.
- blamestross 4y ago> Plus, it can certainly have psychological implications, dramatically impacting how we feel about the things that have happened to us and life in general. Other than offering amusement by recreationally asking how many parallel universes can dance on the head of a pin, how should it affect anything? It is no mercy to know there are kinder universes out there, for with them come those more cruel. You are already a mote in the sea of infinity, what hope is offered by adding more dimensions to that ocean's depth? Anyone wise enough to make it this far should know better than to presume that the best available theoretical model is actually the truth. We just use it out of pragmatic lack of a better one (which will likely someday come, but we are approaching the less fun side of the scientific knowledge sigmoid)
- dilap 4y agoWell, do you think there is a truth, understandable by humans, about the nature of the universe? If you think there is, what better guide than our best theories of physics so far? So of course what the nature of the universe is doesn't really affect anything, on a physical level, but our sense of what happens after we're gone does in fact change our behaviors. E.g. Most people contemplate with more horror the possibility of all humanity being wiped out than their own isolated death, even though from the individual perspective it is the same. Somehow things that cannot possibly matter to us physically still matter to us intellectually. > It is no mercy to know there are kinder universes out there, for with them come those more cruel. Well, that's debatable. For example, if you're finding this universe to be particularly cruel, perhaps it is a solace to think it's just one of the universes you must endure, and in some other universe you're having a much easier time.
- _0w8t 4y agoThe article misses that we do not know how classical world that we perceive arises. Ultimately according to QM the whole universe is just single wave function with no probabilities. But this contradicts our experience of the classical world including that we measure probabilities. So we need to explain that to avoid various very ad-hock notions of classical measurement device and similar routes. There are attempts to explain the classical world using a notion of decoherence, but that have problems with little progress in the last, say, 20 years to address them. Then there are ideas based on Everett works that perhaps it is a conscious itself that perceives the classical world and the real world is the wave function. But then such ideas do not explain the exact numerical probabilities. The interesting resent suggestion was that the probabilities were not really physical but rather represent the lack of information in Bayesian sense. In past that was used to construct various hidden variable theories, but the new take is that the classical notion that the state of a system can be fully described by its properties at some moment in time is wrong. One also needs to know some information about future to fully describe evolution of the system. This is very speculative, but at least it is fully compatible with relativity and explains probabilities. They simply represent lack of knowledge of boundary conditions in the future.
- FeepingCreature 4y agoIn the single wavefunction, beings who perceive classical reality arise from mere wavefunction mathematics. How does this not answer the question? Once you can locate yourself in a system, the system is adequate as a physical theory of your phenomenological state.
- _0w8t 4y agoThis does not explain how a classical observer gets probabilities that are precisely measured. In universe-as-a-wave-function there are no probabilities. So how exactly do they arise and what they mean?
- layer8 4y agoMy understanding is that this is just the law of large numbers. Most branches match the mathematical probabilities very closely, and hence that’s what we observe. Yes, people on one of the rare branches where things behave differently wouldn’t observe that, but we simply happen to not be on one of those rare branches.
- dools 4y agoWhat I don't get is why people are more concerned with how Qauntum Mechanics works than they are with the way in which, for example, electro magenetic waves travel in a vacuum. Like we can "physically" understand how sound travels, and we can "visualise" that as a "mechanism" right? But we have no similar way of "physicalising" the way in which light travels, but no-one seems to have any trouble accepting that. Quantum states seem to be no different: they're just a way things work, that we don't have a good "macro physical" analogy for.
- sampo 4y agoQuantum mechanics has wave function collapse, which is both essential in applying the theory to explain any physical situation, and at the same time not described by the theory. Other than "and then it collapses". Classical theories don't have this problem.
- _0w8t 4y agoAnd then the whole notion of the collapse is not really compatible with relativity.
- astrange 4y agoIt’s also difficult to understand how chaotic systems are explained by quantum mechanics, although they must be. And of course what gravity has to do with it.
- dools 4y agoThe whole “wave function collapse” thing as far as I understand is simply the result of any measurement involving entanglement. When you measure something by any means you create an entanglement that cancels out the term in the equation that produces “wave like” behaviour.
- krastanov 4y agoFor many people the statement "electromagnetic fields exist as a (fundamental) building block of Nature" is just as reasonable as "atoms exist as a (fundamental) building block of Nature". The word "fundamental" is not particularly important, I am keeping it for historical reasons. You are perfectly comfortable with the existence of atoms (given your comments about understanding sound waves), presumably because you know of experiments that have demonstrated their existence. We have experiments that have demonstrated the existence of EM waves. So the questions is, what in your personal aesthetic tastes is making atoms more palatable? The question of interpreting quantum mechanics is quite different. We do not have a popular mathematical framework that clearly explains why we perceive a classical world while being "inside" of a quantum wavefunction. There is plenty of vagueness and oversimplification in that last statement, but the difference is "we have an abstraction that explains mostly-perfectly EM waves and we do not care about whether people are comfortable with the abstraction" vs "we do not even have a mathematical abstraction explaining why we perceive a classical world inside of a quantum universe".
- dekhn 4y agoIt's so odd to read about QM by people who don't go into a lab and do QM experiments. Like, this whole article is about the math currently used to make predictions using QM. Not what actually goes on when you prepare entangled particles, not what happens (physically), etc. The "interpretation" of QM (IE, how do we square our mental intuition about how physical matter and energy behave) isn't super interesting, as long as you can retrain your intuition to help make predictions about interesting experiments. Unlearn you must.
- dekhn 4y agoThe right frame of mind is not "shut up and calculate", it's "shut up and make testable hypotheses and then invalidate them experimentally".
- layer8 4y agoEven if the different interpretations currently have no testable hypotheses, it is still significant which interpretation you subscribe to, because it guides how you think about the physics, and may prevent you from thinking in certain directions, or “out of the box”. The blog post’s Zen approach sounds like an agnostic stance, which probably isn’t a bad thing in that regard.
- lacasito25 4y agoBut what if "make testable hypotheses and then invalidate them experimentally" is wrong to begin with?
- mike_hock 4y agoThen it wouldn't be the right frame of mind, contradicting dekhn's axiom that it's the right frame of mind.
- dekhn 4y agothat is a metascientific process (IE, questioning whether the scientific process is applicable), and outside the scope of exploration of QM, until somebody manages to demonstrate (in which case, I am truly interested in seeing what the alternative is... some sort of spooky mysticism?)
- DoctorOetker 4y ago(self-)censorship has seldom brought progress, especially in science. consider the question: is the distinction between theory A vs B testable? if we can not yet verify that a distinction is untestable, it might still be testable, but we might just be missing the insight on how to construct the experimental setup to test a distinction. if in fact a hypothesis eventually turns out to be testable, there is no guarantee that a single person or single group would have come up with such a test, perhaps devising the test requires careful and deliberate thought by a lot of people separated by location and or generations. in that case, the prescription to "shut up and make testable hypotheses and then invalidate them experimentally" would be counter-productive advice, eliding the agressive "shut up" might do wonders... as an aside, perhaps we fail to see the forest for the trees: consider Youngs double slit experiment, the quantum mechanical version, perhaps with single photons or alternatively electrons, self-interfering with single particle detection on a screen. according to the path integral formalism the particle is taking all possible paths, and the complex amplitudes are added together with their respective path-length-delays, i.e. "simple interference", except I only see course notes picturing the paths through slit A and B, and I never see the quantum mechanics books picturing the infinite number of topological loops: through slit A -> [back through slit B, through slit A again] x N -> to screen... are many worlds interpretations truly untestable, or are we refusing to acknowledge their having been measured a long time ago? what prevents a physicist from claiming all of the paths in the path integral formalism correspond to the system histories of the universe splitting over the (continuous or discrete) paths, and then merging by interference on the same final measurement point on the screen. one can not explain the interference as long as one refuses to recognize the particle passed both slits. if something so basic to the theory of quantum mechanics such as the single particle equivalent to Youngs double slit experiment could be recognized as not just proof of splitting histories, but also proof of merging histories, that might be seen as a paradigm shift. what makes self-interference of a particle exploring all paths so much more palatable than simply claiming all these paths correspond to different histories of the photon, and those same histories merging through the laws of interference? That would render the acceptance of interference into an acceptance of not just many worlds, but also the possibility of diverging histories interacting (at least in setups where interference takes effect).
- dang 4y agoDiscussed at the time: The Zen Anti-Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26363004 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26363004 - March 2021 (64 comments)
- jasonhansel 4y ago> OK, but are the quantum states “ontic” (really out in the world), or “epistemic” (only in our heads)? Scott's answer to this seems like a cop-out. He's basically saying "I can't tell which things are epistemic or ontic, and this all seems very complicated, so I'm going to assume the distinction doesn't exist."
- achrono 4y agoI actually thought it was good enough to get going, because wouldn't we then enter the rabbit hole of the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics? Only way out might be a Penrosian realm!
- hackandthink 4y agoI will never reach the Zen state and still think the epistemic/ontic discussion makes sense. Scott Aaranson: "OK, but are the quantum states “ontic” (really out in the world), or “epistemic” (only in our heads)?" ... "Bad dichotomy." Daniel Harlow #16: "silliness of the ontic/epistemic discussion" Mateus Araújo #50: "The crucial distinction between ontic versus epistemic entities is that the latter don’t have to respect the laws of physics." "If quantum states are epistemic, the unphysical collapse is not a problem. If they are ontic, well, we can’t have them collapsing, can we?" Scott #88: "There’s the state that I ascribe to the system I’m measuring, which does collapse when I measure it (more epistemic), and then there’s the state that I’d hypothetically ascribe to the entire universe including myself, which never collapses (more ontic)" Mateus Araújo #97: "Both of your examples are trivially ontic states, the state of the system in your branch of the wavefunction, and the state of the whole wavefunction." "... you can’t even understand what people mean when they say they’re epistemic." Scott #108: ? Mateus Araújo #124: ? Scott #129: no-go theorems => epistemicists should give up Mateus Araújo #138: Agrees with #129 but lists some epistemicists (including Bohmians). Scott #187: Are Bohmians epistemicists? Mateus Araújo #199: "I think calling them (Bohmians) epistemicists is fair, though perhaps an oversimplification."
- howling 4y agoIn some sense, classical probability is just the study of category of Markov Kernels [0]. We can gain much of the insight without a lot of measure theory/functional analysis machineries by restricting to its full subcategory of finite states, which gets us to the category of stochastic matrix. In this view, quantum probability (of finite states) is just about study of category of classical quantum maps described in Picturing Quantum Processes by Bob Coecke and Aleks Kissinger [1]. I highly recommend the book, which requires hardly any prerequisites other than linear algebra and mathematical maturity. Once we get into this framework, no philosophical interpretation is required. E.g. we can't reproduce a quantum state by classical data just means any morphism from a (non-trivial) purely quantum state to a purely classical state does not have a left inverse. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markov_kernel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markov_kernel [1]: https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/picturing-quantum-processes/1119568B3101F3A685BE832FEEC53E52#fndtn-information https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/picturing-quantum-proce...
- klysm 4y agoIdk anything about measure theory, but I do know some things about markov chains so I was excited about [0]. Unfortunately measure theory is invoked directly in the definition so I’ll have to go down that wiki rabbit hole
- atomflunder 4y agoI worked through large parts of PQP ([1]) with only the prerequisites that you state, as part of a Uni course taught by Aleks Kissinger. I got quite comfortable with the formalism and could solve most problems without too much issue, but at the end I still knew nothing at all about quantum physics. YMMV
- aj7 4y agoWhy that’s Feynman’s interpretation. “Shut up and calculate”
- bananapub 4y agoer, no, Feynman didn't say that[0] and the article explicitly talks about the difference from that point [0]: https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Shut_up_and_calculate https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Shut_up_and_calculate
- adamnemecek 4y agoIt's just eigenvalue calculations. I'm also a fan of the interpretations that use linear logic, like Vaughan Pratt's http://boole.stanford.edu/pub/ql.pdf http://boole.stanford.edu/pub/ql.pdf.
- scottmsul 4y agoSomething that's always bothered me about many-worlds is that it states the number of worlds should always be increasing exponentially. Which means from an anthropic point of view, the most likely time to be born is the last ever human, with insanely exponential odds. But many people have been born in my lifetime, ergo many-worlds seems unlikely.
- consilient 4y agoThe many-worlds interpretation is badly named: the "worlds" are just particularly classical-looking regions of the wavefunction we've chosen to draw some lines around for our own convenience. They're part of the map, not the territory. It's true that a decohering system will have exponentially more classical-ish parts over time - but the parts get smaller at the same rate, and the total size of the system remains the same.
- kbelder 4y agoDoes that argument hold for all of us?
- andrewflnr 4y agoThis kind of thing is exactly why you shouldn't take those sorts of anthropic argument too seriously.
- kovezd 4y agoI've been curious to learn theories where only a subset of scenarios beget alternative world, and many of these ultimately merge into more probable branches of reality. Keeping the total number of worlds growing at less than O(n*2) with respect to time.
- sudosysgen 4y agoIn the MWI there is an infinite number of worlds (as many as there are real numbers). So the total number of worlds grows at O(1) :)
- ravel-bar-foo 4y ago
- mathgenius 4y agoI like the many-interpretations interpretation of quantum. It says that you should believe all of them, or rather, choose a different interpretation based on your mood. For the optimistic, it's many-worlds. If you are going out tonight & hoping to get lucky, it better be Copenhagen. If you are falling into despair then it's going to be superdeterminism for you.
- LightMachine 4y ago> If you are falling into despair then it's going to be superdeterminism for you. If you don't believe in fairy tales nor assume the existence of a magic mysterious force named "free will" *
- andreareina 4y agoSuperdeterminism is hardly the only one to pose problems for some definitions of free will. It's also not a problem for others, i.e. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibilism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibilism
- oersted 4y agoYou are right in that interpretations have utility as helpful (mostly consistent) analogs that are easier to reason about when solving certain problems with the theory. One interpretation might be more handy than another in a given context. They are just tools to facilitate thought. But they are not models that can be accepted as scientific "reality" (as physicists use the word), since they cannot be experimentally verified by design (they do not lead to different predictions from the accepted theory), they are merely plausible.
- coldtea 4y ago>I hold that all interpretations of QM are just crutches that are better or worse at helping you along to the Zen realization that QM is what it is and doesn’t need an interpretation. As Sidney Coleman famously argued, what needs reinterpretation is not QM itself, but all our pre-quantum philosophical baggage—the baggage that leads us to demand, for example, that a wavefunction |ψ⟩ either be “real” like a stubbed toe or else “unreal” like a dream. Sounds more like a cop-out
- stubish 4y agoHe argues this further down as real/unreal being a bad dichotomy.
- graycat 4y agoSure, I'd like to read Aaronson and tried. My difficulty with quantum mechanics is much earlier, that is, more elementary and basic than what Aaronson considers. I've watched MIT lectures, looked into books by experts, ..., and I get nothing I can believe in. Right in the first hour, I get questions with no answers. E.g., (1) Wave Function. Okay. I can't find a definition of a wave function. Nothing subtle but just the most elementary objection possible: What are the range and domain of the function? That is, for a function f, we usually write f: A --> B for sets A and B meaning that for each element x in set A there is an element y in set B so that f(x) = y. For function f, set A is the domain and set B is the range. Fine. Now for a wave function, what are the sets A and B? No joke -- I can't find a clean, clear, unambiguous, simple, beginning, first step definition. (2) Everything. There is a common statement that the wave function has everything we can know about the particle, molecule, whatever. Okay: What about Schrödinger's Cat -- where in the wave function is the color of the cat? Simpler, for an electron, where in the wave function is the spin of the electron? (3) Probability Density. We are supposed to take the complex valued wave function, take its absolute value, scale the function so that its integral is 1, and then, presto, bingo, since it is continuous, non-negative, and integrates to 1, it can be a probability density. In particular it can be the probability density of the current location of the particle. Okay, it CAN be. Now, what is the evidence that it actually IS the probability density of the particle? That is, so far I can't find any argument, justification, reason to conclude that the probability density of the particle is not something else. E.g., the probability density of the particle might be Gaussian. (4) Hilbert Space. I've read so many times, more than I can count, that the set of all wave functions form a Hilbert space. Tilt. The definition of Hilbert space I saw in math, e.g., W. Rudin, Real and Complex Analysis, is that a Hilbert space is a complete inner product space where complete means that every Cauchy convergent sequence converges. Well, the wave functions have to be differentiable and, thus, continuous, and it's easy enough to have a sequence of such functions converge to a discontinuous and, thus, not differentiable function and not a wave function. So, wave functions might be points in a Hilbert space, but they can't form a Hilbert space. (5) Superposition. Some definitions say that superposition is just linearity. But if I have complex numbers a and b and wave functions f and g and form the linear combination h = af + bg that seems to be an example of superposition. Okay. Now, is h actually also a wave function? Its absolute value might not integrate to 1. Okay, scale it so that we do get 1. Now what particle has wave function h? That is, what physics does this linear combination describe? What does h in h = af + bg have to do with physics? E.g., from the Pauli exclusion principle, maybe h can't correspond to anything in physics. What is going on with superposition? (6) Can't Know. We are told that as an electron goes by, we can't know anything about it except its wave function unless we take a measurement at which time we change the wave function, what the electron might do, or some such. Hmm. The electron has a negative charge and mass. As it goes by, it has to emit from its electric charge an electrostatic force, that is, a Coulomb field and since it has mass, a gravitational wave. If that situation is not strong enough, then have the electron go past a strong Coulomb field so that it moves in a curve. Such a curve is acceleration so that the electron might generate a photon. We detect the photon and then "know" that the electron went by. And, even if we don't have a strong Coulomb field, our universe is awash in Coulomb fields that might deflect the electron. So, the wave function can't be "destroyed" merely by some Coulomb field. Then we just use a strong Coulomb field, detect the photon, and, thus, know a lot about the electron without changing its wave function. So, the claim that we can't know seems wrong. (7) The Other Half. We take a beam splitter, such as in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, and shoot an electron at it. The wave function splits into two parts, say, f and g. For part f, we have a detector. For the last electron we shot, we got a detection from part f. Now, what happens to part g? No fair saying that part g does not exist since the Mach-Zehnder interferometer can bring such f and g back together and generate interference fringes that part f or g can't generate alone. So, part g does exist. So, what happens to it? (8) Domain. For the wave function, a guess at the domain is the set of all ordered pairs (x, t) where x is a point in three space and t is time. Well, three space is a big place, and we usually believe that nothing can travel, propagate faster than the speed of light. So, all the wave functions so far are still traveling, still expanding. Right? What happens to them? Just a few, simple, obvious, elementary, first day questions. I can't find any answers.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoI'm certain that I fall and part of me lands on a rock, I'll be sorry. If someone buries gold in the ground, it's still there when someone finds the map and digs it up. Gold and granite are damned stable. If I don't know what they "really" are made of, that's an uncertainty I can live with. When someone finds another 'world' where those properties are different, I'll be all eyes. Until then, I'll continue to suspect that some people take the current state of our mathematics too seriously. Re-normalizing? Really?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ThePhysicist 4y agoYou could develop interpretations of classical mechanics (CM) in a similar way, but nobody does it as CM doesn't seem counter-intuitive to us. Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, is very much not intuitive, and the different interpretations are just a coping mechanism to deal with that (IMHO). Some of these interpretations actively harmed quantum mechanics research for decades, i.e. the original interpretation of what we'd call strong quantum measurements today.
- lew89 4y agoI'm not professional physicist, just trying to understand modern physics, partly as a Koan, partly as a part of philosophical endeavor. I think that my view is similar to yours. I'd say that modern physics really needs vast refactor. To my amatheur mind, it's just a bunch of equations proved to be useful; however variables named after well defined and comprehensible terms, seems to mean nothing except that they seem to fit those equations (so they are not properly defined). This is really situation I never met studying any other science. I think there is something wrong with assumptions. That's usually the case when I'm caught in paradoxes or my code works strange. :) Especially interesting point I'd love to read more is that "Because QM is a (the?) generalization of probability theory to involve complex numbers, whose squared absolute values are probabilities. It includes probability as a special case."
- oersted 4y agoThis is probably reductive and ignorant. I do have some post-grad education on quantum computing, but I by no means have a full grasp of actual mathematical foundations of the theory. The main issue I have with the prevailing perspective on QM (including this Zen one, which is more widely accepted than the article makes it sound), is just that it's rather pessimistic and slightly unscientific. When declaring that the world works on this foundation of pure mathematical randomness, you are effectively stating that's the end of the line, there's nothing below to explain the phenomena. Probability is a tool to meaningfully reason about incomplete information, but the information is not fundamentally unknowable. You could for instance say that wether a child will be male or female is purely mathematically random. For all intents and purposes, it is random in the sense we cannot hope to predict it before conception in a single instance. It's not uniformly random, there are external factors that may affect the probability, but it would still be correct to model it as a random variable. But we must never forget it is a model. We do actually (mostly) know why it looks random from a macro scale: (being very simplistic, I might be quite wrong here) we have many molecules with a certain temperature wizzing past each other with Brownian motion, and it is effectively impossible to predict which will react with which, leading to a certain gene to be selected. We cannot predict it, but we can explain it and prove it by experimental means. It's a chaotic system ruled by relatively simple rules, and we can do a lot of meaningful work with that. I'm sure many professional physicists also treat QM as an abstraction and model, and there are people trying to peek under the rug. But the community has mostly failed to express this perspective when communicating with a wider audience, and possibly between themselves and their students, for the last century. Physicists like to redefine the word "real" as to mean "the mathematical model that currently best fits observations", but that is not the common sense of the word. It is merely a pragmatic excuse to focus students on actual publishable research and prevent them from getting constantly philosophical. But it does also make it slightly heretical to keep researching how these phenomena emerge from underlying laws. Which, to an outsider, is kind of the whole point of physics. To be fair, it is becoming exceedingly expensive to do any experimental work in this area. And as long as we don't have a good number of strong measurements that differ from the theory's predictions, we can only formulate plausible but mostly unprovable theoretical models. I understand why the community is pushing students away from such folly with a small sprinkling of dogmatism.
- superposeur 4y agoThis reads to me as a cogent defense of one particular interpretation: Everett. All is clear and logical except the part where Aaronson endorses the opinion that Everett isn’t wrong, but grandiose (whatever this means). In justification, it seems he is pushed into further twisted locutions. He speaks of what “breathes fire” into branches of the wave function and says that the question of existence of other branches is “above the pay grade of physics”. Breathing fire and pay grade of physics? How much simpler to just assert that yes evolution is unitary at all times and, yes, this implies many classical branches.
- baja_blast 4y agoI feel like Everett is a way of trying to fit quantum mechanics with the block universe concept i.e. the past and future exist simultaneously. But I like the idea proposed by Swiss physicist Nicolas Gisin who reasoned that when you our universe is finite and inherently imprecise that “time really passes and new information is created.” which fits with having to update after quantum collapse because new information has been introduced. https://www.quantamagazine.org/does-time-really-flow-new-clues-come-from-a-century-old-approach-to-math-20200407/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/does-time-really-flow-new-clu...
- ngoilapites 4y agoZen is great, physics is great, you can get inspired across them, but mixing them is IMHO a misstep.
- fedeb95 4y agoI'm speaking as an amateur reader of QM things. This approach may be useful to someone using QM. But for someone wondering about the world, it is not. The question remains: which model that describes nature better than QM we will have in a hundred years or more?